Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
"
!
%
&
#
# !
"$
!
"
' &
(
!
"
#
"
##
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
$%
#
&
'''
(
%
(
)
%
'*
(
%
''
#
!
-2-
(
%%+
#
%%
#
#
(
#
(
,
% '* %'%
)
"
# %'%
"
-
%
#
!
# (
(
#
""
*+
*'
#
%
#
"
# %'% -
!
*
%%$
#
%
*
%%$
#
(
(
(
.
*
) .
#
%
*
*
#
.
"
*
"
#
%
#
(
/
-3-
/
.
)
0123 4012503 6785904 :72 ;<0 =0;>;>7502 153 4012503
6785904 :72 209=75305;
%
<>9 =0;>;>75 >9 :>403 ?@ ;<0 =0;>;>7502 A<7 >9 ;<0
7?B06;72
;<>23
%'%
=12;@
>5
;<0
7CC026>14
D068;>75
?0>5E 1EE2>0F03 ?@ ;<0 >C=8E503 72302 31;03
% '* %'%
)83E0
=19903 ?@ ;<0
2>56>=14
>9;2>6; 153
099>759
<0 :16;9 7: ;<0 6190 120 ;<1;/
<0 =0;>;>7502 >9 ;<0 72>E>514 7A502 7: ;<0 =27=02;@ >5
G809;>75
09=75305;
D604405;
0F047=029 > 0
306200 <74302 >5 ;<0 0D068;>75 =0;>;>75 1:;02 7?;1>5>5E 1
306200 1E1>59; 209=75305;
7 % =20:02203 15 0D068;>75
=0;>;>75 ;7 0D068;0 ;<0 91>3 1A123
5 ;<0 0D068;>75
=276003>5E9 =20:02203 ?@ 209=75305;
306200 <74302
15 1==4>61;>75 61C0 ;7 ?0 :>403 85302
2302 "
$
-4-
$ 153
% 2013 A>;<
06;>75
27603820 :72 9<72; H;<0
7: ;<0
730 7:
>F>4
I! :72 1;;16<C05; 153 9140 7:
;<0 =27=02;>09 :72 2067F02@ 7: ;<0 1C785; ;<1; A19
7230203 >5 ;<0
$
1;;0C=;
2?>;214
<0 =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 ?0>5E 1EE2>0F03 ?@ ;<0
;7
1;;16<
1==4>61;>75 85302
D068;>5E
A123
9044 <>9
2302 ""
=27=02;>09
840 *+ 7: ;<0
:>403
?0:720 ;<0
782; 641>C>5E ;<1; ;<0 =27=02;>09 ?0475E03 ;7
;<0 =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 153 ;<0 91>3 72302 7: 1;;16<C05; >9
>440E14 153 12?>;212@
?B06;>759 61C0 ;7 ?0 :>403 ;7 ;<0
91>3 1==4>61;>75 ?@ 209=75305;
<012>5E ;<0 1==4>61;>75 75 C02>;9
306200 <74302
=75
;<0
782;
D068;>5E
20B06;03 ;<0 1==4>61;>75 :>403 ?@ ;<0 =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72
F>30 >C=8E503 72302 31;03
% '* %'%
A<>6< ;<0 =0;>;>7502 >9 ?0:720 ;<>9
EE2>0F03 ?@
782;
; >9 ;<0 675;05;>75 7: ;<0 =0;>;>7502 ;<1; <0
05;0203 >5;7 1 9140 1E200C05; A>;< 209=75305;
'
'
7 % 75
%' $ :72 ;<0 9140 7: ;<0 =27=02;@ >5 G809;>75 :72 1
-5-
;7;14 6759>3021;>75 7:
91C0 31@ 1
050214
9%
7A02 7:
>5 :1F782 7: 209=75305;
>C=7903
'' '''
153 75 ;<0 F02@
;;7250@ A19 1497 0D068;03
7 % 153 ;<0 6753>;>759 A020
66723>5E ;7 ;<0 =0;>;>7502 ;<0 91>3 =7A02 7:
