Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
1. Krishna Prasad, aged about 63 years, Son of late Ganga
Vishun Prasad, Resident of Village Religadha
Premnagar, P.O, P.S. Gidhi, District Hazaribag.
2. Nitu Devi, aged about 35 years, Wife of Sri Sanjay
Malakar, Resident of Village Khirgaon, P.O. & P.S.
Sadar, District-Hazaribag.
3. Sanjay Malakar, aged about 55 years, Son of Not
Known, Resident of Village Khirgaon Malitola, P.O. &
P.S.- Sadar, District- Hazaribag,
4. Asha Devi, aged about 33 years, Wife of Birendra
Kumar @ Rahul, Resident of Village- Vid Mohalla,
Chatra, P. P.S. Chatra, District- Chatra.
5. Virendra Kumar @ Rahul, aged about 39 years, Son of
Not Known, Resident of Village Vid Mohalla, Chatra,
P.O. P.S. Chatra, District Chatra.
6. Madhu Devi, aged about 28 years, Wife of Mahesh
Malakar, Resident of Village Khirgaon Malitola, P.O. &
P.S.- Sadar, District- Hazaribag.
7. Mahesh Malakar, aged about 35 years, Son of
Bhuneshwar Bhagat, Resident of Village Khirgaon
Malitola, P.O. & P.S.- Sadar, District- Hazaribag.
8. Sarita Devi, aged about 31 years, Wife of Anil Malakar,
Resident of Village -Kataiya, P.O., P.S. DistrictAurangabad.
9. Anil Malakar, aged about 45 years, Son of Not Known,
Resident of Village Kataiya, P.O., P.S. & DistrictAurangabad.
Present address of petitioner no. 9, Resident of Village
Religadha Premnagar, P.O. & P.S. Gidhi, District –
Hazaribag
...... Petitioners
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. Priti @ Priti Saini @ Priti Soni @ Priti Soni Devi, Wife of
late Aashish Prasad @ late Aashish Malakar Resident of
Village Religadha Premnagar, P.O. & P.S. Gidhi, District
Hazaribag, at present, Resident of Bokaro Thermal
Nisan Hat Govindpur B Panchayat. P.O. & P.S. Bokaro
Thermal, District Bokaro (Jharkhand).
.….. Opposite Parties
For the Petitioners
For the State
For the O.P. No. 2
: Mr. Yogendra Prasad, Adv.
: Ms. Lily Sahay, Addl. PP
: Mr. Niranjan Kumar , Adv.
PRESENT
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
By the Court:-
Heard the parties.
2. This criminal miscellaneous petition has been filed invoking the
jurisdiction of this Court under Section 482 CrPC with the prayer
to quashing and set aside the entire criminal proceeding in
connection with Complaint Case no. 236 of 2023 as well as the
order taking cognizance dated 14.07.2023 in connection with
Complaint Case no. 236 of 2023 whereby and where under,
learned JMFC, Bermo at Tenughat found prima facie case for the
offences punishable under Sections 448, 427 and 506 of the IPC
and passed the summoning order against the petitioners.
3. The allegation against the petitioners is that the petitioners being
the relatives of the husband of the complainant, first falsely
lodged Giddi P.S. case no. 101 of 2022 against the complainant–
Opp. Party no. 2 herein, alleging that the she abetted the suicide of
her own husband and in that case, the complainant – Opp. Party
no. 2 was remanded to judicial custody. After remaining in jail for
a considerable period of time in connection with that case, the
complainant– Opp. Party no. 2 herein was enlarged on bail. There
is further allegation of the complainant– Opp. Party no. 2 herein
that the husband of the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 committed
suicide, as he was pressurized by the petitioners to press for
dowry demand of motorcycle to be brought by the complainant
from her parents. As after being granted bail, the complainant was
not allowed to enter inside her matrimonial house, hence, she was
staying in a room in the house of her paternal uncle at Bokaro
Thermal. It is also alleged that on 25.02.2023 at 6.00 P.M., all the
accused persons of the case, that is the petitioners committed
house trespass and they entered into the said room of the
complainant with an intent to commit the offence of mischief and
criminal intimidation and they vandalized the room of the
complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 by throwing the articles and
thereby diminishing their values and committed theft of money
and jewellery and also committed criminal intimidation by
threatening the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 with an intent to
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
terrorise the complainant so that she will not to demand her share
from the property of her husband; which was the joint property of
the petitioners and accused the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2.
On the basis of the complaint, the statement of the complainant on
Solemn Affirmation and the statement of the inquiry witnesses,
learned JMFC Bermo at Tenugant found prima facie case for the
said offences.
4. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioners relying upon
the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
the State of Haryana & Ors. vs. Bhajan Lal and Others reported
in 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335, submits that the category 7 of the para
102 of the said judgment, which reads as under :“
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended with mala fide
and/or where the proceeding is maliciously instituted with an ulterior
motive for wreaking vengeance on the accused and with a view to spite
him due to private and personal grudge.”
that the said category is squarely applicable to the facts of this
case as the present complaint case is manifestly attended with
malafide and the prosecution is maliciously instituted with ulterior
movie for wrecking vengeance on the petitioners and with a view
to spite them due to private and personal grudge; as the petitioner
no. 1 lodged FIR of Giddi P.S. case no. 101 of 2023 against the
complainant – Opp. Party no. 2.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioners next relies upon the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Achin Gupta
vs. State of Haryana & Another reported in 2024 INSC 369 and
submits that in para 31 thereof, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in the facts and circumstances of that case, where the
appellants before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and his
family members were alleged to have demanded dowry and
thereby caused mental and physical trauma to the first informant,
by shortly after marriage, started harassing the first informant on
the false pretext that she has failed to discharge her duty as a wife
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
and pressurized her for some more dowry and the appellant
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India was alleged to be an
alcoholic and used to beat her regularly, raised her hands on the
first informant and treated her inhumanly, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India observed that if the court is convinced by the fact of
the case concerned, that the involvement of the complainant or
her husband or his close relatives is with an oblique motive, then
even if the FIR and the chargesheet disclose the commission of the
cognizable offence, still the court with a view to do substantial
justice, should read in between the lines, the oblique motive of the
complainant and take pragmatic view of the matter and therein
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India considering the conduct of
the parents of the wife, making mountain out of a mole and in the
facts of that case, came to the conclusion that if the criminal
proceeding are allowed to continue against the appellant, the
same will be nothing short of abuse of process of law and quashed
the entire criminal proceeding. It is next submitted that in this
case also, the complaint case has been filed with an oblique
motive only to harass the petitioners because the petitioner no. 1
instituted Giddi P.S. case no. 101 of 2022, against the complainantOpp. Party no. 2, hence, it is submitted that this is a fit case where
the power under Section 482 of CrPC be exercised to quash the
entire criminal proceeding.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioners next relies upon the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of B.N.John vs.
State of U.P. and Anr. reported in 2025 INSC 4 and submits that
in facts of that case, wherein in the FIR, the vital facts to constitute
the offence punishable under Section 353 of IPC i.e. assault or
criminal force being applied was absent and at best, the only
offence that could be made out was the one, punishable under
Section 186 of IPC which is non-cognizable offence, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India held that as even in respect of the offence
punishable under
Section 186 of
IPC, the due
process
contemplated under the provisions of law was not followed; so
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
that was a fit case for quashing the criminal proceeding against
the appellant before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and
quashed the criminal proceeding.
7. Learned counsel for the petitioners next relies upon the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of M/s JM
Laboratories and Others vs. State of Andhra Pradesh and
Another reported in 2025 INSC 127 and submits that as therein
the summoning order was totally non-speaking one, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India quashed the summoning order passed by
the trial court.
8. Learned counsel for the petitioners next relies upon the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Anukul
Singh vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another reported in 2025
INSC 1153 and submits that in the facts of that case, where the
machinery of criminal law was misused for settling civil disputes
or to wreak vengeance, it was held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
of India that the High Court, in that case, mis-directed itself in law
by failing to apply the ratio laid down in the case of Bhajan Lal
(supra).
9. Learned counsel for the petitioners next relies upon the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of the
Mohammad Wajid and Another vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and
Others in Criminal Appeal no. 2340 of 2023 dated. 08.08.2023,
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the facts of that
case, considered that criminal antecedent of the accused, cannot
be the sole consideration to decline to quash the criminal
proceedings and an accused has a legitimate right to say before
the Court that howsoever bad his antecedents may be, still if the
FIR fails to disclose commission of any offence or the case falls
within one of the parameters as laid down in the case of Bhajan
Lal (supra), then the Court should not decline to quash the
criminal case only on the ground that the accused is a history
sheeter.
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
10. Learned counsel for the petitioners next relies upon the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Sri Gulam
Mustafa vs. The State of Karnataka and Another reported in
2023 LiveLaw (SC) 421 and submits that in para 27 of that
judgment, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India relied upon its
own judgment in the case of the S.W. Palanitkar vs. State of
Bihar reported in (2002)1 SCC 24 wherein it was observed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India that in appropriate cases, to
prevent judicial process from being an instrument of oppression
or harassment in the hands of frustrated or vindictive litigants,
exercise of inherent power is not only desirable but necessary
also, so that the judicial forum of court may not be allowed to be
utilized for any oblique motive.
