Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:42008
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CR No.159 of 2025
Reserved on: 13.08.2026
Decided on: 29.09.2026
Uploaded on: 29.09.2026
Kishan Singh alias Krishan Singh
...Petitioner
Versus
Diwan Singh and others
...Respondents
Coram
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? 1 Yes
For the petitioner:
Mr.
Sanjeev Kuthiala,
Senior
Advocate with Ms. Tamanna
Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr.
Anand
Sharma,
Senior
Advocate,
with
Mr.
Virender
Thakur, Advocate, for respondents
No.1 & 2.
Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge
The petitioner-judgment debtor has challenged
the order dated 12.08.2025 passed by the learned Senior
Civil Judge, Mandi, Distt. Mandi, H.P. in Execution Petition
No.27 of 2020, titled, Diwan Singh and another vs.
Kishan Singh and others, whereby the executing Court
has ordered to grant the relief of joint possession in favour
of respondents No.1 and 2-decree holders, along with
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:42008
judgment debtors, wherein symbolic possession is to be
given in their favour by way of Munadi, the charges of which
shall be deposited by respondents No.1 and 2-decree
holders with the Court within a period of 7 days and
thereafter one copy of warrant of possession has been
directed to be affixed on the conspicuous part of the suit
property.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are
hereinafter referred to as decree holders-plaintiffs and
judgment debtors-defendants.
3.
The decree holders-plaintiffs had filed a suit for
declaration
judgment
and
possession
debtors-defendants
of
suit
land
against
the
which
was
decreed
on
29.09.1997 by the learned Senior Sub Judge, Mandi, H.P. (in
short ‘learned trial Court’). A decree declaring the Will
executed by Pat as illegal, null and void was passed and the
decree holders-plaintiffs were held owners in possession of
the suit land to the extent of 1/6 th share and judgment
debtors-defendants No.3 to 7 to the extent of 1/6 th share
each as successors of Pat and a decree for joint possession
of the suit land in favour of the decree holders-plaintiffs and
against the judgment debtors-defendants was passed.
2026:HHC:42008
4.
The
judgment
debtors-defendants
feeling
aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated 29.09.1997
passed by the learned trial Court had preferred an appeal
before the learned Additional District Judge, Mandi, which
was dismissed on 29.08.2003. Thereafter, the judgment
debtors-defendants preferred an Appeal before this Court,
which was registered as RSA No.438 of 2003 and the same
was dismissed vide judgment dated 01.12.2012.
5.
The decree holders-plaintiffs thereafter filed an
execution petition under Order 21 Rule 11 read with Rule 35
of the Code of Civil Procedure (in short ‘CPC’), seeking
execution of the judgment and decree dated 29.09.1997
passed by the learned trial Court. The petitioner-Judgment
debtor No.1 preferred objections against the execution of
the decree on the grounds that the execution petition is not
legally maintainable and is liable to be dismissed, since the
same has not been filed within limitation.
6.
Thereafter an application under Order 6 Rule 17
CPC was filed by the petitioner-Judgment debtor No.1
seeking amendment of the objections. It was averred in the
amended objections that it is wrong that the decree holdersplaintiffs are having 1/6th share in the suit land. As a matter
2026:HHC:42008
of fact, Pat had died on 17.10.1981 and after his death, the
Will executed by him has been declared null and void and as
such after his death, his land/property has also been
inherited by his widow Smt. Kanchnu Devi, two sons, Inder
Singh and Lalman and four daughters and as such decree
holders-plaintiffs
being
predecessor-in-interest
of
Sh.
Lalman are having 1/7th share in the land under execution.
Smt. Kanchnu Devi had died on 08.12.1988 and she had
already bequeathed her landed property in favour of
judgment debtors No. 1 and 2. Similarly Kala Devi daughter
of Pat had died on 12.06.2017 leaving behind judgment
debtors No.1 and 2 being her sole successors on the basis
of registered Will dated 30.07.2001. Further the decree
holders-plaintiffs are having no legal right to file the
execution
petition
against
the
judgment
debtors-
the
of
defendants.
7.
The
executing
Court
on
basis
the
averments made in the execution petition coupled with the
decree sought to be executed has passed an order on
12.08.2025, thereby granting the relief of joint possession of
the suit land by way of symbolic possession to be given to
the
decree
holders-plaintiffs
alongwith
the
judgment
2026:HHC:42008
debtors-defendants No.3 to 7 by way of Munadi.
