Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment Reserved on: 23.04.2026
Judgment Delivered on: 15.06.2026
%
+
W.P.(C) 13302/2005 & CM APPL. 3215/2021
KRISHAN CHANDER
.....Petitioner
versus
D.D.A.
.....Respondent
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Roopak Bansal, Advocate.
For the Respondent
:
Mr. M. K. Singh, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
JUDGMENT
TEJAS KARIA, J
1.
The present Petition has been filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 seeking, inter alia, following prayers:
“(a) issue a writ declaration, declaring the act of the respondent
authority in canceling the allotment of plot bearing No.48, Pocket B4, Sector-17, measuring 60 Sq.Mtrs. in Rohini Phase II Residential
Scheme as being totally illegal, arbitrary and unjustified; and
(b) issue a writ of certiorari thereby quashing the decision dated
13/05/2005 as communicated vide letter dated 26/07/2005; and
(c) issue a writ of mandamus thereby directing the respondent
authority to hand over the possession of plot bearing No.48, Pocket
B-4, Sector-17, measuring 60 Sq.Mtrs. in Rohini Phase II
Residential Scheme to the petitioner;”
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
2.
The Petitioner has challenged the decision dated 13.05.2025
communicated vide letter dated 26.07.2025, whereby the Respondent has
cancelled the allotment of the plot admeasuring 60 sq. mtrs. bearing No. 48,
Pocket B-4, Sector -17 in Rohini Phase-II Residential Scheme, Delhi
(“Plot”) and has sought direction to the Respondent to handover the
possession of the Plot to the Petitioner.
FACTUAL MATRIX
3.
In 1981, the Petitioner was registered with the Respondent under the
Rohini Residential Scheme. After 22 years, on 01.09.2003, the Petitioner
was allotted the Plot vide Allotment-cum-Demand Letter dated 01.09.2003
to 05.09.2003 (“Allotment Letter”).
4.
The Allotment Letter stated that in the computerised draw held on
11.06.2003, the Petitioner was allotted the Plot on perpetual lease hold basis
subject to fulfilment of terms and conditions of eligibility as contained in the
Brochure of registration. The Petitioner was required to pay the premium as
per the schedule provided in the Allotment Letter. Accordingly, the
Petitioner was required to pay a total amount of ₹7,18,872/- as under:
1. (a)
(b)
(c)
2.
(i)
Premium of the Plot @ Rs. 10892 (Provisional)
for 60 sq. mtrs.
Corner charges 10% of (a) above
Location Charges if plot is located on a road of 24
meter wide or more 10% of (a) above
Grand Total
35% of the premium of the Plot
Deduction
I. Registration Amount
- ₹5,000.00
+
II. Interest on Registration Amount - ₹7,783.44
₹6,53,520/₹65,352/₹0/₹7,18,872/₹2,51,605/₹12,783.44
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
3.
5.
Net amount to be deposited within 60 days from
the date of issue of the Allotment Letter, i.e. latest
by 04.11.2003
(ii) 50% of the premium to be deposited by
03.01.2004
(iii) 15% of the premium to be deposited by
02.02.2004
Cost of operation of lease deed to be deposited
with last instalment
₹2,38,822/-
₹3,59,436/₹1,07,831/₹100/-
On 04.11.2003, the Petitioner deposited a sum of ₹2,38,822/-, being
35% of the premium amount with the Respondent and also submitted the
relevant documents.
6.
It is the Petitioner’s case that, since he was residing in Canada, he had
authorised his brother, Sh. Parshotam Lal, to liaise with the Respondent on
his behalf. Accordingly, the Petitioner had remitted the requisite amount to
his brother for deposit with the Respondent. However, owing to the serious
illness of his wife, who subsequently passed away, the said amount was
utilised towards her medical treatment.
7.
The Petitioner claims that he had remitted the funds once again,
pursuant to which the balance amount of ₹3,60,000/- was deposited on
11.04.2005.
8.
Vide letter dated 26.07.2005, the Respondent informed the Petitioner
that the allotment of the Plot had been cancelled by the competent authority
on account of non-payment of the premium within the stipulated time. It was
further stated therein that the said decision had earlier been communicated to
the Petitioner vide letter dated 13.05.2005, whereby the Petitioner had been
requested to submit the requisite documents to facilitate refund; however,
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
the said communication was received back undelivered. Accordingly, the
Respondent once again called upon the Petitioner to submit the necessary
documents for refund of the deposited amount in accordance with the
applicable rules.
9.
