The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
02. 01.2026, whereby, the mandate of Learned Arbitrator was extended by this Court, with directions to conclude the arbitral proceedings within six months from the date of receipt of copy of the judgment.
13. Taking into account the entirety of the facts and circumstances and the object and intent of arbitral proceedings, this Court disposes of the instant petition, in the following terms:(i) Order dated 22.02.2025 [Annexure P-1], in Case No. 12 of 2023 passed by Learned Arbitrator-cum-Divisional Commissioner, Mandi, Singh In Re: Kismat Versus National Highway Authority of India is quashed and set aside; (ii) Arbitrator-cum- Divisional Commissioner, Mandi, is mandated to complete the arbitral proceedings and to pass the Award, in accordance with law within six months from the date of receipt of copy of this judgment; and (iii) Costs made easy for respective parties. - 14 - 2026:HHC:3290 2025:HHC:39284 In aforesaid terms, the instant petition is allowed and all pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also, stand disposed of, accordingly. January 09, 2026 [G.M] (Ranjan Sharma) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:3290
2025:HHC:39284
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
Arbitration Case No: 19 of 2026
Decided on : 09th January, 2026
__________________________________________________________
Kismat Singh
...Petitioner
Versus
The Land Acquisition Officer, NHAI
and another
...Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge
1 Whether approved for reporting?
For the petitioner
: Mr. Karam Pal, Advocate.
For the respondent
:
Ms.
Shreya
Advocate
for
No. 1.
Chauhan,
respondents
Mr.
Amit
K.
Chauhary,
Deputy Advocate General for
respondents No. 2 to 4.
Ranjan Sharma, Judge
Petitioner, Kismat Singh has come up before
this Court in instant petition filed under Section 29-A
of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, seeking
following relief(s):“
That
the
period
from
28.01.2025
onwards may kindly be extended for a
reasonable time.”
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
-2-
2026:HHC:3290
2025:HHC:39284
Upon listing of the case today Ms. Shreya
2.
Chauhan, Advocate and Mr. Amit K. Chaudhary,
Learned
Deputy
appearance
Advocate
on
behalf
of
General
have
respondent
put
in
No.1
&
respondents No.2 and 3, respectively. They jointly
submit that no reply is intended to be filed in the
instant matter in view
matters relating
of the fact that
to the same
subject
in identical
extension for
mandate has been allowed by this Court.
3.
On query by this Court, Learned Counsel
for the petitioner submits that identical matters have
been
allowed
by
granting
extension
to
Learned
Arbitrator-cum-Divisional Commissioner, Mandi, (HP)
for concluding the arbitral proceedings.
4.
In above backdrop, this Court, proceeds to
dispose of the instant petition, without the reply
having been filed, at this stage itself, which shall only
expedite the conclusion of arbitral proceedings, in
which parties herein have participated since the year
2023, till the passing of the Impugned Order on
22.02.2025 [Annexure P-1].
-3-
2026:HHC:3290
5.
to
the
2025:HHC:39284
Grievance of the petitioner is that pursuant
passing
parties
of
the
Award
offered
by
CALA
themselves
concerned,
for
arbitral
proceedings, before Learned Arbitrator-cum-Divisional
Commissioner, Mandi, who commenced the arbitral
proceedings vide Case No. 12/2023. It is averred that
though arbitral proceedings continued since 2023 but
Learned Arbitrator passed an order on 22.02.2025
[Annexure P-1]. for keeping the arbitral proceedings in
abeyance. It is in this background, the present petition
has been filed, with the prayer to direct Learned
Arbitrator to conclude the arbitral proceedings within a
stipulated period by extending the time for concluding
the arbitral proceedings under Section 29 A (4) & 5
of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, by quashing
the order dated 22.02.2025 [Annexure P-1].
6.
Heard, Mr. Karam Pal, Advocate for the
petitioner, Ms. Shreya Chauhan, Advocate for the
respondents-National
Highway
Authority
of
India
and Mr. Amit.K. Chaudhary, Learned Deputy Advocate
General for respondents No. 2 to 4.
