Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 6th October, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010414432025
+
W.P.(C) 9365/2025
LALIT
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. A.K. Babbar, Adv.
versus
UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF FINANCE THROUGH ITS
SECRETARY & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through:
Mr. Gaurav Gupta, SSC with
Mr. Shivendra Singh, Mr.Yojit
Pareek, JSCs with Mr. Vedansh
Anand, SPC with Mr. Shivam
Kumar, GP
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH MEHTA
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE ADITI CHOUDHARY
JUDGMENT
REPORTABLE
DINESH MEHTA, J.(ORAL)
1.
The case in hand is an apparent case of misuse of Permanent Account
Number and the petitioner, who appears to have fallen prey to such fraud has
been visited with a huge demand.
2.
The petitioner claims to have obtained Permanent Account Number
AKGPL3356C out of anxiety to secure an identity proof issued by
government, though his income was never taxable. The petitioner has been
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:13.10.
2026 19:32
W.P.(C) 9365/2025
working as a small contractual employee either as a security guard or as a
cook at the relevant time (01.04.2015 to 31.03.2019). As per the facts pleaded
before the AO, the Petitioner worked in Hotel Ashoka through an agency
called Suraksha Security Agency and thereafter in Vigyan Bhawan through
another agency known as M/s. Mass Management Services Pvt. Ltd. as a
cook.
3.
The petitioner came to receive a notice under Section 148A(b) of
Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act of 1961’) on
26.02.2024, alleging that as per the Risk Management Strategy, formulated
by CBDT, the Petitioner (assessee) had made cash payment to one Montage
Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. of Rs.24,86,63,500/-. The notice also showed a cash sale
of Rs.24,62,01,485/- under Permanent Account Number AKGPL3356C.
4.
On receipt of the aforesaid notice, the petitioner proceeded to file a
police complaint on 07.03.2024 at PS Greater Kailash G.K.-I, New Delhi, so
also with the Cyber Cell, Saket, New Delhi on 30.05.2024, but said
complaints bore no fruit.
5.
The petitioner filed a reply to the aforesaid notice and asserted that he
had earned no taxable income, had not entered into any transaction mentioned
in the notice and that somebody had misused his PAN details. In his reply, the
petitioner had also asked for various information relating to the transactions
and copies/details of the transactions. Said information was never supplied to
the petitioner and an assessment order dated 17.03.2025 came to be passed in
which and the amount of Rs. 49,48,64,985/- was treated as petitioner’s
turnover and 8% of the same was determined as his income for the relevant
assessment year i.e. 2017-18.
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:13.10.
2026 19:32
W.P.(C) 9365/2025
6.
Apart from raising the demand of about Rs. 3,91,06,511/-, the
Assessing Officer has also recorded satisfaction to initiate penalty
proceedings
against
the
petitioner
for
misreporting
of
income;
non-compliance of the statutory notice, non-maintenance of books of account
and for failure to get the books of account audited.
7.
Mr. Babbar, learned Counsel for the petitioner, argued that the
impugned assessment order and the proceedings initiated against the
petitioner are wholly void without jurisdiction. He further argued that the
petitioner has been made a victim of identity theft and somebody has misused
his PAN credentials and in spite of the fact that he had proved beyond doubt
that somebody had misused his PAN details and that he had no nexus or
business connection with Montage Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. (which was engaged
in the business of packaging material) whereas the petitioner does the small
job of a cook or security guard, the Assessing Officer had arbitrarily and
vindictively created the demand paying no heed to the petitioner’s response to
notice under Section 148A(b) of the Act of 1961.
8.
Learned counsel submitted that, though the copies of the complaint
filed before the police were produced before the Assessing Officer and a
request was also made that the proceedings be kept in abeyance until the
investigation was over or that an inquiry be made in this regard, the Assessing
Officer refused to consider such request as it was not within his domain to
carry out such inquiry.
9.
During the course of submissions, learned Counsel for the petitioner
drew the Court’s attention to page Nos. 80-102 of the paper book and
submitted that during the period of 2011-2019, the petitioner had been
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:13.10.
