Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision:08th September, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010422432026
+
RSA 164/2026, CM APPL. 60557/2026, CM APPL.60559/2026
& CM APPL.60560/2026
KISHAN KUMAR
S/o Sh. Satya Pal
R/o Flat No. C-445, DDA LIG Flats,
East of Loni Road, Delhi-110093.
....Appellant
Through: Mr. Hitesh Kumar Bhardwaj and
Mr. Sumit Kumar, Advocates with
Appellant in person.
versus
Suresh Kumar (Since Deceased)
Through Lrs.
1.
Smt. Amresh
W/o Late Suresh Kumar
2.
Sh. Piyush
S/o Late Suresh Kumar
3.
Ms. Monu Chaudhary
D/o Late Suresh Kumar
4.
Ms. Sonu Chaudhary
D/o Late Suresh Kumar
All residents of;
H.No. A-139, Kabir Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi-110094
Through: None.
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
.....Respondent
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M E N T (oral)
CM APPL. 60558/2026 (Exemption)
1.
Exemptions allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The Application is disposed of accordingly.
RSA 164/2026
3.
Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 read with Section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’), has
been filed on behalf of the Appellant against the common Judgment dated
23.05.2026 whereby the learned Appellate Court reversed the Judgment
dated 30.09.2016 of the learned Civil Judge and decreed the Suit of the
Plaintiff for Possession, Arrears of Rent and Mesne Profits.
4.
The Civil Suit bearing CS No. 214/2009 was filed by the plaintiff,
Mr. Suresh Kumar for Possession, Permanent Injunction and Recovery of
Arrears of Rent.
5.
The facts in brief, are that the Plaintiff/Respondent was the owner
of property bearing No. C-445, DDA LIG Flats, East of Loni Road,
Shahdara, Delhi, consisting of two rooms, one kitchen, one bathroom, one
latrine and one balcony (hereinafter referred to as ‘the suit property’).
6.
The erstwhile owner, Mr. Ashok Kumar had inducted the
Defendant, Mr. Kishan Kumar as a tenant in the suit property in the
month of March, 1995, on a monthly rent of Rs.1,500/- per month,
excluding water and electricity charges vide oral Agreement. The Defendant
had paid the increased rent of Rs.3,212/- to Mr. Ashok Kumar, till April,
2003.
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
7.
On 03.05.2003, the Defendant, Mr. Kishan Kumar filed a Suit for
Permanent and Mandatory Injunction against Mr. Ashok Kumar, for
restraining him from creating third party rights in the suit property and from
dispossessing him, on the ground that he had entered into an Agreement to
Sell dated 04.02.2003, for a total consideration of Rs.1,40,000/-, out of
which, Rs.90,000/- had been paid as earnest money to Mr. Ashok Kumar.
The Suit was decreed ex-parte, vide Judgment dated 13.04.2024.
8.
Thereafter, Mr. Ashok Kumar moved an Application under Order 9
Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC, on 10.09.2005, pursuant to which the
ex-parte Judgment and Decree was set aside on 19.12.2005 and Mr. Ashok
Kumar was allowed to contest the Suit. The Defendant had thereafter,
withdrawn the aforesaid Suit with liberty to file afresh, on the same cause of
action on 24.04.2007.
9.
In the meanwhile, Mr. Ashok Kumar had executed the Agreement to
Sell, GPA, SPA and Will dated 01.04.2003, in favour of Mr. Ravi Kant
Bansal.
10.
Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal further executed GPA, Agreement to Sell and
a registered Will in favour of the Plaintiff, Mr. Suresh Kumar (since
deceased), on 27.05.2005, for a total consideration of Rs.1,00,000/-. It was
stated that the Agreement to Sell had been executed on the condition that
Mr. Ashok Kumar shall get the suit property vacated from the Defendant
and hand over the possession to Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal, who further shall
hand over the possession to the Plaintiff.
11.
Mr. Ashok Kumar thereafter, terminated the tenancy of the
Defendant, Krishan Kumar and filed the earlier Suit for Possession,
Declaration, Permanent Injunction and Recovery of Rent against him.
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
12.
The Plaintiff claimed that the Defendant was a regular defaulter in
payment of rent, which was in the sum of Rs.3,212/-. He issued Legal
Notice dated 14.05.2009, through registered AD, thereby terminating the
tenancy and seeking peaceful vacant possession of the Suit Property along
with the Arrears of Rent. Sh. Ashok Kumar failed to disclose the execution
of the said documents in favour of Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal.
