Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 1st April, 2026
Pronounced on: 30th July, 2026
%
+
W.P(C) 7192/2006
1. KULDEEP SINGH & ORS.
S/o Late Sardar Singh
104-B/B-U & V
Shalimar Bagh, Delhi, presently working as
Executive Engineer with Tala Hydro Electric
Project Authority, Thimpu, Bhutan on deputation
From of Ministry of Power, Government of India,
New Delhi.
Through:
.....Petitioners
Ms. Aditi Anup, Advocate
versus
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH
The Secretary,
Ministry of External Affairs,
Government of India,
New Delhi, North Block
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Bhagwan Swamp Shukla, CGSC
with Mr. Dashmesh Tripathi,
Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Writ Petition has been preferred under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India seeking issuance of a writ of mandamus and/or any
other appropriate order or directions for grant of Bhutan Compensatory
Allowance to the Petitioners, at par with the Foreign Allowance payable to
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
the employees and staff of the Ministry of External Affairs posted in
Bhutan, with effect from 01.01.1998, along with consequential financial
benefits.
2.
The facts in brief are that the Government of India and the Royal
Government of Bhutan entered into an Agreement dated 05.03.1996 for
implementation of the Tala Hydro Electric Project in Bhutan. Article 14(3)
of the said Agreement provided that the Government of India shall permit
the Tala Hydro Electric Project Authority to select and appoint deputationist
officers, staff and workers directly from the concerned departments of the
Government of India, State Governments, State Electricity Boards and
Public Sector Undertakings in India, after inviting Applications through the
respective departments. It was further agreed that the funds required for
implementation of the said Project, would be provided by the Government
of India.
3.
Pursuant to the aforesaid Agreement, the Petitioners who were
permanent employees of various departments of the Central Government,
State Governments and Public Sector Undertakings, including the Ministry
of Power, Ministry of Water Resources, Ministry of Finance, Government of
India, Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board, Nathpa Jhakri Power
Corporation Limited, Karnataka Power Corporation Limited, Central Water
Commission, West Bengal State Electricity Board, Rajasthan State
Electricity Board and National Hydroelectric Power Corporation, were
deputed to the Tala Hydro Electric Project Authority, Thimphu, Bhutan,
between the years 1997 and 2005.
4.
The Appointment Letters issued to the Petitioners by the Tala Hydro
Electric Project Authority, specifically provided that the services of the
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
Petitioners during their period of deputation in Bhutan, would be governed
by the terms and conditions applicable to officers of the Central/State
Governments of India on deputation with the Royal Government of Bhutan,
as contained in the Ministry of External Affairs Letter No. EIV/551/77/77
dated 08.11.1977, as amended from time to time.
5.
The Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India, vide the
aforesaid letter dated 08.11.1977, prescribed the terms and conditions of
service, including payment of compensatory allowance, for officers and staff
of the Central and State Governments deputed to Bhutan. In terms thereof,
the Petitioners were granted Bhutan Compensatory Allowance, during their
deputation.
6.
It is the case of the Petitioners that the rate of Bhutan Compensatory
Allowance and the Foreign Allowance payable to the officers and staff of
the Embassy of India in Bhutan remained at par and were revised from time
to time up to December, 1997. However, vide Notification dated 19.02.1998,
the Ministry of External Affairs revised the Foreign Allowance payable to
the officers and staff of the Embassy of India, Thimphu, Bhutan, whereas no
corresponding revision was made in respect of the Bhutan Compensatory
Allowance payable to the Petitioners.
7.
The Petitioners contended that thereafter, the Foreign Allowance
payable to India-based Officers and members of staff of the Embassy of
India in Bhutan, was revised periodically by the Ministry of External Affairs
through various Orders dated 16.09.1998, 09.07.1999, 27.07.2000,
13.08.2001,
21.02.2002,
12.06.2002,
20.05.2003,
28.07.2004
and
17.03.2005. However, such revisions were not extended to the Petitioners,
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
who continued to receive Bhutan Compensatory Allowance, at the existing
rates.
8.
