Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
KINSHUK MAHANTY & ORS.
Through:
.....Petitioners
Mr. Manoj Mishra, Mr. Vishesh Jain
and Mr. Rajesh Gupta, Advocates
versus
OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Abhishek Puri, Ms. Surbhi Gupta
& Mr. Sahil Grewal, Advocates for
R-1 to R-12.
Mr. Satya Ranjan Swain, CGSC with
Mr. Kautilya Birat, Mr. Ankush
Kapoor & Mr. Vishwadeep, Advs. for
R-13.
Mr. Virender Pratap Singh Charak &
Ms. Shubhra Parashar, Advs. for R13.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
09.01.2026
%
1.
This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeks, in substance,
two sets of directions: first, a mandamus to regularise or absorb the
Petitioners, who were engaged as fixed tenure Field Executives pursuant to
Advertisement No. 3/2008 (R&P); and second, a mandamus directing parity
in salary, promotional avenues and allied service benefits with regular
executives of the Respondent Corporation, particularly Graduate Trainees
(E-1 level) recruited in the same period.
2.
The relevant facts are largely undisputed. In 2008, the Respondent
issued an advertisement for recruitment of 250 fixed tenure Field
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
Executives. The engagement was on consolidated remuneration (Onshore:
INR 45,000/-; Offshore and North-East: INR 48,000/-), with the
advertisement and the offer terms clarifying that the engagement was
contractual, fixed-term, and not a route to absorption in the regular cadre.
3.
In the same year, the Respondent issued a separate advertisement for
recruitment of Graduate Trainees, described as the entry-level route to the
regular executive cadre, carrying a basic pay of INR 24,900/- (with dearness
allowance and other admissible components as per the applicable structure).
4.
The Petitioners were selected as tenure-based Field Executives
through an All-India written test followed by interview, and were issued
appointment letters on the terms and conditions extracted in the record.
Those terms leave little room for ambiguity. The tenure was “for a maximum
period of four years”, coming to an end automatically on completion of the
period, without further notice, subject to the possibility of fresh engagement
depending on requirement and satisfactory performance. Pertinently, the
offer letter required the appointee to sign an undertaking that “engagement
on tenure basis will not entitle” the appointee “for any regular employment”
and that “no claim” seeking regularisation based on tenure engagement
would be preferred. The remuneration was consolidated, with a notional
“tenure pay” indicated for limited reimbursement purposes, and the letter
specified, with equal clarity, that no benefits beyond those enumerated
would be admissible.
5.
Mr. Manoj Mishra, counsel for the Petitioners, makes the following
submissions in support of the Petitioner’s prayer:
5.1.
Although the initial engagement was described as tenure-based and
non-absorbable, in practice, it acquired the attributes of regular service. The
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
Petitioners were appointed in 2009 pursuant to Advertisement No. 3/2008
(R&P), through a national level written examination followed by interview,
and that their tenure was thereafter extended repeatedly over an
uninterrupted period of about 16 years, without any interim protection from
a court. Such long and continuous engagement shows that the work was
neither transient nor genuinely project specific. The Petitioners were
deployed at established operational units of the Respondent, including
drilling rigs, production installations, refineries and plants, and were utilised
as substitutes or relievers for regular executives, thereby discharging duties
broadly comparable to those performed by Graduate Trainees in the regular
executive cadre.
5.2.
On this footing, the Respondent cannot maintain a rigid segregation
between “tenure” and “regular” personnel when, on the ground, the
Petitioners were deployed for core and continuing functions. The
designation “Field Executive” was used to create a separate tenure stream
primarily as a cost-containment device, despite the work being of a
continuing operational character. The Respondent had a practice of
recruiting regular Graduate Trainees through campus selections between
2008 and 2016. Thus, while the regular cadre expanded, the Petitioners
continued to be retained for comparable operational work without access to
cadre benefits, promotional avenues or pay progression.
5.3.
A wage disparity emerged over time. The Petitioners, even after about
14 years of continuous service, received only consolidated remuneration,
stated to be approximately INR 87,990/- (Onshore), INR 92,490/- (North
East), and INR 93,490/- (Offshore) per month, whereas regular executives
appointed in and around 2009 allegedly draw salaries in the range of INR
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
3,10,000/- per month. This, it is submitted, is not a mere incident of different
pay structures but a case of unequal treatment for substantially similar work,
offending Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. There is also violation of
Article 21 as prolonged engagement under a tenure label, despite continuous
service and comparable work, results in insecurity of tenure and denial of
dignity and fair conditions of service.
5.4.
Reliance is placed on the Constitution Bench decision in Secretary,
State of Karnataka & Ors. v. Umadevi (3) & Ors.1 to submit that the
Respondent’s rejection of the Petitioner’s representation solely on the
ground that the Petitioners did not opt for regular recruitment is legally
misconceived. The proper inquiry, consistent with Umadevi, is whether
sanctioned posts existed, whether vacancies were available, whether the
Petitioners possessed the requisite qualifications, and whether their initial
entry was through a process bearing the attributes of open and fair selection.
