Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.09.06 10:44:26 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC(El. Pet.) No. 36 of 2023
Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022
2) El. Pet. No. 10 of 2022
Kshetrimayum Biren Singh, aged about 60 years, S/o Late
Ksh. Pishak Singh of Sabungkhok Mayai Leikai, BPOYaingangpokpi, P.S. Yaingangpokpi Imphal East District,
Manipur.
… … Applicant/Election Petitioner
-VERSUS1. Khongbantabam Ibomcha Singh, aged about 63 years, S/O
Late Pishak of Nongada Makha Leikai, P.O. Lamlong, P.S.
Lamlai, Imphal East District, Manipur.
…. …. Op/Respondent.
2. Achoibam Deben Singh, aged about 41 years, S/O A.
Rabungo Singh of Lamlai Mayai Leikai, P.O Lamlong,
P.S.Lamlai, Imphal East District, Manipur.
3. Mongjam Poireihenba Meetei, aged about 35 years, S/O
Late Mongjam Ibochou Meetei Singh of Yourabung
Mamang Leikai, P.O. Lamlong, P.S. Lamlai, Imphal East
District, Manipur.
4. Sapam Kangleipal Meitei, aged about 40 years, S/O S.
Shyamdunder Meitei of Nongada Awang Leikai, P.O.
Lamlong, P.S. Lamlai, Imphal East District, Manipur.
…. …. Respondents.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
Page |2
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the applicant
.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. T. Rajendra, Sr. Adv.
::
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, Adv.
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
05.07.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
06.09.2023
::
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
Heard Mr. T. Rajendra, learned senior counsel for
the applicant and Mr. Ajoy Pebam, the learned counsel for the
first respondent.
2.
This miscellaneous case has been filed by the
petitioner to permit the petitioner to file a rejoinder to the
replication/subsequent pleading filed by the first respondent in
the election petition.
3.
The petitioner herein is the election petitioner. The
petitioner has filed the election petition to declare the election of
the first respondent from No.8-Laimai Assembly Constituency
as void and to declare the petitioner as duly elected candidate
from the said Constituency. Pending election petition, the first
respondent filed M.C.No.111 of 2022 to reject the election
petition.
The petitioner has filed his written objection to
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
Page |3
M.C.No.111 of 2022 and the first respondent has filed
M.C.No.212 of 2022 to allow him to file replication to the written
objection. By the order dated 16.5.2023, M.C.No.212 of 2022
was allowed by this Court. Subsequently, the petitioner has
filed the present M.C.No.36 of 2023 to allow him to file the
rejoinder to the replication.
4.
Mr. T. Rajendra, the learned senior counsel for the
applicant submitted that during the pendency of the election
petition, the first respondent filed M.C.No.111 of 2022 under
Order 7, Rule 11(a) CPC read with Section 86(1) of the
Representation of People Act for rejecting the election petition.
The petitioner herein opposed the said petition by filing his
written objection dated 28.9.2022.
The first respondent had
filed M.C.No.212 of 2022 under Order 8, Rule 9 CPC for
granting leave to file subsequent pleading/replication to the
written objection dated 28.9.2022 filed by the petitioner. This
Court, by the order dated 16.5.2023 in M.C.No.212 of 2022
granted leave to the first respondent to file the replication to the
written objection dated 28.9.2022 filed by the petitioner. While
allowing the petition, in paragraph 13, this Court observed that
there is no dispute that “replication” is the plaintiff’s answer to
the defendant’s plea and “rejoinder” is the defendant’s answer
to the plaintiff’s replication. This Court also held that filing of
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
Page |4
additional
pleadings
not
contrary
to
the
earlier
pleas
explanatory to the plea advanced earlier is permissible.
In
order to explain the plea of the party and also for fair enquiry,
this Court allowed the prayer of the first respondent to file his
replication.