1;;7250@ ;7 67C=40;0 ;<0 =1@C05; 7: ;<0 05;>20 9140
6759>3021;>75 1C785; 153 :72 >9981560 7: %' 31@9 =2>72
57;>60
; >9 1497 675;05303 ;<1; 78; 7: ;<0 ;7;14 9140
6759>3021;>75 1C785; 7:
9%
7:
C130
9 $' '' '''
A19
'' '''
1 =12; =1@C05;
98?9;15;>14
?141560
1C785; A19 57; =1>3 153 ;<020 A19 57 >9981560 7: %' 31@
=2>72 57;>60 A<>6< A19 C1531;72@
; >9 :82;<02 675;05303
;<1; 309=>;0 575 :84:>44C05; 7: ;<090 09905;>14 6753>;>759
9;>=841;03 >5 ;<0 1E200C05; ;<0 9140 3003 >5 :1F782 7:
209=75305;
7 % >9 >5F14>3 153 8505:72601?40 19 ;<0 91C0
>9 57; 67C=40;03 153 675648303
; >9 :82;<02 675;05303 ?@ ;<0 4012503 6785904
:72 ;<0 =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 ;<1; ;<0 1440E03 9140 3003 31;03
'* %'
>5 :1F782 7: 209=75305;
7 % >9 >5F14>3 153
8505:72601?40 153 ;<020?@ 209=75305;
7 % <19 57;
-6-
16G8>203 1 F14>3 ;>;40 ;7 ;<0 =27=02;>09 A<>6< 209=75305;
306200 <74302 >9 900J>5E 1;;16<C05; =829815; ;7
2014>9>5E ;<0 :28>;9 7: ;<0 1A123 :72 2067F02@ 7: C750@
;
>9 :82;<02 675;05303 ;<1; 309=>;0 ;<090 :16;9 <1F>5E ?005
?278E<; ?0:720 ;<0
85302
;<0
2302 ""
D068;>5E
D068;>5E
782; ?@ :>4>5E 15 1==4>61;>75
840 *+ 7: ;<0
;<0 4012503 )83E0 7:
782; <19 57; 6759>30203 144 ;<090 19=06;9
153 <19 C06<15>6144@ 3>9C>9903 ;<0 1==4>61;>75
; >9
:82;<02 675;05303 ;<1; ;<0 72302 97 =19903 >9 =1;05;4@
>440E14
=02F0290 153 675;212@ ;7 ;<0 A044 09;1?4>9<03
=2>56>=409 7: 41A
;<0
D068;>5E
012503 6785904 :82;<02 675;0539 ;<1;
782; <19 :1>403 ;7 1==206>1;0 ;<1; ;<0
=27=02;>09 A<>6< 120 978E<; ;7 ?0 1;;16<03 153 9743 >5
186;>75 =829815; ;7 ;<0 1A123 1E1>59; 209=75305;
57; 0F05 ?0475E ;7 209=75305;
=27=02;>09
7:
G809;>75 7: ;<0
;<0
7%
=0;>;>7502 7?B06;72
D068;>5E
7 % 37
?8; 120 1?9748;0
<020:720
;<0
782; =276003>5E :82;<02 :72
1;;16<C05; 7: ;<0 =27=02;>09 :72 2014>K1;>75 7: ;<0 :28>;9 7:
;<0 1A123 7: 209=75305;
306200 <74302 3709 57; 12>90
-7-
153 ;<0 91C0 61557; ?0 3750 19 209=75305;
7 % >9 57;
;<0 7A502 7: ;<0 =27=02;@ >5 G809;>75
+
; >9 1497 675;05303 ?@ 4012503 6785904 ;<1; ;<0
D068;>5E
782; <19 57; 13F02;03 ;7 144 ;<090 19=06;9
50>;<02 <19 >; 675386;03 15@ >5G8>2@
572 159A0203 144
;<090 G809;>759 153 <19 C06<15>6144@ =19903 15 72302
20B06;>5E ;<0 1==4>61;>75
5302 ;<090 6>268C9;15609 A<05
15 1==4>61;>75 >9 :>403 85302
'
7: ;<0
;<0
2302 ""
