Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:15780-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 1371 of 2025
Mukesh Lautre @ Mukku @ Monu S/o Ramesh Lautre Aged About 24 Years
R/o Adarsh Nagar, Sirgitti, Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur Chhattisgarh.
--- Appellant
versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through - Station House Officer, Police Station Sirgitti
District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
--- Respondent
For Appellant
:
Mr. Y.C. Sharma, Senior Advocate along
with Mr. Ajay Kumar Chandra, Advocate
For Respondent/State
:
Mr. Priyank Rathi, Govt. Advocate
CRA No. 1858 of 2025
Jay Kumar @ Ajju S/o Krishna Kumar Yadav Aged About 23 Years R/o
Sardar Mohalla, Sirgitti, Bilaspur, District : Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
---Appellant
Versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through The District Magistrate Bilaspur (C.G.)
--- Respondent
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Digitally signed
by VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Date: 2026.04.13
19:42:42 +0530
For Appellant
:
Mr. Raj Kumar Gupta, Advocate
For Respondent/State
:
Mr. Priyank Rathi, Govt. Advocate
CRA No. 1528 of 2025
Abhishek Lal @ Lucky S/o Ajay Lal Aged About 23 Years R/o Durga Bada,
Govind Nagar, Police Station Sirgitti Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
---Appellant
Versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Station House Officer Sirgitti DistrictBilaspur (C.G.)
--- Respondent
For Appellant
:
Mr. Mohit Kumar, Advocate
For Respondent/State
:
Mr. Priyank Rathi, Govt. Advocate
CRA No. 1714 of 2025
Abhjeet Lal @ Vikku S/o Ajay Lal Aged About 21 Years R/o Durga Bada,
Govind Nagar, Police Station Sirgitti, Bilaspur, District : Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
---Appellant
Versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Station House Officer Sirgitti, District :
Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent
For Appellant
:
Mr. Mohit Kumar, Advocate
For Respondent/State
:
Mr. Priyank Rathi, Govt. Advocate
CRA No. 2098 of 2025
1 - Kishan Tanti @ Laalu @ Kunal S/o Late Vanshilal Tanti Aged About 21
Years R/o Sardar Mohalla, Sirgitti, District : Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
2 - Lucky Naidu @ Khebda Lucky S/o Ramdani Naidu Aged About 19 Years
R/o Mahima Nagar, Sirgitti, District : Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
---Appellants
Versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through Station House Officer, Police Station Sirgitti,
District : Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant
:
Mr. Sachin Nidhi, Advocate
For Respondent/State
:
Mr. Priyank Rathi, Govt. Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
07/04/2026
1.
All these criminal appeals are arising out of the same crime number,
same sessions trial and common judgment, therefore, they are being
heard and decided together.
2.
The CRA No. 1371 of 2025 has been filed by the appellant Mukesh
Lautre @ Mukku @ Monu, the CRA No. 1528 of 2025 has been filed
by the appellant Abhishek Lal @ Lucky, the CRA No. 1714 of 2025 has
been filed by the appellant Abhijeet Lal @ Vikku, the CRA No. 1858 of
2025 has been filed by the appellant Jay Kumar @ Ajju and the CRA
No. 2098 of 2025 has been filed by the appellant Kishan Tanti @ Laalu
@ Kunal and Lucky Naidu @ Khebda Lucky. All these appeals are filed
by the respective appellants against the impugned judgment of
conviction and sentence dated 25.06.2025, passed by learned 9 th
Additional Sessions Judge, Bilaspur, in Sessions Case No. 63 of 2020,
arising out of Crime No. 229 of 2020, registered at Police Station
Sirgitti Bilaspur, whereby the appellants have been convicted and
sentenced in the following manner:
CONVICTION
SENTENCE
Section 148/149 IPC
years
Imprisonment (R.I.)
Rigorous
Section 342/149 IPC (Twice)
01 year R.I. each for deceased
Yuvraj and injured Akash
(Separate)
Section 323/149 IPC
01 year R.I.
Section 302/149 IPC
Life Imprisonment + ₹2,000 fine
(In default: 01 year R.I.)
Section 396/149 IPC
Life Imprisonment + ₹2,000 fine
(In default: 01 year R.I.)
Section 201/149 IPC
07 years R.I. + ₹2,000 fine (In
default: 01 year R.I.)
Section 506 Part-II IPC (Twice)
05 years R.I. each for deceased
Yuvraj and injured Akash
(Separate)
All the sentences are directed to run concurrently.
3.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that, in the intervening period of
26.05.2020, 14:30 hrs. and 27.05.2020, 7:00 hrs., the accused
persons formed unlawful assembly at Adarsh Nagar, Sirgitti and in
furtherance thereof abused, illegally confined and threatened with dire
consequences to the deceased Yuvraj Khare and injured Akash
Banjare and assaulted them by wooden plank, hockey stick, clutch
wire and bamboo club and has committed murder of the deceased
Yuvraj Khare. They also committed dacoity of Rs. 1000/- from the
injured Akash and in order to conceal the offence, they took the dead
body of deceased Yuvraj by a Maestro two-wheeler vehicle and threw
the dead body near Ghumra Murum Khadan, Village Dhamni.
