Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
Cr.MP No: 5601 of 2025 in
Criminal Appeal No. 476 of 2024
Reserved on: 23.03.2026
Decided on: 07.04.2026
____________________________________________________________
Kuldeep Singh @ Rana
...Applicant-appellant.
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
…Respondent.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge
1 Whether approved for reporting?
Yes.
For the petitioner:
Mr. Sahil Malhotra, Advocate.
For the respondent:
Mr. J. S. Guleria, Deputy Advocate
General.
Ranjan Sharma, Judge
Applicant,
Kuldeep
Singh
@
Rana,
being
appellant, who is undergoing sentence, has come up
before this Court by way of instant application under
Section
430(1)
of
Sahita
2023,
seeking
the
Bhartiya
Nagarik
suspension
of
Suraksha
sentence,
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
in
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
-2-
terms of the judgement of conviction and sentence
dated 28.06.2024 and 10.07.2024 respectively, passed
by
Learned
Special
Judge,
Mandi,
sentencing
the
applicant to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a
period of 10 years and to pay fine of Rs. 1,00,000/[Rs One Lakh Only] and in default of payment of
fine to undergo simple imprisonment for a period
of one year for the commission of offences punishable
under Section 20(b)(ii)(c) and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs
and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985.
GROUNDS FOR SUSPENSION OF SENTENCE IN
INSTANT APPLICATION:
2.
of
Instant application, praying for suspension
sentence,
has
been
filed
with
the
plea
that
the applicant-convict has undergone two years and
seven months of substantive sentence. It is averred
that prolonged detention is weakening the economic
condition of the applicant. It is averred that the
prolonged
incarceration
has
made
the
family
to
starve and for enabling him to earn a livelihood
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
-3-
for himself and family the prayer for suspension
of sentence has been made. It is averred that there
are inconsistencies and procedural irregularities in
the trial and the judgement passed by the Learned
Special
Judge.
It
is
averred
that
PW-9
Joginder
Singh ASI, had acted as a complainant and also
an Investigating Officer. It is averred that the noncompliance of Section 42 and Section 50 of the
NDPS
Act
has
vitiated
the
trial
and
the alleged
recovery is violative of the mandate of law in case
of State of Punjab versus Baldev Singh (1999) 6
SCC 172. It is averred that there is a discrepancy
between the contraband seized 1.350 Kg. vis-à-vis
1.310 Kgs. Plea for suspension of sentence on the
principle of parity as the sentence imposed on the
co-accused was suspended. It is further averred that
the conscious possession has not been proved.
2(i).
It is averred that the applicant had earlier
also filed an application for suspension of sentence
Cr.MP
No.
of
2024,
which
was
dismissed
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
-4-
as withdrawn on 02.05.2025. Feeling aggrieved, the
applicant
filed
SLP
before
the
Honble
Supreme
Court, and the aforesaid SLP (Crl) No. 9495 of 2025,
was withdrawn on 07.07.2025. It is averred that since
the appeal is likely to take considerable time for
its disposal, therefore, the sentence imposed on the
applicant-appellant
may
be
suspended
during
the
application
and
pendency of the instant application.
REPLY BY STATE AUTHORITIES :
3.
Upon
issuance
of
the
State
listing
notice
of
instant
by
this
Court
on
Authorities
have
filed
the
18.12.2025,
reply
dated
02.03.2026, on affidavit of Superintendent of Police,
Mandi (HP), opposing the prayer for suspension of
sentence.
4.
Heard, Mr. Sahil Malhotra, Learned Counsel
for the petitioner and Mr. J.S. Guleria, Deputy Advocate
General for the Respondent-State.
ANALYSIS:
5.
Taking into account the averments made
-5-
in
the
application
for
suspension
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
and
the
reply
filed thereto and the evidence led during the trial,
this
Court
is
of
the
considered
view
that
the
prayer of the applicant for suspension of sentence,
is not made
out, at this stage, for the following
reasons:
5(i).
Prosecution story is that recovery relates
to Commercial Quantity of 1.350 kgs of Cannabis
-Charas, which was recovered from the bag kept
on
his
lap
by
the
applicant-appellant
Kuldeep
Singh who was accompanying the driver, namely,
Jaswant Singh @ Nitu. The contraband so seizedrecovered stands duly proved by prosecution beyond
all reasonable doubts. The applicant has failed to
point out glaring discrepancy and illegality which
goes to the root of the matter.
