Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010603232025
Bench Sr.No:-12
[3584]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
WRIT PETITION NO: 31712 of 2025
Konkyana Sravan Kumar
...Petitioner
Vs.
The High Court of Andhra Pradesh and Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
CORAM :THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 21st September 2026
Present:
Advocate for Petitioner:
P NAGENDRA REDDY
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s): GP FOR SERVICES I,
N V SUMANTH
ORDER: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
By way of present writ petition filed under Article 226 of
Constitution of India, the petitioner seeks the following relief:
“to issue a writ order or direction more particularly one in
the nature of writ of Mandamus to declare the action of
the
Respondent
No.1
in
issuing
the
Impugned
Proceedings in ROC No.247/2024-RC, dated 05.02.2025
declaring that the Petitioner is not selected to the post of
District Judge (Entry Level) (25% Quota) under direct
Recruitment
in
pursuant
to
the
Notification
in
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31712 of 2025
ROC.No.247/2024, dated 10.05.2024 and consequently
not considering the Amendment to Rule 6 of the AP State
Judicial (Service and Cadre) Rules, 2007 issued by the
Government in G.O.Ms.No.3, Law (L.A. & J – SC.F.),
dated 28.01.2025 with retrospective effect and select the
Petitioner as arbitrary, illegal and violation of Article 14
and 21 of the Constitution of India and consequently
direct the Respondents to select the Petitioner as District
Judge (Entry Level) (Open Category) under direct
recruitment in pursuant to the Notification No.247/2024
dated 10.05.2024 issued by the 1st Respondent and
consequential amendment to Rule 6 of the AP State
Judicial (Service & Cadre) Rules, 2007 issued by the
2nd Respondent in G.O.Ms.No.3, Law (L.A. & J – SC.F),
dated 28.01.2025, in the interest of justice.”
2.
(a)
1st respondent issued Notification No.247/2024, dated
10.05.2024, for recruitment to seven posts of District Judge (Entry
Level) under direct recruitment, in terms of Andhra Pradesh State
Judicial (Service and Cadre) Rules, 2007. Petitioner belongs to
BC-A category, as no posts were reserved for such category, he
applied under OC category, under which three posts were notified.
In terms of the said notification, the scheme of examination
envisages that there shall be a written examination for three
subjects, namely, I) Constitutional and Civil Law, II) Criminal Law,
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31712 of 2025
and III) English (Translation and Essay Writing) Test, which will
carry 100 marks each.
(b)
Further, for a candidate to be eligible for viva voce, he or she
should secure not less than 50% of marks in each paper and not
less than 60% of marks in aggregate, if they belong to OC/EWS
category. Viva voce test will carry 50 marks. Only those candidates
who secure at least 60% marks in aggregate in written examination
and viva voce shall be eligible for selection to the post of District
Judge in that particular category. The written test was conducted
in the month of October, 2024 and Viva Voce was held on
13.12.2024, in which, petitioner secured following marks:
Name of the paper
Marks Secured
I. Constitution and Civil Law
63.25
II. Criminal Law
III. English (Translation and Essay Writing)
Total secured
193.25
Aggregate
64.42
Viva Voce
Total
206.25
Aggregate of Written Test + Viva Voce
58.92
(c)
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31712 of 2025
In the interregnum, before the merit list was published on
05.02.2025, amendment was brought into Rule 6 of the Rules, vide
G.O.Ms.No.3, dated 28.01.2025, whereby, by virtue of proviso to
Rule 6(e), it was envisaged that the marks secured in Paper III shall
not be taken into account for eligibility for viva voce or selection,
and that marks secured in Paper I, Paper II and viva voce shall
alone be taken into account for selection.
(d)
Petitioner secured aggregate of 58.92% marks (aggregate
of written examination and viva voce), falling short of the eligibility
of 60%, however, it is stated that on account of amendment to Rule
6, if marks secured in Paper III are excluded, the aggregate of
Paper I, Paper II and viva voce (which would be 60.5%) would
make the petitioner eligible for selection.