13.
The present Suit bearing CS No.214/2009 was filed by Sh. Suresh
Kumar on 21.08.2009 for Possession, Permanent Injunction and Recovery
of Arrears of Rent.
14.
The Suit was contested by the Defendant, Mr. Kishan Kumar, who in
his Written Statement, admitted that Mr. Ashok Kumar was the owner of
the suit property and the Defendant had been inducted as a tenant. He
asserted that Mr. Ashok Kumar had agreed to sell the suit property to the
Defendant by executing an Agreement to Sell etc., dated 04.02.2003, against
which Rs.90,000/- out of the total sale consideration of Rs.1,40,000/, were
paid to Mr. Ashok Kumar, who failed to execute the sale documents in
favour of the Defendant.
15.
The Defendant, Mr. Kishan Kumar, then filed a Suit for Specific
Performance against Mr. Ashok Kumar. In the said Suit, neither Mr. Ashok
Kumar on 21.11.2007 but he failed to disclose that he had already executed
the documents in respect of the suit property in favour of Mr. Ravi Kant
Bansal on 01.04.2003; rather he filed the earlier Suit for Possession,
Declaration, Permanent Injunction and Recovery of Damages against
the Defendant wherein also, he did not disclose the fact of execution of the
said documents in favour of Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal, who was thereafter,
impleaded as a party. He also, in his Written Statement also did not disclose
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
that he had further executed documents in respect of the suit property in
favour of the Plaintiff, Mr. Suresh Kumar, on 27.05.2005.
16.
The Defendant, Mr. Kishan Kumar denied that he was a defaulter of
rent. He further asserted that he did not recognise the Plaintiff as a landlord
of the suit property and there was no question of paying the arrears of rent
or handing over the vacant possession to the Plaintiff.
17.
The Plaintiff in the Replication, controverted the assertions made in
the Written Statement and reiterated the submissions made in the Plaint.
18.
From the pleadings, the Issues were framed on 02.06.2010, which
are as under:-
19.
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
1.
Whether the plaintiff is the owner of the suit
property? OPP
2.
Whether the suit of the plaintiff is liable to be
dismissed for concealment of material facts? OPD
3.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of
possession as prayed for? OPP
4.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of
permanent injunction as prayed for? OPP
5.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the damages as
prayed for, if so at what rate and for which period?
OPP
6.
Whether the plaintiff is also entitled to the interest
on damages as prayed for? OPP
7.
Relief.
PW-1, Mr. Suresh Kumar, the Plaintiff tendered his evidence by
RSA 164/2026
way of Affidavit as Ex.PW-1/A. He proved the GPA, Agreement to Sell etc.
on 27.05.2005 as Ex.PW-1/2 and the Legal Notice dated 14.05.2009 as
Ex.PW-1/3.
20.
PW-2, Mr. Ashok Kumar, the erstwhile owner proved the copy of
the Judgment dated 13.03.2004 as Ex.PW-2/1 and the Legal Notice as
Ex.PW-2/2. The Agreement to Sell etc. dated 01.04.2003 was exhibited as
Ex.PW-2/3.
21.
PW-3, Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal tendered his evidence by way of
Affidavit, Ex. PW-3/A, corroborating the case of the Plaintiff.
22.
The Defendant, Mr. Kishan Kumar examined himself as DW-1 and
tendered his evidence by way of Affidavit, Ex.DW-1/A, wherein he
reiterated the defence as taken in the Written Statement.
23.
DW-2, Mr. Vivek Saxena and DW-3, Mr. Pradeep Kumar,
corroborated the defence of the Defendant.
24.
DW-4, Janki, UDC from the Office of Sub-Registrar-IV, Seelampur,
produced the relevant records.
25.
The learned Civil Judge SCJ-cum-RC, on appreciation of the
evidence held that Mr. Ashok Kumar admittedly was the owner of the suit
property from whom the Plaintiff, Mr. Suresh Kumar was deriving the
interests in the suit property, on the basis of Agreement to sell, etc. executed
in his favour by Ashok Kumar. It was further observed that the Plaintiff
could not claim ownership in the suit property on the basis of GPA,
Agreement to Sell, etc.
