Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURTOF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 12th March, 2026
Pronounced on: 11th May, 2026
%
RFA 949/2025
+
LALIT KUMAR
R/o C-104, The Jewel of Noida,
Point No. G-14, Eco City, Sector 75,
Noida-201301.
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. M P Sahay, Ms. Yaman Verma,
Ms. Chitra Chanda, Mr. Kartik Jindal
and Mr. Kartik Virmani, Advocates.
Versus
E-HOMES INFRASTRUCTURE PVT. LTD.
Dasnac Annexe I ECE House,
28A Kasturba Gandhi Marg,
Delhi-110001.
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Sunil Dalal (Sr. Adv.) alongwith
Srinivasan Ramaswamy, Mehak
Nakra, Gunjan Suyal, Ankit Rana,
Shipra Bali & Sarthak Malhotra,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
1.
Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI CPC has
been
filed
by
the
Plaintiff/Appellant
whereby
his
Suit
for
Compensation/Damages, Mandatory Injunction, Declaration and for
Rendition of Accounts, has been dismissed, vide Judgment dated
31.08.2024.
2.
The 12 Plaintiffs including the Appellant had filed Civil Suit
No.220/2024
under
Section
Compensation/Damages/Mandatory
Specific
Relief
Act
for
Injunction/Declaration
and
for
Rendition of Accounts.
3.
The facts as stated in the Plaint, are that the Defendant E-Homes
Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. is a Private Limited Company engaged in the
business of real estate development having its registered office at Kasturba
Gandhi Marg, Delhi. The Defendant was allotted land by Noida Authority,
to develop the land in various phases which included the Project the Jewel
of Noida (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Project’), to develop and complete
the same into a Group Housing Complex.
4.
The public at large including the Plaintiffs, were lured by the
representations that the Project would be a state-of-the-art Project with the
best of facilities and amenities.
Various advertisements in print and
electronic media were taken out specifying the areas, super areas and carpet
areas, maintenance aspects, quality of construction, spacious and convenient
car parking etc. The Plaintiffs applied for their respective units/apartments
in the said Project. Offer letters were issued broadly underlining the terms
and conditions for the sale of the properties to the Plaintiffs.
5.
The Plaintiffs claimed a massive shortfall and disparity in
actual/carpet area vis a vis the super area, which was in total violation of the
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
permitted loading limit of the Builder Buyer Agreement and other laws,
rules and guidelines.
6.
Despite the law and rule being clear on the area, super area and
carpet area, maintenance charges and all other aspects, the Defendant
Builder in a mala fide manner did not transfer the maintenance to the
Owner’s Association, which it was bound to do. More than 60 months have
elapsed since the possession was offered/taken, but till date the transfer has
not happened. The Defendant Builder is obviously usurping money from
the residents in the name of maintenance and profiting from the same.
7.
The Defendant Builder has also been trying to create all sorts of
obstacles and hindrances in formation of lawful AoA/Owner’s Association.
The one which has been formed is wholly illegal and various illegalities
including forgery is being committed by the Defendant Builder.
The
concerned residents/ Plaintiffs and others, have been pursuing criminal
litigation before the jurisdictional Courts in District Gautam Budh Nagar
(U.P.). The Membership has been taken @ Rs.1,000/- and the signatures
had been obtained in the Register, on various dates in the first half of the
year 2018, but no AoA has been formed and there are gross illegalities in its
formation and functioning.
8.
The Defendant has deliberately kept Units unsold, so as to create
grounds for not transferring the maintenance to the Owner’s Association,
clearly to negate Section 14(5) of the U.P. Apartments Act, 2010 and also
Section 11 of RERA. Furthermore, one Tower is still incomplete in respect
of which, the Defendant keeps extending dates of its completion as reported
to RERA,
which as per the latest figureis 04.11.2028, once again to
circumvent the transfer of maintenance.
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
9.
As per the Lease Deed issued by Noida Authority, the Project
consisting a total of 7 Towers, was to be completed by March, 2020 i.e.
within a period of 10 years from the date of original Lease Deed. As stated
before RERA, the Defendant has given the date of completion as
04.11.2028, without any basis or approval from Noida Authority.
10.