D068;>5E
840 *+ 2013 A>;<
782; 78E<; ;7 <1F0
675386;03 ;<0 30;1>403 >5F09;>E1;>75 153 ;2>14 19 E773 19
306>3>5E 1 :209< 98>; ?@ E>F>5E =27=02 7==72;85>;@ ;7 ;<0
=0;>;>7502 7?B06;72
?8; <1F>5E 57; 3750 ;<0 91C0
02272 >9 67CC>;;03 6189>5E C>96122>1E0 7: B89;>60 ;7 ;<0
=0;>;>7502
5 ;<090 E278539 <0 900J9 ;7 90; 19>30 ;<0
>C=8E503
72302
=19903
?@
;<0
D068;>5E
782;
7590G805;4@ 4012503 6785904 :72 ;<0 =0;>;>7502 900J9 ;7
1447A ;<0 91>3 1==4>61;>75
4012503
209=75305;
6785904
1==012>5E
:72
;<0 306200 <74302 F0<0C05;4@ 675;0539
-8-
;<1; ;<020 >9 57 >440E14>;@ 72 =02F029>;@ >5 ;<0 72302 =19903
?@ ;<0
D068;>5E
782;
5 :16; 1 A044 20197503 72302 >9
=19903 ;1J>5E >5;7 6759>3021;>75 ;<0 05;>20 C1;02>149
=41603 75 206723 153 ;<0 B83EC05;9 204>03 ?@ ;<0 67859049
:72 ?7;< ;<0 =12;>09 153 ;<0 91C0 >9 3750 >5 1667231560 ;7
;<0 A044 09;1?4>9<03 =2>56>=409 E7F025>5E 85302
840 *+ 7: ;<0
<020:720
2302 ""
<0 675;0539 ;<1; ;<0
>C=8E503 72302 >9 989;1>51?40 153 ;<0 =20905; =0;>;>75 >9
:>403 754@ A>;< 15 >5;05;>75 ;7 =27;216; 153 =27475E ;<0
=276003>5E9 ;7 97C0<7A 6744830 A>;< 209=75305;
7%
<0 =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 <19 ?005 90; 8= 153 6201;03 ;7
;<A12; ;<0 1;;0C=; 7: ;<0 306200 <74302 ;7 9866003 >5 ;<0
1A123 A<>6< ;<78E< 57; G809;>7503 ?@ 209=75305;
7%
<19 1497 57; 9;1@03 ;<0 0D068;>75 =276003>5E9 72 ;<0
1A123
<020:720
;<020
>9
?12
:72
209=75305;
306200 <74302 ;7 =276003 :82;<02 >5 ;<0 0D068;>75 153
2014>90 ;<0 :28>;9 7: ;<0 1A123
*
209=75305;
; >9 1497 675;05303 ?@ 4012503 6785904 :72
306200 <74302 ;<1; ;<0 675;05;>759 =8;
-9-
:72;< >5 ;<0 1==4>61;>75 :>403 85302
;<0
2302 ""
840 *+ 7:
?@ ;<0 7?B06;72 120 :2>F74789 153 120 57;
989;1>51?40 0F05 75 ;<0 C02>;9 7: ;<0 1==4>61;>75 >;904: :72
;<0 9>C=40 201975 ;<1; ;<0 7?B06;72 <19 204>03 8=75 15
1E200C05; 7: 9140 31;03 '
6759>3021;>75 7:
9%
?005 =1>3 ?@ 209=75305;
'
%' $ :72 1 ;7;14 9140
'' '''
A<>6< 78E<; ;7 <1F0
7%
<0 91C0 <1F>5E 57; ?005
=1>3 ;<0 ;>;40 3709 57; E0; ;2159:02203 ;7 209=75305;
153 ;<0 G809;>75 7: 209=75305;
7%
>5>;>1;>5E 15@ 16;>75
:72 1;;16<C05; 153 9140 7: ;<0 =27=02;@ A7843 57; 12>90 19
209=75305;
7 % >9 57; ;<0 7A502 7: ;<0 98>; =27=02;@ :1449
:41; 153 91C0 >9 57; 98?9;15;>1;03 :72 ;<0 201975 ;<1; ;<0
