The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. Whether the petitioner is having an independent income to live, as in the same standard of the respondent, who is admittedly doing the job of a Pilot and the assets for herself thereof, is a matter of evidence and the court cannot look into those aspects in detail while considering an interim application for maintenance. As I have already pointed out, Annexure A2 agreement, prima facie, doesn’t provide expressly that anything paid towards maintenance and otherwise the inference, prima facie, is that the right of maintenance was waived or relinquished. Such relinquishment or waiver has no legal footing as already found. But I leave the question regarding payment of maintenance, if any, as per 2025:KER:31422 Annexure A2 to be decided by the trial court on evidence. As things stand now, acting on the income disclosed by both sides, considering the status of the husband as a Pilot getting Rs.8,35,000/- as monthly take away salary, where income of the petitioner is not at all established, prima facie, the trial court granted interim maintenance of Rs.30,000/- and the appellate court confirmed the same. The said concurrent findings do not require any interference.
19. In the result, this petition fails and is accordingly dismissed with direction to the respondent to clear the entire due amount within a period of 30 days from today, failing which, the petitioner is at liberty to go with coercive steps to realise the same as per law.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. BADHARUDEEN
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.REV.PET NO. 1121 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 11.04.2024 IN Crl.A NO.1 OF 2023
OF II ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM ARISING OUT OF
THE ORDER DATED 30.11.2021 IN CMP.NO.23/2021 IN MC NO.1 OF 2021 OF
JUDICIAL
MAGISTRATE
OF
FIRST
CLASS
IV
(MOBILE),
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
REVISION PETITIONER/APPELLANT/RESPONDENT:
LAJU CHERIAN, AGED 51 YEARS,
S/O. P.J. CHERIAN, PALAMATTOM HOUSE,
H.NO.126, GANDHI NAGAR, ANGAMALI P.O.,
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN – 683572.
BY ADVS.
P.A.AYUB KHAN
NIJI K.SHAHUL(K/1158/2010)
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER:
TARA LAJU, AGED 47 YEARS,
D/O ROSY SUDARSANAN, 7C,
SARASWATHINILAYAM APARTMENTS,
JAWAHAR NAGAR, KOWDIAR P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695003.
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT,
PIN – 682031.
BY ADV REMA SMRITHI V K
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR SRI JIBU T S
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
04.04.2025, THE COURT ON 10.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
“C.R”
A. BADHARUDEEN, J.
================================
Crl.R.P.No.1121 of 2024-A
================================
Dated this the 10th day of April, 2025
ORDER
This Revision Petition has been filed under Sections 438 and 442
of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (`BNSS’ for short) by the
respondent in C.M.P No.23/2021 in M.C.1/2021 on the files of Judicial
Magistrate of First Class-IV (Mobile), Thiruvananthapuram, challenging
the judgment in Crl.Appeal No.1/2023 dated 11.04.2024 arising out of
C.M.P.No.23/2021 in M.C.1/2021. The petitioner in the above C.M.P and
M.C is the respondent herein.
2.
Heard
the
learned
counsel
for
the
revision
petitioner/appellant/respondent as well as the learned counsel appearing
for the respondent/respondent/petitioner and the learned Public Prosecutor.
Perused the order impugned along with decisions placed by the learned
counsel for the revision petitioner and by the learned counsel for the
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
respondent.
3.
Parties in this Revision Petition are referred as to their
status before the trial court as `petitioner’ and `respondent’, hereafter.
4.
The petitioner approached trial court under Section 20 of
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (`D.V Act’ for
short hereafter) seeking various reliefs. Along with the petition,
CMP.No.23/2021 also was filed under Section 23 of the D.V Act seeking
interim maintenance. According to the petitioner, marriage between the
petitioner and the respondent was dissolved by a decree of divorce passed
by the Family Court in the year 2018. According to her, the petitioner was
gifted with 301 sovereigns of gold ornaments by her parents, as demanded
by the respondent and an amount of Rs.10 lakh was also entrusted to the 1 st
respondent for the welfare of the petitioner.
