Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:623
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND
AT NAINITAL
HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE ALOK MAHRA
Criminal Misc. Application No.2266 of 2025
Kuldeep Nandrajog.
...Applicant
Versus
State of Uttarakhand.
...Respondent
(Mr. Sharang Dhulia, Advocates for the applicant and Mr. Sandeep Sharma,
A.G.A. and Mr. Vikas Uniyal, Brief Holder for the State of Uttarakhand)
JUDGMENT
The present application has been filed under
Section 528 of the Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita,
2023, seeking a direction to permit the Applicant to
furnish common sureties in respect of all 120 cases, as
mentioned in the relief clause of the Application, in
which bail has already been granted by the court below
but the Applicant could not be released since he could
not arrange the separate sureties in each of the cases.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that multiple
FIRs have been lodged against the Applicant at Police
Station Bahadrabad, District Haridwar, for offences
under Sections 420, 120-B, 504, 506, 427 & 406 of the
IPC. The total number of cases stands at 120. The
Applicant contends that he is Director of the company,
namely, M/s Octagon Builder and Promoters Private
2026:UHC:623
Limited, but he could not complete the project. Multiple
F.I.R.s have been lodged against him, which are similar
in nature.
3.
It is submitted that the Applicant has been in
judicial custody since long. In several of the said cases,
he has been granted bail by the learned courts below.
However, his release could not be secured as the
orders require him to furnish two separate sureties in
each case, which is practically impossible considering
the large number of cases.
4.
The Applicant applied for bail in all 120 cases,
the reference of which has been given in the relief
clause of the application, which are reproduced as
below:S.NO
Case Crime
Numbers
Under Sections
465 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
277 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
306 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
468 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
168 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
170 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
169 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
189 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
172 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
401 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
563 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
437 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
451 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
486 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
438 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
Police
Station
Bahadrabad,
District
Haridwar
2026:UHC:623
459 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
203 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
202 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
413 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
497 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
428 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
442 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
441 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
495 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
391 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
491 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
492 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
496 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
191 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
223 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
408 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
404 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
429 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
419 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
409 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
426 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
164 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
425 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
187 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
181 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
165 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
498 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
424 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
456 of 2023
420,120-B, 504, 506
of IPC
453 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
194 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
499 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
504 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
2026:UHC:623
448 of 2023
420,120-B, 504, 506
of IPC
458 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
454 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
449 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
161 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
407 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
490 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
213 of 2023
420,427, 120-B of IPC
417 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
487 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
403 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
423 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
209 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
488 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
430 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
412 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
414 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
415 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
411 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
236 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
205 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
505 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
392 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
221 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
479 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
139 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
483 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
452 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
147 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
416 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
463 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
410 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
175 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
494 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
2026:UHC:623
201 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
493 of 2023
420,120-B of IPC
197 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
208 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
173 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
162 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
199 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
166 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
174 of 2024
420,120-B of IPC
365 of 2018
420,120-B of IPC
101 of 2016
420,506,406 of IPC
281 of 2019
420 of IPC
273 of 2019
420 of IPC
177 of 2019
420 of IPC
377 of 2018
420 of IPC
409 of 2018
420, 406 of IPC
405 of 2018
420 of IPC
399 of 2018
420 of IPC
192 of 2024
420, 406 of IPC
337 of 2018
420,120-B of IPC
336 of 2018
420 of IPC
287 of 2018
420,406 of IPC
241 of 2018
420,406 of IPC
286 of 2018
420,406 of IPC
278 of 2018
420,406 of IPC
345 of 2018
420 of IPC
109 of 2018
420 of IPC
276 of 2018
420,406 of IPC
288 of 2018
420,406 of IPC
275 of 2019
420 of IPC
263 of 2018
420,406 of IPC
176 of 2019
420 of IPC
308 of 2018
420,406 of IPC
179 of 2018
420, 406, 504, 506 of
IPC
2026:UHC:623
175 of 2019
420 of IPC
274 of 2019
420 of IPC
333 of 2018
420 of IPC
284 of 2018
420, 406 of IPC
5.
Learned counsel for the Applicant submits
that, in similar circumstances, the Coordinate Benches
of this Court has granted relief by permitting common
sureties in Criminal Misc. Application No. C-528 No.226
of 2024 decided on 16.08.2024 and Criminal Misc.
Application No.C-528 No.369 of 2025 decided on
25.03.2025.
