Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 663 of 2024
Reserved on 24.02.2026
Decided on : 02.03.2026
Kesar Singh (deceased) through LRs
...Petitioners.
Versus
Ved Ram
…..Respondent.
Coram
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioners:
M/s B.L.Soni & Nitin Soni, Advocates.
For the respondent:
Mr. Tara Singh Chauhan, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Surya Chauhan, Advocate.
Romesh Verma, Judge
The present petition arises out of the order passed
by learned Civil Judge, Kullu, District Kullu, H.P. in Case No. 94
of 2016, titled Vidya Devi vs. Ved Ram, decided on 26.10.2024,
whereby the application filed by the petitioner for implementation
of the order dated 05.08.2016, directing to demolish the
construction raised by the respondent, has been rejected.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that the plaintiff/petitioner
filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction in the Court of
Civil Judge, Kullu, District Kullu, H.P. It was averred in the plaint
that land measuring 01.05-00 Bigha comprised in Khasra No.
857, contained in Khatauni No. 317 of Khata No. 188, situated in
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
Tosh, Phati Manikaran Kothi Kanawar, Tehsil Bhuntar, District
Kullu, H.P. as incorporated in Jamabandi for the year 2008-2009,
is recorded in the joint ownership and possession of the plaintiffs
and defendant alongwith other co-sharers.
3.
It was averred in the plaint that initially there was a
two and half storied slate roofed house of Poshi Devi, plaintiff
No.1, and in the month of November 2001, the same was gutted
in fire,
and in its place, plaintiff No.1 constructed
a single
storied CGI sheet roofed shed measuring 15 Hath x 13 Hath
and the same is being used by her as grass and wooden store
and rest of the suit land is vacant on the spot and is cultivable.
4.
It has further been averred that the defendant is a
very rich
and influential person, who by taking
undue
advantage of this fact is openly threatening to grab the most
valuable portion of the suit land facing towards the aforesaid
agricultural path and that too in excess of his share and to this
effect he is collecting construction material over the suit land in
order to raise construction over the same, that too, in excess of
his share, without getting the same lawfully partitioned, of which
he has no right. The aforesaid act on the part of the defendant is
highly wrongful and illegal.
5.
In this background, suit was filed by the plaintiff/
petitioner seeking a decree by restraining the defendant from
raising any type of construction over the suit land and further
from changing the nature of the aforesaid land in any manner
and further for grant of permanent prohibitory injunction.
6.
The suit was contested by the defendant by raising
various objections such as maintainability, non-joinder of
necessary parties, estoppel and that
the plaintiff has not
approached the court with clean hands etc.
7.
almost
On merits, it was stated that in the fire outbreak,
all houses of Village Tosh were gutted in fire. The
defendant had two residential
houses and one agricultural
house in village Tosh. Out of these two residential houses, one
was ancestral house of Ved Ram, the defendant, that existed
near the suit land but on the other land, there was another
residential house, which was individually owned by him, existed
on the North-Eastern portion of the suit land abutting both the
aforesaid two paths running alongwith its Northern and Eastern
sides. The third house was agricultural house which also existed
outside the suit land but quite near to it. All these three houses
of the defendant and house of the plaintiff, alongwith other
houses of the co-villagers, were gutted in the fire outbreak in the
year 2001.
8.
The defendant had acquired 1/4th share in the suit
land equivalent to 0-06-05 bighas, alongwith one residential
house over it, from one Sarvu widow of Totu by way of gift.
9.
It was submitted that after the previous houses of the
parties were gutted in fire in the year 2001, plaintiff Smt. Poshi
Devi through her son Kesar Singh constructed her aforesaid two
storied tin roofed residential house measuring 43 ft 3 inches x
25 ft 2 inches on the northern portion of the suit land. Now, the
plaintiffs are estopped from objecting to the re-construction of
the residential house by the defendant, as she had acquiesced
and consented to such re-construction as submitted hereto
before and also for further reason that she had also constructed
her own residential house, bath room, shed etc. As a result of
aforesaid understanding/arrangement between the co-sharers,
plaintiffs are estopped from not extending such concession given
by the plaintiff and other co-sharers to the defendant in breach
of the aforesaid arrangement/agreement.