On 01.08.2005, Sh. Parshotam Lal submitted a representation to the
Respondent on behalf of the Petitioner seeking regularisation of the delay in
respect of the Plot. It was stated in the said representation that due to certain
unavoidable family circumstances, including a bereavement in the family,
there had been a delay in payment of the second and third instalments of the
premium for the Plot. It was further stated that the Petitioner was willing to
pay such interest and other charges, if any, as may be required by the
Respondent for regularisation of the delay.
10.
However, as no response was received from the Respondent, the
Petitioner instituted the present Writ Petition.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
11.
Vide order dated 22.08.2005, notice was issued to the Respondent
returnable on 14.12.2005.
12.
On 13.09.2005, the Petitioner filed CM APPL. 11577/2005 seeking
stay of allotment of the Plot to a third-party by way of draw of lots, which
was scheduled on 21.09.2005. Vide order dated 19.09.2005, this Court
directed that the Plot would be withdrawn from the proposed draw of lots to
be held on 21.09.2005.
13.
On 14.12.2005, in view of the photographs filed by the Petitioner
along with the Petition, which indicated that the Pocket in Sector-17, where
the Plot had been allotted to the Petitioner, lacked basic civic amenities such
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
as electricity, sewerage, water supply and roads, this Court directed the
Vice-Chairman of the Respondent to remain present before the Court and
place on record the development works carried out by the Respondent, along
with particulars of the expenditure incurred on laying roads, sewer lines,
water lines and storm water drains in Pocket B-4, Sector-17, Rohini.
14.
Accordingly, on 02.01.2006, the Vice-Chairman of the Respondent
appeared before this Court, whereupon it was directed that the Respondent
shall file an additional affidavit in the context of the aforesaid photographs
explaining the development works stated to have been carried out.
15.
Vide order dated 20.02.2006, this Court directed the Engineer-in-
Chief of the Central Public Works Department to constitute a team of three
senior engineers to visit Pockets B-4 and B-5, Sector-17, Rohini, and
ascertain the position and status of the waterlines, roads, storm water drains
and sewer lines.
16.
As the report directed to be placed on record pursuant to the order
dated 20.02.2006 had not been made available, this Court, vide order dated
14.07.2006, granted a further period of four weeks to the Engineer-in-Chief
and directed that the matter be listed on 06.10.2006.
17.
Thereafter, the report was filed on 21.07.2006, whereupon the learned
counsel for the Respondent sought time to examine the same. Accordingly,
the matter was directed to be listed on 17.01.2007. As the matter could not
be taken up on 17.01.2007, it was adjourned to 09.05.2007. On the said date,
the Petitioner relied upon a judgment rendered in W.P.(C) 11148/2005,
wherein, in similar circumstances involving a delay of 408 days in payment,
the delay had been condoned subject to payment of interest at the rate of
15% for the period of delay. The learned counsel for the Respondent,
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
accordingly, sought time to obtain instructions as to whether a similar course
could be adopted in the present Writ Petition.
18.
Thereafter, the present Writ Petition was adjourned on several
occasions. On 24.09.2007, the learned counsel for the Respondent sought
time to file an additional affidavit. On 24.01.2008, further time for the said
purpose was sought and granted. Thereafter, on 10.12.2008, it was recorded
that the additional affidavit had not been filed by the Respondent and that, if
the same was not filed within four weeks, it could be filed within a
maximum period of eight weeks subject to payment of costs of ₹3,000/-.
19.
On 27.03.2009, the additional affidavit was filed beyond the time
granted vide order dated 10.12.2008. Accordingly, the learned counsel for
the Respondent stated that the costs would be paid to the Petitioner, and the
learned counsel for the Petitioner sought time to respond to the additional
affidavit. On 01.09.2009, the learned counsel for the Petitioner submitted
that no response to the additional affidavit filed by the Respondent was
required and sought an adjournment. Thereafter, the matter was adjourned
on several occasions for various reasons.
20.
Vide judgment dated 26.08.2011, upon hearing the parties, the Writ
Petition was dismissed and the interim order stood vacated. The Respondent
was further directed to refund the amounts deposited by the Petitioner in
accordance with the applicable policy.
21.
Aggrieved by the judgment dated 26.08.2011, the Petitioner preferred
Letters Patent Appeal being LPA 904/2011. Vide judgment dated
03.11.2011, the said Appeal was allowed, the judgment dated 26.08.2011
was set aside, and the Writ Petition was restored for fresh adjudication on
merits.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
22.
