Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:38138
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.15445 of 2026
Decided on: 9th September, 2026
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Kumari Sudesh
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. and others
.....Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting? 1 Yes.
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Karan Singh Kanwar, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Ashok Kumar,
Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. Rajat Choudhry, Assistant
Advocate General, for respondents
No.1 to 5.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
On a complaint moved by respondent No.6,
income certificate issued to the petitioner on 29.10.2025 by
the Naib Tehsildar, Nirmand, District Kullu to the effect
that income of petitioner’s family from all sources does not
exceed Rs.39000/- per annum, was quashed by respondent
No.2-the Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil) Nirmand, District
Kullu
vide
order
dated
16.07.2026.
Petitioner
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
feels
2026:HHC:38138
aggrieved against the aforesaid order and hence, instituted
this writ petition.
2.
Heard and considered the case file.
2(i).
Procedure
for
issuing
various
certificates
including the income certificate has been delineated in
Chapter 28 of the Himachal Pradesh Land Records Manual.
In terms of para 28.1 thereof, as amended vide notification
dated 20.12.2010, the Tehsildar/Naib Tehsildar is the
competent authority to issue the income certificate. The
para reads as under:“28.1- The Tehsildar/Naib Tehsildar Mohal shall be the
competent authority to issue SC/ST, income, backward
class and bonafide/domicile Himachali Certificates
within their respective jurisdiction.”
Paras 28.7 to 28.11 give the procedure for
issuing income certificate as under:“Procedure
for issuing
income
certificate
28.7. The applicant who wants to obtain the income
certificate shall apply to the competent Revenue Officer
in Form ‘C’ appended to the chapter alongwith
certificates mentioned in para 28.3 supra. The
Revenue Officer shall forward the application to the
concerned patwari for inquiry and report.
Report of 28.8. The patwari shall make a report regarding
the
income of the applicant from agriculture, horticulture
patwari
and all other sources. He shall record the details of the
land owned and possessed by the applicant's family
in his patwar circle as an owner or tenant and shall
mention cultivated and uncultivated lands separately.
Income from uncultivated lands like private forest,
ghasni etc. shall be assessed by the patwari by local
inquiry from the reliable and respectable residents of
the estate.
The patwari shall also report the number and
2026:HHC:38138
kind of bearing, and non-bearing fruit trees with age
owned and possessed by the family. The age of the
fruit trees shall be ascertained after local inquiry from
the applicant and other reliable residents of the
village. If an applicant or members of his family is in
Govt. or Semi-Govt. or autonomous bodies or private
service, the patwari shall report the facts in his report.
He shall report income of the family from all other
sources.
If the applicant owns/possesses land in other
patwar circle, the patwari shall make a mention of this
fact in his report after local inquiry.
Duty
of
the
Revenue
Officer
28.9. The report submitted by the patwari shall be
examined by the competent Revenue Officer. He will
calculate the income of the cultivated, uncultivated
lands and fruit bearing trees. The calculation of
income of the uncultivated lands shall be based on the
inquiry conducted by the patwari. The income of
cultivated lands shall be assessed by him on the basis
of farm prices multiplied by product figures of different
crops. This will give an estimate of the income of the
producer agricultural commodities.
When the income of the family of a land-owner,
whose lands are under tenants is to be calculated only
1/4th share of the produce of the land held under
tenancy shall be taken into consideration for
calculating the income of such land. When the income
of the family of the tenant is to be calculated, only
tenant's share to the extent of 3/4th shall be taken into
consideration for the purpose of calculating the income
of such tenancy land.
The competent Revenue Officer shall assess the
income from non-agricultural sources i.e. business and
income from property etc. on the basis of the reports of
the Sale tax/Income tax/Municipal authorities to be
submitted by the applicant with his application.
In case the applicant has income from house
property, out-side the town, the Revenue Officer shall
base his estimates on the certificate issued by the
concerned Pradhan Gram Panchayat, which shall be
produced by the applicant at the time of presenting the
application.