=0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 <>C904: <19 57; =2738603 986< 1 9140
3003 153 57 C1;02>14 >9 =41603 ?0:720 ;<0
;<1; ;<0 9140 6759>3021;>75 A19
7:
9 $' '' '''
9%
782; ;7 91@
'' '''
153 98C
A19 =1>3 19 13F1560 A<>6< A19 2060>F03
?@ ;<0 7?B06;72
'
209=75305;
; >9 1497 675;05303 ?@ 4012503 6785904 :72
306200 <74302 ;<1; ;<0 7589 4>09 8=75 ;<0
- 10 -
7?B06;72 ;7 67C0 ?0:720 ;<0
782; A>;< 64015 <1539
C1J>5E 144 3>964798209 91;>9:16;72@ ;7 ;<0
782; 153
09;1?4>9< 153 =27F0 <>9 6190 75 ;<0 C02>;9 7: >;9 7A5 6190
21;<02 ;<15 ;2@>5E ;7 30=053 8=75 ;<0 30C02>;9 7: ;<0
306200 <74302
0 :82;<02 675;0539 ;<1; ;<020 >9 57 3>9=8;0
A>;<
;7
20E123
;<0
1A123
9866099:844@ ?@ 209=75305;
209=75305;
7%
;<0
;<020
1A123
<1F>5E
7?;1>503
306200 <74302 1E1>59;
<78E< 209=75305;
>9
?005
9;1@
7 % <19 6<14405E03
7?;1>503
1E1>59;
;<0
05:7260C05; 7: ;<0 1A123 ;<020?@ ;<0 7589 4>09 <01F@ 75
;<0 7?B06;72 ;7 67C0 ?0:720 ;<0
782; ;7 =8; :72;< 144
C1;02>149 ;7 09;1?4>9< 6190 A<>6< >9 57; 3750 >5 ;<0
=20905; 6190 75 <153
012503 6785904 <19 =2738603 1
C0C7 A>;< 3768C05;9 >56483>5E ;<0 1440E03 9140 3003
A<>6< >9 204>03 ?@ ;<0 7?B06;72 >5 ;<0 1==4>61;>75 =20:02203
?@ <>C A<>6< A19 57; =2738603 ?@ ;<0 7?B06;72 153 <0
204>09
8=75
'* %'
;<0
30039
31;03
'$ %'
A<>6< 120 0D068;03 ?@ ;<0 =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72
>5 :1F782 7: 209=75305;
7% >0
B83EC05; 30?;72
- 11 -
;<090 ;A7 9140 30039 ;<0 9140 6759>3021;>75 1C785; 19
C05;>7503 >5 ;<0 9140 30039 A<>6< 120 ;<0 20E>9;0203
3768C05;9 <19 ?005 =1>3 >5 :844 153 1660=;03 ?@ ;<0 904402
:27C ;<0 =826<1902 153 >; >9 9=06>:>6144@ C05;>7503 >5 ;<0
641890
%! 7: ?7;< ;<0 9140 30039 ;<1; ;<0 904402 F05372
F05302 <19 304>F0203 ;<0 =799099>75 7: ;<0 96<03840
=27=02;@ 1; ;<0 ;>C0 7: 0D068;>75 153 20E>9;21;>75 7: ;<0
91>3
050214
7A02 7:
;;7250@
<0 91C0 <19 ?005
16J57A403E03 153 ;<0 ;>;40 30039 <1F0 ?005 304>F0203 ;7
;<0 =826<1902
<020:720 4012503 6785904 :72 ;<0 209=75305;
306200 <74302 675;0539 ;<1; >5 ?7;< ;<0 9140 30039
A<>6< 120 =02;1>5>5E ;7 ;<0 =27=02;>09 ?012>5E
79 *
153 *
E85;19
=1>3
C01982>5E
82F0@
E85;19 153
$
;<0 05;>20 9140 6759>3021;>75 1C785; <19 ?005
=27=02;@ <19 ?005 304>F0203 153 ;<0 1C785; <19
?005 16J57A403E03 ?@ ;<0 904402 A<7 >9 5750 7;<02 ;<15
;<0
=0;>;>7502 7?B06;72
