Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
Serial No.01
Daily List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Review Pet.No.13/2025
Date of Judgment: 20.11.2025
Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council, Shillong represented by the
Secretary to the Executive Committee, KHADC, Shillong.
..... Petitioner
Vs.
1. Shri Cyprian Dkhar, S/o Shri J. Nonglang, R/o Rynjah-Lapalang,
Shillong, East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
2. The State of Meghalaya represented by its Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya, District Council Affairs Department,
Shillong.
3. The Registrar (Judicial Service), High Court of Meghalaya, Shillong.
4. Smti. Vyblue of Rest Mawlieh, Magistrate First Class, Subordinate
District Council Court, Nongstoin, West Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya.
5. Smti. Eblincy Lyngdoh Mawnai, Magistrate First Class, Subordinate
District Council Court, Mawkyrwat, South West Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya.
6. Smti. Kerphidalin Warjri, Magistrate First Class, Subordinate District
Council Court, Nongpoh, Ri Bhoi District, Meghalaya.
..... Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Soumen Sen, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
:
For the Respondents :
Mr. T.T. Diengdoh, Sr.Adv with
Mr. CCT Sangma, Adv
Mr. K. Paul, Sr.Adv with
Mr. B. Snaitang Adv for R/1
Ms. T. Sutnga, Adv for R/4-6
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (Oral)
This is an application for review of an order dated 19.08.2025
passed by a Division Bench presided over by the then Hon’ble Chief
Justice.
2.
The review application was filed by the Khasi Hills
Autonomous District Council (hereinafter referred to as the ‘KHADC’).
The review applicant has prayed for review of the order in so far as the
order directed the KHADC and the State to create one supernumerary
post by 30.09.2025 and thereafter to complete the entire exercise of
selection within a period of three months.
3.
It is stated in the review application that while the impugned
judgment had appreciated the submissions advanced by the learned
senior counsel for the KHADC that there is one existing vacancy and
one future vacancy which will arise soon. However, it was not brought
to the notice of the Court of the existing vacancy is in respect of the post
of Additional Judge, Additional District Council Court, Shillong and
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
not for the post of Magistrate First Class. It is contended that there is an
error apparent on the face of the record as the impugned judgment has
failed to consider that a supernumerary post is a shadow post which is
created for temporarily accommodating a permanent employee till the
employee is absorbed substantially in a regular post and cannot be
created for an indefinite period. It is further contended that there are six
Magistrates First Class holding the post of Presiding Officer,
Subordinate District Council Court within the KHADC with one
vacancy remaining to be filled up. There is no requirement nor has there
been any decision to create another post of Magistrate First Class and as
such the direction of the Court to create one more supernumerary post is
not necessary and would result in financial constraint to the Council.
4.
In order to appreciate the submissions made on behalf of the
KHADC, it is necessary to briefly narrate the facts that has culminated
in the judgment.
5.
The genesis of the writ petition was an advertisement issued by
the KHADC dated 06.11.2019 by which the present applicant had called
for applications for filling up of three vacant posts of Magistrate First
Class, Subordinate District Council Court, KHADC and on the basis of
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
the written examination conducted, six candidates had qualified for the
interview. After the interview, in the final select list dated 11.01.2021,
three candidates were declared selected and three candidates i.e.
respondent Nos.4, 5 and 6 were placed in the waiting list. Thereafter,
the respondent No.1 (KHADC) on 19.08.2020 sought approval from the
Registrar (Judicial Service) High Court of Meghalaya for filling up the
remaining vacant posts from the waiting list as a special condition as it
was not conducive to conduct fresh examinations because of the
situation in the State and country inasmuch as there were many pending
cases which required speedy trial. The respondent No.3 then approved
the said appointments and the respondent No.2 also by a notification
dated 04.02.2022 was pleased to approve the said appointments and the
respondent Nos.4, 5 and 6 were then conferred powers by the Governor
of Meghalaya in exercise of powers under sub-paragraph (1) of
paragraph 5 of the Six Schedule to the Constitution of India. Thereafter,
the appointment orders were issued in favour of respondent Nos.4, 5
and 6 and they joined their respective posts. This was under challenge in
the writ petition and the writ petition was dismissed.
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
6.
However, in appeal the Hon’ble Division Bench after hearing
the learned counsel for the parties and considering the materials on
record had directed the Council and the State to create one
supernumerary post. This direction according to the applicant, there is
an error apparent on the face of the record.
