Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010106432021
2026:UHC:6716
THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Criminal Misc. Application No. 1176 of 2021
Kharak Singh Dhapola
... Applicant
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and Another
… Respondents
---------------------------------------------------------------------Presence:Mr. Devang Dobhal, learned counsel for the applicant.
Mr. Chitrarth Kandpal, learned Brief Holder for the State.
Mr. Kunwar Nripendra Singh Rautela, learned counsel with Mr.
B.S. Kathayat, learned counsel for the respondent no.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------Hon’ble Siddhartha Sah, J. (Oral)
By means of the present Criminal Misc.
Application filed under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973, the applicant has sought
quashing of the judgment and order dated 07.08.2021,
passed by 2nd Additional Sessions Judge, Nainital in
Criminal
Revision
No.132
of
2019,
Kharak
Singh
Dhapola vs. State of Uttarakhand and another, as well as
the summoning order dated 04.08.2016, passed by
Judicial Magistrate 1st, Haldwani, District Nainital in
Criminal Case No.2019 of 2015, Smt. Sarojini Dhapola
vs. Kharak Singh Dhapola and entire proceedings of
Criminal Case No.2019 of 2015, Smt. Sarojini Dhapola
vs. Kharak Singh Dhapola under Sections 494, 504 of
IPC read with Section 357 of the Cr.P.C. pending in the
Court of Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Haldwani,
District Nainital.
2.
The present Criminal Misc. Application under
UKHC010106432021
2026:UHC:6716
Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. emanates out of a criminal
complaint, which was filed by complainant Smt. Sarojini
Dhapola against the applicant, Bharat Singh Dhapola,
with the allegations of contracting a second marriage
during the subsistence of the first marriage with the
complainant. It has been alleged in the complaint that
the complainant, who is the wife of the accused, got
married with him on 07.03.1988, and it is contended
that the accused/applicant, herein, contracted a second
marriage without nullifying the first marriage with the
complainant on 04.07.2010. Therefore, it was prayed that
cognizance of the offence committed by the accused be
taken and he may be prosecuted accordingly.
3.
In pursuance to the aforesaid complaint, the
complainant/respondent No.2, herein, was examined
under Section 200 of the Cr.P.C. and a report of Thana
Mukhani, District Nainintal, was also summoned by the
Trial Court and based on the said statement, by a
summoning
order
dated
04.08.2016,
the
Judicial
Magistrate 1st, Haldwani, District Nainital has summoned
the accused/applicant herein under Sections 494 and
504 of the IPC.
4.
The said summoning order was assailed by the
accused/applicant, herein, by means of filing a Criminal
Revision, which was dismissed by the 2nd Additional
Sessions Judge, Nainital, vide judgment and order dated
07.08.2021.
5.
Assailing the aforesaid summoning order dated
04.08.2016
as well as
the
revisional order dated
07.08.2021, the present application has been filed.
6.
The learned counsel for the applicant would
UKHC010106432021
2026:UHC:6716
submit that prima facie no case is made out against the
accused/applicant and the main ground on which he
challenges the summoning order and the revisional order
is that, in the absence of establishment of marriage by
performing
the
ritual
of
Saptapadi
as
per
Hindu
marriage, no offence under Section 494 of the IPC would
be made out.
7.
Learned counsel for the applicant has relied
upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court
in the case of Nisha vs. State of U.P. and Another,
reported in 2024 SCC Online All. 1462, and he has, in
particular, invited the attention of the Court to paragraph
12 thereof. Paragraph 12 of the said judgment is being
extracted hereunder for ready reference:
“12. Having heard the submissions of learned
counsel for the parties and perusing the record, I find
that so far as the second marriage of revisionist is
concerned, it is well settled that the word ‘solemnize’
means, in connection with a marriage, ‘to celebrate
the marriage with proper ceremonies and in due
form’. Unless the marriage is celebrated or performed
with proper ceremonies and due form, it cannot be
said to be ‘solemnized’. If the marriage is not a valid
marriage, according to the law applicable to the
parties, it is not a marriage in the eyes of law. It is
also well settled that to constitute an offence under
Section 494 I.P.C., it is necessary that the second
marriage should have been celebrated with proper
ceremonies and in due form. The ‘Saptapadi’
ceremony under the Hindu Law is one of the
essential ingredients to constitute a valid marriage
but the said evidence is lacking in the present case.
