Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:3309
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
CWPOA
No.6702
of
a/w CWPOA Nos.7894, 7897,
7898, 7901, 7929, 7931 and
7933 of 2019, CWP No.1203 of
2020 Execution Petition No.503
of 2023 and CWP No.12116 of
Decided on: 09.01.2026.
________________________________________________________
CWPOA No.6702 of 2020
1.
Ramesh Chand and Others
...Petitioners
Versus
2.
State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others
CWPOA No.7894 of 2019
Mansa Ram
...Respondents
...Petitioner
Versus
3.
State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others
CWPOA No.7897 of 2019
Mohan Singh
...Respondents
...Petitioner
Versus
4.
State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others
CWPOA No.7898 of 2019
Mor Dass
...Respondents
...Petitioner
Versus
5.
State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others
CWPOA No.7901 of 2019
Brij Lal
...Respondents
...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others
...Respondents
-2-
6.
CWPOA No.7929 of 2019
Ramesh Chand
2026:HHC:3309
...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others
7.
CWPOA No.7931 of 2019
Sita Ram
...Respondents
...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others
8.
CWPOA No.7933 of 2019
Jia Lal
...Respondents
...Petitioner
Versus
9.
State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others
CWP No.1203 of 2020
Madan Mohan Singh
...Respondents
...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others
...Respondents
10. Execution Petition No.503 of 2023
in CWP No.7040 of 2021
Krishnu Ram
...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others
...Respondents
Kulbir Singh
...Petitioner
11. CWP No.12116 of 2024
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
...Respondents
& Others
______________________________________________________
-3-
2026:HHC:3309
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge
1Whether approved for reporting?. Yes.
For the petitioner:
Ms.
Manisha
Thamta,
Advocate,
for
the
petitioner
in
CWPOA
No.6702 of 2020.
Mr. Neel Kamal Sood, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Amir
Khan and Ms. Divya Jyoti,
Advocates, for the petitioners
in CWPOA Nos.7894, 7897,
7898 [since deceased], 7901,
7929, 7931 and 7933 of
2019.
Mr. A.K. Sharma, Advocate,
for the petitioner(s) in CWP
No.1203 of 2020.
Mr. S.K. Pandey, Advocate,
for
the
petitioner
in
Execution Petition No.503 of
2023.
Mr.
Bhim
Raj
Sharma,
Advocate,
for
the
petitioner(s)
in
CWP
No.12116 of 2024.
For the respondents:
Mr.
Sumit
Sharma,
Deputy Advocate General, for
the
respondents-State,
in
respective petitions.
Mr. Lokender Paul Thakur,
Senior Panel Counsel, for the
Respondent-Accountant
General, in the respective
petitions, except in CWP
No.1203 of 2020 and CWP
No.12116 of 2024.
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
-4-
2026:HHC:3309
Mr. Rangil Singh, Advocate,
for
the
RespondentAccountant General in CWP
No.1203 of 2020 and CWP
No.12116 of 2024.
Ranjan Sharma, Judge [Oral]
Petitioner, Ramesh Chand, along with 09
others, had filed Original Application No. 1648 of
2019 before the State Administrative Tribunal and,
upon abolition of the Tribunal, the matter came to be
re-transferred to this Court as CWPOA No. 6702 of
2020.
2.
Likewise, the petitioners, namely, Mansa
Ram, Mohan Singh, Mor Dass, Brij Lal, Ramesh
Chand,
Sita
Ram
and
Jia
Lal
had
filed
had
filed Original Applications Nos.1648 of 2019, 3480 of
2016, 3481 of 2016, 3482 of 2016, 3483 of 2016,
3484 of 2016, 3486 of 2016 and 3485 of 2016,
before the State Administrative Tribunal and upon
abolition
of
Tribunal,
the
matters
came
to
be
re-transferred to this Court as CWPOA No.7894,
7897, 7898, 7901, 7929, 7931 and 7933 of 2019,
respectively.
3.
With the consent of Learned Counsel(s)
-5-
2026:HHC:3309
since issue relates to re-fixation of pay and recovery
of retirees as well as in service employes, therefore,
CWPOA
No.6702
of
[originating
from
OA
No.1648 of 2019, titled Ramesh Chand & Others
versus State of Himachal Pradesh & Others] is
treated as the lead case for adjudicating all the
connected cases.
FACTUAL
2020:
4.
MATRIX
Petitioner,
IN
CWPOA
NO.6702
OF
Ramesh
Chand,
had
filed
Original Application No.1648 of 2019, converted as
CWPOA No.6702 of 2020, seeking the following
relief(s):
“i. That
the
Respondents
may
kindly
be
directed to cancel and held void the Office
Order No.PW-ED-CB-EA-II-Pay Fixation/
2018-19-7039-43,
7069-73
Dated
7069-73,
27.03.2019
7074-78,
and
other
similar orders issued on the same date
specifically addressed to all the present
Applicants in pursuance to the order of
recovery vide office order No.6897-6902
dated 23.03.2019, whereby the orders of
recovery
consequent
upon
the
revised
fixation made by the Respondent No.3
were passed in contravention to the well
established legal principles as well as in
contravention to the directions passed by
-6-
2026:HHC:3309
the Hon’ble Apex Court from time to
time.”
4(i).
Case as set up by Learned Counsel for the
petitioner, is that the petitioners are working as
technicians
[Technician
Grade-II
and
Technician
Grade-I] under the Public Works Department of the
State Government. They were initially engaged on
daily wage basis and were regularized on different
dates w.e.f. 1994 onwards. It is further averred that
the
petitioners
were
granted
the
benefit
of
promotions as Technician Grade-II and thereafter as
Technician Grade-I on different dates from 2002 to
2019.
4(ii).
It is averred that while the petitioners were
working as Technicians, the State Authorities notified
the
Assured
Career
Progression
Scheme
on
09.08.2012, giving effect to the said Scheme w.e.f.
27.08.2009, whereby progression incentives were to
be granted on completion on 4, 9 & 14 years of
service in a cadre. Based on the ACP Scheme,
notified on 09.08.2012, the State Government issued
a Communication dated 07.07.2014 [Annexure A-2]
reiterating the admissibility of benefits under the
-7-
2026:HHC:3309
Scheme.
4(iii).
It is averred that on the ACP Scheme
notified on 09.08.2012, State Authorities granted the
benefit of ACP benefits on completion of 4, 9 & 14
years of service to the petitioners and benefit of
higher pay was extended/granted to them and some
of the petitioners retired on different dates between
30.04.2019
and
31.03.2025,
while
some
of
the
petitioners are still in service.
4(iv).
It
is
averred
that
abruptly,
the
State
Authorities issued an order on 23.03.2019 [Annexure
R-3], with the Reply-Affidavit, whereby the ACP
benefits
and
progression
incentives
granted
on
completion of 4, 9 & 14 years of service to the
petitioners as in the cadre of Technicians was
withdrawn/revised leading to re-fixation of pay and
the recovery also.
It is in this backdrop that the petitioners
have
come
up
before
this
Court,
assailing
the
re-fixation order dated 23.03.2019 [Annexure R-3]
and the resultant-orders issued for effecting recovery
of excess amount given to the petitioners due to
-8-
2026:HHC:3309
wrongful release of ACP benefits.
