Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
Reserved On
: 08/07/2026
Pronounced On : 14/07/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2167 of 2013
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA
Sd/-.
and
HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI
Sd/-.
================================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
a
================================================================
KETAN NATVARLAL BRAHMBHATT
Versus
UNION OF INDIA THRO SECRETARY & ORS.
================================================================
Appearance:
MR YATIN SONI(868) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1
RULE UNSERVED for the Respondent(s) No. 1
MR.VARUN K.PATEL(3802) for the Respondent(s) No. 2,3
MR.RAJ TANNA, AGP for the Respondent(s) No. 4
================================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA
and
HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA)
(1)
By
way
of
the
present
writ
petition,
the
petitioner is seeking a declaration to declare Rule
8A(3) of the Wealth Tax Rules, 1957 (for short “the
Rules”), as ultra vires of Articles 14 and 19 of
the Constitution of India. The petitioner has also
called in question the legality and validity of the
order dated 26.09.2012 passed by respondent No.3Chief
Commissioner
of
Income
Tax,
whereby
the
petitioner's application seeking registration as a
"Registered
Valuer"
under
Section
34AB
of
the
Wealth Tax Act, 1957 (for short “the Act”) read
C/SCA/2167/2013
with
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
Rule
8A(3)
of
the
Rules
for
Category-II,
namely, Agricultural Lands (other than coffee, tea,
rubber
and
cardamom
plantations),
came
to
be
rejected on the ground that the petitioner lacks
prescribed
educational
qualification,
namely,
a
Degree in Agricultural Science from a recognized
University, as contemplated under Rule 8A(3) of the
Rules.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE :
(2)
The
petitioner
profession,
holding
is
a
a
Civil
Bachelor
Engineer
of
by
Engineering
degree from Gujarat University. During the course
of
his
engineering
studies,
the
petitioner
had
undertaken and successfully completed the subject
of
"Professional
eighth
semester
Practice
and
of
degree
the
Valuation"
in
the
programme.
The
petitioner has been practicing as a professional
Real Estate Valuer for more than twelve years and
has been duly registered as a Government Approved
Valuer
for
immovable
properties
(other
than
agricultural lands, plantations, forests, mines and
quarries)
pursuant
to
Registration
No.Cat/I/
402/2001-2002 dated 20.08.2001 issued by the Chief
Commissioner of Income Tax, Ahmedabad-II.
(3)
On
17.04.2012,
application
before
the
petitioner
submitted
the
respondent
No.3
an
under
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
Section 34AB of the Act read with Rule 8A(3) of the
Rules seeking registration as a Registered Valuer
for Category-II, namely Agricultural Lands (other
than coffee, tea, rubber and cardamom plantations).
The application was accompanied by all requisite
documents
together
with
the
prescribed
fees.
However, vide order dated 26.09.2012, respondent
No.3 rejected the said application solely on the
ground
that
educational
the
petitioner
qualification
did
not
possess
the
under
Rule
prescribed
8A(3) of the Rules.
(4)
The petitioner's principal grievance is that
the requirement of a degree in Agricultural Science
as an essential qualification for registration as a
valuer of agricultural lands under Rule 8A(3) of
the Rules is arbitrary, irrational and devoid of
any reasonable nexus with the object sought to be
achieved.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER :
(5)
Learned advocate Mr.Soni
no
specialized
educational
has submitted that
programme
in
India
imparts training specifically in the valuation of
agricultural lands through a degree in Agricultural
Science, whereas the curriculum for a Bachelor of
Civil
Engineering
Professional
includes
Practice
and
the
subject
Valuation,
of
thereby
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
equipping
Civil
Engineers
with
the
requisite
expertise to undertake valuation assignments. It
is, therefore, contended that the prescription of a
degree in Agricultural Science bears no rational
relationship
with
the
function
of
valuation
of
agricultural lands and is consequently liable to be
declared ultra vires of Articles 14 and 19 of the
Constitution of India.
(6)
It is contended that under the scheme of the
Wealth
Tax
Act,
1957,
and
the
Rules
framed
thereunder, valuation reports in respect of both
agricultural as well as non-agricultural properties
are
required
to
be
submitted
in
the
prescribed
statutory format. While referring to the Form, it
is
submitted
that
the
exercise
fundamentally
involves valuation principles and does not require
any specialized academic knowledge in Agricultural
Science.