4.
On 27.05.2020, the injured Akash Banjare lodged a report to the police
that on 26.05.2020, at about 1:00 p.m. he and his cousin brother
Yuvraj Khare had gone to the house of accused Vicky and demanded
their borrowed amount, but he died not repay it rather he gave them
Rs. 100/- and asked to brought snacks for drinking liquor and called
them near water tank at an under construction house. He also assured
them that, Lucky and other persons were also present there and he too
is coming there. When they reached at the under construction house,
they found the accused Monu @ Mukesh, Lucky, Khebda Lucky, Jay
and his other friends were present. They also joined them and started
drinking liquor along with them.
5.
During this, there was some hot talk between Yuvraj and Monu @
Mukesh. Thereafter, the accused persons who were present there,
started marpeet with Yuvraj. They tied the hands of Yuvraj and Akash
and tied their mouth by Gamchha. They continuously assaulted them
by wooden plank, hockey stick, clutch wire, bamboo club, brick piece
and kicks. They also looted Rs. 1000/- from the injured Akash Banjare
and the accused Mukesh. Harish, Kishan and Vicky left them to their
house by the Maestro vehicle of Yuvraj. On 27.05.2020, at about 7:00
a.m. the injured Akash came to know that Yuvraj has died and then he
lodged the report against the accused persons. On the report of Akash
Banjare, the FIR (exhibit P-46) of Crime No. 229 of 2020 has been
registered against Monu @ Mukesh, Lucky, Vicky, Khebda Lucky, Jay
and his other friends for the offence under Sections 342, 323, 294,
393, 394, 302, 147, 148 and 149 of IPC.
6.
During the investigation, one Manish Sharma (PW-16), Sarpanch of
the village Dhamni gave a merg intimation (exhibit P-44) to the police
that a dead body is lying there at Ghumrao Murum Khadan in injured
condition and his Maestro vehicle and a carry bag is also lying there.
On being inquiry, the Chowkidar Bahoran informed him that 2-3
persons thrown the dead body and ran away towards village Nagpura.
Police reached there and prepared inquest (exhibit P-2) in presence of
the witnesses. The dead body was identified by Riddhram Banjare,
who was relative of the deceased and identification panchnama
(exhibit P-3) was prepared. The dead body was sent for its
postmortem to Community Health Centre, Bilha, where Dr. Nikita
Kanwar (PW-20) conducted the postmortem of the dead body and
gave the postmortem report (exhibit P-48). While conducting the
postmortem, the doctor noticed multiple bruises on right side of
forehead, over right and left eyes, both cheeks, which were variable
size, triangular and quadrangle, over nasal bridge, oval in shape,
multiple contusions on right side of neck variable size and length,
multiple contusions on whole chest, abdomen and both legs, both
hands and whole back. The doctor opined that cause of death is
cardio-respiratory arrest due to multiple blunt injuries and syncope.
7.
Th injured Akash Banjare (PW-17) was also sent for his medical
examination to District Hospital, Bilaspur where he was medically
examined by Dr. P.C. Banerjee (PW-13), who gave the MLC report
(exhibit P-38). While medically examining the injured, the doctor has
noticed the following injuries in his body.
* Contusion with redness- on back.
* Contusion with redness- left buttock (upper ½).
* Contusion with redness- right buttock (upper ½).
* Contusion with redness- left arm.
* Contusion with redness- right arm.
* Contusion with redness- upper ½ of left arm.
* Contusion with redness- upper ½ of right arm.
* Contusion with redness- right chest.
* Contusion with redness- left thigh.
* Contusion with redness- right thigh.
* Contusion with redness- left cheek.
All injuries were simple in nature caused by hard and blunt
object.
8.
The nature of death to be investigated by the police and it may be
homicidal. One DVR of CCTV footage of the spot has been seized vide
seizure memo (exhibit P-4), in which the accused persons were seen
to be carrying the dead body in the two-wheeler vehicle. A certificate
under Section 65-B of Evidence Act (exhibit P-5) with respect to the
authenticity of the CCTV footage was also obtained from Girish Kumar
Sahu (PW-4). One pen drive of CCTV footage has also been seized
from Manish Vishwakarma vide seizure memo (exhibit P-6) and the
certificate under Section 65 of the Evidence Act (exhibit P-7) has also
been obtained. The Maestro vehicle bearing registration No. CG 10 AB
6605 with keys and one carry bag contained with shirt and pant have
been seized from the spot and two items of Nano SIM cards have
been seized from the pocket of the pant of the deceased vide seizure
memo (exhibit P-8). The spot panchnama (exhibit P-9 and P-10) have
been prepared by the police in presence of the witnesses. Spot map
(exhibit P-47, P-58 and P-65) were prepared by the police.
9.
The accused persons were arrested on 27.05.2020 and the
memorandum statement of Abhishek Lal @ Lucky (exhibit P-12),
Harish Chouhan (exhibit P-13), Kishan Tanti @ Laalu @ Kunal (exhibit
P-14), Mukesh Lautre @ Monu @ Mukku (exhibit P-15), Abhijeet Lal
@ Vikku @ Vicky (exhibit P-16), Sumit Upvanshi @ Lepard (exhibit P17), Joy Lauka (exhibit P-18), Jay @ Ajju Yadav (exhibit P-19) were
recorded.
