Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL MISC. APPLICATION (FOR QUASHING & SET
ASIDE FIR/ORDER) NO. 6657 of 2018
With
R/CRIMINAL MISC. APPLICATION NO. 6389 of 2018
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. M. RAVAL
================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
√
================================================
KHODABHAI DHANABHAI JOGRANA
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR.
================================================
Appearance:
MR MK PUJARA with MR JAY AMBANI for MR ASHISH M
DAGLI(2203) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
JAIVIK UDAY BHATT(7319) for the Respondent(s) No. 2
MR UDAY H BHATT(6457) for the Respondent(s) No. 2
MR ROHAN SHAH, APP for the Respondent(s) No. 1
================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. M. RAVAL
Date : 07/10/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
1.
Both these applications arise out of the same FIR and
accordingly, they were heard together and are being decided by
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
this common judgment and order.
2.
By these applications, the applicants are before this Court
praying for quashing and setting aside the FIR being C.R. No. I-37
of 2018, registered on 09.03.2018 with Malviyanagar Police Station,
District: Rajkot, for the offences punishable under Sections 306,
386, and 114 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) as well as
Sections 5, 40 and 42 of the The Gujarat Money-Lenders Act, 2011
(the Money-Lenders Act).
3.
Rule.
Learned advocates for the respective respondents
waive service.
4.
Facts of the prosecution case are that Parulben, W/o.
Amitbhai Bagthariya, lodged the impugned FIR on the facts that
her marriage was solemnized with the deceased in the year 2009,
and out of the said wedlock, they have a son named Rahil who
was 9 years old at that time. Her husband (deceased) and brotherin-law - Samirbhai run a barber shop under the name and style of
“Samir Hair Art” situated at Gitanagar Street No. 5. In the year
2012–2013, her husband had borrowed a sum of Rs. 4,00,000/with interest at the rate of 5% from one Khodabhai Dhanabhai
Jograna (applicant in Criminal Misc. Application No. 6657 of 2018),
who was residing in neighborhood, and had also obtained money
on interest from other persons. Her husband had borrowed these
amounts to enter into a partnership business in construction with
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
one Kalpeshbhai Kadiya, residing at Gitanagar. However, having
suffered losses in the said construction venture, Kalpeshbhai
Kadiya expressed his inability to arrange the funds immediately
and informed the husband of the de facto complainant that he
would return his invested capital in piecemeal. In order to repay
the money borrowed on interest, a housing loan of Rs. 10,00,000/was procured against the residential house, which was registered
in the name of the mother-in-law of the de facto complainant, and
out of the said loan, repayments were made to Khodabhai
Dhanabhai Jograna and other creditors. The husband of the de
facto complainant had not revealed specific details to the de facto
complainant, his mother and the brother regarding the identities of
the persons from whom he had borrowed money on interest,
merely stating that he had availed money on interest and would
repay on his own. To pay off the interest to these lenders, her
husband resorted to taking hand loans (hath-uchhina) and further
loans on interest from various individuals. To the best of her
knowledge, the husband of the de facto complainant had borrowed
a cumulative sum of Rs. 5,85,000/- in staggered amounts from his
friend Kanabhai Dhanabhai Maiyad, on interest ranging between
5% and 10%. Despite paying interest regularly for the past five
years at the rate of 5% to 10%, Kanabhai continued to unlawfully
demand the outstanding principal amount of Rs. 5,85,000/-. In
order to meet the interest liabilities of Kanabhai, in August 2017,
the husband of the de facto complainant borrowed Rs. 2,00,000/- at
an exorbitant interest rate of 10% from Lalabhai Rupabhai Mir
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
(Bharwad).
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
Towards the said liability, interest at the rate of
Rs.20,000/- per month was paid for three months, yet the debt
remained outstanding. The husband of the de facto complainant
had taken money under a financial scheme from Pravinbhai
Babubhai Gadhvi, resident of Rajkot, and had additionally
borrowed Rs.1,00,000/- at 10% interest, approximately ten months
prior. In the ninth month (September) of the preceding year, her
husband borrowed Rs.1,50,000/- at 8% interest from Kalubhai
Shiyaliya (applicant in Criminal Misc. Application No. 6389 of
2018, residing near Jai Vijay School, Gitanagar.