4(v).
It is averred that petitioners are Class-III
employees and, therefore, recovery from Class-III
employees is contrary to law in view of the judgment
Rafiq Masih and the recovery beyond five years and
that to without any misrepresentation or fraud on the
part of the petitioners was also uncalled for.
It is in this backdrop that orders dated
23.03.2019 [Annexure R-3] and resultant recovery
orders dated 27.03.2019 [Annexure A-1, Colly] have
been assailed in instant petition and connected
cases.
STAND OF STATE AUTHORITIES IN REPLYAFFIDAVIT:
5.
Pursuant to the issuance of notice on
25.04.2019, the State Authorities were directed to file
a Reply-Affidavit and the recovery in pursuance to
the Office Order dated 27.03.2019 [Annexure A-1] was
stayed.
5(i).
Perusal of the Reply-Affidavit indicates that
petitioners along with 56 other incumbents were
granted the benefit of ACP on 11.07.2013 [Annexure
R-1] in contravention of Instructions issued by the
-9-
2026:HHC:3309
Finance Department. Reply-Affidavit further indicates
that as per the Instructions issued by the Finance
Department on 07.07.2014 [Annexure A-2] the ACP
benefits were not admissible to the category of
Technicians i.e. petitioners herein.
5(ii).
Reply-Affidavit further indicates that after
the superannuation of some of the Technicians and
while processing the cases for retiral benefits, the
factum of non-admissibility of ACP benefits came to
light. It is in this backdrop that the Reply-Affidavit
states that revised fixation orders dated 23.03.2019
[Annexure R-3] and resultant recovery orders dated
27.03.2019 [Annexure A-1, Colly] were issued. ReplyAffidavit further indicates that after noticing the
factum of inadmissibility of ACP benefits, the Review
DPC was held and thereafter the orders of re-fixation
of pay and recovery of the petitioners and other
incumbents were issued, in terms of order dated
27.03.2019 [Annexure A-1, Colly].
5(iii).
Reply-Affidavit further indicates that once
the pay of an employee was fixed then, the said
fixation was subject to verification by the audit and
- 10 -
2026:HHC:3309
the overpayment, if any, was liable to be recovered
from the concerned official in Lump sum. ReplyAffidavit further indicates that as per Annexure R-5
the alleged recovery of overpayment on account of
wrongful extension of ACP benefits ranges from
₹40,000/- to ₹50,000/- in case of petitioners also.
It is in this backdrop, prayer is made for
dismissal of the writ petition.
NO REBUTTAL BY PETITIONER:
6.
Petitioners have not filed any rebuttal to
the Reply-Affidavit. However, it is contended by
Learned Counsel for the petitioners that even if the
ACP
benefits
were
not
admissible
in
case
of
petitioners who were Technicians still the recovery
could not be ordered/affected from them by giving a
complete go by to the statutory Rules and the
mandate of law in the case of Syed Abdul Qadir
versus State of Bihar, (2009) 3 SCC 475; ITC
Limited Versus State of Uttar Pradesh and Others,
(2011) 7 SCC 493; Thomas Daniel versus State of
Kerala and Others, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 536;
Jagdish Prasad Singh versus State of Bihar and
- 11 -
2026:HHC:3309
Others, Civil Appeal No(s).1635 of 2013; State of
Punjab and Others versus Rafiq Masih, 2015 (4)
SCC
334,
Jogeswar
Sahoo
and
Others
versus
District Judge, Cuttack and Others, 2025 SCC
OnLine
SC
Development
Panchayat
and
Department
and
&
Rural
Others
versus
Santosh Kumar Shrivastava, 2025 SCC OnLine SC
2042.
7.
Heard
Ms.
Manisha
Thampta,
for
the
petitioners, in the Lead case, along with Mr. Neel
Kamal Sood, Learned Senior Counsel, assisted by
Ms. Divya Jyoti and Mr. Amir Khan, Advocates, for
the petitioners in other connected matters; Mr. Sumit
Sharma, Learned Deputy Advocate General, for the
respondent–State; Mr. A.K. Sharma, Mr. S.K. Pandey
and Mr. Bhim Raj Sharma, Learned Counsel for the
petitioners
in
their
respective
cases;
and
Mr. Lokender Paul Thakur, Learned Senior Panel
Counsel,
for
the
respondents
in
his
respective
petitions, and perused the material available on
record.
8.
During the course of hearing, Learned State
- 12 -
2026:HHC:3309
Counsel relied upon the Judgment passed by this
Court in Ramesh Chand versus State of Himachal
Pradesh & Ors., CWPOA No.6192 of 2020, decided
on 02.12.2024, dealing with both the issues firstly,
as to whether the ACP benefits were admissible to the
Junior
Technicians,
Technician
Grade-II
and
Technician Grade-I and secondly, as to whether the
excess amount released due to wrong application of
ACP could be recovered stands answered by this
Court, mandating that the ACP benefits were not
admissible to Technicians in terms of the Pay Rules
and ACP Scheme and due to inadmissibility of ACP
benefits dehors the Rules/Scheme the withdrawal of
ACP benefit was upheld for reason that these benefits
could not be extended dehors the Rules/Scheme.
9.
So
far
as
recovery
is
concerned,
the
recovery orders were quashed by this Court by taking
into account the mandate of judgments passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih, Thomas
Daniel and Jagdish Prasad Singh.
10.
Faced with the above situation, Learned
Counsel for the petitioners does not dispute the
- 13 -
2026:HHC:3309
mandate of this Court in the case of Ramesh Chand
(supra). On instructions, the petitioners fairly admit
that they do not intend to assail-pursue refixation
orders dated 23.03.2019 [Annexure R-3], whereby, the
ACP benefits wrongly given were withdrawn by the
State. Learned Counsel(s) further submit that only
surviving grievance is with respect to recovery, which
is intended to be affected from the petitioners, on the
basis of [Annexure R-3] dated 23.03.2019 and the
consequential order dated 27.03.2019 [Annexure A-1,
Colly].
10(i).
So
inadmissibility
far
as
of
ACP
the
issue
regarding
to
Technicians
benefits
[Junior Technician, Technician Grade-II, Technician
Grade-I] is concerned, the same stand adjudicated in
the judgment, in the case of Ramesh Chand (supra),
which reads as under:“ANALYSIS ON CLAIM [A]:
WITHDRAWAL OF ACPS ON 03.10.2018,
18.10.2018 & 29.10.2018 [ANNEXURE A-5
TO A7]:
10.