10.
From the accused Sumit Upvanshi, one wooden plank and clutch wire
have been seized vide seizure memo (exhibit P-20), from Jay @ Ajju
Yadav, one wooden plank and clutch wire have been seized vide
seizure memo (exhibit P-21), from the accused Abhijeet Lal @ Vikku
@ Vicky, one club, one belt and one mobile phone have been seized
vide seizure memo (exhibit P-22), from the accused Harish Chouhan,
one mobile phone and one wooden plank have been seized vide
seizure memo (exhibit P-23), from the accused Mukesh Lautre, one
mobile phone, one Royal Enfield motorcycle and Rs. 530/- cash have
been seized vide seizure memo (exhibit P-24) and one belt, one
chappel, one wooden plank, broken piece of hockey stick, broken
piece of belt, gamchha, shirt, empty liquor bottles, disposal glass and
chillum have been seized from the spot on the instance of the accused
Mukesh Lautre vide seizure memo (exhibit P-25). From Jay Lauka,
one wooden plank and clutch wire have been seized vide seizure
memo (exhibit P-26), from Abhishek Lal @ Lucky, one belt and one
bamboo plank have been seized vide seizure memo (exhibit P-27),
from accused Kishan Tanti @ Laalu, one belt has been seized vide
seizure memo (exhibit P-28). The seized articles were sent for its
query report to the doctor, who gave his query report (exhibit P-40) and
opined that the injuries found on the body of injured Akash Banjare
could have been caused by the said weapons. One unclaimed Aviator
two-wheelers vehicle bearing registration No. CG 10 EC 3708 with
keys have been seized from jungle area vide seizure memo (exhibit P46). The seized weapon were also sent for its query report to the
doctor, who conducted the postmortem of the dead body of the
deceased, who gave the query report (exhibit P-49) and opined that
the death may be possible by the sent objects, the nature of death may
be homicidal.
11.
Another CCTV footage in the DVR has been seized from Arjun Xaxa
(exhibit P-36) and the certificate (exhibit P-37) was also obtained from
Arjun Pratap Xaxa (PW-10). The accused persons were put to test
identification parade, which was conducted by the Executive
Magistrate, Bilaspur at Juvenile Remand Home, Sarkanda, Bilaspur
and the witnesses have duly identified the accused persons in the TIP
and the TIP memo (exhibit P-42, P-43) have been prepared.
12.
Statement of the witnesses under Section 161 of the CRPC have been
recorded and after completion of usual investigation, charge sheet was
filed against six arrested accused persons, one absconding accused
Lucky Naidu before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bilaspur and
against two juveniles in conflict with law before the learned Juvenile
Justice Board. The permanent warrant of arrest against the
absconding accused Lucky Naidu @ Lucky Khebda was issued by the
Judicial Magistrate First Class, Bilaspur vide order dated 07.09.2020,
however pursuant to the permanent arrest warrant issued against him,
he was arrested and produced before the learned Judicial Magistrate
First Class, Bilaspur on 18.09.2020 and a supplementary charge sheet
has been filed against him. The case was committed to the learned
Sessions
Judge,
Bilaspur
vide
order
dated
12.10.2020
and
subsequently the case was transferred to the learned trial Court for its
trial.
13.
The learned trial Court framed charges against all the accused persons
for the offence under Sections 148, 294, 506 Part-II, 342/149, 323/149,
302 read with Sections 149, 396 read with Sections 397 and 201 read
with Section 149 of the IPC. The accused persons denied the charge
and claimed trial.
14.
In order to prove the charges against the accused persons, the
prosecution examined as many as 23 witnesses. The statement under
Section 313 of CRPC of the accused persons have also been
recorded, in which they denied the circumstances, that appears
against them, pleaded innocence and have submitted that, they have
been falsely implicated in the offence.
15.
After appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence led by the
prosecution, the learned trial Court has convicted the accused persons
and sentenced them as mentioned in the earlier part of this judgment.
Hence these appeals by the respective appellants.
16.
Learned counsel appearing for the respective appellants would jointly
submit that, the allegation against all the accused persons are almost
common. There is no eyewitness to the incident and the injured
witness Akash Banjare has not fully supported the prosecution’s case
and
his
evidence
suffers
from
inconsistencies
and
material
discrepancies. The witnesses to the memorandum and seizure of
weapons of offence from the accused persons have not supported the
prosecution’s case and have turned hostile. There is no exact cause of
death that the deceased died due to the injuries and the doctor has
opined that the death of the deceased may be homicidal. They would
further submit that there is substantial difference in “may be” and “shall
be”. The prosecution has to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the
death of the deceased was homicidal in nature. The test identification
parade was neither conducted in accordance with law, nor has been
proved by the prosecution under its requirement to prove. The coaccused Harish Chouhan has been acquitted by the learned trial Court
on the same set of evidence and the appellants are also entitled for the
same relief as has been granted to him. They would further submit that
there is material omissions and contradictions in the evidence of
prosecution witnesses, which cannot be made basis to convict the
appellants for the offence in question. The prosecution has failed to
prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.