The Maintenance Agreements were signed by the Plaintiffs under
pressure and as they had no other option, the Defendant being in a dominant
position. Not just the Maintenance Agreements, but many other valuable
security documents such as stamp papers, undertakings etc. have been
obtained under duress and have been further misused.
11.
The AoA was formed and registered on 11.07.2019, after a delay of 9
months and it came to be known as “The Jewel of Noida Association of
Apartment Owners”. A.G.B.M was purportedly held on 18.11.2018, so that
it would be within one year of offering of possession, which is the criterion
as per the Rules for formation of AoA.
12.
The Affidavit of the Secretary concerned was filed on 03.06.2020,
when the residents moved for the formation of an Association of their own.
There are approximately 250 allottees as on 18.11.2018, out of which 150
are residing in the Project, though only 10 were reported to the concerned
Registrar’s Office. Incidentally, one of these 10 was an employee of the
Defendant. This was again done to circumvent the criterion of minimum 10
allottees.
If the name of this one employee of Defendant is undone, the
number gets reduced to 9 and the criterion of 10, cannot be fulfilled. These
10 naturally took charge as office bearers of the Association and no
elections took place, even though the Rules stipulated that the Board of
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
Management is to consist of 4-10 office bearers, who are the owners/coowners of the Apartments in the Project.
13.
The functioning of AoA has also not been proper. The AoA became
kalateet (time barred) for not conducting the elections within one year. The
election of a New Board was announced by Dy. Registrar (Societies) Meerut
twice. The election process was sabotaged by the Defendant and the elected
Board of flat owners was stayed on 16.02.2024 by SDM (Dadri), who is
investigating in the elections related complaints, which have been filed by
Mrs. Sangeeta Sharma in February, 2022 at the behest of the Defendant.
14.
Exorbitant Club charges are being levied on a monthly basis, despite
the Plaintiffs having paid one-time Club charges at the time of booking/
purchase.
They had given Rs.1 Lakh, despite which the Defendant is
demanding monthly Club charges from all the residents @ Rs.1,000/- per
month per flat. The GST and taxes are being levied on monthly maintenance
charges, for which there is no basis or justification.
15.
The Defendant is charging for the meter (pre-paid meter charges). As
and when the amount charged/ credited for the prepaid meter gets exhausted,
the electricity supply is stopped, even though the amount charged would be
sufficient for the entire month.
The Builder has stopped deducting
maintenance charges for meter from 20.07.2020, but is still deducting
Rs.10.2.5 per KW, Rs.100 per KVA for DG fix charges and Rs.30/- for
meter vending charge, which comes out to be Rs.742.50 per month of
5KVA connection and 2 KVA DG connection, in addition to electricity
charges for Rs.6.9 per unit for UPPCL supply and Rs.19/- per unit for
electricity from DG.
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
16.
The Defendant has diverted the electricity supply from residential
areas to be used for commercial purposes in construction of Tower F and A
which has the Marketing Office.
In addition, other resources of
Maintenance are also being diverted for the said purpose. The electricity
through DG, has been stopped to two Plaintiffs Mr. Lalit Kumar i.e. the
Appellant and Mr. Varun Singh Chandel, since 29.04.2022.
17.
Various issues have been brought to the knowledge of the Builder, but
no remedial/ corrective steps have been taken. The audited accounts of the
maintenance account have not been produced or submitted. The Pro-rata
arrears of VAT charged from the Plaintiffs, has also not been paid. The
sizable premium on the base price prevailing at the time of launch of the
Project in 2013, was charged. The amounts varied from Rs.2 lakhs to
Rs.3.50 lakhs, depending upon the size and the area of a particular flat.
18.
There is reduction in central lawn area, contrary to what was
represented in advertisement and brochures. The Marketing office has been
constructed by the Defendant in the central lawn, which covers roughly 1/3 rd
portion of the lawn.
19.
The P.L.C and Green Belt Charges have been charged by the Builder
as “preferential location charges” from the residents @ Rs.75/- per square
foot for a corner flat. However, since every flat is a corner flat, the basis for
charging PLC, does not arise.
20.
The Defendant has further charged Rs.125/- per sq. ft. plus taxes, as
being the Lawn/green area facing charges. The Central Lawn, however,
does not belong to Builder and the green belt on the back side of the
Society, is just 3-4 ft wide alongside the boundary wall. Also, there is a
cluster of jhuggis and garbage, on the back side.