7.
In deciding the said appeal, the Hon’ble Division Bench after
recording the submissions of the parties as well as the decisions relied
upon and referred to by the respective parties formulated the question
that is whether the actions of the respondent No.1 i.e. the review
applicant in affording appointments to candidates over and above the
advertised vacancy is justifiable or whether the said decision is visible
in arbitrariness and illegal.
8.
The Hon’ble Division Bench after referring to the mandate of
paragraphs 4 and 5 (1) of the Sixth Schedule has recorded that in
matters of appointment of the judicial officer, the District Council is the
appointing authority and the recruitment rules have not yet been
published as apprised to the Court and the same are waiting approval of
the Governor. As such, this Court occupying a very special place in the
system of administration of justice in this hill, the reason for directing
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
the creation of one supernumerary post followed from paragraphs 11 to
20 of the said judgment, which are reproduced hereunder for
convenience: “Facts in detail:
On 6th November, 2019, the Khasi Hills Autonomous
District Council, Shillong published an advertisement inviting
applications for filling up three vacant posts of Magistrates FirstClass for the Subordinate District Council Court, Khasi Hills
Autonomous District Council, Shillong. The candidate was to be
a citizen of India belonging to the Schedule Tribes of Meghalaya,
conversant in the Khasi language and customs, be not more than
37 years and less than 25 years and have at least five years’
standing as an Advocate. In this recruitment process, a written
test followed by a personal interview was taken. After the
selection process on 11th January, 2021, the said District Council
announced the list of three successful candidates and a waiting
list of another three. In a communication by the District Council
dated 11th January, 2021, the following was inserted “the result is
valid for a period of one year from the date of this publication”.
On 19th August, 2021, this Court was approached with a request
from the Secretary to the Executive Committee of the Council to
the effect that there were three further vacant posts and that as a
special case, the Council be allowed to fill up these vacancies
from the said waiting list. This Court approved the said proposal
of the Council as would be evident from the communication of
the Registrar Judicial service to the Council dated 25 th October,
2021. On 6th December, 2021, the Council extended the validity
of the select list till 31st March, 2022. On 4th February, 2022, the
three waitlisted candidates were appointed by the Hon’ble
Governor as Magistrate First-Class, Subordinate District Council
Court, Shillong along with powers of Judicial Magistrate of the
First-Class.
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
Views:
When the appointments to the three posts of First-Class
Magistrates were made with publication of a select list which
included a list of the selected candidates and a list of waitlisted
candidates, the selection process initiated by the advertisement of
6th November, 2019 was concluded. The list so published was in
relation to that process and was valid for one year. That is to say
if any of the selected candidates did not join or resign or was
discharged within the one-year period, then the list of waitlisted
candidates could be utilised to fill up that vacancy.
Now, according to the above cited authorities, this waiting
list could not be used to fill up any other vacancy for which a new
selection process had to be initiated. However, there is one
exception to this rule, namely, grave urgency to fill up the post.
On 19th August, 2021, the Council wrote to this Court that “the
current situation in the State and the country as a whole” referring
to the covid pandemic and the need for more judicial officers to
conduct speedy trial, necessitated filling up of the vacant post
from the said waiting list. This High Court as it is evident from
the communication dated 25th October, 2021 acceded to this
request.
Does this mean that the right of a selecting authority to
appoint candidates from the waiting list of a selection process
which had been concluded was being exercised by the selecting
authority? When the High Court acceded to this request, could it
be said that a policy decision in this behalf had been taken?
We hold on the basis of the above authorities that
subsequent appointments of the respondent Nos.4, 5 and 6 on
28th February, 2022, 28th February, 2022 again on 4th March,
2022 on the basis of which all three joined duties on 3 rd March
2022 and 4th March, 2022, respectively were invalid. It is plain
that these respondents have been discharging their functions for
well over three and a half years. Two judgments cited by learned
Deputy Solicitor General, Dr. Mozika in Sivanandan C.T. & ors
v. High Court of Kerela & ors reported in (2024) 3 SCC 799
(paragraph 55) and in Vivek Kaisth & anr v. State of Himachal
Pradesh & ors reported in (2024) 2 SCC 269 (paragraphs 43
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
and 44) come to the rescue of the government. The Supreme
Court took into account the long service which the judicial
officers had rendered, the experience they had gained and the
contribution they had made to the judiciary and declined to
“unseat” them. Here the service rendered by the respondent
Nos.4, 5 and 6 is similar in nature. Hence, I am also of the view
that their service should not be interfered with.
