Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 2nd April, 2026
Pronounced on: 9th July, 2026
+
RSA 256/2016& CM APPL. 33802/2016
1.
SMT. KUCHCHI @ SHANTI DEVI
(Deceased Through her L.Rs)
Wife of Late Sh. Shankar Lal
2.
SH. BISHAN DASS
S/o Late Sh. Shankar Lal
3.
SH. BABU RAM
S/o Late Sh. Shankar lal
4.
SH. CHHOTEY LAL
S/o Late Sh. Shankar Lal
5.
SMT. SHAKUNTALA
W/o Sh. Bishan Dass
6.
SMT. USHA
W/o Sh. Babu Ram
7.
SMT. RAJ RANI
W/o Sh. Chhotay Lal
All R/o 1104, New Usman Pur,
Delhi-110053.
8.
SMT. SHASHI-KALA @ LALIA
D/o Late Sh. Shankar Lal
W/o Sh. Ganga Ram
R/o Ghasiyari Mandi,
Malik Mau, Near Mal Godam,
Rai Bareilly (U.P.)
SMT. BUDHANI (pre-deceased)
D/o Late Sh. Shankar Lal
9.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
W/o Late Sh. Rajinder
Though her legal heirs
9A.
JITENDER (Son)
9B.
MS. SEEMA (Daughter)
R/o 1104, New Usman Pur,
Delhi.
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. S. K. Gupta, Ms. Aarti Bansal
and Mr. Gaurav Gupta, Advocates
versus
1.
SMT. DAULATI (Deceased following through LRs)
Wd/o Sh. Makua Ram
1(a) SH. KALLU RAM
S/o Late Sh. Makua Ram
1(b) SH. GANGA RAM
S/o Late Sh. Makua Ram
All R/o B-110, New Usman Pur,
Delhi.
1(c) SMT. GUDDO
D/o Late Sh. Makua Ram
W/o Sh. Bahadur
R/o B-133, New Usman Pur,
Delhi-110053.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Rajesh Tyagi and Mr. Puneet
Verma, Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
1.
Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “CPC”) has been filed against
the Judgment and Decree dated12.05.2016 whereby the learned ADJ in the
First Appeal, has upheld the Judgment and Decree dated 18.11.2010 of the
Ld. Civil Judge, whereby the Suit of the Plaintiff/Respondent for Possession,
Declaration and Permanent Injunction, was decreed.
2.
The Plaintiffs had filed a Civil Suit No.610/2007 for Possession,
Declaration and Permanent Injunction.
3.
The facts in brief as stated in the Plaint, were that Late Makua Ram
during his lifetime was allotted Plot No.90 admeasuring 250 sq. yds. in lieu
of his agricultural land in village Ushmanpur, Delhi, through registered
Lease Deed dated 18.11.1961 executed by Assistant Development
Commissioner of Delhi Administration. On the same date, an Agreement
for Lease was also executed.
4.
Late Shri Makua Ram out of love and affection permitted Defendant
No.1 Shri Shankar Lal, his younger brother to occupy one room having two
portions, as shown in red colour in the site plan, as a licensee without any
consideration. The Defendant No.1 along with Defendant No.2 to 8
occupied the suit premises and also fixed an Atta Chakki. The Defendants
thus, were enjoying the possession of the part of the suit property as a
licensee up to 18.10.1992, when Shri Makua Ram died.
5.
Thereafter, the Defendants threatened and got vacated four rooms
from the tenants and tried to forcibly occupy them in the month of January,
1993, but due to timely intervention of the Plaintiffs and other relatives and
common friends, the Defendants were unable to succeed in occupying the
remaining portion.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
6.
On 07.05.1994 at about 08:00 A.M, the Defendants starting
demolishing those four rooms, which had been vacated by the tenants.
When the Plaintiffs tried to prevent them, they threatened to kill the
Plaintiffs. The Police of Police Post New Ushmanpur, did not record the
Complaint and advised them to approach the Court.
7.
The Plaintiffs thus, filed a Suit for Permanent Injunction praying to
restrain the Respondents from demolishing the rooms, on 07.05.1994. The
learned Sub-Judge, Delhi issued Notice to the Defendants, who on receiving
the Notice demolished half portion of the House No.1104, New Ushmanpur,
Delhi. On 09.05.1995, the learned Sub-Judge restrained the Defendants
from demolishing the wall which divided the House No.1104, New
Ushmanpur, into two parts.
8.