As collateral
security, said Kalubhai obtained from two blank cheques of Indian
Overseas Bank bearing only signatures of her husband without
any date or amount endorsed thereon, alongside a blank nonjudicial Stamp paper of Rs.50/- bearing signature of only husband
of the de facto complainant.
The husband of the de facto
complainant had also paid 8% interest on the said amount of Rs.
1.5 lakhs. Her husband continuously arranged hand loans from
his friends to service the mounting interest payments to the
aforesaid persons. The above-named lenders routinely subjected
her husband to intimidation and coercion, frequently visiting their
residence and shop of her husband, threatening that he would be
forced to sell his house and shop to satisfy their exorbitant
demands. Furthermore, Khodabhai Dhanabhai Jograna, a relative
of Lalabhai Rupabhai Mir, used to visit and issue threats for
recovering Lalabhai’s money. Although,
previously repaid
Rs.10,00,000/- against an earlier principal loan of Rs.4,00,000/-
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
taken from Khodabhai Dhanabhai Jograna, he continued to accost
the husband of the de facto complainant on the street, at the shop,
and at their residence and in case of delay of even 2–3 days in
paying the interest, he arbitrarily levied arbitrary penalties and
compounded the dues, causing the husband of the de facto
complainant extreme mental distress.
Due to their escalating
harassment and coercive recovery tactics, an application was
previously submitted by the de facto complainant, her husband and
her brother-in-law namely Samirbhai, and also her mother-in-law
namely Ramaben before the police authorities.
Following the
application, an attempt was made to arrive at an amicable
resolution through talks; however, the accused continued to
arbitrarily inflate their interest demands by two to three-fold,
subjecting the husband of the de facto complainant to unrelenting
stress. Her husband repeatedly expressed that “Kanabhai
Dhanabhai Maiyad, Lalabhai Rupabhai Mir (Bharwad), Pravinbhai
Babubhai Gadhvi, Kalubhai Shiyaliya, and Khodabhai Dhanabhai
Jograna were mounting unbearable pressure on him for the
principal and the interest and that, he was exhausted and would
die due to their torture to which, the de facto complainant and
other family members used to console him. However, thereafter,
Kalubhai Shiyaliya unilaterally filled in an amount of Rs.3,00,000/in each of the two blank signed cheques drawn on Indian Overseas
Bank, deposited in the bank account, got them dishonored, and
served a statutory Legal Notice through an Advocate, which drove
her husband into severe mental trauma. All settlement talks were
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
failed. On 08.03.2018, at about 09:00 a.m., the husband of the de
facto complainant left home on his motorcycle stating that he was
proceeding to the shop. Subsequently, at about 04:30 p.m., her
brother-in-law Samirbhai contacted over the telephone informing
to rush to the Civil Hospital immediately as her husband
consumed poison and was critical. Thereupon, she picked up her
son from school and reached the Civil Hospital in an autorickshaw accompanied by her father, Natubhai and upon inquiry
by her and her brother-in-law, her husband stated due to
unrelenting harassment of Kanabhai Maiyad, Lalo Mir, Pravinbhai
Gadhvi, Khodabhai Dhanabhai, and Kalubhai Shiyaliya, he had
consumed poisonous medicine. Thereafter, he lost consciousness.