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
21.
In a similar way of misrepresentation, Builder charged Lease Rent
and Services @ Rs.95/- per sq. ft., but again charged Lease Rent at the time
of possession/Execution of Sub Lease Deed and thus, charged the amount
twice, unauthorizedly.
22.
The Car Parking has virtually become unusable due to practical
difficulties.
Moreover, the Defendant has sold some parking slots to
multiple residents, which reflects that he has usurped the money of the home
buyers/ residents.
23.
The interest of delayed payments has not been paid by the Defendant.
Initially, he started with ROI of 24% per annum and slowly reduced it in
stages and finally in most of the cases 6% Simple Interest has been paid and
also waived the same in some cases as the demand was not genuine. The
unwarranted clauses in the sub-lease deed, were put by the Defendant
Builder, misusing its dominant position.
24.
The Builder had also stipulated a condition that at the time of transfer
of the flat to any other person, the permission would be taken from the
Builder and transfer charges at the rate prevailing at that time, would be paid
to the Builder. A similar condition has been incorporated in the Bye Law of
AoA that at the time of transfer ½% of the sale value shall be paid to AoA.
The U.P Apartment Act stipulates the charges in such cases to be not more
than 1%.
25.
Moreover, the Builder has given rights to develop 700 sq. metres of
commercial space, which is separate from the residential area.
Some
portions of Tower A are being used for this purpose, which is grossly illegal.
26.
On 29.11.2017, Completion Certificate was given by the Noida
Authority. The Possession offer was given to the Plaintiffs, on 02.12.2017.
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
Later on, the Unit allotments were done and possession letters were issued
to various Plaintiffs by the Defendant.
27.
The Plaintiff further claimed that he made various letters raising all
the aforesaid concerns. On 18.04.2019 the Plaintiff received response from
the Defendant regarding the ongoing correspondence, wherein they denied
all the issues in a blanket, vague, ambiguous and unspecified manner.
Various RTI Applications were made to the Public Information Officer,
Noida with regard to various issues affecting the Plaintiffs, in the Project. A
Representation was also written on 12.08.2020 to CEO, Noida highlighting
various irregularities and misconduct on the part of Defendant Builder.
28.
The Plaintiffs have further stated that on the issues raised in the Suit
the Plaintiffs along with several others, had approached National Consumer
Disputes Redressal Commission vide Complaint No.864 of 2020 in the end
of 2020. The Complaint was decided vide Judgment dated 14.06.2023
where the Commission held that issues before it were complex,
omnibus, multifold and were the subject matter of trial by means of
Civil Court.
29.
The Civil Appeal No.6243/2023 was filed before the Supreme Court,
which was dismissed on 27.09.2023 affirming the Judgment of NCDRC.
30.
The Plaintiff has thus, filed the present Suit with the prayers as under
:
(i)
to resume the daily essential services (picking up
garbage from flats and resumption of electricity thru DG) to
Plaintiffs and to refund the fixed charges for electricity thru DG
since April, 2022;
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
(ii)
a Money Decree to refund the wrongly charged farmer’s
compensation along with interest @ 12% per annum;
(iii)
a Money Decree in respect of excess areas, consequent
stamp duty and registration along with interest @ 18% per annum
for refund of interest on advance maintenance charges and MMC
excess charges;
(iv)
Refund of P.L.C and Green Belt charges with interest;
(v)
Refund of fixed meter charges and all incidental and
consequential costs and charges;
(vi)
Refund arbitrarily charged interest on delayed payment
with GST;
(vii)
to refund wrongly charged tax including GST and VAT
and other charges along with interest @ 12 %;
(viii)
to appoint an independent Architect/ Consultant/ Court
Commissioner to measure and ascertain the actual basis with
regard to carpet area, super area, loading limits etc;
(ix)
Mandatory Injunction to execute supplemental sub-lease
deed by removing unwarranted and one-sided clauses;
(x)
for directing the Defendant to produce original copies of
all forms, undertakings;
(xi)
directing the Defendant not to collect or charge
maintenance directly
(xii)
to direct the Defendant to provide convenient, adequate,
safe independent car parking space and to refund the charges
towards car parking space along with interest @ 18%;
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
(xiii)
to direct the Defendant to assist in formation/
functioning of lawful Owner’s Association;
(xiv)
Decree for Rendition of Accounts;
(xv)
directing the Defendant to pay compensation/ punitive
damages and the cost of the Suit.
