The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. 360); (ii) As per the undertaking of NHIDCL, around 135 heritage trees falling (in) the right of way will be saved in pursuance of the understanding reached between all the stakeholders between the Chainage stretch of 6130-7360; (iii) As and when the need arises, the user agency/concerned authority can approach the State Government for seeking approval for laying down utility infrastructure like water pipeline and telephone lines, etc., through reserved forest in terms of general approval of the Government of India under the Forest Conservation Act, 1980 and MoEF and CC guidelines for the stated public utility projects; (iv) Transplantation of certain non-heritage trees is not a viable solution since it appears to be costly and cumbersome. Therefore the HPC is of the view that compensatory afforestation and strip plantation may be adopted as an effective and viable solution; and (v) The Highway expansion project should be completed at the earliest in public interest without cutting the heritage trees as discussed above.” Thereafter, on 9th August, 2021, upon hearing the parties, we were of the view that another round of deliberation was required by the 5(five) Member High Powered Committee (HPC) in order to resolve the issues centering around this PIL. The result of such deliberation, in the form of minutes of meeting of the High Powered Committee (HPC) dated 29th September, 20…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.03
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
PIL No.7/2021
Date of Order: 30.09.2021
Kaustav Paul
Coram:
Vs.
Union of India & ors
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Biswanath Somadder, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
: In-person
: Dr. N Mozika, ASG
Mr. A Kumar, Advocate General with
Ms. R. Colney, GA
Mr. R Deb Nath, CGC for R/10
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
When the matter is taken up for hearing, the learned Senior
Advocate who appears in-person in this Public Interest Litigation (PIL),
draws our attention to the minutes of the meeting of the High Powered
Committee (HPC) dated 29th September, 2021. For convenience, the entire
minutes of the said meeting of the High Powered Committee (HPC) is
setout hereinbelow:-
“MINUTES OF MEETING
MEETING OF THE HIGH POWERED COMMITTEE
Dated 29th September, 2021.
All members of the High Powered Committee were present in the
meeting held on 29.9.2021. The list of the members present in the
meeting is enumerated below:
i. Shri Amit Kumar, Advocate General;
ii. Shri Kaustav Paul, Senior Advocate (Petitioner in person);
iii. Col. Narendra Sheoran, Executive Director (P), NHIDCL,
Regional Office, Shillong;
iv. Shri M.B.K. Reddy, IFS (Addl. Principal Chief Conservator of
Forest (T); and
v. Shri Jiwat Vaswani, Environmentalist and Hotelier & Owner
of M/s Jiva Hospitality.
The meeting of the High Power Committee (HPC) constituted
vide order of the Hon’ble High Court of Meghalaya dated
30.6.2021 in PIL No. 7/2021 was held today i.e. 29.09.2021 at
12.30 PM in the office of learned Advocate General.
The meeting was held to discuss the issue concerning 20 or more
trees falling in Chainage Stretch between 5.6 to 5.8.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior Advocate and Mr. Jiwat Vaswani,
Environmentalist suggested that if the road can be shifted by 3
meters on the right hand side, all trees can be saved.
Col. Narendra Sheoran, Executive Director (P), NHIDCL,
Regional Office, Shillong apprised the Committee Members that
there are large number of difficulties in shifting right of way by 3
meters. He submitted that the following difficulties would arise:
(a) The alignment of road by shifting the right of way by 3 meters
shall necessarily involve diversion of land in Upper Shillong
which is part of protected/reserved forest;
(b) This would necessarily entail user agency to obtain a fresh
forest clearance under Forest Conservation Act and it would
involve taking clearance right from the start. This would also
involve clearance by State Forest Department and Ministry of
Forest Environment and Climate Change, Govt. of India;
(c) User agency will further be required to change proposals for
compensatory afforestation etc.;
(d) He also submitted that earlier clearance was obtained by user
agency by going through the rigorous process and it took almost 2
years;
(e) It was also stated that project would be adversely affected
which would delay the project and it would also lead to cost
escalation also;
(f) It is also likely to affect the speed at which vehicle can travel
in this stretch. He also emphasised that in this stretch as against
the requirement of 60 meters Right of Way for construction of a 4
lane highway, only 24 meters right of way has been acquired due
to many constraints. Due this even median width has been
reduced to 0.61 meters against requirement of 2.5 meters. He,
therefore, submitted that it is not worthwhile to save 20 trees
which are not of the same nature which have already been saved
by shifting the utility lines;
Shri M.B.K. Reddy, IFS (Addl. Principal Chief Conservator of
Forest (T) also endorsed the views of Col. Narendra Sheoran by
stating that clearance would be required under the Forest Act
including clearance from Ministry of Forest, Environment and
Climate Change, Government of India and it is a time consuming
process.
In view of the above issue, Members felt that the above said
report be placed before the Hon’ble High Court on 30.09.2021.