During the hearing of the said Suit, Defendant produced a General
Power of Attorney, Agreement to Sell, Affidavit, Will and a duly registered
receipt of Rs.50,000/- dated 24.07.1989 allegedly executed in their favour by
late Makua Ram. The Defendants claimed that the half portion of the House
No.1104, had been sold by Shri Makua Ram to the Defendant No.1 on
24.07.1989, and since then they are in occupation.
9.
The Plaintiffs stated that the perusal of the documents revealed that
the signatures of Late Makua Ram, had been forged. It was asserted that
Makua Ram during his lifetime, had never visited the office of SubRegistrar nor had he executed the documents, which had been fabricated to
grab the property of the Plaintiffs, who were the owners of the property in
question. The Plaintiffs served a Notice dated 21.05.1994 terminating their
license w.e.f. 21.05.1994 and sought the peaceful and vacant possession
within 30 days of the Notice.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
10.
The Defendants on receiving the Notice started contacting the
Property Dealers with a view to sell the Suit property and thereby, cause loss
to the Plaintiffs.
11.
The Plaintiffs thus, filed the Suit for recovery of Possession,
Declaration in favour of the Plaintiffs and against the Defendants and also
to declare GPA, Agreement to Sell dated 24.07.1989 as forged documents
and for Permanent Injunction to restrain the Defendants from creating third
party rights, in the suit property.
12.
The Defendant No.8, Smt. Munni and Defendant No. 9 Smt. Shashi
Kala, in their Written Statement took the preliminary objection that the
Plaintiffs had no locus standi to file the Suit since Late Makua Ram had
already sold the half property to Defendant No.1 Sh. Shankar Lal, his
younger brother, vide documents dated 24.07.1989. After purchasing the
Suit property, the Defendant No.1 became the lawful owner thereof. They
along with other LRs of Defendant No.1, have become the joint owners of
the Suit property.
13.
It was further claimed that Shri Makua Ram during his lifetime, never
filed any Suit against the Defendants, despite being aware that he had sold
the property to his younger brother Shankar Lal who had been exercising his
ownership rights in the property. Even the Plaintiffs became aware of the
sale of the property by Makua Ram in the year 1989 but had not raised any
objection, at the relevant time. The Suit is, therefore, barred by limitation.
14.
It was further asserted that the Suit was barred under Order 2 Rule II
CPC.
Admittedly, the Plaintiff had earlier filed a Suit for Permanent
Injunction against the Defendants, but did not seek effective and appropriate
relief of Declaration and Possession, despite being aware of the entire facts.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
15.
On merits, it was re-emphasized that on account of execution of
Agreement to Sell, etc., Sh. Shanker Lal, the Defendant No.1, the younger
brother of Makua Ram, became the absolute owner of the suit property. It
was denied that the documents were forged and fabricated or had been
executed by playing fraud and mis-representation. It was thus, submitted
that the Suit of the Plaintiff be dismissed.
16.
The Plaintiffs in the Replication, denied the claim of the Defendants
to be the absolute owner in the Suit property and reiterated the averments
made in the Plaint.
17.
The Issues were framed on 17.04.1997, as under :
(i)
Whether documents comprising of GPA dated
24/07/1989,
agreement
dated
24/07/1989,
affidavit dated 24/07/1989 and receipt dated
24/07/189 as referred to in the prayer clause 'B'
of the plaint are forged documents and
possession of the defendants in the suit property
is of unauthorised occupants? If, so, its effect?
OPP
(ii)
Whether defendants are absolute owner of half
of the suit property as claimed in paragraph no.l
of the preliminary objection of the written
statement? OPP
(iii)
Whether suit is without cause of action? OPD
(iv)
Whether plaintiff has no right, title or interest in
the suit property and has no locus standi to file
this suit? OPD
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
(v)
Whether there is any concealment of the
material facts? If so, its effect? OPD
(vi)
Whether plaintiff is entitled to the relief as
claimed in the plaint? OPP
(vii)
18.
Relief.
The Plaintiffs in support of their case examined PW1 Smt. Premwati,
from the office of Sub-Registrar, Kashmere Gate to deposed that the suit
property had been allotted to Sh. Late Makua Ram by way of Perpetual
Lease deed dated 18.11.1961vide registration no. 878, Vol. no. 691. She also
proved the Agreement for lease dated 18.11.1961, which was brought on
record.
19.