Taking
into
account
the
entirety
of
the
facts and circumstances and the Himachal
Pradesh Civil Services [Revised Pay] Rules
dated 01.09.1998 and the New Assured Career
Progression
Scheme
dated
09.08.2012
- 14 [Annexure
the
2026:HHC:3309
A-3],
considered
petitioner
for
03.10.2018,
this
view,
Court
is
of
prayer
of
the
that
quashing
of
18.10.2018
orders
and
dated
29.10.2018
[Annexure A-5 to A-8] after completion of 4, 9
and 14 years of service as Technician [GradeII] [Mechanical-cum-Fitter] and in refixing the
pay
of
petitioner
does
not
calls
for
any
interference, for following reasons :HPCS [REVISED PAY] RULES:
GRANTING THREE TIER PAY STRUCTURE
TO TECHNICIAN PETITIONER
10(i). The State notified the Himachal Pradesh Civil
Services Revised Pay Rules on 01.09.1998,
providing that the Skilled and Semi-Skilled
Technicians
in
each
trade
i.e.(i)
Junior
Technicians, (ii) Technician-Grade-II; and (iii)
Technician Grade-I, would be given three tier
higher pay structure of Rs.3120-5160; Rs.
4020-6200
&
Rs.4550-7220,
50:30:20
w.e.f.
in
01.01.1996.
ratio
of
These
Revised Pay Rules provided that 50% posts
would be of Technicians [Junior Technicians]
at entry level in pay scale of Rs.3120-5160;
and next 30% posts would be for Technicians
Grade-II in the higher pay scale of Rs.40206200; and remaining 20% posts would be of
Technicians Grade-I, in the next higher pay
scale
of
Rs.4550-7220
in
the
cadre
of
Technicians w.e.f. 07.01.1996 onwards. After
the
revision
of pay
scales, vide
Himachal
Pradesh [Revised Pay] Rules dated 26.08.2009
w.e.f.
01.01.2006,
the
pay
scales
of
Technicians [Junior Technicians; Technicians
Grade II and Technicians Grade I] were granted
revised
pay
scales
by
way
of
conversion.
Petitioner, Ramesh Chand, in the instant case
- 15 was
treated
as
2026:HHC:3309
Technician
[Mechanic-cum-
Fitter] w.e.f. 01.01.1994 and the petitioner was
given placement in the next higher pay band
by the respondents w.e.f. 01.06.2010 [as is
borne
out from Serial No.5 in [Annexure A-4].
OLD ACPS AND NEW ACPS:
NOT
APPLICABLE
TO
PETITIONER
10(ii). In
addition
Revised
Pay
to
the
Himachal
Rules
dated
Respondents
notified
the
Progression
Scheme
applicable
w.e.f.
TECHNICIAN:
Pradesh
01.09.1998,
Assured
dated
01.01.1996
the
Career
15.12.1998
and
after
the
revision of pay scales on 26.08.2009 w.e.f.
01.01.2006 the respondents notified the New
ACPS
dated
09.08.2012
[Annexure
A-3],
applicable w.e.f. 27.08.2009.
Perusal
of
the
Old
ACPS
dated
15.12.1998 and New ACPS dated 09.08.2012
reveals that the benefits of higher pay/higher
grade pay under Old ACPS of 1998 and New
ACPS of 2012 was not available to those
categories of government employees, who have
been allowed three or more trade structure of
pay scales. Meaning thereby, that benefits
under
Old
ACPS
and
even
under
New
ACPS were not available to those categories of
employees, who were allowed/presented the
three or more pay structure of pay scales. The
categories who were allowed three or more tier
pay
scales
applicable
under
the
Revised
w.e.f.
01.01.1996
Pay
Rules
and
w.e.f.
01.01.2006 were not at all eligible for any
benefits [either of higher scale/increments/
higher grade pay under the Old ACPS of 1998
[applicable w.e.f. 01.01.1996] or under the New
ACPS of 2012 [applicable w.e.f. 27.08.2009].
- 16 -
2026:HHC:3309
NON-APPLICABILITY OF OLD ACPS & NEW
ACPS TO TECHNICIANS:
10(iii). As a sequel to Para 10(i)& (ii), admittedly, the
Respondent-State
Authorities
have
allowed
prescribed the Three Tier Pay Scales to the
category
of
Technicians
[Skilled
&
Semi-
Skilled] of Rs.3120-5160 to 50% posts; then,
the higher scale of Rs.4020-6200 to 30% posts
and
thereafter
Rs.4550-7220
the
to
next
higher
remaining
20%
scale
of
posts
in
every cadre of Technicians w.e.f. 01.01.1996.
The
above
Three
Tier
Pay
Structure
was
prescribed to Technicians by virtue of HPCS
[RP] Rules dated 26.08.2009 [applicable w.e.f.
01.01.2006] and by way of conversion even in
the corresponding revised pay scales w.e.f.
01.01.2006 onwards. Thus, once as per the
Revised Pay Rules applicable w.e.f. 01.01.1996
and w.e.f. 01.01.2006, once the category of
Technicians [alike the petitioner] were granted
the Three Tier Pay Structure therefore, such
Technicians [alike petitioner] on having been
allowed/prescribed
the
Three
Tier
Pay
Structure were not at all eligible and were
specifically excluded from the purview and
applicability of the benefits under the Old and
New ACP Schemes.
PRESCRIPTION
OF
THREE
TIER
PAY
STRUCTURE UNDER HPSC [REVISED PAY]
FOR
PETITIONER-TECHINICIANS:
DISENTITLES HIM FOR ACPS:
10(iv). Even on facts of instant case, the petitioner
was
treated/regularized
as
Technicians
[Mechanical-cum-Fitter] w.e.f. 01.01.1994 in
the pay scale of Rs.3120-5160 i.e. entry grade.
Thereafter, the petitioner was granted next
higher
pay
scale
of
Rs.4020-6200
w.e.f.
- 17 -
2026:HHC:3309
01.06.2010 [against Serial No.5 in Annexure A4], in terms of Himachal Pradesh Civil Services
[Revised Pay] Rules of 2009 [applicable w.e.f.
01.01.2006]. Thus, once the petitioner was
governed by the Three Tier Pay Structure as
per
the
Revised
Pay
Rules, therefore,
the
petitioner could not be eligible for benefits
under Old as well as New ACPS.
EXPRESS
OUSTER
FROM
DISENTITLES
PETITIONER
FOR
LEADING TO ERRONEOUS RELEASE:
ACPS
ACP:
10(v). Once the pay of the petitioner was regulated by
the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services [Revised
Pay] Rules notified on 01.09.1998 [applicable
w.e.f. 01.01.1996], prescribing the Three Tier
Pay Structure in the ratio of 50:30:20, which
continued on further revision by virtue of
Himachal Pradesh [Revised Pay] Rules dated
26.08.2009 applicable w.e.f. 01.01.2006 by
way of conversion in the corresponding revised
scales in ratio of 50:30:20 and having been
prescribed
Three
Tier
Pay
Structure;
the
petitioner was not to be granted benefits under
Old ACPS dated 15.12.1998 and also the New
ACPS dated 09.08.2012 [Annexure A-3] being
an ousted category; then, the express-ouster of
the petitioner from Old and New ACPS cannot
confer any right on the petitioner for higher
pay under ACPS, dehors the ACP Scheme.
