Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:27526
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
RSA No.
286/2025
Decided on:
Khazana Ram @ Gian Chand
03.07.2026
..…Appellant
Versus
Chhitri
…..Respondent
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting ?1
For the appellant:
Mr. H. S. Rangra, Advocate.
For the respondent: Mr. J. R. Poswal, Advocate.
Romesh Verma, Judge (Oral)
The present appeal arises out of the judgment and
decree, dated 12.06.2025, as passed by the learned Addl.
District Judge, Sundernagar, District Mandi, H.P., whereby
the appeal preferred by the present appellant/defendant No.1
has been dismissed and the judgment and decree dated
1.4.2023, as passed by the learned Senior Civil Judge, Court
No.1, Sunder Nagar, District Mandi, H.P., decreeing the suit
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the Judgment ?Yes
of the plaintiff for permanent prohibitory injunction, has been
affirmed.
Brief
facts
of
the
case
are
that
the
plaintiff/respondent, Chhitri,
filed a suit for permanent
prohibitory
injunction
and
mandatory
against
the
defendants before the learned trial court on 29.12.2015. As
per the averments, as made in the plaint, the land comprised
in Khewat No. 289, Khatauni No. 318, Khasra Nos. 434, 435,
437, 445, 466, 434/444, 836/467, Kita-7 measuring 11-418 Bighas, situated
in Muhal Chamukha/41, Tehsil
Sundernagar, Distt. Mandi, H.P. is recorded
ownership
and possession
in the joint
of the plaintiff and defendant
No.1 together with other co-sharers, but the same has been
partitioned vide mutation No. 1086, dated 31.10.2014 thus,
the plaintiff, defendant No.1 and other co-sharers are coming
in the separate ownership and possession
allotted to them in the partition.
of their land
The suit land bearing
Khasra No. 437/2, measuring 0-8-12 bighas has been
allotted to the plaintiff and she is the exclusive owner in
possession
of the same.
without consent
The defendants from 25.12.2015
and permission of the plaintiff started
digging the suit land and they were adamant to raise
unlawful construction over the suit land. It was averred that
in case the defendants are not restrained from causing
unlawful interference and raising illegal construction over the
suit land, in that event the rights of the plaintiff will be
adversely affected. Therefore, it was prayed that the suit of
the plaintiff be decreed restraining the defendants
from
raising any construction over the suit land and changing its
nature and converting it into their house use in any manner
whatsoever and in case the defendants succeeded in raising
construction over the suit land or are found in possession of
any part of the suit land in that event a decree for mandatory
injunction be passed for demolition of the structure and
vacant possession
of suit land be got delivered
to the
plaintiff at the cost of the defendants.
The suit was resisted by defendants No. 1 to 4 by
filing written statement, wherein preliminary objections qua
maintainability, cause of action, locus standi, estoppel etc.
were raised. On merits, it was averred that the plaintiff is not
in possession of the joint land, though she is joint owner.
The entire joint land comprised in Khewat No. 289, Khatauni
No. 318, Khasra Nos. 434, 435, 437, 445, 466, 434/444,
836/467, Kita-7 measuring
11-4-18 Bighas, situated
in
Muhal Chamukha/41, is in possession of one Mangat Ram,
son of Bangali and land measuring 00-04-00 bighas was
purchased by defendant No.1 from Mangat Ram vide
registered sale deed No. 135/2011, dated 8.3.2011 and at the
time of purchase, defendant No.1 was put in possession of
Khasra
No.
437/1.
After
purchase
of
aforesaid
defendant No.1 levelled the same by cutting
land,
it through
excavator.
w/o
It was further averred that one Manpreet Kaur,
Kulwant being daughter-in-law of Goldsmith had
purchased a share of one Dimple, who was not in possession
of the suit land and applied for the partition of land under
Section 123 of the H.P. Land Revenue Act
45/2011 and being not in possession
vide file No.
of the land under
partition in connivance with revenue officials and with the
abuse of process of law took undue advantage of the illiteracy
of simpleton persons of the village and illegally got allotted
the entire road frontage of the land in her name. Defendant
No.1 came to know about the alleged partition on 4.12.2015
when the Kanungo came on spot and thereafter he filed an
appeal before Sub Divisional Collector, Sundernagar.