26.
It was noticed that though, PW-2, Mr. Ashok Kumar had expired
before his cross-examination could be concluded, but his Will dated
01.04.2003 was not proved in accordance with Sections 68 and 70 of the
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
27.
Accordingly, it was held that the Plaintiff did not become an absolute
owner of the suit property.
28.
It was further observed that Mr. Kishan Kumar, the erstwhile
tenant/Defendant had filed a Suit No.259/2007 (CIS/S. No.5613/2015) titled
Sh. Kishan Kumar vs. Ashok Kumar & Ors., for Specific Performance and
for Permanent Injunction, was patently barred by limitation and the Appeal
was dismissed, vide Judgment dated 30.09.2016.
29.
The Suit bearing CS No.214/2009 filed by Mr. Suresh Kumar for
Recovery of Possession, Permanent Injunction and Arrears of Rent had
already been dismissed, vide Judgment dated 14.09.2016 and was
challenged by respondent, vide RCA DJ No.91/2016.
30.
Mr. Kishan Kumar also filed RCA DJ No.96/2016 challenging the
dismissal of his Suit for Specific Performance.
31.
Both the Appeals were decided by the common Judgment dated
23.05.2026, by the learned District Judge. The Appeal in respect of Suit for
Specific Performance of the Appellant was dismissed, against which the
Appellant has preferred no second Appeal.
32.
Sh. Suresh Kumar, the landlord had filed the present Regular first
Appeal, in regard to RCA DJ No.91/2016, in regard to the dismissal of
his Suit for Possession.
33.
Ld. District Judge observed that though the documents namely,
Agreement to Sell, GPA etc. did not constitute conventional documents of
sale and did not confer absolute ownership, but the Suit for Specific
Performance filed by Mr. Kishan Kumar, the tenant, had been dismissed.
34.
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
It was further noted that Mr. Kishan Kumar had been inducted as a
RSA 164/2026
tenant and he never perfected his title as that of an owner by virtue of the
Agreement to Sell etc. dated 04.02.2003. It was held that the Plaintiff, Mr.
Suresh Kumar had derived a better possessory/proprietary right in the suit
property through the registered GPA, Agreement to Sell etc. dated
27.05.2005.
35.
It
was
further
observed
that
attornment
is
primarily
an
acknowledgment of the tenant regarding the new landlord and protection for
the tenant regarding the payment of rent, but the absence of attornment shall
not per se, invalidate the status of Mr. Suresh Kumar as a transferee
landlord. The Plaintiff, Mr. Suresh Kumar had a better right vis-à-vis the
Defendant and was entitled to seek possession.
36.
Consequently, the Appeal was allowed and Suit of Mr. Suresh
Kumar for Possession and Permanent Injunction, was decreed. The
Arrears of Rent w.e.f. 01.05.2006 till 20.05.2009 @ Rs.3,886/- per month, to
be increased @10% p.a., amounting to Rs.1,39,896/- along with interest
@6% p.a. and Mesne Profits @Rs.5,000/- per month along with interest
@6% p.a. w.e.f. 20.06.2009 till the date of delivery of possession, were
allowed and the Suit of the Plaintiff, was accordingly decreed.
37.
Aggrieved by the said Judgement, Mr. Kishan Kumar, the Appellant
has preferred the present Second Appeal.
38.
The grounds of challenge are that the learned Civil Judge had rightly
observed that on the basis of an Agreement to Sell, GPA and Will, neither
Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal and thereafter, the Plaintiff could have acquired
ownership in the suit property, since these documents do not confer
ownership title in the suit property.
39.
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
It was further contended that despite there being no transfer of
RSA 164/2026
ownership from Mr. Ashok Kumar to Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal and thereafter,
to the Plaintiff, it has still been held that Mr. Suresh Kumar, the Plaintiff was
entitled to maintain the Suit for Possession, against the tenant. The
possession never came in the hands of the Plaintiff and without the
possession, the Plaintiff had no locus to claim the possession from the
tenant.
40.
Furthermore, there was no averment that Mr. Suresh Kumar had ever
let out the suit property to the Appellant nor had the Appellant attorned to
the Respondent as the landlord. Therefore, in the absence of such
relationship, Section 116 of the Indian Evidence Act was not applicable
and the Appellant had a right to raise a question about the title of the
Plaintiff.
