Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 08th July 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 513/2018
KIRPAL SINGH
.....Appellant
Through:
Mr. Navneet Goyal, Advocate.
versus
QUTABUDDIN & ORS (UNITED INDIA INSURNACE CO LTD)
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Kinger Vijay, Advocate for
Respondent nos.1 & 2.
Ms. Shruti Jain, Mr. Pankaj Seth,
Advocates for Respondent no.3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed seeking enhancement of compensation
awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Karkardooma Courts,
Delhi (‘MACT/Tribunal’) vide impugned judgment/award dated 12th
March 2018 in DAR No.14513/2015 at Rs.8,73,000/- along with interest at
9% per annum.
2.
The accident occurred on 13th October 2014, when appellant/injured
claimant- Kirpal Singh, who was working as a TSR driver, sustained
injuries when he was crossing the road at Power House, Main Pusta Road,
Delhi and was hit by a scooter bearing registration no. DL-14-SA-5794
MAC.APP. 513/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:58:43
(hereinafter, ‘offending vehicle’) allegedly being driven in a rash and
negligent manner. As a result of the accident, he fell down on the road and
sustained grievous injuries and underwent surgeries with steel implants in
his right leg and right pelvis. As per the Disability Certificate, he suffered
67% permanent locomotor impairment in relation to his right lower limb
and right upper limb.
3.
Mr. Navneet Goyal, counsel for appellant/injured claimant, seeks
enhancement principally on two counts. Firstly, functional disability was
considered at 40%, despite permanent disability being 67% in relation to
his right upper and lower limb, due to which he was unable to pursue his
occupation as a TSR driver and; secondly, income was considered at
minimum wages of an unskilled worker, whereas, proof to the effect that he
was working a TSR driver was placed on record, therefore, minimum
wages of a skilled worker at Rs.10,478/- ought to be considered.
4.
Ms. Shruti Jain, counsel appears for respondent no.3/Insurance
Company and Mr. Kinger Vijay, counsel appears for respondent nos.
1/driver and respondent no.2/owner.
5.
As regards the first issue, Mr. Navneet Goyal, counsel for
appellant/injured claimant draws attention to the evidence of Dr. Mrudul
Shah, Senior Resident, GTB Hospital, Delhi (‘PW2’) who testified that the
Disability Certificate bore his signatures, as per which permanent disability
was certified at 67%.
6.
Dr. Ashok Makhija, M.S. Orthopaedics, Durga Hospital, Mukherjee
Nagar (‘PW-3’), had treated the appellant/injured claimant. PW-3 opined
that appellant/injured claimant would require ortho plasty of right hip and
MAC.APP. 513/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:58:43
also plasty of right knee, and the approximate cost of surgery and
hospitalization would be Rs.8,00,000/-. Even after the treatment, the patient
will have persistent permanent disability of about 40% in relation to right
lower limb.
7.
Mr. Navneet Goyal, states on instructions, that no further surgery
took place, since a long passage of time has passed since the accident took
place. He further points to two documents on record relating to
appellant/injured claimant’s vocation, which is the Registration Certificate
of TSR issued in favour of appellant/injured claimant (Ex. PW1/4), as well
as, the vehicle badge (Ex. PW1/6) issued by the Transport Department,
Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (‘GNCTD’) with badge
no. 05234.
8.
Further reliance is placed on the testimony of appellant/injured
claimant (‘PW1’), who stated that he was working as a TSR driver and was
earning Rs.20,000/- per month on the date of the accident and he has since
become permanently crippled due to the injuries and cannot lift any weight,
squat, run, climb stairs and walk properly. He stated that he has been
unable to drive any vehicle. In cross-examination, his testimony was not
diluted in any manner whatsoever, nor was any suggestion placed that he
was not a TSR driver.
9.
Ms. Shruti Jain, counsel for respondent no.3/Insurance Company,
points out to paragraph nos.13 & 14 of the impugned award, stating that no
proof in support of his vocation as a TSR driver has been filed. However,
considering the facts above, this contention is untenable.
10.
In this view of the matter, MACT’s finding on assessing income on
MAC.APP. 513/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:58:43
the basis of minimum wages of an unskilled worker cannot be sustained
and will therefore, be enhanced to minimum wages of a skilled worker at
Rs.10,478/- per month.
11.
As regards functional disability, considering his vocation was that of
a TSR driver, reliance may be placed upon decisions of the Supreme Court
in Chanappa Nagappa Muchalagoda v. Divisional Manager, New India
Insurance Co. Ltd. (2020) 1 SCC 796 and Gurudev Singh v. Reliance
General Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors. SLP (C) No. 5351 of 2019.
12.
In Chanappa (supra), the claimant was a heavy vehicle driver aged
33 years at the time of the accident and was permanently incapacitated due
to an injury to his right leg, resulting in complete disability from continuing
his vocation. Considering that he required the support of a walking stick to
walk, needed assistance to ensure mobility, and had lost the prospect of
securing any other manual employment, therefore, the Supreme Court
assessed his functional disability at 100%. Relevant findings of the Court
are extracted as under:
“12. In K.Janardhan v. United India Insurance Co.