The competent Revenue Officer shall assess the
income from horticulture on the basis of the age and
kind of the fruit bearing plants according to formula
evolved and approved by the Govt. of Himachal
Pradesh as per Appendix 'C' of this chapter.
2026:HHC:38138
In case the applicant or any member of his
family is in Govt. or Semi-Govt., or autonomous bodies
or private service, he shall obtain the income certificate
from the applicant of Drawing and Disbursing Officer
of the concerned organisation. He shall asses the
income of salary on the basis of these certificates.
If the applicant owns/possesses land in more
than one patwar circle, he shall obtain the reports of
the concerned patwaris.
Issue
of 28.10. The competent Revenue Officer shall issue
certificate
income certificate in Form-D based upon all sources
after taking into consideration, the report of patwari
and other certificate mentioned above. For issuing the
certificate he shall maintain, a register in Form R-I. He
shall obtain the signature of the applicant in token of
receipt of the certificate in relevant column of the
register.
Validity of 28.11. The income certificate shall be valid for a period
Income
of one year from the date of issue.”
Certificate
Para 28.3, as finds mention in para 28.7, reads
as under:“Verification
of
application/
declaration
28.3. The applicant shall submit the application Form
duly filled-in and verified. He shall state true facts in the
application. For obtaining Income certificate he shall
attach certificates of income from Municipal authorities if
the family has any income from house property in a town.
Similarly he shall obtain income certificate from concerned
Pradhan Gram Panchayat in case the family derives
income from house property, in panchayat area. In case
the applicant runs business in the town or in a village, he
shall obtain income certificate from Sales Tax and Income
Tax authorities and shall attach the certificates with the
application. The employee of an organisation shall attach
salary certificate from the Drawing and Disbursing
Officer.”
Cancellation of certificate is provided in paras
28.19 to 28.21 as under:“Prosecution 28.19. If it is found during inquiry or otherwise, that any
of applicant information given by the applicant is wrong, the certificate
2026:HHC:38138
for
giving issuing authority shall initiate prosecution proceedings
wrong
against the delinquent under the law.
information
28.20.- Cancellation of Certificate Issued.- In case the
issuing authority, either on a complaint or on receipt of
information from any source, has reason to believe that
any certificate has been issued wrongly, he shall after
making such enquiries and hearing such persons as
considered necessary and after affording a reasonable
opportunity of being heard to the person to whom the
certificate had been issued, cancel such certificate.
28.21. Appeal.- A person aggrieved by such order may
within a period of 30 days file an appeal before the SubDivisional Officer (C) to whom the Tehsildar/Naib
Tehsildar is subordinate and the Sub-Divisional Officer (C)
after giving the parties an opportunity of being heard,
reverse or confirm the cancellation order and such
reversal or confirmation shall be final.
Provided that in case of certificates issued earlier
by authorities higher than Tehsildars, the appellate
authority shall be the authority to whom such issuing
authority to whom such issuing authority is subordinate."
2(ii).
In
terms
of
the
procedure
prescribed
for
issuance of income certificate, petitioner furnished an
affidavit in form of declaration, which is available at
Annexure P-9 of the paper book. As per the declaration,
Smt. Pingla Devi-mother-in-law of the petitioner, was a
member of her family. The petitioner had sworn in the
affidavit that her annual family income from other sources
was Rs.15000/- and total family income of the petitioner
from all sources was to Rs.45,000/- per annum. This
affidavit
was
furnished
by
the
petitioner
herself
on
16.10.2025. Income certificate was issued to the petitioner
2026:HHC:38138
by the concerned Naib Tehsildar on 29.10.2025 to the effect
that petitioner’s family income from all sources does not
exceed Rs.39000/- per annum.
2(iii).