41.
It was further contended that the learned Appellate Court overlooked
the testimony of PW-2, Mr. Ashok Kumar (in CS No.214/2009), who
admitted having offered to sell the suit property to Mr. Kishan Kumar and
also admitted his signatures on the Agreement to Sell, the presence of
witnesses and their signatures on the Agreement to Sell. The possession of
Mr. Kishan Kumar, the Defendant, was thus claimed to be protected as the
Agreement to Sell in his favour, was genuine.
42.
The definition of landlord, has been claimed to have been
misinterpreted. It was asserted that the rights claimed by the Plaintiff
ultimately traced through the GPA, etc. executed by Mr. Ashok Kumar in
favour of Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal and that upon the demise of Mr. Ashok
Kumar, the agency so created ceased. The Plaintiff was neither entitled to
collect rent from the Appellant nor had he ever collected any rent from the
Appellant. Hence, it was claimed that there was no relationship of landlord
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
and tenant and the Plaintiff was not entitled to a decree of possession.
43.
Furthermore, while observing that Mr. Suresh Kumar did not have a
perfect title, it was held that he had a right to seek eviction of the tenant. It
has not been appreciated that the possession of the suit property had never
been delivered to the Plaintiff.
44.
It is asserted that the Judgments in Mahendra Raghunathdas Gupta
vs. Vishvanath Bhikaji Mogul & Ors. and Charanjit Singh Makkar vs.
Phalwinder Arora, RFA (Comm) 347/2025, have been misapplied by
ignoring the fact that Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal had allegedly executed the GPA
etc. in favour of the Plaintiff and the Defendant/Appellant had never been a
tenant of Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal.
45.
It is claimed that further error has been committed in the impugned
Judgment, by ignoring that even after executing the GPA etc., Mr. Ashok
Kumar had instituted a Suit bearing CS No.599/2017 for Recovery of
Possession, Declaration, Permanent Injunction and Arrears of Rent against
the Defendant though, it was rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC vide
Judgment dated 18.03.2009.
46.
It is further contended that there was no evidence of any nature to
prove that the rate of rent in respect of the suit property, was more than
Rs.3,500/- per month. There was no document, rent receipt or any other
proof of rent, being more than Rs.3,500/-. The Judgment is, therefore, bad in
law and is liable to be set-aside.
Submissions heard and the record perused.
47.
At the outset, it may be noted that the Suit for Specific Performance
filed by the Appellant/Defendant, Mr. Kishan Kumar had been dismissed by
the learned Civil Judge against which, RCA DJ No.96/2016 had been filed
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
but the Appeal has also been dismissed upholding the Judgment of the
learned Civil Judge. The dismissal of RCA DJ No.96/2016 has not been
assailed in any Appeal.
48.
Therefore, it stands established that Mr. Kishan Kumar has not
acquired ownership on the basis of the Agreement to Sell etc. dated
04.02.2003, allegedly executed in his favour by the erstwhile owner, Mr.
Ashok Kumar. The status of the Appellant is, therefore, established to have
originated as that of a tenant and not an owner.
49.
It is not in dispute that Mr. Ashok Kumar, erstwhile owner, who had
inducted the Appellant as a tenant, had executed an Agreement to Sell, etc.
dated 01.04.2003 in favour of Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal, who appeared in the
witness-box and corroborated having purchased the suit property from Mr.
Ashok Kumar, the erstwhile owner.
50.
Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal further executed the Agreement to Sell etc.
dated 27.05.2005, Ex.PW-1/2, in favour of Mr. Suresh Kumar, the Plaintiff.
Mr. Suresh Kumar, therefore, stepped into the shoes of the erstwhile owner,
Mr. Ashok Kumar, on the basis of these documents.
51.
It has been rightly held by the learned Appellate Court that even
though the Agreement to Sell, etc. are not conventional documents of sale
and do not confer absolute ownership, they may create enforceable
proprietary rights inter se the parties. Here is a case where Mr. Ashok
Kumar, the erstwhile owner, who had appeared as PW-2, had corroborated
having executed the documents in favour of PW-3 Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal,
who in turn executed the documents in favour of the Plaintiff. It has been
rightly held that, in the facts of the present case, the Plaintiff had stepped
into the shoes of Mr. Ashok Kumar and had a better right as against the
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
Defendant in respect of the suit property.
