The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. The Court is, therefore, of the considered view that no case of jurisdictional error, perversity, or manifest injustice is made out so as to warrant interference under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. In view of the foregoing discussion and reasons recorded hereinabove, the writ petition fails and is accordingly dismissed. The interim order dated 21.07.2022, as extended from time to time during the pendency of the writ petition, stands vacated. No order as to costs. (Ashish Naithani J.) Dated:08.01.2026 Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1706 of 2022 -----Smt. Kaushalya Bansal and another Vs. Shri Sharad Kumar Gupta and others - Ashish Naithani J.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:326
Judgment Reserved on: 16.12.2025
Judgment Pronounced on:08.01.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND
AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition (M/S) No.1706 of 2022
Smt. Kaushalya Bansal and another
......Petitioners
Vs.
Shri Sharad Kumar Gupta and others
…..Respondents
Presence:
Mr. Piyush Garg, learned counsel for the Petitioners.
Mr. Neeraj Garg, learned counsel for the Caveator.
Hon’ble Ashish Naithani, J.
1.
The present writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India has been instituted by the Petitioners, who are tenants of a shop
situated at Jhanda Chowk, Rishikesh, District Dehradun, assailing the
orders passed by the Prescribed Authority and the appellate authority
under the provisions of the U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972.
2.
The dispute traces its origin to the filing of a release application
by Respondents over the findings recorded by statutory authorities, nor
does it substitute its own view merely because another view is possible.
Interference is warranted only where the order impugned discloses
patent perversity, manifest miscarriage of justice, jurisdictional error, or
a failure to consider material evidence.
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1706 of 2022 -----Smt. Kaushalya Bansal and another Vs. Shri Sharad Kumar Gupta and
others -
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:326
3.
In the release application, Respondent No.1 asserted that the shop
in question was originally let out to the predecessor of the Petitioners
and that after the demise of the original tenant, the tenancy devolved
upon the Petitioners and the pro forma respondents. It was further
pleaded that pursuant to a partition decree, the shop fell in the exclusive
share of Respondent No.1.
4.
Respondent No.1 pleaded that although he owns a hotel and
certain other properties, the same are either old constructions,
commercially unviable, or unsuitable for the proposed business. It was
specifically pleaded that for running a furniture and interior business, a
larger consolidated space was required and that the shop in question
was essential for such purpose.
5.
The Petitioners filed detailed objections to the release
application, disputing the alleged bona fide need. They asserted that
Respondent No.1 is in possession of multiple commercial properties,
including a hotel building having several shops, open land near GMVN
guest house, and other commercial spaces which are either vacant or
recently let out, thereby negating any genuine necessity.
6.
The Petitioners also pleaded that the son of Respondent No.1 is
permanently settled abroad and has no intention of returning to India
for carrying on any business, and that the release application was a
mere pretext to evict the tenants.
7.
Upon appreciation of evidence, the Prescribed Authority allowed
the release application. The appeal preferred by the Petitioners under
Section 22 of the Act was dismissed by the appellate authority,
affirming the findings regarding bona fide need and comparative
hardship.
8.
Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioners invoked the supervisory
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1706 of 2022 -----Smt. Kaushalya Bansal and another Vs. Shri Sharad Kumar Gupta and
others -
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:326
An interim order was granted on 21.07.2022 protecting the Petitioners
from dispossession, subject to deposit of use and occupation charges,
which interim protection continued during the pendency of the writ
petition.
9.
Learned counsel for the Petitioners assailed the impugned orders
with considerable emphasis and submitted that the findings recorded by
the Prescribed Authority and the appellate authority are vitiated by nonconsideration of material evidence and by misapplication of the settled
principles governing bona fide requirement.
10.
It was argued that Respondent No.1 admittedly owns and controls
several commercial properties, including a hotel building with multiple
shops, open commercial land, and other business premises, some of
which are either vacant or have been recently let out. According to
learned counsel, such conduct is wholly inconsistent with a plea of
bona fide need.
11.
Learned counsel further contended that the alleged proposed
business is illusory. It was submitted that Respondent No.1 himself is
not carrying on any such business and his only son is permanently
settled abroad with no intention to return. The plea of future business
requirement was contended to be speculative and unsupported by any
concrete material.
12.