17.
In alternative, they would further submit that the alleged incident is
occurred in a heat of passion during drinking liquor by them and on a
trivial issue. No traditional weapon were issued by the accused
persons in commission of the offence. The act of the accused persons,
if it is found proved, does not travel beyond the scope of Section 304
of IPC and the conviction of the appellants is liable to be modified
under Section 304 Part-I or Part-II of IPC and their sentence may be
reduced for the period already undergone by them, as the accused
persons are in jail since 27.05.2020 and Lucky Naidu @ Khebda Lucky
since 18.09.2020.
18.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the State opposes the
submissions made by learned counsel for respective appellants in all
these appeals and submitted that the prosecution has proved its case
beyond reasonable doubt. But for minor omissions or contradictions,
their evidence are fully reliable and sufficient to hold guilty of the
appellants for the offence in question. The evidence of injured witness
Akash Banjare (PW-17) is the crucial piece of evidence. He duly
supported the prosecution’s case and involvement of the accused
persons in the offence in question. He detailed in his evidence about
the manner in which the offence is committed by the accused persons.
The accused persons have been named in the FIR, which has been
promptly lodged by the injured Akash Banjare. Further, the test
identification parade, the memorandum and seizure of the weapon of
offence have also been proved by the prosecution witnesses. The
number of injuries found on the body of the deceased as well as the
injured, clearly demonstrates that the deceased was intentionally
murdered by the accused persons. He would further submit that
brutally assaulting the deceased and injured cannot be said to be the
incident occurred in a heat of passion and therefore, there is no merit
in the submissions made by learned counsel for the respective
appellants and their appeals are liable to be dismissed.
19.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and considered their
rival submissions made hereinabove and also went through the
records with utmost circumspection.
20.
With respect to the homicidal death of the deceased, Manish Sharma
(PW-16) lodged the merg report that dead body is lying near Ghumra
Talab having injuries over it. Thereafter the unnumbered merg
intimation (exhibit P-44) was registered and it was identified by the
witnesses to be the dead body of deceased Yuvraj Khare. Inquest
(exhibit P-2) was prepared and then the dead body was sent for its
postmortem. In the inquest also, the injuries over the dead body have
been noticed by the witnesses. The eyewitness Akash Banjare (PW17) the assault made by the accused persons upon the deceased has
been proved.
21.
Dr. Nikita Kanwar (PW-20), who conducted the postmortem of the dead
body of the deceased has stated in her evidence that, on 27.05.2020,
she conducted the postmortem of the dead body of the deceased and
noticed multiple bruises on right side of forehead, over right and left
eyes, both cheeks, which were variable size, triangular and
quadrangle, over nasal bridge, oval in shape, multiple contusions on
right side of neck variable size and length, multiple contusions on
whole chest, abdomen and both legs, both hands and whole back. The
doctor opined that cause of death is cardio-respiratory arrest due to
multiple blunt injuries and syncope and gave her postmortem (exhibit
P-48). In the query report (exhibit P-49) the doctor has also opined that
the nature of death may be homicidal. In cross-examination, the
defence could not be able to extract any material, so that the evidence
of the doctor could be disbelieved or the death of the deceased could
be considered otherwise. From the evidence of the witnesses, injuries
found on the dead body of the deceased, its postmortem report, the
learned trial Court found that the death of the deceased was homicidal
in nature, in which we also concur with the finding record recorded by
the learned trial Court and affirmed that the death of the deceased was
homicidal.
22.
So far as the involvement of the appellants/accused persons in the
offence in question is concerned, the case of the prosecution is based
on eyewitnesses. PW-17, Akash Banjare is the injured eyewitness. He
stated in his evidence that on the date of incident he along with his
brother Yuvraj had gone to the house of Vicky for taking back his
borrowed amount. Vicky did not repay the borrowed amount, but he
gave them Rs. 100/- and asked to come near water tank with snacks
and also informed that other friends were also present there. When
they reached near water tank at an under construction house, Lucky,
Khebda Lucky, Mukesh and Jay were also there and at the same time,
Vicky also came. When Yuvraj asked for refund of his amount, Vicky
challenged him and demanded Rs. 25-30 thousands. On that issue,
altercation started. Vicky supplemented that Yuvraj had earlier told that
he will kill Mukku by gun. On the said issue the altercation culminated
into marpeet and while drinking liquor they assaulted them up to 10:30
in the night. When he assured that, he will pay the amount, they took
him to his house by Maestro vehicle and asked him not to disclose the
incident to anyone, otherwise all of them would be killed. His mother
paid them Rs. 500/- and then they went back. After sometime Vicky
made a mobile call in the mobile phone of his brother Vikas and
informed that Yuvraj was being taken by branch persons, who are
acquainted with Mukku. Thereafter the mother of Yuvraj gave Rs.