Even there is no averment with regard to ‘Saptapadi’
in the complaint as well as in the statements under
Section 200 and 202 Cr. P.C., hence, this Court is of
the view that no prima facie offence is made out
against the revisionist as the allegation of second
marriage is a bald allegation without corroborative
materials. In absence of cogent evidence in this
regard, it is difficult to hold that the ‘Saptapadi
UKHC010106432021
2026:UHC:6716
ceremony’ of the marriage as contended by the
complainant was performed so as to constitute a
valid marriage between the parties concerned. As
such on taking into consideration the contents of the
complaint on its face value, the basic ingredients to
constitute an offence under Section 494 of I.P.C. are
lacking, hence, no offence under Section 494 I.P.C. is
made out against the revisionist.”
8.
Relying upon the judgment of the Allahabad
High Court in the case of Nisha (Supra), he would submit
that it is settled law that the word 'solemnize' in
connection with a marriage would be to celebrate the
marriage with proper ceremonies and in due form.
9.
He would submit that to constitute an offence
under Section 494 of the IPC, it is necessary that the
second marriage should have been celebrated with proper
ceremonies and in due form. The Saptapadi ceremony
under the Hindu Law is one of the essential ingredients
to constitute a valid marriage, and the said evidence is
lacking in the present case.
10.
Hence, in the absence of cogent evidence in
this regard, it is difficult to hold that the Saptapadi
ceremony of the marriage has been performed to
constitute
a
valid
marriage
between
the
parties
concerned. Hence, the complaint on its face value lacks
the basic ingredients to constitute an offence under
Section 494 IPC. Hence, the cognizance order is bad and
the Trial Court as well as the Revisional Court have erred
in law by summoning the applicant and by dismissing
the revision respectively.
11.
He would further submit that, in view of the
facts and circumstances of the case, no prima facie case
is made out. Section 494 of IPC would not be attracted in
UKHC010106432021
2026:UHC:6716
the absence of establishing the ceremony of marriage by
Saptapadi between the applicant and the alleged second
wife.
12.
Hence, he would urge that the powers under
Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. be exercised in the interest of
justice to prevent the abuse of the process of law, and the
summoning order as well as the order passed in criminal
revision be quashed.
13.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent
no.2 would submit that the main question of law that
falls for consideration in this case is whether it is
incumbent upon the complainant/respondent No. 2 to
establish and give evidence of Saptapadi and the
ceremonies of marriage to establish a case under Section
494 IPC for the purposes of summoning the accused to
face the trial under the aforesaid section.
14.
Refuting the contentions as raised by learned
counsel for the applicant, the learned counsel for
respondent No. 2 has relied upon a judgment of the High
Court of Delhi in the case of Pooja Sharma Bajaj vs.
Kunal Bajaj and Others, reported in (2024) SCC OnLine
Del 38, and he has invited the attention of the Court to
paragraph 18 and paragraphs 54, 55, 56, and 57 of the
said judgment, which are extracted hereunder for ready
reference :“18. While observing so, this Court remains guided
by the observations of Supreme Court in K.
Neelaveni v. State of T.N. (2010) 11 SCC 607 wherein it
has held that in case of an offence under Section
494IPC, it is a matter of trial as to whether the essential
ceremonies of the marriage were performed or not. The
relevant portion of the decision reads as under: (SCC p.
610, paras 14-15)
UKHC010106432021
2026:UHC:6716
“14. It has to be borne in mind that while
considering the application for quashing of the
charge-sheet, the allegations made in the first
information report and the materials collected
during the course of the investigation are required
to be considered. Truthfulness or otherwise of the
allegation is not fit to be gone into at this stage as
it is always a matter of trial. Essential ceremonies
of marriage were gone into or not is a matter of
trial.
15. From what we have said above, we are of
the opinion that the High Court erred in holding
that the charge-sheet does not reveal the
ingredients constituting the offences under
Sections 494 and 406 of the Penal Code.”
(emphasis supplied)
54. Therefore, to insist that all the ceremonies of
marriage, as performed for the purpose of a valid
marriage, must be proved for the purpose of even
summoning the accused for offence of bigamy will put
the first wife into a situation where though she knows
that her husband is living with another woman after
performing some kind of marriage ceremony, and are
living and projecting themselves as husband and wife,
but still she can take no action against him since one of
the ceremonies of marriage could not be proved by her.
In any case, it cannot be expected that the husband of a
wife will get married for the second time, during the
subsistence of earlier marriage, after informing her first
wife or in her presence so that she can collect evidence
of his second marriage and the ceremonies performed
therein.
