The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Be that as it may, in our opinion, the delay of over two decades in applying for the correction of date of birth is ex facie fatal to the case of the respondent, notwithstanding the fact that there was no specific rule or order, framed or made, prescribing the period within which such application could be filed. It is trite that even in such a situation such an application should be filed which can be held to be reasonable. The application filed by the respondent 25 years after his induction into service, by no standards, can be held to be reasonable, more so when not a feeble attempt was made to explain the said delay. There is also no substance in the plea of the respondent that since Rule 84 of the M.P. Financial Code does not prescribe the time-limit within which an application is to be filed, the appellants were duty-bound to correct the clerical error in recording of his date of birth in the service book.” The above principles were reiterated by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Karnataka Rural Infrastructure Development Limited versus T.P. Nataraja and others11, - 12 - (2026:HHC:36759 ) wherein after considering its previous pronouncements on the subject, the law on change of date of birth was summarized as under: “10. Considering the aforesaid decisions of this Court in law on change of date of birth can be summarized as under: (i) application for change of date of birth can on…
11. Therefore, applying the law laid down by this Court in the aforesaid decisions, the application of the respondent for change of date of birth was liable to be rejected on the ground of delay and laches also and therefore as such respondent employee was not entitled to the decree of declaration and therefore the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court is unsustainable and not tenable at law.” 4(iv) Insofar as petitioner’s reliance upon the decision rendered in Chet Ram2 is concerned, suffice to note that applicability of Himachal Pradesh Financial Rules, 2009 had not been discarded in the said decision. Rather, Hon’ble Court observed that the same has to be read in harmony with Fundamental Rule 56 and further clarified the issue as under:“12. This Court clarifies that by not allowing this petition and by not directing the correction of date of birth, the Court is not giving any adjudication on the issue as to what actually is the date of birth of the petitioner. All - 13 - (2026:HHC:36759 ) that the Court is observing is that when an entry with regard to date of birth is made in the service record of an employee, which obviously was made on the basis of information provided by the employee himself, then, if as per said employee, there is any infirmity in the date of birth which he initially informed to the employer, then, he has to approach the employer for correcti…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
(2026:HHC:36759 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
CWP No. 15138 of 2026
Decided on: 31st August 2026
_________________________________________________________________
Kusum Lata
....Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors
…Respondents
_________________________________________________________________
Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
1 Whether approved for reporting?
_________________________________________________________________
For the petitioner:
Mr. Rupinder S. Minhas, Advocate.
For the respondents:
Ms. Menka Raj Chauhan, Deputy
Advocate General.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Petitioner feels aggrieved by the rejection of her
representation by the respondents in terms of the decision
contained in office letter dated 18.06.2026 (Annexure P-6),
whereby petitioner’s prayer for changing her date of birth in
service record was turned down.
2.
Heard and considered the case file.
3.
Petitioner is currently aged 57 years. She was
appointed
as
Trained
Graduate
Teacher
(Arts)
in
the
respondent-Education Department on contract basis on
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
-2-
(2026:HHC:36759 )
18.02.2021.
3(i)
During the hearing of the case, learned counsel
for the petitioner submitted that at the time of entry into
service, i.e. in February 2021, the petitioner had furnished
her Matriculation Certificate issued to her on 18.07.1984
(Annexure P-4), reflecting her date of birth as 06.09.1968.
The same was accordingly entered in her service record. The
services of the petitioner were regularized by the respondentdepartment on 06.04.2023.
3(ii)
It is the case of the petitioner that after joining the
service, she noticed that her date of birth had been wrongly
recorded as 06.09.1968, whereas her correct date of birth
was 06.09.1969. The petitioner instituted Civil Suit No. 25/1
of 2023 on 01.03.2023 in the Court of learned Civil Judge,
Court No. 2, Mandi, District Mandi, seeking declaration to the
effect that her correct date of birth was 06.09.1969 and not
06.09.1968, which had been wrongly recorded in the
Matriculation Certificate issued by the defendant. The only
defendant impleaded in the civil suit was the H.P. Board of
School Education, Dharamshala, District Kangra, through its
Secretary. The petitioner did not implead her employer, viz.
