Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
~`APHC010622852018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3459]
FRIDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 29713/2018
Between:
1. KOLA SUGUNA, W/O.PRABHAKARA RAO, AGED ABOUT 65
YEARS, HINDU,
R/O.LAWYERPET, ONGOLE, PRAKASAM
DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP. BY ITS PRL.
SECRETARY,
REVENUE
DEPARTMENT,
VELAGAPUDI,
AMARAVATHI, GUNTUR DISTRICT.
2. THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR, ONGOLE, PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
3. THE REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER, ONGOLE, PRAKASAM
DISTRICT.
4. THE TAHSILDAR, TANGUTUR,
TANGUTUR MANDAL,
PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in
the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may
be pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction, more in the
nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the 4th respondent in
issuing Form-I notices dt.02-06-2018 in respect of petitioner schedule land
in Sy.No.426-2, admeasuring 0-18 cents, Sy.No.426-7 admeasuring 0-87
cents and land in Sy.No.426-3 admeasuring 0-60 cents and 426-5
admeasuring 0-58 cents situated in Vallur Village, Tangutur Mandal,
Prakasam District without following the procedure contemplated under
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
Rule 3 of A.P. Assign Land (Prohibition) Act, 2007 as highly illegal,
arbitrary against all canons of fair play and natural justice and offends
Articles 14, 21, 300A of the constitution of India and also contrary to
procedure contemplated under A.P. Assign Land (Prohibition of Transfer)
Act, 1977 and consequently set aside the same and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
pleased to stay all further proceedings in pursuance of Form-I notices
dt.02-06-2018 including interference with possession of petitioner schedule
land in Sy.No.426-2, admeasuring 0-18 cents, Sy.No.426-7 admeasuring
0-87 cents and land in Sy.No.426-3 admeasuring 0-60 cents and 426-5
admeasuring 0-58 cents situated in Vallur Village, Tangutur Mandal,
Prakasam District pending disposal of the above writ petition and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SITA RAM CHAPARLA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR ASSIGNMENT (AP)
This Court made the following:
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
ORDER:
Whether the impugned Form-I notice, issued by the 4th respondent
to the vendor, the original assignee, without serving the corresponding
Form-II notice on the current possessor (subsequent purchaser),
constitutes a gross violation of the mandatory procedure under Rule 3 of
the A.P. Assigned Lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Rules, 2007, thereby
violates the principles of natural justice (audi alteram partem) and
rendering the proceeding liable to be set aside?
2.
Heard Sri Sitaram Chaparla, learned counsel for the petitioner, and
learned Government Pleader for Revenue appearing on behalf of the
respondents.
3.
The petitioner is the owner and possessor of land measuring
Ac.0.18 cents in Sy No. 426-2 and Ac.0.87 cents in Sy No. 426-7 of Vallur
Village, Tangutur Mandal, Prakasam District. On 6 May 1975, the
petitioner entered into an agreement of sale with the vendor, Smt.
Paladugu Akkamma. Subsequently, the vendor sold Ac.0.18 cents to M.
Padmavathamma, who, following mediation by the village elders,
transferred the land back to the petitioner vide a registered sale deed
(Document No. 1071/1977) on 26 March 1997. Additionally, Smt. Paladugu
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
Akkamma registered the sale deed (Document No. 5320/1995) on 6
November 1995 in favour of the petitioner.
4.
The petitioner has been in continuous possession of the property for
over 20 years as at the date of the impugned notice dated 2-6-2018. The
Form-I notice was issued to the petitioner‘s vendor under Rule 3 of the
Rules, 2007. The petitioner‘s counsel submits that, prior to taking action
under Clauses (a) and (b) of Section 4(1) of the Act, 1977, the District
Collector or the authorised officer is required to issue notices in both Form
I and Form II to the transferor and transferee. In the present case, only
Form-I notice was issued; no Form-II notice was issued. Therefore, the
respondents have violated the prescribed legal procedure, and the Form-I
notice must be quashed. Additionally, the failure to issue a Form-II notice
to the actual possessor (the petitioner) constitutes a violation of the
principles of natural justice.