3000/- to Mukku and then they went back for releasing Yuvraj from
branch persons. In the morning, Mukesh informed his family members
that Yuvraj is not found, the accused persons threatened him that if he
disclosed their name, they will kill them. When he was being convinced
by police person, he lodged the report, which is exhibit P-46. When the
leading questions were asked, he stated the entire evidence and the
manner in which, the offence has ben committed by the accused
persons and also the identification of them. In his detailed crossexamination, the defence could not be able to impeach the credibility
of this witness, who is also the victim of the said offence and received
injuries by the marpeet committed by the accused persons. He has
named all the accused persons who committed marpeet with him as
well as the deceased Yuvraj.
23.
In the FIR lodged by him (exhibit P-48), the name of Monu, Lucky,
Vicky, Khebda Lucky, Jay and his other friends have been mentioned.
Further, the accused persons have been identified by this witness in
the test identification parade. In the TIP (exhibit P-46) conducted by
the Executive Magistrate on 16.06.2020, the accused persons
Abhishek Lal, Jay Kumar @ Ajju, Harish Chouhan, Abhijeet Lal,
Mukesh Lautre and Kishan Tanti have been duly identified by this
witness Akash Banjare (PW-17). We found no any infirmity or
discrepancy in his evidence, but for minor or trivial contradictions,
which does not affect the substantial allegation of the incident against
the accused persons.
24.
PW-8, Vijay Giri Goswami and PW-9, Dina Prasad Sahu are the
witnesses to the memorandum and seizure from the accused persons,
though they have turned hostile, but they admitted their signatures and
the documents. PW-11, Pushpa Khare is the mother of the deceased
Yuvraj, she stated in her evidence that, at about 12:00 in the night, her
sister Rukhmani made a telephonic call to her and informed that Akash
came back to house and whether Yuvraj came back or not and also
informed that Akash is having injuries. When she had gone to the
house of Rukhmani, four accused persons Abhijeet Lal, Kishan Tanti,
Harish Chouhan and Mukesh Lautre came to her house and
demanded Rs. 20,000/- and other ID documents and informed that
Yuvraj is being taken by crime branch police in Narcotics case and he
will get him released. Since, he was not having sufficient money, she
gave Rs. 3000/- to them. Up to 8:00 a.m. when they have not received
any information, they proceeded to police station and then Akash
disclosed in the police station that the accused Abhijeet Lal, Kishan
Tanti, Harish Chouhan and Mukesh Lautre brutally assaulted him and
committed murder of Yuvraj. In cross-examination, the involvement of
the aforesaid four accused persons could not be impeached by the
defence, though she is not the eyewitness to the incident, but she
witnessed that in the night, four accused persons came to the house of
her sister Rukhmani and she gave them Rs. 3000/- to get her son
released from the police.
25.
PW-12, Rukhmani has also supported the evidence of PW-11 that in
the night, Vicky, Mukesh Rautre, Abhishek Lal and Kishan Tanti came
to her house and she gave them Rs. 500/-. When they went back, she
called her sister Pushpa (PW-11). Vicky informed in he mobile phone
of Vikash that Yuvraj is being arrested by crime branch and after
sometime all the four accused persons Vicky, Mukesh Rautre,
Abhishek Lal and Kishan Tanti again came and demanded Rs.
20,000/- to get Yuvraj released from the police and then they gave
them Rs. 3000/-. Akash disclosed about the incident that the accused
persons brutally assaulted them. From her evidence also, the
involvement of the appellants in the offence in question has been
proved. But for minor omissions or contradictions, her evidence is
reliable in support of other evidence available on record.
26.
PW-15, Smt. Prakriti Dhruv is the Executive Magistrate, who conducted
the TIP and prepared the TIP memo (exhibit P-42 and P-43). The
injured Akash Banjare identified two juveniles in conflict with law and
their TIP memo (exhibit P-42) was prepared and the other accused
persons have been identified and TIP memo (exhibit P-43) was
prepared. In her cross-examination, the deceased put the question
about the sequence and order in which they were standing at the time
of TIP, but that has been properly answered by this witness. The
involvement of the appellants in the offence in question has also been
proved by their TIP.
27.
PW-22, U.N. Shant Kumar Sahu and PW-23, Sukhnandan Patel are
the investigating officers, who proved their part of the investigation,
which they conducted.
28.
From the aforesaid evidence, the involvement of the appellants in the
offence in question have been proved that on the date of incident, they
committed marpeet with the deceased Yuvraj and injured Akash
Banjare.
29.
The next question for consideration is whether the case of the
appellants is covered with Exception-IV to Section 300 of the IPC visa-vis culpable homicide not amounting to murder and their conviction
can be altered to Section 304 Part-I or Part-II of the IPC, as submitted
by learned counsel for the respective appellants.
30.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Sukhbir Singh v. State of
Haryana, 2002 (3) SCC 327 observed as under:“21. Keeping in view the facts and circumstances
of the case, we are of the opinion that in the
absence of the existence of common object
Sukhbir Singh is proved to have committed the
offence of culpable homicide without premeditation
in a sudden fight in the heat of passion upon a
sudden quarrel and did not act in a cruel or
unusual manner and his case is covered by
Exception 4 of Section 300 IPC which is
punishable under Section 304 (Part I) IPC. The
finding of the courts below holding the aforesaid
appellant guilty of offence of murder punishable
under Section 302 IPC is set aside and he is held
guilty for the commission of offence of culpable
homicide not amounting to murder punishable
under Section 304 (Part I) IPC and sentenced to
undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10 years and to
pay a fine of Rs.5000. In default of payment of
fine,
he
shall
undergo
further
rigorous
imprisonment for one year.”
