Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:236-DB
Serial No.01
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
W.A. No.70 of 2024
Date of Hearing: 10.03.2025
Date of Decision:27.03.2025
____________________________________________________________
Shri Lalrinmawia Ralte
Vs.1.The State of Meghalaya represented
Son of (L) Zaisoma Ralte,
by the Chief Secretary, Government
Resident of Madanrting, Mawblei,
of Meghalaya, Shillong.
Block-B, East Khasi Hills District.
Meghalaya.
2.The Under Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya, Home
(Police) Department, Meghalaya,
Shillong.
3. The Commandant, 1st Battalion,
Meghalaya Police, Mawiong,
Shillong.
….. Appellant.
……Respondents.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. S. A. Sheikh, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. S. Laloo, GA.
2025:MLHC:236-DB
(JUDGMENT)
Per. B. Bhattacharjee, Judge:
This intra-Court appeal is preferred by the appellant against the Judgment
dated 24-07-2024 of the learned Single Judge passed in WP(C) No.309 of
2024 whereby the writ petition filed by the appellant against his dismissal
from service was dismissed.
1.
The appellant, while serving as a BN Constable in the First
Battalion of the Meghalaya Police, was found absent from duty w.e.f. 1512-2020 and was issued with three notices for resumption of duty. After
receiving the 3rd notice dated 02-02-2021, the appellant resumed his duty
as a guard at the Covid-19 Centre, Mawiong, Shillong on 08-02-2021.
Thereafter, the appellant was served with a show-cause notice dated 1002-2021 to answer the charges based on the statement of allegation which
read as follows: “1. That while you were posted at BN/HQ, you were found absent
from General Roll Call w.e.f. 15.12.2020 (AM) without any leave or
permission from the competent authority.
2. That inspite of issuing several notice in your address available in
the Service Sheet record, you failed to neither report nor resume
your duties.
3. It was only after issuing 3rd Notice to resume duty, you reported
for duty on 08.02.2021 (PM) without any supporting documents
after remaining absent for a period of 56 (fifty six) days. Thus you
have failed to maintain full devotion to duty and thereby committed
gross misconduct and dereliction of duty and violated Rule 3 (1), 3
(A) and 3 B of Meghalaya Services Conduct Rules, 2019.”
2.
In response to the show-cause notice, the appellant filed his written
statement dated 17-02-2021. As the written statement was found not
2025:MLHC:236-DB
satisfactory, a departmental proceeding was taken up against the appellant
and an enquiry officer was appointed to conduct the enquiry into the
allegations made against the appellant. The enquiry officer, after holding
the enquiry, came to a finding that the allegations against the appellant
were proved beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the appellant was
dismissed from service vide B.O. No. 2770 dated 19-05-2021 issued by
the Commandant, First Battalion Meghalaya Police, Mawiong, Shillong.
The appellant preferred a statutory appeal against his dismissal before the
Director General of Police, which was disposed of by order dated 11-082021 without any interference with the order of dismissal.
Being
aggrieved, the appellant filed the writ petition challenging his dismissal
from service. The learned Single Judge by the impugned Judgment dated
24-07-2024 dismissed the writ petition by holding that in view of the
categorical admission of the relevant charges by the appellant, no case has
been made out.
3.
Assailing the decision of the learned Single Judge, Mr. S. A. Sheikh
learned Counsel for the appellant, submits that the appellant had never
admitted to any of the charges and the alleged unauthorized absence was
not willful but because of sickness of the appellant. He contends that since
the appellant was dismissed after holding a full-fledged departmental
proceeding and not on the basis of the alleged admission in his written
statement, the department was duty bound to follow all the procedures laid
down by law. He submits that the allegation of failure on the part of the
appellant to report or resume his duty inspite of issuance of several notices
has not been proved by any of the witnesses in the departmental enquiry.
He further submits that no presenting officer was appointed in the enquiry
and no defence assistance was provided to the appellant and he was also
2025:MLHC:236-DB
not supplied with a copy of the enquiry report. He also submits that the
appellant was not provided with a list of witness at any point of time
hampering appellant’s defence at the enquiry. In addition, the learned
Counsel strongly argues that the punishment of dismissal from service of
the appellant is grossly disproportionate and in total violation of doctrine
of proportionality. He submits that the length of service of the appellant in
the department should have been taken into consideration before passing
the extremely harsh order of dismissal and the punishment of compulsory
retirement would have been proper.
He, therefore, prays that the
impugned Judgment dated 24-07-2024 may be set aside and the
punishment awarded may be modified allowing the appellant to go on
compulsory retirement. In support of his contentions, the learned Counsel
has placed reliance on the decisions reported in (1987) SCC Online Gau
84, (2005) SCC Online Gau 120, (2007) SCC Online Gau 551, (2010) 2
Gauhati Law Reports 811, (2008) 8 SCC 236, (1993) 4 SCC 727, (2024)
SCC Online SC 3325, (2012) 3 SCC 178, (2016) 15 SCC 693, (2018) 18
SCC 341 and (2020) 3 GLR 244.
