Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MNHC:150
REPORTABLE
Sl. No. 1 & 2
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 33 of 2026
Km. Laishram Thoinu @ Kajal Devi, aged about 46 years,
D/o Late Laishram Iboton Singh of Singjamei Waikhom
Leikai, P.O. & P.S.- Singjamei, District Imphal West,
Manipur – 795008.
…..Petitioner
Versus
1. Laishram Iboton Singh, aged about S/o Late Laishram
Ibungohal Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal,
P.O.-Imphal
&
P.S.-City,
District-Imphal
West,
Manipur- 795001 (Deceased), represented by her
Legal representatives/Legal heirs namely:(i) Smt. Laishram (Ongbi) Sorojini Devi aged
about 81 years W/o Late Laishram Iboton Singh
of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal, P.O.- Imphal
& P.S.- City, District-Imphal West, Manipur795001.
(ii) Laishram Sanjika Devi, aged about 43 years,
D/o Late Laishram Iboton Singh of Thangal
Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal, P.O.- Imphal & P.S.City, District- Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
(iii) Shri Laishram Sanjit Singh, aged about 41
years, S/o Late Laishram Iboton Singh of
Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal, P.O.-Imphal &
2026:MNHC:150
P.S.- City, District-Imphal West, Manipur795001.
(iv) Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha Singh (PREDECEASED), S/O Laishram Iboton Singh
through/by his L.R./Legal Heirs namely:
(a) Smt. Laishram (Ongbi) Geeta Devi, aged
about 36 years, W/o Late Laishram Heroraj
@ Naocha Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali,
Imphal, P.O.- Imphal & P.S.-City, DistrictImphal West, Manipur-795001.
(b) Laishram Prithiraj Singh, aged about 15
years S/o Late Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha
Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal,
P.O.- Imphal & P.S.- City, District-Imphal
West, Manipur- 795001 and
(c) Laishram Chaningleima Devi, aged 12
years, D/o Late Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha
Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal,
P.O.- Imphal & P.S.- City, District-Imphal
West, Manipur- 795001.
The Respondents No. (iv) (b) & (c) being
minors may be allowed to be represented by
their mother and guardian i.e. Respondent
No. (iv)(a).
2.
Smt. Laishram (Ongbi) Sorojini Devi aged about 81
years W/o Late Laishram Iboton Singh of Thangal
Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal, P.O.- Imphal & P.S.- City,
District- Imphal West, Manipur- 795001.
3.
Laishram Sanjika Devi, aged about 43 years, D/o
Late Laishram Iboton Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu
Gali, Imphal, P.O.-Imphal & P.S.- City, DistrictImphal West, Manipur- 795001.
2026:MNHC:150
4.
Shri Laishram Sanjit Singh, aged about 41 years, S/o
Late Laishram Iboton Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu
Gali, Imphal, P.O.-Imphal & P.S.- City, DistrictImphal West, Manipur- 795001.
5.
Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha Singh (DECEASED),
S/O Laishram Iboton Singh through/by his L.R./Legal
Heirs namely:
(a) Smt. Laishram (Ongbi) Geeta Devi, aged
about 36 years, W/o Late Laishram Heroraj
@ Naocha Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali,
Imphal, P.O.- Imphal & P.S.-City, DistrictImphal West, Manipur- 795001.
(b) Laishram Prithiraj Singh, aged about 15
years S/o Late Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha
Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal,
P.O.- Imphal & P.S.- City, District-Imphal
West, Manipur- 795001 and
(c) Laishram Chaningleima Devi, aged 12
years, D/o Late Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha
Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal,
P.O.- Imphal & P.S.- City, District-Imphal
West, Manipur- 795001.
The Respondents No. 5 (b) & (c) being
minors may be allowed to be represented by
their mother and guardian Respondent No.
5 (a).
…...Respondents
2026:MNHC:150
With
MC(CRP(CRP.Art.227)) No. 56 of 2026
Km. Laishram Thoinu @ Kajal Devi, aged about 46 years,
D/o Late Laishram Iboton Singh of Singjamei Waikhom
Leikai, P.O. & P.S.- Singjamei, District Imphal West,
Manipur – 795008.
…..Applicant
Versus
1. Laishram Iboton Singh, aged about S/o Late Laishram
Ibungohal Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal,
P.O.-Imphal
&
P.S.-City,
District-Imphal
West,
Manipur- 795001 (Deceased), represented by her
Legal representatives/Legal heirs namely:(i) Smt. Laishram (Ongbi) Sorojini Devi aged
about 81 years W/o Late Laishram Iboton Singh
of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal, P.O.- Imphal
& P.S.- City, District-Imphal West, Manipur795001.
(ii) Laishram Sanjika Devi, aged about 43 years,
D/o Late Laishram Iboton Singh of Thangal
Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal, P.O.- Imphal & P.S.City, District- Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
(iii) Shri Laishram Sanjit Singh, aged about 41
years, S/o Late Laishram Iboton Singh of
Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal, P.O.-Imphal &
2026:MNHC:150
P.S.- City, District-Imphal West, Manipur795001.