PW2 Smt. Daulti,(Plaintiff No.1), has deposed on the similar lines as
the averments made in the Plaint.
20.
PW3 Sh. Kamal Kant Khandelwal was the Handwriting Expert, who
deposed that the signatures on the documents namely Agreement to Sell,
etc., were not of Sh. Makua Ram.
21.
PW4 Sh. Ganga Ram deposed that the property was purchased by his
father and he was seriously ill and was bed-ridden and was not in position to
walk to the office of Sub-Registrar, to execute the documents dated
24.7.1989. Sh. Ganga Ram has got verified the signatures of his father
through handwriting expert Sh. Kamal Kant Khandelwal,who gave his
Report Ex. PW3/15.
22.
The Defendants in support of their case, examined DW1 Sh. Sanjay
Ray, Assistant Grade-II, BSES Yamuna Power Ltd., who proved the record
of installation and test report of meter installed at the questioned property
Ex. DW1/A and copy of K number file Ex. DW1/B.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
23.
DW2 Sh. Babu Ram deposed that his father, Sh. Shankar Lal is
paying the House Taxof the questioned property to MCD and receipt for the
same is Ex. DW1/E. He is also paying the electricity charges as per bills Ex.
DW1/F,G,H, against the Meter No. 0303556.
24.
DW3 Sh. Chhotay Lal, son of Shanker Laldeposed on the same lines
as his brother, DW2. He also deposed that his father is residing in the suit
property since 1967, being owner and was receiving the rent in respect of
various tenanted portion.
25.
DW4 Sh. Bishan Dass deposed that Ex. DW1/A to D are not forged
documents as they have been duly signed by his uncle Sh. Makua Ram,
wherein he put his signatures at point A on all documents and also put his
thumb impression at point B, on document Ex. DW1/A.
26.
DW5 Sh. P.C. Tiwari, LDC from the office of Sub-Registrar IV,
Nand Nagri, Delhi deposed that theReceipt pertaining to payment of Rs.
50,000/- by Sh. Shankar Lal to Sh. Makua Ram Ex. DW1/A, was registered
vide document registration no. 33354 book no. 4, volume no. 2096 page no.
57 dated 24.07.1989.
27.
DW6 Sh. Rajesh Kumar from House Tax Department, MCD proved
Receipt Ex. PW4/D1 to Ex. PW4/D3 as
pertain to property no. 99/5,
Ushmanpur Village; whereas Ex. PW/D4 and Ex. PW4/D5 pertain to
property no. 29/5, Ushmanpur village.
28.
The Learned Civil Judgein the impugned judgment dated
18.11.2010, observed that the Defendants/Appellants had sought to claim
the ownership on the basis of Agreement to Sell, Will, Affidavit and
Receipts, all dated 24.07.1989 alleged to have been executed in their father,
Sh. Shanker Lal, by late Sh. Makua Ram.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
29.
However, on a close scrutiny of the evidence of the Handwriting
Expert and also the testimony of the witnesses, it was concluded that these
documents were not genuinely executed by late Sh. Makua Ram and were
forged and fabricated documents. It was thus, concluded that the Defendants
had not been able to establish their right, title and interest to establish their
absolute ownership in respect of half part of the Suit Property.
30.
It was further observed that the Plaintiffs were able to establish their
ownership rights in the Suit Property. Consequently, it was declared that
Defendants were unauthorised occupants in the Suit Premises and the
decree of possession was passed in favour of the Plaintiffs. The Suit was
decreed with cost of Rs.3,500/- to be paid by the Defendants.
31.
The Defendants have filed Regular CivilAppeal No. 40/16/11against
the impugned judgment dated 18.11.2010 and decree dated 20.11.2010.
32.
The learned ADJconcurred with the appreciation of evidence by the
Ld. Civil Judge and dismissed the Appeal,vide judgment dated 12.05.2016.
33.
Aggrieved by the dismissal of the Regular First Appeal, the present
Second Regular Appeal under Section 100 CPC, has been filed to
challenge the impugned Judgment dated 12.05.2016.
34.
The grounds of challenge are that the facts and circumstances as well
as the documents placed on record, had not been appreciated correctly and
wrong conclusions/observations were made, based on conjectures and
surmises and not on any sound legal reasoning. The documents which were
admittedly part of the Court record, had not been considered in the right
perspective. The legality and validity of the sale purchase documents in
favour of the Appellants/Defendants, is based on incorrect appreciation of
evidence.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
35.
