The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. 01.2024; that the writ appellants before us filed two writ petitions namely W.P. (C) No. 308 of 2024 assailing the DPC decision dated 22.12.2023 and another writ petition being W.P. (C) No. 79 of 2024 assailing the 27.12.2023 promotion order and 16.01.2024 transfer order; that these two writ petitions came to be disposed of in and by the common impugned order alluded to supra elsewhere in this order; that in the impugned order, as is evident from the undisputed narrative thereat, writ appellants, took the plea that they would give a representation within two weeks timeframe regarding the preparation of seniority list of EEs and the State can take a decision on the same on its own merits and in accordance with law; that this aspect of the matter is captured in paragraphs 17 & 18 of the impugned order by the Hon’ble Single Bench; that pursuant to the impugned order, writ appellants have given a representation dated 04.02.2025 (Annexure/M-4 before us in captioned MCs); that under such circumstances, even before giving the representation, writ appellants have preferred the captioned writ appeals by presenting the same on 24.01.2025 with Condonation of Delay (CoD) applications, the CoD prayers were allowed on
07. 08.2025 (post representation dated 04.02.2025) and the captioned writ appeals are before us in the admission Board today. [5] This Court carefully considered facts and circumstances of the case in the light of the trajectory the matter has taken from the promotion of writ appellants as EEs on and with effect from 03.02.2018 which is the nucleus and genesis of the matter. [6] To be noted, the trajectory the matter has taken, together with essential facts have been captured supra vide short narrative of facts. [7] This Court heard Mr. E. Premjit Singh, learned counsel for appellants in detail in the admission Board. This Court finds that the captioned main WAs do not pass muster in the admission Board and the reasons are as follows: (a) Before the Hon’ble Single Bench, though the writ appellants have challenged DPC proceedings dated 22.12.2023 as well as promotion order dated 27.12.2023 and transfer order dated
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
KABORAMBA Digitally
KABORAMBAM
M SANDEEP SANDEEP SINGH
Date: 2025.11.05
SINGH
16:34:24 +05'30'
Sl. No. 5-8
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.A. No. 38 of 2025
Lairikyengbam Tamocha Roy; & Ors.
Appellants
Vs.
State of Manipur; & Ors.
Respondents
Clubbed with
MC (WA) No. 79 of 2025 With
W.A. No. 39 of 2025 with
MC (W.A.) No. 78 of 2025
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
ORDER (ORAL)
(Order of the Court was made by M. Sundar, CJ)
03.11.2025
[1]
This common order will now govern the captioned two ‘main Writ
Appeals’ (‘WAs’ in plural and ‘WA' in singular for the sake of brevity) and
captioned two Miscellaneous Cases thereat. The ‘Miscellaneous Cases’ shall be
referred to as ‘MCs’ in plural and ‘MC’ in singular, also for the sake of brevity.
[2]
Captioned two main WAs are intra–court appeals vide which a
common order dated 29.11.2024 made by a Hon’ble Single Bench of this Court
in W.P. (C) No. 308 of 2024, W.P. (C) No. 79 of 2024 and the MCs thereat has
been assailed. This ‘29.11.2024 common order’ shall be referred to as ‘impugned
order’ for the sake of clarity.
[3]
To be noted, captioned W.A. No. 39 of 2025 is directed against
W.P. (C) No. 308 of 2024 and W.A. No. 38 of 2025 is directed against W.P. (C)
No. 79 of 2024, obviously with the respective MCs thereat.