Again the respondent
demanded for more ornaments and money and done acts of domestic
violence. Consequently, the marriage was dissolved. According to the
petitioner, she doesn’t have any means for maintenance and the respondent
is a Pilot by profession and he is getting more than Rs.15 lakh per month
as salary from his job. Therefore, he is bound to pay maintenance to the
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
petitioner and on this premise interim maintenance was sought for.
5.
The 1st respondent resisted the petition by filing detailed
objection and the crux of the objection is that the petitioner had completely
waived her right to maintenance from the respondent in view of Annexure
A2 agreement entered into between them. Therefore legally she is not
entitled to get maintenance as contended. Further, the respondent raised a
contention that the petitioner has been running a Yoga Centre and she has
been getting an average income of Rs.2 lakh per month. Therefore, she is
not entitled to maintenance, as she could maintain herself.
6.
The trial court disbelieved the income alleged to be
derived by the petitioner for want of materials. In consideration of the fact
that the respondent has been doing the job of a Pilot and admittedly he has
been receiving Rs.8,35,000/- per month as gross income, as can be seen
from his own disclosure in the statement showing his assets and liabilities,
the trial court granted Rs.30,000/- as interim maintenance per month to the
petitioner.
7.
Even though the said order was challenged in appeal, as
per judgment dated 11.04.2024, the learned Additional Sessions Judge
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
dismissed the appeal concurring the finding of the trial court. Now the
concurrent verdicts are under challenge before this Court.
8.
While assailing the concurrent verdicts, it is argued by
the learned counsel for the respondent that in this matter, the parties, after
birth of one child, decided to divorce their marriage and accordingly an
agreement had been entered into between them as on 28.10.2017 executed
before a Notary Public and copy of the same is Annexure A2. As per
Annexure A2, it has been agreed that the second party (petitioner in the
M.C) had amicably settled all disputes towards dowry, permanent alimony
and maintenance etc. and she would not claim any more against the same,
as she had collected all her belongings. Further, properties also shared
between them. In view of clause No.4 in Annexure A2, the petitioner
could not claim maintenance. Therefore, the trial court as well as the
appellate court went wrong in granting interim maintenance to the
petitioner, who actually did not deserve maintenance from the respondent.
9.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that
Annexure A2 agreement has been created by the petitioner and the same
also is under challenge in a litigation at the instance of the petitioner. But
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
she did not disclose its number or other details. After reading the contents
in Annexure A2 it is submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner
that even though in clause No.4 it was stated that the parties had settled all
disputes towards dowry, permanent alimony and maintenance etc., the
subsequent clause of Annexure A2 agreement itself would show that there
was no payment of any sum towards maintenance as per Annexure A2 and
waiver of maintenance is foreseeable from Annexure A2, prima facie.
Therefore the said clause in Annexure A2, which is illegal, would not
stand in the way of grating maintenance to the petitioner.
According to
the learned counsel for the petitioner, the petitioner did not have any
means of maintenance and the allegation that she has been earning Rs.2
lakh per month by running Yoga Centre is not at all proved, prima facie.
Whereas the respondent, who is a Pilot by profession, is getting Rs.15 lakh
every month and the take home salary as per his own disclosure statement is
Rs.8,30,000/-. In such a case, the interim maintenance of Rs.30,000/- granted
by the trial court is very reasonable and the order doesn’t require any
interference.
10.
Having heard the parties, the questions arise for
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
consideration are :
(i) Whether waiver or abandonment of right by maintenance
would negate the claim of maintenance to a wife?
(ii)
What are the matters to be considered when interim
maintenance is canvassed?
(iii)
Once an act of domestic violence is committed whether
the subsequent decree of divorce would absolve the liability of the
husband to deny the benefits entitled under the D.V Act?
(iv)
Whether
the
verdicts
impugned
would
require
interference?
(v)
Relief.
11.
In answer to the first question, it is relevant to refer the
law on the subject.
12.