The learned Civil Judge accepted the Report of hand-writing expert
selectively by relying upon the opinion with regard to thumb impression, but
disregarding the opinion as regards the
signatures. The learned Civil
Judgedisbelieved the Report with respect of thumb impressions by basing
his observations on the literature available on Wikipedia. The learned First
Appellate Court disapproved the approach of learned Civil Judge in placing
reliance on such unauthenticated material on Wikipedia, but surprisingly
chose to affirm the findings of the learned Civil Judge, in regard to the
evidence of Handwriting Expert. This has given rise to anomalous situation
whereby while the Appellate Court itself discarded the basis on which the
learned Civil Judge gave his finding in respect of the evidence of
Handwriting Expert, however, chose to agree with the findings of the
learned Civil Court.
36.
Furthermore, both the Courts committed an error in fact and law, by
relying upon one aspect of the report of the Handwriting Expert and
discarding the other aspects. Such piecemeal reliance on the Report of the
Handwriting Expert is against the law; either the entire Report should have
been accepted or rejected in toto.
37.
The learned Civil Judge held that the sale-purchase documents relied
upon by the Defendants/Appellants, were legally invalid, on the premise that
only the Receipt was registered, which carried the thumb impression of
Makua Ram, while thumb impression was not present on all other
documents, i.e., GPA, Agreement to Sell, etc. It is asserted that learned Trial
Court lost site of the fact that thumb impression of executants is mandatory
only on the documents which is submitted for registration. Therefore, thumb
impression was not mandatorily required to be present on all other
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
documents, i.e., GPA, Agreement to Sell, etc., as they were not submitted
for registration, before the Sub-Registrar.
38.
The learned Civil Judge further observed that the registered Receipt
did not contain the photograph of the payer and the payee. However, the
testimony of DW5, witness from the office of Sub-Registrar has been
overlooked. It would clearly show that in the year 1989, there was no
requirement of affixing the photograph of the parties on the documents
submitted for registration. The absence of the photograph on registered
Receipt Ex.PW2/D1, could not have been the basis to hold the document
invalid.
39.
It remains undisputed that the plot in question was divided in two
equal parts and one half was in the possession of the Plaintiffs and the other
half was in the possession of the Appellants, since 1989. It is also not in
dispute that the Appellants were depositing the House Tax and the essential
service provided in this half portion, were in the name of the Appellants, in
the records of statutory authorities.
40.
No evidence has been placed on record by the Respondents/Plaintiffs
to show that they were being assessed to house tax in respect of half portion
and that the essential services were in their name, thereby establishing the
long possession of the Appellants in the suit property. The inevitable
conclusion was that since 1989, it was accepted that the suit property was
owned and possessed by the Appellants/Defendants. The stand of the
Respondents/Plaintiffs that the Appellants were in occupation of the suit
property as a licensee, is an afterthought and devoid of any merit.
41.
Furthermore, the basis on which the learned Civil Judge held the sale
documents to be invalid, did not find favour with the First Appellate Court
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
and it proceeded to declare the documents invalid on a totally different
premise, which was not even addressed by the learned Civil Judge.
42.
According to the First Appellate Court, the documents were invalid
because its execution was not proved in accordance with law, as none of the
witnesses to the documents, had been examined.
43.
The Appellants submitted that if at all, the learned Appellate Court
was of the view that the basis adopted by the learned Civil Judge to give a
finding on the factual aspect was incorrect, then too, it ought to have
remanded the matter back and allowed the parties to lead evidence on the
aspect on which the observations had been made.
44.
It has been erroneously held by learned First Appellate Court that the
Respondents/Plaintiffs were able to discharge the burden, to prove that the
documents were forged and fabricated by examining the Handwriting
Expert. Such a finding is totally unsustainable, in fact and in law.
45.
The careful reading of the impugned judgment of First Appellate
Court would reflect that no reasons have been given as to how the Report of
Handwriting Expert found favour with it ,since the basis on which the
learned Civil Judge attached credence to the Handwriting Expert Report,
was ignored by the First Appellate Court.No basis has been explained by the
First Appellate Court for holding the Expert Report to be correct.
46.
From the observations made by the learned Civil Judge as well by the
First Appellate Court, it emerges that the Report of Handwriting Expert
remained as a piece a paper with no evidentiary value; such a Report could
not have been held to be an admissible evidence, and that too, sufficient to
hold the documents in favour of the Defendants/Appellants as forged and
fabricated.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
47.
