Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:1779-DB
I N TH E H I GH COURT OF UTTA RA K H A N D
A T N A I N I TA L
H ON ’ BLE SRI M A N OJ K UM A R TI W A RI
AND
H ON ’ BLE SRI JUSTI CE PA N K A J PUROH I T
W RI T PETI TI ON ( S/ B) N O. 3 2 OF 2 0 2 3
1 3 TH M A RCH , 2 0 2 6
Darshan Singh Rawat and Ot hers
……
Pet it ioner s
……
Respondent s
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and Ot hers
W I TH
W RI T PETI TI ON ( S/ B) N O. 5 7 2 OF 2 0 2 2
Pyar Singh Panwar
……
Pet it ioner
……
Respondent s
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and Ot hers
Counsel for t he pet it ioner
:
Mr. Shailendra Naur iyal and Dr. N.K.
Pant , learned counsel
Counsel for t he respondent s
:
Mr. S.S. Chaudhar y, learned St anding
Counsel for t he St at e of Ut t arakhand.
Mr. Bhupendra Bisht , learned counsel for
respondent no.4.
:
W I TH
W RI T PETI TI ON ( S/ B) N O. 5 7 3 OF 2 0 2 2
Keshav Lal Todariya
……
Pet it ioner
……
Respondent s
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot her s
Th e Co u r t m a d e t h e f o l l o w i n g :
JUD GM EN T: ( p e r H o n ’ b l e Ju st i ce Sr i M a n o j K u m a r Ti w a r i )
1.
Since com m on quest ions of law and fact s are involved
in all t hese writ pet it ions, t herefore, t hey are being heard
and decided t oget her. However, for t he sake of brevit y Writ
Pet it ion ( S/ B) No.32 of 2023, shall be t he leading case.
2026:UHC:1779-DB
2.
Pet it ioners were appoint ed as Junior Engineers in Rural
Engineering Services Depart m ent ( RES) of t he St at e on
different dat es and all of t hem ret ired from service before
31.10.2017. Pet it ioners filed claim pet it ion no.157/ DB/ 2019
challenging Governm ent Order dat ed 26.12.2017 issued by
Secret ary, Panchayat i Raj and Rural Engineering Service
whereby
it
was
provided
t hat
pay
scale
for
post
of
Superintending Engineer shall be upgraded from ₹1560039100/ - grade pay 7600/ - to ₹37400- 67000/ - grade pay
₹8700/- wit h im m ediat e effect .
3.
Pet it ioners also challenged order dat ed 01.11.2019
whereby t heir claim for pay scale, as upgraded vide G.O.
dat ed 26.12.2017, was rej ect ed. Learned Tribunal dism issed
claim
pet it ion
filed
by
pet it ioners on
t he ground
t hat
st ipulat ion m ade in G.O. dat ed 26.12.2017, whereby cut - off
dat e was fixed for grant of upgraded pay scale, is a policy
decision of St at e, which cannot be int erfered by t he Tribunal.
The
operat ive
port ion
of
im pugned
j udgm ent
dat ed
31.10.2020 is ext ract ed below:
“ 22. I t shall, however, be open t o t he Govt . of
Ut t arakhand t o review it s decision. The discret ion t o
issue a fresh G.O., on t he lines of G.O. issued by t he
Govt . of U.P., t o give financial benefit s t o t he pet it ioners
and sim ilarly sit uat e em ployees, from an earlier dat e,
vest s wit h t he Govt . of Ut t arakhand. The decision
should, however, be well inform ed by reason.
23. We are given t o underst and t hat exercise for
revising t he grade pay of Rupees 7600 of t he post of
superint ending engineer t o Rupees 8700 from an earlier
dat e is under way. The Governm ent m ay consider t he
sam e at an early dat e so t hat som e of t he pet it ioners
and sim ilarly placed engineers in ot her depart m ent s
m ay be benefit ed by t he sam e. I f t he sam e is not
possible, t he Governm ent m ay consider revising t he
pension of pet it ioners and sim ilarly placed persons wit h
effect from 31 st Oct ober, 2017 worked out on t he basis
of t heir last pay as upgraded t o level 13 on t his dat e.”
2026:UHC:1779-DB
4.