It appears that based upon the aforesaid income
certificate, petitioner participated in the selection process
for the post of Anganwari Worker at Anganwari Centre Badi
Lanj, Tehsil Nirmand, District Kullu. One of the eligibility
conditions for participating in the selection process was
that the applicant should be having family income not
exceeding Rs.50,000/-. Petitioner was selected against the
post of Anganwari Worker at the aforesaid centre.
2(iii).
Respondent No.6-Rumila Devi filed a complaint
on 16.12.2025 before the Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Kullu with the grievance that income certificate issued by
the Naib Tehsildar, Nirmand on 29.10.2025 in petitioner’s
favour was not correct; That petitioner’s income had not
been assessed properly; The petitioner had concealed
material information for obtaining the income certificate.
The said complaint was disposed of on 13.01.2026 in
presence of counsel for the petitioner, reserving liberty to
respondent No.6 to file appeal before the Sub-Divisional
Officer (Civil), Nirmand within two weeks with direction to
the concerned Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil) to decide the
2026:HHC:38138
appeal within one month from the date of filing of the
appeal
and
to
report
compliance.
The
order
dated
13.01.2026, as made available by the learned Assistant
Advocate General, reads as under:“In the matter of :Rumila D/O Sh. Niti Ram R/O Village Gaigai, P.O. Urtoo
Tehsil Nirmand, Distt. Kullu H.P.
Versus
1. The Child Development Project Officer, Banjar, Distt.
Kullu H.P.
2. Kumari Sudesh W/O Sh. Pratap Singh R/o Village
Badilanj P.O. Urtoo Tehsil Nirmand, Distt. Kullu H.P.
Order
13-01-2026
Present
1. Sh. Dharamveer Ld. Counsel for appellant
2. Ms. Hira Choudhari Ld. Counsel for R-2
The Ld. Counsel for the appellant stated that the main
contention in this petition is the income certificate issued by
the Naib Tehsildar Nirmand on dated 29-10-2025 of the
respondent No.2 and petitioner wants an enquiry in this
matter as he has alleged that the income of the respondent
No.2 is not assessed properly and respondent No.2 has
concealed some material information to get this income
certificate. It was apprised to Id. Counsel as well as both the
parties that, there is separate guidelines & procedures for
challenging the income certificate.
Accordingly liberty is granted to the petitioner to file
proper appeal before SDO(C) Nirmand within a period of two
weeks. The SDO (C) Nirmand shall decide the appeal within a
period of one month from the date of filing appeal and send
report to the undersigned.
Sd/Additional Deputy Commissioner
Kullu, District Kullu”
2(iv).
the
Respondent No.6’s complaint was processed by
Sub-Divisional
Officer
(Civil),
Nirmand.
Present
2026:HHC:38138
petitioner participated in the proceedings conducted before
the concerned Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil). During the
course of proceedings, parties were afforded adequate
opportunity to adduce oral as also the documentary
evidence. Petitioner also appeared before the authority and
her statement was recorded. During the course of inquiry,
the concerned Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil) also called for
an income verification report from the Tehsildar, Nirmand.
The Tehsildar Nirmand inquired into the matter through
the
concerned
inconsistencies
field
in
revenue
the
agencies
declaration
and
furnished
reported
by
the
petitioner and the actual position. The report furnished by
the
concerned
Tehsildar
on
03.07.2026
regarding
verification of petitioner’s income certificate is as under:“With reference to the subject cited above, it is
submitted that the matter has been got enquired into
through the concerned field revenue agency.
During the course of enquiry, it has been noticed
that the allegation made in the complaint is that the
husband of Kumari Sudesh, namely Sh. Partap Singh,
is serving as a Vocational Teacher in the H.P. Tourism
Department and that the family is also receiving
pensionary benefits.
However, the self-declaration/affidavit submitted
by Kumari Sudesh at the time of issuance of the income
certificate reflects the occupation of Sh. Partap Singh
and Smt. Pingla Devi as Agriculture and further
declares that none of
the family members is in
Government/Semi Government service.