012503
6785904
:72
;<0
209=75305;9 204>09 8=75 ;<0 B83EC05; >5 ;<0 6190 7:
- 12 -
20=72;03 >5
A<020?@ <0 204>09 8=75 ;<0 1514@9>9
153 :>53>5E9 20672303 >5 ;<0 91>3 B83EC05; 7: ;<0
=0D
75.?40
782; A>;< 20E123 ;7 ;<0 ;2159:02 7: ;<0 =27=02;@ 19
675;0C=41;03 85302
6;
%
06;>75
$ 7: ;<0
2159:02 7: 27=02;@
; >9 1497 ?278E<; ;7 ;<0 57;>60 7: ;<>9
782;
A<020?@ >5 ;<0 91>3 B83EC05; 1 B83EC05; >5 ;<0 6190 7:
! "
%
>9 204>03 8=75
20=72;03 >5 #$$$
0 :82;<02 675;0539 ;<1; ;<0
98?C>99>75 7: ;<0 =0;>;>7502 ;<1; ;<0 575 =1@C05; 7: ;<0
?141560 6759>3021;>75 1C785; A7843 57; ;2159:02 ;<0 ;>;40
>9 57; 1660=;03 ?@ ;<0
B83EC05;
75I?40
=0D
782; >5 ;<0 91>3
19 575 =1@C05; 7: 1 =12; 7: ;<0 9140 =2>60
A7843 57; 1::06; ;<0 F14>3>;@ 7: ;<0 9140 3003 7560 ;<0 ;>;40
7: ;<0 =27=02;@ <19 142013@ ?005 304>F0203 153 =19903
153 >; A7843 754@ ?0 1F1>41?40 19 1 C1;;02 7: 678290 :72 ;<0
=0;>;>7502 ;7 2067F02 >: 15@ ?141560 1C785; >9 20144@ ;7 ?0
=1>3 ?@ 209=75305;
7 % >5 :1F782 7: ;<0 =0;>;>7502
<020:720 4012503 6785904 675;0539 ;<1; ;<0 1==4>61;>75
- 13 -
:>403 ?@ ;<0 =0;>;>7502 <19 ?005 2>E<;4@ 20B06;03 ?@ ;<0
4012503
D068;>5E
782;
A<>6<
57;
:72
>5;02:020560
%
1F>5E <0123 ;<0 4012503 6785904 :72 ?7;< ;<0
=12;>09
;<0 =7>5;9 ;<1; A7843 12>90 :72 6759>3021;>75
?0:720 ;<>9
782; >9 L(<0;<02 ;<0 >C=8E503 72302 >9 4>1?40
:72 >5;02:020560 153 (<0;<02 15@ >5384E0560 >9 20G8>203 ;7
?0 9<7A5M (<1; 72302MN
<0
:16;
306200 <74302
20C1>59
;<1;
;<0
209=75305;
<1F>5E 7?;1>503 15 1A123
0D068;>75 =0;>;>75 ?0:720 ;<0
:>403 15
7CC026>14
782; ;7 0D068;0
;<0 1A123 :72 2014>K1;>75 7: ;<0 C750@
<020:720 ;<020
A19 57 =799099>75 ;<1; A19 978E<; >5 ;<0 0D068;>75
=0;>;>75 ?@ ;<0 306200 <74302 1E1>59; ;<0 B83EC05; 30?;72
72 15@ ;<>23 =12;@ >56483>5E ;<0 7?B06;72
; >9 57; ;<0 6190
7: ;<0 7?B06;72 ;<1; <0 >9 >5 =799099>75 153 05B7@C05; 7:
;<0 =27=02;@ >5 G809;>75
1C785;
<0 1A123 >9 :72 2067F02@ 7: ;<0
<0 0D068;>75 =0;>;>75 >9 :>403 ;7 05:7260 ;<0
1A123 :72 2067F02@ 7: ;<0 1C785; :27C 209=75305;
- 14 -
7% )
>560 )
;<0 1A123 1C785;
3>3 57; C1J0 E773 ;<0 =1@C05; 7:
;<0 209=75305;
306200 <74302
A19 40:; A>;< 57 7;<02 14;0251;>F0 ?8; ;7 :>40 15 1==4>61;>75
:72 1;;16<C05; 7: ;<0 =27=02;@ 7: ;<0 209=75305;
)
7%
:;02 15 1==4>61;>75 A19 C130 153 >; A19 7230203 ;7