It was also argued that the authorities below failed to correctly
assess comparative hardship. Learned counsel submitted that the
Petitioners are long standing tenants dependent on the shop for their
livelihood, whereas Respondent No.1 has multiple alternative sources
of income and accommodation.
13.
Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondents supported the
impugned orders and submitted that both the authorities below have
returned concurrent findings of fact after due appreciation of evidence.
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1706 of 2022 -----Smt. Kaushalya Bansal and another Vs. Shri Sharad Kumar Gupta and
others -
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:326
It was contended that the adequacy or sufficiency of accommodation
cannot be dictated by the tenant and that the landlord is the best judge
of his requirement.
14.
Learned counsel for the Respondents further submitted that the
availability of other properties does not ipso facto disentitle a landlord
from seeking release if those properties are unsuitable for the intended
purpose. It was argued that the findings recorded are neither perverse
nor based on irrelevant considerations.
15.
It was lastly contended that the jurisdiction of this Court under
Article 227 is supervisory and not appellate, and that the Petitioners are
seeking a reappreciation of evidence, which is impermissible in such
proceedings.
16.
Heard learned counsel for the Parties and perused the records.
17.
In the present case, the Prescribed Authority as well as the
appellate authority have concurrently recorded findings on the issues of
bona fide requirement and comparative hardship. These findings are
based upon pleadings, documentary evidence, and oral submissions
advanced before them.
18.
A perusal of the impugned orders reflects that the plea of bona
fide need set up by Respondent No.1 has been examined in detail. The
authorities have taken note of the nature of the business proposed, the
requirement of space for such business, and the explanation furnished
by the landlord regarding the alleged alternative accommodations.
19.
It is settled law that the landlord is the best judge of his
requirement. The tenant cannot dictate to the landlord as to how and
where he should carry on his business, nor can the Court compel the
landlord to adjust himself in a manner contrary to his stated
requirement, unless the plea is shown to be a mere pretext or
demonstrably mala fide.
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1706 of 2022 -----Smt. Kaushalya Bansal and another Vs. Shri Sharad Kumar Gupta and
others -
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:326
20.
Insofar as the argument regarding availability of alternative
properties is concerned, the authorities below have not brushed aside
this contention cursorily. The impugned orders reflect a conscious
consideration of the nature, location, and suitability of the other
properties relied upon by the Petitioners. Mere ownership of other
properties does not, by itself, negate bona fide requirement, particularly
when the landlord furnishes reasons as to their unsuitability for the
intended purpose.
21.
The contention that the proposed business is speculative or
illusory has also been examined by the authorities below. The plea of
bona fide requirement does not mandate that the landlord must already
be engaged in the proposed business. A genuine intention to commence
business, supported by surrounding circumstances, is sufficient. The
findings recorded in this regard cannot be said to be arbitrary or
unsupported by material.
22.
As
regards comparative hardship, the impugned orders
demonstrate that the authorities have weighed the respective hardships
of the parties. The length of tenancy, dependence of the Petitioners on
the shop, and the availability of alternative means were considered.
Simultaneously, the requirement of the landlord and the feasibility of
the tenant securing alternative accommodation were also assessed.
23.
Comparative hardship is essentially a question of fact. Unless the
finding is shown to be perverse or based on irrelevant considerations,
this Court would be slow to interfere. The Petitioners have not been
able to demonstrate that any material factor was ignored or that
irrelevant considerations were taken into account.
24.
The submissions advanced on behalf of the Petitioners, when
closely examined, essentially invite this Court to reassess the evidence
and arrive at a different conclusion. Such an exercise would amount to
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1706 of 2022 -----Smt. Kaushalya Bansal and another Vs. Shri Sharad Kumar Gupta and
others -
Ashish Naithani J.
2026:UHC:326
converting the supervisory jurisdiction into an appellate one, which is
impermissible.
25.
The Court is, therefore, of the considered view that no case of
jurisdictional error, perversity, or manifest injustice is made out so as to
warrant interference under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
ORDER
In view of the foregoing discussion and reasons recorded
hereinabove, the writ petition fails and is accordingly dismissed.
The interim order dated 21.07.2022, as extended from time to
time during the pendency of the writ petition, stands vacated.
No order as to costs.
(Ashish Naithani J.)
Dated:08.01.2026
NR
Writ Petition (M/S) No. 1706 of 2022 -----Smt. Kaushalya Bansal and another Vs. Shri Sharad Kumar Gupta and
others -
Ashish Naithani J.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review