-3-
(2026:HHC:36759 )
the present respondent. The civil suit was decreed on
24.07.2024. The defendant, viz. the H.P. Board of School
Education, Dharamshala, implemented the judgment and
decree by issuing a fresh Matriculation Certificate to the
petitioner incorporating 06.09.1969 as her date of birth.
3(iii)
Armed with the judgment and decree passed by
the learned Civil Court and the fresh Matriculation Certificate
issued to her, the petitioner, for the first time, represented to
her employer on 25.08.2025, seeking correction of her date of
birth recorded in the service record from 06.09.1968 to
06.09.1969. Petitioner’s representation was turned down by
respondent No. 2, viz. the Director of Education, on
18.06.2026, with the following reasoning: “It is further informed that, as per the provisions contained
in Rule 1972 of the Himachal Pradesh Financial Rules,
2009, and the judgment dated 17.04.96 passed by the
Hon'ble H.P. Administrative Tribunal in OA No. 341/1995,
an application for change of date of birth is required to be
submitted by a Government servant within two years from
the date of entry into Government-service. However, the
documents enclosed with the case reveal that Smt. Kusum
Lata TGT (Arts), GSSS Dhawal, District Mandi, submitted
her application for change of date of birth on 23.08.2025,
i.e., after the expiry of the prescribed period of two years
from the date of her entry into Government service.
Therefore, her request for alteration of date of birth in the
(2026:HHC:36759 )
-4-
service records cannot be considered and allowed under
the existing rules and instructions.”
3(iv)
It is in the above background, petitioner has
instituted this writ petition for the grant of following
substantive reliefs: “i)
That in view of the above mentioned facts and
circumstances,
the
impugned
order
dated
18.02.2026
(Annexure P-4), may kindly be quashed and set aside, in the
interest of justice and fair play.
ii)
That the respondents may kindly be directed to make
correction in service record of the petitioner by entering his
date of birth as 06.09.1969 instead of 06.09.1968.”
Learned counsel for the petitioner emphasized
that
the
respondents
had
wrongly
rejected
petitioner’s
representation seeking correction in the date of birth on the
ground of it being a stale claim. Inviting attention to following
paragraph from Chet Ram Versus State of H.P. and
others2, it was contended that the petitioner had represented
to the respondents for correction of her date of birth in the
service record within five years as provided under Note 6 of
Fundamental Rule 56:“11.
A reading of Clause 172 of 2009 Rules supra
harmoniously with Note 6 of Fundamental Rule 56,
leaves no room of doubt that after the 2009 Rules
have come into force, a person has to approach the
CWPOA No.7212 of 2019, decided on 31.08.2020
(2026:HHC:36759 )
-5-
competent authority for correction of the date of birth
within 5 years as from the date when he entered into
service, which in this case, has to be treated as the
date of regularization. As from the date of
regularization, be it 1971 Rules or be it 2009 Rules
read with Fundamental Rule 56, Note 6, the petitioner
did not approach the competent authority within the
time stipulated therein for correction of his date of
birth.”
4.
Consideration
4(i)
Admittedly, at the time of appointment, the
petitioner
had
furnished
her
Matriculation
Certificate
categorically reflecting her date of birth as 06.09.1968. The
respondent, therefore, did not commit any error in recording
06.09.1968 as petitioner's date of birth.
It is also worth
noticing here that petitioner had passed out her 10th class in
terms of certificate dated 18.07.1984 (Annexure P-4), wherein
her date of birth was recorded as 06.09.1968. The petitioner
was thus all along aware about 06.09.1968 having been
recorded as her date of birth in the Matriculation Certificate.
She had herself submitted the said certificate at the time of
her entry into service.
4(ii)
It was only around regularisation of her service
that the petitioner instituted civil suit seeking declaration
that her correct date of birth was 06.09.1969 and not
(2026:HHC:36759 )
-6-
06.09.1968. The civil suit was decreed on 24.07.2024.
However,
the
petitioner
cannot
enforce
the
aforesaid
judgment and decree against her employer, as the employer
was not impleaded as a defendant in the aforesaid civil suit.