4.
Mr. N. D. Chullai, learned AAG assisted by Ms. S. Laloo, learned
GA for the State-respondents, on the other hand, submits that the appellant
in his written statement as well as in the enquiry has admitted all the
allegations made against him. He submits that the appellant failed to
resume his duty inspite of having received number of notices and joined
his duty only after receiving the 3rd notice, clearly projecting the act of
gross misconduct and lack of discipline. He submits that the appellant,
being a member of the disciplined force, should have strictly adhered to
the rules and procedure more than the members of any other department,
but was a habitual absentee instead. He contends that in view of the
2025:MLHC:236-DB
appellant’s admission to the allegations made, no scope is left for differing
with the finding and conclusion arrived at the departmental proceeding.
He further submits that there is no illegality or irregularity in the conduct
of the departmental proceeding and the appellant was provided with all the
opportunities required by law. The learned AAG further submits that the
copy of the enquiry report as well as all the relevant documents were
supplied to the appellant which, in fact, were placed on record by the
appellant in his writ petition. He submits that nowhere in the pleading, the
appellant has pleaded any prejudice due to non-supply of the enquiry
report or document, and in absence of any such specific plea, the order of
dismissal from service cannot be rendered illegal. He submits that the
entire service carrier of the appellant was marked by numerous instances
of unauthorized absence and indiscipline exemplifying the incorrigible
misconduct of the appellant, and the punishment awarded, as such, cannot
be termed as excessive or disproportionate. He submits that the learned
Single Judge was right in dismissing the writ petition of the appellant and
the said decision requires no interference in this writ appeal. To buttress
his argument, the learned AAG has referred to the decisions reported in
(1996) 1 SCC 302, (2003) 3 SCC 464, (2011) 14 SCC 682, (1996) 10 SCC
409, (2008) 5 SCC 569, (2009) 15 SCC 620, (1971) 1 SCC 1, (2001) 6
SCC 392, (2008) 9 SCC 31, (2005) 8 SCC 264, (1998) 4 SCC 310, (2005)
2 Gau LR 418, (2006) 3 Gau LR 17, (2011) 2 SCC 316, (2006) 3 SCC 150,
(2003) 3 Gau LR 657, (2008) 4 SCC 406 and in WP(C) No. 127 of 2021,
Amzad Khan v. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
5.
From the submissions made by the rival parties and perusal of the
materials on record, it transpires that the appellant was found absent from
duty w.e.f. 15-12-2020 without any leave or permission from the
2025:MLHC:236-DB
competent authority. He resumed his duty only after receiving the 3rd
notice after remaining absent for a period of 56 (fifty six) days. Upon
issuance of show-cause notice along with the statement of allegation vide
Letter No. BN/MLP/R-BNC-2452(LR)21/08 dated 10-02-2021, the
appellant submitted his written explanation on 17-02-2021. For the sake
of facility, the written explanation is reproduced below: “To
The Commandant
1st MLP BN Mawiong
Shillong-16 (Through Proper Channel)
Subject: WRITTEN STATEMENT
Ref:- Your letter Memo No. BN/MLP/R-BNC-2452(LR)21/08,Dt: 10
Feb,2021.
Madam,
With reference to the subject cited above and with reference
to your letter so called cited above 1 have the honour to lay before
you some few lines for favour of your kind consideration and
sympathetic order please:1. That Madam as per the Article of Charge No 1, I was found
absent from General Roll Call w.e.f. 15.12.2020 (AM) without any
leave or permission from the competent authority is true and
admitted but the reason behind was that I was suffering from illness
and the same could not be reported before the competent authority.
2. That Madam, I also do not possess any medical certificate for my
sickness as I was under Ayurvedic treatment and that apart I did not
opted for allopathic treatment due to several protocol to be
followed/observed during this Covid pandemic.
3. That Madam, as per the Article of Charge No 2 several notices
were issued to the address available in the Service Sheet/record but
I was not available at that address as was residing at my rented
house at Mawiong, Shillong.
4. That Madam, as per the Article of Charge No 3, 1 reported for
duty on 08.02.2021 (PM) without any supporting documents after
remaining absent for a period of 56 days is true but the facts is that
2025:MLHC:236-DB
I was under Ayurvedic treatment and so I do not possessed any
documents for my sickness.
In the premises and circumstances stated above I
therefore pray before you to kindly admit my Written
Explanation and I promise/ assures you not to repeat
the same in the near future if I am found guilty, and
further prays to kindly grant apology.
And for which act of kindness I shall ever remain
grateful and oblige.
Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,
Dated 17th Feb,2021
6.