6.
Per contra, learned State counsel opposes the
application on the ground that the satisfaction of
sureties lies within the discretion of the trial court, and
the informants in the individual cases should also be
heard before any blanket relief is granted.
7.
This Court considered the submissions of
both sides and perused the record. It is evident that
the Applicant is facing multiple prosecutions, all arising
out of similar allegations of cheating in the name of
providing land/plots. In most of these cases, he has
been enlarged on bail, but his continued incarceration
is solely due to his inability to furnish separate sureties
in each case.
8.
The Coordinate Benches of this Court, in
previous orders dated 16.08.2024 and 25.03.2025
passed in the matter of co-accused, Anjali Tyagi, have
granted similar relief, allowing the Applicant to furnish
2026:UHC:623
common sureties in multiple cases. The present matter
stands on the same footing.
9.
This Court is, therefore, confronted with the
question
as
to
whether,
in
such
exceptional
circumstances, the Applicant may be permitted to
furnish a single set of sureties and personal bond to
operate across all the FIRs in which bail has already
been granted.
10.
The provisions of Section 441 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure govern the nature and sufficiency of
bonds and sureties to be executed upon the grant of
bail. The law empowers the Court to determine, in each
case, what conditions would reasonably secure the
presence of the accused at trial.
11.
In the opinion of this Court, when bail has
already been granted in each of the 120 FIRs, and
there is no allegation of breach of conditions or flight
risk, the continued incarceration of the Applicant solely
for want of multiple sureties is neither procedurally
necessary nor constitutionally tenable.
12.
This Court is also mindful of recent judicial
observations made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
comparable contexts, particularly in Girish Gandhi v.
State of Uttar Pradesh, (2024 INSC 617), where, in
view of multiple prosecutions and the impossibility of
furnishing distinct sureties in each case, the Hon’ble
Apex Court permitted the accused to execute one
personal bond and two common sureties per State,
2026:UHC:623
holding such a direction to be legally permissible,
proportionate, and consistent with the mandate of
Article 21 of the Constitution.
13.
It has also been judicially recognised that
when the substratum of allegations is common, the
imposition of repetitive surety conditions may, in effect,
operate as a denial of bail in substance, even where it
has been formally granted.
14.
In the present case, the multiplicity of FIRs
appears to have created a procedural bottleneck, and
not one rooted in any substantive apprehension of the
Applicant's conduct.
15.
In the interest of justice, to prevent undue
hardship to the Applicant, and to secure his right to
liberty, this Court deems it appropriate to allow this
application.
17.
The apprehension of abscondence raised by
the State can be sufficiently addressed by imposing
suitable conditions.
18.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the
present criminal misc. application is allowed, subject to
the following conditions:
i. The Applicant shall furnish his current
permanent address, along with valid proof
thereof, to the satisfaction of the learned trial
court and the investigating agency. He shall
not change his residence without prior
intimation to the trial court concerned.
2026:UHC:623
ii.
The learned courts below are directed to
accept common sureties for the release of the
Applicant in all the cases mentioned in the
annexed list, wherein he has already been
granted bail.
iii. The Applicant shall also provide a written
undertaking to the effect that:
(a) He shall remain present before the
Investigating Officer and the concerned
courts as and when required;
(b) He shall not tamper with evidence or
threaten or influence any witness;
(c) He shall not leave the country without
prior leave of the competent court.
19.
The Superintendent, District Jail, Haridwar,
shall take all necessary steps for the Applicant’s release
upon acceptance of the consolidated bond and sureties,
unless his custody is required in any other unconnected
matter.
20.
It is clarified that this direction is being
issued as a matter of legal and procedural economy,
considering the large number of FIRs arising from
similar allegations, and shall not be treated as a
precedent in any unrelated proceedings.
21.
Let a copy of this order be circulated to the
District Judge, Haridwar, and to all concerned Judicial
Magistrates and courts for immediate compliance.
(ALOK MAHRA, J.)
22.01.2026
Arpan
ARPAN
JAISWAL
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH
COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=eabb68a3895e41937c266c23964c0485365445e3a20
dddb7393398f9fe45ba3e, postalCode=263001,
st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=060FC17022BEAE3DE215D68D9D454C5109CB9
87446351E4DF04AADAA2C2CEA66, cn=ARPAN JAISWAL
Date: 2026.01.23 14:35:26 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review