It was contended that both, the employees of the Embassy of India in
Bhutan and the Petitioners, being deputationist from various Departments of
the
Central
Government,
State
Governments
and
Public
Sector
Undertakings, were governed by the terms and conditions prescribed by the
Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India, in relation to their
service in Bhutan. According to the Petitioners, denial of corresponding
revision in Bhutan Compensatory Allowance, (BCA) despite revision of
Foreign Allowance payable to Embassy staff, was contrary to the terms of
their deputation and discriminatory in nature.
9.
The Petitioners made representations before the concerned authorities
seeking revision of BCA at par with Foreign Allowance payable to the
Embassy staff. Subsequently, vide Order no. EIV/235/5/95 dated
29.12.2000, the Ministry of External Affairs granted an ad hoc increase of
25% in the existing Bhutan Compensatory Allowance payable to officers
of the Central and State Governments of India, during their service on
deputation to Bhutan or with the Royal Government of Bhutan, with effect
from 01.01.2001. The said increase was granted pending a final decision
regarding payment of Foreign Allowance/Bhutan Compensatory Allowance
to such deputationist at par, with the employees and staff of the Embassy of
India in Bhutan.
10.
Thereafter, vide Order dated 27.07.2005, a further ad hoc increase of
11% was granted in the existing Bhutan Compensatory Allowance payable
to officers on deputation, with effect from 01.04.2005.
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
11.
Aggrieved by the continued denial of revision of Bhutan
Compensatory Allowance at par with the Foreign Allowance payable to the
Embassy staff in Bhutan, the deputationist submitted Representations dated
19.08.2005 and 26.02.2006 before the concerned authorities. The Petitioners
asserted that non-revision of Bhutan Compensatory Allowance in line with
the revisions granted to the Embassy staffs, was violative of the terms of
their appointment and amounted to discrimination under Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
12.
The Petitioners placed reliance upon the decision of this Court in
W.P.(C) No.17184/2004 titled Captain Gurdev Singh & Ors. v. Union of
India, wherein parity in payment of compensatory allowance with the
personnel of the Ministry of External Affairs, was granted. On the basis of
the said decision, the Petitioners again requested the Respondent authorities
to extend similar benefits to them.
13.
The Ministry of External Affairs, vide Office Memorandum dated
24.03.2006, directed the Petitioners to approach the Tala Hydro Electric
Project Authority, being the employer authority. Accordingly, the Petitioners
vide Letter dated 25.03.2006 submitted their representation before the
THPA. However, THPA informed the Petitioners vide communication dated
07.04.2006 that it was only implementing the directions issued by the
Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India, and that the issue
regarding revision of Bhutan Compensatory Allowance, was required to be
decided by the Respondent Ministry.
14.
The Petitioners have accordingly, sought issuance of Mandamus or an
appropriate order or direction directing the Respondents to revise and grant
Bhutan Compensatory Allowance to the Petitioners at par with the Foreign
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
Allowance payable to the employees and staff of the Embassy of India in
Bhutan with effect from 01.01.1998, along with all consequential benefits
including arrears and retrospective financial benefits.
15.
The Respondent in his Counter-Affidavit, has stated that the
Petitioners are deputationist from various Central and State Government
departments of India and were posted in Bhutan, in accordance with the
terms and conditions of their appointments, as contained in the Letter No.
EIV/551/77/77 dated 08.11.1977, as amended from time to time, including
the subsequent amendment vide Letter No. EIV/551/9/2001 dated
21.11.2001, of Ministry of External Affairs.
16.
The Respondent asserted that the Petitioners, having accepted the
terms and conditions governing their deputation before proceeding to
Bhutan, are governed by the rules and instructions issued by the Ministry of
External Affairs from time to time with respect to Bhutan Compensatory
Allowance. According to the Respondents, the terms and conditions
accepted by the Petitioners at the time of their deputation, do not provide for
payment of Bhutan Compensatory Allowance at par with the Foreign
Allowance payable to the employees of the Embassy of India in Bhutan.
17.
The Respondent has further contended that the Bhutan Compensatory
Allowance payable to deputationist has been revised from time to time, in
accordance with the Orders issued by the Ministry of External Affairs. It is
stated that subsequent to the year 1997, the said allowance was revised on
two occasions, firstly vide order dated 29.12.2000 bearing No.
EIV/235/5/95, whereby an increase of 25% was granted, and thereafter vide
order dated 27.07.2005, whereby a further increase of 11% was granted.
