Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
+
: 23.04.2026
: 29.05.2026
: 29.05.2026
FAO 453/2010
KRISHNA MALHOTRA
.....Appellant
Through:
Ms. Shruti Munjal, Ms. Trisha Dhara
and Mr. Gurmehar Singh, Advocates
versus
KISHAN DHINGRA & ANR
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Seema Singh, Advocate for
respondent No.1
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1.
The present appeal filed under Section 299 of the Indian Succession
Act, 1925 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”) challenges the order dated
21.08.2010 passed by the learned ADJ in Probate Case No. 462/06. Vide the
impugned order, the Trial Court allowed the underlying probate petition
filed under Section 276 of the Act and granted probate qua the Will dated
22.06.1997 executed by Late Sh. Nand Lal Dhingra.
2.
The said petition was filed by the testator’s son, namely Sh. Kishan
Dhingra and the same was opposed by the testator’s daughter, namely Dr.
(Smt.) Krishna Malhotra.
3.
The present appeal has been preferred by the appellant challenging the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
judgment whereby the Trial Court held the Will dated 22.06.1997 to be the
duly executed last Will and testament of late Sh. Nand Lal Dhingra.
4.
Briefly stated, the facts relevant for the adjudication of the present
appeal are as follows:
Late Sh. Nand Lal Dhingra (hereinafter referred to as the “testator”) expired
on 12.12.2000 leaving behind the respondent No.1/son and the
appellant/daughter as his only Class-I legal heirs. The respondent
propounded a Will dated 22.06.1997, allegedly executed by the testator in
respect of property bearing no. 4-D/10, Old Rajinder Nagar, New Delhi,
whereunder the said property was bequeathed exclusively in his favour.
5.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant, while assailing the
impugned judgment, contends that the Trial Court failed to appreciate the
various suspicious circumstances surrounding the Will in question. It is
contended that the Will itself does not correctly mention the complete name
of the testator and further bears signatures in the name of “Nand Lall”,
whereas the testator admittedly used to sign as “Nand Lal Dhingra” or “N.L.
Dhingra”. Learned counsel submits that the said circumstance goes to the
root of the matter and supports the plea of forgery raised by the appellant. It
is further contended that the Will was stated to be executed in the presence
of two attesting witnesses, however, the document itself bears signatures of
three witnesses, namely Sh. S.K. Tandon, Dr. Mrs. K. Bhargava and Sh. J.C.
Khera. Learned counsel submits that the presence of signatures of a third
witness is itself suspicious, particularly when the testimony of PW-1/Sh.
S.K. Tandon suggests that the third witness had not signed in his presence. It
is furthermore submitted that the Will was executed merely a few days after
the demise of the testator’s wife, at a stage when the testator was around 86
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
years of age and it is contended that the testator had suffered repeated falls,
sustained head injuries and developed haematoma, for which he had
remained admitted in Khera Hospital on several occasions. In such
circumstances, it is argued that the testator could not be stated to be in a
sound disposing state of mind capable of understanding the nature and
consequences of the testamentary disposition.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent, while
supporting the impugned judgment, submits that the Will stood duly proved
through the testimony of the attesting witness/Sh. S.K. Tandon (PW-1), who
unequivocally deposed regarding the execution and attestation thereof in
accordance with law. It is submitted that the mere non-examination of the
remaining attesting witness is not fatal once one attesting witness has been
examined and has satisfactorily proved the execution of the Will. Learned
counsel further submits that no cogent medical evidence has been brought
on record by the appellant to establish that the testator lacked testamentary
capacity on the date of execution of the Will. Learned counsel submits that
the Will itself records the reasons for bequeathing the property in favour of
the respondent, namely that the testator was being looked after by him
during his old age and that sufficient amounts had already been spent on the
marriage of the appellant. It is lastly submitted that the findings returned by
the learned Trial Court are based upon proper appreciation of the oral and
documentary evidence on record and do not warrant any interference in
appellate jurisdiction.
7.
I have heard the learned counsels for the parties and carefully
examined the record.
8.
The law relating to execution and proof of Wills is fairly well settled.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
Section 63(c) of the Act mandates that a Will must be attested by two or
more witnesses, each of whom has either seen the testator sign the document
or has received from the testator an acknowledgment of his signature.
Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 further stipulates that at least
one attesting witness must be examined for proving execution of a Will.
9.
The propounder is required to establish that the Will was signed by
the testator while being in a sound disposing state of mind and that the same
was executed of his own free volition. The principles governing suspicious
circumstances have been expounded by the Supreme Court in Surendra Pal
v. Dr. (Mrs.) Saraswati Arora1, wherein it was held that the propounder
should demonstrate that the Will was signed by the testator and at the
relevant time, the testator was in a sound and disposing state of mind and
had understood the nature and effect of the dispositions, that he had put his
signature on the testimony of his own free will and at least two witnesses
have attested the Will in his presence. In such situations, the burden upon
the propounder becomes heavier and the suspicious circumstances are
required to be satisfactorily explained before the Will can be accepted as
genuine.