5.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
in the replication of the first respondent there are many facts
which are very much required to be answered by giving proper
explanation and clarification by filing a rejoinder, more
particularly, paragraphs 1, 2, 5, 7 to 18 of the said replication
and the rejoinder of the petitioner so far as the said paragraphs
are very much necessary.
According to the learned senior
counsel, filing of the rejoinder in reply to the replication is
necessary in order to avoid any procedural lapses and other
legal difficulties.
Hence, the petitioner has filed the present
miscellaneous case allowing him to file the rejoinder to the
replication of the first respondent.
6.
Drawing this Court’s attention to Order 8, Rule 9
CPC, learned senior counsel submitted that the said provision
gives ample powers to this Court to allow the election petitioner
to file rejoinder to the subsequent pleading of the first
respondent and the learned senior counsel also relied upon the
following decisions in support of his arguments:
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
Page |5
(i)
Gorantla
Kondalarayudu
v.
Marvel
Organics, rep. by its Partners, Chirala,
1997 Legal Eagle (AP) 767.
(ii) Malgireddy
Venkata
Ramana
v.
Thippana Narsi Reddy, 2010 Legal Eagle
(AP) 153.
(iii) P.Saraswathi v. C.Subramaniam, AIR
2014 Madras 50.
(iv) Shreenath and another v. Rajesh and
others, AIR 1998 SC 1827.
(v) Rani Kusum v. Kanchan Devi and
others, (2005) 6 SCC 705.
7.
Per contra, Mr. Ajoy Pebam, the learned counsel
for the first respondent submitted that paragraphs 1, 2, 5 7 to 18
of the replication dated 28.11.2022 filed in M.C.No.111 of 2022
are explanation/clarification and amplification of the earlier
pleading made. Moreover, the election petition is being filed
just for the sake to harass the first respondent, as after being
rejected by the public in the 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly
Election, the petitioner is looking for a chance to point out on
technicality thereby basing on some baseless issues. As such,
there is no point of entertaining the present miscellaneous case.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
Page |6
8.
The learned counsel further submitted that there is
no such provision under Code of Civil Procedure or the
Representation of People Act for filing rejoinder to the
replication and, moreover, there is no requirement for filing
further rejoinder in reply to the replication dated 28.11.2022.
9.
According to the learned counsel, the petitioner is
trying to amend the written objection by inserting so many new
facts in his rejoinder which are not permissible under law and if
the petitioner desires to bring new facts, he could file
amendment application instead of filing rejoinder. Only to fill up
the lacuna, the present miscellaneous case has been filed,
which is not permissible under law.
Therefore, the present
miscellaneous case is liable to be dismissed.
10.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
11.
The petitioner seeks permission of this Court to file
a rejoinder to the replication filed by the first respondent, as the
rejoinder is very much necessary. The petitioner states that
there are many facts which are very much required to be
answered by giving proper explanation by filing a rejoinder,
more particularly, paragraphs 1, 2, 5, 7 to 18 of the replication
filed by the first respondent.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
Page |7
12.
It is apposite to mention that pleas taken in the
replication is part of pleadings and, therefore, the averments
made in the replication unless replied may be considered as
admitted.
13.
Order 8, Rule 9 of the CPC gives ample powers to
the Court to allow the applicant to file rejoinder to the
replication/subsequent pleading of the opposite party. Order 8,
Rule 9 deals with subsequent pleadings. It states as follows:
“No pleading subsequent to the written
statement of a defendant other than by way
of defence to a set-off or counter-claim shall
be presented except by the leave of the court
and upon such terms as the court thinks fit.
But the court may at any time require a
written
statement
or
additional
written
statement from any of the parties and fix a
time for presenting the same.”
14.
Pending Election Petition, the first respondent filed
M.C.No.111 of 2022 to reject the election petition under Order
7, Rule 11(a) CPC where the petitioner has filed his written
objection
dated
28.9.2022.