(7)
It
is
next
submitted
that
there
exists
no
independent statutory authority or regulatory body
in
India
for
registration
of
valuers,
and
the
Income Tax Department alone regulates registration
of valuers under the Wealth Tax Act and allied
legislations.
Hence,
as
a
consequence,
a
person
registered under the said statutory framework is
universally
recognized
as
a
Government
Valuer or Government Registered Valuer.
Approved
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
(8)
Learned Advocate Mr.Soni has further submitted
that
the
determination
of
the
market
value
of
agricultural land primarily depends upon accepted
principles
rather
of
than
valuation
academic
and
market
knowledge
in
assessment
Agricultural
Science. Hence, the requirement of an Agricultural
Science
degree
has
no
rational
nexus
with
the
object of valuation.
(9)
It
is
further
urged
that
various
public
authorities such as Collectors, Deputy Collectors,
Settlement
Officers,
Superintendents
of
Land
Land
Valuation
Records
Officers,
and
Registrars
under the Registration Act, 1908 are made eligible
for registration under Rule 8A(3)(ii) of the Rules
nevertheless that they may neither possess a degree
in
Agricultural
Science
nor
have
any
formal
academic training in valuation. According to the
learned advocate, while Government officials having
prescribed
service
eligibility
under
experience
the
Rules,
are
granted
similarly
placed
professionals from the private sector are excluded
solely on the basis of educational qualification.
It
is,
therefore,
classification
violative
of
is
submitted
arbitrary,
Article
of
India.
that
such
discriminatory
the
Constitution
and
of
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
(10) Elaborating
valuation
that
of
the
methodology
agricultural
the
exercise
consideration
of
land,
adopted
it
is
necessarily
several
for
contended
involves
relevant
factors,
including the location and situation of the land,
surrounding development, comparable sale instances,
judicial
awards
determining
market
value,
Government Jantri valuation, land-use restrictions,
prevailing market conditions and, where applicable,
capitalization of agricultural income, and none of
these
recognized
specialized
methods
academic
of
valuation
knowledge
in
requires
Agricultural
Science. Even the statutory format prescribed for
valuation does not envisage such qualification. It
is, therefore, contended that the prescription of a
degree in Agricultural Science under Rule 8A(3) of
the
Rules
is
arbitrary,
unreasonable
and
constitutionally unsustainable.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT :
(11) Learned Senior
Standing Counsel Mr.Varun
K.
Patel while opposing the present writ petition has
submitted
that
Rule
8A(3)
of
the
Rules
is
constitutionally valid and does not suffer from any
infirmity warranting interference by this Court. It
was
contended
Constitution
that
Article
expressly
empowers
19(6)
of
the
the
State
to
prescribe professional or technical qualifications
C/SCA/2167/2013
for
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
carrying
business
in
impugned
Rule
on
any
profession,
the
larger
merely
public
occupation
or
interest.
The
prescribes
the
educational
qualification
for
valuer
agricultural
land
a
restriction
of
constitutes
reasonable
minimum
registration
and,
as
a
therefore,
within
the
meaning of Article 19(6) of the Constitution. It
was further submitted that the Rule neither creates
an arbitrary classification nor discriminates on
any prohibited ground and, consequently, does not
violate Article 14 of the Constitution.
(12) Learned
Senior
Standing
Counsel
further
submitted that Rule 8A of the Rules comprehensively
prescribes
the
educational
qualifications
and
experience required for registration of valuers in
respect of different classes of assets under subrules (1) to (12). The qualifications prescribed
vary depending upon the nature and characteristics
of the asset sought to be valued. Rule 8A(2) of the
Rules
specifically
deals
with
valuation
of
immovable properties other than agricultural lands,
plantations,
forests,
Agricultural
lands
distinct
owing
category,
to
the
mines
constitute
requiring
unique
a
quarries.
separate
different
factors
valuation.
and
and
expertise
governing
their
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
(13) It was next contended by the learned Senior
Standing
Counsel
that
the
qualified
Civil
Engineer,
petitioner,
is
fully
being
a
eligible
to
undertake valuation of buildings, urban lands and
other immovable properties falling within the ambit
of
Rule
8A(2)
of
the
Rules.
His
educational
qualifications adequately equip him to discharge
functions
relating
to
architecture,
structural
engineering, town planning, development of land,
quantity surveying, valuation of buildings and real
estate
consultancy.
