Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$
I s4881
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION NO: 33548 OF 2016
Between:
L.S.Chowhan, S/o.H.S.Chowhan Hindu, aged 43 years Occ Deputy Commissioner of
Police R/o.Villa No.23, Magadha Village Kokapet, Hyderabad. Telangana.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The Union of lndia, Rep.by its Secretary Ministry of Home Affairs New Delhi.
2. Union Public Service Commission, Rep.by its Secretary Dholpur House, New
Delhi
3. The State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep.by its Chief Secretary Home Department,
Secretariat Hyderabad.
4. The Director General of Police, State of Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad.
5. Sri S.V.Rajasekhar Babu, IPS Superintendent of Police, Ananthapur, A.P.
6. Sri V.Satyanarayana, IPS DCP, South Zone, Hyderabad.
7. Sri K.V.Mohan Rao, IPS Superintendent of Police Vigilance and Enforcement
Nellore.
8. Smt B.Sumathi, lPS, DCP, North Zone, Hyderabad
9. Sri P.H.D.Ramakrishna, IPS Superintendent of Police, Kadapa YSR Kadapa
District, AP
10.Sri M.Srinivasulu, lPS, Superintendent of Police, CID Telangana State,
Hyderabad.
1'l.The Central Administrative Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, Hyderabad. Rep.by
its Registrar.
..,RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
//
.,-,"
pleased to call for the records relating to O.A.No.130312011 on the file of the
Honble Central ,\dministrative Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, Hyderabad and quash
the order dt.30-06-2016 in so far as went against the petitioner by issuing a writ of
certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or direction as the same is illegal
and contrary to iaw and consequently allowthe O.A. No.1303/2011 as prayed for
and pass such other order or orders as this Honble Court may deem fit and
proper in the circ;umstances of the case.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRt T.KOTESWARA RAO
counsel for the Respondent No.1 : sRl B.NARASTMHA SHARMA,
. Addl.Solicitor General of lndia, rep., SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO,
Dy.Solicitor General Of lndia
counsel for the Respondent No.2 : sRl AJAY KUMAR, sc FoR upsc
counsel for the lRespondent No.3&4: SRr A.RAGHURAM MAHADEV,
rep., SRt B.RAJESHWAR RAO, Gp FOR Ap STATE
Counsel for the llespondents No.5TO11 :
cou nser fo r the Res po n de nts No. 1 2i
ij' sfl [[i,i|Ji,
The Court made the following: ORDER
rl
l;
tt
hl
ill
IN THE HIGH COI'RT F1OR THE STATE OF. TELIINGANA
AT IIYDERABAI)
THT HON'BUE THE CHIE,F JI'SCICE SRI APARTSH KI'MAR SIITGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JI'STICE G.M.MOTIIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION No.33548 of 2O16
DATE:0j.O3.2O26
BEIWEEN:
L.S.Chowhan
..Petitioner
AND
Union of India and 9 others
..Respondents
ORDER
Heard Sri T.Koteswara Rao, learned counsel for the petitioner;
Sri B.Narasimha Sharma, learned Additional Solicitor General of
India representing Sri N.Bhujanga Rao, learned Deputy Solicitor
General of India appearing for respondent No.l; Sri Ajay Kumar
Kulkarni, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.2-Union
Public Service Commission (UPSC); Sri A.Raghuram Mahadev,
learned counsel representing Sri B.Rajeshwar Rao, learned
Government Pleader for the State of Andhra Pradesh appearing for
respondent Nos.3 and 4 and Sri B.Krishna, learned Government
Pleader appearing for Services (Home) appearing for respondent
Nos.12 and 13 and perused the record.
..)..
2.
The present writ petition is filed with the following prayer
'......it is prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to call for
th.e reards relating to O.A. No.13O3/ 201 1 on the file of tlte Hon'ble
Central Administratiue Tibunal, Hgderabad Bench, Hyderabad
and quash th.e order dt. 30-06-2016 in so far as went against the
petitioner by issuing a writ of certiorai or anA other appropiate
wit, order or direction as the same is illegal and antrary to laut
and unseqrtently allow the O.A.No.13O3/ 2O11 as prayed for and
pass such other order or orders as fhrs Hon'ble Court may deem
fit and proper in the circumstances of tlrc case."