Accordingly, the Petitioners have been paid Bhutan Compensatory
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
Allowance (BCA) in accordance with the applicable terms and conditions
governing their deputation.
18.
The Respondent has contended that the employees and staff posted at
the Embassy of India in Bhutan constitute a distinct category and are
governed by the Ministry of External Affairs, Indian Foreign Service (Pay,
Leave and Compensatory Allowances) Rules (IFS (PLCA) Rules). The
terms and conditions applicable to such personnel, are entirely different
from those governing deputationists posted in Bhutan. Furthermore, the
nature of duties, functions and responsibilities performed by the Embassy
staffs are distinct from those performed by the Petitioners, who were
deputed for specific project-related assignments connected with the Tala
Hydro Electric Project.
19.
It is further stated that merely because both the categories of
employees are posted in Bhutan, the petitioners cannot claim parity with the
Foreign Allowance payable to the Embassy staffs. According to the
Respondents, the Petitioners are neither employees of the Embassy of India
nor governed by the Foreign Service Rules applicable to Embassy personnel
and cannot claim entitlement to Foreign Allowance. The Petitioners, having
accepted the terms and conditions of deputation, are entitled only to Bhutan
Compensatory Allowance, as applicable to them. They cannot subsequently
seek alteration or modification thereof by claiming parity with a different
category of employees governed by a separate set of rules.
20.
In response to the reliance placed by the Petitioners on the judgment
Captain Gurdev Singh & Ors. (Supra), the Respondents have contended that
the said proceedings are pending adjudication and therefore, the Petitioners
cannot claim any benefit on the basis thereof.
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
21.
The Respondent has relied upon the judgment of the Guwahati High
Court in Shri Bishnu Pada Chakraborty & Ors. v. Union of India, W.P.(C)
No.3748/2001, wherein the claim for payment of Bhutan Compensatory
Allowance at par with Foreign Allowance, was considered. It was held
therein that an employee who had accepted the terms and conditions of
deputation and was receiving BCA in accordance with such terms, could not
subsequently claim parity with Foreign Allowance payable to personnel
rendering service under Foreign Service conditions.
22.
Accordingly, the respondent has contended that no case of
discrimination or violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India is made
out, as the Petitioners and the employees of the Embassy of India in Bhutan
are governed by different Rules, perform different functions and are placed
in distinct service conditions. The Respondent has henceforth, opposed the
relief sought by the Petitioners and prayed for dismissal of the present
Writ petition.
23.
The Petitioners, in their Rejoinder Affidavit, have controverted the
averments made by the Respondent in the Counter-Affidavit and submitted
that the stand taken by the Respondent, is misconceived.
24.
The Petitioners in their rejoinder affidavit further controverted the
stand of the Respondent that the terms and conditions governing Embassy
personnel and deputationists, are distinct. The Petitioners have submitted
that both categories of personnel were governed by the same terms and
conditions up to the year 1997 and, therefore, denial of subsequent revisions
in Bhutan Compensatory Allowance (BCA) was discriminatory and
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
25.
Written Submissions were filed on behalf of the Petitioners; wherein
similar contentions were reiterated.
26.
The Petitioners in their written submissions, submitted that the claim
raised in the present petition is not one seeking parity between two distinct
classes of employees, but is founded upon the principle of equal application
of the same governing framework.
27.
Furthermore, it was asserted that Respondent has failed to
demonstrate any reasonable basis or intelligible differentia for treating the
Petitioners differently from the Embassy personnel, despite both categories
being governed by the Ministry of External Affairs and performing services
in Bhutan. Mere difference in nomenclature of the allowance, cannot justify
unequal treatment when the entitlement flows from the same governing
instructions.
28.
It is contended that once the Petitioners and the employees of the
Embassy of India in Bhutan are governed by the same policy framework
issued by the Ministry of External Affairs; selective extension of subsequent
revisions in allowance to only one category, while denying the same to the
other, is arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
29.
Reliance has been placed upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Union of India v. Munshi Ram, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1493,
wherein it has been held that similarly situated employees under the same
employer, cannot be subjected to differential treatment in the matter of
service benefits and that financial implications cannot be a ground to deny
legitimate parity.
