Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 13th March, 2026
%
+
CS(COMM) 681/2024
KENT RO SYSTEMS LTD & ANR.
.....Plaintiffs
Through: Mr. Kumar Chitranshu and Mr. Ansh
Sharma, Advocates.
versus
KANCHAN SINGH & ORS.
Through:
parte.
.....Defendants
Defendants No. 1, 2 and 4 are ex
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE JYOTI SINGH
JUDGEMENT
JYOTI SINGH, J. (ORAL)
1.
Present suit is instituted by the Plaintiffs seeking decree of permanent
injunction restraining the Defendants and all others acting on their behalf
from manufacturing, selling, offering for sale, advertising and/or directly or
indirectly dealing in any goods under Plaintiffs’ trademark KENT or any
other mark which is identical to or deceptively similar thereto, amongst
other reliefs.
2.
As per the plaint, Defendants No.1, 2 and 4 are various entities which
were selling infringing products on e-commerce platform IndiaMart/
Defendant No. 3. By ex parte ad interim order dated 12.08.2024, Court
restrained the Defendants from manufacturing, selling etc., any goods under
Plaintiffs’ mark KENT and/or any mark deceptively similar thereto and/or
goods which infringed Plaintiffs’ registered design no. 312406. Defendant
No. 3 was represented on the said date and summons were issued to the
remaining Defendants. On 04.11.2024, it was recorded that Defendants
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
No.1, 2 and 4 were served with summons but there was no appearance on
their behalf and that Defendant No. 3 had complied with the directions
passed by the Court. By order dated 18.09.2025, right of Defendants No.1, 2
and 4 to file written statements was closed since no written statements were
filed within the maximum permissible period.
3.
On 21.11.2025, Court decreed the suit qua Defendant No. 3 in terms
of prayer clause 92 (d) and (e) of the plaint. Plaintiffs sought time to seek
instructions with respect to prosecuting the suit qua Defendants No.1, 2 and
4 since they had not joined proceedings despite service. On 24.12.2025,
counsel for the Plaintiffs submitted that the suit be disposed of qua
Defendants No.1, 2 and 4 limited to relief of permanent injunction and
Plaintiffs will not press the remaining reliefs. Defendant No. 5 being John
Doe was deleted from array of parties and since none appeared for
Defendants No.1, 2 and 4 they were set ex parte and the suit was listed for
disposal. Amended memo of parties was filed by the Plaintiffs and original
Defendants No.1, 2 and 4 were arrayed as Defendants No.1, 2 and 3.
4.
It is the case of the Plaintiffs that Plaintiff No. 1 is one of the leading
companies in India engaged in business of manufacture and sale of diverse
range of home electronic items like water purifiers, air purifiers, kitchen
appliances, vacuum cleaners, water softeners, automatic water pressure
boosting systems, CCTV Cameras etc., under the trademark KENT. Plaintiff
No. 2 adopted the mark KENT in 1988 and while initially it was conducting
the business of oil meters, it subsequently expanded its footprint in various
other segments such as water purifiers, air purifiers, kitchen appliances etc.,
and the said entity assigned its trademark KENT under various classes in
favour of Plaintiff No. 2 vide Assignment Deed dated 02.07.2007.
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
5.
It is stated that in 1999, Plaintiff No. 2 launched the revolutionary
Reverse Osmosis (‘RO’) based domestic water purifier in the Indian market
under the trademark KENT and was also granted a patent, which has now
expired. RO is a technology validated by UNESCO and certified by
organizations such as NFS International, Water Quality Association, TUV
SUD America Inc. and ISO. In 1999, Plaintiff No. 2 also founded a firm M/s
Kent RO Systems with a vision of providing pure and healthy drinking
water in Indian homes. In 2007, Plaintiff No. 2 incorporated Plaintiff No. 1,
which took over the business of M/s Kent RO Systems, including its assets
and liabilities and expanded the business under the mark KENT and since
then mark KENT has been extensively and continuously used and currently
Plaintiff No. 1 has a team of about 5000 employees supporting in developing
the new technology of its products and serving customers throughout the
world.
6.
It is stated that Plaintiff No. 2 is the registered proprietor of trademark
KENT and other entities including Plaintiff No. 1 are conducting businesses
by virtue of license granted by Plaintiff No. 2. The registrations obtained by
Plaintiff No. 2, which are valid and subsisting are as follows:-
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
7.
It is stated that Plaintiffs have also registered their domain names
kentrosystems.com
and
https://www.kent.co.in/
on
19.03.2021
and
03.02.2006, respectively. Since 1988, Plaintiffs have extensively sold their
products under mark KENT and the increasing sales turnover establish the
measure of public reaction, reputation and goodwill acquired by the
Plaintiffs. Details of sales of Plaintiff No. 1’s products under the mark
KENT are as follows:-
8.