Learned counsel for pet it ioners subm it s t hat pet it ioners
were given 3rd ACP in grade pay of ₹7600/- , t herefore, t hey
are ent it led t o benefit of pay upgradat ion as grant ed by G.O.
dat ed 26.12.2017. He subm it s t hat st ipulat ion m ade in t he
said G.O. t hat benefit of pay upgradat ion would be given
wit h im m ediat e effect is unj ust and arbit rary and benefit of
pay upgradat ion should be m ade available t o all persons
sim ilarly
sit uat e,
including
t hose
who
ret ired
before
31.10.2017.
5.
I t would not be out of cont ext t o m ent ion here t hat on
31.10.2017, Principal Secret ary, Depart m ent of Finance had
issued a com m unicat ion addressed t o Secret ary of Public
Works Depart m ent , I rrigat ion Depart m ent , Rural Engineering
Service
Depart m ent
and
Minor
I rrigat ion
Depart m ent
inform ing t hem about in principle decision t aken by t he St at e
Governm ent
to
Engineering
t o bring t hem
at
Superint ending
Engineering
serving
under
t he
Governm ent .
paragraph
no.3
t hat
G.O.,
In
upgrade
pay
scale
of
Superint ending
par wit h pay scale of
of
Cent ral
it
was
m ent ioned t hat com pet ent aut horit y in each of t he four
depart m ent s m ent ioned would be at libert y t o issue separat e
G.Os. providing for such pay upgradat ion.
6.
The view t aken by learned Tribunal t hat fixat ion of cut -
off dat e is wit hin dom ain of t he Execut ive and t hus a policy
decision cannot be fault ed. Law is well- set t led t hat j udicial
int erference wit h cut - off dat e fixed by t he Execut ive can be
in very lim it ed circum st ances and in t he present case no
such
circum st ance
exist s which
int erference wit h cut - off dat e fixed.
would
have
warrant ed
2026:UHC:1779-DB
7.
Hon’ble Suprem e Court in t he case of Union of I ndia vs.
S.R. Dhingra & ot hers report ed as ( 2008) 2 SCC 229, while
considering t he sim ilar case, has held as under: “ 25. I t is well set t led t hat when t wo set s of
em ployees of t he sam e rank ret ire at different point s of
t im e, one set cannot claim t he benefit ext ended t o t he
ot her set on t he ground t hat t hey are sim ilarly sit uat ed.
Though t hey ret ired wit h t he sam e rank, t hey are not of
t he sam e class or hom ogeneous group. Hence Art icle 14
has no applicat ion. The em ployer can validly fix a cut off dat e for int roducing any new pension/ ret irem ent
schem e or for discont inuance of any exist ing schem e.
What is discrim inat ory is int roduct ion of a benefit
ret rospect ively ( or prospect ively) fixing a cut - off dat e
arbit rarily t hereby dividing a single hom ogenous class of
pensioners int o t wo groups and subj ect ing t hem t o
different
t reat m ent
[ vide Col.
B.J.
Akkara
( Ret d.) v. Govt . of I ndia [ ( 2006) 11 SCC 709 : ( 2007) 1
SCC ( L&S) 529] , D.S. Nakara v. Union of I ndia [ ( 1983)
1 SCC 305 : 1983 SCC ( L&S) 145] , Krishena
Kum ar v. Union of I ndia [ ( 1990) 4 SCC 207 : 1991 SCC
( L&S) 112 : ( 1990) 14 ATC 846] , I ndian Ex- Services
League v. Union of I ndia [ ( 1991) 2 SCC 104 : 1991 SCC
( L&S) 536 : ( 1991) 16 ATC 488] , V. Kast uri v. MD,
SBI [ ( 1998) 8 SCC 30 : 1999 SCC ( L&S) 78] and Union
of I ndia v. Dr. Vij ayapurapu Subbayam m a [ ( 2000) 7
SCC 662 : 2000 SCC ( L&S) 1012] ] .”
8.