5(ii).
Mere prolongation of incarceration does
not by itself constitute a ground for suspension of
sentence, imposed by Learned Trial Court after due
appreciation of evidence and full trial. Suspension
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
-6-
of
sentence
cannot
be
asserted
nor
granted
on
applicant
that
PW-9
ASI
sympathetic grounds.
5(iii).
Plea
of
the
Joginder Singh, being the complainant was also
the Investigating Officer, cannot come to the aid
of the applicant for the reason,
no
firstly, there is
bar under the NDPS Act that an
informant-
complainant cannot act as Investigating Officer ; and
secondly, merely because the complainant-informant
had investigated the case cannot be the ground
to
doubt or discard the entire prosecution case unless
accused has established bias; and thirdly, except
in the case of established bias, after weighing the
evidence on record, there is no bar that informant
cannot act as Investigator, in terms of the mandate
of law declared by the Constitutional Bench of the
Honble
Supreme
Court
in
Mukesh
Singh
versus
State (NCT of Delhi) (2020) 10 SCC 120 {Paras
10.5, ; 12.1 and 13.1(II)}; and lastly, even on the
basis of evidence on record, the applicant has not
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
-7-
been able to establish any bias and therefore, the
submission of the applicant has no force.
5(iv).
Plea of the applicant regarding the non-
compliance of Section 42 and 50, is devoid of
any merit for the reason, firstly, the prosecution
story is that on 03.02.2018, police party consisting
of 5 persons, headed by PW-9 Joginder Singh, were
on routine patrolling and nakabandi duty near gate
of Police Station, Thalout. At about 8.40 am, a car
bearing registration number PB-01A-4464, came from
Kullu side, in which two persons were found sitting
and the person on driver seat disclosed his name
as Jaswant Singh @ Nitu and the person sitting on
front seat disclosed his name as Kuldeep Singh @
Rana,
who
was
carrying
an
orange
color
carry
bag (MO-2) on his lap. After associating independent
witnesses, the search of bag was conducted and on
checking, the bag was found containing black colored
stick substance, wrapped with transparent polyethene
wrappers. After competing codal formalities, recovered
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
-8-
contraband
was sealed
and
the
Rukka
was sent
to SHO, Police Station at Aut for registration of
FIR. Pursuant to the registration of FIR, the case
file alongwith documents were sent to PW 9 Joginder
Singh
for
conducting
further
investigation
in
the
matter; and secondly, perusal of prosecution story
and
the
evidence
on
record
establishes
that
the
provision of Section 50 of the NDPS Act is attracted
in case of personal search of an accused before
a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate ; and thirdly,
the
prosecution has not conducted any personal search
of
the
applicant-accused
and
in
the
absence
of
any personal search of the applicant-accused, the
provision of Section 50 is not applicable, in view
of the mandate of the Constitutional Bench of the
Honble Supreme Court in case of State of Punjab
versus Baldev Singh (1999) 6 SCC 172 and incase
a search or an arrest of a person is made during
the normal course of investigation leading to the
recovery of contraband then Section 50 of the Act
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
-9-
is not attracted as in instant case.
Plea of the applicant about discrepancy of
5(v).
weight of contraband, that at the time of recovery,
the weight of contraband (Charas) was 1.350 Kgs
whereas as per FSL Report Ex P-12, the weight came
out to be 1.310 Kgs. The aforesaid plea cannot come
to the aid of the applicant-accused, for the reason,
that weight of contraband came out to be 1.310
Kgs, after deducting the weight of carry bag, thread,
parcel, polythene wrappers and the certification of
seized contraband under Section 52-A (2) by the
Magistrate stands proved vide Ex P-32 coupled with
the fact that the loss in weight is nominal and
even no suggestion was put by applicant-accused
during trial, therefore, the plea at this stage is not
tenable.