Land
for the construction of four-lane had been acquired in the
joint holding before partition and the compensation of the
acquired land has also been given to the parties as per their
respective shares in the joint holding, as such partition was
required to be done after deducting the acquired land from
the joint holding, which has not been done by the Assistant
Collector, 1st Grade, Sundernagar.
It was stated that
defendant No.1 intended to raise only protection wall in the
suit land, which is in his possession as co-sharer and has
been levelled by him much prior to filing of the suit.
Therefore, defendants No.1 to 4 prayed for dismissal of the
suit.
The plaintiff
filed
replication
to
the written
statement, wherein the contents of the plaint were reiterated.
On the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial
court on 23.06.2018 and 10.10.2022 framed the following
issues:1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of
permanent prohibitory injunction, as prayed
for?...OPP.
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the decree of
mandatory injunction, as prayed for? ... OPP.
2A Whether the partition proceedings on the basis
of which plaintiff is laying claim over Khasra
No.437/2 is wrong, illegal, null and void? ...OPD.
3. Whether the suit is not maintainable? ... OPD.
4. Whether the plaintiff has not come to the court
with clean hands?...OPD.
5. Whether the suit is bad for non joinder and mis
joinder of necessary parties? OPD.
6. Whether the plaintiff has no cause of action to
file the present suit? OPD.
7. Whether the plaintiff has no locus standi to file
the present suit? OPD.
8. Whether the plaintiff is estopped from filing the
present suit by her own act and conduct? OPD
9. Relief.
The learned trial court directed the respective
parties to adduce evidence in support of their contentions to
corroborate their respective case. The learned trial court vide
its judgment and decree dated 1.4.2023 decreed the suit of
the plaintiff for permanent prohibitory injunction restraining
the defendants from causing
any sort of interference over
the suit land and changing its nature
in any manner,
whereas the suit of the plaintiff seeking mandatory injunction
was dismissed.
Feeling dissatisfied by the judgment and decree,
dated 1.4.2023, defendant No.1, Khazana Ram, preferred an
appeal before the learned first appellate Court on 16.05.2023
which came to be dismissed vide judgment and decree dated
12.6.2025.
Still feeling aggrieved by the aforesaid judgments
and decrees, the appellant/defendant No.1 has preferred the
present regular second appeal.
is
With the consent of the parties, the instant appeal
finally
heard
at
admission
stage
on the
following
substantial question of law:Whether the judgments and decrees of both the
learned Court below are based on mis-appreciation
and misinterpretation of the oral as well as
documentary evidence placed on record?
It is contended by Mr. H. S. Rangra, learned
counsel for the appellant/defendant No.1 that the impugned
judgments and decrees, as passed by the learned courts
below, are erroneous and, thus, liable to be quashed and set
aside. He has submitted that the learned courts below have
not taken into consideration the material placed on record in
its right perspective.
He has further submitted that
after
accepting the instant appeal, suit as filed by the plaintiff,
deserves to be dismissed.
On the other hand,
Mr. J. R. Poswal, learned
counsel for the plaintiff/respondent, has defended the
impugned judgments and decrees as passed by the learned
courts below. He has submitted that this Court while
invoking provisions of Section 100 of CPC will not interfere
with the concurrent findings of fact, as rendered by the
learned Courts below and, thus, has prayed for dismissal of
the instant appeal.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties
and have also gone through the material available on the
case file.