However,
such
qualifications
cannot ipso facto entitle him to registration as a
valuer of agricultural lands, for which a distinct
educational
qualification
has
consciously
been
prescribed by the rule-making authority.
(14) Elaborating the rationale behind the impugned
Rule,
learned
that
the
Senior
valuation
Standing
of
Counsel
agricultural
submitted
land
is
fundamentally different from the valuation of other
immovable properties. Besides location and market
value,
the
valuation
necessarily
depends
upon
several agriculture-specific parameters, including
fertility
of
cultivation,
the
soil,
nature
irrigation
and
facilities,
quality
of
cropping
pattern, agricultural productivity, classification
of land in revenue records, annual yield, proximity
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
to markets, accessibility, mode of cultivation and
other
allied
effective
factors.
It
appreciation
was
of
submitted
these
that
an
considerations
necessarily requires specialized academic knowledge
in
Agricultural
Science
coupled
with
practical
exposure in the field. It was also submitted that
there are several Agricultural Universities across
the
country,
Universities
including
in
the
four
State
of
Agricultural
Gujarat,
imparting
recognized degrees in Agricultural Science.
[
(15) Learned
Senior
Standing
Counsel
further
submitted that Rule 8A(3)(ii) of the Rules extends
eligibility
Government
to
certain
officers,
categories
such
as
Collectors,
Settlement
Officers,
Superintendents
Officers,
Registration
Act,
of
and
Deputy
Land
Valuation
Land
Records,
Registrars
1908,
retired
Collectors,
Officers,
Agricultural
of
under
officers
the
holding
equivalent posts, provided they have rendered not
less than five years' service in such capacity.
According to the respondents, the inclusion of such
officers is founded upon their extensive practical
experience
acquired
during
official
duties
involving
assessment,
classification
agricultural
lands.
The
the
and
discharge
administration,
valuation
preferential
of
of
treatment
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
accorded to such officers is, therefore, based upon
intelligible differentia having a direct nexus with
the object sought to be achieved.
(16) It
was
Standing
further
Counsel
submitted
that
by
learned
recognition
of
Senior
relevant
practical experience, as an alternative to formal
educational qualification, is not unique to Rule
8A(3) of the Rules, but is a consistent legislative
feature
found
governing
throughout
registration
Rule
of
8A
of
the
Rules
valuers
for
different
classes of assets. The rule-making authority has
consciously balanced academic qualifications with
specialized
field
appropriate.
It
experience
was,
wherever
therefore,
considered
argued
that
the
impugned Rule represents a well-considered policy
decision based upon expert evaluation and technical
considerations, which ordinarily ought not to be
interfered
with
in
exercise
of
the
writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution.
(17) Learned Senior Standing Counsel appearing for
the
respondents
further
submitted
that
the
challenge mounted by the petitioner proceeds on an
erroneous assumption that valuation of agricultural
land
merely
involves
application
of
general
valuation principles. According to the respondents,
agricultural land constitutes a distinct class of
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
immovable
linked
property
to
its
whose
value
agricultural
is
intrinsically
characteristics
and
productive potential. Consequently, prescription of
specialized
educational
qualifications
cannot
be
said to be either arbitrary or irrational.
(18) Referring to the prescribed statutory format
for valuation of agricultural land, learned counsel
for the respondents submitted that the registered
valuer
is
required
to
furnish
comprehensive
particulars relating to the quality and fertility
of the soil, classification of the land in the
revenue
records,
irrigation,
crops
nature
grown,
availability
and
and
of
proximity
pattern
to
mode
of
cultivation,
villages,
towns
and
markets, availability of roads and transportation
facilities, whether the land is cultivated by the
owner
or
through
tenants,
and
other
special
features having a bearing on its valuation. The
valuer is also required to disclose the unit value
adopted and explain the methodology and basis for
determining the market value. It was, therefore,
contended
that
the
statutory
proforma
itself
demonstrates that valuation of agricultural land
necessarily
requires
specialised
knowledge
of
agricultural science and practical familiarity with
agricultural
operations.
Consequently,
the
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
prescription of a degree in Agricultural Science
under Rule 8A(3) of the Rules bears a direct and
rational
nexus
achieved
and
with
cannot
the
be
object
said
to
sought
be
to
be
arbitrary,
discriminatory, or violative of Articles 14 and 19
of the Constitution.
ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION :
(19) The petitioner is aggrieved by the order dated
26.09.2012,
whereby
his
application
for
registration as a valuer under Section 34AB of the
Act was rejected on the ground that he does not
possess the requisite qualification as prescribed
under Rule 8A(3) of the Rules. The petitioner has,
therefore, challenged the said order as well as the
constitutional validity of Rule 8A of the Rules.
(20) We may mention that the Wealth Tax Act, 1957
along
with
discontinued
the
Rules
has
been
from
01.04.2016.
Rule
abolished
and
8A(3)
the
of
Rules has been replaced by Rule 247 of the Income
Tax Rules, 2026, wherein Section 34AB of the Act
has been replaced by Section 514 of the Act, 2025.
In order to avoid further challenge to the pari
materia Rule, and in the wake of the fact that the
right of the petitioner to get himself registered
has
been
denied,
we
have
examined
the
constitutional validity of Rule 8A(3) of the Rules.
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
(21) Before adverting to the rival contentions on
merits,
it
would
be
appropriate
to
examine
the
statutory scheme governing registration of valuers
under Section 34AB of the Act read with Rule 8A of
the Rules together with the object sought to be
achieved
by
prescribing
distinct
educational
qualifications for different categories of assets.
“34AB. Registration of Values (1) The [Chief
Commissioner or Director General) shall maintain a
register to be called the Register of Valuers in
which shall be entered the names and addresses of
persons
registered
under
sub-section
(2)
as
valuers.
(2) Any person who possesses the qualifications
prescribed in this behalf may apply to the [Chief
Commissioner or Director General] in the prescribed
form for being registered as a valuer under this
section:
Provided that
prescribed for
assets.
different qualifications may
valuers of different classes
be
of
Rule 8A OF THE WEALTH TAX RULES, 1957
[Qualifications of registered valuers].
8A. (1) For the purposes of sub-section (2) of
section 34AB, the qualifications for registration
as valuers of different classes of asset shall be
as specified in sub-rules (2) to (11).
xxx xxx xxx
(3) A valuer of agricultural lands [other than
plantations referred to in sub-rule (4)] shall have
the following qualifications, namely:- (i) he must
be a graduate in agricultural science of a
recognised university and must have worked as a
farm valuer for a period of not less than five
years; or
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
(ii) he must be a person formerly employed in a
post under Government as a Collector, Deputy
Collector,
Settlement
Officer,
Land
Valuation
Officer,
Superintendent
of
Land
Records,
Agricultural
Officer,
Registrar
under
the
Registration Act, 1908 (16 of 1908), or any other
officer of equivalent rank performing similar
functions and must have retired or resigned from
such employment after having rendered service in
any one or more of the posts aforesaid for an
aggregate period of not less than five years.”
(22) It
is
undisputed
registered
valuer
that
on
the
the
petitioner
strength
is
of
a
his
qualification of a Bachelor of Engineering (Civil)
and
is
respect
seeks
duly
of
registered
immovable
registration
as
an
Estate
properties.
as
a
valuer
The
for
Valuer
in
petitioner
agricultural
land, including coffee, tea, rubber and cardamom
plantations falling under Category-II of Rule 8A(3)
of
the
Rules.
qualification
equally
According
to
in
Engineering
Civil
competent
to
the
undertake
petitioner,
the
his
renders
him
valuation
of
agricultural land.
(23) It is further the petitioner's case that there
are only a limited number of valuers qualified to
assess the market value of agricultural land in
accordance with the qualifications prescribed under
the Rules. The petitioner is seeking a declaration
from this Court to declare Rule 8A(3) of the Rules
as
ultra
vires
of
Articles
and
of
the
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
Constitution,
on
qualification
the
in
registration
as
a
ground
that
it
Agricultural
valuer
of
mandates
a
Science
for
agricultural
land,
despite the fact that such specialized knowledge is
not indispensable for carrying out such valuation.
Furthermore, the Rule permits Collectors, Deputy
Collectors and other specified Gazetted Government
officers to be registered as valuers even though
they
are
not
Agricultural
required
Science.
to
The
possess
a
petitioner,
degree
in
therefore,
contends that the impugned Rule is arbitrary and
discriminatory
and
deserves
to
be
declared
unconstitutional.
(24) At this stage, it would be apposite to examine
Rule
8A
of
the
Rules,
which
prescribes
the
qualifications for registration as a valuer under
the
various
categories/assets
specified
therein.