Plea for suspension of sentence on parity
5(vi).
on the ground that that co-accused Jaswant Singh,
driver
of
the
vehicle
was
granted
the
benefit
of
suspension of sentence in Cr. MP No. 3974 of 2024
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
- 10 -
in Criminal Appeal No. 494 of 2025, Jaswant Singh
@ Nitu vs State of Himachal Pradesh on 25.04.2025
cannot be a ground for parity, for the reason, the
claim for suspension of sentence is to be tested
keeping in view the role of the applicant-appellant
Kuldeep Singh who was the prime accused from
whom the alleged bag kept in his lap was recovered
vis-à-vis co-accused, Jaswant Singh, who was the
driver of the vehicle in question. Once the role of
both the accused was different therefore, the plea
for automatic parity is not tenable.
5(vii).
The
plea
for
suspension
of
sentence
of
the applicant cannot sustain, when, the applicantappellant,
at
this
stage,
has
not
been
able
to
establish on the basis of the adduced evidence that
there are fair chances of his acquittal in the instant
appeal.
5(viii).
Even, Para 66 of the judgement passed
by the Learned Trial Court negates the prayer for
suspension, in view of categorical findings, recorded
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
- 11 -
after due trial, that the stand of the prosecution
was consistent throughout and no major contradiction
exists in their testimonies. It was further held that
minor
contradictions,
if
any,
were
not
sufficient
to make the prosecution case suspectable as has
been alleged by the applicant. The evidence on record
consistently indicate that the recovery of contraband
from the bag kept in the lap by applicant-appellant
Kuldeep Singh was sufficient to hold him guilty of
the offence. In these circumstances, the recovery of
contraband from the alleged bag from the conscious
and exclusive possession of the applicant-appellant
was
validly
accepted,
making
him
liable
for
the
offence. Learned Trial Court had recorded in Para
74 of the Judgement that provision of Section 42
and 50 were not at all attracted. Findings recorded
in
any
Para
enmity
of
the
between
Impugned
the
Judgement denying
accused
and
the
police
officials. The applicant-appellant at this stage has
not been able to establish on the basis of adduced
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
- 12 -
evidence that there are fair chances of his acquittal
in the instant appeal. Moreover, applicant-appellant
has not pointed out any palpable or gross error
in
the
impugned
judgement
passed
by
the
Trial
Court. The conviction and sentence imposed on the
applicant after due trial and said findings cannot
be brushed aside at this stage. The scope of Section
Cr.P.C
[now
Section
Bhartiya
Nagarik
Suraksha Sahita, 2023] has been outlined by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Aasif @ Pasha versus
State of Uttar Pradesh and others, 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 1644, in the following terms:
18.
In
“Omprakash
Sahni
vs.
Jai
Shankar
Chaudhary and Anr. (2023) 6 SCC 123,
this Court while considering the scope of
389 CrPC in cases of life imprisonment
held as under:30. In Kishori Lal v. Rupa (2004) 7 SCC
this
Court
has
indicated
the
factors that require to be considered by
the
courts
while
granting
benefit
under Section 389CrPC in cases involving
serious offences like murder, etc. Thus,
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
- 13 -
it is useful to refer to the observations
made
therein,
which
are
as
follows:
(SCC pp. 639-40, paras 4-6)
“4.
Section 389 of the Code deals with
suspension
of
execution
of
sentence
pending the appeal and release of the
appellant on bail. There is a distinction
between
bail
and
suspension
of
sentence. One of the essential ingredients
of Section 389 is the requirement for
the appellate court to record reasons
in writing for ordering suspension of
execution
of
the
sentence
or
order
appealed against. If he is in confinement,
the said court can direct that he be
released on bail or on his own bond.
The
requirement of
recording
reasons
in writing clearly indicates that there
has to be careful consideration of the
relevant aspects and the order directing
suspension
of sentence
and
grant
of
bail should not be passed as a matter
of routine.
5. The appellate court is duty-bound
to
objectively
assess
the
matter
and
to record reasons for the conclusion that
the
case
warrants
suspension
of
execution of sentence and grant of bail.
In
the
instant
case,
the
only
factor
which seems to have weighed with the
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
- 14 High
Court
for
directing
suspension
of sentence and grant of bail is the
absence
of
allegation
of
misuse
of
liberty during the earlier period when
the accused respondents were on bail.
6.
The
mere
fact
that
during
the
trial, they were granted bail and there
was no allegation of misuse of liberty,
is really not of much significance. The
effect of bail granted during trial loses
significance when on completion of trial,
the accused persons have been found
guilty.