Copies of the self-declaration, income certificate,
relevant revenue records and the report of the field
2026:HHC:38138
revenue agency
reference.
are enclosed herewith for ready
The report is submitted for favour of information
and further necessary action.”
2(v).
The Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil) also called for
verification report from the H.P. State Electricity Board
regarding pension allegedly received by Smt. Pingla Devithe mother-in-law of the petitioner. This was in view of
allegation leveled by respondent No.6 that petitioner’s
mother-in-law was a retired
employee of
H.P. State
Electricity Board Limited and was in receipt of pension. The
report so received confirmed that Smt. Pingla Devi was
receiving monthly pension of Rs.15399/- and total pension
received by her during the relevant financial year was
Rs.1,84,788/-. The concerned Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil)
considered the ‘parivar register nakal’ placed on record
before him, wherein Smt. Pingla Devi was recorded as
member of petitioner’s family. Taking into consideration the
evidence before him, the Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil),
Nirmand held that Smt. Pingla Devi is the member of
petitioner’s family and is in receipt of pension amounting to
Rs.1,84,788/- during the concerned financial year. The
income verification report furnished by the Tehsildar
Nirmand was also kept in view, which pointed out
2026:HHC:38138
discrepancies in the declaration given by the petitioner
while obtaining the income certificate. Holding that the
petitioner could not prove her plea that her mother-in-law
was living separately in order to rebut the official record of
parivar register, the income certificate issued to the
petitioner on 29.10.2025 by the Naib Tehsildar, Nirmand
was held to have been issued on false and incorrect
information, which does not reflect the real & actual family
income of the petitioner. Accordingly, the aforesaid income
certificate was quashed.
3.
Learned
Senior
Counsel
for
the
petitioner,
placing reliance upon Ashok Thakur and another Versus
M.C. Shimla and others2, submits that it was beyond the
domain of the Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil) to have decided
the complaint preferred by respondent No.6. That in terms
of para 28.20 of H.P. Land Records Manual, it is only the
issuing authority, i.e. concerned Tehsildar/Naib Tehsildar,
who can cancel such certificate. Appeal against such
cancellation though can be preferred before the SubDivisional Officer (Civil) under para 28.21. That an action to
be taken in a particular manner as provided by the Statute
must be taken, done or performed in the manner prescribed
CMPMO No.79 of 2017, decided on 17.03.2017
2026:HHC:38138
or not at all. Relevant paras from the judgment are as
under:“43. As already observed above, an action to be taken in a
particular manner as provided by the statute, must be
taken, done or performed in the prescribed manner or
not at all. Likewise, when a particular act has to be
performed by particular authority (ies), then it is those
authority (ies) alone, who can perform the said Act and
nobody else.
44. It is more than settled that an action to be taken in a
particular manner as provided by a statute, must be
taken, done or performed in the manner prescribed or
not at all. More than eighty years back, the Hon’ble
Privy Council in Nazir Ahmad vs. King Emperor (AIR
1936, PC 253) held that where a power is given to do a
certain thing in a certain way, the things must be done
in that way or not at all and this has been approved
and further expanded by the Hon’ble Supreme court in
catena of judgments (Refer: Rao Shiv Bahadur Singh
and anr. vs. State of Vindh-P, AIR 1954, SC 322; Deep
Chand vs. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1961 SC 1527; State
of Uttar Pradesh vs. Singhara Singh and Ors, AIR 1964,
SC 358; Chandra Kishore Jha vs. Mahavir Prasad,
1999 (8) SCC 266 ; Dhananjaya Reddy vs. State of
Karnataka, 2001 (4) SCC 9; State of Jharkhand & Ors
vs. Ambay Cements and anr. (2005) 1 SCC 368 ;
Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited vs. Essar Power
Limited, 2008 (4) SCC 755 ; Zuari Cement Ltd vs.
Regional Director, ESIC, Hyderabad & Ors., AIR 2015,
SC 2764 ; and Uddar Gagan Properties Ltd. vs. Sant
Singh and Ors. 2016 (5) JT 389.).