The counsel for the petitioner has relied on
the following citations:
a)
Sudalagunta Sugars Ltd., Chittoor District, A.P. Vs. Joint
Collector, Chittoor, Chittoor District, reported in 2017 (2) ALD 529 –
wherein a learned Single Judge of the common High Court of Andhra
Pradesh held as follows:
“21. The Government through G.O.Ms. No. 208 Revenue
(Assn.-POT) dated 22.02.2007 framed the A.P. Assigned
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
Lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Rules, 2007. Rule 3 has laid
down the procedure for eviction of the transferee and taking
possession and restoration of assigned lands. Rule 3 reads
thus:
3. Procedure for eviction of the Transferee and taking
possession and restoration of Assigned Lands : - The District
Collector or the Authorized Officer shall, before taking action
under clauses (a) and (b) sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the
Act, issue notices in Form No. 1 and Form II to the persons
who have transferred and also to the persons who have
acquired any assigned land in contravention of the provisions
of sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the Act. The notices shall be
served by delivering a copy on Transferor and transferee or
some adult male member of the family of such transferor or
transferee at their usual place of abode or to their authorized
agent or by affixing a copy thereof at some conspicuous place
of their last known place of residence or on some conspicuous
part of the assigned land. After the expiry of (fifteen) 15 days
specified in the notice, the District Collector or the Authorized
Officer shall consider the representation, if any, received with
reference to the said notice and pass such order as he thinks
fit and proper. If it is held that the provisions of sub-sections (1)
and (2) of Section 3 of the Act, have been contravened in
respect of any assigned land, a copy of the order shall be
communicated to the Village Officer concerned under whose
territorial jurisdiction that land is situated for taking possession
of the land and thereupon the land shall be disposed of in
accordance with the provisions of Section 1 of the Act.
(emphasis added)
22. The answer to the point under consideration firstly
depends on interpretation of Rule.3. Plain and literal
construction of Rule 3 leads to the following results:
i)
The District Collector or authorized officer shall issue
notices in Form-I and Form-II before taking action under
clauses (a) and (b) of sub section (1) of Section 4 of the
Act to persons who have transferred and also to the
persons who have acquired any assigned land in
contravention of sub section (2) of Section 3 of the Act.
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
ii)
The notices are directed to be served by delivering a
copy on transferor and transferee or on some adult
person etc. as stated therein.
iii)
The District Collector or authorized officer is under
obligation to consider the representation, if any, with
reference to the said notice and pass such order as he
thinks fit and proper.
iv)
The copy of order is also directed to be communicated to
the Village Officer. (emphasis added)
xxxx
xxxxxx
xxxxxx
xxxxx
24. Unless and until this jurisdictional fact is decided with
reference to assignment, order of assignment, conditions on
which assignment made, the mere issuance of notice in FormII to transferee will not serve the purpose of hearing or
considering the objections. The forms under the Rules cannot
guide literal meaning of Rule 3 of the Rules. On the other hand,
if a restricted meaning as sought to be canvassed by the
learned Government Pleader is accepted, then transferee is
heard only on the eviction but not on the valuable defences
available to him in the enquiry conducted by the District
Collector or authorized officer. After considering the totality of
scheme of Act, Rules and the content of notices in Form-I and
Form-II, this Court is of the view that whenever action under
Section 4 of the Act is initiated by the District Collector or
authorized officer, the authority is required to issue notices in
Form-I and Form-II to the assignee and the transferee from the
assignee.‖
b)
When a similar issue came up for consideration, a Division Bench of
this Court in State of Andhra Pradesh v. Kota Venkata Ramana,
reported in 2024 Supreme (AP) 609 and 2024 APHC 28216, held as
follows:
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
―17. The admitted case on both sides is that Form-I notices
have been issued to the original assignees and no Form-II
notice had been issued to them. Similarly, Form-II notices were
issued to the purchasers and persons claiming through them
and no Form-I notice had been issued to them.