2026 19:32
W.P.(C) 9365/2025
working as security guard/cook as a contractual employee in Ashoka Hotel
and Vigyan Bhawan. He added that as a contractual employee, the petitioner
had worked through various agencies and had given copies of his PAN card
and in that process the details might have been copied or stolen. He argued
that simply because the TCS records or Form 26AS and annual summary
finds mention of the petitioner’s Permanent Account Number, the demand
cannot be raised against him and the corresponding amount cannot be treated
as his turnover/business receipts in absence of any other material evidence.
10.
Mr. Gaurav Gupta, learned Senior Standing Counsel, on the other hand,
submitted that the petitioner has approached this Court against an assessment
order bypassing the statutory remedies. His argument has been that the case in
hand involves a host of disputed questions of fact which cannot be gone into
by this Court in its extraordinary writ jurisdiction.
11.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
12.
So far as respondent’s preliminary objection regarding the existence of
alternate remedy is concerned, we are of the view that having regard to the
factual matrix of the case and nature and quantum of demand, the petitioner
cannot be relegated to avail remedy of appeal against a huge demand of
Rs.3,91,06,511/- given his financial status. Even if his entire demand is stayed
by the appellate authority. At the least he would be expected to furnish surety
which we are sure, he would be unable to furnish–the remedy of appeal
would, therefore, be illusory and inefficacious.
13.
The remedy of appeal is not available to the petitioner in any real sense,
because as per the guidelines issued by the Central Board of Direct Taxes
(Office Memorandum F. No. 404/72/93-ITCC dated 31.07.2017) the standard
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:13.10.
2026 19:32
W.P.(C) 9365/2025
condition for granting stay is deposit of 20% of the disputed demand. Interest
also continues to run on the unpaid demand under Section 220(2)of the Act of
1961. The petitioner within his limited means cannot arrange for a sum
approaching ₹78 lakh merely to avail of interim protection.
14.
The right to a fair hearing is an integral part of “procedure established
by law” under Article 21 (Maneka Gandhi v Union of India reported in
(1978) 1 SCC 248) and of the guarantee against arbitrariness under Article
14. The Petitioner replied to the notice, produced his police and cyber cell
complaints, and sought the material relied upon. The Assessing Officer did
not supply the material to the petitioner and declined to await the outcome of
the investigation on the ground that it was not within his domain. An
assessment made without disclosing the adverse material and without
considering the assessee’s response is vitiated for breach of natural justice
and, being founded on no independent inquiry, cannot be sustained.
15.
Rather than getting into the intent or motive of the AO, what matters in
the instant case is the effect of the exorbitant demand hoisted against the
petitioner. A demand of about Rs. 3.91 crore, slapped against a person with no
means, that too on the strength of portal data alone, without an answer to his
request for particulars, exposes him to recovery proceedings, accrual of
interest and penalty proceedings that he cannot meet or contest on the terms
the statute lays down. Such a liability is not a neutral fiscal event for him, it
results into a continuing cause of anxiety, constant fear of coercive recovery
and complete loss of mental peace. That is an additional reason, along with
the breach of Article 14 and the inefficacy of the appellate remedy, why we do
not relegate him to the statutory forum.
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:13.10.
2026 19:32
W.P.(C) 9365/2025
16.
It is pertinent to note that the right to life under Article 21 is not
confined to bare human existence. It includes the right to live with dignity
(Francis Coralie Mullin v. Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi,
reported in (1981) 1 SCC 608). Hon’ble the Supreme Court has also
recognized that mental health is an integral component of the right to life
(Sukdeb Saha v. State of Andhra Pradesh reported in 2025 INSC 893).
Accordingly, where the State’s conduct causes avoidable mental anguish to a
person of no means, it impinges upon Article 21of the Constitution of India,
and the Court is justified in entertaining the writ and in treating the alternate
remedy as illusory.
17.
We are therefore, persuaded to exercise our discretionary jurisdiction
given that the petitioner before us, is a contractual security guard / cook with
meagre means. Even a fraction of the above sum by way of a deposit or surety
is beyond him. Without a stay, he would face recovery of a demand of nearly
Rs. 4 crore, along with penalty proceedings that the Assessing Officer has
already initiated.
18.