Sd/(BNC/2452 Lalrinmawia Relte)
1st MLP BN Mawiong Shillong.”
From the above, it is clear that the appellant did not deny the
allegation of unauthorized absence from duty. The reason for absence was
stated to be his suffering from illnesses for which he had to take
Ayurvedic treatment. However, no supporting document was enclosed by
the appellant. With regard to the issuance of several notices, the appellant
stated that he was not available at the address provided in his service
record as he was residing at his rented house at a different place.
Additionally, the appellant tendered his apology and assured not to repeat
the same in the near future.
7.
In the course of the enquiry, the statement of 4(four) departmental
witnesses were recorded by the enquiry officer. The appellant did not
produce any witness from his side. Out of the 4(four) departmental
witnesses, the Reserve Officer of 1st MLP BN, stated that 3 (three) notices,
dated 17-12-2020, 08-01-2021 and 02-02-2021 respectively, were issued
to the appellant and the appellant resumed his duty only on 08-02-2021.
The appellant declined to cross-examine any of the departmental witnesses
2025:MLHC:236-DB
inspite of the opportunities provided to him.
The statement of the
appellant was also recorded by the enquiry officer wherein he admitted
that he was absent from duty since 15-12-2020. He stated that he did not
remember whether he had received all the notices or not, but joined his
duty on 08-02-2021 after receiving the 3rd notice and also did not produce
any supporting document with regard to his absence from duty. It is, thus,
apparent that the appellant did not deny or contest any of the allegations
made by the department against him in the enquiry.
8.
There is no dispute to the fact that the appellant had resumed his
duty on 08-02-2021, only after receiving the 3rd notice dated 02-02-2021.
The learned Counsel for the appellant contended that the factum of service
of the 1st and the 2nd notices have not been proved in the enquiry. The
contention of the learned Counsel for the appellant appears to be totally
contrary to the materials on record as the 1st notice issued vide letter
No.BN/MLP/R-430/20/65 dated 17-12-2020 has a signature of the
appellant appearing on it signed on 17-12-2020 as a mark of
acknowledgement. The contention, as such, is not worth acceptance by
this Court.
9.
As to the contention of the appellant that no presenting officer was
appointed in the enquiry, no rule has been placed before this Court to show
that such appointment was mandated by law. Moreover, there is nothing
on record to show that the non-appointment of a presenting officer has
resulted in denial of a fair hearing or reasonable opportunity to the
appellant. Further, the argument of the appellant that the admission made
by the appellant in his written statement lost its significance because of the
holding of the full-fledged departmental proceeding, has no merit as there
is no legal bar for the department to proceed with the enquiry to confirm
2025:MLHC:236-DB
the admission of the allegation by the delinquent officer. The decision to
proceed with the enquiry, inspite of the admission of the allegation by the
delinquent official, does not make such admission insignificant or
inadmissible in a departmental proceeding.
10.
Apart from the above, it is seen from the documents appended with
the writ petition that the enquiry report and the statement of witnesses
recorded in the enquiry have been annexed thereto by the appellant. There
is also no indication in the averments made in the writ petition that the
appellant was seriously prejudiced because of non-supply of the enquiry
report to him. Even if it is assumed that the appellant was not supplied
with the copy of the enquiry report, that per se would not invalidate the
punishment awarded to the appellant in absence of any specific plea of
prejudice.
11.
The order of appellant’s dismissal vide B.O. No. 2770 dated 19-05-
2021 contains the details of previous misconduct and misdemeanour
including the suspension of the appellant from service and the
punishments awarded to him which are not challenged by the appellant.
The details reflected therein show that the appellant was awarded Leave
Without Pay (LWP) on 28 different occasions for his unauthorized
absence from duty. In addition, ‘Punishment Drill’ was awarded to the
appellant on 6 occasions for his misbehaviour, indiscipline conducts and
absence from duty. The appellant was also suspended from service on 4
occasions and departmental proceedings were drawn up against him
wherein orders of punishment including stoppage of increment were
passed against him. Hence, the argument of the appellant that the order of
dismissal from service is violative of the doctrine of proportionality does
not hold water.
2025:MLHC:236-DB
12.
There is no quarrel with the proposition of law relied on by the
learned Counsel for the appellant in the various case laws cited by him.
However, in the facts and circumstances of the case in hand, the
propositions laid therein do not lend any help to the appellant’s case.
Hence, detailed discussion is deemed not necessary.
13.
In view of the discussions made above, no case is made out by the
appellant warranting interference with the Judgment dated 24-07-2024
passed by the learned Single Judge.
14.
Resultantly, the writ appeal stands dismissed.
(B. Bhattacharjee)
JUDGE
(H.S.Thangkhiew)
JUDGE
Meghalaya
27.03.2025
“Biswarup PS”
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2025.03.27 18:23:12 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review