(iv) Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha Singh (PREDECEASED), S/O Laishram Iboton Singh
through/by his L.R./Legal Heirs namely:
(d) Smt. Laishram (Ongbi) Geeta Devi, aged
about 36 years, W/o Late Laishram Heroraj
@ Naocha Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali,
Imphal, P.O.- Imphal & P.S.-City, DistrictImphal West, Manipur-795001.
(e) Laishram Prithiraj Singh, aged about 15
years S/o Late Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha
Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal,
P.O.- Imphal & P.S.- City, District-Imphal
West, Manipur- 795001 and
(f)
Laishram Chaningleima Devi, aged 12
years, D/o Late Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha
Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal,
P.O.- Imphal & P.S.- City, District-Imphal
West, Manipur- 795001.
The Respondents No. (iv) (b) & (c) being
minors may be allowed to be represented by
their mother and guardian i.e. Respondent
No. (iv)(a).
2.
Smt. Laishram (Ongbi) Sorojini Devi aged about 81
years W/o Late Laishram Iboton Singh of Thangal
Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal, P.O.- Imphal & P.S.- City,
District- Imphal West, Manipur- 795001.
3.
Laishram Sanjika Devi, aged about 43 years, D/o
Late Laishram Iboton Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu
2026:MNHC:150
Gali, Imphal, P.O.-Imphal & P.S.- City, DistrictImphal West, Manipur- 795001.
4.
Shri Laishram Sanjit Singh, aged about 41 years, S/o
Late Laishram Iboton Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu
Gali, Imphal, P.O.-Imphal & P.S.- City, DistrictImphal West, Manipur- 795001.
5.
Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha Singh (DECEASED),
S/O Laishram Iboton Singh through/by his L.R./Legal
Heirs namely:
(a) Smt. Laishram (Ongbi) Geeta Devi, aged
about 36 years, W/o Late Laishram Heroraj
@ Naocha Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali,
Imphal, P.O.- Imphal & P.S.-City, DistrictImphal West, Manipur- 795001.
(b) Laishram Prithiraj Singh, aged about 15
years S/o Late Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha
Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal,
P.O.- Imphal & P.S.- City, District-Imphal
West, Manipur- 795001 and
(c) Laishram Chaningleima Devi, aged 12
years, D/o Late Laishram Heroraj @ Naocha
Singh of Thangal Bazar Alu Gali, Imphal,
P.O.- Imphal & P.S.- City, District-Imphal
West, Manipur- 795001.
The Respondents No. 5 (b) & (c) being
minors may be allowed to be represented by
their mother and guardian Respondent No.
5 (a).
…...Respondents
2026:MNHC:150
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
For revision petitioner/applicant
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, Advocate
Date of Order
01.08.2026
ORDER
[1]
The following abbreviations/short forms have been used in
this order (for the sake of brevity, convenience and clarity):
Sl.
No.
Abbreviation/Short
Form/other short
references
Full Form/Expansion
1.
CRP
Civil Revision Petition
MC
Miscellaneous Case
3.
Trial Court
Court of Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Imphal West-I, Manipur
4.
CPC
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
5.
said suit
O.S. No. 22 of 2008/113/2013 on
the file of Trial Court
6.
said Judl. Misc. Case
Judl. Misc. (Amendment) Case No.
88 of 2018)
7.
impugned order
order of Trial Court in said Judl.
Misc. Case in said suit being order
dated 12.02.2026
8.
D1
first defendant in Trial Court and
similar abbreviation/s are used for
other defendants also
2026:MNHC:150
[2]
Short facts, shorn of elaboration/particulars which are not
imperative for appreciating instant order are that said suit was filed by CRP
petitioner in Trial Court way back in 2008 (15.04.2008 to be precise); that
said suit was filed with declaratory reliefs and injunction inter-alia pertaining
to 3(three) items of immovable properties (‘suit properties’ for the sake of
convenience); that said suit was filed by CRP petitioner arraying her father,
father’s first wife (to be noted, CRP petitioner is daughter to second wife one
Hemolata), her half-sister and two half-brothers arraying them as D1 to D5
respectively; that the defendants on being served with suit summons filed a
common written statement dated 20.06.2008; that thereafter, issues were
framed, trial was commenced and deposition/marking of exhibits concluded;
that the said suit was first listed in Trial Court for final hearing on 07.09.2015
itself; that thereafter, in and vide petition dated 07.05.2018 said Judl. Misc.
Case was filed with a prayer for amendment of plaint resorting to /invoking
Order VI Rule 17 of CPC; that this Judl. Misc. Case was resisted by the
defendants; that the Trial Court after full contest, dismissed the Judl. Misc.
Case in and vide impugned order inter-alia on the grounds the Judl. Misc.