It is asserted that the onus of proving that the documents of title, all
dated 24.07.1989 in favour of the Appellants were forged and fabricated,
was on the Plaintiffs. However, the Plaintiffs failed to discharge this burden
and the Plaintiffs were unable to explain the presence of late Makua Ram on
24.07.1989, i.e., the date of execution of documents.
48.
Surprisingly, for the first time, PW4-Ganga Ram in his evidence
disclosed that the father was suffering from illness on the relevant date, but
during the cross-examination, he was unable to given any specific details of
the illness and the treatment, in proof thereof. It is claimed that late Sh.
Makua Ram was hale and happy and capable of walking and executing the
relevant documents in the year 1989.
49.
The Appellate Court in the impugned judgment dated 12.09.2016, had
observed that the Plaintiffs claim that Makua Ram was bed ridden and could
not have gone to the office of Sub-Registrar in the year 1989 for registration
of the receipt, was not proved in any manner. This establishes the execution
of the registered Receipt dated 24.07.1989 Ex.DW1/A. Once the registration
of the Receipt is duly proved and established, the authenticity and the
execution of other
documents, namely, Agreement to Sell, GPA, etc.,
cannot be held to be forged and fabricated.
50.
Late Sh. Makua Ram had expired in the year 1992, despite which no
steps were taken by the Plaintiffs for eviction of the Defendants/Appellants
from the Suit Property. This was so because they were well aware of the title
documents executed by late Makua Ram in favour of his brother Sh.
Shankar Lal after taking the sale consideration of Rs.50,000/-.
51.
It is submitted that the evidence of the witnesses examined by the
Plaintiffs was full of discrepancies and were far from truth. Therefore, the
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
impugned judgment and decree of both the Courts be set aside and the
Suit of the Plaintiffs, be dismissed.
52.
Written Submissions were filed on behalf of the Respondents, who
gave the narration of entire facts and the evidence and stated that the
evidence has been rightly appreciated by the learned Civil Judge and the
cogent reasons have been given by the First Appellate Court for decreeing
the Suit of the Plaintiffs. There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is
liable to be rejected.
53.
The Appellants had essentially argued on the lines of their grounds
of Appeal, to claim that the impugned judgment was liable to be set aside.
Reliance was placed on ChennadiJalapathi Reddy v. Baddam Pratapa
Reddy(2019) 14 SCC 220, Kartar Singh v. DDA 1999 SCC OnLine Del
1013, Vinod Kumar and Ors. v. Smt. Krishna Devi &Anr.2011 SCC OnLine
Del 887 andAmar Nath v. Gian Chand(2022) 11 SCC 460.
Submissions heard and record perused.
54.
The substantial question of law was framed on 03.01.2024 by this
Court, which are as under:-
55.
“Whether the manner in which the learned trial
court as well as the learned first appellate court
examined the evidence with respect to the claim of
the appellants that the title in the suit property
stood transferred by Makua Ram to Shankar Lal,
suffers from perversity?”
In order to ascertain, whether the findings of the learned Civil Judge,
which have been upheld by the Appellate Court, are perverse, it would be
pertinent to examine the facts and the evidences led by the parties.
56.
The Plaintiffs had claimed that the suit property was owned by Sh.
Makua Ram. PW-2, Smt. Daulati w/o Sh. Makua Ram, had proved the
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
Agreement for Lease Ex.PW-2/1, Perpetual Lease Deed Ex.PW-2/2, and the
Mortgage DeedEx.PW-2/3 dated 18.11.1961 in favour of Late Sh. Makua
Ram. The perpetual Lease Deed, Ex.PW-2/2 clearly establishes that the Suit
Property, which was a plot of land at the relevant time admeasuring 250 sq.
yds. of land, had been allotted to Late Sh. Makua Ram. On the same date,
the Agreement for Lease, Ex.PW-2/1 was executed for raising the
construction on the said plot of land within a period of 12 months at the own
expense to the satisfaction of the Chief Commissioner of Delhi.
57.
In order to raise the construction, a loan of Rs.3,000/- had been taken
by Sh. Makua Ram from the Government for which, Mortgage Deed dated
19.11.1966, Ex.PW-2/3 was executed. The authenticity of these documents,
is not being questioned by the Defendants and it is an admitted fact that the
Suit Property, which was a plot at the relevant time, was allotted to Sh.
Makua Ram vide the perpetual Lease.
58.
