Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
****
WRIT PETITION NO: 35896/2025
Between:
1.KATIKALA SHIVABHAGYA RAO, S/O. K.GEORGE AGED ABOUT 65
YEARS, R/O. FLAT NO. 102, ROAD NO. 14, BANJARA HILLS,
HYDERABAD, TELANGANA STATE-500001
...PETITIONER
AND
1.THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY, HOME DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT, VELAGAPUDI,
AMARAVATHI, A.P. 522237
2.THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE,
VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT, A.P. 530001
VISAKHAPATNAM
CITY,
3.THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, DUVVADA POLICE STATION,
VISAKHAPATNAM COMMISSIONERATE, A.P. 530001
4.THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, DWARAKA POLICE STATION,
VISAKHAPATNAM COMMISSIONERATE, A.P. 530001
5.THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, GOPALAPATNAM POLICE
STATION, VISAKHAPATNAM COMMISSIONERATE, A.P. 530001
6.THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, II TOWN POLICE STATION,
VISAKHAPATNAM COMMISSIONERATE, A.P.. 530001
...RESPONDENT(S):
****
DATE OF ORDER PRONOUNCED
:
06.02.2026
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE Y. LAKSHMANA RAO
1. Whether Reporters of Local Newspapers
may be allowed to see the Judgment?
Yes/No
2. Whether the copy of Judgment may be
marked to Law Reporters/Journals?
Yes/No
3. Whether His Lordship wish to see the
fair copy of the Judgment?
Yes/No
_________________________
Dr. Y. LAKSHMANA RAO, J
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
* THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE Y. LAKSHMANA RAO
+ WRIT PETITION NO: 35896/2025
% 06.02.2026
# Between:
1.KATIKALA SHIVABHAGYA RAO, S/O. K.GEORGE AGED ABOUT 65
YEARS, R/O. FLAT NO. 102, ROAD NO. 14, BANJARA HILLS,
HYDERABAD, TELANGANA STATE-500001
...PETITIONER
AND
1.THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY, HOME DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT, VELAGAPUDI,
AMARAVATHI, A.P. 522237
2.THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE,
VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT, A.P. 530001
VISAKHAPATNAM
CITY,
3.THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, DUVVADA POLICE STATION,
VISAKHAPATNAM COMMISSIONERATE, A.P. 530001
4.THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, DWARAKA POLICE STATION,
VISAKHAPATNAM COMMISSIONERATE, A.P. 530001
5.THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, GOPALAPATNAM POLICE
STATION, VISAKHAPATNAM COMMISSIONERATE, A.P. 530001
6.THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, II TOWN POLICE STATION,
VISAKHAPATNAM COMMISSIONERATE, A.P.. 530001
...RESPONDENT(S):
! Counsel for the Petitioners
: Sri N.Subba Rao
^Counsel for the Respondents : Sri P.Ajay Babu
< Gist:
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
> Head Note:
? Cases referred:
1. MANU/TL/2544/2022
2. (2001) 6 SCC 181
3. 2020 SCC OnLine SC 462
4. (2010) 12 SCC 254
5. (2004) 13 SCC 292
6. (2010) 9 SCC 567
7. (2010) 14 SCC 444
8. (2013) 6 SCC 384
9. 2007 SCC OnLine Pat 116
10. 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 1164
11. W.P. No.20132 of 2025, dated 31.01.2026
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE Y. LAKSHMANA RAO
WRIT PETITION NO: 35896/2025
ORDER:
The Writ Petition has been filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India seeking the following relief:“…to issue a Writ order or direction more particularly one in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the Respondents in registering
multiple FIRs vide FIR No 85 of 2025 on the file of Dwaraka Police Station
Visakhapatnam District FIR No 215 of 2025 on the file of Gopalapatnam
Police Station Visakhapatnam District FIR No 222 of 2025 on the file of II
Town Police Station Visakhapatnam District arising out of the same and a
similar offence/incident based on the same set of allegations in FIR No 166
of 2025 dated 22/04/2025 on the file of Duvvada Police Station
Visakhapatnam Commissionerate and not clubbing all FIRs as illegal
arbitrary violation of Principles of Natural Justice violation of Articles 14 and
21 of the Constitution of India and violation of various precedents laid down
by the Honble Apex Court and this Honble Court and consequently direct
the Respondents to club all the pending FIRs registered against the
Petitioner with FIR No 166 of 2025 dated 22/04/2025 on the file of Duvvada
Police Station Visakhapatnam District to ensure fair and thorough
investigation by the single investigation agency and pass….”