52.
The Appellant has taken objection to the maintainability of the
Suit, essentially on the grounds that: (a) upon the demise of Mr. Ashok
Kumar, the agency created under the GPA ceased to have any effect; (b)
that the Plaintiff had never been put in physical possession of the suit
property nor had the Appellant attorned to him as the landlord; and (c) that
in the absence of proof of rent being more than Rs.3,500/- per month, the
jurisdiction of the Civil Court was barred.
(a) Whether the Agency stood Terminated under Section 201 Indian
Contract Act:
53.
An objection had been taken by the Appellant that on demise of Mr.
Ashok Kumar, the GPA ceased to be of any effect and the agency created
thereunder, got automatically terminated, thereby leaving the Plaintiff with
no right to deal with the suit property.
54.
Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 carves out an exception
in respect of an agency coupled with an interest, which cannot be terminated
to the prejudice of the interest so created. The mere use of the expression
"irrevocable" is not, by itself, determinative.
55.
The principle is traced back to the settled exposition in Seth Loon
Karan Sethiya v. Ivan E. John, AIR 1969 SC 73, wherein it was
authoritatively laid down that where the agency is created for valuable
consideration and authority is given to effectuate a security or to secure
interest of the agent, the authority cannot be revoked.
56.
The Supreme Court, in the case of P. Seshareddy (D) v. State of
Karnataka, 2022 INSC 1191, has reaffirmed that Section 201 of the Indian
Contract Act cannot be read in isolation of Section 202, and has
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
authoritatively held that where an interest has accrued in favour of the
holder of a Power of Attorney in the subject-matter of the agency, the said
agency is not terminated to the prejudice of such interest, even upon the
demise of the principal.
57.
Applying the said principles to the facts of the present case, the GPA
dated 01.04.2003 having been executed along with the Agreement to Sell,
etc. for valuable consideration in favour of Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal, the
interest created thereunder could not be brought to an end merely by the
subsequent demise of Mr. Ashok Kumar. Furthermore, much prior to the
demise of Mr. Ashok Kumar, Mr. Ravi Kant Bansal had already executed
the GPA, Agreement to Sell etc. dated 27.05.2005, Ex.PW-1/2, in favour of
the Plaintiff, Mr. Suresh Kumar.
58.
Therefore, the assertion of the Appellant that the Plaintiff lost his right
in respect of the suit property merely on account of the demise of Mr. Ashok
Kumar, is without any merit.
59.
Admittedly, the Appellant had been inducted initially as a tenant in
the suit premises by Mr. Ashok Kumar as already noted above. Though, the
Appellant had claimed to have purchased the suit property from Mr. Ashok
Kumar, vide Agreement to Sell etc. dated 04.02.2003. However, his Suit for
Specific Performance of Agreement to Sell has been dismissed by the
learned Civil Judge and the Appeal bearing RCA DJ No.96/2016, has also
been dismissed. The dismissal has not been challenged in the present
Appeal. It is, therefore, established that he had not acquired the
ownership rights and his initial induction in the suit property was as a
tenant and he continues to be so under the Plaintiff.
b) Whether the Plaintiff had never been put in physical possession of the
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
suit property and whether the attornment of Plaintiff as the landlord, is
mandatory:
60.
The contention raised by the Appellant was that the Plaintiff was
never handed over physical possession of the suit property and thus, cannot
claim the same from the Defendant/Appellant, is absolutely fallacious. It is
the legal right, which has travelled from Mr. Ashok Kumar to Mr. Ravi
Kant Bansal and thereafter, to the Plaintiff. The physical possession may not
have ever come to the Plaintiff, but through these documents of ATS etc., he
acquired
a
better
possessory/proprietary
right
as
against
the
Defendant/Appellant, and received the legal possession under these
documents, thereby entitling him to maintain the Suit for possession.
61.
Learned counsel for the Appellant had further asserted that the
Appellant had never attorned to the Plaintiff, Mr. Suresh Kumar, as the
landlord. However, first and foremost, it may be considered who is defined
as a Landlord and what are his rights.
62.
