Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMP(M) No. 1685 of 2025
Reserved on: 20.03.2026
Decided on: 24.03.2026
________________________________________________
LAC & Anr.
....Applicants
Versus
Prem Prakash & Ors.
_
Coram
…Respondents
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sushil Kukreja, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the applicants
:
For the respondents:
Mr. Manoj Chauhan, Additional
Advocate General.
None.
Sushil Kukreja, Judge
This order shall dispose of an application filed
under Section 5 of the Limitation Act for condonation of delay
of one year, eleven months and four days in filing the present
appeal. As per the applicants, Reference Petition was
decided by the Reference Court on 11.08.2023 and copy
whereof, was applied by the District Attorney on the same
day, which was attested on 26.08.2023 and delivered on
28.08.2023. The District Attorney, Shimla forwarded the
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
certified copy of the award alongwith the case file to
Executive Engineer, HPPWD, Karsog vide letter dated
05.09.2023, which was received at the Office of Executive
Engineer, Karsog on 14.09.2023, who sent the case file to
Assistant Engineer, HPPWD, Sub-Division Churag, vide
letter No. 5299, dated 15.09.2023, which was received on
30.09.2023.Thereafter, the file was marked to Sh. Padam
Nabh, Junior Engineer, Churag/Tattapani Section vide
endorsement No. 441, dated 04.10.2023. In the meanwhile,
the area experienced severe flooding due to heavy rainfall.
The situation was critical, with residents facing displacement
and considerable hardship. The overflowing of rivers/khads
caused extensive damage to infrastructure, including roads
and bridges, severely affecting mobility and access to
essential services. Faced with this situation, all field staff was
deployed
for
road
clearance
and
restoration
work.
Subsequently, Assistant Engineer was transferred from
HPPWD Sub-Division, Churag and the dealing hand also
joined
another
office
upon
his
promotion.
In
these
circumstances, no steps could be taken for processing the
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
matter for appeal. The Office of appellant No. 2 was not
made aware of the status of the case until it was listed before
the learned Sessions Court Camp at Karsog on 08.04.2025
and at the time of scrutiny, it was found that legal opinion
from the competent authority was required. Hence, Executive
Engineer, Karsog forwarded the matter to the Legal Cell of
the office of Engineer-in-Chief vide letter dated 19.04.2025,
which was received on 26.04.2025. Thereafter, the matter
was further forwarded to the Government for seeking opinion
of Law Department vide letter No. 242-44, dated 26.04.2025.
The Secretary (PW) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh
conveyed the opinion vide letter dated 20.06.2025 to the
Office
of
Engineer-in-Chief,
which
was
received
on
24.6.2025, who further conveyed the opinion alongwith
relevant case file to the Office of Executive Engineer, Karsog
vide letter No. 823-24, dated 24.06.2025, which was
received in his office on 28.06.2025. On receipt of the
opinion of Government, the Executive Engineer, Karsog
prepared and drafted the appeal and submitted the same to
the Office of Engineer-in-Chief, HPPWD, Shimla vide letter
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
dated 27.06.2025, which was received in his office on
28.06.2025. Some record was sought from field office and on
its receipt, the same was vetted in his office on 04.07.2025
and the said office forwarded the same to the office of
learned Advocate General vide letter dated 04.7.2025, who
vetted the same on 07.07.2025. Thereafter, Executive
Engineer, HPPWD Division Karsog submitted the fair appeal
to the Superintending Engineer 1 st Circle, HPPWD Mandi
vide letter dated 08.07.2025 for signatures, being authorized
signatory, who further sent the fair appeal duly signed, to the
Office of learned Advocate General vide letter No. PW-SEIR-24-7-C.C./Karsog/25-5121-23 dated 11.07.2025. In this
way, delay of one year, eleven months and four days in filing
the present appeal has occurred, which is neither intentional
nor willful, but was beyond the control of the applicants, as
such, deserves to be condoned in the interest of justice.
2.
I have heard the learned Additional Advocate
General for the applicant/State and have also gone through
the material available on record.
3.
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
It is a settled legal proposition that law of
limitation may harshly affect a particular party but it has to be
applied with all its rigour when the statute so prescribes. In
Basawaraj and Another Vs. Special Land Acquisition
Officer, 2013 (14) SCC 81, the Hon’ble Apex Court has
observed as under:
“12. It is a settled legal proposition that law of limitation
may harshly affect a particular party but it has to be
applied with all its rigour when the statute so prescribes.
The Court has no power to extend the period of limitation
on equitable grounds. "A result flowing from a statutory
provision is never an evil. A Court has no power to ignore
that provision to relieve what it considers a distress
resulting from its operation." The statutory provision may
cause hardship or inconvenience to a particular party but
the Court has no choice but to enforce it giving full effect
to the same. The legal maxim "dura lex sed lex"which
means "the law is hard but it is the law", stands attracted
in such a situation. It has consistently been held that,
"inconvenience is not" a decisive factor to be considered
while interpreting a statute.