45. The aforesaid settled legal proposition is based on a
legal maxim “Expressio unius est exclusion alterius”
meaning thereby that if a statute provides for a thing to
be done in a particular manner, then it has to be done in
that manner and in no other manner and following
some other course is not permissible.
47. It is evidently clear from the aforesaid provisions that
the same in fact does not and cannot confer the powers
of Commissioner upon any authority for the simple
reason that the Commissioner, Municipal Corporation of
his own cannot confer his own powers upon someone
else as these powers are only vested with the State
who may in exercise of powers conferred under Section
46 vest upon any person like Joint/Assistant
2026:HHC:38138
Commissioner etc., the powers and duties as conferred
and imposed upon the Commissioner under this Act.
48. However, Mr. Hamender Singh Chandel, would argue
that no objection regarding jurisdiction was ever raised
by the petitioners before the authorities below,
therefore, this question cannot be gone into by this
Court in these proceedings.
49. Even this contention is without merit as the Court
cannot be conferred jurisdiction by consent of parties
and in case there is inherent lack of jurisdiction, then
the order passed by such court is void ab initio, nullity
and therefore, is coram-non-judice and the decision
amounts to nothing. Reference in this regard can
conveniently be made to the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Harshad Chiman Lal Modi Vs. DLF
Universal Ltd. and another (2005) 7 SCC 791, which
reads as follows:
“29. Ms. Malhotra, then contended that Section 21 of the
Code, requires that the objection to the jurisdiction must
be taken by the party at the earliest possible
opportunity and in any case where the issues are
settled at or before settlement of such issues. In the
instant case, the suit was filed by the plaintiff in 1988
and written statement was filed by the defendants in
1989 wherein jurisdiction of the court was 'admitted'.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, issues were
framed by the court in February, 1997. In view of the
admission of jurisdiction of court, no issue as to
jurisdiction of the court was framed. It was only in 1998
that an application for amendment of written statement
was filed raising a plea as to absence of jurisdiction of
the court. Both the courts were wholly wrong in
allowing the amendment and in ignoring Section 21 of
the Code. Our attention in this connection was invited
by the learned counsel to Hira Lal v. Kali Nath, (1962) 2
SCR 747 and Bahrein Petroleum Co. v. Pappu, 1966 (1)
SCR 461.
30.
We are unable to uphold the contention. The jurisdiction
of a court may be classified into several categories. The
important categories are (i) Territorial or local
jurisdiction; ii) Pecuniary jurisdiction; and (iii)
Jurisdiction over the subject matter. So far as territorial
and pecuniary jurisdic tions are concerned, objection to
such jurisdiction has to be taken at the earliest possible
opportunity and in any case at or before settlement of
issues. The law is well settled on the point that if such
objection is not taken at the earliest, it cannot be
allowed to be taken at a subsequent stage. Jurisdiction
as to subject matter, however, is totally distinct and
stands on a different footing. Where a court has no
2026:HHC:38138
jurisdiction over the subject matter of the suit by reason
of any limitation imposed by statute, charter or
commission, it cannot take up the cause or matter. An
order passed by a court having no jurisdiction is nullity.
31.
In Halsbury's Laws of England, (4th edn.), Reissue, Vol.
10; para 317; it is stated;
317. Consent and waiver. -Where, by reason of any
limitation
imposed
by
statute,
charter
or
commission, a court is without jurisdiction to
entertain any particular claim or matter, neither the
acquiescence nor the express consent of the parties
can confer jurisdiction upon the court, nor can
consent give a court jurisdiction if a condition which
goes to the jurisdiction has not been performed or
fulfilled. Where the court has jurisdiction over the
particular subject matter of the claim or the
particular parties and the only objection is whether,
in the circumstances of the case, the court ought to
exercise jurisdiction, the parties may agree to give
jurisdiction in their particular case; or a defendant
by entering an appearance without protest, or by
taking steps in the proceedings, may waive his right
to object to the court taking cognizance of the
proceedings. No appearance or answer, however,
can give jurisdiction to a limited court, nor can a
private individual impose on a judge the jurisdiction
or duty to adjudicate on a matter. A statute limiting
the jurisdiction of a court may contain provisions
enabling the parties to extend the jurisdiction by
consent."