These documents and the ownership of Sh. Makua Ram, is admitted
by the Appellants, as well.
59.
According to the PW-2, the wife of Sh. Makua Ram, the Defendant
No. 1/Appellant, Sh. Shankar Lal, was the younger brother of Late Sh.
Makua Ram, who had been allowed to reside him in part of the property in
question, out of love and affection.
60.
The Defendant No. 1, Sh. Shankar Lal as DW-1, deposed that he has
been residing in the suit property, which is part of the property in question
since 1967 in the capacity of an owner. However, there were no title
documents executed in his favour in 1967 when he entered into the
premises; thereby lending support to the testimony of the Plaintiff that he
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
had been permitted to occupy part of the property in question, out of love
and affection.
61.
DW-1, Sh. Shankar Lal had asserted his ownership rights by
claiming that his brother, Sh. Makua Ram had executed the registered
Receipt in the sum of Rs.50,000/-, GPA, ATS, Affidavit,Ex.DW-1/A to
Ex.DW-1/D respectively. He also deposed that a Will of the same date i.e.
24.07.1989, Ex.DW-1/1 was also executed in his favour.
62.
DW-2, Sh. Babu Ram, DW-3, Sh. Chhotay Lal and DW-4, Sh. Bishan
Dass, who are the three sons of Sh. Shankar Lal, had deposed on similar
lines as their father, DW-1, Shankar Lal.
63.
The challenge to the authenticity of this Agreement to Sell, etc., had
been questioned by the Plaintiffs, on the grounds that these documents had
never been executed by Sh. Makua Ram and his thumb impression and
signatures on these documents, were forged and fabricated; a fact, which
was deposed by PW-2, Smt. Daulati and PW-4, Sh. Ganga Ram s/o Late Sh.
Makua Ram, who consistently deposed that the Defendants/Appellants had
been in occupation only because of pure love and affection, being the
younger brother of Late Sh. Makua Ram.
64.
The most material witness examined by the Plaintiffs, to corroborate
that these documents did not bear the signatures/thumb impression of Late
Sh. Makua Ram, was PW-3, Sh. Kamal Kant Khandelwal, the Hand
Writing Expert, who gave his Report, Ex.PW-3/15. He deposed that he had
examined the disputed thumb impression on the Receipt, Ex.DW-1/A by
comparing it to the thumb impression of Sh. Makua Ram, on the Perpetual
Lease Deed and Agreement to Lease Deed. He also enlarged the ink prints
and the photographs, which are Ex.PW-3/1 to Ex.PW-3/13, the negatives of
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
which are Ex.PW-3/14 (collectively). He deposed that the thumb impression
on the Receipt, did not match with the admitted thumb impression, as it was
found that the admitted thumb impression at C-1 and C-2, was of „WHORL‟
type while the questioned thumb impression on the ReceiptEx.Ex.DW-1/A
at point D1 to D3, was of „LOOP‟ type and was opening towards left side.
The thumb impressions on the Receipt, did not match with the admitted
thumb impression.
65.
The learned Civil Judge had referred to this aspect of the testimony of
PW-3, to observe that in the Hand Writing Expert Report, Ex.PW-3/15, he
had categorically stated that the thumb impressions on the admitted and the
disputed documents, were not same for the reasons stated hereinabove.
66.
For the purpose of explaining what a LOOP and WHORL type thumb
impression is, Ld. Civil Judge had referred to WIKIPEDIA. It was only for
the purpose of comprehending the two terms and not for the purpose of
ascertaining the credibility of the Report of the Hand Writing Expert, that a
reference was made to Wikipedia.
67.
The learned Civil Judge in the light of this Report and the testimony
of the PWs, had concluded that the thumb impression on the Receipt, was
not that of Late Sh. Makua Ram.
68.
The learned District Judge while recording the contention of the
Appellants that the WIKIPEDIA could not have been referred to determine
the authenticity of the thumb impression, it was observed that the Report of
the Hand Writing Expert, Ex.PW-3/15, gave cogent reasons and established
the thumb impression on the Receipt, Ex.DW-1/A as not those of Late Sh.
Makua Ram and therefore, the Receipt was a forged document. It would be
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
erroneous on the part of the Appellant to say that the authenticity of the
Report has been determined on the Wikipedia information.
69.
PW-4, Sh. Ganga Ram s/o Late Sh. Makua Ram, further explained
that Late Sh. Makua Ram had suffered paralysis and was bed ridden in the
year 1989 and was incompetent to even go to the Office of the SubRegistrar, to execute the Receipt.