In
Laxmi
Singh
Verma
Vs.
H.P.
Board
of
School
Education3, it was held that decree by the Civil Court
against the Education Board directing correction of date of
birth in the educational certificate will not entitle the
employee to get his date of birth as entered in the service
record corrected on that basis.
4(iii)
In terms of Note 6 of Fundamental Rule 56 date of
retirement of a Government servant, be it 58 years or 60
years, as the case may be, has to be determined with
reference to date of birth declared by the Government servant
at the time of appointment and accepted by the appropriate
authority on production, as far as possible, of confirmatory
documentary evidence such as High School Certificate or
extracts from the Birth Register. The Note further provides
that the date of birth so declared by the Government servant
and accepted by the appropriate authority, shall not be
subject to any alteration except as specified in this note, as
CWP No. 1227/2021 decided on 14.12.2021
-7-
(2026:HHC:36759 )
under: “Note 6(a)
a request in this regard is made within five years of
his entry into Government service;
(b)
It is clearly established that a genuine bona fide
mistake has occurred; and
(c)
the date of birth so altered would not make him
ineligible to appear in any School or University or
Union Public Service Commission examination in
which he had appeared, or for entry into
Government service on the date of which he first
appeared at such examination or on the date on
which he entered Government service.”
Clause 7.1 of Chapter VII of Himachal Pradesh
Financial Rules, 1971, provides that declaration of age made
by the employee at the time of or for the purpose of entry into
government service be deemed to be conclusive unless the
employee applies for correction of his recorded age within two
years from the date of his entry into the government service.
Clause 7.1(d) of Chapter VII reads thus: ““(d)(1)
in regard to the date of birth a declaration of age
made at the time of or for the purpose of entry into
Government service, shall as against the
Government servant in question, be deemed to be
conclusive unless he applies for correction of his
age as recorded within 2 years from the date of his
entry into Government service. Government,
however, reserves the right to make a correction in
the recorded age of the Government servant at any
time against the interest of that Government servant
when it is satisfied that the age recorded in his
service book or in the history of services of a
gazette. Government servant is incorrect and has
been incorrectly recorded with the object that the
Government servant may derive some unfair
-8-
(2026:HHC:36759 )
advantage therefrom.
(2)
When a Government servant, within the period
allowed, makes an application for the correction of
his date of birth as recorded, an inquiry shall be
made to ascertain his correct age and reference
shall be made in all available sources of
information such as certified copies of entries in the
Municipal birth register, University or School age
certificates, JANAMPATRI (horoscope) as the case
may be. It should, however, be remembered that it
is entirely discretionary on the part of the
sanctioning authority to refuse or grant such
application on being satisfied and no alteration
should be allowed unless it has been satisfactorily
proved that the date of birth as originally given by
the applicant was a bona fide mistake and that he
has derived no unfair advantages therefrom. In
case the matriculation certificate is available, the
date of birth recorded in the certificate will be
deemed to be the correct age.
(3)
The result of every such inquiry should in the case
of Gazetted/Non Gazetted Government servants be
briefly stated in their service cards/service books
and if correction is sanctioned, the fact should be
reported to the Accountant General.”
In Bharat Coking Coal Limited and others
Versus Shyam Kishore Singh4, the Hon’ble Apex Court held
that request for change of date of birth in the service records
at the fag end of service after accepting the same to be correct
during service, cannot be entertained. Even if there is good
evidence to establish that the recorded date of birth is
erroneous, the correction cannot be claimed as a matter of
right. Relevant paragraphs of the judgment read as under: “9.
This Court has consistently held that the request for
(2020) 3 Supreme Court Cases 411
(2026:HHC:36759 )
-9-
change of the date of birth in the service records at
the fag end of service is not sustainable. The
learned Additional Solicitor General has in that
regard relied on the decision in the case of State of
Maharashtra and Anr. vs. Gorakhnath Sitaram
Kamble5, wherein a series of the earlier decisions of
this Court were taken note and was held as
hereunder:
“16. The learned counsel for the appellant has
placed reliance on the judgment of this Court in U.P.
Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad v. Raj Kumar
Agnihotri6. In this case, this Court has considered a
number of judgments of this Court and observed
that the grievance as to the date of birth in the
service record should not be permitted at the fag
end of the service career.
17. In another judgment in State of Uttaranchal v.
Pitamber Dutt Semwal7 relief was denied to the
government employee on the ground that he sought
correction in the service record after nearly 30 years
of service. While setting aside the judgment of the
High Court, this Court observed that the High Court
ought not to have interfered with the decision after
almost three decades.
*
*
*
19. These decisions lead to a different dimension of
the case that correction at the fag end would be at
the cost of a large number of employees, therefore,
any correction at the fag end must be discouraged
by the court. The relevant portion of the judgment in
Home Deptt.v. R. Kirubakaran8 reads as under:
“7. An application for correction of the date
of birth [by a public servant cannot be
entertained at the fag end of his service]. It
need not be pointed out that any such
direction for correction of the date of birth of
the public servant concerned has a chain
reaction, inasmuch as others waiting for
years, below him for their respective
promotions are affected in this process.
Some are likely to suffer irreparable injury,
inasmuch as, because of the correction of
the date of birth, the officer concerned,
(2010) 14 SCC 423
(2005) 11 SCC 465
(2005) 11 SCC 477
1994 Supp (1) SCC 155
- 10 -
(2026:HHC:36759 )
continues in office, in some cases for years,
within which time many officers who are
below him in seniority waiting for their
promotion, may lose their promotion forever.
… According to us, this is an important
aspect, which cannot be lost sight of by the
court or the tribunal while examining the
grievance of a public servant in respect of
correction of his date of birth. As such,
unless a clear case on the basis of materials
which can be held to be conclusive in
nature, is made out by the respondent, the
court or the tribunal should not issue a
direction, on the basis of materials which
make such claim only plausible. Before any
such direction is issued, the court or the
tribunal must be fully satisfied that there
has been real injustice to the person
concerned and his claim for correction of
date of birth has been made in accordance
with the procedure prescribed, and within
the time fixed by any rule or order. … the
onus is on the applicant to prove the wrong
recording of his date of birth, in his service
book.”
10.
This Court in fact has also held that even if there
is good evidence to establish that the recorded
date of birth is erroneous, the correction cannot
be claimed as a matter of right. In that regard, in
State of M.P. vs. Premlal Shrivas9, it is held as
hereunder;
“8. It needs to be emphasised that in matters
involving correction of date of birth of a
government servant, particularly on the
eve of his superannuation or at the fag
end of his career, the court or the tribunal
has to be circumspect, cautious and
careful while issuing direction for
correction of date of birth, recorded in the
service book at the time of entry into any
government service. Unless the court or
the tribunal is fully satisfied on the basis
of the irrefutable proof relating to his date
of birth and that such a claim is made in
accordance with the procedure prescribed
or as per the consistent procedure
adopted by the department concerned, as
(2011) 9 SCC 664
- 11 -
(2026:HHC:36759 )
the case may be, and a real injustice has
been caused to the person concerned, the
court or the tribunal should be loath to
issue a direction for correction of the
service book. Time and again this Court
has expressed the view that if a
government servant makes a request for
correction of the recorded date of birth
after lapse of a long time of his induction
into the service, particularly beyond the
time fixed by his employer, he cannot
claim, as a matter of right, the correction
of his date of birth, even if he has good
evidence to establish that the recorded
date of birth is clearly erroneous. No court
or the tribunal can come to the aid of
those who sleep over their rights (see
Union of India v. Harnam Singh)10
12.
Be that as it may, in our opinion, the delay of over
two decades in applying for the correction of date
of birth is ex facie fatal to the case of the
respondent, notwithstanding the fact that there
was no specific rule or order, framed or made,
prescribing the period within which such
application could be filed. It is trite that even in
such a situation such an application should be
filed which can be held to be reasonable. The
application filed by the respondent 25 years after
his induction into service, by no standards, can be
held to be reasonable, more so when not a feeble
attempt was made to explain the said delay.