(e)
Petitioner
made
a
representation
dated
10.02.2025
requesting to apply the amended rule by giving retrospective
application for the purpose of considering his candidature to the
post of District Judge. The request of petitioner was eventually
rejected vide communication dated 24.03.2025, thus, aggrieved by
the same, present writ petition is preferred.
3.
(a)
1st respondent filed counter, inter alia, stating that as
notification for recruitment was issued on 10.05.2024, written
examination was conducted in October 2024, and viva voce was
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31712 of 2025
held on 13.12.2024, thus amendment to Rule 6 issued on
28.01.2025 would only have prospective application and definitely,
the said amendment would not operate retrospectively.
(b)
Further, it is stated that as petitioner could not secure
minimum aggregate marks of 60% in terms of notification, his
candidature was not considered for selection, therefore, sought
dismissal of the writ petition.
4.
Heard Sri P.Nagendra Reddy, learned counsel appearing for
petitioner and Sri N.V.Sumanth, learned counsel appearing for
respondents.
5.
Learned counsel for petitioner contended that the amended
rule, since was issued in midst of selection process, should have
been made applicable and, giving benefit of the same, petitioner
ought to be selected. It is further stated that as against seven
vacancies notified, merely two candidates were qualified for
interview and even amongst them, only one candidate was finally
appointed. Therefore, considering the marks secured by petitioner
and having regard to the number of unfilled vacancies,
1st respondent ought to have reduced minimum qualifying marks
rather than rejecting the representation of the petitioner. In support
of the above submissions, learned counsel for petitioner relies on
judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Commissioner of Income
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31712 of 2025
Tax (Central)-I, New Delhi v. Vatika Township Private Limited1
and Ajaykumar Shyamkishor Tripathi & Ors. V. Registrar
General and another2.
6.
Conversely, learned counsel appearing for 1st respondent,
while maintaining the stand as pleaded in the counter, contended
that the amendment brought to Rule 6 would have only prospective
application and will not apply to notifications already issued. It is
further contended that any amendment to procedural law can be
construed retrospectively, but not the one which affects
substantive rights. The exclusion of Paper III for the purpose of
arriving at aggregate marks in both written examination as well as
viva voce for selecting a candidate would definitely be substantive
in nature, thus, the same cannot be applied retrospectively. In
support of aforesaid submissions, reliance has been placed on
judgments of Hon’ble Apex Court in A.A.Calton v. Director of
Education and another3 and Abhay Kumar Patel and others v.
State of Bihar and others4.
7.
The short question that arises for our consideration is
whether the amendment issued to Rule 6 of the Rules would have
retrospective application and whether the criteria of minimum
1 (2015) 1 SCC 1
2 SLP(C) No.18274/2026, dated 26.05.2026
3 (1983) 3 SCC 33
4 2026 SCC OnLine SC 20
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31712 of 2025
marks specified in notification dated 10.05.2024 issued prior to the
amendment would continue to apply for selection of subject posts.
8.
1st respondent issued notification for recruitment to the post
of District Judges on 10.05.2024. The said notification set out the
qualifications, reservation and the scheme of examination a
candidate to possess and undergo. Clause IV(b) dealing with
written examination reads as under:
“IV (b): Written Examination consist of the following three
(3) papers. Each paper will carry 100 marks. The duration
of each paper is three (3) hours.
The question/s in the examination shall be
answered only in English (except Translation)
I)
Constitution and Civil Law
II)
Criminal Law
III)
English
(Translation
and
Essay
writing).
Translation test has to be made from English to
Telugu and Telugu to English.
The Translation test is conducted for 25 marks
and Essay Writing test for 75 marks on Legal
Subjects.”
9.
Minimum marks criteria specified under Clauses 5, 6, and 8,
read as under:
“V. MINIMUM MARKS TO BE SECURED IN THE
WRITTEN EXAMINATION TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR VIVA
VOCE:
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31712 of 2025
The candidates who are eligible and claim under
OC/Economically Weaker Section (EWS) category must
secure not less than 55% of marks in each paper and not
less than 60% of marks in aggregate in the written
examination.