32.1 In Bahrein Petroleum Co., this Court also held that
neither consent nor waiver nor acquiescence can confer
jurisdiction upon a court, otherwise incompetent to try
the suit. It is well-settled and needs no authority that
'where a court takes upon itself to exercise a jurisdiction
it does not possess, its decision amounts to nothing.' A
decree passed by a court having no jurisdiction is non est and its validity can be set up whenever it is sought
to be enforced as a foundation for a right, even at the
stage of execution or in collateral proceedings. A decree
passed by a court without jurisdiction is a coram non
judice.
33.
In Kiran Singh v. Chaman Paswan, (1955) 1 SCR 117 :
AIR 1954 SC 340, this Court declared;
"It is a fundamental principle well established that a
decree passed by a court without jurisdiction is a
nullity and that its invalidity could be set up
whenever and it is sought to be enforced or relied
upon, even at the stage of execution and even in
collateral proceedings. A defect of jurisdiction
strikes at the very authority of the court to pass any
2026:HHC:38138
decree, and such a defect cannot be cured even by
consent of parties."
(emphasis supplied)
37.
In the instant case, Delhi Court has no jurisdiction since
the property is not situate within the jurisdiction of that
court. The trial court was, therefore, right in passing an
order returning the plaint to the plaintiff for presentation
to the proper court. Hence, even though the plaintiff is
right in submitting that the defendants had agreed to
the jurisdiction of Delhi Court and in the original written
statement, they had admitted that Delhi Court had
jurisdiction and even after the amendment in the
written statement, the paragraph relating to jurisdiction
had remained as it was, i.e. Delhi Court had
jurisdiction, it cannot take away the right of the
defendants to challenge the jurisdiction of the court nor
it can confer jurisdiction on Delhi Court, which it did not
possess. Since the suit was for specific performance of
agreement and possession of immovable property
situated outside the jurisdiction of Delhi Court, the trial
court was right in holding that it had no jurisdiction.”
50. Thus, it is evidently clear that respondent No.2 has
illegally usurped the power, authority and jurisdiction
that was not even vested in him and proceeded to pass
an order which is without jurisdiction and is coram non
judice. Unfortunately, the Appellate Authority failed to
notice this aspect of the matter and illegally affirmed
the order passed by respondent No.2.”
Another
ground
urged
by
learned
Senior
Counsel was that petitioner’s mother-in-law Smt. Pingla
Devi was not member of petitioner’s family; Petitioner’s
family had separated from her mother-in-law; Petitioner
had stated so before the Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil).
Therefore, also, income of petitioner’s mother-in-law could
not be computed towards family income of petitioner’s
family.
2026:HHC:38138
4.
Consideration:-
4(i).
In the instant case, it has to be born in mind
that though para 28.20 gives out the procedure for
cancellation of income certificate and in terms thereof, “In
case the issuing authority, either on a complaint or on
receipt of information from any source, has reason to
believe that any certificate has been issued wrongly, he
shall after such inquiry and hearing such person as
considered necessary and after affording a reasonable
opportunity of being heard to the person to whom the
certificate had been issued, cancel such certificate”, but the
aforesaid is only a procedural mandate given under Chapter
20 of the H.P. Land Records Manual. It is not that subject
is governed by any enactment/statute, which compulsorily
mandates that in no case, the income certificate issued by
the Tehsildar can be cancelled by the Sub-Divisional Officer
(Civil).