[4]
Short facts, shorn of particulars/details not imperative for
appreciating this order are that the three writ appellants in the captioned WAs
are now serving as ‘Executive Engineers’ (‘EEs’ for the sake of brevity) in Water
Resources Department (WRD) in the Government of Manipur; that the writ
appellants were promoted as EEs with effect from 03.02.2018; that Assistant
Engineers (AEs) is the feeder post qua EEs; that writ appellants are promotee
AEs; that direct AEs (to be noted, individuals who were appointed directly as AEs
unlike the writ appellants) assailed the promotion of writ appellants as EEs with
effect from 03.02.2018 by way of W.P. (C) No. 917 of 2017 etc. (9 writ petitions
in all); that the main writ petition Nos. are (1) W.P. (C) No. 917 of 2017 (2)
W.P. (C) No. 1168 of 2018 (3) W.P. (C) No. 119 of 2018 (4) W.P. (C) No. 164 of
2018 (5) W.P. (C) No. 166 of 2018 (6) W.P. (C) No. 274 of 2018 (7) W.P. (C)
No. 665 of 2022 (8) W.P. (C) No. 78 of 2022 (9) W.P. (C) No. 99 of 2018; that
these 9 writ petitions came to be disposed of by a Division Bench of this Court
by a common order dated 30.10.2023 inter alia upholding the promotion of writ
appellants as EEs and the Rules which enabled such promotion; that in and vide
this 30.10.2023 order, the Division Bench also made it clear that the direct AEs
can also be considered for promotion to the post of EEs; that the direct AEs
(petitioners in 6 out of the 9 writ petitions) carried the matter to Hon’ble Supreme
Court by way of SLPs being SLP (C) Nos. 25889-25894 of 2023; that these SLPs
were filed in the Hon’ble Supreme Court on 08.11.2023;
that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court disposed of the 6 SLPs in and by an order dated 03.02.2025; that
in the interregnum, Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) met on
22.12.2023, took a decision and pursuant to such decision, promoted the direct
AEs as EEs vide order dated 27.12.2023 and passed transfer order dated
16.01.2024; that the writ appellants before us filed two writ petitions namely
W.P. (C) No. 308 of 2024 assailing the DPC decision dated 22.12.2023 and
another writ petition being W.P. (C) No. 79 of 2024 assailing the 27.12.2023
promotion order and 16.01.2024 transfer order; that these two writ petitions
came to be disposed of in and by the common impugned order alluded to supra
elsewhere in this order; that in the impugned order, as is evident from the
undisputed narrative thereat, writ appellants, took the plea that they would give
a representation within two weeks timeframe regarding the preparation of
seniority list of EEs and the State can take a decision on the same on its own
merits and in accordance with law; that this aspect of the matter is captured in
paragraphs 17 & 18 of the impugned order by the Hon’ble Single Bench; that
pursuant to the impugned order, writ appellants have given a representation
dated 04.02.2025 (Annexure/M-4 before us in captioned MCs); that under such
circumstances, even before giving the representation, writ appellants have
preferred the captioned writ appeals by presenting the same on 24.01.2025 with
Condonation of Delay (CoD) applications, the CoD prayers were allowed on
07.08.2025 (post representation dated 04.02.2025) and the captioned writ
appeals are before us in the admission Board today.
[5]
This Court carefully considered facts and circumstances of the case
in the light of the trajectory the matter has taken from the promotion of writ
appellants as EEs on and with effect from 03.02.2018 which is the nucleus and
genesis of the matter.
[6]
To be noted, the trajectory the matter has taken, together with
essential facts have been captured supra vide short narrative of facts.
[7]
This Court heard Mr. E. Premjit Singh, learned counsel for
appellants in detail in the admission Board. This Court finds that the captioned
main WAs do not pass muster in the admission Board and the reasons are as
follows:
(a)
Before the Hon’ble Single Bench, though the writ appellants
have challenged DPC proceedings dated 22.12.2023 as well as
promotion order dated 27.12.2023 and transfer order dated
16.01.2024, at the time of disposal of the writ petitions, writ
appellants have by their own volition, taken the plea that they are
concerned only with the preparation of the seniority list of EEs,
they urged the State to prepare a seniority list of EEs though the
SLPs were pending and also by their own volition submitted that
they will give a representation to
the State with regard to
preparation of seniority list of the EEs and the State can make an
order on its own merits and in accordance with law on their
representation. To be noted, as already alluded to supra, writ
appellants have also given a representation dated 04.02.2025;
(b)
Writ appellants on their own volition having taken such a
stand before the Hon’ble Single Bench and having invited the
impugned order dated 29.11.2024 cannot now be heard to assail
the impugned order by way of captioned intra-court appeals i.e.,
captioned WAs. To be noted, as per allusion supra, the aforereferred aspect of the matter which unfurled before the Hon’ble
Single Bench has been captured by the Single Bench inter alia in
paragraph 16–18, we deem it appropriate to extract and
reproduce paragraph 16-18 together with concluding paragraph
19 and the same read as follows:
‘[16] Mr. RK. Mehta, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits
that since there is no stay by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
pending SLP, the State respondent may be directed to prepare the
seniority list of Executive Engineer within a stipulated period of
time.