20. A learned single judge of the erstwhile High Court of
Andhra Dasari Narayana Rao v. Deputy Collector and Mandal
Revenue Officer, had laid down certain mandatory guidelines,
which are as follows:
16. In Vatticherukuri Village Panchayat v. Nori V. Deekshithulu,
1991 Supp (2) SCC 228, the Supreme Court explained the
principle:
―23. The jurisdiction of a tribunal created under statute may
depend upon the fulfilment of some condition precedent or upon
existence of some particular fact. Such a fact is collateral to the
actual matter which the tribunal has to try and the determination
whether it existed or not is logically temporary prior to the
determination of the actual question which the tribunal has to
consider. At the inception of an enquiry by a tribunal of limited
jurisdiction, when a challenge is made to its jurisdiction, the
tribunal has to consider as the collateral fact whether it would
act or not and for that purpose to arrive at some decision as to
whether it has jurisdiction or not. There may be tribunal which
by virtue of the law constituting it has the power to determine
finally, even the preliminary facts on which the further exercise
of its jurisdiction depends; but subject to that, the tribunal
cannot by a wrong decision with regard to collateral fact, give
itself a jurisdiction which it would not otherwise have had‖.
17. Much earlier, a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in
T.C. Basappa v. T. Nagappa, AIR 1954 SC 440, while dealing
with the scope of a writ of certiorari approved the principle
evolved in Bunbury v. Fuller, (1853) 9 EX. 111; and R v. Income
Tax Special Purposes Commissioners, (1888) 22 QBD 313, and
held that when the jurisdiction of the Court depends upon the
existence of some collateral fact, the Court cannot by a wrong
decision of the fact give itself jurisdiction which it would not
otherwise possess.
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
18. In the light of the above principles as to the jurisdictional
limits of a Tribunal of limited jurisdiction, it is clear that a correct
conclusion as to the land in the possession of the petitioners
being ―assigned land‖ (as this expression is defined in Section
2(1) of the 1977 Act); and the such conclusion arrived at on the
basis of the evidence on record; such evidence having been
recorded after due opportunity to the aggrieved petitioners, is a
condition precedent to the exercise of power under Section 4(1)
of the Act.
23. In the considered view of this Court the show-cause notice
dated 16.2.2002 is itself invalid. The minimum requirement of a
show-cause notice, in the context of an action initiated under
the provisions of the 1977 Act is (a) it should assert that there
was an assignment of land either under the provisions of the
1977 Act or under any Rules for the time being in force subject
to a condition of non-alienation; that such ―assigned land‖ was
transferred by such assignee in contravention of the prohibition
of alienation clause contained in the deed of assignment; (b) it
should assert that the respondents to the show-cause notice
had entered upon possession of ―assigned land‖ under a deed
of transfer which is invalid under the provisions of Section 3 of
the 1977 Act. The show-cause notice must of necessity contain
such factual assertions to enable the recipient (of the notice) to
rationally respond and submit his objections, if any, to the
proceedings initiated against him under the provisions of the
1977 Act. Issuance of a show-cause notice is not an empty
ritual. It should provide a reasonable and fair opportunity to the
recipient of the show-cause notice to defend his title and
possession of, the valuable right to property.
24. The procedure for taking steps under Section 4 is set out in
Rule 3 of the Rules. Rule 3 of the Rules is set out below: Rule
3.-- Procedure for eviction of the transferee and taking
possession and restoration of assigned lands:- The District
Collector or the Authorised Officer shall, before taking action
under clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the
Act, issue notices in Form No.1 and Form II to the persons who
have transferred and also to the persons who have acquired
any assigned land in contravention of the provisions of subsection (2) of Section 3 of the Act. The notices shall be served
by delivering a copy on transferor and transferee or some adult
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
male member of the family of such transferor or transferee at
their usual place of abode or to their authorised agent or by
affixing a copy thereof at some conspicuous place of their last
known place of residence or on some conspicuous part of the
assigned land. After the expiry of (fifteen) 15 days specified in
the notice, the District Collector or the Authorised Officer shall
consider the representation, if any, received with reference to
the said notice and pass such orders as he thinks fit and proper.