Factual background (in briefl
3.
The petitioner was appointed as a Deputy Superintendent of
Police (I)SP) in the erstwhile State of Andhra Pradesh in the year
1998 through direct recruitment conducted by the Andhra Pradesh
Public Service Commission (APPSC). The petitioner was promoted as
Additional Superintendent of Police (ASP) in the year 2005 and
thereaftr:r as Superintendent of Police (SP) in the year 2OO8. It is the
case of the petitioner that he was never superseded by any of his
juniors in these promotions.
4.
Indian Police Service (Appointment by
Promotion)
Regulations, 1955 (for short '1955 Regulations') govern the
promotion of officers from the State Police Service to the Indian
Police fiervice (lPS). Under the said Regulations, a Selection
Commitl:ee is constituted every year to prepare a iist of suitable
officers for promotioq to the IPS. The petitioner, having completed
the requisite eight years of service as a DSP, became eligible for
consideration for the panet years 2OOg-Aand 2O1O.
5.
The Selection Committee convened its meeting on27.10.2011
to consider eligible officers for the said panel years. While forwarding
the proposal to respondent No.2-Union Public Service Commission
(UPSC), respondent No-3-State Government and respondent No.4-the
Director General of Police (DGP) withheld the integrity certifisate of
the petitioner on account of certain allegations said to have been
levelled against him, which were subsequently enquired into and
culminated in issuance of a warning memorandum dated
22.O8.20Lr.
6.
Aggrieved by the withholding of the integrity certificate, the
petitioner filed O.A.No.1O73 of 2OL1. The said O.A. was disposed of
on 18.11.2011 directing the respondents to issue the integrity
certificate to the petitioner if he fell within the parameters of the
Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) Circular, dated
27.1O.L999. However, by the time this order was passed, the
Selection Committee for 2OO9-A and 2O1O years had already met on
27.1O.2OL1, and the selection process had been concluded.
7.
The petitioner's case was considered by the Selection
Committee for the panel years 2OO9-A and 2010. As per the minutes
of the meeting placed on record by the UPSC, tl e petitioner was
assessed as "Good" for both the panel years on an overall assessment
of his service record. In view of the statutory limitation on the size of
i24.i
the sele,:t list and the availability of oflicers who had secured higher
gradingr; such as "Very Good", ttre petitioner could not be included in
the sek:ct lists. The select lists were thereafter notified by the
Governrnent of India on 19. L2.2Ol1-
8.
'[he petitioner thereafter instituted O.A.No.13O3 of 2O11
before the Tribunal, challenging the selection process and seeking
reconsicleration of his case. During the pendency of the said original
application, the petitioner liled several miscellaneous applications
seeking impleadment of selected candidates, amendment of the relief
sought, and permission to raise additional grounds, all of which
came to be allowed by the Tribunal.
9.
Lrpon consideration of the pleadings and the record, including
the peti':ioner's personal file relating to the allegations against him,
the Tritrunal, by order dated 30.06.2016, dismissed the original
application. Though the Tribunal noticed certain procedural lapses
on the part of the State authorities in withholding the integrity
certificate and also made observations regarding the scrutiny
undertaren by the UPSC, it ultimately concluded that no case was
made c,ut warranting interference with the selection process.
Subseqtrently, the petitioner was issued an integrity certificate and
was thereafter, promoted to the IPS against the select list of the year
2012, which came to be acted upon by the Government of India on
16.O3.2015.
\^
//
10. Aggrieved by the order, dated 30.06.2016 passed by the
Tribunal dismissing the aforesaid original application, tJre petitioner
has filed the present writ petition.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioner
11. l.earned counsel for the petitioner has made the following
submissions:
i. That the petitioner was assessed as "Good" by the Selection
Committee for the panel years 2OO9-A and 2010, whereas he
was subsequently assessed as "Very Good" for the panel year
2OL2. According to the learned counsel, for the very same
assessment year 2OO9-2OLO, the petitioner was graded as
"Good" in 2O1O selection but was assessed as "Very Good" for
the year 2012, which demonstrates non-application of mind on
the part of tl:e Selection Committee which considered tl.e
petitioner for the years 2OO9-A and 2O 10.