As noticed above, the plaintiff/respondent had
filed a suit before the learned trial court seeking permanent
prohibitory
and
mandatory
injunction
against
the
defendants on the ground that though the land comprised in
Khewat No. 289, Khatauni No. 318, Khasra Nos. 434, 435,
437, 445, 466, 434/444, 836/467, Kita-7 measuring 11-418 Bighas, situated
in Muhal Chamukha/41, Tehsil
Sundernagar, Distt. Mandi, H.P. is recorded
ownership
and possession
in the joint
of the plaintiff and defendant
No.1 together with other co-sharers, but the same has been
partitioned by competent Court of law vide mutation No.
1086, dated 31.10.2014
and the plaintiff, defendant No.1
and other co-sharers are coming in separate ownership and
possession of their land allotted to them in the partition.
It is the case of the plaintiff that the suit land
bearing Khasra No. 437/2, measuring 0-8-12 bighas has
been allotted to the plaintiff and she is the exclusive owner in
possession of the same. The defendants, being headstrong
persons, started to interfere in the peaceful possession of the
plaintiff and change the nature of the suit land.
On the other hand, defendants No. 1 to 4 resisted
and contested the suit, as filed by the plaintiff, by filing
written statement, wherein they refuted and denied all the
allegations, as levelled in the plaint and prayed for dismissal
of the suit.
In order to corroborate her case, the plaintiff
examined herself as PW1 and tendered in evidence her
affidavit, Ext. PW1/A, wherein she reiterated the averments
as made in the plaint. She has specifically stated that vide
mutation No. 1086, dated 31.10.2014
she was put in
possession of the land bearing Khasra No. 836/467/1
measuring 01-09-04 bighas and 437/2 measuring 00-08-12
Bighas, total land 01-17-16 Bighas of land, which has fallen
in her share vide rapat rojnamcha No. 60, dated 21.10.2014.
The land bearing Khasra No. 437/2, measuring 00-08-12
bighas, is situated abutting the National Highway 21, which
is a prime land for
construction of shops and house. She
further stated that in December 2015, the defendants started
construction over the suit land without consent of the
plaintiff and in case the defendants are not restrained from
causing unlawful interference and raising construction over
the suit land, in that event she would suffer huge
and
irreparable loss. She prayed that the suit be decreed. In her
cross-examination,
the
defendants
could
not
extract
anything material in their favour.
PW2 Joginder Pal, proved on record Rapat No. 60
pertaining to year 2014-15, Ext. PW2/A.
In
order to rebut
the case of the plaintiff,
defendant No.1 Khazana Ram, appeared in the witness box
as DW2 and tendered in evidence his affidavit, Ext. DW2/A,
wherein he stated that
he had purchased the land
measuring 0-4-0 bighas
from Mangat Ram vide registered
sale deed No. 135/2011, dated 8.3.2011 and at the time of
purchase, he was put in possession of Khasra No. 437/2,
which has been wrongly and illegally allotted to the plaintiff
in the alleged partition proceedings.
DW1 Ramesh Chand, DW3 Tilak and DW4 Gama
Chisti are the official witnesses examined by the defendants.
Perusal of para 4 of the written statement, on
merits, as filed by defendants No. 1 to 4, clearly stipulates
that
defendant
No.1/appellant
intended
to
raise
only
protection wall in the suit land, which is in his possession as
co-sharer and has been levelled by him much prior to filing
of the suit. Such admission on the part of defendant No.1
gave right to the plaintiff to file the suit.
Learned counsel for the respondent
has heavily
relied upon copy of document, Ext. PW1/E, whereby Khasra
No.437/2 was allotted to the plaintiff in partition proceedings
and mutation No. 1086 to this effect was attested by the
revenue authority in presence of defendant No.1/appellant.
The plaintiff has approached the Court on the strength of
mutation attested in respect of Khasra No. 437/2, measuring
00-08-12 Bighas, whereby this parcel of land has been
allotted to her in partition proceedings. The plaintiff has been
able to prove her title over the same, therefore, the Courts
below have rightly decreed her suit.