For the discussion foregoing, we entertain the present writ petition to
save the petitioner’s fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles 14 & 21 of
the Constitution of India, as the huge demand of Rs. 3.91 crores is nothing
short of threat to his mental and emotional health, which takes away mental
peace of a person having no means.
19.
On Court’s query as to whether the assessment order makes reference
of any other evidence or material apart from the details of Form 26AS and
annual summary, or whether the Department has conducted any independent
inquiry or recorded the statement of owner of said Montage Enterprises Pvt.
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:13.10.
2026 19:32
W.P.(C) 9365/2025
Ltd. so as to establish that transactions had taken place with the petitioner,
Mr.Gaurav Gupta, learned Senior Standing Counsel could not give any
satisfactory reply on the basis of available record. It is, therefore, clear that the
impugned assessment order is founded solely on the limbs of information
available on risk management strategy or Form 26AS and no independent
inquiry has been conducted by the AO.
20.
Having gone through the material, we are of the opinion that the
petitioner’s stand that during relevant period he was having engagement as a
contractual employee as security guard/cook with Ashoka Hotel and Vigyan
Bhawan is plausible, and there is every reason to accept that he had no nexus
with the transactions mentioned in the assessment order. The assessment
order on the allegation levelled against the petitioner is sans any cogent and
incriminating material/evidence against him. The least the AO ought to have
done was to issue a notice under section 133(6) of the Act of 1961 to said
vendor Montage and ask for further details or record its statements.
21.
A simple look at the reply of the assessee and assessment order reveals
that the AO has proceeded absolutely arbitrarily and with closed or
predetermined mind. In his reply, which the AO has reproduced, the
petitioner stated that he had withdrawn amount from his PF account between
2013 and 2018 to meet the needs of funds and that he had got a EWS
certificate issued and applied for waiver of school fee for his children. This
plea of the petitioner needed some empathy, if not sympathy and objective
scrutiny of the matter and detailed examination. Because, these facts clearly
suggested that petitioner’s defence that someone had misused his PAN
number, had some substance.
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:13.10.
2026 19:32
W.P.(C) 9365/2025
22.
That apart, the petitioner produced all his Bank statements and said
Montage was dealing in plastic packaging goods; the AO has not brought on
record any evidence to show that assessee has ever indulged in any business,
let alone packaging business. Once the petitioner had denied the transactions
and rebutted the presumption, the burden was upon the AO to establish that
the petitioner had really entered into these transactions.
23.
Furthermore, what concerns us the most is, that the AO has not even
considered the information in Form 26AS in accordance with law. In the
notice dated 26.02.2024 so also in the impugned Assessment Order, the AO
has taken the amount of Rs. 24,86,63,500/- as cash payment by the petitioner
and the net amount shown in Form 26AS being Rs.24,62,01,485/- after
collection of Tax @1% by Montage (Rs. 24,62,015/-) as cash sale and added
both the figures to make the total turnover ofRs.49,48,64,985/-. This approach
of the AO reveals that he has not even cared to understand the nature of
transaction –either he did not understand the basics of accounting or he did
not want to. It has resulted in demand against the petitioner being twofold.
Though the order in toto is wholly void and without jurisdiction inasmuch as
the transactions did not relate to the petitioner, but we have analysed the same
in order to show the manner in which an assessing officer can agonise an
assessee.
24.
A Tax Enforcement Officer should strive to achieve high revenue
target but he should keep his feet firmly grounded on the floor of reality. His
eyes should be sharp to pierce through the fraud but they should not slip away
from the facts.
25.
As an upshot of discussion foregoing, the impugned assessment order
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:13.10.
2026 19:32
W.P.(C) 9365/2025
dated 17.03.2025 is hereby quashed and set aside.
26.
We however leave it open for the respondents to take up the
proceedings afresh, in case they find any other cogent and incriminating
evidence or material linking the petitioner with the aforesaid transaction of
purchase of packaging material or that the petitioner is the person who had in
fact transacted in cash with the said Montage Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., as alleged
in the order impugned, subject of course to limitation prescribed under law.
27.
The writ petition is allowed in the above terms.
DINESH MEHTA
(JUDGE)
ADITI CHOUDHARY
(JUDGE)
OCTOBER 06, 2026/naw
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:13.10.
2026 19:32
W.P.(C) 9365/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review