While
passing the order, the executing Court has taken note of the
fact that the Will executed by Pat was declared illegal, null
and void and the decree holders-plaintiffs were held owners
in possession of the suit land to the extent of 1/6 th share
and judgment debtors-defendants No.3 to 7 to the extent of
1/6th share each as being successors of Pat along with joint
possession. The averment made by the judgment debtorsdefendants that the decree holders-plaintiffs are not entitled
to 1/6th share of the property, rather to the 1/7 th share as
Pat's property was inherited by his widow Kanchnu Devi,
two sons Inder Singh and Lalman and four daughters was
also considered. As per the head note of the judgment
dated 29.09.1997, the plaintiffs-decree holders are sons of
deceased Lalman, son of Pat and defendants No.1 & 2 are
sons of Inder Singh, son of Pat and defendants No.3 to 6 are
the daughters of deceased Pat and defendant No.7 is son of
Pat and the Court has set aside the Will alleged to have
been executed by Sh. Pat in favour of the sons of Inder
Singh. Therefore, the judgment debtor Nos.1 and 2defendants No.1 & 2 would step into the shoes of defendant
No.7 as to the share that he will be receiving by their father
2026:HHC:42008
Inder Singh and thus, the entitlement of the decree holdersplaintiffs and the judgment debtors-defendants is only to
the extent of 1/6th share to the property and not 1/7 th share
as alleged. No doubt, the decree holders-plaintiffs have not
denied the receipt of the share of Kanchnu Devi upon her
death by judgment debtors-defendants No.1 and 2, but
since the matter qua her share was never raised at the time
of decision in the main suit, it cannot be raised in the
execution petition, hence, the executing Court passed an
order granting relief of joint possession, to be given to the
decree holders-plaintiffs along with the judgment debtors,
wherein symbolic possession is to be given in favour of the
decree holders-plaintiffs by way of Munadi.
8.
The
petitioner-judgment
debtor
No.1
feeling
aggrieved by the order dated 12.08.2025 passed by the
learned Senior Civil Judge, Mandi, District Mandi, H.P. (in
short ‘learned executing Court’), has preferred the present
petition inter alia on the ground that once a finding was
given by this Court in RSA No.438 of 2003, titled, Kishan
Singh and another vs. Jawahar Singh and others to
the effect that the Will of Pat was shrouded by suspicious
circumstances and on the basis of inheritance, the sons,
2026:HHC:42008
daughters and widow of Pat were entitled to 1/7 th share and
not 1/6th share, as has been sought to be executed in the
execution petition, the finding returned by the executing
Court that the decree holders-plaintiffs are entitled to 1/6 th
share is bad in law and deserves to be quashed and set
aside. Further the executing Court had dismissed the
application for amendment of the objections on the
inference that the share of Kanchnu Devi by way of
inheritance from the property of Pat was never raised in the
suit and had failed to take into consideration that the suit
was for declaration with respect to the Will made by Pat in
favour of the petitioner-judgment debtor No.1 and proforma
respondent No.3, was held to be invalidated on account of
suspicious circumstances and the property was to be given
by way of inheritance. It has also been averred that the
executing Court has failed to take into consideration the fact
that the amendment of the objections, as sought, and the
objections
amendment
were
was
to
be
decided
required
for
together,
proper
and
since
the
effective
adjudication of the controversy between the parties and
thus, prayed for quashing the order passed by the executing
Court, whereby the symbolic possession was ordered to be
2026:HHC:42008
given in favour of the decree holders-plaintiffs by way of
Munadi and also prayed to allow the objections preferred by
the petitioner-judgment debtor No.1.
9.
I
have
heard
the
learned
senior
counsel
representing the parties and also perused the record
carefully.
10.