While under initial treatment at the Civil Hospital, upon the
advice of relatives, he was shifted and admitted for intensive care
at Shanti Multi-Speciality Hospital, Sadhu Vaswani Road at
around 06:00 p.m. on 08.03.2018, where, he died during the course
of treatment approximately at 09:00 p.m. Thus, the aforesaid five
accused persons advanced unauthorized loans at exorbitant
interest rates, extorted blank signed cheques and blank stamp
papers, arbitrarily filled and bounced the cheques, served legal
notices, persistently subjected the deceased to aggressive recovery
(pathani ughrani), instilled constant fear of death, and levied
arbitrary and extortionate penalties. By creating unendurable
psychological pressure and continuously tormenting him, the
accused abetted and drove the deceased to commit suicide by
consuming poisonous substance, resulting in his death during
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
treatment. Thus, on the said fact, the FIR in question has been
lodged.
5.
Heard, the learned advocates for the respective parties and
perused the material available on record.
6.
Submissions on behalf of the applicant in Criminal Misc.
Application No. 6657 of 2018:
6.1
It is submitted that the FIR is based on a false prosecution
and that the deceased, Amitbhai, was running a hair-cutting salon
but was also allegedly involved in IPL betting for a considerable
period. It is submitted that the deceased and his wife were living
separately and had ongoing matrimonial disputes even before the
incident. Further, the deceased had financial dealings with several
persons and had earlier submitted an application mentioning the
names of about 13–14 persons. The applicant’s name was not
mentioned in that application.
6.2
The learned advocate for the applicants submitted that
although the deceased had taken some amount from the applicant
in 2011–2012 and repaid it, there was no subsequent financial
transaction between them. The applicant alleges that the deceased
himself approached various persons for financial assistance and
subsequently, suffered losses in IPL betting. It is submitted that
deceased’s father had also committed suicide, allegedly due to
family disputes.
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
6.3
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
It is further submitted that essential ingredients of abetment
of suicide under Sections 107 and 306 IPC are absent. The learned
advocate would submit that for an offence under Section 306 IPC,
there must be instigation, conspiracy, or intentional aid as
contemplated under Section 107 IPC. Mere quarrels, disputes, or
allegations of harassment are not by themselves sufficient unless
they amount to abetment. It is stated that there must be some
positive, active and intentional act of instigation or aid which has a
proximate connection with the suicide. It is submitted that people
react differently to similar circumstances. Therefore, merely
because a person takes the extreme step of suicide due to his own
emotional or personal difficulties, Section 306 IPC cannot
automatically be invoked against another person.
6.4
The learned advocate submits that prosecution under Section
306 IPC requires material showing direct or proximate instigation
or intentional aid, leaving the deceased with no reasonable
alternative but to commit suicide.
6.5
So far as Section 386 IPC is concerned, it is contended that
the facts stated in the FIR do not disclose the essential ingredients
of Section 386 IPC (extortion by putting a person in fear of death or
grievous hurt).
6.6
Thus, eventually, it is the case of the applicant that the FIR
does not disclose the necessary ingredients of Sections 306 or 386
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
IPC, and therefore the criminal proceedings against the applicant
deserve to be quashed.
6.7
It is submitted that the de facto complainant has filed an
affidavit, which is on record, to the effect that no grievance is
survived between them and that, she has no objection if the
complaint is quashed, however, later on she resiled.
7.
Submissions on behalf of the applicant in Criminal Misc.
Application No. 6389 of 2018:
7.1
It is submitted that the applicant is innocent and that, the FIR
does not disclose the ingredients of offences under Sections 306,
386 and 114 IPC, or Sections 5, 40 and 42 of the Money-Lenders
Act.
7.2
It is submitted that the alleged incidents occurred from
August 2017 to 09.03.2018, but the FIR was lodged belatedly.
Although an earlier application had allegedly been submitted, no
FIR was registered at that time. It is submitted that the applicant is,
subsequently, falsely implicated after the deceased committed
suicide.
7.3
The learned advocate would submit that the applicant
merely acted as a mediator in a transaction whereby the deceased
borrowed money from Bhupat Shiyaliya, who was the applicant’s
nephew.
When deceased failed to repay the amount, Bhupat
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
initiated proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable
Instruments Act.