ii. That the only distinguishing factor between the selection held
in the year 2O1O and the selection in 2Ol2 was the nonissuance of the integrity certihcate in the former and its
issuance in the latter. That the petitioner was ultimately
promoted to the IPS in the year 2OL2 on the basis of the same
service records, including the Annual Confidential Reports
(ACRs) for the year 2OO9-201O. Thus, the withholding of the
integrity certificate was the sole reason for the petitioner's non-
A-
s(-'lection in the earlier panel years, rendering the selection
p::ocess arbitrary.
iii. That the then DGP, who was instrumental in withholding the
in.tegrity certificate, was also a member of the serection
crmmittee, and the presence of such an officer in the serection
C,rmmittee vitiated the proceedings on account of bias.
Rr:liance in t]lis regard was placed upon the decisions of the
Srrpreme Court in A.K. Kroiipak a. llnion oJ Indiat and
Ranjit Thakur a. union of rndiaz, to submit that where there
exists a reasonable likelihood of bias, the decision-making
process itself stands vitiated.
iv. Th.at although the Tribunal noticed certain procedural tapses
in the withholding of the integrity certificate and also observed
th.et the UPSC had not detected the same at the relevant stage,
it ::revertheless erred in declining to interfere with the selection
process, and t]1e Tribunal ought to have held the selection
vitiatecl once the issue of bias and procedural irregularity was
esl.ablished.
v. That the Tribunal, being the court of first instance, ought to
ha,re called for all the relevant records incruding the
cornparative assessment sheets of the petitioner and the
selected candidates. The failure to summon the complete
r (ie6e) 2 sicchq
2 (198714 f;CC 6l 1
record and the consequent dismissal of the o.A.No.13O3 of
2OLL was a jurisdictional error.
vi. That the argument based on the grading in the year 2oL2
constituted a new plea, the learned counsel placed reliance on
the decision in Rattan Lal Shartna a. Managing Comtnittee,
Dr. Hari Ram Co-education Higher Secondo;ry School and.
others3 to contend that a new plea going to the root of the
matter can be permitted to be raised-
vii. That despite an undertaking given before this Court to place
on record the relative assessment sheets of the petitioner and
the selected candidates, the same had not been produced. It
was urged that an adverse inference ought to be drawn against
the respondents.
viii.
That the submission of certain documents by the UPSC
in a sealed cover without furnishing copies to the petitioner,
violates the principles of natural justice, as held by the Honble
supreme court in comtnander Amit Kumar shartna and
others a. llnion oJlndla o:nd. othersa.
Submissions on behalf of respondent No.2-UPSC
L2.
Learned counsel for the respondent No.2-UPSC has made the
following submissions:
3 (1993)4 SCC 10
4 (2023120 SCC 486
4.,
::8::
i. That the assessment made by the Selection committee is
basr-d exclusively on the service records of the concerned
officers, particularly the ACRs for the relevant period. The
issuance of an integrity certificate by the State Government
onl1. d,etermines whether the inclusion of an officer in the
select list is unconditional or provisional and does not
influence the grading assigned by the Selection Committee'
ii. That the selection committee makes an independent
ass()ssment of the service records in accordance with the
applicabte guidelines, and such assessment may differ from
the overall grading recorded in the ACRs. Therefore, the fact
tha:- the petitioner was assessed differently by a Selection
Cor:rmittee constituted for another panel year cannot render
the earlier assessment illegal-
iii. That tl.e petitioner cannot claim a right to compare his grading
acr()Ss different panel years, since each Selection Committee
functions independently and makes its own assessment on the
basis of the material placed before it and the relative merit of
offir:ers within the zone of consideration for that particular
year)'-=
iv. That reliance was placed on the minutes of ttre Selection
Cornmittee meeting dated 27.1O.2OL1, which demonstrate that
the petitioner's case was duly considered in accordance with
, ..o..