Learned
senior
counsel
representing
the
petitioner-judgment debtor No.1 vehemently argued that
this Court had returned the findings in the Regular Second
Appeal preferred by the judgment debtors-defendants that
the Will executed by Pat was shrouded by suspicious
circumstances and on the basis of inheritance, the sons,
daughters and widow of late Pat were entitled to 1/7 th share
and not 1/6th share, as has been sought to be executed in
the execution petition and thus, the executing Court has
erred while passing the impugned order holding that the
decree holders-plaintiffs are entitled to 1/6th share. He
further strenuously argued that the executing Court has also
erred in dismissing the application seeking amendment of
the objections. The executing Court has not framed the
issues to the effect whether the decree holders-plaintiffs
were entitled to 1/6th share and 1/7th share. The executing
2026:HHC:42008
Court has failed to take into consideration that the suit was
for declaration with respect to the Will made by Pat and
once the Will was declared as void, the property was to be
inherited by way of inheritance and widow of Pat namely
Kanchnu Devi was also entitled to one share and the
executing Court while passing the impugned order has
acted illegally and with material irregularity and as such
prayed for quashing the order under challenge as well as for
allowing the objections. He placed reliance upon the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sanwarlal
Agrawal and others vs. Ashok Kumar Kothari and
others, (2023) 7 SCC 307 and judgment passed by the
Punjab and Haryana High Court in M/s. Woolways, Shopcum-Office, Chandigarh and others vs. Central Bank
of India, Chandigarh and others, AIR 1990 Punjab and
Haryana 92 and argued that the executing Court is free to
refer the pleading while executing the decree, so as to
construe the true import of the decree.
11.
On the other hand, the learned senior counsel
representing the decree holders-plaintiffs supported the
order under challenge and submitted that once the trial
Court had passed the decree for declaration that the Will
2026:HHC:42008
executed by Pat is illegal, null and void and the decree
holders are owners in possession to the extent of 1/6 th share
in the suit land and further defendant Nos.3 to 7 are also
owners in possession to the extent of 1/6 th share each as
successors of Pat along with a decree for joint possession of
the suit land, the executing Court has rightly passed the
order and it is settled law that the executing Court cannot
go behind the decree. He placed reliance upon the
judgments passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Rafique Bibi (dead) by LRs. vs. Sayed Waliuddin
(dead) by LRs. and others, (2004) 1 SCC 287, and
Deepa Bhargava and another vs. Mahesh Bhargava
and others, (2009) 2 SCC 294. He argued that since there
is no ambiguity in the judgment and decree sought to be
executed, the executing Court has rightly held that the
decree holders-plaintiffs are entitled to 1/6 th share and no
interference is called for while exercising the revisional
jurisdiction and thus, prayed for dismissal of the revision
petition.
12.
I have given my thoughtful consideration to the
submissions made at the Bar. Before adverting to the
submissions made at the Bar and the issue raised in the
2026:HHC:42008
present petition, it will be relevant to quote the relevant
para of the judgment dated 29.09.1997 passed by the trial
Court, which reads as under:
“19. Thus, for the foregoing reasons recorded for
deciding the aforesaid issues, the suit of the plaintiffs
succeeds and therefore, is decreed for declaration
that the Will in suit is illegal, null and void and the
plaintiffs are owners in possession to the extent of
1/6th share in the suit land and the defendants No.3
to 7 are also owners in possession to the extent of
1/6th share each as successors of Sh. Pat alongwith a
decree for joint possession of the suit land is granted
in favour of the plaintiffs and against defendants,
with no order as to costs in the peculiar
circumstances of the case. Decree sheet be prepared
accordingly. File, after completion, be consigned to
the record room.”
13.
It is apt even to take note of the decree passed
by the trial Court, which is sought to be executed and the
same reads as under:“The suit is decreed for declaration that the will in
suit is illegal, null and void and the plaintiffs are
owners in possession to the extent of 1/6th share in
the suit land and the defendants No.3 to 7 are also
owners in possession to the extent of 1/6th share
each as successors of Pat alongwith a decree for joint
possession of the suit land is granted in favour of the
plaintiffs and against defendants. There is no order
as to costs.”
14.
A perusal of the judgment and decree passed by
the trial Court, which was sought to be executed, clearly
2026:HHC:42008
shows that the decree holders-plaintiffs have been held
owners in possession to the extent of 1/6 th share in the suit
land and judgment debtors-defendants No.3 to 7 in the suit
are held to be owners in possession to the extent of 1/6 th
share each as successors of Pat and a decree of declaration
to that effect has been passed along with a decree for joint
possession of the suit land. The petitioner-judgment debtor
No.1 and proforma respondent No.3 who are the sons of
defendant No.7 Inder Singh are entitled to inherit share of
Inder Singh. It is not in dispute that the judgment passed by
the trial Court holding that the decree holders-plaintiffs are
owners in possession to the extent of 1/6 th share in the suit
land has been affirmed up to this Court when the appeal
preferred by the judgment debtors-defendants has been
dismissed. Once the trial Court has categorically held that
the decree holders-plaintiffs are entitled to 1/6th share, the
executing Court cannot go behind the decree.