The Petitioner’s entry was not ‘back door’ in character, since it followed a
national examination and interview. At the highest, the Petitioner’s
appointment can be termed as ‘irregular’, capable of being regularised, and
not an ‘illegal’ entry beyond the zone of permissible relief. It is contended
that the tenure model, as operated, undermines the constitutional scheme
governing public employment.
5.5.
Reliance is also placed on Central Inland Water Transport
Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly2 to contend that the Respondent,
being an instrumentality of the State, cannot enforce contractual terms in a
manner that is unfair, unreasonable or arbitrary. On this basis, they submit
(2006) 4 SCC 1.
(1986) 3 SCC 156.
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
that the undertaking clause and the no absorption stipulation cannot be
treated as conclusive where the Respondent allegedly continued to extract
regular work for years, deployed the Petitioners alongside regular executives
in operational roles, and thereby entrenched a sustained inequality in pay
and service benefits. They submit that the rejection order dated 12 th January,
2023, passed by the Office of Executive Director – Chief, Employee
Relations, is vitiated for treating the tenure label as determinative, without
addressing the substance of the engagement and the governing constitutional
and service law principles.
6.
Mr. Abhishek Puri, counsel for Respondents No. 1 to 12, opposes the
petition and contends as follows:
6.1.
The Petitioners were never appointed to any regular cadre post and
their engagement was consciously structured as a fixed-term, contractual
arrangement to meet fluctuating manpower requirements linked to work
plans under the New Exploration Licensing Policy. The terms of
engagement, including the maximum tenure, consolidated remuneration and
service conditions, were expressly stipulated in the offer letters. The
Petitioners accepted those terms with full knowledge and executed an
undertaking acknowledging that the tenure engagement would not confer
any right to regular appointment and that no claim for regularisation would
be raised on that basis. In these circumstances, the Petitioners cannot seek a
writ commanding the Respondent to confer a status that the engagement
itself excluded.
6.2.
A regular recruitment channel existed contemporaneously. In the
same time period, ONGC issued recruitment notifications for Graduate
Trainees, the entry level in the regular executive cadre, for which the
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
Petitioners were eligible. They, however, chose not to participate in that
process. Having declined the regular route of entry, they cannot now seek
absorption through judicial direction by relying upon the longevity of their
contractual engagement.
6.3
The claim for pay parity proceeds on an incorrect assumption of
identity of work and responsibility. Regular executives, including Graduate
Trainees, are subject to All-India transfers and carry broader accountability.
They are required to undertake supervisory, administrative, reporting and
coordination functions and exercise controls over personnel and operational
decisions, whereas tenure-based Field Executives are deployed to meet
specific field requirements within a more limited functional domain and do
not perform the full range of executive responsibilities. The difference in
role, accountability and service conditions provides a rational basis for
distinct pay structures and defeats any claim founded on Articles 14 and 16
of Constitution of India.
Analysis
7.
The Petitioners seek two broad reliefs. First, a mandamus to
‘regularise/absorb’ tenure-based Field Executives into regular posts with
consequential service benefits. Second, a direction for pay parity and nondiscrimination in salary, progression and benefits with regular executives
(Graduate Trainees and those appointed around the same period). The
controversy turns on the limits of judicial power in matters of public
employment, and the legal consequences of a consciously structured fixedterm engagement accepted by the Petitioners with an express a no absorption
undertaking.
8.
Regularisation/Absorption
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
8.1.
The starting point is the nature of the initial engagement. The
appointment letters do not describe the Petitioners as probationers or regular
appointees in a cadre. They spell out, in clear terms, a fixed tenure,
consolidated remuneration, and a contractual framework under which the
tenure “comes to an end” automatically upon expiry, unless the employer
considers a fresh engagement. The terms also contain an undertaking clause
that the tenure engagement “will not entitle” the incumbent to regular
employment and that “no claim” for regularisation based on tenure
engagement shall be preferred.
8.2.
The Petitioners have argued that their long continuation through
extensions has, in substance, converted the arrangement into regular service,
and that the label “Field Executive” was only a device for cost saving.
Courts do examine substance over form where a label is used to defeat
constitutional protections. However, in public employment, the decisive
limitation is different. Even if the employer has taken work for a long
period, the Court cannot convert a contractual engagement into regular cadre
appointment by judicial fiat if that conversion would bypass the
constitutionally mandated route of recruitment.
8.3.
The Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Umadevi draws a
firm line. Public posts are to be filled through a process consistent with
Articles 14 and 16. Courts do not create posts, nor do they direct
regularisation as a routine remedy merely because a person has worked for
long or has been continued through extensions. The one-time measure
adverted to in Umadevi was not a general licence to regularise all longserving contractual employees. It was confined to a narrow class, and even
that subject to strict conditions, including that the engagement must be
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
against duly sanctioned vacant posts and must not be an illegal entry. Later
decisions have repeatedly clarified that longevity of service, by itself, does
not mature into a right to absorption, and that regularisation cannot be used
as an alternative route to public employment.
8.4.