10.
It was further submitted that the house of the
defendant had become uninhabitable
and as such it was
demolished in the month of March, 2016 and soon thereafter reconstruction work was started by him. The construction is being
done well within his share on such land which is in his settled
possession and on which his said previous house existed. The
defendant has not covered any fresh land under his house or
occupation, as alleged. Therefore, the defendant had prayed for
dismissal of the suit as filed by the plaintiff.
11.
Alongwith the suit, plaintiff had also filed an
application for stay and on 24.05.2016, learned Civil Judge (Sr.
Div.), Kullu, H.P.
had directed that notices be issued to the
respondents returnable for 22.06.2016, and till then, both the
parties were directed to maintain status quo qua the nature,
possession and construction over the suit land.
12.
Thereafter, the said interim order was confirmed on
05.08.2016, whereby
raising
the respondents was restrained
from
further construction in any manner over the suit land
comprised in Khata No. 188, Khatauni No. 317, Khasra No. 857,
measuring 01-05-00 bighas, situated at Phati Manikaran, Kothi
Kanawar, Tehsil Bhuntar, District Kullu, H.P. till final disposal of
the suit.
13.
It is contended by learned counsel for the petitioners
that despite passing of the injunction order passed by the
learned Civil Judge (Sr. Div.), Kullu, District Kullu, H.P.
respondent continued with the construction work.
14.
The plaintiffs/ petitioners filed an application under
Order 39 Rule 7 CPC for appointment of a Local Commissioner
on 31.05.2016, immediately, after passing of the interim order
with the direction to the Local Commissioner to visit the spot and
report about the construction work carried out by the present
respondent. The said application was allowed by learned Civil
Judge (Sr. Div.), Kullu, District Kullu, H.P. on 01.06.2016 and
Sh. Harish Sharma, Advocate was appointed
as Local
Commissioner with the direction to inspect the spot and to report
the construction, if any, being raised by the respondent on the
spot. The Local Commissioner visited the spot and gave his
report on 04.06.2016. The copy of the report has been appended
with the present petition, as Annexure P-7.
15.
It is contended by the learned counsel for the
petitioners that despite passing of the interim order which was
confirmed by learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Kullu, District
Kullu, H.P. on 05.08.2016, the respondent continued with the
construction.
16.
Thereafter, the plaintiffs on 31.10.2023 filed an
application for the implementation of the order dated 05.08.2016
with further direction that police be directed to seize the
construction material lying on the spot and illegal construction
raised after passing of the injunction order may be ordered to be
demolished at the cost and expenses of the respondent and
property of the respondent may be ordered to be attached and
respondent may be ordered to be sent in civil imprisonment in
the interest of justice.
17.
Respondent
filed
reply
to
the
application
on
04.11.2023, whereby it has been contended that respondent is
an old person and he is shepherd by vocation and he has fairly
big flock of sheep and goats and in addition to that he has
agricultural land in high acres in the hill tops of Tosh/Maantalai
area which is far away from his village where suit property is
situated. In summers, the respondent takes his sheep and goats
and cattle to his agricultural land situated in the hill tops of the
aforesaid village which adjoins grazing runs. He had taken cattle,
sheep and goats to the aforesaid grazing runs in the middle of
May, 2016, which is about 10-15 k.m. from village Tosh and the
whole distance is not connected by roads and one has to walk
all this distance on foot.
18.
It has further been submitted in the reply that son of
respondent namely Pyare Lal had taken
knowledge
of the
aforesaid notice/ ex-party injunction order on 18th June, 2016
and thereafter, he informed the respondent and immediately,
thereafter, he stopped the construction work on the spot. It has
further been contended in the reply that construction work on the
suit land was done by son of respondent, namely Pyare Lal, and
he should not carry out any construction work on the spot.