70.
While there was no cogent evidence produced by the Plaintiffs, to
show that Sh. Makua Ram was physically disabled, but the fact remains that
the thumb impression as per the Hand Writing Expert and even to the naked
eye and on examining of the enlarged photographs blatantly are different
and are not those of Sh. Makua Ram..
71.
The learned Civil Judge thus, rightly concluded that the thumb
impressions on the Receipt, Ex.DW-1/A were not of Late Sh. Makua Ram.
This finding of fact has been duly upheld by the learned Appellate Court and
there is no infirmity, which has been brought forth by the Appellants, in this
Second Appeal.
72.
The next significant aspect was the alleged signatures of Makua
Ram on the Agreement to Sell and Affidavit, Ex.DW-1/B to Ex.DW-1/D
dated 24.07.1989. It had been observed in the Report of the Hand Writing
Expert that the examination of the disputed signatures with the admitted
signatures of Late Sh. Makua Ram, reflected that the signatures on the
documents, Ex.PW-1/B to Ex.PW-1/D were not those of Late Sh. Makua
Ram and were forged by the forger with free hand.
73.
The explanation was given that there were dissimilarities in the
Curves, Angles, Slant, Alignment, Spacing, Sizing, Pen-Hold, Movement
and in Pictorial aspect in both the signatures. The formation of Letter „Ma‟
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
is totally different in both the set of signatures in the executional manner.
The Letter „Ma‟ is written with two pen operation in the admitted signatures
on A-1 and A-2 whereas in the disputed documents, it is written with one
pen operation. There is a Loop formation at the bottom of first staff in the
admitted documents at A-1 and A-2 but in the disputed document, there was
an angular formation. Further, there was also dissimilarity in the formation
of Letters “Ka” and “Va” and the placing of formation of “U” matrain the
manner of execution of both the sets of signatures. It was further found that
there were dissimilarities in the over stroke over the signature. It was thus,
concluded that the signatures on the disputed documents, Ex.PW-1/B to
Ex.PW-1/D, were not of Late Sh. Makua Ram.
74.
PW-3, Sh. Kamal Kant Khandelwal, withstood the extensive cross-
examination by the Plaintiffs, but were unable to bring out any discrepancy
in the Report. the Defendants/Appellants had also been unable to establish
the execution of the sale documents in their favour.
75.
It may be observed that the two signatures, on bare examination by
the naked eye, are also blatantly distinct. Though it was contended that with
passage of time, there is bound to be natural variation in handwriting, but it
has been explained by PW-3 Mr. Khandelwal that the basis strokes remain
the same. The disputed signatures were intrinsically distinct from the
admitted signatures and were not of the same person.
76.
While the Defendant/DW-1, Sh. Shankar Lal admitted that he came
into the possession since 1967,he has not explained the capacity in which he
entered into the suit property, especially when the sale documents allegedly
were executed in favour of Late Sh. Shankar Lal, in 24.07.1989.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
77.
Pertinently, to prove that they had proprietary rights in the suit
property, DW-1 in his testimony, deposed that he had been renting out the
portions of the Property since 1967, to various tenants and one tenant, Sh.
Ram Kripal and Sh. FirtuRam, had been inducted by him from 1993 to 1997
at a monthly rent of Rs.400/- per month. Further, PW-4, Sh. Ganga Ram has
also admitted that Sh. Shankar Lal had erected AattaChakki in the portion of
the Plaintiffs. However, the fact remains that such user of the property does
not confer any ownership rights on the Defendants merely because he was
using the Property of Late Sh. Makua Ram and the Plaintiffs.The Defendant
having been put into the permissive occupation of the premises by Sh.
Shankar Lal, may have permitted him to rent out some part of the Property
and collect their rent, but that in itself in the absence of any cogent evidence
or documents, cannot be a ground to prove that he had acquired ownership
rights in the suit property.
78.
The Defendants had also claimed that they had the electricity
connection in their name for their portion of the Suit Property.
79.
They had also relied on the House Tax Receipts, Ex.DW-4/D1 to
Ex.DW-4/D5 in the name of Sh. Shankar Lal, but it has been rightly noted by
the learned Civil Judge and endorsed by the learned ADJ, that these House
Tax Receipts mentioned the address as 99/5, Usmanpur Village (Ex.PW4/D1 to Ex.PW-4/D3) and as 29/5, Ex.PW-4/D4 and Ex.PW-4/D5.