,I.
the appl.icabte regulations. It was submitted that the petitioner
was graded as "Good" and could not be included in the select
tist due to the availability of officers who were graded "Very
Good' and the statutory limitation on the size of the select list.
v. That the scope of judicial review in matters relating to
recommendations of Departmental Promotion Committees or
Selection Committees is extremely limited. Reliance was placed
upon the decisions of the Apex court in uPSC a. K. Rolialahs,
M.V. Thimmoliah o. U.P,SC6, Dalpo;t Afu'saheb Solo;nke o'
B.S. MahaJanr, and UPSC a. M. So;ttl:iga Prigas, to contend
that the courts cannot sit in appeal over the assessment of
merit made by expert bodies unless mala fides or violation of
statutory rules is established.
vi. That the petitioner had failed to implead atl the officers whose
selection is sought to be challenged; that any interference with
the select lists would affect the rights of such officers.
Therefore, the writ petition suffers from non-joinder of
necessary parties.
vii.That the contention based on the grading in the year 2012 was
not raised before the Tribunal and cannot be permitted to be
raised in the present proceedings.
s (2005) 10 scc 15
6 (2008) 2 SCC 119
? (1990) 1 SCC 305
8 (2018)
ls SCC 796
\
\
(,
::10::
viii.
That the allegation of bias against the DGp was vague
aed unsupported by any material. It was pointed out that the
S=lection committee consisted of several members including
rt:presentatives of the Government of India and the upSC, and
ttre mere presence of a State representative cannot be a ground
tc vitiate the entire selection process.
ix. That the documents in a sealed cover were produced only for
the perusal of the court pursuant to its directions and that the
essential records, including the minutes of the Selection
cr>mmittee, had already been furnished to trre petitioner.
13. we herve taken note of the respective submissions and the
material placed on record.
Consideration by this Court
L4. The principal grievance of the petitioner is that the withholding
of his irLtegrity certificate was illegal and that, had the same been
issued, he would have been selected. The Tribunal, in the impugned
order, h:rs indeed observed that there were procedural lapses on the
part of rt:spondent Nos.3 and 4 in withholding the integrity certificate
and that the UPSC failed to notice such lapse. The question,
however,lthat arises for consideration is whettrer such lapse, by
\.
itself, co:rfers a legal right upon the petitioner to claim selection, or
warrants interference with the entire selection process. In ttris
context, it becomes necessary to advert to the scheme of the 19s5
.r
::1 1::
Regulations, particularly the Regulation No.S governing the
preparation of the Select List, which is extracted as under:
5. Pteparatlon oJ a llst oJ Sutta,bte offfcers.5 (1) Each Commtttee shall ordinaily meet euery year and
prepare a list of such members of the State Police Seruice as are
held by them to be suitable for promotion to the Seruice. The
number of members of the State Police Seruice to be included in
the list shall be detennined bg the Central Gouentment bt
cnnsultation with the State gouemment @ncerrted, and shall not
exeed tlw number of substantiue uacancies as on ttrc Jirst day
of January of thc gear in which th.e meeting is held, in the posts
auailable for them under rule 9 of the Recruitment Rules. The
date and uenue of the meeting of the Committee to make the
selection shall be determined by the C;ommission;
Prcuided that no meeting of the bmmittee shall be h.eld, and no
list for the gear in question shall be prepared when,
a. tlere are no substantiue uacanaes cs on the first day of
January of ttw year in tle posts available for the members
of the state Police Seruice under rule 9 of tlte reauitmerfi
ntles; or
b. the Central Gouemment in ansultatiott with the State
Gouentment decides that no recntitment shall be made
during th.e gear to the substantiue uacancies os on the first
day of January of the gear in the posts auailable for the
members of the State Police Seruice under tule 9 of the
Recruitment Rules,'
houided funher thnt uthere no meeting of the Committee
could be lrcld duing a gear for anA reason other than that
prouided for in tle first prouiso as and when the Committee
meets again, the Select List shatl be prepared separately for
each year during which the Committee auld not meet as on
the 3l"t Deccmber of each year.
Exptanationt In case of Joint Cadres, a separate select list
shall be prepared in respect of each State Police Seruice.
5(2) Tle Committe.e shall ansider for inclusian to the said
list, the cases o/ members of the State Police Seruices in tlrc
order of senioitg in that seruice of a number which is e.qual to
three times the number referred in subteguldtion (1).