The Rule has been framed in exercise of the powers
conferred under sub-section (2) of Section 34AB of
the Act.
(25) Section 34AB of the Act falls under Chapter
VII-B of the Act. Sub-section (2) of Section 34AB
of the Act governs the registration of valuers.
Proviso (ii) to sub-section (2) of Section 34AB of
the Act contemplates the prescription of distinct
qualifications for valuers of different classes of
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
assets.
In
furtherance
intent,
Rule
8A
prescribing
of
of
the
the
Rules
separate
said
has
legislative
been
framed,
qualifications
for
registration as a valuer in respect of different
classes of assets. The relevant sub-rules of Rule
8A are summarised hereunder:
25.1
Rule
8A(2)
qualifications
for
of
the
Rules
registration
prescribes
as
a
valuer
the
of
immovable property (other than agricultural land,
plantations,
forests,
mines
and
quarries).
It
requires the applicant to possess a degree in Civil
Engineering, Architecture or Town Planning, or a
postgraduate degree in Real Estate Valuation from a
recognised University. Alternatively, a person who
has served as a Gazetted Government officer in the
prescribed capacity is also eligible.
25.2
Rule
8A(3)
qualifications
agricultural
hold
a
for
land.
degree
in
of
the
Rules
prescribes
the
registration
as
a
valuer
of
It
the
applicant
to
requires
Agricultural
Science
from
a
recognised University and to have worked as a farm
valuer for a period of not less than five years.
25.3
Rule
8A(4)
qualifications
for
of
the
Rules
registration
prescribes
as
a
valuer
coffee, tea, rubber and cardamom plantations.
the
of
C/SCA/2167/2013
25.4
Rule
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
8A(5)
qualifications
of
for
the
Rules
registration
prescribes
as
a
the
valuer
of
forests. It requires the applicant to have served
under the Government for not less than five years
in a gazetted post in the prescribed capacity.
25.5
Rule
8A(6)
qualifications
mines
and
possess
a
of
the
Rules
prescribes
the
for
registration
as
a
valuer
of
quarries,
requiring
the
applicant
to
degree
Mining
in
Engineering
from
a
recognised University.
[
25.6
Rule
8A(7)
qualifications
of
for
the
Rules
registration
prescribes
as
a
valuer
the
of
stocks, shares, debentures, securities, partnership
interests
and
business
applicant
to
be
a
assets.
member
of
It
requires
the
the
Institute
of
Chartered Accountants of India or the Institute of
Cost and Works Accountants of India.
[
25.7
Rule
8A(8)
of
qualifications
for
machinery
plant,
possess
and
a
degree
the
Rules
registration
requiring
in
prescribes
the
as
a
valuer
of
the
applicant
to
Mechanical
or
Electrical
Engineering from a recognised University.
25.8
Rule
8A(9)
qualifications
for
of
the
Rules
registration
prescribes
as
a
valuer
the
of
jewellery. It requires the applicant to have not
C/SCA/2167/2013
less
than
proprietor
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
five
or
years'
partner
experience
in
a
as
a
sole
partnership
firm
carrying on the business of jewellery.
25.9
Rule
8A(10)
qualifications
for
of
the
Rules
registration
prescribes
as
a
the
valuer
of
works of art, whereas Rule 8A(11) of the Rules
prescribes the qualifications for registration as a
valuer of life interests, reversions and interests
in expectancy.
(26) Rule
8A(13)
of
the
Rules
provides
that,
notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rules (1)
to
(12),
no
person
shall
be
eligible
for
removed
from
registration as a valuer if :
“(a) he has been dismissed
Government service; or
or
(b) he has been convicted of an offence connected
with any proceeding under the sub-Rule 13(b).
(c) he is an undischarged insolvent; or
(d) he has been convicted of any offence
sentenced to a term of imprisonment; or
and
(e) he has been found guilty of misconduct in his
professional capacity.
Thus, while framing Rule 8A of the Rules, the
rule-making
authority
has
consciously
prescribed
distinct qualifications for valuers of different
C/SCA/2167/2013
classes
expertise
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
of
assets,
required
having
in
the
due
regard
respective
to
the
fields.
A
statutory rule cannot be declared invalid merely
because the petitioner contends that no specialised
expertise
is
agricultural
necessary
land
or
for
that
the
valuation
of
such
valuation
can
equally be undertaken by a person possessing the
petitioner's qualifications.