2.
The Writ Petition is filed by the Petitioner, aged about 65 years, who has
been arrayed as Accused No.2 in Crime No.166 of 2025, registered on
22.04.2025 at Duvvada Police Station, Visakhapatnam Commissionerate, for
the offences punishable under Sections 406, 411, 414 and 120-B read with
Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for brevity ‘the I.P.C’), and
Sections 21(1), 21(2), 21(3) and 23 of the Banning of Unregulated Deposit
Schemes Act (for brevity ‘the BUDS Act’), and Sections 3 and 4 of the Prize
Chits and Money Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act.
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
3.
At the behest of one Peerubandi Prakasa Rao, the de-facto complainant,
a case in Crime No.85 of 2025 was registered by the Station House Officer,
Dwaraka Police Station, Visakhapatnam Commissionerate, on 01.05.2025 for
the very same offences, namely, under Sections 406, 411, 414 read with
Section 34 of ‘the IPC.,’ and 120-B of ‘the IPC.,’ Sections 21(1), 21(2), 21(3)
and 23 of ‘the BUDS Act.,’ and Sections 3 and 4 of the Prize Chits and Money
Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act (for brevity ‘the PC & MCSBA’), in which
also the petitioner was shown as Accused No.1.
4.
At the behest of Chikati Chiranjeevi Rao, a report was lodged before the
Gopalapatnam
Police
Station,
Visakhapatnam
Commissionerate
on
07.08.2025 as a case in Crime No. 215 of 2025 for offences punishable under
Sections 420, 406, 411, 414 read with Section 34 of ‘the I.P.C.’ 120-B of ‘the
I.P.C.,’ Sections 21(1)(2)(3), 23 of ‘the BUDS Act’, and Sections 3, 4 of ‘the PC
& MCSBA’. This FIR also contained allegations identical to those in the earlier
FIRs, concerning the same alleged irregularities in deposits of the Sneha
MACS Society.
5.
Subsequently, on 03.12.2025, while the Petitioner was released from
custody in FIR No.215 of 2025, he was again arrested and remanded by the
learned Jurisdictional Magistrate on the remand report submitted by the II
Town Police Station, Visakhapatnam Commissionerate, which registered
Crime No.222 of 2025. This FIR was registered with similar allegations under
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
provisions of ‘the I.P.C.,’ ‘the BUDS Act’, and ‘the PC & MCSBA’, again arising
out of the same alleged irregularities in deposits of the Sneha MACS Society.
6.
Sri N.Subba Rao, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of Sri
Bhuvanagiri Subramanya Kumar, learned Counsel for the Petitioner, submits
that all the FIRs registered against the Petitioner and his family members are
based on the same set of allegations concerning alleged irregularities in the
Sneha Mutually Aided Cooperative Society. The complaints are identical in
nature, arising out of one alleged offence/incident, yet multiple FIRs have
been registered at different police stations without any preliminary enquiry.
This multiplicity of FIRs is illegal, arbitrary, and violative of Articles 14 and 21
of the Constitution of India, as well as contrary to the settled precedents of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court which mandate that subsequent complaints on the
same incident must be treated as statements under Section 162 of ‘the
Cr.P.C.,’ and clubbed with the first FIR.
7.
It is further submitted that registering separate FIRs leads to multiplicity
of investigations, conflicting opinions of investigating officers, harassment of
the Petitioner and his family, and prejudice to the cooperative society’s
members
whose
deposits
remain
unsettled
due
to
the
Petitioner’s
incarceration. It is further submitted that the Petitioner is willing to clear dues
by securing funds, but the continuation of multiple criminal cases obstructs
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
resolution. Therefore, the action of the Respondents in registering FIRs
Nos.85, 215, and 222 of 2025 instead of clubbing them with FIR No.166 of
2025 is unconstitutional, violative of principles of natural justice, and
unsustainable in law.
8.
The learned Senior Counsel further submits that the offences alleged in
the four FIRs relate to the very same incident and transaction. Placing reliance
on the judgment of the High Court of Telangana in Akbaruddin Owaisi v.