7.4
It is further submitted that deceased had initially started a
construction business with his friend Kalpeshbhai. After suffering
losses, he allegedly borrowed money from several persons and
was unable to repay the debts. According to the applicant, these
financial difficulties led the deceased to take the extreme step of
suicide. He submitted the otherwise, the applicant had no direct
or indirect role in the suicide.
His alleged involvement was
limited to acting as a mediator in a financial transaction. Therefore,
his implication in the FIR is alleged to be an abuse of the process of
law.
7.5
It is submitted that Section 306 IPC requires proof of
abetment of suicide and that mere disputes or other circumstances,
without evidence of instigation or intentional aid, are insufficient.
He submitted that an offence under Section 306 IPC can arise only
where the ingredients of abetment under Section 107 IPC are
established.
Section 107 IPC contemplates abetment through
instigation, conspiracy followed by an act/illegal omission, or
intentional aid. It is submitted that none of these ingredients is
disclosed against the applicant. The learned advocate submitted
that as per settled law, there must be an active, positive and
intentional act having a proximate connection with the suicide.
Mere circumstances, financial difficulties, or emotional reactions of
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
the deceased cannot by themselves establish abetment. It is also
submitted that different persons may react differently to the same
circumstances and that Section 306 requires material showing
instigation or intentional aid.
7.6
The learned advocate would further submit that the
prosecution must show that the accused intended to instigate or
aid the deceased and that such conduct was sufficiently connected
with the suicide. In the absence of such material, Section 306 IPC
cannot be sustained.
7.7
Moreover, it is submitted that the FIR does not disclose the
necessary ingredients of Sections 386 and 114 IPC or Sections 5, 40
and 42 of the Money-Lenders Act against the applicant.
7.8
It is submitted that the deceased was facing independent
financial and personal difficulties, that the applicant merely acted
as a mediator, and that there is no material showing instigation,
conspiracy or intentional aid on his part. Consequently, the
proceedings against him are alleged to constitute an abuse of the
process of law and are sought to be quashed.
7.9
Last but not the least, it is submitted that the de facto
complainant has filed an affidavit, which is on record, to the effect
that no grievance is survived between them and that, she has no
objection if the complaint is quashed, however, later on she resiled.
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
8.
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
Conversely, learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the
respondent - State and learned advocate for the de facto
complainant would submit that:
8.1
That since the Charge-sheet has been filed, the applicants
have an alternative efficacious remedy of preferring a discharge
application, since the scope of exercising powers under Section 482
of the Code is very narrow. Having made a prima facie case, the
present applications deserve to be dismissed.
8.2
It is submitted that the deceased has given statement before
the concerned police officer in the presence of a witness, which can
be termed as Suicide Note, wherein, it is categorically stated that
on account of harassment of the persons from whom he had taken
money on interest, he fed away. It is submitted that names of the
persons from whom he had taken money are also mentioned and
accordingly, when there is prima facie gross case against the
applicants, this Court may not interfere.
8.3
It is further submitted that the contention raised by the
learned advocate for the applicants requires a full-fledged trial and
can be tested only on the basis of the evidence led before the trial.
8.4
The learned advocates for the respondents further submits
that the applicants are the persons having criminal antecedents
involving offences of a similar nature. It is further contended that
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
such antecedents, coupled with the material collected during the
course of investigation, prima facie substantiate the allegations
levelled against the applicants and, therefore, no case is made out
for the exercise of the inherent jurisdiction of this Court to quash
the impugned FIR or the consequential criminal proceedings.
8.5
The learned advocate for the respondent No. 2 as well as the
learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the respondent – State
submitted that as per the settled law, inherent powers under
Section 482 of the Code should be used sparingly and with a view
to curb the abuse of process of law. It is submitted that in the case
on hand, a prima facie case is made out against the applicants and
hence, they requested that it is ultimately a matter of trial after
which, the truth could be churned out and hence, it is requested
not to entertain these applications.
9.
Heard, the learned advocates for the respective parties and
perused the material on record.
9.1
At the outset, it is well-settled that the jurisdiction under
Section 482 of the Code is to be exercised sparingly and with
circumspection to prevent the abuse of the process of any court or
otherwise to secure the ends of justice. In State of Haryana v.