It is stated that Plaintiffs have invested time, effort and money in
promoting their products under KENT apart from incurring huge costs on
endorsement of their products by various celebrities such as Mr. Shahrukh
Khan, Ms. Hema Malini, Ms. Esha Deol, Mr. Boman Irani. Advertisements
have been released on various TV channels including Sony, Star, Zee TV as
also published in print media including leading newspapers such as Times of
India, Economic Times and Hindustan Times. Plaintiff No. 1 is the principal
sponsor of almost all news channels during Prime Time (07:00 PM to 10:00
PM) such as Aajtak, ABP News, Times Now, Republic Bharat etc. Plaintiff
No. 1 was associate sponsor of ICC Cricket World Cup and has also
sponsored numerous IPLs, ODIs and Test matches. Plaintiff No. 1 has
received several awards for its excellent quality such as Best Domestic
Purifier by UNESCO, The Golden Peacock Award, Excellence Award by
Institute of Economic Studies, Distinguished Water Purifier-Reverse
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
Osmosis Award by UNESCO, Indian Home Award, 2012, India’s Most
Trusted Water Purifier Brand, to name a few. Advertisement and
promotional figures from 2018-2019 to 2022-2023 are as follows:-
9.
It is stated that trademark KENT has been declared as well-known
trademark by this Court in CS (OS) 1626/2014 titled ‘Kent RO Systems Ltd.
v. Kentech Technology & Ors.’, and is published in the list of well-known
marks in Trade Marks Journal No. 2110 on 26.06.2023. Plaintiffs have
diligently protected their statutory and common law rights in KENT and this
Court has granted interim injunctions in many matters, details of which are
furnished in the plaint. All this reflects that Plaintiffs’ products under KENT
command a substantive market and are associated exclusively with the
Plaintiffs.
10.
It is stated that Plaintiffs have obtained design registration in respect
of the aesthetic appearance of the water purification systems. In particular,
Plaintiff No. 2 has been granted design registration no. 312406 on
26.11.2018, as follows:-
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
11.
It is stated that the said design registration was granted with the
following statement of novelty: “The Novelty resides in the shape and
configuration of WATER PURIFIER, particularly as portion marked in
‘A’ and ‘B’ in Sheet 1-8”. Design registration has been licensed to
Plaintiff No. 1 by Plaintiff No. 2 and is valid and in force. Plaintiffs
launched the purifier in a shape which was covered by design no. 312406
under the mark KENT GRAND + (New) in 2019, whereafter the ZERO
WATER WASTAGE technology was introduced and it came to be known
as KENT GRAND+ ZWW. The new technology involves pushing the
rejected water in the system back to the overhead tank thereby rendering
water wastage to almost zero and hence, instead of wasting the rejected
water, its get diluted and is reused as normal tap water for household
purposes.
12.
It is stated that around April-May, 2024, Plaintiffs received
complaints from its consumers and field forces that several water
purifier systems bearing mark KENT or having same shape as of design no.
312406 were being sold on Defendant No. 3. Investigation revealed that
Defendants No.1 and 3 were using mark KENT for their water purifier
albeit labelled as KENT RO WATER PURIFIER FOR HOME,
KENT WATER PURIFIER, KENT COMPLETE MACHINE RO AQUA
CANDY
FOR HOME, KENT
RO+UV
AQUAGUARD
WATER
PURIFIER. In addition, Defendant No. 2 was manufacturing, assembling
and selling water purifiers which were replica of Plaintiffs’ KENT
GRAND+ ZWW and also infringing design no. 312406 to create an
association with Plaintiffs’ products. Screenshots of some of the infringing
products are as follows:-
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
13.
Learned counsel for the Plaintiffs submits that Defendants are
engaged in the business of selling water purifiers using the registered KENT
marks of the Plaintiffs and the design of their water purifiers is an exact
copy of Plaintiffs’ registered design no. 312406. Defendants have attempted
to come as close as possible to Plaintiffs’ product by using identical colour
palate and arrangement of the logo, with an intent to ride upon and encash
their hard earned reputation and goodwill. The extent of dishonesty is
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
evident from the fact that Defendants have even adopted mark AQUA
GRAND+ for selling water purifiers, which is visually, structurally and
phonetically deceptively similar to Plaintiffs’ KENT GRAND+ ZWW, a
mark coined and invented by the Plaintiffs and being arbitrary and fanciful
has a degree of protection. A comparison of similarities between the rival
designs reflects that no stone has been left unturned to copy the registered
design of the Plaintiffs. Defendants have never taken any license or
permission to use the mark KENT and/or the registered design of the
Plaintiffs. Registration in the mark KENT grants statutory rights to the
Plaintiffs to protect its mark as also to use it exclusively. The rival marks are
identical/deceptively similar and the goods are identical. The trade channels
and consumers being common, confusion amongst members of public and
consumers is inevitable and thus Defendants are infringing Plaintiffs’
well-known KENT trademark under Section 29 of the Trade Marks Act,
1999 (‘1999 Act’) as also Plaintiffs’ registered designs, which can be seen
from the comparative features brought forth in the plaint. In this backdrop, it
is prayed that the suit be decreed granting permanent injunction in favour of
the Plaintiffs and against Defendants.
14.
Heard learned counsel for the Plaintiffs.
15.