31.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Gurmukh Singh v. State
of Haryana, 2009 (15) SCC 635, laid down certain factors which are to
be taken into consideration before awarding appropriate sentence to
the accused with reference to Section 302 or Section 304 Part II of the
IPC, which state as under :“23. These are some factors which are required to
be taken into consideration before awarding
appropriate sentence to the accused. These
factors are only illustrative in character and not
exhaustive. Each case has to be seen for its
special perspective. The relevant factors are as
under :
(a) Motive or previous enmity;
(b) Whether the incident had taken place on
the spur of the moment;
(c) The intention/knowledge of the accused
while inflicting the blow or injury;
(d)
Whether
the
death
ensued
instantaneously or the victim died after
several days;
(e) The gravity, dimension and nature of
injury;
(f) The age and general health condition of
the accused;
(g) Whether the injury was caused without
premeditation in a sudden fight;
(h) The nature and size of weapon used for
inflicting the injury and the force with which
the blow was inflicted;
(i) The criminal background and adverse
history of the accused;
(j) Whether the injury inflicted was not
sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to
cause death but the death was because of
shock;
(k) Number of other criminal cases pending
against the accused;
(l) Incident occurred within the family
members or close relations;
(m) The conduct and behaviour of the
accused after the incident.
Whether
injured/the
the
accused
deceased
had
to
taken
the
the
hospital
immediately to ensure that he/she gets
proper medical treatment ?
These are some of the factors which can be
taken into consideration while granting an
appropriate sentence to the accused.
24. The list of circumstances enumerated above is
only illustrative and not exhaustive. In our
considered view, proper and appropriate sentence
to the accused is the bounded obligation and duty
of the court. The endeavour of the court must be to
ensure that the accused receives appropriate
sentence, in other words, sentence should be
according to the gravity of the offence. These are
some of the relevant factors which are required to
be kept in view while convicting and sentencing
the accused.”
32.
Likewise, in the matter of State Vs. Sanjeev Nanda, 2012 (8) SCC
450, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that once knowledge that it
is likely to cause death is established but without any intention to
cause death, then jail sentence may be for a term which may extend to
10 years or with fine or with both. It has further been held that to make
out an offence punishable under Section 304 Part II of the IPC, the
prosecution has to prove the death of the person in question and such
death was caused by the act of the accused and that he knew that
such act of his is likely to cause death.
33.
Further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Arjun Vs. State of
Chhattisgarh, 2017 (3) SCC 247, has elaborately dealt with the issue
and observed in paragraphs 20 and 21, which reads as under :“20. To invoke this Exception 4, the requirements
that are to be fulfilled have been laid down by this
Court in Surinder Kumar v. UT, Chandigarh
[(1989) 2 SCC 217 : 1989 SCC (Cri) 348], it has
been explained as under :(SCC p. 220, para 7)
“7.
To
invoke
this
exception
four
requirements must be satisfied, namely, (I)
it was a sudden fight; (ii) there was no
premeditation; (iii) the act was done in a
heat of passion; and (iv) the assailant had
not taken any undue advantage or acted in
a cruel manner. The cause of the quarrel is
not relevant nor its I relevant who offered
the provocation or started the assault. The
number of wounds caused during the
occurrence is not a decisive factor but what
is important is that the occurrence must
have been sudden and unpremeditated and
the offender must have acted in a fit of
anger. Of course, the offender must not
have taken any undue advantage or acted
in a cruel manner. Where, on a sudden
quarrel, a person in the heat of the moment
picks up a weapon which is handy and
causes injuries, one of which proves fatal,
he would be entitled to the benefit of this
exception provided he has not acted
cruelly.”
21. Further in Arumugam v. State [(2008) 15 SCC
590 : (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 1130], in support of the
proposition of law that under what circumstances
Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC can be invoked if
death is caused, it has been explained as under :
“9. .... '18. The help of exception 4 can be
invoked if death is caused (a) without
premeditation; (b) in a sudden fight; (c)
without the offender's having taken undue
advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual
manner; and (d) the fight must have been
with the person killed. To bring a case
within Exception 4 all the ingredients
mentioned in it must be found. It is to be
noted that the “fight” occurring in Exception
4 to Section 300 IPC is not defined in the
Penal Code, 1860. It takes two to make a
fight. Heat of passion requires that there
must be no time for the passions to cool
down and in this case, the parties had
worked themselves into a fury on account
of the verbal altercation in the beginning. A
fight is a combat between two or more
persons whether with or without weapons.
It is not possible to enunciate any general
rule as to what shall be deemed to be a
sudden quarrel. It is a question of fact and
whether a quarrel is sudden or not must
necessarily depend upon the proved facts
of each case. For the application of
Exception 4, it is not sufficient to show that
there was a sudden quarrel and there was
no premeditation. It must further be shown
that the offender has not taken undue
advantage or acted in cruel or unusual
manner. The expression “undue advantage”
as used in the provisions means “unfair
advantage”.