VI. VIVA VOCE:
The Viva Voce test will carry fifty (50) marks. Any
candidate who remain absent for the Viva Voce will be
deemed to have been disqualified for the selection.
VIII. MINIMUM AGGREGATE MARKS TO BE SECURED
IN THE WRITTEN EXAMINATION AND VIVA VOCE FOR
SELECTION TO THE POST OF DISTRICT JUDGE.
For the selection to the post of District Judge (Entry
Level) under Direct Recruitment, the candidate claims under
OC/EWS category must secure at least 60% marks in
aggregate in the Written Examination and Viva Voce, the
candidate of BC category and intend to avail reservation
under B.C. category must secure at least 55% marks in
aggregate in the written examination and Viva-Voce (in view
of orders of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh in W.P.Nos.
7965 of 2019 and another), and the candidate of SC/ST
category and intend to avail reservation under SC/ST must
secure at least 50% marks in aggregate in written
examination and Viva Voce. The candidates who secure less
than the above such percentage of marks will be ineligible
for selection to the post.”
10.
The amended Rule 6, which was issued on 28.01.2025,
reads as under:
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31712 of 2025
“Provided that the candidates shall secure 40% of marks in
Paper-III English (Translation and Essay writing test) and the
marks secured in Paper-III shall not be taken into account
for eligibility for viva voce or selection. The marks secured in
Paper-I, Paper-ll and viva voce shall be taken into account
for selection."
11.
The law regarding the sanctity of recruitment process and
changes in eligibility criteria and procedure after initiation of the
recruitment process is well-settled. The Hon'ble Apex Court, in a
series of judgments, held that "rules of game", meaning thereby,
i.e., criteria for selection cannot be altered by the authorities in
middle or after process of selection has commenced.
12.
Recently, in Abhay Kumar Patel and Others4, while
reviewing the law on the aforesaid aspect, the Hon'ble Apex Court
held as under:
“34. In the present case, the "game" had not only
commenced but was at its fag end. The written examinations
were held in March 2022. The results were declared in
June/July 2022. The candidates were called for document
verification. At this stage, the selection process had
proceeded significantly, and would have concluded with the
filling up of vacancies.
35. The issuance of the 2022 Amendment Rules, introducing
Rule 8(5) with retrospective effect from 06.03.2019, attempts
to rewrite the rules of the game which has already begun.
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31712 of 2025
By reducing the weightage of the written examination to 75
marks and introducing 25 marks for contractual experience,
the State has fundamentally altered the basis of selection
and changed the 'eligibility criteria for being placed in the
merit list' which is not permissible.
36. While the State undoubtedly has the power to amend
rules under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of
India, this power is not unbridled. The power of retrospective
legislation cannot be exercised to take away vested rights or
to arbitrarily disrupt a selection process that has already
resulted in the identification of successful candidates by
publication of a provisional merit list.”
13.
Learned counsel for petitioner sought to place reliance on
the judgment in Vatika Township Private Limited1, even in the
said case, the Hon'ble Apex Court, dealing with legislation
conferring benefit on some persons without inflicting corresponding
detriment to some other person, in said context, held that
procedural provisions would have to be treated as applying
retrospectively. In the present case, change of criteria of marks
would definitely not be procedural in nature, but rather is
substantive. There could be other candidates who also might
benefit in case rule was to be applied retrospectively. Therefore,
given the facts and circumstances, we are of the view that above
judgment sought to be relied has no application. Insofar as the
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31712 of 2025
judgment in Ajay Kumar Shyam Kishore Tripathi2 is concerned,
the Hon’ble Apex Court, being conscious of the fact that a
substantial part of vacancies remain unfilled, that in all only 13
candidates against 42 vacancies were filled, cases of petitioners
therein were directed to be considered sympathetically by High
Court having regard to vacancies available and unfilled, which
ultimately was left to the discretion of the High Court therein, which,
in our respectful view, cannot be applied to the facts in the present
case.
14.
Thus, we find no merit in the writ petition. Accordingly, the
same stands dismissed. No costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending consideration,
if any, in this case shall stand closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
SS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review