13. The Statute of Limitation is founded on public policy,
its aim being to secure peace in the community, to
suppress fraud and perjury, to quicken diligence and to
prevent oppression. It seeks to bury all acts of the past
which have not been agitated unexplainably and have
from lapse of time become stale. According to Halsbury's
Laws of England, Vol. 28, p. 266:
"605. Policy of Limitation Acts. The courts have
expressed at least three differing reasons
supporting the existence of statutes of limitations
namely, (1) that long dormant claims have more of
cruelty than justice in them, (2) that a defendant
might have lost the evidence to disprove a stale
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
claim, and (3) that persons with good causes of
actions should pursue them with reasonable
diligence".
An unlimited limitation would lead to a sense of
insecurity and uncertainty, and therefore, limitation
prevents disturbance or deprivation of what may
have been acquired in equity and justice by long
enjoyment or what may have been lost by a
party's own inaction, negligence' or laches. (See:
Popat and Kotecha Property v. SBI Staff Assn.,
Rajendar Singh v. Santa Singh and Pundlik Jalam
Patil v. Jalgaon Medium Project).
14. In P. Ramachandra Rao v. State of Karnataka, this
Court held that judicially engrafting principles of limitation
amounts to legislating and would fly in the face of law laid
down by the Constitution Bench in A. R. Antulay v. R. S.
Nayak.
15. The law on the issue can be summarised to the effect
that where a case has been presented in the court
beyond limitation, the applicant has to explain the court
as to what was the "sufficient cause" which means an
adequate and enough reason which prevented him to
approach the court within limitation. In case a party is
found to be negligent, or for want of bonafide on his part
in the facts and circumstances of the case, or found to
have not acted diligently or remained inactive, there
cannot be a justified ground to condone the delay. No
court could be justified in condoning such an inordinate
delay by imposing any condition whatsoever. The
application is to be decided only within the parameters
laid down by this court in regard to the condonation of
delay. In case there was no sufficient cause to prevent a
litigant to approach the court on time condoning the delay
without any justification, putting any condition
whatsoever, amounts to passing an order in violation of
the statutory provisions and it tantamounts to showing
utter disregard to the legislature.”
4.
In
Esha
Bhattacharjee
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
Vs.
Managing
Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar Academy and Others,
2013 (12) SCC 649, the Hon'ble Supreme Court referred to
some of its Judgments regarding Law of Limitation. It may be
useful to extract relevant paragraphs which read as follows:
"15. In this context, we may refer with profit to the authority
in Oriental Aroma Chemical Industries Limited v. Gujarat
Industrial Development Corporation and another, where a
Two-Judge Bench of this Court has observed that: (SCC
p.465, para 14)
“14. the law of limitation is founded on public
policy. The legislature does not prescribe limitation
with the object of destroying the rights of the
parties but to ensure that they do not resort to
dilatory tactics and seek remedy without delay. The
idea is that every legal remedy must be kept alive
for a period fixed by the legislature. To put it
differently, the Law of Limitation prescribes a
period within which legal remedy can be availed for
redress of the legal injury. At the same time, the
Courts are bestowed with the power to condone
the delay, if sufficient cause is shown for not
availing the remedy within the stipulated time.”
Thereafter, the learned Judges proceeded to state that this
Court has justifiably advocated adoption of liberal
approach in condoning the delay of short duration and a
stricter approach where the delay is inordinate.
16. In Improvement Trust, Ludhiana v. Ujagar Singh and
others,, it has been held that: (SCC p. 789, para 16)
“16. while considering an Application for
condonation of delay no straitjacket formula is
prescribed to come to the conclusion if sufficient
and good grounds have been made out or not. It
has been further stated therein that each case has
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
to be weighed from its facts and the circumstances
in which the party acts and behaves”
17. A reference to the principle stated in Balwant Singh v.
Jagdish Singh, would be quite fruitful. In the said case the
Court referred to the pronouncements in Union of India v.
Ram Charan, P.K. Ramachandran v. State of Kerala and
Katari Suryanarayana v. Koppisetti Subba Rao and stated
thus: (Balwant Singh case, SCC p.696, paras 25-26)
“25. We may state that even if the term sufficient
cause has to receive liberal construction, it must
squarely fall within the concept of reasonable time
and proper conduct of the party concerned. The
purpose of introducing liberal construction normally
is to introduce the concept of reasonableness as it
is understood in its general connotation.
26. The Law of Limitation is a substantive law and
has definite consequences on the ri ght
andobligation of a party to arise. These principles
should be adhered to and applied appropriately
depending on the facts and circumstances of a
given case. Once a valuable right has accrued in
favour of one party as a result of the failure of the
other party to explain the delay by showing
sufficient cause and its own conduct, it will be
unreasonable to take away that right on the mere
asking of the Applicant, particularly when the delay
is directly a result of negligence, default or inaction
of that party.Justice must be done to both parties
equally. Then alone the ends of justice can be
achieved. If a party has been thoroughly negligent
in implementing its rights and remedies, it will be
equally unfair to deprive the other party of a
valuable right that has accrued to it in law as a
result of his acting vigilantly."
18.