11. Learned counsel for the petitioners by drawing attention of the
Court to the Article 141 of the Constitution of India submits that
the same provides that the law declared by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India shall be binding on all courts within the territory of
India, hence, the law declared in the judgments relied upon by the
petitioners, is binding on this court, hence, it is submitted that
prayer as made in this criminal miscellaneous petition be allowed.
12. Learned Addl. PP and learned counsel for the Opp. Party no. 2, on
the other hand, vehemently oppose the prayer of the petitioners
and submit that unlike the case of Achin Gupta vs. State of
Haryana & Another (supra), the offence involved in this case is
not one under section 498A of IPC. It is further submitted that in
this case, though there was allegation against the petitioners of
also demanding dowry in the shape of motorcycle to be brought
by the complainant but the said occurrence was before the death
of the husband of complainant – Opp. Party no. 2. The real
dispute began after the death of the husband of the complainant –
Opp. Party no. 2 and the real dispute is because complainant –
Opp. Party no. 2, who is undisputedly the wife of the son of the
petitioner no. 1, is claiming the share in the joint property of her
deceased husband from the petitioners. The undisputed fact
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
remains that the petitioner no. 1 lodged Giddi P.S. case no. 101 of
2022 alleging that complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 abetted the
commission of suicide of her husband; whereas it is the case of
complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 that as the petitioner no. 1 and
others pressurized the husband of complainant – Opp. Party no. 2,
to ensure fulfilment of the dowry demand of motorcycle and
prohibited the husband of the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2
from continuing conjugal life with the complainant – Opp. Party
no. 2, without fulfilment of the said dowry demand and as the
husband of the complainant-opposite party no.2, brought her to
her matrimonial house without the fulfilment of the said dowry
demand, consequent upon filing a petition for the restitution of
conjugal life with the complainant and further as the petitioner
no. 1 instructed on the fateful day to the husband of complainant
– Opp. Party no. 2 to drop the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 at
her parents’ house at Sonipat in the State of Haryana; as the
husband of the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2, brought her back
from the parents’ house even without fulfilment of the dowry
demand, that led to the loss of face of the husband of the
complainant – Opp. Party no. 2; which led him to commit suicide.
13. It is next submitted by learned Addl. PP and learned counsel for
the Opp. Party no. 2 that it is common knowledge that greed for
property and demand of partition often turns own brothers to be
the enemy of each other. Now, the person claiming the property
was only a widowed daughter-in-law of the petitioner no. 1
whose husband has already died and the undisputed fact remains
that she is living in a room in the house of her paternal uncle at
Bokaro Thermal, in the State of Jharkhand after she was not
allowed to enter inside her matrimonial house after being released
on bail, and her parents are at a far-away place at Sonipat in the
State of Haryana. Under such circumstances the act of the
petitioners in order to prevent the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2
from demanding any share from the joint property, which she
was otherwise entitled in law, committing the alleged offence is
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
quite natural, so this is not a case; where it can be said that the
process of the court is used for oblique purpose rather the young
widow standing against the mighty petitioners in their den;
demanding her share from the property, at a place far away from
her father’s place; the petitioners with the greed of denying the
sale of the complainant, stooping to the low of even committing
the house trespass and vandalizing the room occupied by her to
terrorise her by committing criminal intimidation; it is the court
which has come to her rescue by setting the law in motion and
passing the summoning order; when the undisputed fact remains
that the allegation made in the complaint, the statement of the
complainant on Solemn Affirmation and the statement of the
inquiry witnesses, if are considered to be true in their entirety, the
same is sufficient to constitute each of the offences in respect of
which learned Magistrate has found the prima facie case.
14. It is further submitted that there is absolutely no doubt regarding
Article 141 of the Constitution of India which mandates that law
declared by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India shall be binding
on all the courts within the territory of India and the law declared
by each of judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for the
petitioners is also binding upon this Court; but the fact remains
that the ratio of those cases are not applicable to the facts of this
case as this is not a case where complainant – Opp. Party no. 2
used judicial proceeding for oblique purpose rather the court
came to rescue of the young widow who is fighting for her rights
of share of property through her deceased husband from the
petitioners living alone in a room in the house of her paternal
uncle, far-away place from her parents’ house,
hence, it is
submitted that this Criminal Miscellaneous Petition being without
any merit, be dismissed.
15. Having heard the submissions made at the Bar and after going
through materials available in the record, it is pertinent to
mention here that the only contention of the petitioners is that the
complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 is using the judicial forum for
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
oblique purpose and for wrecking vengeance as the petitioner no.
1 has lodged Giddi P.S. case no. 101 of 2022 alleging therein that
she has abetted the suicide of her husband. The complainant was
in judicial custody for a considerable period of time in connection
with the Giddi P.S. case no. 101 of 2022 and she has been released
on bail.
16. The undisputed fact remains that on the date of occurrence,
complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 was in her room in the house of
her paternal uncle at Bokaro Thermal in the state of Jharkhand;
which is a far-away place from her paternal house situated at
Sonipat
in
Haryana.