Mr. D.K. Mishra, learned Senior Advocate appearing for
these respondents also made similar arguments as the learned
Deputy Solicitor General. He did not fail to argue that the induction
of his clients from the waitlist was further to a considered policy
decision of the selecting authority with the concurrence of the
High Court, based on grave urgency to fill up the vacancies for
the cause of speedy judicial administration during covid period.
A silver lining in the sky occurred during the close of
hearing of this appeal, when learned Deputy Solicitor General
remarked that there was existing one vacancy and one future
vacancy to arise soon.
Taking into account those submissions, we direct that to
have a fair and just result, the clock should be put back where it
was when the three posts were filled up from the waiting list.
This could be done by creation of one supernumerary post.
There should be no difficulty in this because the Council has
repeatedly urged that it was in need of more judicial officers to
dispose of pending cases.
Hence, we direct the Council and the State to create one
supernumerary post. Any approval from the High Court or the
government is deemed to have been obtained. Such
supernumerary post should be created by 30th September, 2025.
Thereafter, a selection test to fill up these posts should be
carried out where the appellant is at liberty to participate and to
be concluded within a further period of three months. In this
way, the grievance of the appellant is also redressed.
In view of the above, this appeal is disposed of.”
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
9.
The creation of the supernumerary post was justified on the
basis of the reasoning furnished in paragraphs 19 and 20 of the
aforesaid judgment. A plain reading of the said two paragraphs would
clearly show that the respondent Nos. 4, 5 and 6 are qualified candidates
who had come to the selection process and were discharged with duties
for over two years and to discharge them at this stage would not be in
the public interest. The writ petitioners are unsuccessful candidates who
even did not clear the written examination and dispensing out
respondent Nos.4, 5 and 6 would not establish that the appellant was
qualified. The Hon’ble Division Bench allowed the deviation, in view
of the exceptional circumstances noticed in the instant case and record
to such deviation was resorted to meet an emergent situation. The
Hon’ble Division Bench has also relied upon several decisions of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in justification of the conclusion arrived at by
the Hon’ble Division Bench.
10.
The power of review is circumscribed by order 47 Rule 1 CPC.
Review jurisdiction is distinct from appellate jurisdiction. The review
proceedings are not meant for rehearing of appeal. The power of review
can be exercised, inter alia, where some mistake or error is appellant on
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
the face of the record. It may also be exercised on any analogous
ground, but under no circumstances on the ground that the decision was
erroneous on merits, that would fall within the exclusive domain of a
court of appeal.
11.
It is also well-settled that mistake or error apparent on the face of
the record has to be self-evident and does not require a process of
reasoning and the same is clearly distinct from erroneous decision as
has been held in Parsion Devi & Ors. vs. Sumitri Devi & Ors1. In the
said decision, the Hon'ble Supreme Court was considering the phrase
"mistake or error apparent on the face of record". It was held, an error
which is not self-evident and has to be detected by a process of
reasoning, can hardly be said to be an error apparent on the face of the
record justifying the Court to exercise its power of review under Order
47, Rule 1 CPC. In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47, Rule 1
CPC it is not permissible for an erroneous decision to be "reheard and
corrected". There is a clear distinction between an erroneous decision
and an eггor apparent on the face of the record. While the first can be
corrected by the higher forum, the latter can only be corrected by
1997 (8) SCC 715
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
exercise of the review jurisdiction. A review petition has a limited
purpose and cannot be allowed to be “an appeal in disguise”. [See.
Paragraphs 19 and 20 in Barun Kumar Das v. State of West Bengal2].
12.
In Hari Sankar Pal v. Anath Nath Mitter3, considering a five
Judge Bench of the Federal Court while question whether the Calcutta
High Court was justified in not granting relief to nonappealing party,
similar to that of the successful whose position was appellant, held:
(FCR p.48) “That a decision is erroneous in law is certainly no ground
for ordering review. If the court has decided a point and decided it
erroneously, the error could not be one apparent on the face of the
record or even analogous to it. When, however, the court disposes of a
case without adverting to or applying its mind to a provision of law
which gives it jurisdiction to act in a particular way, that may amount to
an error analogous to one apparent on the face of the record sufficient to
bring the case within the purview of Order 47 Rule 1, Civil Procedure
Code.