Sim ilar view was expressed by Hon’ble Suprem e Court
in t he case of St at e of Bihar vs. Bihar Pensioners Sam aj ,
report ed as ( 2006) 5 SCC 65. Para 17 of t he said j udgm ent
is reproduced below: “ 17. We t hink t hat t he cont ent ion is well founded. The
only ground on which Art icle 14 has been put forward
by t he learned counsel for t he respondent is t hat t he
fixat ion of t he cut - off dat e for paym ent of t he revised
benefit s under t he t wo not ificat ions concerned was
arbit rary and it result ed in denying arrears of paym ent s
t o cert ain sect ions of t he em ployees. This argum ent is
no longer res int egra. I t has been held in a cat ena of
j udgm ent s t hat fixing of a cut - off dat e for grant ing of
benefit s is well wit hin t he powers of t he Governm ent as
long as t he reasons t herefor are not arbit rary and are
based on som e rat ional considerat ion.”
2026:UHC:1779-DB
9.
Upgradat ion of pay scale of Superint ending Engineers t o
bring it at par wit h Superint ending Engineers serving under
t he Cent ral Governm ent has financial im plicat ions.
Having
regard t o t he huge financial burden, which would have been
im posed upon t he St at e Governm ent , it was decided t hat t he
benefit of pay upgradat ion would be given only from t he dat e
of issuance of Governm ent Order. The Governm ent Order
was issued on 26.12.2017, while pet it ioners ret ired before
issuance of Governm ent Order dat ed 26.12.2017.
10. Having regard t o t he financial im plicat ions involved in
upgradat ion t he pay scales, St at e Governm ent fixed cut - off
dat e and anyone who was serving on t hat cut - off dat e is
eligible for t he upgraded pay scale. Since pet it ioners were
not serving on t hat cut - off dat e, t herefore, t hey cannot claim
parit y wit h persons who were serving on t he cut - off dat e.
The cut - off dat e fixed by t he St at e Governm ent cannot be
said t o be arbit rary, as t here is a rat ional considerat ion for
fixat ion of cut - off dat e. The reason for fixing cut - off dat e,
according t o t he St at e Counsel, is financial im plicat ions as
St at e Governm ent does not have sufficient resources t o pay
upgraded pay scale t o all t hose who have ret ired before t he
cut - off- dat e.
11. Learned St at e Counsel subm it s t hat if pet it ioners are t o
be given benefit of upgraded pay scale, t hen ot hers, who
ret ired several decades ago, can also not be denied benefit
of upgraded pay scale and it would not be possible for t he
St at e t o arrange necessary resources t o m eet t he financial
burden of upgraded pay scale t o all ret ired em ployees.
12. Learned counsel for t he pet it ioner, however, relied upon
a j udgm ent rendered by Hon’ble Suprem e Court in t he case
of Maharasht ra St at e Financial Corporat ion Ex- Em ployees
2026:UHC:1779-DB
Associat ion & ot hers vs. St at e of Maharasht ra & ot hers
report ed as 2023 SCC OnLine SC 100. I n para 32 of t he said
j udgm ent also, Hon’ble Suprem e Court held t hat fixat ion of
cut - off dat e for grant of benefit s cannot be quest ioned and
observed t hat what is wit hin t he dom ain of t his Court , is t o
exam ine t he im pact of such fixat ion and whet her it result s in
discrim inat ion.
13. This Court is of t he considered opinion t hat fixat ion of
cut - off- dat e in t he present case does not result in invidious
discrim inat ion and having regard t o t he financial burden
involved, St at e Governm ent had t o fix cut - off dat e. Thus,
cut - off dat e cannot be said t o be arbit rary. Thus, we do not
find any scope of int erference wit h t he j udgm ent rendered by
learned Tribunal.
14. The
writ
pet it ions,
however,
are
disposed
of
by
providing t hat t he St at e Governm ent m ay revisit t he issue as
per t he observat ion m ade by learned Tribunal in para 22 and
23 of it s j udgm ent and pass appropriat e order, as per law,
wit hin six m ont hs from t he dat e of present at ion of cert ified
copy of t his order.
______________________
M A N OJ K U M A R TI W A RI , J.
_______________
PA N K A J PUROH I T, J.
Dt : 13 TH MARCH, 2026
Mahinder/
MAHIND
ER
SINGH
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=da6212e6e78d94ed3134842bc6a8d6c
a168979ca7b8c2f031a92d1a18b08923c,
postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=AB77B7C5B240908B392BE84F5C
DD4C2AF35DC4626D305B1BC9EA4BABA43D2
B8F, cn=MAHINDER SINGH
Date: 2026.03.20 18:31:13 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review