In the decision of the Apex Court reported in [(1979
KHC 494: AIR 1979 SC 442 : 1979 (1) SCC 352: 1979 SCC (Cri) 302:
1979 CriLJ 198: 1979 MLJ (Cri) 446 : 1979 ALJ 209)] Bhupinder Singh
v. Daljit Kaur the Apex Court dealt with a case of almost identical facts
and held as under:
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
“We are concerned with a Code which is complete on the
topic and any defence against an order passed under S.125 Cr.P.C.
must be founded on a provision in the Code. S.125 is a provision to
protect the weaker of the two parties, namely, the neglected wife. If
an order for maintenance has been made against the deserter it will
operate until vacated or altered in terms of the provisions of the
Code itself. ..... But until the original order for maintenance is
modified or cancelled by a higher court or is varied or vacated in
terms of S.125(4) or (5) or S.127, its validity survives. It is
enforceable and no plea that there has been cohabitation in the
interregnum or that there has been a compromise between the
parties can hold good as a valid defence. .... A statutory order can
ordinarily be demolished only in terms of the statute”. (emphasis
supplied)”
13.
In [(1992 KHC 170 : 1992 (1) KLT 868 : 1992 (2) KLJ
17: ILR 1993 (1) Ker. 112 : 1992 CriLJ 3275)], Haroon v. Sainabha a
contention was raised that the wife and child cannot claim maintenance
from the husband because in an earlier proceedings the matter was settled
out of Court and the wife had executed an agreement in favour of the
husband whereby all the disputes regarding maintenance were permanently
settled. This Court repelled the contention holding that it is the statutory
obligation of the husband to maintain his wife and minor son and he could
not be permitted to contract out of such an obligation and such agreement
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
is opposed to public policy. It was held that a waiver in derogation of a
statutory right could not be recognised by the court as it affects public
policy and as it is against the very statutory obligation imposed on a
husband to maintain his wife and children, who are unable to maintain
themselves.
14.
In [(1979 KHC 545 : AIR 1979 SC 362 : 1979 (2) SCC
316 : 1979 SCC (Cri) 473 : 1979 CriLJ 151 : 1979 Mah LJ 95)], Bai
Tahira v. Ali Hussain Fidaalli Chothia, the Apex Court considered the
question as to whether a divorced wife would lose her right to claim
maintenance for herself under S.125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
on making a declaration in the compromise resulting in a consent decree
that she had no further claim against the husband. The wife had got right in
immovable properties and she had also received Rs.5,000/- as mehar from
the husband. The Trial court held that the former husband was liable to pay
maintenance to his former wife and the children in spite of receiving the
customary dues and other rights in the properties. The Supreme Court
upheld the order of the Trial court. Similar is the view taken in [2018 (5)
KHC 156 : 2019 (1) KLT 826 : 2018 (4) KLJ 528 :ILR 2018 (4) Ker.627],
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
Vikraman Nair v. Aishwarya. Thus the legal position is very clear on the
point that when an agreement is entered into between the wife and the
husband, as a part of compromise filed in the Court or otherwise, whereby
the wife relinquishes or waives the right to claim maintenance in future
from the husband, such an agreement is opposed to public policy and it
does not preclude her from claiming maintenance.
Therefore waiver or
abandonment of right of maintenance by the wife would not negate the claim of
maintenance by the wife or by the child/children.
15.
In [AIR 2021 SC 569], Rajnesh v. Neha and anr., the
Supreme Court considered the claim for maintenance under various
enactments and in paragraphs 7 to 11 addressed how interim maintenance
is to be granted and the same read as under:
“At present, the issue of interim maintenance is decided
on the basis of pleadings, where some amount of guess-work or
rough estimation takes place, so as to make a prima facie
assessment of the amount to be awarded. It is often seen that both
parties submit scanty material, do not disclose the correct details,
and suppress vital information, which makes it difficult for the
Family Courts to make an objective assessment for grant of interim
maintenance. While there is a tendency on the part of the wife to
exaggerate her needs, there is a corresponding tendency by the
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
husband to conceal his actual income. (i) Parties may lead oral and
documentary evidence with respect to income, expenditure,
standard of living, etc. before the concerned Court, for fixing the
permanent alimony payable to the spouse. (ii) In contemporary
society, where several marriages do not last for a reasonable
length of time, it may be inequitable to direct the contesting spouse
to pay permanent alimony to the applicant for the rest of her life.