The learned District Judge has relied upon the Judgment in Swadesh
Ranjan Sinha vs. Haradeb Banerjee, 1992 AIR 1590, wherein the Supreme
Court of India considered the expression ‘landlord’ in wide terms so as to
include a person who, for the time being, is entitled to receive or but for a
special contract, would be entitled to receive the rent of the premises,
whether or not on his own account. This definition shows that even if the
rent is received by a person not on his own account, but on account of any
other person, such as his principal or his ward, he would for the purpose of
the Act, be treated as a landlord. Therefore, such person is entitled to
institute proceedings for eviction.
63.
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
It has further been observed that ownership denotes relationship
RSA 164/2026
between a person and an object forming the subject-matter of his ownership.
It consists in a complex of rights, all of which are in rem, being good against
the whole world but not merely against specific persons. (Salmond on
Jurisprudence, 12th ed., Ch. 8, p.246 et seq.).
64.
There are various incidents or rights of ownership all of which need
not necessarily be present in every case that may include a right to possess,
use or enjoy the thing owned; and a right to consume, destroy or alienate it.
Such a right may be indeterminate in duration and residuary in character. A
person has a right to possess the thing which he owns, even when he is not
in possession, but only retains a reversionary interest, i.e., a right to
repossess the thing on the termination of a certain period or on the
happening of a certain event. All that a Plaintiff is required to prove is
that he has a better title than the Defendant. The question, however, is
whether he has a superior right or interest vis-à-vis the person
challenging it.
65.
Therefore, it has been rightly held by the learned District Judge that
even if Mr. Suresh Kumar did not have a perfect title, but he had a right to
possession and to enforce the right for eviction of the tenant.
66.
The Appellant had contended that he has never attorned to the
Plaintiff as a landlord and thus, there was no relationship of landlord-tenant
between the parties and Section 116 of the Indian Evidence Act, was not
attracted. In this regard, the learned District Judge had rightly observed as
under:“It is trite, attornment by a tenant is not the source of
title of the transferee. When a lessor transfers his interest
in the property, the transferee acquires all rights of the
lessor in respect of the tenancy and a subsequent
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
transferee can sue for eviction even if no formal letter of
attornment was issued and even if the tenant never
expressly consented to the transfer. An attornment is
primarily acknowledgment by the tenant regarding the
new landlord and protection for the tenant regarding
payment of rent. In Charanjit Singh Makkar v.
Phalwinder Arora, RFA (COMM) 347/2025 decided on
26.08.2025, the Hon’ble Delhi High Court observed that
“a letter of attornment is not required to complete the
title of the transferee under the mandate of Section 109 of
the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. The title of the
transferee becomes effective upon the execution of the
sale deed itself or by any other lawful mode of transfer
and is not dependent on or postponed until attornment by
the tenant.”
Attornment is merely a notice to the tenant so that he
knows to whom the rent is payable. Absence of
attornment shall not per se invalidate the status of Suresh
Kumar as a transferee landlord. It is trite that in
landlord- tenant litigation, absolute ownership is not
required, a better title than the tenant is sufficient. In
these circumstances, it is sufficiently clear that Suresh
Kumar could have easily maintained a suit against
Kishan Kumar seeking the relief of possession,
permanent injunction and recovery of arrears of rent and
the Ld. Trial Court committed an error in dismissing the
said suit on this account.
67.
The learned District Judge, therefore, rightly held that the
attornment was not a necessary incident, but the Plaintiff being having
better
possessory/proprietary
rights
and
a
better
title
than
the
Defendant/Appellant, had a right to maintain the Suit for Possession and
Injunction.
(c) Whether the jurisdiction of the Civil Court was barred, in the
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
absence of proof of rent being more than Rs.3,500/- per month:
68.
Another aspect which merits consideration is that the Appellant has
asserted that he acquired ownership rights by virtue of Agreement to Sell,
etc. dated 04.02.2003, and had a right to continue in the suit premises.
69.
The question which thus emerges for consideration is, what is the
status of a tenant who denounces being a tenant in the suit property and
whether such claim of the Appellant, resulted in forfeiture of his status as a
tenant.
70.
Section 111(g) Transfer of Property Act deals with Determination of
Lease and provides for circumstances in which the lease of immovable
property gets determined. It reads as under:
S.111. By forfeiture; that is to say,
(1) in case the lessee breaks an express condition which provides that,
on breach thereof, the lessor may re-enter; or
(2) in case the lessee renounces his character as such by setting up a
title in a third person or by claiming title in himself; or
(3) the lessee is adjudicated an insolvent and the lease provides that
the lessor may re-enter on the happening of such event;
and in any of these cases the lessor or his transferee gives notice in
writing to the lessee of his intention to determine the lease.