Prouided that such restidion slwll not apply irt respect of a
State where tle total number of eligible offiers is less than three
times the maximum permissible size of the. Select List and in
such a cose tlrc Committee shall corsider all th.e eligtble officers;
Prouided further that in computing the number for inclusion in
the field of mnsideration, th.e number of officers referred to in
sub-regulation (3) shall be excluded;
Prouided also that thc Committee shall not oonsider the ca.se
of a member of the State Police Seruice unless on the first day of
l.
z:L2:z
January of the year for which th.e Select Lisf is prepared trc is
su!:stantiue in the State Police Seruice and ltas completed not
less than eight years of continuous sertice (tuhether offi.ciating or
sultstantiue) in tle post of Deputg Supeintendent of Police or tn
atty other post or posts d.eclared equiualent thereto bg the State
Gouentmerfi.
Prouided also that in respect of ang released Emergency
Commissiorred or ShorT Seruice Commissioned olficers appointed
to the State Police Seruice, eighl years of ontinuous setuice as
required under the preceding prouiso shall be rcunted from the
dee-med date of their appointment to that seruice, subject to the
cottdition that such olficers shall be eligible for onsideration if
th.eA haue ampleted nof less that four years of actual
cotztinuous seruice, on the lst daA of January of tlrc year for
which tlrc Select ,ist is prepared, in the post of Deputy
Superintendent of Police or in any oth.er post or posis declared
eqtdualent thereto bg the State Gouemment.
Explanation:- The powers of tle State Gouemment under the
thircl prouiso to the sub-regulation shall be exercised in relation
to the members of the State Police Seruice of anstituent State, by
the Goue.mttent of that State.
5 {2)(A): Deleted.
.5 (3): The Committee shall not ansider fhe cases of the
mernbers o_f the State Police Seruice wh.o haue attained the age of
54 years on the first dag of January of the year for which the
Sele.ct Lisf is prepared :
Prouided that a member of the State police Seruice wlrcse
name appears in the Select List prepared for the earlier gear
before the date of the meeting of the Committee and who hoLs not
beet appoirtted to the senice onlg because te was included
prouisiottally in that Select List stnll be ansidered for inclusion
in the fresh list to be prepared by the Committee, euen if he has
in tlrc meanwhtle, attained the age of fifiy four Aeats.
I>rouided further that a member of the State police Seruice
uth<> has attained the age of fiftg four gears on the
first day of
January of tlte gear for which the Select List is prepared shall be
ansidered by tlte Comtnittee, if he was eligible for unsideratiort
on the. fi.rst dag of "January of the Aear or any of the years
immediately preceding the year in which such meeting b hetd
but auld not be considered as no meeting of the Committee was
held duing such preceding year or Aears under item. (b) of the
prouiso to sub -regulation( 1 )".
5 (3) (A) The Committee shall not crr:.s,ider the case of such
member of tlrc State Police Seruice who hnd been included in an
earher select hst and:
a. lwd expressed his unwillingness pr appointment to the
seruice under regulatiott 9;
::13::
Prouided thot he shatt be ansidered for indusion in the
Setect List, if before the ammencement of tle year, h'e
applies in witing, to the State Gouernment eryressing hts
unwillingness to be ansidered for appointment to tle
seruice;
b. was not appointed to the seruice by the Central Gouernment
under regulation 9 (a).
Sft) The Selection Committee shall classify the eligible officers
as "Outstanding", "Very Good", "Good" and "unfit" as th.e case
may be on an ouerqll relative assessmenf of tlrcir seruice
reards.
5 (5) The List shall be prepared bg including the required.
number of names first from amongst tle officers finally classified
as "Outstanding" then frum amongst those similarly classified
as "Very Good" and thereafter fiom amongst those simitarlg
classified as "Good" and tlrc order of names inter-se within each
categot! shalt be in the order of their senioritg in thc State Police
Seruice.
Prouided that the name of an officer so included in the list
shall be treated as prouisional if the State Gouernment withholds
the integitg certif.cate in respect of such an offcer or anq
proceedings, d.epartmental or crininal are pending against him
or attgthing aduerse agaittst him which renders him unsuitable
for oppointment to th.e seruice has ame to the notie of the State
Gouenunertt.