The duration of the marriage would be a relevant factor to be taken
into consideration for determining the permanent alimony to be
paid. (iii) Provision for grant of reasonable expenses for the
marriage of children must be made at the time of determining
permanent alimony, where the custody is with the wife. The
expenses would be determined by taking into account the financial
position of the husband and the customs of the family. (iv) If there
are
any
trust
funds/investments
created
by
any
spouse/grandparents in favour of the children, this would also be
taken into consideration while deciding the final child support.
In the same decision, the Apex Court addressed the criteria for determining
maintenance and it has been held as under:
“Financial capacity of the husband, his actual income,
reasonable expenses for his own maintenance, and dependant
family members whom he is obliged to maintain under the law,
liabilities if any, would be required to be taken into consideration,
to arrive at the appropriate quantum of maintenance to be paid.
The Court must have due regard to the standard of living of the
husband, as well as the spiraling inflation rates and high costs of
living. The plea of the husband that he does not possess any source
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
of income ipso facto does not absolve him of his moral duty to
maintain his wife if he is able bodied and has educational
qualifications. A careful and just balance must be drawn between
all relevant factors. The test for determination of maintenance in
matrimonial disputes depends on the financial status of the
respondent, and the standard of living that the applicant was
accustomed to in her matrimonial home. The maintenance amount
awarded must be reasonable and realistic, and avoid either of the
two extremes i.e. maintenance awarded to the wife should neither
be so extravagant which becomes oppressive and unbearable for
the respondent, nor should it be so meagre that it drives the wife to
penury. The sufficiency of the quantum has to be adjudged so that
the wife is able to maintain herself with reasonable comfort. Some
factors would also be relevant for determining the quantum of
maintenance payable like, age and employment of parties, right to
residence, where wife is earning some income, maintenance of
minor children, serious disability or ill health.”
16.
In the decision reported in [2014 (2) KLD 693 : 2014
(10) SCALE 738 : 2014 (10) SCC 736 : 2015 (1) KLT SN 56], Juveria
Abdul Majid Patni v. Atif Iqbal Mansoori and another, the Apex Court
considered the question as to whether once an act of domestic violence is
committed, whether subsequent decree of divorce would absolve the
liability of the husband to deny the benefits to which the aggrieved person
is entitled by the D.V Act, and held that an erstwhile wife can also claim
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
maintenance under the D.V Act.
17.
Thus the judgment of the Apex Court in Rajnesh v.
Neha (supra) would govern entitlement of maintenance under various
enactments and the criteria for determining maintenance. In the instant
case, as per the statement of the assets and liabilities disclosed by the
respondent/husband, he has a take away salary of Rs.8,35,000/- per month.
On perusal of the said statement filed by the petitioner, no independent
income of her own could be seen.
18.
Whether the petitioner is having an independent income
to live, as in the same standard of the respondent, who is admittedly doing
the job of a Pilot and the assets for herself thereof, is a matter of evidence
and the court cannot look into those aspects in detail while considering an
interim application for maintenance.
As I have already pointed out,
Annexure A2 agreement, prima facie,
doesn’t provide expressly that
anything paid towards maintenance and otherwise the inference, prima
facie, is that the right of maintenance was waived or relinquished. Such
relinquishment or waiver has no legal footing as already found. But I
leave the question regarding payment of maintenance, if any, as per
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
Annexure A2 to be decided by the trial court on evidence. As things stand
now, acting on the income disclosed by both sides, considering the status
of the husband as a Pilot getting Rs.8,35,000/- as monthly take away
salary, where income of the petitioner is not at all established, prima facie,
the trial court granted interim maintenance of Rs.30,000/- and the appellate
court confirmed the same. The said concurrent findings do not require any
interference.