-4-
2026:HHC:3290
7.
2025:HHC:39284
Ms. Shreya Chauhan, Learned Counsel
for the respondents, does not dispute the factual
matrix that the arbitral proceedings commenced in the
year
and
since
then,
the
parties
have
participated in these proceedings. It is not in dispute
that
in
other
identical
cases
relating
to
the
same subject-land though the arbitral proceedings
were kept in abeyance and the mandate of the
Arbitrator was terminated but consequent upon the
intervention
of
enlarged/extended
this
Court,
the
for
concluding
time
the
was
arbitral
proceedings. Pursuant to the orders passed in similar
cases arbitral process are underway and/or in some
case the same have been concluded.
8.
While dealing with a similar fact-situation,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in TATA Sons Pvt. Ltd.
(Formerly TATA Sons Ltd.) vs. Siva Industries and
Holdings Ltd. and others, reported in 2023 (1)
SCALE 793, held that the mandate of an Arbitrator is
liable to be extended by the Court, under Section
29A(4) and 29A(5) of the Act, in the following terms:-
-5-
2026:HHC:3290
“24
The provisions of Section 29A, as
originally introduced into the statute,
mandated that all awards shall be
made within a period of twelve months
from the date on which the arbitral
tribunal enters upon the reference. The
explanation clarified when the arbitral
tribunal would be deemed to have
entered upon the reference, namely, the
date on which the arbitrator has
received
written
notice
of
the
appointment. The mandatory nature of
the provisions of Section 29A(1) and
their application to all arbitrations
conducted under the Act, domestic or
international commercial, was evident
from the use of the word “shall”. In
terms of Section 29A(4), in case the
arbitral award was not rendered
within the twelve or eighteen month
period as the case may be, the
mandate of the arbitrator(s) would
stand terminated, unless on an
application made by any of the
parties, the court extended time on
sufficient cause being shown.
xxxx.
26.
2025:HHC:39284
xxx…
xxx..
Sub-section
(3)
of
Section
29A
empowers parties, by consent, to
extend the period specified in subsection (1) for making the award by a
further period not exceeding six
months. Thereafter, if the award is not
made within the period which is
specified in sub-section (1) or the
extended period specified in sub-section
(3), the mandate of the arbitrator shall
terminate unless the court has
extended the period either prior to or
after the expiry of the period so
2026:HHC:3290
-6-
2025:HHC:39284
specified. In other words, the timeline
of twelve months for making the
award (in matters other than
international
commercial
arbitration), is qualified by the
consensual entrustment to the
parties under sub-section (3) to extend
the period by six months after which the
court is empowered in terms of subsection (4) to extend the period for
making the award. The submission of
the second respondent is that the
provisions of sub-section (3) and subsection (4) must also apply to an
international commercial arbitration.
This would merit close scrutiny. The
legislature has not expressly excluded
the applicability of sub-sections (3) and
(4) of Section 29A to an international
commercial arbitration. But, at the
same time, it must be noticed that
the rationale underlying sub-section
(3) is to ensure that despite the
stipulation of twelve months for the
making of an arbitral award in the
domestic context, parties may by
consent agree to an extension of
time by a further period of six
months. Such an extension of six
months is envisaged in the case of a
domestic arbitration since there is a
mandate that the award shall be
made within a period of twelve
months. A further extension has,
however, been entrusted to the court
in terms of sub-section (4) of
Section29A. However, insofar as an
international commercial arbitration is
concerned, the statutory regime is clear
by the substantive part of sub-section 1
of Section 29A in terms of which the
timeline of twelve months for making
-7-
2026:HHC:3290
2025:HHC:39284
an arbitral award is not applicable to it.
In
an
international
commercial
arbitration, the legislature has only
indicated that the award should be
made as expeditiously as possible and
that an endeavour may be made to
dispose of the matter within a period of
twelve months from the completion of
pleadings.”
(emphasis supplied)
9.
While dealing with a similar situation,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in Civil Appeal No.