19.
Initially, the application filed under Section 151 of
CPC for implementation of the order dated 05.08.2016 was
disposed of by the learned Civil Judge, Kullu District Kullu, H.P.
on 08.11.2023 and the same was partly allowed, whereby the
SHO
was directed to depute a responsible
officer with a
direction to visit the spot within 10 days of passing of the order
and to make sure that
order dated 05.08.2016 shall not be
violated and shall be enforced in its letter and spirit.
20.
Since the petitioners felt aggrieved by partly allowing
of the said application, therefore, he preferred CMPMO No. 729
of 2023 under Section 227 of the Constitution of India and this
Court vide its order dated 06.08.2024 had disposed off the
petition, whereby the matter was remanded back to the learned
Trial Court
for an adjudication with respect to the prayer for
demolition of construction qua the construction raised after
passing of the interim order dated 24.05.2016 by the learned
Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Kullu, District Kullu, H.P.
21.
Finally, vide its order dated 26.10.2024 learned Civil
Judge, Kullu, District Kullu, H.P. rejected the application and the
prayer of the petitioner for demolition of construction being raised
by the respondent has been declined.
22.
Feeling dissatisfied
against the impugned order
dated 26.10.2024, the present petition has been filed by the
plaintiffs/petitioners.
23.
I have heard Mr. B.L.Soni, Advocate, assisted by
Mr. Nitin Soni, Advocate, for the petitioners and Mr. Tara Singh
Chauhan, Senior Advocate assisted by Mr. Surya Chauhan,
Advocate, for the respondent and gone through the case file.
24.
It was contended by learned counsel for the
petitioner that learned Trial Court has erred in dismissing the
application filed by the plaintiffs/petitioners for implementation of
the order dated 05.08.2016. He has further submitted that once it
has been pleaded and proved that there is violation of the Court
orders,
especially
injunction
orders,
then
the
necessary
consequences which follow are that the construction in question
is liable to be demolished.
25.
On the other hand, Sh. Tara Singh Chauhan, Senior
Advocate, assisted by Mr. Surya Chauhan, Advocate, submitted
that the learned Civil Judge, Kullu, District Kullu, H.P. after due
application of mind and appreciating the oral or documentary
evidence on record, has rightly passed the order. He has further
contended that while exercising power under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, this Court will not interfere with the
impugned order.
26.
From perusal of the record, it is clear that the plaintiff
has filed a suit for permanent prohibitory and mandatory
injunction. The suit is at the initial stage and parties have yet to
lead evidence in support of their respective contentions. On
asking a specific query from the learned counsel for the
petitioners, this Court has been apprised that no application
under Order 39 Rule 2-A for disobedience of the injunction order
was ever filed by the present petitioner for the reasons best
known to them.
27.
The prayer which the present petitioners is seeking
in the present proceedings is that the construction which has
been raised by the respondent in violation to the Court orders
should be demolished. In the opinion of this Court, from perusal
of the copy of the plaint, it is clear that this is the main relief as
claimed by the plaintiff in the suit.
28.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in its various decisions has
held that interim relief cannot be granted to a party in the guise of
the final relief. Both parties have yet to prove their respective
cases by leading cogent and authentic evidence to substantiate
their rival contentions.
29.
The petitioners have raised a specific contention that
despite the passing of the injunction order, the respondent has
violated the same and has raised the construction. On the other
hand, the respondent has refuted all the contentions raised by
the present petitioners. Meaning thereby, this is a question of
fact which has to be proved by leading independent witnesses.
The parties are yet to establish their case and, in case,
hypothetically the application of the petitioners is allowed, at this
stage, that will virtually amount to decreeing the
suit of the
plaintiff at the threshold. Such relief in the guise of final relief
cannot be granted to the plaintiffs/petitioners, at this stage.