At the same time, the Supreme Court also clarified that mere exclusion of a
natural heir does not by itself render a Will invalid, since a testator is fully
entitled to distribute his estate in the manner he deems appropriate. The role
of the Probate Court is confined to examining whether the Will was validly
executed by a competent testator and not whether the distribution made
therein was fair or equitable.
10.
In the present case, a careful reading of the testimony of PW-1/ Sh.
(1974) 2 SCC 600
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
S.K. Tandon shows that the witness categorically deposed that the testator
had approached him expressing his desire to execute a Will and thereafter,
visited his residence on 22.06.1997. PW-1 specifically stated that the testator
executed and signed the Will in his presence and in the presence of Dr.
(Mrs.) K. Bhargava and that he, in turn, appended his signatures in their
presence. The witness also identified the signatures of the testator as well as
those of Dr. (Mrs.) K. Bhargava appearing upon the Will. PW-1 further
deposed that the Will had already been prepared by the testator and was
brought by him at the time of execution and attestation. Significantly, no
suggestion was put to PW-1 in his cross-examination that the signatures
appearing on the Will were suspicious merely because the testator had
signed as “Nand Lall” instead of “Nand Lal”.
11.
The appellant has sought to assail the credibility of PW-1 by
contending that he was not an independent witness. This Court finds no
merit in the said submission. Merely because a witness is acquainted with
the family or knows the beneficiary does not render him an “interested”
witness in law. It is natural for an elderly testator to call upon persons
known and trusted by him for witnessing the execution of his testamentary
document. Nothing has been brought on record to demonstrate that PW-1
stood to derive any direct or indirect benefit from the Will. On the contrary,
PW-1 was a retired judicial officer and no material contradiction affecting
the core of his testimony has been elicited during cross-examination.
12.
The contention regarding the existence of signatures of a third
witness/Sh. J.C. Khera upon the Will also does not persuade this Court to
hold the document suspicious. Learned counsel for the appellant argued that
since the Will records execution in the presence of two witnesses, the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
presence of a third signatory renders the entire document doubtful. Section
63(c) of the Act merely prescribes the minimum statutory requirement of
attestation by two witnesses. The provision nowhere stipulates that a Will
cannot bear signatures of additional persons. As noticed by the Supreme
Court in Raj Kumari and Others v. Surinder Pal Sharma2, no particular form
of attestation is necessary so long as the mandatory ingredients of due
execution and attestation stand fulfilled. It is also pertinent to note that Sh.
J.C. Khera was never examined during the course of trial and no specific
objection regarding his alleged role appears to have been seriously pursued
before the Trial Court. In such circumstances, the appellant cannot seek to
invalidate the entire testamentary document merely on the basis of
arguments concerning the third signatory.
13.
The appellant has heavily relied upon the statement of PW-1 that Sh.
J.C. Khera had not signed in his presence. In the opinion of this Court, the
aforesaid circumstance, at best, pertains to the role of the third signatory and
not to the due execution and attestation of the Will by the testator and the
two attesting witnesses whose signatures stand proved on record. The
evidence of PW-1 clearly establishes that the testator signed the Will in the
presence of PW-1 and Dr. (Mrs.) K. Bhargava and that they attested the
same in the manner contemplated under Section 63(c) of the Act. Once the
essential statutory ingredients stand fulfilled, the existence or participation
of an additional signatory does not invalidate the testamentary instrument.
14.
The appellant has next questioned the signatures appearing on the
Will by contending that the testator used to sign as “Nand Lal Dhingra” or
“N.L. Dhingra” and not as “Nand Lall”. In this regard, A careful perusal of
(2021) 14 SCC 500
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
the testimony of RW-1/Sh. Deepak Jain, the handwriting expert examined
by the appellant, shows that the opinion regarding the disputed signatures
was rendered on the basis of comparison with certain documents alleged to
contain admitted signatures of the testator. However, the Trial Court, upon
appreciation of the evidence on record, did not find the said opinion
sufficiently reliable to dislodge the direct testimony of the attesting witness
regarding execution of the Will. The very basis of the comparison exercise
therefore remained uncertain. It is trite law that opinion of a private
handwriting expert is merely advisory in nature and cannot override reliable
direct evidence regarding execution of a Will. The direct testimony of PW-1
identifying the signatures of the testator assumes greater significance than
the inconclusive opinion of the handwriting expert. Significantly, even RW1 admitted in his cross-examination that “looking with the naked eye the
writing is identical on the disputed signatures and those of the admitted
signatures” and further admitted that in all the admitted as well as disputed
signatures, the writer used to write his name as “Nand Lall”. Furthermore,
the record itself contains documents bearing signatures of the testator as
“Nand Lall”, including the letter dated 21.09.1998 as well as the
communication dated 29.10.1998 addressed to CDA Pension, Allahabad.