INELIGIBLY DISENTITLES PETITIONER FOR
ACP BENEFITS:
10(vi). The State Authorities have allowed Three Tier
Pay Structure as per the Revised Pay Rules of
1998 and Revised Pay Rules of 2006 [as
applicable w.e.f. 01.01.1996 & 01.01.2006] for
the category of Technician(s) [i.e. Technician,
Technician Grade-II and Technician Grade-I,
- 18 with
the
2026:HHC:3309
entry
higher
scale
scale
and
then,
and
higher
scale],
next
therefore, in view of the prescription of Three
Tier Pay Scales i.e. Higher Scales, the category
of Technician(s) were treated as Ineligible for
benefits of Old ACP Scheme of 1998 [applicable
w.e.f. 01.01.1996 i.e. higher pay scale and
proficiency increments on completion of 8, 16,
24 and 32 years service] and the Technicians
were Ineligible for benefits of New ACP Scheme
of 2012 [as applicable w.e.f. after 4, 9 and 14
years service; therefore, the petitioner being
ineligible cannot claim benefits dehors the Old
and New ACP Schemes. Thus, the ineligibility
of petitioner, in view of the “Ouster Clause (i)
in Old ACPS and New ACPS”, ex-facie reveals
that
ACPS
benefits
erroneously
extended
were
wrongly
and
to
petitioner
on
the
07.08.2013 [Annexure A-4], which were validly
withdrawn
by
the
State
03.10.2018
[Annexure
A-5]
Authorities
and
on
therefore,
these orders and the consequential orders
dated
18.10.2018
[Annexure
A-6]
and
29.10.2018 [Annexure A-7], do not suffer from
any illegality or infirmity.
NO VESTED RIGHT FOR BENEFITS DEHORS
ACP SCHEME:
10(vii). Petitioner
can
neither
claim
any
benefit
nor any vested right is available to him, to
claim benefits under Old ACPS as well as New
ACPS, in view of his ineligibility, as per the
Ouster Clause (i) of these Schemes Ineligibility
carved under the Rules/Schemes, qua the
petitioner, is valid basis, for withdrawing the
benefits of ACP Scheme, which were extended
dehors the express intent and stipulation in
Rules/Schemes.
Thus,
the
ACP
benefits
- 19 -
2026:HHC:3309
granted/extended
to
petitioner
dehors
the
Rules/Schemes, resulting in refixation of pay
[without permitting recovery as in later part of
this judgment], is legal and valid.
10(viii). Plea
of
Learned
Counsel
for
petitioner
is
that the State Authorities have extended the
benefit of New ACPS dated 27.09.2012, on
completion of 4, 9 and 14 year service on
07.08.2013 [Annexure A-4], then, the said
benefit(s) cannot be withdrawn on 03.10.2018
[Annexure
A-5]
and
like
orders
dated
18.10.2018 and 29.10.2018 illegally, when, the
benefits
granted
under
ACPS
were
more
beneficial to the petitioner.
The above contention of Learned Counsel
for petitioner is without any merit, for the
reason, that merely because the petitioner
considers the release of benefits under ACPS to
be beneficial is no ground, to permit the
petitioner to enjoy benefits, dehors the ACP
Scheme
and
when,
the
petitioner
is ineligible and his category [who have already
been allowed Three Tier Pay Structure], has
been excluded from the ACP Scheme. Pay
fixation and formulation of ACP Schemes are
complex matters which primarily fall within the
domain
of
Commission
expert
bodies
i.e.
the
Pay
and
the
experts
in
the
government. An employee, alike the petitioner
has neither any vested right nor any locus to
assert that the ACP Scheme being beneficial
vis-à-vis
Three
Tier
Pay
Scale
may
be
continued for the petitioner, is misconceived as
the application of the ACP Schemes cannot be
left at the mercy of employees, so as to render
such policies impracticable. Insisting for a
particular benefit under a ACP Rule/Scheme
- 20 dehors
the
2026:HHC:3309
mandate,
intent
and
other
conditions contained in such scheme/Rules
and by ignoring the “Exclusion-Ouster Clause”
contained in Old & New ACP Schemes, will not
in any manner confer any vested or legal right
on petitioner-employee who was not eligible for
higher pay benefits under either the Old ACPS
dated 15.12.1998 or under the New ACPS
dated 09.08.2012. No vested right is violated
for
denying
ACP
benefits
which
are
inadmissible under the Scheme, in terms of the
mandate of Hon’ble Three Judge Bench of the
Supreme Court, In re: The Vice Chairman
Delhi Development Authority Versus Narender
Kumar & Ors. [Civil Appeal No.1880 of 2022,
decided on 08.03.2022, in following terms :“30. This brings the court to the next point,
which is whether the employees can
assert what is termed as a vested right.
The first submission in this regard is
that according to Para 9 of the MACP
scheme, those who are in employment on
the date when MACP scheme was
brought into force and who are entitled
to the ACP benefits, especially the
second financial up-gradation had a
right to insist that their second upgradation should be granted in terms of
the ACP scheme. In this context, the
argument advanced is that Rule 9
preserves and protects such a right (for
entitlement) to be granted the ACP
benefits even after the introduction of
the MACP scheme.
37.
The myriad intricate details which the
executive has to consider, while framing
a scheme applicable generally, to a large
section of the employees, may not always
admit of one, or one set of solutions.
To insist that a particular kind of
benefit, hitherto applicable, should be
continued for a set of employees,
while the others should be governed
by another, new set or scheme, would
be imposing a significant burden on
the
administration,
apart
from
- 21 -
2026:HHC:3309
swelling financial costs as well as
administrative
energies.
Such
directions would result in creating
different
time
warps,
rendering
efficient administration of personnel
policies impracticable. Sans palpable
or facial arbitrariness, the courts should
be circumspect in adding conditions, or
tampering with such arrangements. In
Ajoy Kumar Banerjee v Union of India22
a five judge Bench of this court had
emphasized this aspect in the following
terms:
“46…. The legislature however is free to
recognise the degree of harm or evil
and to make provisions for the
same. Making dissimilar provisions
for one group of public sector
undertakings does not per se make
a law discriminatory as such. It is
well-settled that courts will not
sit as superlegislature and strike
down
a particular classification on the
ground that any under-inclusion,
namely, that some others have
been left untouched so long as
there
is
no
violation
of
constitutional restraints…… The
same principle was reiterated by
this Court in the case of State of
Gujarat v. Shri Ambica Mills Ltd.,
Ahmedabad [1974 (3) SCR 760]. In
that case, this Court was of the
view that in the matter of economic
legislation or reform, a provision
would not be struck down on the
vice of under-inclusion, inter alia,
for the reason that the legislature
could not be required to impose
upon administrative agencies task
which could not be carried out or
which must be carried out on a
large scale at a single stroke.
It was further reiterated that piece
meal approach to a general problem
permitted
by
under-inclusive
classific-ations,
is
sometimes
justified when it is considered that
legislatures
deal
with
such
problems
usually
on
an
experimental basis. It is impossible
to tell how successful a particular
approach
might
be,
what
dislocation might occur, and what
- 22 -
2026:HHC:3309
situation might develop and what
new
evil
might be generated in the attempt.
Administrative expedients must be
forged
and
tested.
Legislators
recognizing these factors might
wish
to proceed cautiously, and courts
must allow them to do so….”
This court is of the opinion that the
same considerations apply in the present
case. That, some employees could have
benefitted
more
under
the
ACP
benefits, if the MACP scheme had not
been introduced from an earlier date,
is no ground to hold so and compel an
executive agency to grant the claimed
benefits.”