71.
In Mohammad Amir Ahmad Khan vs. Municipal Board of Sitapur and
Ors., MANU/SC/0326/1964, while making a reference to the case of
Maharaja of Jeypore vs. Rukmini Pattamahadevi, MANU/PR/0154/1919,
AIR 1919 PC 1, the Apex Court observed that the principles embodied in
Section 111(g) TPA are equally applicable to tenancies in which the TPA
does not apply, on the ground of the same being in consonance with justice,
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
equity, and good conscious. It was further observed that it was clear law that
permanent tenancies are within the rule and are liable to forfeiture, if there
is a disclaimer of tenancy or denial of the landlord’s title. This disclaimer
of repudiation of landlord’s title, must be clear and unequivocal and made to
the knowledge of the landlord. It was further observed that where there is a
disclaimer of tenancy and repudiation of landlord’s title, it would amount to
forfeiture of relationship of landlord and tenant
72.
In Kundan Mal vs. Gurudutta, MANU/SC/0280/1989, JT 1989 (1) SC
147, it was held that the principle of forfeiture on disclaimer is founded on
the rule that a man cannot approbate and reprobate at the same time. Since
the consequence of applying the rule is very serious, it must be held that the
denial has to be clear and in unequivocal terms.
73.
Similar observations were made by the Supreme Court in Majati
Subbarao vs. P.V.K. Krishna Rao (Deceased) by Lrs. AIR 1989 SC 2187. It
was observed that it is abundantly clear from the decision of the Apex Court
in Kundan Mal vs. Gurudutta, JT 1989 (1) SC 147, that the principle of
forfeiture on disclaimer was founded on the rule that a man cannot
approbate and reprobate at the same time. Since the consequence of
applying the rule was very serious, it must be held that the denial of title has
to be clear and in unequivocal terms. It was further noted that where there
is a provision under the Rent Act for eviction on the ground of repudiation
of the title, then the remedy with the landlord is only to approach under the
Rent Act, as was the case in Rajasthan Rent Law.
74.
Certain State tenancy laws provide denial of title of landlord, as a
ground for eviction, in which case the remedy for the landlord is to approach
under Rent Law, but where there is no such provision in Rent Act as in
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
Delhi, the only remedy remains under the general civil law, to which the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is applicable.
75.
In the case of Hatimullah and Ors. vs. Mahamad Arju Choudhury
MANU/WB/0396/1927, 113 Ind. Cas. 13, this aspect was further explained
by observing that where the tenant denies the Plaintiff’s title to recover rent
on the bona fide ground of seeking information of such title or having such
title established in a Court of law in order to protect himself, he cannot be
charged with disclaiming the Plaintiff’s title. But, where the disclaimer is
done not with this object, but with expressed repudiation of tenancy under
the Plaintiff, it would operate as forfeiture
76.
In
the
case of
Sada
Ram
& Ors.
vs.
Gajjan
Shiama
MANU/PH/0080/1970, AIR 1970 P&H 511; Shiv Parshad vs. Smt. Shila
Rani MANU/HP/0009/1974, AIR 1974 HP 22, it has been held that the
proposition that a denial of title in the Written Statement cannot be taken
advantage of that Suit, but can be taken advantage of only in a subsequent
Suit to be filed by the landlord, would only lead to unnecessary multiplicity
of legal proceedings as the landlord would then be obliged to file a second
suit for ejectment of the tenant on the ground of forfeiture, entailed by the
tenants’ denial of his character as a tenant in the Written Statement.
77.
In Sheikh Miadhar vs. Rajani Kanta Roy, MANU/WB/0481/1909, 5
Ind. Cas. 708, more light was thrown on this aspect, wherein it was held that
where in a suit for rent the Defendant denies the Plaintiff’s title and claims
to hold under a third party, the Defendant can be, in a Suit for ejectment by
the landlord, debarred from pleading his tenancy and claiming protection of
possession on that ground. It was further observed that this principle was
embodied in Section 111(g) TPA, wherein one of the grounds for forfeiture,
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
was to set up a title in the third person or in himself.