The
mere
fact
that
during
the period when the accused persons
were on bail during trial there was
no misuse of liberties, does not per se
warrant
suspension
of
execution
of
sentence and grant of bail. What really
was necessary to be considered by the
High Court is whether reasons existed to
suspend the execution of sentence and
thereafter grant bail. The High Court
does not seem to have kept the correct
principle in view.”
31. In Vijay Kumar v. Narendra (2002) 9
SCC 364 and Ramji Prasad v. Rattan
Kumar Jaiswal (2002) 9 SCC 366, it
was held
by this Court that in cases
involving conviction under Section 302
IPC, it is only in exceptional cases
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
- 15 that
the
sentence
benefit
of
can
granted.
be
suspension
In
of
Vijay
Kumar v. Narendra, it was held that
in considering the prayer for bail in
a case involving a serious offence like
murder punishable under Section 302
IPC,
the
relevant
court
should
factors
like
consider
the
nature
the
of
accusation made against the accused,
the
manner
in
which
the
crime
is
been
committed,
the
alleged
to
have
gravity
of
the
offence,
and
the
desirability of releasing the accused
on bail after they have been convicted
for
committing
the
serious
view
is
offence
of murder.
32.
The
aforesaid
reiterated
by
this Court in Vasant Tukaram Pawar v.
State of Maharashtra, (2005) 5 SCC
281 and Gomti v. Thakurdas (2007)
11 SCC 160.
33. Bearing in mind the aforesaid principles
of law, the endeavor on the part of
the court, therefore, should be to see
as to whether the case presented by
the prosecution and accepted by the
trial court can be said to be a case
in which, ultimately the convict stands
for fair chances of acquittal. If the
answer to the abovesaid question is to
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
- 16 -
be in the affirmative, as a necessary
corollary, we shall have to say that, if
ultimately the convict appears to be
entitled
to
have
an
acquittal
at
the hands of this Court, he should
not
be
kept
behind
the
bars
for
a
pretty long time till the conclusion of
the appeal, which usually takes very
long for decision and disposal. However,
while
undertaking
ascertain
whether
the
exercise
to
the
convict
has
fair chances of acquittal, what is
to
be looked into is something palpable.
To put it in other words, something
which is very apparent or gross on
the face of the record, on the basis
of which, the court can arrive at a
prima facie satisfaction that the conviction
may not be sustainable. The appellate
court
should
not
reappreciate
the
evidence at the stage of Section 389
CrPC
and
try
to
pick
up
a
few
lacunae or loopholes here or there
in
the
case
of
the
prosecution.
Such would not be a correct approach.”
6.
Besides, the above discussion, this Court,
at this stage is satisfied that on the basis of the
adduced evidence, the prosecution has proved its
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
- 17 -
case against applicant-accused beyond all reasonable
doubts.
In
the
instant
application,
the
applicant-
appellant has not been able to point out any palpable
or grave error in the impugned judgement. Nothing
has
been
pointed
out
that
the
applicant
has
a
fair chance of acquittal. Even, Learned state Counsel
states that the case of the applicant does not fall
under Section 479 BNSS (earlier Section 436-A Cr PC).
Plea of the applicant for reappreciating the evidence
bare-thread, at the stage of considering the prayer
for suspension of sentence under Section 389 CrPC
[now Section 430 BNSS, by taking up few lacuna
or loopholes in prosecution case, cannot be acceded
to.
DIRECTIONS:
7.
In view of the above discussion and for
the reasons recorded hereinabove, instant application
for suspension of sentence, is devoid of any merit,
and consequently, the same is dismissed.
8.
Before
parting,
this
Court
observes
that
- 18 -
[ 2026:HHC:10515 ]
instant appeal relates to the year 2024 and appeals
against conviction have reached the hearing board
of docket of this Court. In the totality of above
circumstances, the applicant-accused, if so desires,
may move this Court afresh, in case, appeal is not
listed for hearing within 6-8 months hereinafter.
9.
The observations made in this order shall
not be construed in any manner as an indictive
of findings, for or against any of the parties to
accompanying appeal.
In the aforesaid terms, instant application
stands disposed of.
(Vivek Singh Thakur)
Judge
April 07, 2026
[tm]
(Ranjan Sharma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review