13.
The power of review, it is trite to say, should not be confused
with appellate power. An Appellate Court is competent to correct errors
2012(2) CHN 617
1949 FCR 36: AIR 1949 FC 106
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
committed by the Court subordinate thereto. In this regard, we can rely
upon the judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court pronounced in the case
of Thungabhadra Industries Ltd. vs. The Government of Andhra
Pradesh4 wherein Hon’ble Supreme Court held:“A review is by no means an appeal in disguise whereby an
erroneous decision is reheard and corrected, but lies only for
patent error. We do not consider that this furnishes a suitable
occasion for dealing with this difference exhaustively or in any
great detail, but it would suffice for us to say that where without
any elaborate argument one could point to the error and say here
is a substantial point of law which stares one in the face, and
there could reasonably be no two opinions entertained about it, a
clear case of error apparent on the face of the record would be
made out.”
(emphasis supplied)
14.
In this regard I can profitably relied upon the judgement of
Hon’ble Apex Court in State of West Bengal and Others Vs. Kamal
Sengupta & Another5 to understand what can be said to be mistake or
error apparent on the face of record.
15.
In State of West Bengal and Others (supra) the Hon’ble Apex
Court held:“22. The term “mistake or error apparent” by its very
connotation signifies an error which is evident per se from the
record of the case and does not require detailed examination,
scrutiny and elucidation either of the facts or the legal position. If
an error is not selfevident and detection thereof requires long
AIR 1964 SC 1372
(2008) 8 SCC 612
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
debate and process of reasoning, it cannot be treated as an error
apparent on the face of the record for the purpose of Order 47
Rule 1 CPC or Section 22(3)(f) of the Act. To put it differently an
order or decision or judgment cannot be corrected merely
because it is erroneous in law or on the ground that a different
view could have been taken by the court/tribunal on a point of
fact or law. In any case, while exercising the power of review, the
court/tribunal concerned cannot sit in appeal over its
judgment/decision.”
23. xxxxxx
24. xxxxxx
25. In Hari Sankar Pal v. Anath Nath Mitter, 1949 FCR 36
a five Judge Bench of the Federal Court while
considering the question whether the Calcutta High
Court was justified in not granting relief to
nonappealing party, whose position was similar to that
of the successful appellant, held: (FCR p.48)
“That a decision is erroneous in law is certainly no ground for
ordering review. If the court has decided a point and decided it
erroneously, the error could not be one apparent on the face of
the record or even analogous to it. When, however, the court
disposes of a case without adverting to or applying its mind to a
provision of law which gives it jurisdiction to act in a particular
way, that may amount to an error analogous to one apparent on
the face of the record sufficient to bring the case within the
purview of Order 47 Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code.”
(emphasis supplied)
16.
In Shri Ram Sahu (Dead) through LRS vs. Vinod Kumar
Rawat & Ors6 power of a review court is stated in following words:
“7. The dictionary meaning of the word “review” is “the act of
looking, offer something again with a view to correction or
(2020) 11 SCR 865
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
improvement”. It cannot be denied that the review is the
creation of a statute. In the case of Patel Narshi Thakershi vs.
Pradyumansinghji Arjunsinghji, (1971) 3 SCC 844, this Court
has held that the power of review is not an inherent power. It
must be conferred by law either specifically or by necessary
implication. The review is also not an appeal in disguise.
8. What can be said to be an error apparent on the face of the
proceedings has been dealt with and considered by this Court in
the case of T.C. Basappa vs. T.Nagappa, AIR 1954 SC 440. It is
held that such an error is an error which is a patent error and
not a mere wrong decision. In the case of Hari Vishnu Kamath
vs. Ahmad Ishaque, AIR 1955 SC 233, it is observed as under:
“It is essential that it should be something more than a
mere error; it must be one which must be manifest on the
face of the record. The real difficulty with reference to this
matter, however, is not so much in the statement of the
principle as in its application to the facts of a particular
case. When does an error cease to be mere error, and
become an error apparent on the face of the record?
Learned counsel on either side were unable to suggest any
clearcut rule by which the boundary between the two
classes of errors could be demarcated.”