80.
DW-3, Sh. Chhotey Lal son of Late Sh. Shankar Lal, admitted that he
was not aware of who was the owner of the Property No. 29/5. DW-4 also
admitted that the Property No. 29/5 was neither owned by his father nor by
him. DW6 Sh. Rajesh Kumar from House Tax Department, MCD proved
Receipt Ex. PW4/D1 to Ex. PW4/D3 as pertaining to property no. 99/5,
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
Ushmanpur Village; whereas Ex. PW/D4 and Ex. PW4/D5 pertain to
property no. 29/5, Ushmanpur village.
81.
These House tax Receipts, on which reliance was placed by the
Defendants, were not proved to be pertaining to the Suit Property.
82.
Even if for the sake of arguments, it is accepted that the Appellants
had been paying the House Tax or had the electricity connection in their
name in the Suit Premises, but that by itself, cannot be any defence of the
occupation of the Appellants in the Suit Property in the nature of ownership.
This may prove their possession, which is admitted by the Plaintiffs also
since 1967 but in no manner creates ownership rights in the Suit Property.
83.
The Defendants had also placed reliance on Affidavit dated
24.07.1989, Ex.DW-1/D, to assert that the Late Sh. Makua Ram had given
an authority to get the Property mutated in his name. It may be noted that
this Affidavit, Ex.DW-1/Dis also partof the same set of documents i.e.GPA,
ATS etc. and the signatures on the documents, has been held to be forged
and fabricated.
84.
Assuming all the contentions of the Defendants/Appellants to be
accepted, then too it is trite law that mere Agreement to Sell, GPA etc.,
cannot create any ownership rights in favour of the Defendants. The GPA
merely gives an Authority to act on behalf of the owner while Agreement to
Sell may give a right to get a sale deed executed in his favour. On the basis
of this mere Agreement to Sell, the defendants cannot claim any proprietary
rights in their favour.
85.
The defendants also relied upon Affidavit dated 24.07.1989 Ex.
DW1/D whereby Late Sh. Makua Ram had authorised Sh. Shankar Lal, to
get the Property mutated. Though the Appellants have failed to establish the
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
authenticity of these documents and the alleged Affidavit is not even
attested, but the fact remains that had Shanker Lal acquired proprietary
rights including the right to get the Property mutated,but it has never been
acted upon by the Defendants and there is nothing to show that the Suit
premises ever got mutated in the name of Sh. Shankar Lal.
86.
The learned Civil Judge rightly concluded that the Defendants had
miserably failed to establish any document of title in their favour. The claim
of the Plaintiffs as deposed by PW-2 and PW-4 that the Defendants being
the younger brother of Late Sh. Makua Ram, had been in permissive user of
the Suit premises, stands fully established and has been rightly so
concluded by the two Courts. There is no infirmity in any of the findings on
fact, which have been arrived at after due appreciation of the evidence on
record.
87.
It may further be noted that though the Appellants had also relied
upon a Will dated 24.07.1989, Ex.DW-1/1 allegedly executed by Late Sh.
Makua Ram in favour of the Defendant No. 1 but as already noted above,
this Will also formed part of the documents i.e. GPA, etc. on which, the
signatures have been found to be forged. It has been established that the
signatures on the Will, are also not genuine.
88.
Moreover, the Will had to be necessarily required to be proved in
accordance with Section 68 of Evidence Act, by examination of at least one
witness to the said document. However, no attesting witness has been
examined. The Will also not only has the forged signatures of Late Sh.
Makua Ram, but has also not been proved in accordance with law. No
benefit can be sought by Sh. Shankar Lal, under the said Will Ex.DW-1/1.
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
89.
The learned Civil Judge had correctly appreciated the evidence and
given the findings of fact in favour of the Plaintiff that the possession of the
Defendants/Appellants, was permissive and has rightly decreed the Suit of
the Plaintiff. The Ld. District Judge, on re-appreciation of evidence, arrived
at the same conclusions. No perversity in any of the findings of the two
Courts, has been shown in the present Appeal.
CONCLUSION:
90.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, it is held that no question of
law is discernible in this Appeal. The challenge is essentially on the findings
of facts, which is beyond the scope of Second Appeal. There is no merit in
the present Second Appeal, which is hereby dismissed. The pending
Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JULY 09, 2026/va/RS
KUMAR BHATT
17:38:05
RSA 256/2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review