30.
It is further submitted that the Petitioners had a legitimate expectation
that the revisions in allowance would continue to be extended in the same
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
manner as applicable to similarly placed personnel, particularly when such
parity existed till December, 1997. Reliance has been placed upon the
judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Rajasthan in Dr. Mukesh Sharma v.
State of Rajasthan, Civil Writ Petition No.10718/2015, to contend that
denial of benefits to similarly situated employees, without any rational basis,
amounts to discriminatory treatment.
31.
Petitioners further contended that the grant of ad hoc increases of
25% and 11% respectively, did not resolve the underlying disparity, as such
increases were neither equivalent to the revisions granted in Foreign
Allowance nor based upon any final determination by the competent
authority. It is, therefore, claimed that the Respondent failed to discharge its
obligation of taking a final decision despite repeated representations,
resulting in continued denial of the benefit claimed by the Petitioners.
32.
No Written Submissions were filed on behalf of the Respondents.
Submissions heard and record perused.
33.
The factual background is that the Government of India and the
Royal Government of Bhutan entered into an Agreement dated 05.03.1996
for the implementation of the Tala Hydro Electric Project in Bhutan. In this
Letter of Agreement dated 05.03.1996, it was clearly mentioned that the
Authority would frame its own Rules of Business.
34.
The Agreement provided for the deputation of employees of the
Central and State Governments, Electricity Boards, and Public Sector
Undertakings, etc. for the implementation of the project. The Plaintiff vide
Letter dated 09.10.2002, was posted on deputation, to Bhutan. This letter
provided that the services of Er. Kuldeep Singh would be governed by the
“Terms and Conditions for Officers of Central/State Government of India on
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
deputation with the Royal Government of Bhutan”, contained in the Ministry
of External Affairs Letter No. EIV/551/77/77 dated 08.11.1977, as amended
from time to time.
35.
The Petitioners were, therefore, in error in equating itself with the
foreign officers, when their terms of appointment and allowance was
governed by different circulars as is evident from the circulars to which the
reference has been made by the Petitioner himself. The Embassy personnel
and officials were entitled to Foreign Allowance, whereas the Petitioners
and others similarly situated deputationists were entitled to Bhutan
Compensatory Allowance, in terms of the Agreement dated 05.03.1996;
there was no parity between these two categories of the deputationists and
therefore, the Petitioner fell in error in claiming parity with the foreign
officers.
36.
The Circular dated 08.11.1977 specifically prescribed the salary and
various allowances payable to such officers, including children’s allowance,
special outfit allowance, travelling allowance, transfer grant, and other
allowances, including the Bhutan Compensatory Allowance (BCA), which
was defined therein. Thereafter, in the coming years, no enhancement was
made to the Bhutan Compensatory Allowance, while on the other hand, for
the foreign service officers, there were different Circulars issued on
16.09.1998, 09.07.1999, 27.07.2000 13.08.2001, 21.02.2002, 12.06.2002,
20.05.2003, 28.07.2004 and 17.03.2005, the Foreign Allowance of the Indiabased officers and members of staff of the Embassy of India (E/I, Thimpu &
Liaison Officers of EOI, Bhutan), were revised.
37.
Significantly, all these Circulars increased and enhanced the Foreign
Allowance payable to the concerned officers. However, such enhancement
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
was not made applicable to officers posted on deputation to various projects
in Bhutan. As has been submitted by the Respondent, these Circulars
pertained to Foreign Allowances. There is nothing on record to show that the
Petitioner and similarly placed officers who were posted on deputation in
Bhutan were entitled to the Foreign Allowance, which was applicable to a
category of foreign officers.
38.
This is very evident that the Petitioners, as per the terms of their
appointment, were entitled to Bhutan Compensatory Allowance, which was
governed by the Circular dated 08.11.1977. The various Circulars to which
reference has been made by the Petitioners, pertained to Foreign
Allowances, applicable to a category of foreign officers. Therefore, these are
two different Services entitled to salary and perks according to their
Appointment and Department Rules, and cannot claim parity.
39.