In aforesaid backdrop, the contention
of Learned Counsel, is devoid of any merit and
the
Impugned
Order(s)
issued
by
the
Respondents in withdrawing the benefits of
ACP which were erroneously granted/released
dehors
the
resultant
ACP
orders
Scheme/Rules;
refixing
the
and
pay
the
[after
withdrawing ACP] so as to grant the benefits as
per
the
eligibility
and
entitlement
for
higher pay structure under the HPCS [Revised
Pay] Rules does not calls for any interference.
NO CHALLENGE TO OUSTER CLAUSES IN
ACP SCHEMES:
10(ix). Clause (i) of Old ACP Scheme dated 15.12.1998
and
New
ACP
Scheme
dated
09.08.2012
[Annexure A-3], which ousts the category of
the petitioner [Technician], for availing benefits
on completion of 4, 9 and 14 years service, for
the
reason,
that
petitioner
was
allowed/governed by three or more grade pay
structures under
01.09.1998,
Revised Pay Rules
Revised
Pay
Rules
dated
w.e.f.
01.01.2006, then, once the petitioner has not
laid a challenge to “ouster clauses”, then, in
- 23 -
2026:HHC:3309
view of the express ouster of category of
Technicians
Structure
orders
[in
view
of
presented-allowed
dated
07.08.2013
granting benefits dehors
Three
Tier
Pay
for
them],
the
[Annexure
A-3],
ACP Scheme
was
rightly withdrawn on 03.10.2018 [Annexure A5] and on 18.10.2018to 28.10.2018.
10(x).
For the reasons spelt out in preceding paras,
the challenge under ‘Claim A’, in passing an
order of withdrawing ACP benefits in terms of
impugned Orders cannot pass this test of
scrutiny. No enforceable right either exists or
is claimable contrary to the Statutory Rules or
applicable Scheme(s), therefore, the Impugned
Orders withdrawing benefits extended dehors
the Rules/ Scheme does not violate any right
of petitioner. Accordingly, the Impugned Order
dated 03.10.2018 [Annexure A-5] and orders
dated 18.10.2018 [Annexure A-6] and orders
dated 29.10.2018 [Annexure A-7] withdrawing
the
higher
grade
pay
granted
erroneously
under ACP Scheme on completion of 4, 9 and
14 years service dehors the HPCS[Revised Pay]
Rules of 1998 and 2009 [supra] and dehors the
Old ACP and New ACP Schemes of 1998 and
2012 [supra], and in recasting/refixing the pay
as per applicable Rules, needs no interference.
All these Impugned Orders are accordingly
upheld.
10(xi). Plea of petitioner is that ACP benefits were
withdrawn
in
view
of
instruction
dated
29.05.2014 [Annexure A-8] which is alleged to
be discriminatory and illegal. The above plea is
misconceived.
Once
ACP
Scheme
was
not
applicable in case of petitioner, as discussed
above, then, the issuance of instruction dated
29.05.2014 [Annexure A-8] cannot be of any
- 24 assistance
or
2026:HHC:3309
cannot
have
any
prejudicial
affect on the petitioner, whose rights and claim
for pay fixation is to be governed by HPCS
[Revised
Structure
Pay]
Rules
thereon
and
and
Three
not
by
Tier
Pay
ACPS
or
instruction clarifying ACPS which was not
applicable to the petitioner.”
11.
So far as the claim regarding recovery is
concerned, the issue also stands adjudicated by this
Court in the case of Ramesh Chand (supra), which
reads as under:“ANALYSIS ON CLAIM [B]: RECOVERY:
11.
Now
coming
to
the
question
of
recovery,
this Court is of the considered view, that the
prayer
of
the
petitioner,
for
restraining
the
respondents
from effecting recovery, carries weight and the
same is accepted, for the following reasons :11(i).
Perusal of Annexure A-4 dated 07.08.2013,
reveals that State Authorities have granted the
benefit of New ACPS i.e. 4, 9 and 14 years of
service to petitioner as Technician-Grade-II, by
wrongly applying the New ACPS, which was not
applicable to him. Even the reply-affidavit
admits that benefit of New ACPS was wrongly
extended
to
the
petitioner.
Reply-affidavit
further indicates that the petitioner enjoyed
benefit of higher grade pay under New ACPS on
completion of 4, 9 and 14 years service, till his
promotion as Junior Engineer on 03.10.2015
and
even
after
his
promotion
as
Junior
Engineer from 03.10.2015 till his retirement on
- 25 -
2026:HHC:3309
30.09.2018. Reply-Affidavit indicates that the
benefits granted on 07.08.2013 [Annexure A4], were withdrawn by Respondent No.3 on
30.10.2018 [Annexure A-5].
During the course of hearing, learned
Counsel for petitioner places on record, copy of
orders
dated
21.02.2019[taken
on
record],
whereby. after withdrawing ACP benefits, an
amount of Rs.1,51,088/- [Rupees One Lakh
Fifty One Thousand Eighty Eight] on account
of wrong fixation due to grant of ACP benefits
has been recovered the Gratuity of petitioner.
The order of recovery dated 21.02.2019 [supra]
cannot be sustained, in the eyes of law, for the
following reasons :11(ii).
Petitioner joined service as a Junior Technician
[Mechanic-cum-Fitter]
in
1994.
During
his
service, respondent extended the benefit of
New ACPS on completion of 4, 9 and 14 years
service on the basis of a communication dated
09.08.2012 [Annexure A-3], despite the fact
that petitioner was not to be governed or
regulated by this communication. Admittedly,
the petitioner was extended benefit of higher
grade pay under New ACPS, till his promotion
as
Junior
Engineer
on
03.10.2015,
till
retirement on 30.09.2018. Admittedly, once the
petitioner has neither misrepresented nor was
a party to any fraud or erroneous pay fixation,
such an eventuality, the wrong pay fixation
dated 07.08.2013 [Annexure A-4], cannot be
made the basis for effecting recovery from
petitioner, being contrary to the mandate in
Para 18(v) in the case of Rafiq Masih’s.
11(iii). Recovery
from
a
Class-III
employee,
as
a
Technician Grade-II and even Petitioner after
his promotion as Junior Engineer he continued
- 26 -
2026:HHC:3309
to be a Class-III employee since 03.10.2015 till
retirement on 13.09.2018, in terms of office
order dated 21.02.2019 [Taken on record] of
Rs.1,51,088/- [Rupees One Lakh Fifty One
Thousand Eighty Eight], from the Gratuity of
petitioner is contrary to Para 18(ii) in Rafiq
Masih, AIR 2015 SC 696and therefore the
impugned recovery cannot stand the test of
judicial scrutiny.
11(iv). Recovery
dated
21.02.2019
from
Gratuity
affected by Respondents-Executive Engineer,
Mechanical Division, HP PWD, Dhamashala,
after
having
retired
from
service
on
30.09.2018, is contrary to Para 18(ii) of the
mandate of law, in the case of Rafiq Masih
[supra].
11(v).