If it is held that the provisions of sub-sections (1) and (2) of
Section 3 of the Act, have been contravened in respect of any
assigned land, a copy of the order shall be communicated to the
Village Officer concerned under whose territorial jurisdiction the
land is situated for taking possession of the land and thereupon
the land shall be disposed of in accordance with the provisions
of Section 4 of the Act.
35. This would mean that a common hearing or common
proceedings would have to be initiated against both assignee
and the transferee. In such a situation both the assignee and
the transferee would have to be apprised of the case against
both of them. Though, the assignee would have to primarily
respond to the notice given in Form-I, he would also have to be
served with Form-II so that the assignee knows what the case is
against the transferee. Similarly, though the transferee
essentially would answer the case against him sent under
Form-II he is entitled to know what the case against the
assignee is. In some cases, the assignee may be apathetic,
after alienating the land and the burden of defending his
possession of the land may be on the transferee. In such
circumstances, the service of notice in Form I, on the
transferee, is necessary. The converse situation may also arise
requiring the assignee to defend the case of the transferee also.
Failure to serve such notices would leave the assignee and the
transferee with inadequate information, which would amount to
violation of principles of natural justice.‖
The relevant aspect was duly considered by a learned Single Judge
of this Court in paragraph 24 of the order in W.P. No. 18226 of 2019
(Baimuthaka Yashoda v. State of Andhra Pradesh, reported in 2020
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
Supreme (AP) 733), in which the writ petition was allowed, directing the
respondent authorities to issue a fresh notice to the petitioner.
c)
Gummadi Subba Rao vs. the Tahsildar, Iragavaram Mandal,
West Godavari, and others, as reported in 2020 Supreme (AP) 863,
wherein a learned Single Judge of this Court held thus:
―26. Though there is a dispute regarding identity of the
property, this Court need not decide the issue as to the identity
of the property, since it is a question of fact, apart from that as
per discussion in earlier paragraphs, notice itself is defective
and contrary to the principles of natural justice and Rule 3 of
Rules, 2007; notice impugned in the petition is declared as
illegal, arbitrary and contrary to Rule 3 of Rules, 2007 and the
same is liable to be set aside.‖
5.
It is evident from the record that the Form-I notice was issued to the
petitioner‘s vendor, Paladugu Anakamma, referencing the transferee as
Kola Suguna W/o L. Prabhakar Rao. The transfer involved is a registered
sale.
6.
Learned Government Pleader for Revenue, based on written
instructions, submits that Form-I notice was issued to the original assignee
as per the Andhra Pradesh Assigned Lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Act,
1977. It is stated that the petitioner purchased the scheduled land from the
original assignee in violation of the conditions of the DKT patta which
prohibits alienation. Furthermore, Form-II notice was issued to the
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
subsequent purchaser also i.e., the petitioner.
The instructions further
reveal that there has been no active cultivation on ground in the subject
land. Consequently, the respondents pray to dismiss the writ petition, as
the land was alienated in contravention to the grant of assignment
rendering the sale void.
7.
The term assigned land is defined in Section 2(1) of the Andhra
Pradesh Assigned Lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Act, 1977.
Assigned land: means lands assigned by the Government to landless
poor person(s) under the rules for the time being in force, subject to the
condition of non-alienation, and includes lands allotted or transferred to
landless poor persons under the relevant law for the time being in force
relating to land ceilings; and the word ‗assigned‘ shall be construed
accordingly.
8.
Section 3 of the Act, 1977, pertains to the prohibition of transfer of
assigned lands, as outlined below:
―3.
Prohibition of transfer of assigned lands.—(1)
Where, before or after the commencement of this Act any land
has been assigned by the Government to a landless poor
person for purposes of cultivation or as a house-site then,
notwithstanding anything to the contrary in any other law for
the time being in force or in the deed of transfer or other
document relating to such land, it shall not be transferred and
shall be deemed never to have been transferred; and
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
accordingly no right or title in such assigned land shall vest in
any person acquiring the land by such transfer.