55. It will be a cumbersome burden on a woman to
be asked to first prove every ceremony of the second
marriage of the husband, even before issuing summons.
56. Learned Sessions Court, at the stage of
summoning, also could not have disregarded the fact
that in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case,
the police assistance was not available to the petitioner,
as for reasons best known to her an application under
Section 156(3)CrPC was not filed so that the police
could have assisted in collecting evidence regarding the
second marriage which could have proved its validity or
its factum.
57. Thus, this Court takes cognizance of the fact
that the inability of one partner to prove performance of
saptapadi by the other partner while marrying for the
second time during subsistence of first marriage, at the
stage of summoning itself, especially when the other
partner may have solemnised such marriage with the
UKHC010106432021
2026:UHC:6716
third person in secrecy, should not be exploited as a
clever tactic to circumvent the legal consequences of
committing offence of bigamy. While legal proceedings
do involve strategic elements, such smart maneuvers
should not be allowed to compromise the principles of
fairness and justice.”
15.
Learned counsel for respondent no. 2 would
submit that it would be a cumbersome burden on a
woman to be asked to first prove every ceremony of the
second marriage of her husband even before issuing
summons. Referring to paragraph 18 of the judgment of
the Delhi High Court in the case of Pooja Sharma Bajaj
(Supra), he would submit that the High Court of Delhi
has relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of K. Neelaveni vs. State Rep. by
Inspector of Police and Others, reported in (2010) 11
SCC 607 and the Delhi High Court has held that it is a
matter of trial as to whether the essential ceremonies
were performed or not.
16.
He has also relied upon the aforesaid judgment
of K. Neelaveni (Supra), as aforesaid, and he has drawn
the attention of the Court to paragraphs 14 and 15 of the
said judgment, which are being extracted hereunder :“14. It has to be borne in mind that while
considering the application for quashing of the
charge-sheet, the allegations made in the first
information report and the materials collected
during the course of the investigation are
required to be considered. Truthfulness or
otherwise of the allegation is not fit to be gone
into at this stage as it is always a matter of
trial. Essential ceremonies of marriage were
gone into or not is a matter of trial.
15. From what we have said above, we are of
the opinion that the High Court erred in holding
that the charge-sheet does not reveal the
ingredients constituting the offences under
UKHC010106432021
2026:UHC:6716
Sections 494 and 406 of the Penal Code.”
17.
After hearing learned counsel for the parties
and after going through the record, the sole question that
falls for determination in this case is whether the
essential ceremonies of marriage were performed or not
would be a matter of trial, or even at the initial stage of
summoning the accused, the said essentials have to be
proved
by
the
complainant
for
the
passing
of
a
summoning order.
18.
On one hand, learned counsel for the applicant
has relied upon the judgment of the Allahabad High
Court in the case of Nisha (Supra), and on the other
hand, learned counsel for respondent no. 2 has relied
upon the judgment of the High Court of Delhi in the case
of Pooja Sharma Bajaj (Supra) and K. Neelaveni
(Supra).
19.
In the case of Nisha (Supra), the Allahabad
High Court has held that in the absence of cogent
evidence regarding the Saptapadi ceremony of marriage,
the basic ingredients to constitute an offence under
Section 494 of the IPC would be lacking, and thus there
is no offence made out, and the summoning order could
not have been passed. However, the view taken by the
High Court of Delhi is contrary. The High Court of Delhi
has relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court
in the case of K. Neelaveni (Supra). A perusal of
paragraph 14 of K. Neelaveni (Supra) would show that it
has been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that
whether essential ceremonies of marriage were performed
or not is a matter of trial.
20.
Therefore, ceremony of Saptapadi would be one
UKHC010106432021
2026:UHC:6716
of the essential ceremonies of marriage that would fall for
consideration by the Trial Court during trial, and that
question cannot be gone into at the primary stage of
taking cognizance.
21.
Hence, in view of the aforesaid facts and
circumstances, and in view of the settled law on the
subject as held in the case of K. Neelaveni (Supra), the
contentions as raised on behalf of learned counsel for the
applicant does not find favour and the contentions as
raised on behalf of respondent No. 2 appear to be correct.
22.
In such view of the matter, the Court does not
find any error in the summoning order or the judgment
passed by the revisional court, and no interference is
called for.
23.
Hence, the application under Section 482 of
the Cr.P.C. is liable to be dismissed and is accordingly
dismissed.
24.
Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed
of accordingly.
(Siddhartha Sah, J.)
31.07.2026
Shiv/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review