Prouided funler that while preparing year-wise selecf lisfs
for more than one gear pursuont to the 2"d proviso to sub
regulation (1), the olJicer included prouisionallg in any of the
Select List so prepared shall be ansidered for indusion in the
Select List of subsequent gear in addition to the normal
cottsideration zone and irt case le is found fit for inclusion in the
suitability list for that year on a provisional ba.sis such inclusion
shalt be in addition to the normal size of th.e select list
detennined by the Central Gouernment for such gear-
Explanation I: The proceedings shall be trcated as pending
ontg if a charge-sheet has actuatly been issued to the officer or
filed in a Courl as tlle case maY beExplanetton tI: The aduerse thing uthich came to th-e notice
of the State Gouerutment renderhtg him unsuitable for
appointment to the seruice shall be trcated as hauing come to the
notice of tlre State only if the details of the same haue been
ommunicated to ttrc Central Gouemment and th.e Central
Gouernment is satisfied that the details furnished bg the State
Gouemment haue a bearing on tte suitabilitg of tle offtcer and
inuestigation thereof is essential 5 (6)Omitted.
5 (7) Deleted
\--
l-
::l4z:
15. { plain reading of the above reguration indicates a clear
distinc:ion between the process of assessment of oflicers and the
proces{i of their inclusion in the Select List. The assessment of an
officer as 'outstanding", "Very Good", or "Good" is required to be
made try t].e Selection Committee on the basis of an overall relative
evalual:ion of the ACRs. The integrity certificate, on the other hand, is
a sepa::ate requirement, the absence of which does not preclude the
Committee from assessing the officer. Its withholding only affects the
nature of the officer's inclusion in the select List, which, in such
circumstances, is treated as provisional rather than unconditional.
16. It is pertinent to note that the grading assigned by the
selectir>n committee is essentially a reflection of the officer,s
perfornrance as borne out from the entries in the senrice record.s, and
not of the opinion of the state Government with regard to his
integrity. The material placed before this court indicates that the
Selectir>n committee had the petitioner's ACRs for the relevant period
before it and, upon due consideration thereof, assessed him as
"Good". Such assessment was arrived at in the course of a
compan:ative evaluation of all eligible officers falling within the zone
of
considr:ration.
L7.
l'he overarl gradings given to the petitioner in his ACRs relating
b,.v
to 200{}-04 to 2OO9-10 are reproduced hereunder:
'f
15::
Grading
Outstanding
Outstanding
(o 1-04-2004 to 02-06-2004l
Good
(03-06-2004 to 3 1 -03:2Q9!I-
2005-o6
2006-o7
Very Good
Very Good
(O1-04-20o6 to r2-o2-2$O7l
2007-o8
Very Good
(O 1-04-2007 to 09 - LO-2OO7\
(L2- LO-2OOT to 3 1 -03-2008)
2008-09
Outstanding
Very Good
Very Good
(O 1-O4-2O09 to 3L-O7 -2OO9l
Outstanding
(O 1-08-2009 to 3 1-03-2010)
Year
2003-o4
2004-o5
2009-10
18. A perusal o[ the minutes of the Selection Committee meeting
dated 27.LO.2O11, placed on record by the UPSC, discloses that
several officers were assessed as "Very Good" for the select year in
question. In view of the statutory timitation on ttre size of the Select
List and the availability of officers possessing a higher grading, the
petitioner, who had been assessed as "Good", could not be included
in the said list.
19. Further, the contention that the absence of the integrity
certificate must have influenced the assessment of the selection
Committee is misconceived as unsupported by any cogent material'
The selection committee comprised senior offrcers from different
authorities, and there is nottring on record to demonstrate that the
assessment was influenced by the withholding of the certificate,
which, in terms of the 1955 RegUlations has no bearing on the
grading of service records. In these circumstances, although the
::16::
withholding of the integrity certificate may
constitute a procedural
lapse, ' t cannot be said that such lapse,
by itserf, vitiated the
assessnrent made by the Selection committee.
The grading assigned
to the trretitioner was the outcome of the committee,s
his seruice records and not a consequence
evaluation of
of tlre non-issuance of the
integrity certificate
2()' The assertion made by the petitioner that the then
had recommended withholding of the petitioner,s
was also a member of the selection committee,
integrity certificate,
and his participation
in the r;aid committee vitiated the entire selection
account ,f a reasonabre likerihood of bias,
process on
cannot be accepted.