As observed above, there is admission on the part
of the appellant that he intended to raise protection wall in
the suit land, therefore, the learned courts below have rightly
and concurrently passed decree for permanent prohibitory
injunction restraining the defendants
from causing any
interference or raising construction over the suit land. The
plaintiff has approached the Court on the strength of the title
and the learned Courts below have concurrently held the
plaintiff, being owner of the
injunction.
suit land, to be entitled
The learned trial court had declined
for
relief of
mandatory injunction to the plaintiff, but those findings
were accepted by the plaintiff and the same were never
challenged before the learned first appellate Court.
The
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
catena
of
judgments has held that the first appellate is the final court
of the fact. No doubt, second appellate court exercising the
power under Section 100 CPC can interfere with the findings
of fact on limited grounds such as - (a) where the finding is
based on inadmissible evidence; (b) where it is in ignorance of
the relevant admissible evidence; (c) where it is based on
misreading of evidence; (d) where it is perverse, but that is
not case in hand.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court while dealing with
scope of interference under Section 100 in Hero Vinoth
(minor) vs. Seshammal, (2006) 5 SCC 545 has held as
under:
“18. It has been noted time and again that without insisting
for the statement of such a substantial question of law in the
memorandum of appeal and formulating the same at the time
of admission, the High Courts have been issuing notices and
generally deciding the second appeals without adhering to the
procedure prescribed under Section 100 of the CPC. It has
further been found in a number of cases that no efforts are
made to distinguish between a question of law and a
substantial question of law. In exercise of the powers under
this section in several cases, the findings of fact of the first
appellate court are found to have been disturbed. It has to be
kept in mind that the right of appeal is neither a natural nor
an inherent right attached to the litigation. Being a substantive
statutory right, it has to be regulated in accordance with law
in force at the relevant time. The conditions mentioned in the
section must be strictly fulfilled before a second appeal can be
maintained and no court has the power to add or to enlarge
those grounds. The second appeal cannot be decided on
merely equitable grounds. The concurrent findings of facts will
not be disturbed by the High Court in exercise of the powers
under this section. Further, a substantial question of law has
to be distinguished from a substantial question of fact. This
Court in Sir Chunilal V. Mehta and Sons Ltd. v. Century Spg. &
Mfg. Co. Ltd. (AIR 1962 SC 1314) held that : "The proper test
for determining whether a question of law raised in the case is
substantial would, in our opinion, be whether it is of general
public importance or whether it directly and substantially
affects the rights of the parties and if so whether it is either an
open question in the sense that it is not finally settled by this
Court or by the Privy Council or by the Federal Court or is not
free from difficulty or calls for discussion of alternative views.
If the question is settled by the highest court or the general
principles to be applied in determining the question are well
settled and there is a mere question of applying those
principles or that the plea raised is palpably absurd the
question would not be a substantial question of law.
" 19. It is not within the domain of the High Court to
investigate the grounds on which the findings were arrived at,
by the last court of fact, being the first appellate court. It is
true that the lower appellate court should not ordinarily reject
witnesses accepted by the trial court in respect of credibility
but even where it has rejected the witnesses accepted by the
trial court, the same is no ground for interference in second
appeal when it is found that the appellate court has given
satisfactory reasons for doing so. In a case where from a given
set of circumstances two inferences of fact are possible, one
drawn by the lower appellate court will not be interfered by
the High Court in second appeal. Adopting any other approach
is not permissible. The High Court will, however, interfere
where it is found that the conclusions drawn by the lower
appellate
court
were
erroneous
being
contrary
to
the
mandatory provisions of law applicable or its settled position
on the basis of pronouncements made by the Apex Court, or
was based upon inadmissible evidence or arrived at by
ignoring material evidence. 20. to 22 xx xx xx xx
23. To be "substantial" a question of law must be debatable,
not previously settled by law of the land or a binding
precedent, and must have a material bearing on the decision
of the case, if answered either way, insofar as the rights of the
parties before it are concerned. To be a question of law
"involving in the case" there must be first a foundation for it
laid in the pleadings and the question should emerge from the
sustainable findings of fact arrived at by court of facts and it
must be necessary to decide that question of law for a just
and proper decision of the case. An entirely new point raised
for the first time before the High Court is not a question
involved in the case unless it goes to the root of the matter. It
will, therefore, depend on the facts and circumstance of each
case whether a question of law is a substantial one and
involved
in
the
case,
or
not;
the
paramount
overall
consideration being the need for striking a judicious balance
between the indispensable obligation to do justice at all stages
and impelling necessity of avoiding prolongation in the life of
any lis.”