Accordingly, the present Writ Petition stood restored and was listed
on 09.01.2012. As none appeared on behalf of the Respondent on the said
date, the matter was adjourned while granting a last opportunity of four
weeks to file an additional affidavit. The said order dated 09.01.2012 also
clarified that, since the present Writ Petition had been restored, the interim
order dated 20.02.2006 directing the Respondent not to allot the Plot to any
third party also stood revived.
23.
On 14.05.2012, the learned counsel for the Respondent sought further
time to file the additional affidavit. On 12.07.2012, the present Writ Petition
was admitted and directed to be listed in due course in the category of
‘Regulars’ in its own turn. When the matter was taken up on 30.05.2017,
none appeared on behalf of the Petitioner; accordingly, the learned counsel
for the Respondent stated that he would inform the learned counsel for the
Petitioner of the next date of hearing. In view thereof, the matter was
directed to be listed in the category of ‘Regulars’ in the week commencing
03.07.2017.
24.
Thereafter, the matter was next taken up on 25.02.2019 and, since
none appeared on behalf of the Petitioner, the Writ Petition was dismissed in
default for non-prosecution. The Petitioner, thereafter, filed CM APPL.
10970/2019 seeking restoration of the Writ Petition. As the learned counsel
for the Respondent had no objection to the restoration subject to terms, the
Writ Petition was restored to its original number vide order dated
01.04.2019, subject to payment of costs of ₹10,000/- by the Petitioner.
25.
The Petitioner also filed CM APPL. 3215/2021 seeking a direction to
the Respondent to maintain status quo. The said application was listed on
29.01.2021, on which date the learned counsel for the Petitioner sought an
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
adjournment. The matter was accordingly adjourned and thereafter
continued to be adjourned on several dates, until it was finally heard on
23.04.2026.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
26.
The learned Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that:
26.1
The allotment of the Plot in favour of the Petitioner was
cancelled arbitrarily, notwithstanding that the Petitioner had
deposited the entire demanded amount with the Respondent,
albeit belatedly.
26.2
The cancellation of the Plot was illegal, as no show cause notice
was issued to the Petitioner prior to such cancellation, and the
cancellation was effected after the payment had already been
deposited by the Petitioner.
26.3
The cancellation was discriminatory and arbitrary, inasmuch as,
in other cases, the Respondent condoned delays exceeding two
years in the deposit of instalments.
26.4
The Pocket in which the Plot was allotted to the Petitioner
remained undeveloped and devoid of basic amenities. Despite the
directions issued by this Court, the Respondent failed to carry out
the requisite development works, with the result that the Pocket
in which the Plot is situated continued to remain undeveloped.
26.5
Notwithstanding that the Petitioner had paid the amount
demanded by the Respondent, the allotment of the Plot was
cancelled in violation of the principles of natural justice, as no
opportunity of hearing was afforded to the Petitioner prior to
such cancellation.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
26.6
As is evident from the Respondent’s letter dated 26.07.2005, the
cancellation was effected after deposit of the entire amount by
the Petitioner under intimation to the Respondent. Accordingly,
the impugned action of cancellation is bad in law and liable to be
set aside.
26.7
In the case of Sh. Pramod Kumar Jain, the instalments had been
delayed by more than two years and the allotment had also been
cancelled; however, the same was restored subject to payment of
current charges and restoration charges. In addition, the
Respondent condoned delay in several other similarly situated
allottees but declined to extend the same benefit to the Petitioner.
Accordingly, on the ground of parity, the Petitioner is entitled to
quashing of the cancellation of the Plot allotted in his favour by
the Respondent.
26.8
In V.P. Sunita v. DDA, 2013 (30) RCR (Civil) 255, this Court
held that, in terms of the Respondent’s policy, the Respondent
was required to consider whether the grounds advanced for the
delay in payment of instalments were genuine and whether its
discretion ought to be exercised to condone such delay. It was
further held that refusal to condone the delay was arbitrary where
no reasons were furnished for condoning delay in other cases.
Accordingly, since the petitioner in that case had made full
payment, this Court held that the petitioner was entitled to
allotment and possession of the property.
26.9
In Lajpat Rai v. DDA, W.P.(C) 13840/2006, this Court held that
cancellation of allotment by the Respondent without issuance of
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
a show cause notice or affording an opportunity of hearing to the
allottee was violative of the principles of natural justice. It was
further held that the allottee was entitled to be heard and afforded
an opportunity to rectify the situation before cancellation.
Accordingly, the allottee was held entitled to restoration or
alternate allotment subject to restoration charges and penalties.