2L- It is weil settled that the Doctrine of nemo judex
(that no person shalr be a judge in
DGp who
in causa sua
his own cause), is an integral
facet of the principres of natural justice.
t]'e doctrine depends upon the existence
However, the apprication of
of circumstances giving rise
to a real Ikelihood of bias.
22' In A'K. Kraipak (supra 1), the Hon'ble supreme
that t,.e test is not whether the authority
whether trrere exists a reasonable ground
was likely to be biased. Similarly, in
observed that the proper test is
possession of relevant information,
court held
was in fact biased, but
for apprehending that he
Ranjtt ,.ho,otr(supra 2), it was
whether a reasonable person, in
wourd think that bias was likely.
23. Examined in the light of the aforesaid principles, the material
on record does not disclose any circumstance St ring rise to a 'real
likelihood' of bias. The then DGPs action of recommending the
withholding of the integrity certifrcate was an administrative function
he was duty-bound to perform, and his subsequent participation in
the Selection Committee, where the function was to assess ACRs,
does not create the kind of direct, personal interest that the doctrine
of bias is designed to guard against.
24. It is also to be noted that the Selection Committee, which met
on 27.LO.2O11, was a multi-member body consisting of six senior
officials, including nominees of the Government of India and the
Union Public Service Commission, with the Chairperson being a
nominee of the UPSC. The function of the Committee was confined to
the assessment of the ACRs of eligible officers within the zone of
consideration. The Committee did not conduct interwiews, and the
petitioner's case was evaluated along with those of several other
officers. In these circumstances, the mere fact that the DGP was one
among the members of the Selection Committee cannot, by itself,
lead to an inference that the proceedings stood vitiated on account of
bias- There is no material placed before this Court to indicate that
the DGP's participation had any determinative influence on the
assessment undertaken by the Committee.
&"
::18::
25. It is well settled that the Doctrine of Bias is attracted only
where there exists a real likelihood of prejudice arising from a
personerl or direct interest in the outcome. rn crautford Bagleg
&
co. a. l'Inion of rndias, the Hon'rrle supreme court held that mere
official ;rssociation with the subject matter, without a demonstrable
personal interest or conflict, would not by itself attract the doctrine.
Thus, having regard to the composition of the selection committee
and the nature of the exercise undertaken by it, this court finds no
basis to conclude ttrat the proceedings were vitiated on account of
bias.
26- orr perusal of the record, it does not substantiate the
petitione'r's contention that the Tribunal failed to call for the
completr: records. It is evident that the Tribunal undertook a detailed
examination of t]:e record. It perused the petitioner,s personal file
containing the proceedings relating to the allegations levelled against
him and considered the reports of the ADGP (Intelligence) and the
DlG, as well as the explanation submitted by the petitioner. upon
such exermination, the Tribunal recorded a categorical finding that
the withholding of the integrity certilicate constituted a procedural
lapse.
27,
Insofar as the petitioner's grievance regarding the comparative
assessment of ACRs vis-d-vis the private respondents
e (2006) 6 SCC 2s
is concerned,
::19::
.,
the Tribunar observed that
no substaqtive material had been
placed
on record to estabrish that the
petitioner was more meritorious.
The
only document relied upon by
the petitioner was an unsigned
and
undated typed statement, which
devoid of evidentiary varue. In
the absence of any reriabre material
regarding the gradings of the
observed that it was difficurt
private respondents, the Tribunal
to adjudicate upon the ailegation
discrimination- Such observation
exercise jurisdiction; rather,
the Tribunal rightry herd to be
cannot be construed as a refusal
of
to
it reflects a legitimate exercise ofjudicial
restraint where the party alleging
discrimination fails to place the
necessary factual foundation.
2a' It is trite law that the power of
records is discretionary and
is ordinar,y exercised when the party
concerned estabrishes a prima
examination. In the present
facte case warranting such
case, the burden lay upon
to demonstrate, at reast primafacie,
been unfairly downgraded. Having
undertaken a roving enquiry into
the petitioner
ttrat his grading/assessing had
failed to discharge this burden,
the petitioner cannot contend that
the Tribunal ought to have
the matter.
29' It may arso be noticed that in
UPSC has placed on record
a court or Tribunal to call for
the present proceedings the
the minutes of the serection
meeting dated 27.Lo.2011, which
officers within the zotae of
committee
disclose the grading assigned
consideration. The said
to all
minutes
fl.