Bhajan Lal, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
crystallised seven illustrative categories where inherent powers
can be exercised to quash criminal proceedings. The relevant
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
portion of Paragraph 102 reads as under:
“(1) Where the allegations made in the First Information Report
or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face value and
accepted in their entirety do not prima facie constitute any offence
or make out a case against the accused.
(2) Where the allegations ins the F.I.R. and other materials, if
any, accompanying the F.I.R. do not disclose a cognizable offence,
justifying an investigation by police officers under S.156(1) of the
Code except under an order of a Magistrate within the purview of
S.155(2) of the code.
(3) Where, the uncontroverted allegations made in the F.I.R. or
complaint and the evidence collected in support of the same do not
disclose the commission of any offence and make out the case
against the accused.
(4) Where, the allegations in the F.I.R. do not constitute a
cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable offence, no
investigation is permitted by a police officer without an order of a
Magistrate as contemplated under S.155(2) of the Code.
(5) Whether, the allegations made in the F.I.R. or complaint are
so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which no
prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion that there is
sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused.
(6) Where, there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of the
provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which a
criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and/or where
there is a specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act,
providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the aggrieved
party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended with
malafide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously instituted with
an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on the accused and with
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
a view to spite him due to private and personal grudge."
9.2
In the present case, the dispute essentially originates from
financial transactions wherein the deceased had borrowed money
on interest from the applicants and other persons. Upon default or
delay in repayment, the applicants along with other lenders
allegedly demanded the return of the principal alongside high
interest rates, leading to verbal disputes and aggressive recovery
attempts, which ultimately resulted in the tragic suicide of the
deceased.
9.3
To attract the offence of abetment of suicide under Section
306 of the IPC, the prosecution must satisfy the essential
ingredients of "abetment" as defined under Section 107 of the IPC.
There must be an active, positive, and intentional act of instigation,
conspiracy, or intentional aid with a direct nexus and proximity to
the act of suicide. Harassment or persistent demands for loan
recovery, without a specific mens rea (guilty mind) to drive the
person to end their life, does not automatically constitute
abetment.
9.4
In Abhinav Mohan Delkar v. State of Maharashtra, (2026) 6
SCC 233, the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed:
“25. What comes out essentially from the various decisions
herein before cited is that, even if there is allegation of
constant harassment, continued over a long period; to bring
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
in the ingredients of Section 306 read with Section 107, still
there has to be a proximate prior act to clearly find that the
suicide was the direct consequence of such continuous
harassment, the last proximate incident having finally
driven the subject to the extreme act of taking one’s life.
Figuratively, ‘the straw that broke the camel’s back’; that
final event, in a series, that occasioned a larger, sudden
impact resulting in the unpredictable act of suicide. What
drove the victim to that extreme act, often depends on
individual predilections; but whether it is goaded,
definitively and demonstrably, by a particular act of
another, is the test to find mens rea. Merely because the
victim was continuously harassed and at one point, he or
she succumbed to the extreme act of taking his life cannot by
itself result in finding a positive instigation constituting
abetment. Mens rea cannot be gleaned merely by what goes
on in the mind of the victim.
26. The victim may have felt that there was no alternative
or option, but to take his life, because of what another
person did or said; which cannot lead to a finding of mens
rea and resultant abetment on that other person. What
constitutes mens rea is the intention and purpose of the
alleged perpetrator as discernible from the conscious acts or
words and the attendant circumstances, which in all
probability could lead to such an end. The real intention of
the accused and whether he intended by his action to at least
possibly drive the victim to suicide, is the sure test. Did the
thought of goading the victim to suicide occur in the mind of
the accused or whether it can be inferred from the facts and
circumstances arising in the case, as the true test of mens rea
would depend on the facts of each case. The social status,
the community setting, the relationship between the parties
and other myriad factors would distinguish one case from
another. However harsh or severe the harassment, unless
there is a conscious deliberate intention, mens rea, to drive
another person to suicidal death, there cannot be a finding of
abetment under Section 306.