State of Andhra Pradesh1 which in turn relied upon the decision in T.T.
Antony v. State of Kerala2, it is submitted that registration of a second or
subsequent FIRs in respect of the same transactions, whether for the same or
different offences, is impermissible and violative of Article 21 of the
Constitution of India.
9.
It is furthermore submitted that against the same accused, the same
cooperative society, and arising out of the same transaction, four FIRs have
been registered at the instance of depositors/de-facto complainants.
Investigation has been conducted and material documents and electronic
devices have already been seized. Therefore, it is urged that all complaints
against Sneha MACS Ltd., including any subsequent complaints, be
transferred to Duvvada Police Station in the interest of justice.
MANU/TL/2544/2022
(2001) 6 SCC 181
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
10.
Per Contra, Sri P. Ajay Babu, the learned Assistant Government Pleader
for Home appearing respondent Nos.1 to 6 argued that the cause of action in
the four cases in Crime Nos.215, 222, 166 of 2025 and Crime No.85 of 2025
are entirely different. The place, date and time of the alleged offences are also
different. The gullible depositors who were deceived by the Petitioner and
other accused of Sneha Macs have chosen to lodge reports with the police
stations of their locality. The investigation in the four cases have not at been
completed. Some more material witnesses are to be examined and some
more accused are to be apprehended. The writ petition is not maintainable as
it is misconceived and urged to dismiss the writ petition with costs.
11.
Heard the learned counsel for the Petitioner and the learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Home. Perused the record.
12.
It is opposite to refer to the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in T.T
Antony 2nd supra wherein at para Nos.27, 28 and 35 it is held that the Court
held that while the police have power under Section 173(8) of ‘the Cr.P.C.,’ to
conduct further investigation, registering a second or successive FIR in
respect of the same incident or transaction is impermissible and amounts to
an abuse of the investigative process. Any additional material or findings
ought to be incorporated only by seeking leave of the Court and filing a further
report in the original FIR, and not by initiating a fresh investigation through a
new FIR. Accordingly, the second FIR and the investigation pursuant thereto
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
were quashed, while leaving it open to the investigating agency to seek
permission for further investigation in the earlier cases in accordance with law.
13.
It is further relevant to mentioned that the judgment of Hon’ble Apex
Court in Arnab Ranjan Goswami v. Union of India3 wherein at para Nos.59
and 61.5 it is held that the Court noted that multiple FIRs and complaints were
filed against the Petitioner across several States and Union Territories in
respect of the same cause of action. By an interim order dated 24.04.2020,
the Hon’ble Apext Court stayed further proceedings in all FIRs and complaints
except the one originally registered at Police Station Sadar, Nagpur, which
was later transferred to N.M. Joshi Marg Police Station, Mumbai. Accepting
the submission of the learned Senior Counsel, the Court held that fairness in
the administration of criminal justice warranted exercise of jurisdiction to
prevent multiplicity of proceedings. Relying on the law laid down in T.T.
Antony supra, the Hon’ble Apex Court reiterated that successive FIRs or
complaints founded on the same transaction are not maintainable.
Consequently, all FIRs and complaints enumerated, except the one under
investigation at Mumbai, were quashed.
14.
In Babubhai v. State of Gujarat4, at paragraph No.14, the Hon’ble
Apex Court, relying on T.T. Antony supra, reiterated that the registration of a
2020 SCC OnLine SC 462
(2010) 12 SCC 254
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
second FIR in respect of the same cognizable offence or the same occurrence
is legally impermissible, holding that all subsequent information relating to the
same incident must be treated only as statements under Section 162 of ‘the
Cr.P.C.’ The Hon’ble Apex Court emphasized that the investigating agency is
obliged to proceed solely on the basis of the first information recorded under
Section 158 of ‘the Cr.P.C.,’ and to investigate not only the offences reported
therein but also any connected offences arising from the same transaction,
culminating in a report under Section 173 of ‘the Cr.P.C.’ Even after
submission of the report under Section 173(2) of ‘the Cr.P.C.,’ any further
material pertaining to the same incident may be investigated only by
undertaking further investigation under Section 173(8) of ‘the Cr.P.C.,’
preferably with leave of the Court. The Hon’ble Apex Court clarified that
receipt of multiple pieces of information relating to the same incident does not
justify registration of additional FIRs, as such subsequent information cannot
constitute fresh FIRs and doing so would offend the scheme of ‘the Cr.P.C.’