In Ashok Kumar Thakur2, fact situation was
different. Petitioners (therein) had challenged an order
issued
by
the
Senior
Architect
Planner,
Municipal
Corporation, Shimla, directing them to stop construction
work and carry out demarcation in association with their
immediate neighbours. The Impugned notice was quashed,
2026:HHC:38138
inter alia, on the grounds that the notice was not in
consonance with the mandatory requirements of Section
254(1) of the H.P. Municipal Corporation Act, 1994; Notice
and order was violative of the principles of natural justice
as no reasons were assigned; The Senior Architect Planner
was not competent to issue notice and order under Section
254(1).
It was held that as per the statutory scheme, the
competent
authority
to
issue
such
notice
is
the
Commissioner and not the Senior Architect Planner.
Municipal Corporation’s objection that no plea regarding
jurisdiction was raised at the first instance and therefore,
could not be raised subsequently in writ proceedings was
rejected, holding that inherent lack of jurisdiction can be
raised at any stage, including in writ proceedings, as it goes
to the root of the authority’s power to act.
In the instant case, it is not the case of the
petitioner that she was not represented by her Advocate
before the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Kullu, who
vide
order
dated
13.01.2026
passed
in
presence
of
petitioner’s counsel, directed the Sub-Divisional Officer
(Civil), Nirmand to decide the appeal to be preferred by
respondent No.6 against the income certificate issued to the
2026:HHC:38138
petitioner and report compliance. Petitioner accepted this
order. She participated in the proceedings conducted by the
Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil), Nirmand in the appeal (sic
complaint) preferred by respondent No.6. A detailed reply
was filed by her through a learned Advocate to the
complaint preferred by respondent No.6. No objection was
taken in the reply that the complaint in the first instance
was required to be adjudicated by the concerned Tehsildar/
Naib Tehsildar, who had issued the income certificate.
Furthermore, during the process of deciding the appeal (sic
complaint) preferred by respondent No.6, the concerned
Sub-Divisional
Officer
(Civil)
called
for
the
income
verification report from the concerned Tehsildar. The
concerned Tehsildar conducted his own inquiry into the
matter and found substance in the allegations leveled by
respondent No.6. It was found
that petitioner’s
self
declaration/affidavit submitted at the time of issuance of
income certificate was not correct.
Objection to the jurisdiction of the Court ought
to have been taken by the petitioner at the first available
instance. Petitioner did not do so and willingly participated
in the proceedings conducted by the Sub-Divisional Officer
(Civil) without raising any question as to jurisdiction of the
2026:HHC:38138
Court. This objection has been taken by the petitioner only
after remaining unsuccessful before the Sub-Divisional
Officer (Civil). Petitioner cannot be permitted to approbate
and reprobate.
In the given facts and circumstances, the ratio
of decision in Ashok Kumar Thakur2
would not be
applicable. The instant cannot be said to be a case of
illegality on account of any statutory violation. At best, it is
a case of procedural irregularity, that too, of the procedure
given in the Land Records Manual. Such irregularity has
also not caused any prejudice to the petitioner as during
the course of adjudication by the concerned Sub-Divisional
Officer (Civil), the Tehsildar Nirmand had also furnished his
own report while verifying the income certificate issued to
the petitioner. Principles of natural justice were duly
complied with giving full opportunity to the petitioner to
plead and present her case/defence. Point is answered
accordingly.
There is yet another reason to hold that the
income certificate issued to the petitioner on 29.10.2025
was de hors the facts. In her affidavit dated 16.10.2025,
petitioner has declared her income from all sources to be
around Rs.45000/-. Despite this, income certificate issued
2026:HHC:38138
to the petitioner on 29.10.2025 certifies her family income
not exceeding Rs.39000/-.
4(ii).