Since the petitioner was not a party to wrong
pay-fixation; but the higher pay was granted
erroneously due to wrong interpretation of
Rules/Schemes by the State Authorities, then
the recovery dated 21.02.2019 of the amount
of higher pay disbursed to petitioner due to
wrong
application
of
Rules/Schemes
by
respondents beyond five years from 2013 to
2018;
then
also,
the
recovery
cannot
be
effected being contrary to the mandate in Para
18(iii), in the case of Rafiq Masih [supra].
11(vi). Moreover,
on
facts
of
instant
case,
the
after retirement from Class-III employee, after
a long lapse; amounts to penalizing petitioner
for fault or inaction of respondents. Since the
petitioner
retired
attained
the
10.01.2018
on
state
then,
the
30.09.2018
of
a
and
had
pensioner
on
recovery
of
gratuity
cannot be affected on 21.02.2019 [as in Para
11(i)
of
this
judgment]
when
departmental
proceedings
nor
neither
any
any
judicial
- 27 -
2026:HHC:3309
proceedings were pending on date of retirement
and even thereafter, therefore the Impugned
recovery from gratuity, in contrary of Rule 9 of
CCS
[Pension]
Rules
and
is
certainly
iniquitous, harsh and arbitrary and thus, the
same cannot be recovered from the petitioner.
11(vii). Deprecating
the
recovery
of
the
financial
benefits extended due to wrong interpretation/
understanding of a Rule or Order, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Thomas Daniel vs State of
Kerala and Others, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 536,
has held the following terms :“12. In Syed Abdul Qadir v. State of
Bihar excess payment was sought
to be recovered which was made to
the appellants-teachers on account
of mistake and wrong interpretation
of prevailing Bihar Nationalised
Secondary
School
(Service
Conditions)
Rules,
1983.
The
appellants therein contended that
even if it were to be held that the
appellants were not entitled to the
benefit of additional increment
on
promotion,
the
excess amount should not be
recovered from them, it having
been
paid
without
any
misrepresentation or fraud on
their part. The Court held that
the appellants cannot be held
responsible in such a situation
and recovery of the excess payment
should not be ordered, especially
when
the
employee
has
subsequently retired. The court
observed that in general parlance,
recovery is prohibited by courts
where
there
exists
no
misrepresentation or fraud on the
part
of
the
employee
and
when the excess payment has
been made by applying a wrong
interpretation/ understanding of
- 28 -
2026:HHC:3309
a Rule or Order. It was held thus:
"59. Undoubtedly, the excess amount
that has been paid to the
appellant
teachers
was
not
because of any misrepresentation
or fraud on their part and the
appellants
also
had
no
knowledge that the amount that
was being paid to them was more
than what they were entitled to.
It would not be out of place to
mention here that the Finance
Department had, in its counteraffidavit, admitted that it was a
bona fide mistake on their part.
The excess payment made was
the result of wrong interpretation
of the Rule that was applicable
to them, for which the appellants
cannot be held responsible.
Rather, the whole confusion was
because of inaction, negligence
and carelessness of the officials
concerned of the Government of
Bihar.
Learned
counsel
appearing on behalf of the
appellant
teachers
submitted
that majority of the beneficiaries
have
either retired or are on the verge
of it. Keeping in View the
peculiar facts and circumstances
of the case at hand and to avoid
any hardship to the appellant
teachers, we are of the view that
no recovery of the amount that
has been paid in excess to the
appellant teachers should be
made."
13. In State of Punjab v. Rafia Masih
(White Washer)* Wherein this court
examined the validity of an order
passed by the State to recover the
monetary gains wrongly extended
to the beneficiary employees in
excess
of
their
entitlements
without
any
fault
or
- 29 -
2026:HHC:3309
misrepresentation at the behest
of the recipient. This Court
considered situations of hardship
caused to an employee, if recovery
is
directed
to
reimburse
the
employer and disallowed the same,
exempting
the
beneficiary
employees from such recovery. It
was held thus:
"8. As between two parties, if a
determination is rendered in
favour of the party, which is
the weaker of the two, without
any serious detriment to the
other (which is truly a welfare
State),
the
issue
resolved
would be in consonance with
the concept of justice, which is
assured to the citizens of
India, even in the Preamble of
the Constitution of India. The
right to recover being pursued
by the employer, will have to
be compared, with the effect of
the recovery on the employee
concerned. If the effect of the
recovery from the employee
concerned would be, more
unfair, more wrongful, more
improper,
and
more
unwarranted,
than
the
corresponding right of the
employer
to
recover
the
amount, then it would be
iniquitous and arbitrary, to
effect the recovery. In such a
situation, the employee's right
would
outbalance,
and
therefore eclipse, the right of
the employer to recover.
XXX
XXX
XXX
18. It is not possible to postulate all
situations of hardship which would
govern employees on the issue of
recovery, where payments have
mistakenly been made by the
- 30 -
2026:HHC:3309
employer,
in
excess
of
their
entitlement. Be that as it may,
based on the decisions referred to
hereinabove, we may, as a ready
reference, summarise the following
few situations, wherein recoveries
by
the
employers,
would
be
impermissible in law:
(i)
Recovery from the employees
belonging to Class III and
Class IV service (or Group C
and Group D service).
(ii)
Recovery
from
the
retired
employees, or the employees
who
are
due
to
retire
within one year, of the order
of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees,
when the excess payment has
been made for a period in
excess of five years, before
the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an
employee has wrongfully been
required to discharge duties of
a higher post, and has been
paid accordingly, even though
he should have rightfully been
required to work against an
inferior post.
(v)
In any other case, where the
court arrives at the conclusion,
that recovery if made from the
employee, would be iniquitous
or harsh or arbitrary to such
an extent, as would far
outweigh the equitable balance
of the employer's right to
recover."
14. Coming to the facts of the present
case, it is not contended before us
that
on
account
of
the
misrepresentation or fraud played
by the appellant, the excess
amounts have been paid. The
appellant
has
retired
on
- 31 -
2026:HHC:3309
31.03.1999. In fact, the case of the
respondents
is
that
excess
payment was made due to a
mistake in interpreting Kerala
Service
Rules
which
was
subsequently pointed out by the
Accountant General.
15. Having regard to the above, we are
of the view that an attempt to
recover the said increments after
passage of ten years of his
retirement is unjustified.
16. In the result, the appeal succeeds
and is accordingly allowed. The
Judgment and order of the Division
Bench dated 02.03.2009 and also
of the learned Single Judge of the
High
Court
dated
05.01.2006
impugned
herein,
and
the
order dated 26.06.2000 passed by
the Public Redressal Complaint Cell
of the Chief Minister of Kerala and
the
recovery
Notice
dated
09.10.1997 are hereby set aside.
There shall be no order as to
costs.”
11(viii). A Co-ordinate Bench of this Court has setaside similar recovery in Kishan Lal versus
State of Himachal Pradesh [CWP No. 1360 of
2023] decided on 09.11.2023.