31.
The Defendant had moved an Application under Order VII Rule 11
CPC as well as Section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act. The Suit has
been dismissed, vide Judgment dated 31.08.2024. Aggrieved, the present
Appeal has been preferred.
Submissions heard and record perused.
32.
The Learned District Judge observed that as per the Clause ‘E’ of
Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the Plaint should disclose the facts which constitute
the cause of action and when it arose. In the Plaint, the Plaintiffs have
articulated virtually every grievance which they may have against the
Defendant Company, whereas what they were required to plead, was a cause
of action.
33.
In so far as the Electricity/ Maintenance Charges were concerned, it
was already in adjudication by U.P RERA. The Appeal was also pending
which the Plaintiffs had undertaken to withdraw. Section 79 RERA Act
prohibits the Civil Court to entertain a Suit or proceeding in respect of any
matter which the Appellate Authority is competent to decide. Consequently,
already there is adjudication against one or the other Plaintiffs. It is not that
the Plaintiffs had directly approached the Civil Court, consequently, on the
aspect of maintenance charges, there is adjudication from the competent
Authority, adverse to the Plaintiff which cannot be nullified by filing the
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
Civil Suit, as is sought to be done by the Plaintiff.
The Consumer
Complaint preferred by the Plaintiffs had also been dismissed, on account of
the issues raised being complex. Furthermore, the Appeal preferred against
the Judgment of the Consumer Forum dated 14.06.2023, has also been
dismissed.
34.
In so far as recovery of money was concerned, on the point of mis-
representation, fraudulent sale or such like reason, as per the documents
filed on record, the properties had been individually purchased by the
Plaintiffs through documents, which culminated into Sale Deeds. The Suit
has been filed in the year 2024 in respect of Sale Deeds, much after the
expiry of three years. The cause of action of recovery of money, is barred
by limitation.
35.
Furthermore, the Civil Suit No.421/2022 titled ‘Vaibhav Gupta
&Anr. vs. E-Homes Infrastructures Pvt. Ltd.’ and Suit No.754/2023 titled
‘Lalit Kumar and Ors. vs. E-Homes Infrastructures Pvt. Ltd.’ had been filed
in the Civil Court. The perusal of the Plaint shows that the Suits pertain to
maintenance and electricity.
Those Suits had been undertaken to be
withdrawn. The Plaintiff had undertaken to withdraw the Suit and not to
press the same, for filing of consolidated Civil Suit. In terms of Order 23
Rule 1 CPC, once the Suit is withdrawn without seeking any liberty, the
cause of action agitated therein is lost and the Plaintiff is precluded from
filing a fresh Suit in respect of the same cause of action. The Plaintiff had
not specifically stated whether they had sought any liberty while
withdrawing their Suits. Learned District Judge observed that the Plaintiffs
were guilty of Forum hunting and were not respecting the Judicial verdicts
adverse to them in their cases.
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
36.
It may also be noted that there are 12 Plaintiffs and each has his
independent cause of action. All their concerns cannot be clubbed together,
because each case needs to be considered on its own facts. This is an
omnibus case filed for adjudication of 12 independent distinct claims of 12
Plaintiffs.
37.
The comprehensive perusal of the Plaint shows that there is also mis-
joinder of cause of action, aside from there being no clear averments to
show that various claims made, are actually tenable or are within limitation.
From the prayer paragraphs it is evident that though refund of various
amounts has been sought, but no quantification has been done and it has
been left for the Local Commissioner to be appointed, to ascertain the
complete facts. The pleadings as well as the relief claimed, aside from
being omnibus, are vague and incomprehensible. Further, Appeal has been
filed by only one Appellant, Latit Kumar and others are not even a party to
the present Appeal.
38.
Learned District Judge has rightly observed that it is a case of abuse
of process of law and has consequently dismissed the Suit with a cost of
Rs.3,000/- on each of the Plaintiff, under Section 35-A CPC.
39.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby
dismissed. Pending Applications are disposed of accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MAY 11, 2026
va
RFA 949/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:17:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review