The
undisputed
fact
remains
that
complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 was claiming the share of joint
property being the widow of her deceased husband. The
undisputed fact also remains that complainant – Opp. Party no. 2
has not been given her share from the joint properties of the
parties and the complainant was not permitted to reside in her
matrimonial house, even after being released on bail.
17. Under such circumstances when the undisputed fact remains that
if the allegations made in the complaint, the statement of the
complainant on Solemn Affirmation and the statement of the
inquiry witnesses are considered to be true in their entirety, then
the offences punishable under Sections 448, 427 and 506 of IPC is
made out, so the only question to be determined is whether the
allegations made in the complaint is for oblique purpose and for
wrecking vengeance.
18. Unlike the case of Achin Gupta vs. State of Haryana & Another
(supra), this is not a simple case involving the offence punishable
under Section 498A and 323 of IPC. It is the common knowledge
that the greed and lust for property even separates the siblings
from each other, as has rightly been submitted by learned Addl.
PP and learned counsel for the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2.
19. Now in this case it is the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 who is a
young widow and claiming her share of joint property from the
petitioners and there is admitted acrimony between them. It is the
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
case of the petitioners that the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 has
abetted the suicide of her husband, of course, it is the defence of
the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 that it is the petitioner no. 1 in
particular and other petitioners indirectly, pressurized the
husband of complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 to ensure the
fulfilment of demand of dowry of motorcycle to be brought by
complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 from her parents and that forced
the husband of the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 to tell the
complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 to go to her parents’ house; as he
has brought her to her matrimonial house without fulfilment of
the dowry of motorcycle and that led to his committing suicide.
20. Under such circumstances, this Court is of the considered view
that the materials in the record is not sufficient for this Court to
come to the conclusion that the complainant – Opp. Party no. 2 is
using the judicial forum for oblique purposes and for wrecking
vengeance; which is the sole ground urged upon by the
petitioners, to quash the entire criminal proceeding in exercise of
its power under Section 482 of CrPC, at this nascent stage, when
only the summoning order has been passed and this is not a fit
case where the category 7 of paragraph 102 of the case of Haryana
& Ors. vs. Bhajan Lal and Others (supra) is to be applied; as in
the considered opinion of this Court, the materials are inadequate
to bring on this case under the category 7 of para 102 of the case of
Haryana & Ors. vs. Bhajan Lal and Others (supra).
21. So far as the judgment in the case of the Md. Wajid and Another
vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Others (supra) is concerned, this
case does not involve any criminal antecedent of either of the
parties, hence, this Court is of the considered view that the ratio of
that judgment is not applicable to the facts of this case.
22. So far as the judgment in the case of M/s JM Laboratories and
Others vs. State of Andhra Pradesh and Another (supra) is
concerned, this Court after going through the materials in the
records, finds that the summoning order passed by learned
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
[ 2026:JHHC:1616]
Magistrate is a speaking order, hence, the ratio of that judgment is
not applicable to the facts of this case.
23. So far as the judgment in the case of Anukul Singh vs. State of
Uttar Pradesh and Another (supra) is concerned, this is not a case
where the machinery of the criminal law was permitted for
settling civil disputes or for wrecking vengeance, hence the ratio
of that judgment is not applicable to the facts of this case.
24. So far as the judgment in the case of B.N.John vs. State of U.P.
and Anr. (supra) is concerned, unlike the facts of that case, where
the FIR was registered in respect of the non-cognizable offence
punishable under Section 186 of IPC, that too without following
the due process as contemplated under the provisions of law, this
is a case based under complaint petition but not FIR, so the ratio
of B.N.John vs. State of U.P. and Anr. (supra), in the considered
opinion of this Court, is also not applicable to the facts of this case.
25. So far as the judgment in the case of Sri Gulam Mustafa vs. The
State of Karnataka and Another
(supra) is concerned, the
observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
S.W. Palanitkar vs. State of Bihar (supra) is no doubt a settled
principle of law; but as already indicated in the foregoing
paragraphs of this judgment, this Court do not find any material
to arrive at the conclusion that the judicial forum of court is being
utilized for any oblique motive, hence, in the considered opinion
of this Court, that judgment is also not applicable to the facts of
this case.
26. Because of the discussions made above, this Court is of the
considered view that this is not a fit case, where the prayers of the
petitioners are to be acceded to in exercise of the power under
Section 482 of CrPC.
27. Accordingly, this Criminal Miscellaneous Petition being without
any merit is dismissed.
(Anil Kumar Choudhary, J.)
High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi
Dated, the 20th January, 2026
Smita /AFR
Uploaded on 27.01.2026
Cr.M.P. No. 3512 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review