?0 1;;16<03 15 1==4>61;>75 A19 :>403 ?@ ;<0 =0;>;>7502 >5
;<0 E8>90 7: 15 7?B06;72 ;7 >5;2830 >5 ;<0 0D068;>75 =0;>;>75
;7 9;7= ;<0 1;;16<C05; =276099 ?@ C1J>5E ;<090 E278539
A<>6<
13F02;03
;7
1?7F0
2>C12>4@
=0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 A7843 <1F0 ;7 91;>9:@ ;<0
;<0
782; 19 ;7
A<0;<02 <0 <19 15@ F14>3 2>E<; 7F02 ;<0 98>; 96<03840
=27=02;@ A<>6< 20G8>209 6759>3021;>75 72 13B83>61;>75 ?@
;<0
D068;>5E
782; 75 ;<0 986< 1==4>61;>75 ?0>5E :>403
;<>9 20E123 >; A7843 ?0 2040F15; ;7 0D;216; ;<0 =27F>9>759
7:
2302 ""
)
840 *+ A<>6< 2013 19 85302/
*+,+-./0* 1 2+-130-, / ,55 6.27* 41 4*1-8
4 ++*++, /
'9( (<020 ;<0 <74302 7: 1 306200 :72 ;<0
=799099>75 7: >CC7F1?40 =27=02;@ 72 ;<0
=826<1902 7: 15@ 986< =27=02;@ 9743 >5 0D068;>75
7: 1 306200 >9 209>9;03 72 7?9;286;03 ?@ 15@
=02975 >5 7?;1>5>5E =799099>75 7: ;<0 =27=02;@ <0
- 15 -
C1@ C1J0 15 1==4>61;>75 ;7 ;<0 782; 67C=41>5>5E
7: 986< 209>9;1560 72 7?9;286;>75
' ( (<020 15@ 1==4>61;>75 >9 C130 85302 98? 2840
! ;<0 782; 9<144 =276003 ;7 13B83>61;0 8=75
;<0 1==4>61;>75 >5 1667231560 A>;< ;<0 =27F>9>759
<020>5 675;1>503 N
$
<0 :>29; =12; 7:
2302 ""
840 *+ 30149 A>;<
A<020 ;<0 <74302 7: 1 306200 :72 =799099>75 7: >CC7F1?40
=27=02;@ 72 ;<0 =826<1902 7: 15@ 986< =27=02;@ 9743 >5
0D068;>75 7: 1 306200 >9 209>9;03 72 7?9;286;03 ?@ 15@
=02975 >5 7?;1>5>5E =799099>75 7: ;<0 =27=02;@ 67843 C1J0
15 1==4>61;>75 :72
7?9;286;>75
782; 67C=41>5>5E 7: 986< 209>9;1560 72
5 ;<0 =20905; 6190 75 <153 >; >9 57; ;<0 6190
7: ;<0 7?B06;72 ;<1; <0 >9 >5 =799099>75
0>;<02 >9 >; ;<0
6190 7: ;<0 =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 ;<1; ;<0 306200 <74302 <19
978E<; :72 =799099>75 7: ;<0 >CC7F1?40 =27=02;@
; >9 1497
57; ;<0 6190 7: ;<0 =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 ;<1; <0 >9 209>9;>5E
;<0 =799099>75 7: ;<0 =27=02;@ :27C ;<0 306200 <74302 19
<0 >9 >5 =799099>75 A<02019 ;<0 7?B06;72 >9 ;2@>5E ;7 C1J0
78; 1 6190 ;<1; <0 <13 1E2003 ;7 9044 ;<0 =27=02;@ A<>6<
>9 57A 978E<; ;7 ?0 1;;16<03 153 ;7 ?0 9743 >5 186;>75 ;7
- 16 -
;<0 209=75305;
7% )
8; 9>560 209=75305;
57;
7?4>E1;>75
7:
:84:>44
;<0
=1@C05;
7:
7 % 3>3
;<0
6759>3021;>75 1C785; ;<0 9140 3003 <19 57; E750 ;<278E<
153 675648303 153 ;<020:720 ;<0 209=75305;
7% )