Minor variations in signatures are also not uncommon, particularly where
the executant is of advanced age and suffering from physical weakness.
15.
The appellant has further contended that the Will is surrounded by
suspicious circumstances as the same was allegedly executed merely about
twenty-two days after the demise of the testator’s wife. It has been argued
that the testator was incapable of taking conscious decisions at the relevant
time. Learned counsel for the appellant has also placed reliance upon the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
decision of the Supreme Court in Kavita Kanwar v. Pamela Mehta3 to
contend that where suspicious circumstances surround the execution of a
Will, the propounder carries a heavier burden to dispel the same by cogent
and satisfactory evidence. There can be no quarrel with the aforesaid
proposition.
16.
However, the facts of the present case stand on an entirely different
footing. The due execution and attestation of the Will stand affirmatively
proved through the testimony of PW-1, which has remained substantially
unimpeached on material particulars. The suspicious circumstances sought
to be projected by the appellant are either adequately explained or do not go
to the root of the execution of the testamentary document.
17.
The medical evidence relied upon by the appellant also fails to
substantiate the plea of incapacity. Considerable emphasis has been placed
upon alleged falls suffered by the testator, development of haematoma and
his admission in Khera Hospital. In order to prove the medical record, Sh.
Prabhat Kumar (RW-2A), MRD Supervisor from R.L.K.C. Hospital and
Metro Heart Institute, was examined and a careful perusal of his testimony
reveals that the witness did not produce any original medical record and had
merely produced photocopies available in the hospital record. The witness
specifically stated that he had no personal knowledge regarding preparation
of the documents in question and was unable to identify either the
handwriting or signatures of the concerned doctors. In such circumstances,
mere production of photocopies of medical papers through a witness having
no personal knowledge regarding their preparation could not have
conclusively established that the testator lacked testamentary capacity on
(2021) 11 SCC
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
22.06.1997. Significantly, the documents relied upon by the appellant
include discharge slips and LAMA forms pertaining to September 1997 i.e.,
three months after execution of the Will. Further, there is no evidence on
record to show that on 22.06.1997, the testator was incapable of
comprehending the nature and effect of the dispositions made by him.
Rather, it has come in the testimony of Dr. Krishan Khera (RW-2) that the
testator had discussions regarding execution of a Will and he was in a
mentally sound condition in September 1997 i.e., within three months of
execution of the Will.
18.
It is equally well settled that old age, illness or physical weakness by
themselves do not render a person incompetent to execute a Will. Reference
in this regard is placed on the decision in Pentakota Satyanarayana v.
Pentakota Seetharatnam4, wherein the Supreme Court observed that the
initial onus upon the propounder stands discharged upon adducing
satisfactory evidence that the Will was signed by the testator in a sound
disposing state of mind and out of his own free volition.
In the present case as well, apart from broad allegations regarding advanced
age and medical condition, no cogent evidence has been led to establish
coercion, fraud or undue influence exercised by the respondent upon the
testator.
19.
The appellant has also argued that the bequest itself is unnatural as the
daughter has been excluded from the immovable property despite cordial
relations with the testator. The Court exercising probate jurisdiction is not
concerned with the fairness of the disposition but only with its genuineness
especially when the Will itself records the reasons which weighed with the
(2005) 8 SCC 67
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
testator, namely that the respondent was taking care of him during his old
age and that sufficient expenditure had already been incurred at the time of
the appellant’s marriage.
20.
The appellant has additionally relied upon the joint communication
dated 10.02.2001 addressed by the parties to Canara Bank to contend that
the respondent himself did not initially assert the existence of the Will. It is
true that during his cross-examination, the respondent initially denied that he
and the appellant had jointly addressed a communication to Canara Bank
seeking to occupy the second floor. However, upon referring to the letter
dated 10.02.2001, he admitted the same and acknowledged that both parties
had requested the Bank to vacate the premises.
Nevertheless, the said communication merely pertained to the tenancy and
possession of a portion of the property and reflected the parties describing
themselves as legal heirs of the deceased for limited administrative
purposes. The same cannot be construed as abandonment, waiver or nonexistence of the testamentary document. At best, the said circumstance may
show that the parties were jointly dealing with the tenant after the demise of
the testator, but the same does not by itself dislodge the otherwise cogent
evidence regarding the due execution and attestation of the Will.
21.
Upon appreciation of the evidence on record, this Court is satisfied
that the respondent successfully proved the due execution and attestation of
the Will dated 22.06.1997 and the findings returned by the Trial Court are
based upon proper appreciation of evidence and do not suffer from
perversity or material irregularity warranting interference in appellate
jurisdiction.
22.
Considering all the above, I find no infirmity or illegality in the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
impugned order and the present appeal is accordingly dismissed.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
MAY 29, 2026
kk
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:23:47
FAO 453/2010
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review