19.
In the result, this petition fails and is accordingly
dismissed with direction to the respondent to clear the entire due amount
within a period of 30 days from today, failing which, the petitioner is at
liberty to go with coercive steps to realise the same as per law.
20.
Interim order of stay stands vacated.
Registry shall forward a copy of this order to the jurisdictional
court for information and further steps.
Sd/-
A. BADHARUDEEN, JUDGE
rtr/
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
APPENDIX OF CRL.REV.PET 1121/2024
PETITIONER’S ANNEXURES
Annexure A1
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN OP NO. 2060 OF
2017 DATED 02.07.2018 OF THE FAMILY COURT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
Annexure A2
A TRUE COPY OF THE MARITAL SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT
DATED
28.10.2017
BETWEEN
THE
PETITIONER AND THE 1ST RESPONDENT.
Annexure A3
A TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION IN MC NO. 1 OF
2021 ON THE FILE OF THE COURT OF THE CHIEF
JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM ALONG
WITH
COPY
OF
NOTICE
RECEIVED
BY
THE
PETITIONER.
Annexure A4
TRUE COPY OF THE AFFIDAVIT OF ASSETS AND
LIABILITY FOR NON-AGRARIAN DEPONENT FILED BY
THE 1ST RESPONDENT IN MC 1 OF 2021 BEFORE THE
JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE OF THE FIRST CLASS- IV,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
Annexure A5
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE JUDICIAL
MAGISTRATE
OF
THE
FIRST
CLASS-IV,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM DATED 30-11-2022 IN CMP
NO.23 OF 2021 IN MC NO.1 OF 2021.
Annexure A6
TRUE COPY OF THE SAID AFFLDAVIT OF ASSETS AND
LIABILITIES SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER.
Annexure A7
TRUE COPY OF THE LIST OF DOCUMENTS ALONG WITH
COPY OF THE DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED BY THE
PETITIONER BEFORE THE JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE OF
THE FIRST CLASS- IV, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM IN MC
NO. I OF 2021
Annexure A8
TRUE COPY OF THE SUMMARY OF THE BANK
STATEMENTS DATED 07.04.2021 SUBMITTED BY THE
PETITIONER BEFORE THE JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE OF
THE FIRST CLASS- IV, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
Crl.R.P.No.1121/2024
2025:KER:31422
Annexure A9
TRUE COPY OF CMP NO. 584 OF 2021 IN MC NO.1
OF 2021 UNDER SECTION 340 OF CRPC BEFORE THE
JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE OF THE FIRST CLASS- IV,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
Annexure A10
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMORANDUM OF APPEAL IN CRL
APPEAL NO. 1 OF 2023 BEFORE THE COURT OF THE
ADDITIONAL
SESSIONS
JUDGE-II,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
Annexure A11
TRUE COPY OF CMP NO. 3 OF 2023 ON THE FILE OF
COURT OF SESSIONS JUDGE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
Annexure A12
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 17.03.2023 OF THIS
HONOURABLE COURT IN CRL RP NO. 258/2023.
Annexure A13
TRUE COPY OF THE VERIFIED PETITION NUMBERED
CRL MA 4/2023 DATED 02.11.2023 OF THE
PETITIONER ALONG WITH THE DOCUMENTS ATTACHED
THEREWITH.
Annexure A14
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER 04.12.2023 IN CRL.RP
258 OF 2023.
Annexure A15
TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DATED 29-01 2021
FILED
BY
REVISION
PETITIONER
WITHOUT
ANNEXURES IN CMP NO.23 OF 2021 IN MC NO.1 OF
2021 BEFORE THE JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE OF THE
FIRST CLASS-IV, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
Annexure A16
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
19.01.2024 ISSUED IN
TTHIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
DEMAND
FAVOUR
DRAFT
DATED
OF JFCMC IV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review