26.10 In K.R. Cultural and Welfare Society (Regd.) v. DDA, W.P.(C)
8116/2008, where the Respondent had discriminated against the
petitioner therein by granting another allottee an opportunity to
make payment beyond the stipulated time, this Court held that
the cancellation was invalid, particularly in view of the
Respondent having retained the payment for nine years prior to
cancellation.
26.11 In DDA v. Jagdish Chopra, LPA 82/2008, the Division Bench of
this Court held that cancellation of allotment on account of delay
in payment following presumed service of a demand-cumallotment letter sent by courier could not result in so drastic a
consequence, particularly where the demand letter ought to have
been served by registered post in accordance with the statutory
provisions and the delay of 25 days was condonable under the
Respondent’s policy.
26.12 In view of the aforesaid, it was prayed that the Respondent’s
action in cancelling the allotment of the Plot be declared wholly
illegal, arbitrary and unjustified, and that the Petitioner be held
entitled to possession of the Plot.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
27.
The learned Counsel for the Respondent submitted that:
27.1.
A Show Cause Notice dated 20.09.2004 (“SCN”) was issued to
the Petitioner calling upon him to furnish his explanation within
15 days for non-payment of Premium within prescribed time as
per the Allotment Letter. It was further stated in SCN that in the
event no reply was received within the stipulated period, it would
be presumed that the Petitioner had nothing further to state in the
matter, whereupon the offer of allotment would stand withdrawn
and the registration cancelled.
27.2.
The Petitioner, vide letters dated 27.02.1997 and 04.11.2003, had
informed the Respondent of the change in his address.
Accordingly, the Allotment Letter was dispatched to the address
available with the Respondent, and the Petitioner made payment
of the first instalment within time. However, the SCN sent to the
same address was received back unserved with the report that the
addressee had left India.
27.3.
As the SCN was not delivered, there was no response to the SCN
and, therefore, the allotment was cancelled and the Petitioner was
informed thereof vide letter dated 13.05.2005. The said
communication, having been sent to the Petitioner’s last known
address, was also received back unserved.
27.4.
However, the letter dated 11.04.2005 sent on behalf of the
Petitioner bore the very same address to which the SCN and the
cancellation letter dated 13.05.2005 had been dispatched by the
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
Respondent. Therefore, it is clear that the Petitioner had
intentionally evaded service of the aforesaid communications.
27.5.
Of the eight allegedly similarly situated cases relied upon by the
Petitioner for claiming parity, six pertained to the draw held on
27.03.1991 and were regularised under Clause 1(a), (b) and (c) of
the policy formulated specifically for the draw held in the year
1991. As regards the remaining two cases, it was submitted that
the particulars furnished by the Petitioner were incorrect,
inasmuch as the names and file numbers did not correspond with
each other.
27.6.
In the year 2004, the Respondent passed Resolution No. 52/2004
dated 24.08.2004, whereby delay of up to 360 days could be
condoned by the competent authority upon payment of
restoration charges and interest for the belated period. In the case
of the Petitioner, however, the delay was 464 days in respect of
the second instalment and 434 days in respect of the third
instalment, which was beyond the permissible scope of the said
policy. Therefore, the cases relied upon by the Petitioner were of
no assistance to his case.
27.7.
The allegations levelled by the Petitioner were an afterthought
following cancellation of the allotment of the Plot on account of
failure to make payment within the stipulated time, and that the
Petitioner was seeking to shift the entire blame upon the
Respondent.
27.8.
The registration under the Scheme, being non-statutory in nature,
conferred only an eligibility to apply for allotment pursuant to a
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
draw conducted by the Respondent. The Allotment Letter
constituted merely an offer, which the allottee could either accept
or decline. Upon acceptance thereof, a concluded contract would
come into existence. The obligation to hand over possession of
the Plot would arise only upon payment being made strictly in
accordance with the terms of the Scheme and the Allotment
Letter, which, according to the Respondent, the Petitioner had
failed to do.
27.9.
The allegations regarding non-availability of basic amenities and
allotment in an undeveloped pocket of Sector-17 were stated to
be devoid of merit, as services such as water supply, sewage,
roads and drains had been completed in the year 1989–90. The
status report filed by the Superintending Engineer of PWD
clearly demonstrated that all basic amenities were available in
the pocket in which the Plot is situated.
27.10. In view of the aforesaid, it was submitted that the present Writ
Petition was liable to be dismissed.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
28.