34.
In the matter of Arjun (supra), the Supreme Court has held that if there
is intent and knowledge, the same would be case of Section 304 Part-I
of the IPC and if it is only a case of knowledge and not the intention to
cause murder and bodily injury, then same would be a case of Section
304 Part-II of the IPC.
35.
Further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Rambir Vs. State
(NCT of Delhi), 2019 (6) SCC 122, has laid down four ingredients to
bring a case within the purview of Exception 4 to Section 300 of IPC,
which reads as under:
“16. A plain reading of Exception 4 to Section 300
IPC shows that the following four ingredients are
required:
(i) There must be a sudden fight;
(ii) There was no premeditation;
(iii) he act was committed in a heat of passion;
and
(iv) The offender had not taken any undue
advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner.”
36.
Reverting to the facts of the present case, it is quite vivid that before
the incident, the deceased Yuvraj and injured Akash had gone to
house of Vicky for refund of his borrowed amount. Vicky instead of
repay their amount, gave them Rs. 100/- and asked to near water tank
with snacks, who that they may enjoy liquor. During drinking of liquor
there some altercation took place, which culminated into marpeet by
the accused persons to the deceased Yuvraj and injured Akash. The
allegation of assault made by hand and fists, wooden plank, hockey
stick and clutch wire, the accused persons have not used any sharp
edged or any deadly weapon. It further transpires that during their
drinking liquor, the incident took place. The appellants were not aimed
or targeted to kill the deceased and called him there and they were not
having any intention to cause death of the deceased, but by causing
such injuries, they must have had the knowledge that such injuries
inflicted by them would likely to cause death of the deceased and as
such the case would fall within the purview of Exception-IV of Section
300 of the IPC, as the act of the appellants herein completely satisfies
the four necessary ingredients of Exception-IV to Section 300 of the
IPC i.e. there must be a sudden fight, there was no premeditation, the
act was committed in a heat of passion and the appellants have not
taken any undue advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner.
37.
Considering the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the
aforesaid cases, considering the evidence of injured eyewitness,
Akash (PW-17), the ends of justice would meet, if the conviction of the
appellants under Section 302 of the IPC is altered/converted to one
under Section 304 Part-I of the IPC.
38.
So far as the conviction of the appellants under Section 148/149 of the
IPC is concerned, it has been established by the prosecution that the
accused persons, who were more than 5 in numbers committed
marpeet with the deceased Yuvraj and injured Akash. Though initially
they were drinking liquor, but during that when the altercation started,
they started marpeet with the deceased and then the purpose of their
assembly would turn into unlawful assembly and all of them assaulted
the deceased Yuvraj and injured Akash. While assaulting the deceased
and the injured, they shared common object and in furtherance
thereof, they assaulted them. The appellants were the member of
unlawful assembly and thus, the conviction of the appellants for the
offence under Section 148/149 of IPC is also justified.
39.
So far as the offence under Section 342/149 of IPC is concerned, from
the evidence of injured Akash (PW-17) and Pushpa (PW-11) and
Rukhmani (PW-12), the prosecution has also able to prove that the
injured Akash and deceased Yuvraj were illegally detained by the
accused persons while committing marpeet and thus, there is no
scope for interference in the conviction of the appellants for the offence
under Section 342/149 of the IPC.
40.
So far as the conviction of the appellants for the offence under Section
323/149 is concerned, injured Akash (PW-17) duly proved the injuries
caused by the accused persons/appellants. In his evidence, he
detailed the names of the accused persons and the manner in which
he was being assaulted by them. The injuries found on the body of
injured Akash has been proved by the Dr. P.C. Banerjee (PW-13), who
gave his MLC report (exhibit P-38). The doctor, who medically
examined the injured Akash found numerous contusions in all parts of
the body of the injured Akash, which were simple in nature. When it
has been established that, the appellants caused injuries to the injured
Akash by hard and blunt object and the injuries have been proved by
the doctor, there is no doubt in conviction of the appellants for the
offence under Section 323/149 of the IPC and hereby it has also been
affirmed.
41.
The appellants have also convicted for the offence under Section
396/149 of the IPC. It is alleged that the appellants along with the
juveniles in conflict with law assaulted the injured Akash and looted Rs.
1000/- from him and thereby they committed the offence of dacoity and
committed murder of Yuvraj. The appellants have been charged for the
offence under Section 396/397 of the IPC. From the evidence of
injured Akash (PW-17), when he was being asked the leading question
by the prosecution, he stated that the accused persons looted Rs.