The
first
respondent
filed
M.C.No.212 of 2022 in M.C.No.111 of 2022 under Order 8,
Rule 9 CPC for granting leave to file subsequent pleading to the
written objection dated 28.9.2022 of the petitioner. M.C.No.212
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
Page |8
of 2022 was allowed by this Court under order dated 16.5.2023
and the replication filed by the first respondent to the written
objection dated 28.9.2022 of the petitioner has been received
by this Court.
15.
The specific plea of the petitioner is that in
paragraphs 1 and 2 of the replication of the first respondent
contain facts which are not the answer to the written objection
of the petitioner. Further, in paragraph 5 of his replication, the
first respondent has pleaded so many facts which are in
addition to the answer of paragraph 2 of the written objection
filed by the petitioner. Further, in paragraphs 7 to 18 of the
replication, the first respondent has given many facts in addition
to the answers of statements of the petitioner made in
paragraphs 2 to 24 of his written objection. Therefore, proper
replies/explanations on the side of the petitioner are very much
required.
16.
In Gorantla Kondalarayudu, supra, the Andhra
Pradesh High Court held thus:
“(4) Order 8, Rule 9 of C.P.C. should not be
confused by reading together that it permits only
additional written statement by way of pleadings.
Because the expression used therein is ‘that no
pleading’ subsequent to written statement shall
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
Page |9
be filed meaning thereby both plaint and written
statement.
Pleadings shall mean plaint and
written statement as per order 6 rule 1 C.P.C. In
that context, the
pleadings and additional
pleadings in order 8 rule 9 include the additional
plaint also which can be either called as
rejoinder or the reply in its real consequences.”
17.
The learned counsel for the first respondent
contended that the petitioner desires to bring new facts and,
therefore, the petitioner could file amendment application
instead of filing rejoinder.
18.
In Malgireddy Venkata Ramana, supra, the Andhra
Pradesh High Court held as under:
“8. In Sri Gavi Matt Samsthanams case (supra), it
has bene held that Rule 9 of Order 8 CPC
specifically
provides
for
filing
subsequent
pleadings by any of the parties with the leave of
the Court.
9. In S.Venkata Ramanaiah’s case 9supra), it has
been observed as hereunder:
“It is needless to say that Order VI, Rule 1 of the
Code dealing with pleadings reads pleading
shall mean plaint or written statement. Instead
of filing an application praying for amendment of
plaint under Order VI, Rule 17 of the Code, may
be the first respondent/plaintiff was advised to
file the present application under Order VIII,
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
P a g e | 10
Rule 9 to put in subsequent pleadings by way of
rejoinder.”
19.
Thus, as per the decision in the case of Venkata
Ramanaiahs, reported in (2009 (5) ALD 211) referred in
Malgireddy Venkata Ramana, supra, the subsequent pleadings
by way of rejoinder is permissible instead of filing an application
for amendment of the petition.
20.
In P.Saraswathy, supra, the Madras High Court
held thus:
“12. Under Order 8 Rule 9 C.P.C. wide discretion
was given to the Court to give a chance to the
parties to agitate their right even by raising
subsequent pleas. Moreover, no restriction was
imposed with regard to the receiving of additional
written statement under Order 8, Rule 9 C.P.C.
after commencement of the trial like in the case
of amending the plaint under Order 6, Rule 17
C.P.C. where unless the Court comes to the
conclusion that in spite of due diligence, the party
could have not raised the matter before the
commandment of the trial.
…….. Keeping the
dictum laid down in the above judgment, I am of
the view that under Order 8 Rule 9, C.P.C. wide
discretion is given to the Court to receive the
written statement or additional written statement
to give opportunity to the parties to agitate the
case effectively.
Therefore, the rigid principle
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
P a g e | 11
applicable in the case of amendment of plaint
under Order 6 Rule 17, C.P.C. cannot be applied
in the case of receiving additional written
statement under Order 8 Rule 9, C.P.C. ……”
21.