10620 of 2024 [Arising out of Special Leave
Petition
Rohan
(Civil)
No.23320
Builders (India)
of
2023]
Private
titled
Limited
as
versus
Berger Paints India Limited, decided on 12.09.2024,
has
reiterated
that
mandate
of
an
Arbitrator
is liable to be extended in view of sufficient cause to
the satisfaction of the Court, in the following terms:“15. Rohan Builders (India) Pvt. Ltd. (supra)
highlights
that
an
interpretation
allowing an extension application post
the expiry period would encourage
rogue litigants and render the timeline
for making the award inconsequential.
However, it is apposite to note that
under Section 29A(5), the power of
the court to extend the time is to be
exercised only in cases where there
is
sufficient
cause
for
such
extension. Such extension is not
-8-
2026:HHC:3290
2025:HHC:39284
granted mechanically on filing of the
application. The judicial discretion of
the court in terms of the enactment
acts as a deterrent against any party
abusing the process of law or espousing
a frivolous or vexatious application.
Further, the court can impose terms
and conditions while granting an
extension. Delay, even on the part of
the
arbitral
tribunal,
is
not
countenanced.28 The first proviso to
Section 29A(4) permits a fee reduction
of up to five percent for each month of
delay attributable to the arbitral
tribunal.
16.
Lastly, Section 29A(6) does not support
the narrow interpretation of the
expression “terminate”. It states that
the court – while deciding an extension
application under Section 29A(4) – may
substitute one or all the arbitrators.
Section 29A(7) states that if a new
arbitrator(s)
is
appointed,
the
reconstituted arbitral tribunal shall be
deemed to be in continuation of the
previously appointed arbitral tribunal.
This obliterates the need to file a fresh
application under Section 11 of the A &
C Act for the appointment of an
arbitrator. In the event of substitution
of arbitrator(s), the arbitral proceedings
will commence from the stage already
reached. Evidence or material already
on record is deemed to be received by
the newly constituted tribunal. The
aforesaid
deeming
provisions
underscore the legislative intent to
effectuate efficiency and expediency in
the arbitral process. This intent is also
demonstrated in Sections 29A(8) and
29A(9). The court in terms of Section
-9-
2026:HHC:3290
2025:HHC:39284
29A(8) has the power to impose actual
or exemplary costs upon the parties.
Lastly, Section 29A(9) stipulates that an
application for extension under subsection (5) must be disposed of
expeditiously, with the endeavour of
doing so within sixty days from the date
of filing.
17.
As per the second proviso to Section
29A(4), the mandate of the arbitral
tribunal continues where an application
under sub-section (5) is pending.
However,
an
application
for
extension of period of the arbitral
tribunal is to be decided by the court
in terms of sub-section (5), and subsections (6) to (8) may be invoked.
The power to extend time period for
making of the award vests with the
court, and not with the arbitral
tribunal. Therefore, the arbitral
tribunal may not pronounce the
award till an application under
Section 29A(5) of the A & C Act is
sub-judice before the court. In a given
case, where an award is pronounced
during the pendency of an application
for extension of period of the arbitral
tribunal, the court must still decide the
application under sub-section (5), and
may even, where an award has been
pronounced, invoke, when required and
justified, sub-sections (6) to (8), or the
first and third proviso to Section 29A(4)
of the A & C Act.
18.
While interpreting a statute, we must
strive to give meaningful life to an
enactment
or
rule
and
avoid
cadaveric consequences that result
in unworkable or impracticable
- 10 -
2026:HHC:3290
2025:HHC:39284
scenarios. An interpretation which
produces an unreasonable result is
not to be imputed to a statute if
there is some other equally possible
construction which is acceptable,
practical and pragmatic.”
10.
Even a perusal of the Statute prescribes
that arbitral proceedings are to be completed within 12
months and the same were extendable by 6 months
with
consent
of
parties.