15.
In Upkar Singh v. Ved Prakash5, the Hon’ble Supreme Court clarified
that its earlier decision in T.T. Antony supra, does not preclude the
registration of a counter- case. The Court explained that T.T. Antony supra
merely prohibits the lodging of any subsequent complaint by the same
complainant or others against the same accused relating to the same incident
(2004) 13 SCC 292
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
once investigation has commenced, as such later complaints would constitute
an impermissible improvement upon the facts of the original complaint,
thereby attracting the bar under Section 162 of ‘the Cr.P.C.’ This embargo,
however, was held to be inapplicable to a counter- complaint filed by the
accused in the first incident, or on his behalf, presenting a different version of
the occurrence; such a counter- case remains legally maintainable as it
represents an independent narrative and not a reiteration or embellishment of
the initial allegations.
16.
In C. Muniappan v. State of T.N6, the Hon’ble Apex Court held at
paragraph No.37 that the contention that two crimes, bearing Nos.188 and
190 of 2000, could not be clubbed together was devoid of merit, as the totality
of the circumstances and the sequence of events clearly established that the
second incident was merely a consequential fallout of the first. The Court
observed that, upon considering the evidence of the drivers, conductors, and
cleaners of the vehicles involved in the first occurrence, along with the
testimony of the Village Administrative Officer (PW- 87), it became evident that
the damage caused to public transport vehicles and the subsequent burning of
the University bus formed parts of a single continuous incident. Thus, the
mere lodging of two separate complaints did not preclude the clubbing of the
cases or the filing of a consolidated charge- sheet.
(2010) 9 SCC 567
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
17.
In Chirra Shivraj v. State of A.P7, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reiterated at paragraph No.14 that the concept of a First Information Report
necessarily connotes the earliest information received by the police relating to
the commission of an offence, and that no second FIR can be registered in
respect of the very same incident or occurrence. The Court held that any
subsequent information received by the investigating agency, even if it
supplements or elaborates upon the earlier facts, must be treated only as
material in continuation of the original FIR, since all such information is
inherently in furtherance of the first report and cannot give rise to a fresh FIR
concerning the same offence or event.
18.
In Anju Chaudhary v. State of U.P8, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
emphasized the intrinsic legal significance of a First Information Report,
describing it as the foundational document that sets the criminal law
machinery in motion and forms the basis of the prosecution’s case. The Court
observed that while multiple pieces of information may be furnished to the
officer- in- charge concerning the same incident involving one or more
cognizable offences, such subsequent information constitutes statements
under Section 162 of ‘the Cr.P.C.,’ and does not justify the registration of
additional FIRs. For determining the legality of more than one FIR, the Court
(2010) 14 SCC 444
(2013) 6 SCC 384
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
held that the “test of sameness” must be applied to ascertain whether the FIRs
relate to the very same incident or occurrence, or whether they pertain to
distinct incidents or different parts of a larger transaction. If both FIRs satisfy
the test of sameness, the latter would be liable to be quashed; however,
where the subsequent FIR discloses a distinct version or pertains to an
entirely separate incident, its registration is legally permissible, consistent with
the principles earlier enunciated in Babubhai supra.
19.
In Kashi Nath Choudhary v. State of Bihar9, the High Court of Patna,
applying the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in T.T.
Antony supra, held that the investigation pursuant to the second FIR,
Begusarai P.S. Case No.274 of 2004, was unwarranted, as it pertained to the
very same incident and facts forming the subject matter of the earlier FIR. The
Court, however, clarified that this bar does not curtail the power of the
investigating agency to conduct further investigation or to proceed against any
additional persons whose involvement may surface during investigation or trial.
Consequently, the order of cognizance in Begusarai Town P.S. Case No.274
of 2004 was quashed insofar as it related to the petitioner, subject to the
observations made therein.
2007 SCC OnLine Pat 116
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
20.