It is not in dispute that the Bhutan Compensatory Allowance was not
enhanced by the Government for which the Petitioner and others similarly
situated officers, submitted Representations dated 19.08.2005, 26.02.2006
and 15.03.2006, seeking enhancement of their Bhutan Compensatory
allowance. The Government had earlier enhanced the Bhutan Compensatory
Allowance vide Letter dated 29.12.2000 to 25% on an ‘ad hoc’ basis.
Thereafter, on 27.07.2005, another ‘ad hoc’ increase of 11% was granted
to different categories of deputationists.
40.
In the case of Captain Gurdev Singh and Another v. Union of India,
the High Court had granted parity and allowed the same allowances as
granted to foreign officers, to the people similarly placed as the Petitioners.
However, this judgment was challenged by Union of India before the Apex
Court, wherein the Apex Court in Union of India v. Captain Gurdev Singh
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
and Another (2019) 14 SCC 289 noted that while it cannot be disputed that
the purpose of both allowances is fundamentally the same, i.e., to meet the
higher costs of living abroad, but at the same time, the requirements that
have to be meted out in the two, are somewhat different.
41.
The Apex Court further observed that IMTRAT personnel get benefits
to a large extent, compared to MEA personnel, in terms of getting food and
other purchases at a cheaper cost due to the provisions of facilities such as
mess, canteen, etc. Moreover, people belonging to different categories of
service, have different service conditions and facilities available to them.
The Difficulty Allowances are also given, depending upon the nature of the
job. Even if there may have been similar allowances being granted to the
different categories of the officers, but it does not imply that it is a service
condition that they would be getting the perks and allowances at par with the
Foreign Officers.
42.
No such Circular has been produced by the Petitioners to support or
establish that they were entitled to the same perks and allowances, as
Embassy personnel. It may not be out of place to mention here that the
Petitioners were entitled to Bhutan Compensatory Allowance, while the
foreign officers were entitled to Foreign Allowances, under their Service
Rules. . These two cannot be equated as one, considering that the Petitioner
and the foreign officers belong to two different categories of service and are
governed by different circulars. Consequently, the Petitioners are not
entitled to the allowances as claimed by them.
43.
In view of the aforesaid legal position, the reliance placed by the
Petitioners on Capt. Gurdev Singh (supra), is misplaced, as it has been set
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
aside. Once the said judgment has been set aside by the Apex Court, no
enforceable right can be claimed on the basis thereof.
44.
The reliance placed by the Petitioners upon Munshi Ram (supra), also
does not advance their case. In the said judgment, the Supreme Court
reiterated that similarly situated employees cannot be discriminated against
in the matter of service benefits. However, the said principle applies only
where the employees are similarly situated and belong to the same class. In
the present case, the Petitioners and Embassy personnel belong to distinct
categories governed by different service conditions. Therefore, the said
judgment has no application to the facts of the present case.
45.
Similarly, the plea of legitimate expectation raised by the Petitioners,
cannot be accepted. Legitimate expectation has to be legitimate, in
consonance with the Service/Deputation Rules, specifically accepted by the
Petitioners. Misplaced expectation based on erroneous assumption of two
services being entitled to same perks, cannot override the terms of
appointment. The Petitioners were entitled only to benefit of Bhutan
Compensatory allowance, as was admissible under the terms and conditions
of their deputation. The mere fact that for a long time, the two Allowances,
were incidentally similar, does not confer a vested right to claim parity in all
future revisions.
46.
In the present case, there is a demonstrable and reasonable basis for
distinction between the Foreign Allowance payable to Embassy personnel
and Bhutan Compensatory Allowance payable to deputationists. The
distinction is founded upon the difference in service framework, nature of
appointment and governing Rules. Therefore, the act of respondent in
enhancing Foreign Allowance from time to time, while there being no
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
similar enhancement in Bhutan Compensatory allowance, cannot be claimed
to suffer from arbitrariness or violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India.
47.
Accordingly, it is held that the Petitioners have failed to establish any
legal right to claim Bhutan Compensatory Allowance at par with Foreign
Allowance payable to Embassy personnel.
48.
The Writ petition, therefore, does not warrant any directions, under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India; it is accordingly, dismissed.
49.
Pending Application(s), if any, are disposed of accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JULY 30, 2026
RS/R/VA
W.P(C) 7192/2006
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
14:51:51
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review