There is also no substance in the plea of the
respondent that since Rule 84 of the M.P.
Financial Code does not prescribe the time-limit
within which an application is to be filed, the
appellants were duty-bound to correct the clerical
error in recording of his date of birth in the service
book.”
The above principles were reiterated by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Karnataka Rural Infrastructure
Development Limited versus T.P. Nataraja and others11,
(1993) 2 SCC 162
(2021) 11 SCALE 110
- 12 -
(2026:HHC:36759 )
wherein after considering its previous pronouncements on the
subject, the law on change of date of birth was summarized
as under: “10. Considering the aforesaid decisions of this Court in
law on change of date of birth can be summarized as
under: (i) application for change of date of birth can only be
as per the relevant provisions/ regulations
applicable;
(ii) application can be rejected on the ground of delay
and latches also more particularly when it is made
at the fag end of service and/or when the employee
is about to retire on attaining the age of
superannuation.
11.
Therefore, applying the law laid down by
this Court in the aforesaid decisions, the application of
the respondent for change of date of birth was liable to
be rejected on the ground of delay and laches also and
therefore as such respondent employee was not entitled
to the decree of declaration and therefore the impugned
judgment and order passed by the High Court is
unsustainable and not tenable at law.”
4(iv)
Insofar as petitioner’s reliance upon the decision
rendered in Chet Ram2 is concerned, suffice to note that
applicability of Himachal Pradesh Financial Rules, 2009 had
not been discarded in the said decision. Rather, Hon’ble
Court observed that the same has to be read in harmony with
Fundamental Rule 56 and further clarified the issue as
under:“12.
This Court clarifies that by not allowing this petition
and by not directing the correction of date of birth, the
Court is not giving any adjudication on the issue as to
what actually is the date of birth of the petitioner. All
- 13 -
(2026:HHC:36759 )
that the Court is observing is that when an entry with
regard to date of birth is made in the service record of
an employee, which obviously was made on the basis
of information provided by the employee himself,
then, if as per said employee, there is any infirmity in
the date of birth which he initially informed to the
employer, then, he has to approach the employer for
correction in date of birth within the time stipulated in
the Rules in vogue, and if he fails to do so, then, he
cannot subsequently approach the authority
concerned for carrying out correction in the date of
birth.”
In the instant case, it was petitioner who had
furnished the authentic proof of her date of birth in form of
her matriculation certificate. Based on said certificate, her
date of birth was entered in the service record. Petitioner was
all along aware that her date of birth had been entered in
service
record
based
on
corresponding
entry
in
her
matriculation certificate. It is appropriate to refer to The
General Manager M/s Barsua Iron Ore Mines Vs. The Vice
President United Mines
Mazdoor Union and
Ors. 12,
wherein Hon’ble Apex Court dealt with the issue of correction
of date of birth in service records, highlighting its critical
importance for both employer and employee. Referring to
precedents such as Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. v. Shib
Kumar Dushad13 and Union of India Vs. C. Rama
AIR Online 2024 SC 333
(2000) 8 SCC 696
(2026:HHC:36759 )
- 14 -
Swamy14, it was reiterated that relief for change of date of
birth should not be granted when the employee had
previously declared a different date for personal benefit. The
principle of estoppel was invoked, as the employee had
initially declared a specific date of birth and only after a
significant delay did he seek to alter it, which would have
made him underage at the time of appointment. The Court
also
relied
on
Karnataka
Rural
Infrastructure
Development Limited v T. P. Nataraja11, summarizing the
law that any application for change must be as per relevant
rules, correction in recorded date of birth in service record
cannot be claimed as a matter of right even with evidence,
and can be rejected due to delay, especially near retirement.
5.
In view of above, relief of change of date of birth in
service record prayed for by the petitioner cannot be granted
to her.
The petition fails and is accordingly dismissed.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
31st August 2026
rohit
(1997) 4 SCC 647
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review