(2) No landless poor person shall transfer any assigned land,
and no person shall acquire any assigned land, either by
purchase, gift, 6[Lease (except in the case of Lease to the
Andhra Pradesh Green Energy Corporation Ltd., for use as
deemed fit and including for usage of non-agriculture
purpose)], mortgage, exchange or otherwise.
[(2A) No assignee shall transfer any assigned house site, and
no person shall acquire any assigned house site, either by
purchase, gift, 8[Lease (except in the case of Lease to the
Andhra Pradesh Green Energy Corporation Ltd., for use as
deemed fit and including for usage of non-agriculture
purpose)], mortgage, exchange or otherwise, till completion of
the period of 20 years from the date of assignment.
(2B) Where the assigned House site was alienated by the
assignee as on the date of commencement of this Act, such
house site shall be regularized in favour of the alienee as a
one-time measure.
(2C) The eligible family shall be assigned house site only once
in life time.]
(3) Any transfer or acquisition made in contravention of the
provision of sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) 9[or sub-section
(2A)] shall be deemed to be null and void.
(4) The Provisions of this section shall apply to any transaction
of the nature referred to in sub-section (2) in execution of a
decree or order of a civil court or of any award or order of any
other authority.
(5) Nothing in this section shall apply to an assigned land
which was purchased by a landless poor person in good faith
and for valuable consideration from the original assignee or
his transferee prior to the commencement of this Act and
which is in the possession of such person for purposes of
cultivation or as a house-site on the date of such
commencement.‖
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
9.
The notice in Rc.DT.67/2018, dated 02.06.2018, issued by the 4th
respondent is hereby examined. It is found that said notice was issued in
flagrant violation of Rule 3 of the Andhra Pradesh Assigned Lands
(Prohibition of Transfers) Rules, 2007. These Rules mandate strict
adherence to the prescribed procedural requirement of issuing prior notice
before the resumption of assigned lands under Sections 3 and 4 of the
Andhra Pradesh Assigned Lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Act, 1977.
10.
While Section 3 of the Act, 1977 prohibits the transfer of assigned
land to any third party and deems any transfer, acquisition or sale made in
violation thereof null and void, implying that no right or title vests in the
subsequent purchaser, the mandatory procedural requirements under Rule
3 of the Rules, 2007 must still be adhered to by the authorities before
resumption.
11.
Although the written instructions state that Form-I and Form-II
notices were issued to both the original assignee and the subsequent
purchaser, no material has been filed to demonstrate that Form-II notice
was actually served on the petitioner. In the absence of such material, this
Court cannot hold that Form-II notice was served to the petitioner. The
authorities or the authorized officer is legally required to serve a notice in
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
Form-I to the original assignee/transferor and a notice in Form-II to the
subsequent purchaser/person in possession. These notices must contain
specific details, including the survey number, the extent of land, the
original allotee's name and the date of allotment.
12.
In the present case, the respondent authorities served notice only to
the vendor and failed to serve the mandatory Form-II notice to the
subsequent purchaser, particularly when the purchaser is in possession
and their name appears in the revenue records. The entire resumption
process is, therefore, flawed and constitutes a breach of mandatory
procedural requirement as established in Sudalagunta Sugars Limited v.
the Joint Collector, Chittoor and another (2017 (1) ALT 499) and the
case of the State of Andhra Pradesh v. Kota Venkata Ramana (2024
Supreme (AP) 609).
13.
Having considered the settled legal position, this Court deems it
appropriate to set aside the impugned notice.
14.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is allowed and the Impugned Form-I
notice dated 02.06.2018 issued by the 4th respondent is set aside. No
order as to costs.
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
However, this order will not preclude the respondent authorities from
initiating fresh proceedings in accordance with law and strictly following the
procedural guidelines laid down in the Andhra Pradesh Assigned Lands
(Prohibition of Transfers) Rules, 2007.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any pending, shall stand
closed.
_________________________
JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
10th April, 2026
cbs
JS,J
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
W.P.No.29713 of 2018
10th April, 2026
cbs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review