[17] Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. A.G., submits that since the
matter is pending before the Hon’ble Supreme Court, it may not
be appropriate to the State respondent to prepare final seniority
list at its own and the petitioners may be directed to submit a
representation in this regard and they will consider as per rule.
[18] Mr. RK. Mehta, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits
that the petitioners will submit a detailed representation to the
State respondent within two weeks and the State respondent may
consider the case of the petitioners as per rule.
[19] With this observations and directions, writ petitions are
disposed of. Misc. applications are also disposed of in terms of the
above observations and directions’ ;
(c) The only option now available for writ appellants is to await
disposal of their representation dated 04.02.2025. If the disposal
of the representation of writ appellants dated 04.02.2025 is in
favour of writ appellants, that would be curtains but if it is adverse
to writ appellants, it is open to writ appellants to assail the same
inter alia by way of seeking a writ of certiorari, if so advised and
if so desired, but we refrain from expressing any opinion on the
course of action which the writ appellants may have to take;
[8]
Be that as it may, if the aforesaid scenario unfurls and if the writ
appellants choose to assail the disposal of the representation dated 04.02.2025
by way of writ petitions or in any other appropriate manner, the same shall be
considered on its own merits and in accordance with law untrammeled by instant
order which has been made for the limited purpose of giving a closure to the writ
appellants’ challenge to the common impugned order dated 29.11.2024.
[9]
In the event of the aforesaid scenario unfurling, though obvious,
we make it clear that it will be open to writ appellants to assail the DPC
proceedings dated 22.12.2023 as well as the promotions of direct AEs vide order
dated 27.12.2023 followed by the transfer order dated 16.01.2024 and the same
shall also be considered on its own merit and in accordance with law
untrammeled by instant order.
[10]
All this means, writ appellants will now have to await disposal of
their representation dated 04.02.2025.
[11]
At this juncture, i.e, when the order was being pronounced, Mr. E.
Premjit, learned counsel for writ appellants brought to our notice that 7 (seven)
direct AEs who were serving as EEs have since been promoted to the next higher
posts of Superintending Engineers (SEs) in and by an order dated 06.02.2025
made by State and a scanned reproduction of this order is as follows:
[12]
Though obvious, we make it clear that it is open to writ appellants
to assail the aforesaid 06.02.2025 order also in a manner known to law and if
writ appellants choose such a course, such challenge would be considered on its
own merits and in accordance with law untrammeled by instant order.
[13]
Though obvious, for the purpose of abundant specificity, we clarify
that this order will not in any manner touch upon much less infringe the right of
direct AEs as they are not before this Court when the instant order is being made.
To be noted, instant order is being made in the admission Board and as already
adverted to supra captioned WAs do not pass muster in the admission Board. If
there is any challenge in the aforesaid manner, all the rights and contentions of
the direct AEs will stand preserved for being canvassed before the Court
concerned which will consider the same also on its own merits and in accordance
with law.
[14]
Captioned Writ Appeals are dismissed in the aforesaid manner
albeit with preservation of rights and observations as set out supra.
Consequently, captioned MCs thereat also perish with the WAs and the same are
dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sandeep
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review