15.
The judgment cited by the learned senior counsel
for the petitioner-judgment debtor No.1 in Sanwarlal
Agrawal’s case (supra) is not attracted to the facts of the
present case for the reason that the Court in this judgment
has held that if there is any ambiguity in the decree, the
2026:HHC:42008
executing Court to construe the decree, if necessary, can
refer the judgment and if sufficient guidance is not available
even from the judgment, the Court can refer to pleadings to
construe the true import of the decree. But in the present
case, the trial Court had specifically returned the findings
and passed the decree that the decree holders-plaintiffs are
entitled to 1/6th share. Thus, no illegality has been
committed by the executing Court to hold that the decree
holders-plaintiffs are entitled to 1/6th share. Relevant para
of the judgment reads as under:
“21. With respect to Rajinder Kumar v. Kuldeep
Singh, the counsel has placed reliance on the
following paragraph: (SCC p. 544, para 21)
"21. If the suit for specific performance is not
decreed as prayed for, then alone the question
of any reference to the alternative relief would
arise. Therefore, there is no question of any
ambiguity. As held by this Court in Topanmal
Chhotamal v. Kundomal Gangaram and
consistently followed thereafter, even if there is
any ambiguity, it is for the executing court to
construe the decree if necessary after referring
to the judgment. If sufficient guidance is not
available even from the judgment, the court is
even free to refer to the pleadings so as to
construe the true import of the decree. No
doubt, the court cannot go behind the decree
or beyond the decree. But while executing a
decree for specific performance, the court, in
case of any ambiguity, has necessarily to
construe the decree so as to give effect to the
intention of the parties. Thus, there is no
2026:HHC:42008
question of any alternate relief regarding the
damages, etc. in the present case since the
suit for the specific performance for the
conveyance of the property has been decreed."
This elucidation of the law is unexceptionable. It is
undeniable that an executing court can construe a
decree if it is ambiguous. However, as in the facts of
the case herein, this cannot result in additions (to the
terms of the consent, embodied in the email dated
28-3-2019) which were not agreed upon by the
parties, since the decree was drawn on by consent of
both parties at admissions stage itself. Both the
Single Judge and Division Bench of the High Court
have interpreted the appellants' silence (manifest in
their not filing any written statement) as
acquiescence to the inclusion of the loan amount,
which, is although worthy of adverse inference,
cannot be the reason to justify expansion of the
decree.”
16.
It is settled law that the executing Court is
empowered to decide questions relating to execution,
discharge or satisfaction of the decree and has no
jurisdiction to go behind the decree, sought to be executed.
Reference in this regard is made to the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vasudev Dhanjibhai Modi vs.
Rajabhai Abdul Rehman and others, (1970) 1 SCC 670
and the relevant para reads as under:
“6. A Court executing a decree cannot go behind the
decree between the parties or their representatives it
must take the decree according to its tenor, and
cannot entertain any objection that the decree was
incorrect in law or on facts. Until it is set aside by an
2026:HHC:42008
appropriate proceeding in appeal or revision, a
decree even if it be erroneous is still binding between
the parties.”
17.
A similar view was taken by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Sunder Dass vs. Ram Prakash, (1977) 2 SCC
662. However, it was held that the executing Court can go
behind the decree if it is pleaded that the decree was a
nullity by reason of the Court passing it lacked inherent
jurisdiction to pass it. The
relevant para of the judgment
reads as under:
“3. Now, the law is well settled that an executing
court cannot go behind the decree nor can it
question its legality or correctness. But there is one
exception to this general rule and that is that where
the decree sought to be executed is a nullity for lack
of inherent jurisdiction in the court passing it, its
invalidity can be set up in an execution proceeding.