78.
In the case of Arjunlal Bhatt Mall Gothani and Ors. vs. Girish
Chandra Dutta and Ors., MANU/SC/0326/1973, AIR 1973 SC 2256,
similar plea of having acquired ownership by virtue of documents of
purchase was raised by the tenant, who further claimed that because of this
Agreement, the old relationship of landlord and tenant, had come to any end.
It was held that the rights of the parties had to be worked out, on the basis of
this subsequent Agreement. It was obvious that when such Agreements
stood cancelled, the landlord would automatically be entitled to
possession, under the terms of the Agreement.
79.
In the case of Guru Amarjit Singh vs. Rattan Chand and Ors.,
MANU/SC/0065/1994, AIR 1994 SC 227, the doctrine of forfeiture was
explained to be founded upon the existence of a lease under jural
relationship between a lessor and a lessee, as contemplated under Section
105 TPA. It is implicit that if the lease is in operation, the lessor has been
given a right to determine the lease for committing breach of a covenant or
for disclaimer by the lessee on the happening of any of the events specified
therein.
The tenant, by repudiation of the relationship of landlord-tenant,
exposes himself to the risk of forfeiting his lease and giving a right to the
lessor to determine the lease. The repudiation, however, must be clear and
unequivocal and anterior to the issuance of the notice determining the
lease. Where there was an unequivocal admission of the earlier
relationship of landlord-tenant, but denial in the subsequent litigation, the
tenant forfeits its right to lease.
80.
The principles of forfeiture as encapsulated in Section 111(g)(2),
may be crystallized as under:
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
(i)
There is denial of title of landlord or the status as a tenant; and
(ii)
It must be clear and unequivocal and anterior to the issuance of
the notice determining the lease.
81.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the present case, it is evident that
the Appellant has in clear and unequivocal terms, repudiated his status as a
tenant, by asserting ownership on the basis of Agreement to Sell etc. dated
04.02.2003. He has completely denied the title of the Plaintiff or the
erstwhile owners, through whom the Plaintiff has derived the title as being
the owner of the suit property. Therefore, there is a complete repudiation
of the status of the Appellant in the suit property, as a tenant.
82.
Once the status of tenant is fortified, the relationship of landlord-
tenant ceases to exist between the parties. The Appellant has thus, become
the unauthorised occupant in the suit property, who has been served with a
Legal Notice to vacate the Property.
83.
In M/s Nopany Investments (P) Ltd. vs. Santokh Singh (HUF), (2008)
2 SCC 728, the Supreme Court has held that filing of an eviction Suit under
the general law itself is a notice to quit on the tenant. Therefore, even
otherwise, the filing of the Suit itself tantamount to termination of the rights
of a tenant/occupant in the suit premises. It is thus, established that the
Appellant has no right title to continue in the suit premises.
84.
Even otherwise, the Appellant was admittedly inducted as a tenant
and, by virtue of termination of his tenancy, he has become an unauthorised
occupant liable to vacate the suit premises.
85.
The contention raised by the Appellant that there was no evidence to
prove that the rate of rent in respect of the suit property was more than
Rs.3,500/- per month and, therefore, the jurisdiction of the Civil Court was
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
barred, is also without merit.
86.
As already discussed above, the Appellant has himself repudiated the
relationship of landlord and tenant and asserted an independent title in
himself. It has already been discussed, the title of the Appellant never
matured into that of an owner, but while claiming ownership, he repudiated
his status in the suit property as that of a tenant thereby, became an
unauthorised occupant, entitling the Plaintiff to seek possession. Having
denied his status as a tenant and having set up ownership in himself, he
cannot simultaneously seek protection of the tenancy under the Delhi Rent
Control Act, 1958.
87.
The Suit for possession under the general civil law is, therefore,
maintainable.
Conclusion:
88.
Accordingly, it is held that the Appeal has been rightly allowed by
setting aside the Judgment of the learned Civil Judge and the Suit of the
Plaintiff, has been rightly decreed for Possession, Mesne Profits and
Permanent Injunction.
89.
No substantial questions of law have been raised. The Appeal is
without merit and is accordingly, dismissed. The pending Applications are
also disposed of, accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 8, 2026/RS
KUMAR BHATT
17:30:42
RSA 164/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review