30.
The allegations of the disobedience and violation
have to be proved by leading cogent evidence and same can be
proved or disproved by leading independent evidence of the
respective parties. Therefore, the learned Civil Judge, Kullu,
District Kullu, H.P. has rightly come to the conclusion that prayer
for demolition of the construction, seizing of the construction
material and sending him to Civil imprisonment are premature
and all these reliefs can be granted on final determination of the
Civil Suit, if proved.
31.
The Hon’ble Apex Court, in Civil Appeal No. 5784 of
2022, titled My Palace Mutually Aided Co-operative Society
vs. Mahesh & others, decided on 23.08.2022, has held as
under:
“26.
Section 151 of the CPC provides for
Civil Courts to invoke their inherent jurisdiction
and utilize the same to meet the ends of justice
or to prevent abuse of process. Although such a
provision is worded broadly, this Court has
tempered the provision to limit its ambit to only
those circumstances where certain procedural
gaps exist, to ensure that substantive justice is
not obliterated by hyper technicalities. As far
back as in 1961, this Court in Padam Sen v.
State of U.P., AIR 1961 SC 218, observed as
under:
“8. …The inherent powers of the Court
are in addition to the powers specifically
conferred on the Court by the Code.
They are complementary to those powers
and therefore it must be held that the
Court is free to exercise them for the
purposes mentioned in Section 151 of
the Code when the exercise of those
powers is not in any way in conflict with
what has been expressly provided in the
Code or against the intentions of the
Legislature. It is also well recognized that
the inherent power is not to be exercised
in a manner which will be contrary to or
different from the procedure expressly
provided in the Code.” (emphasis
supplied)
27.
In exercising powers under
Section 151 of the CPC, it cannot be said that
the civil courts can exercise substantive
jurisdiction to unsettle already decided issues.
A Court having jurisdiction over the relevant
subject matter has the power to decide and
may come either to a right or a wrong
conclusion. Even if a wrong conclusion is
arrived at or an incorrect decree is passed by
the jurisdictional court, the same is binding on
the parties until it is set aside by an appellate
court or through other remedies provided in
law.
28.
Section 151 of the CPC can only
be applicable if there is no alternate remedy
available in accordance with the existing
provisions of law. Such inherent power cannot
override statutory prohibitions or create
remedies which are not contemplated under
the Code. Section 151 cannot be invoked as
an alternative to filing fresh suits, appeals,
revisions, or reviews. A party cannot find
solace in Section 151 to allege and rectify
historic wrongs and bypass procedural
safeguards inbuilt in the CPC.”
32.
Learned Counsel for the petitioners has relied upon
the judgment, in case titled Delhi Development Authority
vs. Skipper Construction Co. (P) Ltd. & Another ( 1996
(4) SCC 622), decided on 06.05.1996.
33.
In the opinion of this Court, this judgment does not
help the petitioners. Though, it is well settled law that no one
should be allowed to defy or violate the Court orders as the
majesty of the Court orders has to be upheld, but at the same
time, it is also settled that final relief cannot be granted to a party
that too in an application filed under Section 151 of CPC, in a
routine manner.
34.
In the opinion of this Court, the learned Civil Judge,
Kullu, District Kullu, H.P. has rightly decided the application vide
its order dated 26.10.2024 and there is no error or infirmity in the
same. Consequently, this petition being devoid of any merit is
liable to be dismissed. Ordered accordingly.
35.
It is made clear that since the injunction order which
was passed by the learned Civil Judge, Kullu, District Kullu, H.P.
on 24.05.2016 was confirmed on 05.08.2016, therefore, during
the pendency of the suit, respondent shall not raise any
construction over the suit land in defiance or in violation of the
said order.
36.
The present petition stands dismissed, in the
aforesaid terms. All pending miscellaneous application(s), if any,
shall also stand disposed off, accordingly.
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
March 2, 2026
(Nisha)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review