Plaintiff No. 2 is the registered proprietor of trademark KENT and its
formative marks and the registrations are valid and subsisting. KENT has
been declared as a well-known trademark by this Court and is included in
the list of well-known trademarks in the Trade Marks Journal. As per the
case set out by the Plaintiffs in the plaint and supported by documents, they
have earned formidable goodwill and reputation by sale of products under
the mark KENT, more particularly, water purifiers with a special technology
of RO, which is evidenced by the sales turnover over the years. Substantial
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
expenditure is incurred by the Plaintiffs in advertising and promoting the
products under KENT, which is substantiated by the document on record.
Several awards have been received by the Plaintiffs and their RO technology
is validated by UNESCO and certified by organizations such as NFS
International, Water Quality Association, TUV SUD America Inc. and ISO.
Many celebrities have endorsed the KENT purifier and as brought forth in
the plaint, Plaintiffs have sponsored many IPL, ODI and Test matches and
are sponsors on many prime TV channels. Plaintiffs design in the KENT
water purifier is registered under design no. 312406 dated 26.11.2018,
where the novelty resides in shape and configuration of the water purifier.
16.
There is no gainsaying that since Plaintiff No.2 has registrations in
trademark KENT and its formative marks and Plaintiff No.1 is the
authorised and permitted user, they are entitled to exclusive use of the marks
and restrain third parties from infringement by virtue of Section 28 of the
1999 Act. KENT has been declared as a well-known mark and is entitled to
a high degree of protection. Comparison of Plaintiffs’ trademark KENT with
the impugned marks KENT RO WATER PURIFIER FOR HOME, KENT
WATER PURIFIER, KENT COMPLETE MACHINE RO AQUA CANDY
FOR HOME, KENT RO+UV AQUAGUARD WATER PURIFIER, leaves
no doubt that the impugned marks are deceptively similar to Plaintiffs’
KENT marks. Since the impugned marks are deceptively similar and are
used by Defendants for identical goods i.e., water purifiers, there is every
likelihood of confusion amongst the members of public and potential
consumers, trade channels and consumers being common. Written
statements have not been filed by the Defendants and thus the averments in
the plaint and the contents of accompanying documents are uncontroverted
and deemed to be admitted. It is thus held that Defendants’ use of KENT
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
mark in respect of water purifier amounts to infringement under Section 29
of the 1999 Act.
17.
Plaintiff No. 2 has registration in the water purifier and certificate of
registration shows that registration was granted with a statement that novelty
resides in the shape and configuration of the water purifier. Registration has
been licensed to Plaintiff No. 1 by Plaintiff No. 2 and is in force. From the
averments in the plaint and the documents filed therewith, it can be seen that
Plaintiffs’ design has a transparent upper half and an opaque lower half. Top
portion of the design contains a stepped construction and the middle portion
has a wave like pattern and an inverted-truncated frustum shape. Upper and
lower half are separated by a prominent belt and lower half bears a concave
depression wherein water indicator and water tap are placed. Edges of the
lower half are curved with the flat bottom and the features have an aesthetic
appeal with no functionality. It is brought out by the Plaintiffs that after the
application was filed for design registration, objections were raised by the
Controller of Designs which included the objection that the design was not
novel in view of a prior art. This position was successfully defended by
Plaintiff No. 2 and the design thereafter proceeded to registration. By virtue
of design registration, Plaintiffs enjoy the monopoly to commercialize the
same and to restrain third parties from copying. Comparison of Plaintiffs’
design with Defendant No. 2’s product is as follows:-
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
18.
The similarities between the rival designs have been elaborately
brought out in the plaint and can be diagrammatically demonstrated as
follows:-
19.
From a comparison of the rival designs, it is easily discernable that
transparent upper half and opaque lower half, stepped construction at the top
of its transparent half, a protruding step-like feature, the upper and lower
half separated by a prominent belt, the lower half of the design bearing a
concave depression wherein the water indicator and water tap are placed, are
all copied by the Defendant including the edges of the lower half portion,
which are curved with a flat bottom. The dishonesty in adoption of the
design and the marks is further substantiated by the fact that Defendants
have adopted the name AQUA GRAND+ on the water purifiers, which is
deceptively similar to KENT GRAND+ ZWW.
20.
Defendants have chosen to stay away from the proceedings and did
not appear despite service and were set ex parte. No steps were taken for
setting aside the ex parte order and Defendants never joined the proceedings
thereafter. It is thus clear that Defendants are not interested in contesting the
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
suit. Written statements were not filed and right to file the same stands
closed. This order was also not challenged and hence, there is no real
prospect of defending the claims of the Plaintiffs in these circumstances and
Plaintiffs are held entitled to a decree in their favour.
21.
Accordingly, this suit is decreed in favour of the Plaintiffs and against
the Defendants in terms of paragraph 92 (a), (b) and (c) of the plaint since
Plaintiffs have given up the remaining reliefs.
22.
Registry is directed to draw up the decree sheet.
23.
Suit stands disposed of.
JYOTI SINGH, J
MARCH 13, 2026/AK
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:32:12
CS(COMM) 681/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review