(Kaustav Paul)
(Senior Advocate)
(Col. Narendra Sheoran)
(Executive Director (P), NHIDCL,
Regional Office, Shillong)
(Amit Kumar)
(Advocate General)
(Shri M.B.K. Reddy, IFS)
(Addl. Principal Chief
Conservator of Forest (T)
(Shri Jiwat Vaswani)
(Environmentalist and Hotelier &
Owner of M/s Jiva Hospitality)”
The issue in this PIL centres around cutting/felling of trees (some
of which are of considerable heritage) for the purpose of widening of
National Highway 40, which connects Shillong to Dawki (commonly
referred to as the Shillong-Dawki road), particularly in the vicinity of the
Eastern Air Command. By our order dated 30th June, 2021, we had
constituted a 5(five) member High Powered Committee (HPC), which were
directed to look into the specific grievances as sought to be highlighted in
the instant PIL. A comprehensive report was directed to be submitted by the
High Powered Committee (HPC), after conducting a thorough and detailed
enquiry with regard to the issue as highlighted and upon inspection of the
actual site. Further observations/directions are contained in our order dated
30th June, 2021. A report was thereafter prepared by the High Powered
Committee (HPC) on 21st July, 2021, which was submitted before this
Court and was duly taken note of in our order dated 22 nd July, 2021. The
following conclusion arrived at by the High Powered Committee (HPC) for
resolution of the issue centering around this PIL was taken note of by this
Court on 22nd July, 2021:“(i) NHIDCL has agreed in terms of its undertaking to execute the
project for expansion of NH 40 (Shillong to Dawki) without
cutting any heritage tree (between Chainage km 6.590 to km
7.360);
(ii) As per the undertaking of NHIDCL, around 135 heritage trees
falling (in) the right of way will be saved in pursuance of the
understanding reached between all the stakeholders between the
Chainage stretch of 6130-7360;
(iii) As and when the need arises, the user agency/concerned
authority can approach the State Government for seeking approval
for laying down utility infrastructure like water pipeline and
telephone lines, etc., through reserved forest in terms of general
approval of the Government of India under the Forest
Conservation Act, 1980 and MoEF and CC guidelines for the
stated public utility projects;
(iv) Transplantation of certain non-heritage trees is not a viable
solution since it appears to be costly and cumbersome. Therefore
the HPC is of the view that compensatory afforestation and strip
plantation may be adopted as an effective and viable solution; and
(v) The Highway expansion project should be completed at the
earliest in public interest without cutting the heritage trees as
discussed above.”
Thereafter, on 9th August, 2021, upon hearing the parties, we were
of the view that another round of deliberation was required by the 5(five)
Member High Powered Committee (HPC) in order to resolve the issues
centering around this PIL. The result of such deliberation, in the form of
minutes of meeting of the High Powered Committee (HPC) dated 29th
September, 2021, is now before us and has been set out at the outset.
After perusing the said minutes of the High Powered Committee
(HPC), we are of the view that there is an imperative necessity for
realignment of the road by shifting right of way by three (3) meters for a
stretch of 200 meters only. This endeavour is required to be done only in
order to protect the environment and conservation of the trees (some of
which are of considerable heritage). It cannot be said that this action will
compromise with the development/expansion of the road project, which is
for a total length of approximately 72 Kms. Here we are concerned with a
stretch of 200 meters only. The Executive Director (P), National Highways
& Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd. (NHIDCL) has highlighted
a few difficulties, which are duly recorded in the minutes of the High
Powered Committee (HPC) dated 29th September, 2021. However, we do
not consider these difficulties to be of such an insurmountable nature,
which would weigh in favour of felling of the heritage trees that fall within
the stretch of 200 meters or for that matter, compromising with the
environment, particularly when the total development/expansion of the road
project is for a considerable length of about 72 Kms.
For a fresh forest clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act
which is required to be obtained for this limited purpose, the learned
Assistant Solicitor General shall impress upon the concerned Ministry to
issue such clearance within a period of four weeks from date. Similarly, we
would also request the learned Advocate General to ensure that necessary
clearance is facilitated by the State Forest Department within a similar
period of time. If other clearances are required to be obtained from the
Ministry of Forest Environment and Climate Change, Government of India,
the learned Assistant Solicitor General shall use his good office to ensure
that those clearances are also obtained within a period of four weeks from
date. Once all clearances are obtained in terms of this order, the process of
realignment shall be completed by the National Highways & Infrastructure
Development Corporation Ltd. (NHIDCL) within a period of six weeks
therefrom.
The above time specific directions are issued by us only because
the Executive Director (P), National Highways & Infrastructure
Development Corporation Ltd. (NHIDCL), has apprehensively stated that
earlier clearance was obtained by the user agency by going through a
rigorous process and it took almost two years. We do not find the excuse of
time consuming process as a justifiable reason in order to compromise with
protection of our environment and conservation of heritage trees. In view of
our specific directions, we do not expect that there would be any delay in
obtaining necessary clearances from the appropriate authorities, as
apprehended by the Executive Director (P), National Highways &
Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd. (NHIDCL), Regional Office,
Shillong.
The writ petition stands disposed of accordingly.
(H.S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
30.09.2021
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review