Tested on that yardstick, the Petitioners’ case does not cross the
threshold for a writ of mandamus. The Petitioners do not demonstrate that
they were appointed against sanctioned cadre vacancies in the regular
executive structure, or that posts were earmarked for them and kept vacant
but filled through tenure engagement. Their engagement was framed as a
separate tenure category with its own compensation structure and service
conditions. The Petitioners may have entered through a written test and
interview, but that does not answer the real question. Regularisation is not
decided only by the manner of initial selection. It is decided by whether a
court can, without undermining the equal-opportunity principle, compel the
State instrumentality to confer permanent status in a cadre where entry is
otherwise regulated through notified recruitment.
8.5.
The Petitioners emphasise that ONGC simultaneously recruited
regular Graduate Trainees through campus processes and contend that this
reveals sanctioned posts and vacancies. The argument is not decisive for two
reasons. First, the existence of a regular recruitment channel undermines
rather than supports the prayer for absorption. If regular cadre posts were
being filled through a known channel, a judicial direction absorbing tenure
appointees would place them ahead of others who would be entitled to
compete for the same posts, and would therefore offend Articles 14 and 16
of the Constitution of India. Second, the Court cannot treat campus
recruitment as a concession that tenure engagement was a disguised regular
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
cadre arrangement. At the highest, it shows that the employer operated two
distinct streams. That distinction, even if debated on policy, cannot be
collapsed by a writ directing absorption, unless the Petitioners establish that
the separation itself was unconstitutional in law. Mere assertion of ‘cost
cutting’ does not substitute the required legal foundation for such a drastic
remedy.
8.6.
The Petitioners also contend that their work was not project-specific
and that they were deployed at existing installations. Even if that factual
assertion is accepted at face value, it still does not carry the Petitioners to a
right of regularisation. Deployment at a continuing establishment does not,
by itself, transform a contractual tenure into a regular cadre appointment.
8.7.
The Petitioners rely on Brojo Nath to contend that contractual
stipulations imposed by a State instrumentality must be fair and nonarbitrary. The proposition is unexceptionable. However, that principle
cannot be stretched to compel creation of permanent service status contrary
to the public employment framework. Brojo Nath addressed unconscionable
contractual power and an oppressive termination clause in a different
context. Here, the no absorption term is not a hidden trap sprung after entry.
It is an upfront condition of engagement, applied uniformly to all tenure
appointees, and aligned with the constitutional rule that public posts are not
to be filled by informal conversion of contractual staff into regular cadre
appointees.
8.8.
The impugned order dated 12th January, 2023, rejects the
representation substantially on the premise that the Petitioners did not enter
the regular cadre through the regular recruitment process. That reasoning is
not contrary to Umadevi. It reflects the basic constitutional limitation that
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
regularisation cannot become a parallel mode of appointment. The
Petitioners’ attempt is, in substance, to secure a permanent cadre status
without undergoing the recruitment route meant for such cadre posts. A Writ
Court cannot grant that relief.
9.
Pay parity and ‘equal pay for equal work’
9.1.
The Petitioners also invoke Articles 14 and 16 on the footing that they
perform similar work as Graduate Trainees and regular executives but
receive consolidated remuneration far below the regular scale. The doctrine
of ‘equal pay for equal work’ is not an abstract slogan. It is applied on a
strict comparison of the nature of duties, the level of responsibility, the
degree of accountability, service conditions and functional requirements.
Courts also recognise that difference in mode of recruitment, tenure security,
transfer liability, supervisory functions and organisational accountability can
constitute a rational basis for separate pay structures.
9.2.
On the material placed on record, the Respondents have articulated a
distinction which cannot be brushed aside as illusory. Regular executives are
part of a cadre, are subject to All-India transfers, and carry broader
supervisory, administrative and coordination obligations. Tenure Field
Executives are engaged on a consolidated package for field deployment,
with a different set of service incidents and a different employment
architecture. Once those differentiating features exist, the Court would not
treat the two classes as identically situated for pay parity by simply
comparing some operational tasks performed at the entry stage. Similarity of
certain field functions is not enough when the overall responsibility profile
and service conditions are materially different.
9.3.
Even otherwise, the Petitioners’ claim, as framed, effectively seeks re-
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
writing of compensation structures by a judicial command. That is not the
function of a Writ Court, absent a clear case of hostile discrimination
between equals. The Petitioners have not demonstrated that tenure Field
Executives are performing the same role, at the same level, with the same
accountability, under the same service incidents, as regular executives, and
are still denied parity. In the absence of that foundation, the parity claim
cannot be granted.
10.
Effect of long continuance
10.1. The Court is conscious that the Petitioners have rendered long service
through repeated extensions, and that such continuity can create legitimate
expectations in ordinary employment. However, in public employment,
legitimate expectation per se cannot override proper public service
recruitment process of entry into a cadre.
Conclusion
11.
For the reasons recorded above, the Petitioners fail to establish a legal
right to regularisation or absorption. The undertaking and tenure terms do
not, by themselves, defeat constitutional review, but the relief sought is
barred by the settled limits of judicial power in public employment and the
discipline laid down by the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in
Umadevi. The claim for pay parity also fails for want of demonstrated
identity of role, responsibility and service conditions.
12.
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
JANUARY 9, 2026/hc
W.P.(C) 13408/2023
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:33:01
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review