11(ix). While dealing with a similar fact-situation the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Jagdish Prasad
Singh vs State of Bihar and Others, 2024
SCC OnLine SC 1909, decided on 08.08.2024,
has deprecated recovery made from employee
on
wrong
understanding
of
applicable
Rules/Scheme in the following terms :“22. Similarly, this Court in ITC Limited
v. State of Uttar Pradesh, held as under :“108. We may give an example from
service
jurisprudence,
where
a
principle
of
equity
is
frequently
- 32 -
2026:HHC:3309
invoked to give relief to an employee in
somewhat
similar
circumstances.
Where the pay or other emoluments
due to an employee is determined and
paid
by
the
employer,
and
subsequently
the
employer
finds,
(usually on audit verification) that
on account of wrong understanding
of the applicable rules by the officers
implementing
the
rules,
excess
payment is made, courts have
recognized the need to give limited
relief in regard to recovery of past
excess payments, to reduce hardship
to the
innocent employees, who
benefited
from
such
wrong
interpretation.”
25. The Government Resolution dated 8 th
February, 1999 to be specific, the
highlighted portion supra is amenable to
the interpretation that it protects the
status and pay of those employees who
had received their time bound promotions
prior to 31 st December, 1995. As a
consequence, the Secretary concerned,
while rejecting the representation clearly
misinterpreted and misapplied the said
Resolution to the detriment of the
appellant.
26. The learned Single Judge as well as
the Division Bench of the High Court of
Patna also seem to have fallen in the same
error. In addition thereto, we are of the
view that any step of reduction in the pay
scale and recovery from a Government
employee would tantamount to a
punitive action because the same has
drastic
civil
as
well
as
evil
consequences. Thus, no such action
could have been taken against the
appellant, more particularly, because he
had been promoted as an ADSO, while
drawing the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500
applicable to the post, way back on 10 th
March, 1991 and had also superannuated
eight years ago before the recovery notice
dated 15 th April, 2009 was issued. The
- 33 -
2026:HHC:3309
impugned action directing reduction of
pay scale and recovery of the excess
amount is grossly arbitrary and illegal and
also suffers from the vice of nonadherence to the principles of natural
justice and hence, the same cannot be
sustained.
27. The order dated 8 th October, 2009
passed by the State Government directing
reduction in the pay scale of the appellant
from Rs.6500-10500 to Rs.5500-9000
w.e.f. 1 st January, 1996 and directing
recovery of the excess amount from him is
grossly illegal and arbitrary and is hereby
quashed and set aside. The impugned
order dated 27 th August, 2012 passed by
the Division Bench of the High Court does
not stand to scrutiny and is hereby
quashed. Therefore, the appellant shall
continue to receive the pension in
accordance with the pay scale of Rs.650010500.”
Thus, the recovery cannot be effected from an
employee
due
to
wrong
interpretation
or
misapplication or wrong construction of Rules/
Schemes by an employer. Such action would
amount
to
penalizing
an
employee
for
inaction(s) of an Employer. Permitting such
recovery
shall
grant
leverage
to
the
respondents to justify their wrongs, inactions,
negligence or faults. Recovery when, petitioner
was not party to any misrepresentation or
fraud is illegal. Recovery from petitioner, a
Class-III Employee, after relevant and when,
the excess payments were made for five years;
and by passing adversarial orders without
notice/hearing
was
stigmatic,
visiting
petitioner with civil consequences. Even the
orders dated 21.02.2019, affecting recovery of
Rs.1,51,008/- [Rupees One Lakh Fifty One
Thousand Eighty Eight], from the Gratuity of
- 34 petitioner
[Pension]
in
2026:HHC:3309
violation
Rules,
departmental nor
of
Rule
when,
any
of
CCS
neither
any
criminal
proceedings
were initiated against petitioner on date of
retirement, cannot stand the test of judicial
scrutiny, when it is iniquitous. Accordingly,
the
Impugned
recovery
is
illegal,
unsustainable, arbitrary and violative of Article
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.”
12.
Even the issue as to whether the benefits
assigned to an employee due to wrong application of
Rules or wrong application or wrong interpretation of
the Rules, which subsequently turned out to be
otherwise, has also been deprecated by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Jogeswar Sahoo & Others versus
District
Judge,
Cuttack
&
Others,
SCC
OnLine SC 724, which reads as under:“11. In the case at hand, the appellants were
working on the post of Stenographers when
the subject illegal payment was made to
them. It is not reflected in the record that
such payment was made to the appellants on
account of any fraud or misrepresentation by
them. It seems, when the financial benefit was
extended to the appellants by the District
Judge, Cuttack, the same was subsequently
not
approved
by
the
High
Court
which
resulted in the subsequent order of recovery.
It is also not in dispute that the payment
was made in the year 2017 whereas the
recovery was directed in the year 2023.
- 35 -
2026:HHC:3309
However, in the meanwhile, the appellants
have retired in the year 2020. It is also an
admitted position that the appellants were not
afforded any opportunity of hearing before
issuing the order of recovery. The appellants
having superannuated on a ministerial post of
Stenographer were admittedly not holding any
gazetted post as such applying the principle
enunciated by this Court in the above quoted
judgment,
the
recovery
is
found
unsustainable.
12.
For the aforestated, we are of the considered
view that the appeal deserves to be allowed.
Accordingly, we allow the appeal and set aside
the
order
of
the
High
Court
and
in
consequence the orders dated 12.09.2023 and
08.09.2023
by
which
the
appellants were
directed to deposit the excess drawn arrears
are set aside.”
12(i).
Pertinently,
some
of
the
petitioners
in
instant case are retirees. Having retired from service
the
Impugned
Order
of
recovery
shall
certainly
dislodge the rights and interest of the retirees.
Even, Hon’ble Supreme Court in Panchayat & Rural
Development
Department
and
Others
versus
Santosh Kumar Shrivastava, 2025 SCC OnLine SC
2042, has mandated that the legal retiral benefits
like pension, gratuity and leave encashment can
neither
be
curtailed,
restricted,
withdrawn
or
- 36 -
2026:HHC:3309
recovered without authority of law. In the instant
case, nothing has been pointed out by the Learned
State Counsel that the State Authorities before
issuing the orders dated 23.03.2019 [Annexure R-3]
and
resultant
recovery
orders
dated
27.03.2019
[Annexure A-1, Colly] have complied with the mandate
of law by giving a prior notice and after affording a
personal hearing and in case the facts were disputed
after holding an inquiry in the matter.
12(ii).
Moreover, the
retiral benefits
are legal
entitlements which constitute the property under
Article 300-A of the Constitution of India. In this
backdrop, the property and the legal entitlements
could not be denied, curtailed, restricted withheld or
recovered without authority of law. Learned State
Counsel has failed to point out <any law= which
permits the recovery so as to confer a premium and
leverage on the State to effect recovery for the
inactions and negligence in wrongfully advancing the
ACP benefits which subsequently came out to be
inadmissible to the petitioners herein.
12(iii).
Deprecating the recovery from a retiree as
- 37 -
mandated
by
the
2026:HHC:3309
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
Panchayat & Rural Development Department and
Others versus Santosh Kumar Shrivastava, 2025
SCC OnLine SC 2042, reads as under:“8.
It has long been held that the payment of
retiral dues/gratuity/ pension is not a matter
of bounty but in fact a matter of right of every
employee, should there be some rule or statute
from where the right may originate.