3709 57; E0; 2>E<; ;>;40 72 >5;0209; 7F02 ;<0 91>3 =27=02;@
A<>6< >9 57A 978E<; ;7 ?0 1;;16<03 ?@ A1@ 7: ;<0
0D068;>75 =276003>5E9
5 72302 ;7 >5F>;0 ;<0
D068;>5E
782; ;7 675386; 72 13B83>61;0 ;<0 C1;;02 ;<0 7?B06;72 A>44
<1F0 ;7 67C0 ?0:720 ;<0
782; A>;< 144 C1;02>149 67E05;
91;>9:16;72@ 153 ?751 :>30 153 =4160 986< C1;02>149 ?0:720
;<0
782; ;7 =2>C1 :16>0 67C0 ;7 1 6756489>75 ;<1; ;<020 >9
98?9;15;>14 C1;02>14 :72 =276003>5E :82;<02 ;7 675386; 15
>5G8>2@
;7
; >9 754@ ;<05 ;<1; ;<0
'
7:
2302 ""
D068;>5E
782; A>44 13F02;
;7 30;02C>50 144 G809;>759
>56483>5E G809;>759 2041;>5E ;7 2>E<; ;>;40 72 >5;0209; >5 ;<0
=27=02;@ 12>9>5E ?0;A005 ;<0 =12;>09 ;7 ;<0 =276003>5E9 75
15 1==4>61;>75 85302
2302 ""
840 *+
5 1 6120:84 =028914 7: ;<0 C1;02>149 =41603
?0:720 ;<0
782; >; >9 1==1205;4@ 9005 ;<1; ;<0 7?B06;72
- 17 -
<19 57; =41603 15@ C1;02>14 0>;<02 ?0:720 ;<0
782; 72 ?0:720 ;<>9
A<>6<
209=75305;
<0
7% )
D068;>5E
782; 0F05 A>;< 20E123 ;7 ;<0 9140
641>C9
;7
<1F0
05;0203
>5;7
A>;<
153 15@ C1;02>14 ;7 9<7A ;<1; ;<020
>9 575 =02:72C1560 7: ;<0 9140 3003 0D068;03 >5 :1F782 7:
209=75305;
7 % 153 ;<0 9140 6759>3021;>75 1C785; <1F>5E
57; ?005 =1>3
7 A<05 ;<020 >9 57 C1;02>14 =41603 ?@ ;<0
7?B06;72 ?0:720 ;<0
D068;>5E
782; 72 ;<>9
782; >; 61557;
?0 1998C03 72 =2098C03 ;<1; A<1;0F02 >9 91>3 ?@ ;<0
7?B06;72 >9 1 E79=04 ;28;<
D068;>5E
; >9 F02@ >C=72;15; :72 ;<0
782; >5 986< 6>268C9;15609 ;7 2014>K0 A<>6< 120
E058>50 C1;;029 153 A<>6< 120 :2>F74789 C1;;029 :>403 754@
A>;< 15 >5;05; ;7 321E 75 153 =27;216; ;<0 =276003>5E9 1;
;<0 >59;1560 7: ;<0 )
<>C904:
A<7 90;9 8= 986<
7?B06;>F09 ;7 3041@ ;<0 =276003>5E9 153 ;<A12; ;<0
1;;0C=; 7: ;<0 306200 <74302 >5 05B7@>5E ;<0 :28>;9 7: ;<0
1A123 306200
5 ;<0 =20905; 6190 75 <153 ;<0 05;>20 628D 7:
;<0 C1;;02 20F74F09 A>;< ;<0 675;05;>759 7: ;<0 7?B06;72
- 18 -
;<1; ;<020 >9 57 ;>;40 ;<1; 209;9 A>;< ;<0 209=75305;
7% )
8; ;<0 91C0 <19 57; ?005 98?9;15;>1;03 72 57;
0F05 1 9>5E40 =>060 7: 3768C05; =2738603
; >9 57A 9005
;<1; ;<0 =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 <19 C0204@ =2738603 ;<0
1E200C05; 7: 9140 31;03 '
'
%' $ A<020 <0 05;029 >5;7
15 1E200C05; 7: 9140 A>;< ;<0 209=75305;
A>;< ;<0 =7A02 7: 1;;7250@
8;
7% )
1475E
<0 <19 304>?021;04@
98==209903 ;<0 9140 3003 =829815; ;7 ;<0 1E200C05; 7:
A<>6< >9 31;03
31;03
'* %'
'$ %'
153 157;<02 9140 3003
>5 A<>6< ;<020 >9 ;2159:02 7: ;<0
=27=02;@ >5 G809;>75 >5 :1F782 7: ;<0 =826<1902
209=75305;
7% )
6759>3021;>75
153 1497 ;<0 =1@C05; 7: ;<0 05;>20
1C785; ;7 ;<0
5302 ;<0 6>268C9;15609
=0;>;>7502 7?B06;72
;<0 3768C05;9 57A =2738603
1475E A>;< ;<0 1==4>61;>75 85302
;<>9
;<0
2302 ""
840 *+ ?0:720
782; 1==0129 ;7 ?0 15 1E200C05; 7: 9140 A<>6< A19
=20=1203 =2>72 ;7 ;<0 20E>9;21;>75 7: 9140 3003
<020:720
1:;02 684C>51;>75 7: ;<0 9140 3003 153 ?@ 20E>9;21;>75 7:
;<0 91>3 3768C05; 19 675;0C=41;03 85302 ;<0
0E>9;21;>75
- 19 -
6; ;<0 ;>;40 >9 ;2159:02203 ;7 ;<0 209=75305;
7% )
;<0 G809;>75 7: =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 ;2@>5E ;7 91@
;<1; ;<0 ;>;40 <19 57; ;2159:02203 >9 :12 :0;6<03 153 754@
>C1E>512@ A<>6< >9 57; 1660=;03 ?@ ;<>9
+
782;
<1F0 E750 ;<278E< ;<0 >C=8E503 72302 7: ;<0
4012503
D068;>5E
13F02;03
;7
782; A<020 ;<0
;<090
19=06;9
D068;>5E
204>03
782; <19
?@
;<0
=0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 153 61C0 ;7 1 6756489>75 ;<1; ;<0
<19 57; :>403 ;<0 0D068;>75 =0;>;>75 :72 2067F02@ 7:
=799099>75 7: 15@ >CC7F1?40 =27=02;@
<0 0D068;>75
=0;>;>75 >9 :>403 :72 2067F02@ 7: C750@ 153 ;<0 B83EC05;9
204>03 ?@ ;<0 =0;>;>7502 ?0:720 ;<0
D068;>5E
782; A19 57;
1==4>61?40 ;7 ;<0 =20905; :16;9 7: ;<0 6190 19 ;<0@ A020
7230203 >5 1 6190 A<020 304>F02@ 7: =799099>75 A19 978E<;
>5 ;<0 0D068;>75 =276003>5E9
<0 D068;>5E
67C0 ;7 1 6756489>75 ;<1; ;<0 )
782; <19 1497
<19 90; 8= ;<0
=0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 >5 :>4>5E ;<0 1==4>61;>75
A<>6< >5 C@
7=>5>75 67843 ?0 ;280 19 ;<0 7?B06;72 <19 57; 67C0 ?0:720
;<0
782; A>;< 64015 <1539 153 <19 57; =41603 98?9;15;>14
- 20 -
C1;02>14 ?0:720 ;<0
782; ;7 0F05 13B83>61;0 ;<0 C1;;02
:82;<02
<1F>5E 6759>30203 144 ;<090 >5 C@
<020:720
<8C?40 7=>5>75 ;<020 >9 57 E773 6190 72 67E05; 2019759
C130 78; ?@ ;<0 =0;>;>7502 7?B06;72 ;7 9<7A ;<1; ;<020 >9
15@ >440E14>;@ 72 =02F029>;@ 67CC>;;03 ?@ ;<0
D068;>5E
782; ;7 9<7A >5384E0560 >5 ;<0 B82>93>6;>75 85302
%%+ 7: ;<0
759;>;8;>75 7: 53>1 ?@ ;<>9
782;
2;>640
66723>5E4@
=199 ;<0 :7447A>5E/
>
<>9 =0;>;>75 >9
>>
230203 166723>5E4@
&
'
>9;
/
)
7/
*
7/
!:;
!
#
"
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review