1000/- from him. In cross-examination, he deposed about the money
transaction between them and the accused persons, there is no
specific evidence that who has taken Rs. 1000/- from his pocket. He
made omnibus allegation that the accused persons looted Rs. 1000/from his pocket. The manner in which the offence is said to have been
committed, the relation between the deceased, injured witness and the
accused persons, the genesis of the alleged incident and the reason
behind the genesis of the offence all would clearly demonstrate that
the incident occurred on the issue of money transaction. Merely stating
that the accused persons looted Rs. 1000/- would not be sufficient to
hold the appellants guilty for the offence under Section 396 of the IPC,
though an amount of Rs. 530/- has been seized from the accused
Mukesh Lautre, but it was the amount, which has been looted from the
injured Akash, has not been proved by the prosecution. In absence of
any specific evidence with respect to loot of Rs. 1000/- cash from the
injured Akash, the appellants cannot be held guilty for the said offence
of Section 396/149 of the IPC.
42.
Further, the evidence with respect to causing disappearance of the
evidence of offence produced by the prosecution is not sufficient to
hold the conviction of the appellants under Section 201/149 of the IPC.
The injured Akash has stated that the accused persons assaulted him
and the deceased Yuvraj and then, they dropped him to his house in
the night and he gave them Rs. 500/-, but he has not stated that the
appellants taken the dead body of the deceased and caused
disappearance the evidence. From the evidence of this witness, it also
appears that when the accused persons dropped him in the house,
Vicky made a call in the mobile phone of his brother Vikas and
informed that Yuvraj is being taken by the Crime branch police. When
the accused persons taken him to his house, Yuvraj was with them.
There is no sufficient evidence on record that the dead body of the
deceased was thrown near the Talab by the accused persons. Though
the prosecution tried to prove it by producing CCTV footage, but that
itself has not been found proved in accordance with law. The evidence
of Ravi Sharma (PW-18) and Devendra Rao Bhosle (PW-19) are not
sufficient, as they could not be able to give the sufficient description
about the data stored in the pen drive and DVDR of CCTV footage.
The learned trial Court has found that the DVD is blank but the pen
drive consists with the CCTV footage in which it has been seen that
two persons have taken another person in the scooty and other scooty
and bullet vehicle had also gone towards same direction is visible, but
neither the number of the said scooty and the bullet motorcycle have
been disclosed, nor the person who were in the vehicles have been
identified. It has been observed that the persons have covered their
faces and thus, the appellants are entitled for benefit of doubt with
respect to the commission of offence under Section 201/149 of the
IPC.
43.
So far as the offence under Section 506 Part-II of the IPC (in two
counts) is concerned, the offence has been duly proved by the
evidence of Akash Banjare (PW-17). He specifically proved that the
accused persons threatened them with dire consequences, if he
disclosed the incident to his family members. The evidence of this
witness with respect to threatening given by the accused persons and
criminal intimidation by the threat to be cause death or grievous hurt
could not be rebutted by the accused persons in his crossexamination. The learned trial Court has also rightly held the accused
persons guilty for the offence under Section 506 Part-II of IPC on two
counts for giving threatening with dire consequences to the deceased
Yuvraj and injured Akash and thereby the conviction of the appellants
under Section 506 Part-II of IPC on two counts are hereby affirmed.
44.
Accordingly, the conviction and sentence passed by the learned trial
Court against the appellants for the offence under Sections 302/149,
396/149 and 201/149 are set aside, and their conviction and sentence
are modified in the following manner:
Conviction by the trial
Court
Sentence awarded by
the trial Court
Conviction and
sentence awarded
by this Court.
Section 148/149 IPC
03 years Rigorous
Imprisonment (R.I.)
Affirmed.
Section 342/149 IPC
(Twice)
01 year R.I. each for
deceased Yuvraj and
injured Akash (Separate)
Affirmed.
Section 323/149 IPC
01 year R.I.
Affirmed.
Section 302/149 IPC
Life Imprisonment +
₹2,000 fine (In default:
01 year R.I.)
Modified/altered for
the offence under
Section 304 Part-I
of the IPC and
sentenced to R.I. for
10 years with fine of
Rs. 2000/-, in
default of payment
of fine, further R.I.
for 03 months.
Section 396/149 IPC
Life Imprisonment +
₹2,000 fine (In default:
01 year R.I.)
Acquitted.
Section 201/149 IPC
07 years R.I. + ₹2,000
fine (In default: 01 year
R.I.)
Acquitted.
Section 506 Part-II
IPC (Twice)
05 years R.I. each for
deceased Yuvraj and
injured Akash (Separate)
Affirmed.
All the sentences are directed to run concurrently.
45.
With the aforesaid modification/alteration, all these appeals are partly
allowed.
46.
The appellants Abhijeet Lal @ Vikku @ Vicky, Abhishek Lal @ Lucky,
Mukesh Lautre @ Mukku @ Monu, Kishan Tanti @ Lalu @ Kunal and
Jay Kumar Yadav @ Ajju are in jail since 27.05.2020 and the
appellants Lucky Naidu @ Khebda Lucky is in jail since 18.09.2020.
they shall serve the sentence as awarded/modified by this Court.
47.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the concerned
Superintendent of Jail, where the appellants are undergoing their jail
sentence to serve the same on each of the appellants informing them
that they are at liberty to assail the present judgment passed by this
Court by preferring an appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court with
the assistance of High Court Legal Services Committee or the
Supreme Court Legal Services Committee.
48.
Let a copy of this judgment and the original records be transmitted to
the trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary information and
compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
ved
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review