::20::
sufliciently indicate that the petitioner's non-inclusion in the Select
List wasi on account of the availability of officers assessed with higher
grading. In such circumstances, no further comparative assessment
materia was necessary for adjudication. Therefore, the submission
that an adverse inference ought to be drawn against the Upsc for
non-production of additional documents is, devoid of merit.
30. Ttre reliance placed by the petitioner on his subsequent
inclusio:r in the Select List of the year 2or2 is misconceived for the
followinll reasons:
i)
Fi::stly, the said plea was not urged before the Tribunal and is
raised for the first time in tl-e present writ petition. In any
ev-'nt, the assessment made in a different panel year by a
dilferently constituted selection committee, in respect of a
dilferent set of vacancies and officers, cannot be relied upon to
challenge an earlier and independent selection process.
iil
Se:ondly, selection under the relevant Regulations is based on
a comparative and relative assessment of officers within the
zone of consideration for the particular panel year. The
pet.itioner's subsequent grading as "Very Good,, in the year
20L2 only indicates that his profile was comparatively superior
in that year; it does not invaridate his earlier assessment as
"Goodr.
" .'t')/r
::21:z
iii)
Thirdly, the fact that the petitioner's ACR for the year 2OO9-10
was assessed differently by two Committees does not indicate
arbitrariness or bias, as each Selection Committee is required
to make an independent evaluation of the service records.
31. It is also to be noted that the issue of non-joinder of necessary
parties goes to the root of the maintainability of the writ petition.
The petitioner has challenged tl:e Select Lists for the panel years
2OO9-A and 2O1O, wherein 11 and 15 officers respectively were
selected and whose rights would be directly affected in the event of
any interference with the said lists. In service matters involving
challenge to a select list, all persons likely to be adversely affected
are necessar5r parties. In the present case, none of the officers
selected in the 2OO9-A list have been impleaded, and out of the 15
oflicers selected for 2O1O, only six have been arrayed as respondents.
In the absence of the remaining selectees, any order passed would
violate the principles of natural justice. Thus, the Tribunal rightly
noted this defect while declining to entertain the challenge to the
2OO9-A list.
32. Further, this Court does not find merit in the sealed cover
submission as made by the petitioner. There was no violation of the
principles of natural justice, as the principal document, namely the
minutes of the Selection Committee, has already been furnished to
\il--:-; = '
\
..r4..
the petitioner. And the remaining material was produced only for the
limited l)urpose of the Court's perusal.
Conclusiion
33. For the foregoing reasons, we find no merit in the writ petition.
The no:r-issuance of the integrity certificate did not vitiate the
assessrrent made by the Selection committee, which was based on
the petitioner's service records and a comparative evaluation of
officers within the zone of consideration. The allegation of bias
against the DGP is unsubstantiated, and the Tribunal's order dated
30-06-2016 does not suffer from any jurisdictional error warranting
interfert:nce by this Court.
34. A()cordingly, the writ Petition is dismissed. The order dated
30.06.2c16 passed by the central Administrative Tribunal,
Hyderal>ad Bench, in O.A.No.1303 of 2O1l is hereby affirmed.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed. No costs.
S
ED ABDULLAH KHAN
ISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One C:C to SRI T.KOTESWARA RAO
PUCI
2. One C;C to SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO, Deputy Solicitor General of lndia, High
Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OPUC]
3. One C;C to SRI AJAY KUMAR, SC FOR UPSC. IOPUC]
4. Two c;cs to GP FoR THE srATE oF ANDHRA PRADESH, High court for
the State of Telarlgana at Hyderabad. [OUT]
-_r-:.
{.:,.!5*.;,_,
5. Two CCs to GP FOR SERVICES (HOtVlE), High Court for the State of
Telangana. [OUT]
6. Two CD Copies.
BSK
BS
w
t
:t
i;
!
I
i
HIGH COURT
DATED::09/03/2A26
T
\
;.,:tt5.
g > TII
- f,rs
t"(t'
.)
CI
0 ? APn ?0?6
t.i
*
ORDER
WP.No.33548 of 2010
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUIT COSTS
\o
to{"4
-q--
*
)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review