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
27. We have already seen that even a rebuke to “go, kill
yourself”; often a rustic expression against distasteful
conduct, cannot by itself be found to have the ingredients to
charge an offence of abetment to suicide. There is no
uniformity in how different individuals respond and react
under pressure. Many stand up, some fight back, a few
runaway and certain people crumble and at times take the
extreme step of suicide. To put the blame on the pressure
imposed and the person responsible for it, at all times,
without something more to clearly discern an intention,
would not be the proper application of the penal provisions
under Section 306.”
(emphasis supplied)
9.5
Applying these principles to the facts at hand, even if it is
assumed that the applicants exerted severe financial pressure or
demanded exorbitant interest, there is no proximate prior act
demonstrating a deliberate intent (mens rea) on their part to force
the deceased to commit suicide. The reaction of an individual
under financial distress cannot be solely attributed to the lenders
in the absence of a positive instigation directly triggering the
suicide.
9.6
With respect to the offence under Section 386 of the IPC
(extortion by putting a person in fear of death or grievous hurt), it
is necessary to examine the definition of "Extortion" under Section
383 of the IPC:
“Section 383. Extortion.—Whoever intentionally puts any
person in fear of any injury to that person, or to any other, and
thereby dishonestly induces the person so put in fear to deliver
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
to any person any property or valuable security or anything
signed or sealed which may be converted into a valuable
security, commits extortion.”
9.7
The essential ingredient of extortion is that the victim must
be dishonestly induced to deliver property or valuable security
while being put in fear of injury. In the present case, the signed
blank
cheques
and
stamp
paper
were
delivered
as
collateral/security at the time of procuring the loans. There is no
allegation in the FIR that the deceased was put in fear of death or
grievous hurt at the time these documents were handed over. The
subsequent dishonor of cheques or issuance of legal notices under
Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, does not
convert a loan recovery dispute into the criminal offence of
extortion under Section 386 of the IPC.
9.8
Regarding the allegations under Sections 5, 40, and 42 of The
Gujarat Money-Lenders Act, 2011, except for vague oral assertions
in the FIR, the record contains no documentary proof, banking
statements,
or
financial
records
demonstrating
specific
extortionate interest payments made by the deceased to the
applicants, rendering these statutory claims unsubstantiated.
9.9
A perusal of the Suicide Note of the deceased placed on
record reveals that it contains only general references to financial
stress, along with names and phone numbers of creditors. It lacks
specific details regarding any direct overt act, threat, or immediate
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
provocation committed by the applicants near the time of the
incident. Furthermore, against the applicant in Criminal Misc.
Application No. 6657 of 2018, the last transaction took place as far
back as 2011–2012, showing a complete lack of proximity to the
incident in 2018.
9.10 As to the contention regarding criminal antecedents, it is
settled law that past antecedents alone cannot replace the
requirement of establishing essential statutory ingredients of the
alleged offences in the present FIR. Moreover, the de facto
complainant has filed affidavits on record stating that the dispute
was personal in nature, had been amicably resolved through
family intervention, and that she has no objection to the quashing
of the proceedings.
10.
On a holistic evaluation of the Charge-sheet papers and the
FIR, this Court finds that continuing the criminal prosecution
against the applicants would constitute a clear abuse of the process
of law. The present case falls within parameters (1), (3), (5), and (7)
laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Bhajan Lal’s case.
11.
In fine, these applications succeed and are accordingly,
allowed. The First Information Report registered against the
applicants, referred in Paragraph 2 above, Charge-sheet and all
consequential criminal proceedings arising therefrom, are hereby
quashed and set aside qua the applicants.
R/CR.MA/6657/2018
(GJHC240213362018)
12.
JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
Rule is made absolute, accordingly.
Direct service is
permitted.
[ P. M. Raval, J. ]
hiren/36tss71026+
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review