Though,
the
arbitral
proceedings were to be completed within 18 months,
but
they
continued
from 2023
order
22.02.2025
impugned
on
till
the
passing
[Annexure
P-1]
,whereby, the mandate of the Learned Arbitrator stood
terminated and the arbitral proceedings were kept in
abeyance. Material on record suggests that, even
after
expiry
of
months
period,
the
arbitral
proceedings were delayed primarily at the instance of
respondent;
due
and
due
to
procedural
delays
and
to administrative delays, for which parties
cannot be made to suffer. The parties have neither
objected to the continuance of arbitral proceedings
beyond permissible period nor placed any material to
- 11 -
2026:HHC:3290
2025:HHC:39284
show that any of the parties had prayed or was granted
extension in arbitral proceedings by this Court, earlier.
11.
to
Respondents-NHAI
take
the
indisputably
plea
of
similar
cannot
delay
and
extension
be
permitted
laches
was
when,
given
to
other similarly placed landowners. Once the parties to
arbitral
proceedings,
including
the
Respondents-
NHAI had participated in the arbitral proceedings
beyond the permissible period, therefore, the mandate
of the Statute, [i.e. Arbitration and Conciliation Act]
was to be given a meaningful life, so as to make it
workable and practicable. Further, once the nonconclusion
of
attributable
the
to
arbitral
the
proceedings
petitioner;
was
not
therefore,
the
Respondents-NHAI cannot be permitted to raise the
plea of delay and laches, so as to defeat the object and
intent of the Enactment but efforts should be to make
it practical and pragmatic, so as to enable the parties
to settle their disputes by alternative resolution, in
an
effective,
efficient
and
expedient
manner
by
arbitration. In these circumstances, sufficient cause
- 12 -
2026:HHC:3290
2025:HHC:39284
for enlargement of time for concluding the arbitral
proceedings is made out, in facts of instant case.
12.
Parties are also ad idem that the matter
is squarely covered by the judgment of this Court in
Arbitration
Case
No.22
Ghanshyam
Mahajan
of
versus
2025,
titled
Land
Acquisition
as
Officer-cum-Competent Authority & Ors., decided
on 07.03.2025. Likewise, Learned Counsel(s) place
reliance on the judgment Arbitration Case No.811
of 2024, titled Hari Ram Versus Collector Land
Acquisition
India
&
National
Others,
Highways
decided
on
Authority
of
20.06.2025
and
Judgment in Arbitration Case No.126 of 2025 titled
Hari Singh Saini & Anr. Versus Land Acquisition
Officer
&
Another,
decided
on
27.06.2025;
Arbitration Case No. 332 of 2025, In re; Meena
Kumari Versus The Land Acquisition Officer and
another, decided on 19.11.2025; Arbitration Case
No.
of
2025,
In
Re;
Balak
Ram
Versus
Secretary National Highway Authority Delhi and
another, decided on
23.12.2025 and Arbitration
- 13 -
2026:HHC:3290
2025:HHC:39284
Case No. 367 of 2025, In re; Rajeev Kumar Verma
Versus Secretary National
another, decided on
High Authority and
02.01.2026, whereby, the
mandate of Learned Arbitrator was extended by this
Court,
with
directions
to
conclude
the
arbitral
proceedings within six months from the date of
receipt of copy of the judgment.
13.
Taking into account the entirety of the
facts and circumstances and the object and intent of
arbitral
proceedings, this
Court disposes
of the
instant petition, in the following terms:(i)
Order dated 22.02.2025 [Annexure P-1], in
Case No. 12 of 2023 passed
by Learned
Arbitrator-cum-Divisional
Commissioner,
Mandi,
Singh
In
Re:
Kismat
Versus
National Highway Authority of India is
quashed and set aside;
(ii)
Arbitrator-cum- Divisional Commissioner,
Mandi,
is
mandated
to
complete
the arbitral proceedings and to pass
the Award, in accordance with law within
six months from the date of receipt of copy
of this judgment; and
(iii)
Costs made easy for respective parties.
- 14 -
2026:HHC:3290
2025:HHC:39284
In aforesaid terms, the instant petition is
allowed and all pending miscellaneous application(s), if
any, shall also, stand disposed of, accordingly.
January 09, 2026
[G.M]
(Ranjan Sharma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review