It is well settled that the primary object of
subsequent pleading is to supply what has been omitted
inadvertently or unintentionally or to deny or clarify the facts
stated in the pleadings of the opposite party. In the rejoinder
the plaintiff can be permitted to explain the additional facts,
which have been incorporated in the written statement.
22.
There is no dispute that “replication” is the
plaintiff’s answer to the defendant’s plea and “rejoinder” is the
defendant’s answer to the plaintiff’s replication. Black’s Law
Dictionary, 6th Edition, defines “replication” as pleading in
common law made by the plaintiff in an answer to the
defendant’s plea; and “rejoinder” as a second pleading in
common law on the part of the defendant being his answer to
the plaintiff’s replication.
23.
Though the first respondent contended that the
election petition itself is filed just for the sake to harass the first
respondent as after being rejected by the public and that the
petitioner is looking for a chance to point out on technicality
based on the baseless issues and, as such, there is no point in
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
P a g e | 12
entertaining the present petition, the merits of the main election
petition cannot be gone into at this stage.
24.
As stated supra, the pleadings and additional
pleadings, includes the additional plaint also which can be
either called as rejoinder or the reply to its real consequences.
In the case on hand, the first respondent has been permitted to
file replication to the written objection of the petitioner dated
28.9.2022 filed in M.C.No.111 of 2022.
The petitioner now
sought to file a rejoinder to the replication dated 28.11.2022
filed by the first respondent, more particularly to give
explanations to paragraphs 1, 2, 5, 7 to 18 of the said
replication.
25.
The law is well settled that the plaintiff cannot be
permitted to raise a new plea under the garb of filing
rejoinder/replication or take a plea inconsistent to the pleas
taken by him in the plaint, nor the rejoinder can be filed as a
matter of right, even the Court can grant leave only after
applying its mind on the pleas taken in the plaint and the written
statement.
26.
On examination of the entire materials on record, it
is clear that the first respondent was permitted to file a
replication
vide
order
dated
16.5.2023.
Thereafter,
on
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
P a g e | 13
12.6.2023
itself,
the
petitioner
has
filed
the
miscellaneous case permitting him to file a rejoinder.
present
Thus,
there is no delay on the part of the petitioner in filing the present
miscellaneous case.
Since the pleadings and additional
pleadings under Order 8, Rule 9 CPC include the additional
plaint which can be either called as rejoinder or reply in its real
consequence, there is no bar in filing the rejoinder by the
petitioner to the replication dated 28.11.2022, as the rejoinder is
the answer by way of explanation to the statement made by the
first respondent in the replication.
27.
Since the provision of Order 8, Rule 9 CPC being
a procedural law, the same is to advance the cause of justice
and any interpretation which eludes or frustrates the recipient of
justice is not to be followed. If the rejoinder of the petitioner is
received, no prejudice would be caused to the first respondent.
The argument of the first respondent that there is no such
provision
under
the
Code
of
Civil
Procedure
or
the
Representation of People Act for filing rejoinder to the
replication and moreover, there is no requirement for filing
rejoinder in reply to the replication cannot be countenanced.
28.
For all the reasons stated above, this Court is of
the view that no new facts brought in his pleading by way ,
rejoinder; the petitioner is not trying to fill up the lacuna of his
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
P a g e | 14
case and therefore, the present petition is bona fide one and, in
the interest of justice, the same is liable to be allowed.
29.
In the result,
(i)
M.C.(El.Pet.)No.36 of 2023 in M.C.
(El.Pet.)
No.111
of
in
El.
Petn.No.10 of 2022 is allowed.
(ii)
The petitioner is permitted to file a
rejoinder to the replication of the first
respondent dated 28.11.2022.
(iii)
There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
MC(El.Pet.) No. 36 of 2023 (Ref:- 1) MC(El.Pet.) No. 111 of 2022 and 2) El. Petn.
10 of 2022))
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review