The second argument raised by learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner is that the pension being received
by petitioner’s mother-in-law Smt. Pingla Devi cannot be
added to petitioner’s family income. The reason assigned for
making this submission is that Smt. Pingla Devi is not a
member of petitioner’s family. That the petitioner has
separated from Smt. Pingla Devi. This argument is also
devoid of any force. Petitioner had herself furnished a
declaration
on
16.10.2025
for
obtaining
the
income
certificate, wherein, she had reflected Smt. Pingla Devi to be
member of her family. Furthermore, the copy of parivar
register of the petitioner made available at Annexure P-11
also records Smt. Pingla Devi to be the member of
petitioner’s family.
Petitioner’s assertion that she had separated
from her mother-in-law cannot be countenanced. Rule 21(2)
of the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj (General) Rules,
1997 pertains to maintenance of parivar register and
registration of birth, death and marriages. It also provides
for the procedure to be followed in respect of separation of
families. The Rule reads as under:-
2026:HHC:38138
“21. Pariwar Register and registration of birts, deaths and
marriages –
(2)
The entries in the Online Pariwar Register,
required to be prepared under sub-rule (1) shall be
revised and all entries pertaining to births, deaths,
marriages and transfer from other Panchayat/area
shall be made in the register. No other addition or
alternation
may
be
made
without
any
authenticated evidence. In the event of division of
the family, separation of family may only be
entered in the Online Pariwar Register on the
decision of the Gram Sabha by passing a
resolution by majority in its general or social
meeting on an application made by the head of
family concerned. However, the Gram Sabha shall
take into consideration the definition of the family
as defined under clause (13-A) of section 2 of the
Act while deciding the matter regarding divisin of
family. It shall be the duty of the Panchayat
Inspector to verify these entries after satisfying
himself about the reasons recorded by the
Panchayat Secretary. He shall also put his initials
on the goshwara prepared by Panchayat Secretary
on Form 19-A:
Provided that no entry with regard to
separation of family shall be made in the Online
Pariwar Register unless the family so separated is
having access to a toilet.”
A reading of above-extracted Rule makes it
evident that in the event of division of family, the entry with
regard to separation of the family is to be made in the
parivar
register
in
accordance
with
the
procedure
prescribed therein. It is not the case of the petitioner that
the
procedure
prescribed
in
the
Himachal
Pradesh
Panchayati Raj (General) Rules, 1997 with regard to
division of family was followed in the instant case. In fact,
as noticed above, it is the projected case of the petitioner in
2026:HHC:38138
her affidavit furnished on 16.10.2025 that her mother-inlaw is the member of her family. That being the position,
the Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil), Nirmand did not commit
any error in computing the pension being received by Smt.
Pingla Devi-mother-in-law of the petitioner, towards her
family income.
In P.U. Sidhique & Ors. Versus Zakariya 3,
Apex Court cautioned that laws are to be interpreted with
empathy & pragmatism and as a force of justice, not
absurdity. There should not be mechanical application of
law.
Relevant
para
from
the
decision
is
extracted
hereinafter:“36. This Court is of the view that human beings, and not
artificial intelligence or computers, are entrusted with
the duties of administration of justice as laws are to be
interpreted with empathy and pragmatism and as a
force of justice, not absurdity. The danger of mechanical
application of law, blind to practical reality, was
famously encapsulated by Charles Dickens in the
classic ‘Oliver Twist’, where Mr. Bumble lamented, “If
the law supposes that … the law is a ass,” critiquing
legal formalism that disregards common sense and
fairness. Consequently, Courts must balance textual
fidelity with interpretive wisdom, ensuring that laws are
not applied mechanically without considering context or
equity; but serve as true vehicles for the administration
of justice.”
5.
For all the aforesaid reasons, I do not find any
error in the impugned order passed by the Sub-Divisional
Civil Appeal Nos.13901-13902 of 2025, decided on 21.11.2025
2026:HHC:38138
Officer (Civil), Nirmand, quashing the income certificate
issued in favour of the petitioner on 29.10.2025. This writ
petition, therefore, fails and is accordingly dismissed
alongwith pending miscellaneous application(s), if any.
September 09, 2026
Mukesh
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review