8.1 In
the case of Parsion Devi vs. Sumitri Devi, (Supra) in
paragraph 7 to 9 it is observed and held as under:
7. It is well settled that review proceedings have to be strictly
confined to the ambit and scope of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC. In
Thungabhadra Industries Ltd. v. Govt. of A.P., AIR 1964 SC
1372 this Court opined:
“What, however, we are now concerned with is whether the
statement in the order of September 1959 that the case did not
involve any substantial question of law is an ‘error apparent on
the face of the record’). The fact that on the earlier occasion the
Court held on an identical state of facts that a substantial
question of law arose would not per se be conclusive, for the
earlier order itself might be erroneous. Similarly, even if the
statement was wrong, it would not follow that it was an ‘error
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
apparent on the face of the record’, for there is a distinction
which is real, though it might not always be capable of
exposition, between a mere erroneous decision and a decision
which could be characterised as vitiated by ‘error apparent’. A
review is by no means an appeal in disguise whereby an
erroneous decision is reheard and corrected, but lies only for
patent error.”
8. Again, in Meera Bhanja v. Nirmala Kumari Choudhury,
(1995) 1 SCC 170 while quoting with approval a passage from
Aribam Tuleshwar Sharma v. Aribam Pishak Sharma (supra) this
Court once again held that review proceedings are not by way of
an appeal and have to be strictly confined to the scope and ambit
of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC.
9. Under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC a judgment may be open to
review inter alia if there is a mistake or an error apparent on the
face of the record. An error which is not selfevident and has to be
detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an
error apparent on the face of the record justifying the court to
exercise its power of review under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC. In
exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC it is not
permissible for an erroneous decision to be “reheard and
corrected”. A review petition, it must be remembered has a
limited purpose and cannot be allowed to be “an appeal in
disguise”. (emphasis supplied)
17.
In a fairly recent decision in S. Murali Sundaram vs. Jothibai
Kannan & Ors.,7 the Hon’ble Supreme Court has discussed the scope
and ambit of Order 47 Rule 1, Code of Civil Procedure in paragraphs 15
to 17. On a review of its earlier decisions, it was held:
15. While considering the aforesaid issue two decisions of
this Court on Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114
2023 SCC Online SC 185
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
CPC are required to be referred to? In the case of Perry
Kansagra (supra) this Court has observed that while
exercising the review jurisdiction in an application under
Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114 CPC, the Review
Court does not sit in appeal over its own order. It is
observed that a rehearing of the matter is impermissible
in law. It is further observed that review is not appeal in
disguise. It is observed that power of review can be
exercised for correction of a mistake but not to substitute
a view. Such powers can be exercised within the limits of
the statute dealing with the exercise of power. It is
further observed that it is wholly unjustified and exhibits
a tendency to rewrite a judgment by which the
controversy has been finally decided. After considering
catena of decisions on exercise of review powers and
principles relating to exercise of review jurisdiction
under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC this Court had summed
upon as under:
“(i) Review proceedings are not by way of appeal and have
to be strictly confined to the scope and ambit of Order 47
Rule 1 CPC.
(ii) Power of review may be exercised when some mistake or
error apparent on the fact of record is found. But error
on the face of record must be such an error which must
strike one on mere looking at the record and would not
require any long-drawn process of reasoning on the
points where there may conceivably by two opinions.
(iii) Power of review may not be exercised on the ground that
the decision was erroneous on merits.
(iv) Power of review can also be exercised for any sufficient
reason which is wide enough to include a misconception
of fact or law by a court or even an advocate.
(v) An application for review may be necessitated by way of
invoking the doctrine actus curiae neminem gravabit.”
16. It is further observed in the said decision that an error
which is required to be detected by a process of
2025:MLHC:1117-DB
reasoning can hardly be said to be an error on the face
of the record.
17. In the case of Shanti Conductors (P) Ltd. (supra), it is
observed and held that scope of review under Order 47
Rule 1 CPC read with Section 114 CPC is limited and
under the guise of review, the petitioner cannot be
permitted to reagitate and reargue questions which have
already been addressed and decided. It is further
observed that an error which is not self- evident and has
to be detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be
said to be an error apparent on the face of record
justifying the court to exercise its power of review under
Order 47 Rule 1 CPC.” (emphasis supplied)
18.
None of the grounds of the review application fulfils the
requirement of Order 47 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
19.
In view of the aforesaid, the review petition stands dismissed.
20.
However, there shall be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Soumen Sen)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
20.11.2025
“Lam DR-PS”
LAMPHRANG KHARCHANDY
Date: 2025.11.21 15:23:05 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review