Recently in Maniben Devaraj Shah v. Municipal
Corporation of Brihan Mumbai, the learned Judges
referred to the pronouncement in Vedabai v. Shantaram
Baburao Patil, wherein it has been opined that a
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
distinction must be made between a case where the delay
is inordinate and a case where the delay is of few days
and whereas in the former case the consideration of
prejudice to the other side will be a relevant factor, in the
latter case no such consideration arises. Thereafter, the
two judges bench ruled thus: (Maniben Devraj Shah Case,
SCC pp. 168-69, paras 23-24)
“23. What needs to be emphasized is that even
though a liberal and justice oriented approach is
required to be adopted in the exercise of power
under Section 5 of the Limitation Act and other
similar statutes, the courts can neither become
oblivious of the fact that the successful litigant has
acquired certain rights on the basis of the judgment
under challenge and a lot of time is consumed at
various stages of litigation apart from the cost.
24. What colour the expression ?sufficient cause?
would get in the factual matrix of a given case
would largely depend on bona fide nature of the
explanation. If the court finds that there has been
no negligence on the part of the applicant and the
cause shown for the delay does not lack bona
fides, then it may condone the delay. If, on the
other hand, the explanation given by the applicant
is found to be concocted or he is thoroughly
negligent in prosecuting his cause, then it would be
a legitimate exercise of discretion not to condone
the delay.”
5.
In Pundlik Jalam Patil (dead) by LRs Vs.
Executive
Engineer,
Jalgaon
Medium
Project
and
Another, (2008) 17 SCC 448, it has been held as under:“31. It is true when the State and its instrumentalities
are the applicants seeking condonation of delay they may
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
be entitled to certain amount of latitude but the law of
limitation is same for citizen and for Governmental
authorities. Limitation Act does not provide for a different
period to the government in filing appeals or applications
as such. It would be a different matter where the
Government makes out a case where public interest was
shown to have suffered owing to acts of fraud or collusion
on the part of its officers or agents and where the officers
were clearly at cross purposes with it. In a given case if
any such facts are pleaded or proved they cannot be
excluded from consideration and those factors may go
into the judicial verdict. In the present case, no such facts
are pleaded and proved though a feeble attempt by the
learned counsel for the respondent was made to suggest
collusion and fraud but without any basis. We cannot
entertain the submission made across the Bar without
there being any proper foundation in the pleadings.”
6.
Thus the sum and substance of all above
decisions make it clear that to decide the application for
condonation of delay, the Court has to consider that whether
there is sufficient and reasonable cause for condonation of
delay in filing any case beyond the prescribed period of
limitation. There cannot be a straitjacket formula or rule
either for condonation of delay or to reject the condonation
and that every case is to be decided considering the facts
and circumstances of that case only. The only requirement
for condonation of delay is that whether there is sufficient
cause for the party not to initiate the litigation in prescribed
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
period of limitation. It is settled law that length of delay is no
matter and acceptability of the explanation is the only
criterion. Sometimes delay of the shortest range may be
uncondonable due to want of acceptable explanation
whereas in certain other cases delay of very long range can
be condoned as the explanation thereof is satisfactory.
7.
In the instant case, the applicants/appellants
have not explained each and every day's delay. Rather, it
has been mentioned in the application as under:
“Thereafter, the file was marked to Sh. Padam Nabh,
Junior Engineer, Churag/Tattapani Section vide
endorsement No. 441, dated 04.10.2023. In the
meanwhile, the area experienced severe flooding due to
heavy rainfall. The situation was critical, with residents
facing displacement and considerable hardship. The
overflowing of rivers/khads caused extensive damage to
infrastructure, including roads and bridges, severely
affecting mobility and access to essential services. Faced
with this situation, all field staff was deployed for road
clearance and restoration work. Subsequently, Assistant
Engineer was transferred from HPPWD Sub-Division,
Churag and the dealing hand also joined another office
upon his promotion. In these circumstances, no steps
could be taken for processing the matter for appeal. The
Office of appellant No. 2 was not made aware of the
status of the case until it was listed before the learned
Sessions Court Camp at Karsog on 08.04.2025.”
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
However, no satisfactory explanation has been offered by the
applicants/appellants for the delay w.e.f. 04.10.2023 till
08.04.2025. The delay to be condoned is one year, eleven
months and four days. It is not open to any litigant to fix his
own period of limitation for instituting proceedings for which
law has prescribed period of limitation. From a reading of the
averments in the application, it is seen that application
seeking to condone the delay of one year, eleven months
and four days was filed in a casual manner without giving
proper reasons, much less acceptable reasons. As observed
earlier, the applicants have not shown sufficient cause to
condone the delay as contemplated in the decisions of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court supra. The application filed by the
applicants
is vague and bereft of particulars without any
convincing explanation for condoning the delay. The
inordinate delay of one year, eleven months and four days in
filing the appeal has not been properly explained.
8.
Applying the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the decisions, supra, to the facts and
circumstances of the case on hand, I am of the view that the
( 2026:HHC:8777 )
applicants have failed to explain each and every day's delay.
Resultantly, the application is devoid of merits and the same
is liable to be dismissed.
9.
Consequently,
the
appeal
filed
by
the
appellants/State is also dismissed.
th
24 March, 2026
(raman)
( Sushil Kukreja )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review