Where there is lack of inherent jurisdiction, it goes to
the root of the competence of the court to try the
case and a decree which is a nullity is void and can
be declared to be void by any court in which it is
presented. Its nullity can be set up whenever and
wherever it is sought to be enforced or relied upon
and even at the stage of execution or even in
collateral proceedings. The executing court can,
therefore, entertain an objection that the decree is a
nullity and can refuse to execute the decree. By
doing so, the executing court would not incur the
reproach that it is going behind the decree, because
the decree being null and void, there would really be
no decree at all. Vide Kiran Singh v. Chaman Paswan
and Seth Hiralal Patni v. Sri Kali Nath. It is, therefore,
obvious that in the present case, it was competent to
the executing court to examine whether the decree
for eviction was a nullity on the ground that the civil
2026:HHC:42008
court had no inherent jurisdiction to entertain the
suit in which the decree for eviction was passed. If
the decree for eviction was a nullity, the executing
court could declare it to be such and decline to
execute it against the respondent.”
18.
The above view that the executing Court cannot
go behind the decree and modify the same has again been
reiterated
by
Bhargava’s
the
Hon'ble
case (supra).
Supreme
The
Court
relevant
in
para
Deepa
of
the
judgment is reproduced hereunder:“9. There is no doubt or dispute as regards
interpretation or application of the said consent
terms. It is also not in dispute that the respondent
judgment-debtors did not act in terms thereof. An
executing court, it is well known, cannot go behind
the decree. It has no jurisdiction to modify a decree.
It must execute the decree as it is. A default clause
contained in a compromise decree even otherwise
would not be considered to be penal in nature so as
to attract the provisions of Section 74 of the Contract
Act.”
19.
Even
in
the
recent
judgment,
the
Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Maurice W. Innis vs. Lily Kazrooni @
Lily Arif Shaikh, 2026 INSC 340, has again reiterated that
the executing Court cannot go beyond the decree and thus,
the plea taken by the petitioner-judgment debtor No.1 that
the decree-holders are entitled to 1/7th share cannot be
accepted and the executing Court has rightly held that they
2026:HHC:42008
are entitled to 1/6th share based on the decree passed by
the trial Court.
20.
Learned
senior
counsel
for
the
petitioner-
judgment debtor No.1 argued that the executing Court has
failed to exercise the jurisdiction vested in it while
dismissing
the
application
seeking
amendment
of
objections. However, the application seeking amendment
was allowed on 19.03.2025 and the executing Court has
considered the averments made in the amended petition
wherein it was raised that the decree holders-plaintiffs are
not
having
1/6th
share.
The
executing
Court
after
considering the said averment has given specific findings
that as per the decree passed by the Court, the decree
holders-plaintiffs are held entitled to 1/6 th share and the
executing Court cannot decide the matter qua the share of
Kanchnu Devi, which was never raised at the time of the
decision in the suit. Once the trial Court had held that the
decree holders-plaintiffs are entitled to 1/6 th share, which
findings have been affirmed up to this Court, the executing
Court cannot held that the decree holders-plaintiffs are
entitled to 1/7th share as pleaded and argued by the learned
senior counsel for the petitioner-judgment debtor No.1.
2026:HHC:42008
21.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner-
judgment debtor No.1 further argued that the learned Court
has not decided the objections judicially and not framed the
issue while deciding the objections. He placed reliance on
the judgment in M/s. Woolways case (supra). In this
judgment, it has been held that the executing Court is not
enjoined by the statute to frame the issues and to dispose
of the same in the same manner as a suit, nevertheless the
executing Court is under obligation to decide the dispute in
a judicial manner. In the present case, the executing Court
has decided the issue after noticing that the decree holdersplaintiffs are held entitled to 1/6th share, which findings are
based on the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court
and the said judgment had attained finality. Therefore, no
illegality of material irregularity has been committed by the
executing Court while passing the order under challenge.
22.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has time and again
held that the power of revisional jurisdiction is to be
exercised very cautiously. This Court while exercising the
revisional jurisdiction cannot act as an Appellate Court. Not
only this, the Court can exercise the jurisdiction, only if
there is material irregularity and illegality having been
2026:HHC:42008
committed by the executing Court. In the present case, as
already noticed above, the executing Court has rightly
understood the import of the decree sought to be executed
passed by the Court in which it was specifically held that
the decree holders-plaintiffs are entitled to 1/6 th share and
thus, this Court while exercising the revisional jurisdiction
cannot conclude that the decree holders-plaintiffs are
entitled to 1/7th share. The executing Court has neither
committed any illegality nor material irregularity while
passing
the
order
under
challenge
and,
thus,
no
interference is called for.
23.
Consequently, I do not find any merit in the
present revision petition and the same is accordingly
dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of. Records
be sent back.
29th September, 2026
(Anurag)
( Jiya Lal Bhardwaj )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review