Case has been filed very belatedly and when the suit is in advanced long
after commencement of trial but CRP petitioner was unable to demonstrate
that in spite of due diligence the amendment plea could not be made before
commencement of trial and that amendments sought are merely in the nature
of typographical errors; that in and vide impugned order, Trial Court dismissed
said Judl. Misc. Case primarily owing to proviso to Order VI Rule 17 which
2026:MNHC:150
makes it clear that no application for amendment shall be allowed after trial
has commenced unless the Court comes to the conclusion that in spite of due
diligence a party could not have raised the matter before commencement of
trial; that it is to be noted that said suit was first listed for final hearing on
07.09.2015 itself.
[3]
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel for CRP petitioner and MC
applicant is before this Court (physical Court). After hearing learned counsel
for CRP petitioner/MC applicant and perusing the case file, this Court comes
to the conclusion that captioned CRP does not pass muster in the admission
Board and it deserves to be dismissed. The reasons are as follows:
i.
As already alluded to in factual matrix narration supra,
trial had not only commenced but had concluded and the
said suit was first listed in Trial Court for final hearing on
07.09.2015 itself. Thereafter, more than 2(two) years
and 8 (eight) months later, Judl. Misc. Case for
amendment under Order VI Rule 17 CPC was filed vide a
petition dated 07.05.2018. It is clearly a case where said
Judl. Misc. Case
has been filed not only after
commencement of trial but after conclusion of trial and
2(two) years and 8 (eight) months after the suit was first
listed for final hearing/arguments;
ii.
A careful perusal of the 5(five) amendments sought to
be made makes it clear that all 4(four) amendments are
2026:MNHC:150
in the nature of correction of spelling (not any proper
noun) and some typographical errors and one of the
5(five) amendments seeks to add the expression ‘and
hence cancelled’ after ‘void’. Adding such expression
would hardly
make any difference and may even be
superfluous. There is no reason to entertain said Judl.
Misc. Case which was filed 2(two) years and 8(eight)
months after the suit was first listed for final hearing. A
careful perusal of the impugned order makes it clear that
the Trial Court has rightly dismissed the said Judl. Misc.
Case by placing reliance on proviso to Order VI Rule 17
as the CRP petitioner was unable to demonstrate and
place any material before Trial Court for Trial Court to
come to the conclusion that in spite of due diligence CRP
petitioner could not have raised the matter before
commencement of Trial;
iii.
The said suit is clearly vintage nay ancient as it was filed
more than 18(eighteen) years ago. To be noted, date of
plaint, date of filing of suit and date of institution of suit
are 15.04.2008. The suit is also in the nature of a partition
suit though it has been filed with prayers for declaratory
reliefs and injunction. The said suit is a case of exception
to the age-old adage ‘blood is thicker’ and therefore, it
would hardly serve any purpose in further delaying the
2026:MNHC:150
matter by allowing the amendment application (said Judl.
Misc. Case) at this distant point of time;
iv.
The Judl. Misc. Case is dated 07.05.2018, the impugned
order is dated 12.02.2026 and the captioned CRP has
been filed in this Court only on 30.07.2016. This means
that not only the said Judl. Misc. Case has been filed at a
very belated stage, the captioned CRP itself has been
filed more than 5(five) months after the impugned order
and the trajectory leaves the case making of delay at all
stages.
[4]
In the light of the facts being rock solid and clear as day light,
this Court refrains from adverting to case laws and burdening instant order
with case laws, less instant order may become verbose.
[5]
This Court having set out discussion and dispositive reasoning
supra now proceeds to write the operative portion of instant order. Before
doing so, it is deemed appropriate to write that the Trial Court will do well to
expedite the matter. At this stage, Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel refers to
the last sentence in paragraph 11 of the impugned order which reads as
follows:
‘This indicates that the mistake is purely sheer negligence and
carelessness on the part of plaintiff’s counsel while conducting the
case and there is no merit in the submission placed by the counsel
for the plaintiff.’
2026:MNHC:150
[6]
Learned counsel submitted that afore-referred sentence has
put the Trial Court’s counsel for plaintiff in a predicament and Mr. Ajoy Pebam,
learned counsel requested this Court to preserve the rights of the CRP
petitioner to file an application in Trial Court for expunging this one sentence
alone. This request is acceded to. If such application for expunging the
sentence is filed, Trial Court shall consider the same on its own merits and in
accordance with law but as expeditiously as the official business of the Trial
Court would permit as the expunge application should not become another
reason for further delay in a suit which is already vintage nay ancient.
Ergo, sequitur is, captioned CRP fails and the same is dismissed
[7]
albeit with limited preservation of rights of CRP petitioner to file an expunge
application in Trial Court as mentioned above. As a consequence, captioned
MC also perishes with the main CRP and the same is also dismissed.
Considering the fair manner in which submissions were made by learned
counsel for revision petitioner, this Court refrains itself from imposing costs.
CHIEF JUSTICE
Ab. Surjit
FR/NFR
P.S. I : Upload forthwith.
P.S. II : All concerned will stand bound by web copy uploaded in High Court website
inter-alia as the same is QR coded.
Abujam
Abujam Surjit Singh
2026.08.01
Surjit Singh Date:
20:00:37 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review