Having considered the submissions advanced on behalf of the parties,
the principal issues that arises for consideration in the present Writ Petition
is whether the Respondent acted arbitrarily or discriminatorily in declining
to condone the delay in payment of the instalments by the Petitioner prior to
cancellation of the allotment of the Plot and whether the principles of natural
justice were followed prior to cancellation of the Plot.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
29.
The case set up by the Petitioner is that the allotment of the Plot came
to be cancelled after the entire dues had been deposited, albeit belatedly, and
without issuance of any show cause notice or affording any opportunity of
hearing. According to the Petitioner, the Respondent failed to condone the
delay in payment despite its own policy and denied him parity with other
allottees to whom such extension had been granted.
30.
Per contra, the Respondent contends that the allotment of the Plot
stood cancelled after issuance of the SCN, which was dispatched to the
Petitioner at his last known address but was returned unserved on account of
his having left the premises. It is further the Respondent’s case that the
Petitioner was not entitled to the benefit of the applicable policy, since the
maximum condonable delay thereunder was 360 days, whereas the delay in
the present case was 464 days in respect of the second instalment and 434
days in respect of the third instalment. On that basis, the Respondent
submits that the cases cited as being similarly situated are of no assistance to
the Petitioner.
31.
The Petitioner has candidly admitted the delay in payment of the
second and third instalments. In the opinion of this Court, the explanation
offered, namely, that the funds remitted to his brother were utilised towards
the medical treatment of his wife, does not constitute sufficient justification
for failure to comply with the payment schedule stipulated in the Allotment
Letter.
32.
The Allotment Letter clearly stipulated that failure to pay the
premium within the prescribed period would entail automatic cancellation of
the allotment of the Plot. Notwithstanding the said stipulation, the Petitioner
failed to adhere to the timeline prescribed therein. In the circumstances, the
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
allotment of the Plot stood cancelled upon non-payment of the premium
within time.
33.
The contention of the Petitioner that the entire amount had been
deposited prior to cancellation cannot be accepted, inasmuch as the request
for condonation of delay was made only after cancellation had already been
communicated.
34.
This Court is also of the view that the Respondent was justified in
declining to condone the delay, since the Petitioner’s case did not fall within
the scope of the policy relied upon by him, the delay being beyond the
condonable limit of 360 days. Consequently, the reliance placed by the
Petitioner on allegedly similarly situated cases is misplaced, as those matters
are clearly distinguishable on facts. The Petitioner, therefore, cannot claim
parity with other allottees who were granted condonation in materially
different circumstances.
35.
The contention founded on violation of the principles of natural
justice is also unpersuasive. The SCN was dispatched prior to cancellation to
the very address from which the Petitioner had addressed correspondence to
the Respondent. In these circumstances, it cannot be held that no opportunity
was afforded to the Petitioner to respond before cancellation. Accordingly,
the decision in Lajpat Rai (supra) does not advance the Petitioner’s case.
36.
For the same reason, the decisions in V.P. Sunita (supra) and K.R.
Cultural and Welfare Society (supra) are also of no assistance to the
Petitioner, as the policies applicable in those matters were materially
different from the policy governing the present case.
37.
Further, the Petitioner has never disputed service of the Allotment
Letter, as is evident from the fact that the first instalment was deposited
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
within time pursuant thereto. The decision in Jagdish Chopra (supra) is,
therefore, inapplicable to the facts of the present case.
38.
As regards the alleged lack of basic amenities in the Pocket where the
Plot is situated, the same does not bear upon the issue that falls for
determination in the present case, namely, condonation of delay in payment
of the second and third instalments and the consequent cancellation of the
allotment on that account. The plea relating to lack of amenities is, therefore,
of no relevance to adjudication of the controversy at hand.
39.
In view of the foregoing analysis, this Court finds no merit in the
Petitioner’s challenge to the cancellation of the allotment of the Plot, which
was in accordance with the terms of the Allotment Letter, the applicable
policy, and after compliance with the principles of natural justice.
40.
In view of the aforesaid, the Petitioner is not entitled to any of the
reliefs prayed for in the present Writ Petition. Accordingly, the Writ Petition
is dismissed and the interim order(s), if any, shall stand vacated. The
Respondent is directed to refund the amount deposited by the Petitioner, if
not already refunded, in accordance with the applicable rules and policies.
All pending Application(s), if any, also stand disposed of. There shall be no
order as to costs.
TEJAS KARIA, J
JUNE 15, 2026/sms
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:47:42
W.P.(C) 13302/2005
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review