In Subhash Narayan Koli v. State of Maharashtra10, the High Court of
Bombay held that a second FIR cannot be registered in respect of the same
cognizable offence or the same incident. The Court noted that, on the facts of
the case, the applicants had already been shown as accused in Crime
Register No.56 of 2006 at Bajarpeth Police Station for the recovery of
contraband from premises at Jainabad, Walmikinagar, Jalgaon, and yet, for
the very same seizure, they were again arrayed as accused in Crime Register
No.19 of 2006 at Shanipeth Police Station, Jalgaon. The Court held that such
duplication of FIRs for the same occurrence is impermissible in law.
21.
Upon a careful perusal of the records in Crime No.85 of 2025, Crime
No.166 of 2025, Crime No.215 of 2025, and Crime No.222 of 2025, it is
evident that the nature of the transactions between the gullible depositors, the
Petitioner, and Sneha MACS Ltd. are one and the same. Though the place,
time, and dates of the alleged acts of fraud or non- payment of assured
deposits along with interest may differ, the underlying transaction remains
identical.
22.
In Alladi Punna Rao v. State of A.P11, this Court held that a careful
examination of the material pertaining to Crime Nos.85 of 2025 and 166 of
2025 demonstrated that the nature of the transactions between the gullible
2010 SCC OnLine Bom 1164
W.P. No.20132 of 2025, dated 31.01.2026
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
depositors, the petitioner, and Sneha MACS Ltd. was fundamentally identical,
notwithstanding variations in the place, time, or date of the alleged defaults.
This Court further observed that, in the interest of justice and to safeguard the
rights of the depositors, the proceedings arising from such FIRs should be
consolidated and investigated by a single police officer to ensure an effective,
coordinated, and seamless investigation.
23.
Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, and in the interest
of justice as well as the interest of the gullible depositors, the proceedings
arising out of the registration of the multiple FIRs ought to be dealt with and
investigated by a single police officer for an effective and coordinated
investigation. Accordingly, the proceedings in FIR No.166 of 2025 of Duvvada
Police Station, FIR No.215 of 2025 of Gopalapatnam Police Station, and FIR
No.222 of 2025 of II Town Police Station are transferred to Dwaraka Police
Station, where FIR No.85 of 2025 is already registered and under
investigation. No prejudice would be caused to the depositors, as all the
Police Stations concerned fall within the Visakhapatnam Commissionerate. In
view of the above, the contention that the subsequent FIRs, registered on
different dates and at different stations, are liable to be quashed cannot be
accepted, since they all arise out of the different set of transactions, through
identical, concerning Sneha MACS Society.
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
24.
Upon a meticulous consideration of the facts and circumstances of the
case and the settled principles of law, this Court has arrived at the conclusion
that the registration of multiple FIRs against the Petitioner, all arising out of the
same set of transactions concerning Sneha MACS Society, is impermissible in
law. The settled jurisprudence of the Hon’ble Apex Court in T.T. Antony supra,
Babubhai supra, Arnab Ranjan Goswami supra, and as reaffirmed in Chirra
Shivraj supra and Anju Chaudhary supra unequivocally establishes that
successive FIRs arising from the same incident or transaction are
impermissible in law, as they offend the scheme of ‘the Cr.P.C.,’ and violate
Article 21 of the Constitution. The Hon’ble Apex Court has consistently held
that subsequent complaints must be treated only as statements under Section
162 of ‘the Cr.P.C.,’ and any further investigation must be undertaken under
Section 173(8) of ‘the Cr.P.C.,’ with leave of the Court, rather than by initiating
fresh FIRs. The High Courts, including those of Telangana, Patna, and
Bombay,
have
applied
these
principles
to
quash
duplicative
FIRs,
emphasizing the “test of sameness” as the touchstone. Applying these
precedents, this Court finds that although the place, date, and time of the
alleged defaults may differ, the substratum of the allegations remains identical,
being one continuous transaction between the depositors and Sneha MACS
Ltd. Therefore, to prevent multiplicity of proceedings, the FIRs are directed to
be consolidated and investigated by a single police station, Dwaraka Police
W.P.No.35896 of 2026
06.02.2026
Dr.YLR,J
Station where FIR No.85 of 2025 is already registered and under investigation,
within the Visakhapatnam Commissionerate, ensuring a coordinated and
effective investigation without prejudice to the depositors.
25.
With the above observations and directions, the Writ Petition is
disposed of. No order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________
Dr.Y. LAKSHMANA RAO, J.
Date: 06.02.2026
Note: LR copy to be marked
B/o
VTS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review