Ltd. [K. Janardhan v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.,
(2008) 8 SCC 518 : (2008) 2 SCC (L&S) 733] this
Court examined the loss of earning capacity in the case
of a tanker driver who had met with an accident, and
lost one of his legs due to amputation. The
Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation assessed
the functional disability of the tanker driver as 100%
and awarded compensation on that basis. The High
Court, however, referred [United India Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. K. Janardhan, 2001 SCC OnLine Kar 841] to
Schedule I to the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
and held that loss of a leg on amputation resulted in
only 60% loss of earning capacity. This Court set aside
the judgment [United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. K.
MAC.APP. 513/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:58:43
Janardhan, 2001 SCC OnLine Kar 841] of the High
Court, and held that since the workman could no
longer earn his living as a tanker driver due to loss of
one leg, the functional disability had to be assessed as
100%.
13. In S. Suresh v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. [S.
Suresh v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., (2010) 13 SCC
777 : (2011) 1 SCC (Civ) 807 : (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)
423] this Court held that: (SCC p. 780, para 9)
“9. We are of the opinion that on account of
amputation of his right leg below knee, he is
rendered unfit for the work of a driver, which he
was performing at the time of the accident
resulting in the said disablement. Therefore, he
has lost 100% of his earning capacity as a lorry
driver, more so, when he is disqualified from even
getting a driving licence under the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988.”
14. The aforesaid judgments are instructive for
assessing the compensation payable to the appellant in
the present case. As a consequence of the accident, the
appellant has been incapacitated for life, since he can
walk only with the help of a walking stick. He has lost
the ability to work as a driver, as he would be
disqualified from even getting a driving licence. The
prospect of securing any other manual labour job is
not possible, since he would require the assistance of a
person to ensure his mobility and manage his
discomfort. As a consequence, the functional disability
suffered by the appellant must be assessed as 100%.”
(emphasis added)
13.
In Gurudev Singh (supra), the Supreme Court was considering the
award of 100% functional disability of a driver by the MACT on the basis
of his Disability Certificate and his avocation. The High Court, on the other
MAC.APP. 513/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:58:43
hand, arrived at the conclusion that functional disability was not more than
30% by placing reliance on the Disability Certificate. The Supreme Court
set aside the High Court’s finding and assessed functional disability at
100%. Relevant observations are extracted as under:
“A perusal of the same would indicate that the MACT on
taking note of the evidence has recorded a finding of fact
with regard to the nature of disability and keeping in
view the disability assessed by the Doctor at 30% has
concluded that it would affect his avocation as a driver
and therefore related the said disability to the functional
disability.
As against the finding recorded by the MACT, a perusal
of the consideration made by the High Court would
indicate that no other contrary material has been
appreciated nor the available records have been reappreciated to record a finding of fact. The High Court,
in fact, has only taken note of the decision of this Court
which indicate the manner in which the disability is to be
considered and has abruptly arrived at the conclusion
that the functional disability was not more than 30%. We
are of the opinion such conclusion reached by the High
Court is only in the nature of presumption which cannot
be sustained.
In that view, in the present facts, the disability is to be
reckoned at 100% and the compensation is to be
recalculated…”
(emphasis added)
14.
Accordingly, taking into account the above decisions of Supreme
Court and considering the vocation of appellant/injured claimant, this Court
is inclined to consider his functional disability at 70%.
15.
Additionally, grant of future prospects shall have to be aligned with
the principles enunciated in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi,
MAC.APP. 513/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:58:43
(2017) 16 SCC 680, therefore, considering that appellant/injured claimant
was 55 years old, 10% towards future prospects shall be granted.
16.
Accordingly, the revised computation is as under:
Sr.
No.
Heads
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Awarded by
this Court
PECUNIARY LOSS
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
Expenditure on treatment (A)
Expenditure on conveyance
(B)
Expenditure on special diet
(C)
Nursing/Attendant Charges
(D)
Income of injured (E)
Rs. 1,33,458/Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 1,33,458/Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 8,632/-
Rs. 10,478/-
Add: Future prospects @
Nil
10% (F)
Multiplier (G)
Functional disability (H)
40%
Loss of income (I)
Rs. 1,03,585/Loss of future income/future
Rs. 4,55,774/earnings [(E + F) x 12 x G x
H] = (J)
NON-PECUNIARY LOSS
Pain and suffering (K)
Loss of amenities of life (L)
Total compensation (A + B +
C + D + I + J + K+ L) = M
Interest awarded
Rs. 1,047.8/11
70%
Rs. 1,25,736/Rs. 10,64,984/-
Rs. 1,00,000/Rs. 50,000/Rs. 8,72,817/-
Rs. 1,00,000/Rs. 50,000/Rs. 15,04,178/-
9%
9%
Directions
17.
For aforesaid reasons, compensation has been enhanced by Rs.
6,31,361/- [‘enhanced amount’].
MAC.APP. 513/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:58:43
18.
Enhanced amount along with 9% interest per annum from the date of
filing the petition shall be deposited by respondent no.3/Insurance
Company before the MACT within a period of four weeks, which shall be
released as lump sum to appellant/claimant within two weeks thereafter.
19.
Accordingly, the appeal is disposed of in the above terms.
20.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
21.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned MACT.
22.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned bank for information
and compliance.
23.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
JULY 8, 2026/ak/sp
MAC.APP. 513/2018
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:58:43
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review