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Annamalai vs.
Vasanthi, 2025 INSC 1267, has held as follows:“16. Whether D-1 and D-2 were able to discharge the
aforesaid burden is a question of fact which had to be
determined by a court of fact after appreciating the evidence
available on record. Under CPC, a first appellate court is the
final court of fact. No doubt, a second appellate court
exercising power(s) under Section 100 CPC can interfere with
a finding of fact on limited grounds, such as, (a) where the
finding is based on inadmissible evidence; (b) where it is in
ignorance of relevant admissible evidence; (c) where it is
based on misreading of evidence; and (d) where it is perverse.
But that is not the case here.
17. In the case on hand, the first appellate court, in paragraph
29 of its judgment, accepted the endorsement (Exb. A-2) made
on the back of a registered document (Exb. A-1) after
considering the oral evidence led by the plaintiff-appellant and
the circumstance that signature(s)/thumbmark of D-1 and D-2
were not disputed, though claimed as one obtained on a blank
paper. The reasoning of the first appellate court in paragraph
29 of its judgment was not addressed by the High Court. In
fact, the High Court, in one line, on a flimsy defense of use of a
signed blank paper, observed that genuineness of Exb. A-2 is
not proved. In our view, the High Court fell in error here. While
exercising powers under Section 100 CPC, it ought not to have
interfered with the finding of fact returned by the first
appellate court on this aspect; more so, when the first
appellate court had drawn its conclusion after appreciating the
evidence available on record as also the circumstance that
signature(s)/thumbmark(s) appearing on the document (Exb.A2) were not disputed. Otherwise also, while disturbing the
finding of the first appellate court, the High Court did not hold
that the finding returned by the first appellate court is based
on a misreading of evidence, or is in ignorance of relevant
evidence, or is perverse. Thus, there existed no occasion for
the High Court, exercising power under Section 100 CPC, to
interfere with the finding of the first appellate court regarding
payment of additional Rs. 1,95,000 to D-1 and D-2 over and
above the sale consideration fixed for the transaction.
18. Once the finding regarding payment of additional sum of
Rs.1,95,000 to D-1 and D-2 recorded by the first appellate
court is sustained, there appears no logical reason to hold that
the plaintiff (Annamalai) was not ready and willing to perform
its part under the contract particularly when Rs. 4,70,000, out
of total consideration of Rs. 4,80,000, was already paid and,
over and above that, additional sum of Rs.1,95,000 was paid
in lieu of demand made by D-1 & D-2. This we say so,
because an opinion regarding plaintiff’s readiness and
willingness to perform its part under the contract is to be
formed on the entirety of proven facts and circumstances of a
case including conduct of the parties. The test is that the
person claiming performance must satisfy conscience of the
court that he has treated the contract subsisting with
preparedness to fulfil his obligation and accept performance
when the time for performance arrives.”
No other point was urged by the learned counsel
for the parties.
Both the Courts below have rightly appreciated
the point in controversy after considering the oral as well as
documentary evidence placed on record and this Court does
not find any illegality or perversity in the impugned
judgments and decrees, as passed by the learned Courts
below, and the same are upheld. The substantial question
of law is answered accordingly.
In view of above, the present appeal being devoid of
any merit deserves to be dismissed. Ordered accordingly.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
3rd July, 2026
(pankaj)
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review