(27) It is also pertinent to note that Form O-2,
which prescribes the format for valuation reports
relating to agricultural land, itself demonstrates
the specialised knowledge expected of a valuer. The
Form
requires
regarding
the
the
valuer
nature
to
and
furnish
particulars
classification
of
the
land, its location in the concerned village, taluka
and
district,
revenue
its
records,
area,
crops
classification
cultivated
in
the
during
the
relevant period, and the annual land revenue, if
any.
(28) The Form further requires the valuer to assess
the special characteristics of the land, including
its quality and fertility, the mode of irrigation
(whether
through
proximity
to
wells,
villages,
tube-wells
or
towns
markets,
and
canals),
the
availability of approach roads and transportation
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
facilities, whether the land is cultivated by the
owner or by tenants, and all other factors having a
bearing on its market value.
(29) In addition, the Form requires verification of
comparable sale instances, including whether the
comparable
lands
are
similarly
situated,
the
distance between the properties, the date of the
transactions, the sale consideration, and the unit
value.
Evidently,
these
parameters
require
specialised knowledge and practical experience in
agricultural valuation. It is, therefore, within
the legislative wisdom to prescribe that a valuer
of agricultural land should possess a degree in
Agricultural Science from a recognised University
and have not less than five years' experience as a
farm valuer.
(30) We find neither any ambiguity in the impugned
provision
nor
any
inconsistency
between
the
prescribed qualifications and the object sought to
be achieved under Rule 8A of the Rules. The Rule
also recognises the eligibility of former gazetted
Government
officers,
such
as
Collectors,
Settlement
Officers,
Superintendents
Agricultural
Officers,
Collectors,
Officers,
of
Land
Valuation
Land
Records,
Registrars
Deputy
under
the
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
Registration
Act,
and
other
specified
officers,
provided they have rendered the requisite period of
service. Such officers, by virtue of their official
duties
extending
over
several
years,
acquire
substantial experience in matters relating to land
administration, valuation and allied subjects.
(31) The
same
throughout
legislative
Rule
8A
of
approach
the
is
Rules,
evident
where
the
qualifications prescribed for valuers of different
classes
of
assets
correspond
with
the
expertise
ordinarily acquired in the relevant profession or
public office. If the petitioner's contention were
to be accepted, the validity of the entire scheme
under
Rule
8A
of
the
Rules
would
be
rendered
vulnerable. By the same logic, the eligibility of
retired Gazetted officers, members of the Institute
of Chartered Accountants of India for valuation of
stocks, shares and business assets, or Government
engineers
and
engineering
academicians
for
valuation of machinery and plant, would also have
to
be
questioned.
Such
an
interpretation
would
defeat the very object of the Rule. It is trite
that the statute must be read as a whole and one
provision of the statute should be construed with
reference to other provisions in the same statute
so as to make a consistent enactment of the whole
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
statute.
The declaration of Rule 8A(3) of the
Rules as ultra vires will have a cascading effect
on the other sub-rules under Rule 8A of the Rules
which
stipulate
different
qualifications
for
several / different categories of assets.
(32) Accordingly, Rule 8A of the Rules cannot be
struck down merely because the petitioner, though
possessing
capable
a
degree
of
in
Civil
determining
agricultural
assets,
and
Engineering,
is
the
valuation
of
is
eligible
for
registration as a valuer in respect thereof.
statutory
rule
cannot
be
struck
down
on
A
the
presumption that qualifications other than the one
mandated
by
the
Rule
can
take
care
of
a
given
situation. Equally untenable is the contention that
the
Rule
creates
a
monopoly
on
account
of
the
limited number of registered valuers in the State
of Gujarat. On the contrary, the material placed on
record by the petitioner itself indicates that he
has been engaged by various banks for the valuation
of agricultural properties, thereby negating the
plea
of
any
such
monopoly
or
practical
impossibility.
(33) Thus, on an overall analysis and examination
of the purpose and legislative intent of Rule 8A of
C/SCA/2167/2013
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/07/2026
the Rules, we refrain from declaring Rule 8A(3) of
the Rules ultra vires Articles 14 and 19 of the
Constitution of India.
The writ petition fails;
the same is, accordingly, dismissed. There shall be
no order as to costs.
Sd/.
(A. S. SUPEHIA, J)
Sd/.
(VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI,J)
Bhavesh-[PPS]* - Radhika*
***
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review