9.
This makes it clear that the Courts below were
correct
in
holding
that
there
was
no
justification for the appellants having not paid
the dues rightly belonging to the respondent to
him even after the passage of almost three
years
after
observe
the
that
whatsoever
for
retirement.
We
there
no
the
was
may
Appellant
also
occasion
to
have
conducted re-fixation of pay after retirement
of
the
Respondent
and
then
proceed
to
recover the excess amount from the retiral
dues payable to the latter. This is a wellsettled position in law. A Bench of 3 learned
Judges in Syed Abdul Qadir v. State of Bihar….
10.
Insofar as the Appellants position that failure
to vacate is the reason that retiral dues were
not being granted to him, we fail to see the
nexus between these two aspects. ……..
11.
In essence, what the Appellants did before the
High Court was to blame the Respondent for
the delay in him receiving benefits rightly owed
to him. We cannot accept this position. Pension
and other retiral dues are benefits that have
been earned by an employee due to the service
- 38 rendered
to
2026:HHC:3309
the
institution
paying
the
pension/other retirement benefits. The grant of
a residence corresponds to the position held at
the time by such employee. The width of these
two aspects is separate and distinct. Pension
and retirement benefits accrue from a much
wider base as the culmination of all efforts,
across employment whereas the latter is only
for a limited time, till such a person is holding
that position. The latter cannot obstruct or
defeat the former. The Appellant cannot be
allowed to withhold a duly accrued right on
this count.
12.
Since the delay is entirely on part of the
Appellant,
and
no
reasonable
explanation
acceptable to law is forthcoming except for the
attempt to hold back pensionary benefits as
a sword on the Respondent’s head for not
having
vacated
his
government
allotted
accommodation, in the facts of this case we
see no error in the order of the learned single
Judge awarding interest to the Respondent.
13.
The appeal is accordingly dismissed. However,
there shall be no order as to cost.
Pending
application(s)
if
any,
shall
stand
closed.”
13.
Another
important
aspect
needs
to
be
addressed in the instant case.
13(i).
While dealing with the matter, another
aspect needs to be addressed. State Authorities have
certainly come up with different stands in respect of
similarly placed incumbents. Reference to the orders
- 39 -
2026:HHC:3309
passed by this Court on 29.10.2025 and Instructions
dated 10.0.2025 furnished by the State Authorities
indicate that this Court has passed a judgment in
CWP
No.1702
of
2024,
titled
Ashwani
Kumar
versus State of Himachal Pradesh & Others, on
25.07.2024, whereby in similar fact-situation relating
to the employees who were Technicians as in this
case, the recovery was quashed and pursuant to the
filing of Execution Petition No.394 of 2025, titled
Ashwani Kumar versus State of Himachal Pradesh
& Others, the State Authorities have admitted that
ACP benefits or higher pay was wrongly given by
mistake
of
Department
and
there
was
no
misrepresentation by the employees and therefore, it
was not a fit case to file SLP or any other proceedings
in the matter.
13(ii).
Similarly, it is also transpired that the
State Authorities have furnished Instructions to this
Court
stating
therein
that
the
issue
regarding
recovery cannot be implemented for the reason that
though the Division Bench of this Court in LPA No.
410 of 2024, titled State of Himachal Pradesh &
- 40 -
2026:HHC:3309
Others versus Krishnu Ram, on 02.12.2024 has
quashed the recovery but the SLP was pending.
The Instructions furnished by the State
that SLP was pending was not in tune with the
factual aspect at the relevant time. In view of the fact
that no SLP has in fact been filed by the State at that
particular point of time. However, subsequently, the
SLP was filed but the SLP(C) Diary No.66398 of
2025, titled State of Himachal Pradesh and Others
versus Krishnu Ram, was dismissed by the Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
on
15.12.2025,
which
reads
as
under:“Delay condoned.
2.
Having considered the matter in its entirety,
we
do
not
find
any
merit
warranting
interference by this Court. Accordingly, the
Special Leave Petition stands dismissed.
3.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.”
In this backdrop, this Court is of the
considered view that once recovery of excess amount
of ACP incentives which were erroneously released by
the Department to petitioners and other Technicians
was not recoverable and said recovery was quashed
by this Court, in the case of titled Ashwani Kumar
- 41 -
2026:HHC:3309
versus State of Himachal Pradesh & Others [CWP
No.1702 of 2024] and Ramesh Chand versus State
of Himachal Pradesh & Ors. [CWPOA No.6192 of
2020] by this Court and even the judgment in LPA
No.410 of 2024, titled State of Himachal Pradesh &
Others versus Krishnu Ram, has been upheld by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court on 15.12.2025, therefore,
this Court sees no reason for not extending the
similar benefits.
Accordingly, as per the findings recorded in
the
judgment
Ramesh
Chand
&
Krishnu
Ram
(supra), the re-fixation of pay of the petitioners as
Technicians
i.e.
[Junior
Technician,
Technician
Grade-I & Technicians Grade-II, respectively] after
withdrawing the inadmissible ACP benefits as in
[Annexure R-3, dated 23.03.2019] is upheld, but the
recovery ordered in pursuance to the re-fixation of
pay leading to recovery in case of petitioners in Lead
Case [CWPOA No.6702 of 2020],
on 27.03.2019
[Annexure A-1, Colly] is quashed and set aside.
14.
Since
connected
the
cases
is
legal
issue
involved
pari
materia,
in
all
therefore,
the
- 42 -
2026:HHC:3309
directions contained in judgment here-in-below in
Lead Case shall mutatis mutandis apply to all the
connected cases.
DIRECTIONS:
15.
In view of above discussion and for the
reasons recorded hereinabove, the instant petitions
are partly allowed in the following terms:
(i). Orders passed by State Authorities in
withdrawing the ACP benefits released to
the petitioners dehors the Pay Rules and
contrary to ACP Scheme dated 09.08.2012
is upheld, as mandated in the judgment
in Ramesh Chand and Krishnu Ram
(supra);
(ii). Orders dated 23.03.2019 [Annexure R-3]
withdrawing ACP benefits leading to refixation of pay is upheld;
(iii). Recovery
of
excess
amount
of
ACP
benefits wrongly advanced/released and
consequential adversarial recovery orders
dated 27.03.2019 [Annexure A-1, Colly],
are quashed and set aside;
(iv). State
Authorities
are
restrained
from
effecting recovery from the petitioners;
(v). State Authorities are directed to refund
the recovered amount to the petitioners,
within two months from today;
(vi). Non-refunding of amount shall make the
respondents liable for interest on the
- 43 -
2026:HHC:3309
amount recovered but not refunded at the
rate of 6% per annum after expiry of two
months till actual refund;
(vii). Though Impugned re-fixation orders are
upheld; and recovery orders are quashed;
but the directions qua re-fixation orders
in connected cases shall be treated as
upheld; and recovery orders shall stand
quashed and set aside in all connected
cases;
(vii). Parties shall bear respective costs.
In the aforesaid terms, the instant petitions
along with all pending application(s) are disposed of
accordingly.
January 09, 2026
[Shivender]
(Ranjan Sharma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review