Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION (HABEAS CORPUS) NO. 12282 of
==========================================================
KATHAN BHAGIRATH NAYAK
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR.ASHISH N PANDYA(9802) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
MR BHARATKUMAR H OZA(12150) for the Respondent(s) No. 4
MR ASHISH N. CHAUDHARY, ADVOCATE FOR MR JIGAR B OZA(11654)
for the Respondent(s) No. 4
MR L B DABHI, APP for the Respondent(s) No. 1
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 27/10/2026
ORAL ORDER
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA)
1.
The petitioner/husband – Kathan Bhagirath Nayak, being a father
of corpus – daughter aged about 6 years, has invoked the extraordinary
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
seeking a writ of Habeas Corpus for production and custody of minor
daughter, presently residing with respondent no.4 Pooja Swami, who is
the mother of the child, inter alia alleging that the corpus is in illegal
confinement of the mother – respondent no.4 at Village Karad, Dist.:
Satara, Maharashtra.
2.
We have heard learned counsel Mr. Ashish N. Pandya and Mr.
Ashish N. Chaudhary for Mr. Jigar B. Oza for the respective parties.
3.
Brief facts giving rise to file present petition are stated to be as
under:
(i)
The petitioner and respondent no.4 got married on 25.06.2019 and
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
thereafter, they resided at Ahmedabad. Out of the wedlock, two
daughters were borne out. Due to matrimonial discord, the parties
are residing separately. The petitioner being a Dental Surgeon,
settled in Ahmedabad and presently, working as a Doctor at
Godhra, whereas the respondent – wife, after the dispute, living at
her parental home – Karad, Dist.: Satara, Maharashtra. The elder
daughter A aged about 6 years, at the time of separation on account
of matrimonial discord, was remained with the petitioner husband
and younger daughter was with the wife respondent.
(ii)
Both the parties have filed an application for permanent custody of
elder daughter A under the provision of Guardians and Wards Act,
1890 before the Family Court at Ahmedabad as well as Court at
Karad, Maharashtra.
(iii)
The respondent wife, thereafter, filed a complaint no.79 of 2025
under the provision of Domestic Violence Act and pending the
complaint vide Exh.38, sought interim custody of the elder
daughter A, invoking Section 21 of the DV Act, 2005. The Court at
Karad, vide its order dated 30.04.2026 was pleased to reject the
application. On appeal, the Sessions Court vide its judgment dated
20.05.2026, while partly allowing the appeal, set aside the order of
the Karad Court and granted temporary custody of the elder
daughter A for the period from 23.05.2026 to 30.05.2026 to the
respondent wife and further directed to handover the custody on
31.05.2026 to the husband petitioner at Ahmedabad. The petitioner
husband pursuant to the order of the Sessions Court, handed over
the custody of the corpus elder daughter A to the respondent wife.
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
However, she failed to return the custody of the child to the
petitioner husband at Ahmedabad.
4.
In such circumstances, it is submitted that the wife has illegally
confined the corpus and in willful defiance to the order dated 20.05.2026
passed by the learned Court of Sessions, Karad, Satara District,
Maharashtra and refused to comply with the directions of the Court. With
a view to non-compliance of the order, just a day before handing over the
child to the petitioner, an FIR on 29.05.2026, came to be registered at
Karad, alleging that the child was assaulted by the husband and his family
members on 23.05.2026 and therefore, by preferring this petition for
habeas corpus, the necessary direction is being sought to produce the
child before this Court and further seeks a direction of her custody in
terms of order passed by the Sessions Court, Karad.
5.
Mr. Ashish N. Pandya, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
- husband, made the following submissions:
(i)
That, the custody of the minor daughter was given by the
Sessions Court, Karad, District: Satara, Maharashtra for a
limited period with a specific direction to handover the custody
to the father after completion of the said period. However, in
willful defiance to the order, the wife-respondent refused to
handover the custody and the mother’s deliberate noncompliance with the court’s custody order is significant
circumstance for exercising discretion in favour of the
applicant-husband as after lapse of specific period, the custody
cannot be said to be a lawful custody and same is regarded as
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
unauthorized or contrary to the subsisting judicial order.
(ii)
That, instead of handing over the child back to the husband, the
wife hatched a conspiracy and with a clear malice in her mind,
got registered an FIR on 29.05.2026 just a day before the
completion of time to handover the child to the petitioner. It is
relevant to note that, in the FIR, it is alleged that the child was
assaulted by the father and his family members on 23.05.2026.
However, she did not approach the police station on the same
day which shows that the FIR is nothing but a sinister design by
the wife so as to create an atmosphere to defy the order of the
Sessions Court, Karad and frustrate the husband’s rightful and
legal custody of the child.
(iii)
That, once by judicial order the custody of the child handed
over to the mother for a limited period, then, neither the Karad
Police, nor Child Welfare Committee, Satara are competent
authority to adjudicate any matter related to the child in
question without the permission/order of the Family Court,
Ahmedabad under whose jurisdiction, the child ordinarily
resides and a custody petition under Guardian and Wards Act is
pending for its adjudication.
(iv)
That, the mother had an occasion to meet the corpus on various
occasions for visitation such as 30.09.2025, 18.10.2025,
09.02.2026 to 18.02.2026. During those visitation and
temporary custody periods, the mother did not file any
complaint regarding assault and harassment meted out to the
child. Thus, in order to get custody, she created a false narrative
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
and with the help of police and others, she keeps continue the
custody of the child illegally and the same is nothing, but an
illegal confinement of the child by the mother.
(v)
That, the petitioner-husband is highly qualified Dental Surgeon
and his father is also a Doctor and therefore, the allegation of
harassment to the child cannot be accepted and same is alleged
to deprive the husband the custody of the child and to scuttle the
legal process.
(vi)
That, the corpus – daughter was happy in the family
environment of the husband and now, due to illegal confinement
of her, the daughter is deprived of her academic classes as she is
studying in Class – Senior K.G. at Ahmedabad School and she
is very good in her studies and excelled academically well in
her school at Ahmedabad and she also enrolled in various Cocurricular activities and classes at Ahmedabad like dance
classes, drawing classes and abacus classes. The husband and
his family members sent the daughter to the picnic organized by
the school and lastly, on 30.03.2026, her half yearly birthday
was celebrated with full joyous and she was used to taken at the
play zone, metro rides, temples, scooter rides etc. which facts
demonstrates that she was happy with the petitioner – father and
his family and considering the attending circumstances, it could
be inferred that the husband and his family members never
committed any act of cruelty as alleged.
6.
In such circumstances, Mr. Pandya, learned counsel appearing for
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
the petitioner-husband submitted that, if the child would continue in the
custody of the mother, then, she would face a language and food problem
because she is not accustomed by Marathi food and culture as compared
to Gujarati environment. Thus, therefore, when the mother – respondent
has deliberately retained the child contrary to the subsisting order of the
court, her custody has now become unauthorized and having regard to the
welfare of the child, the custody with the mother certainly can be
characterized as illegal and unauthorized.
7.
Thus, it was submitted that, case is made out for exercising
extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court for issuance of necessary
directions to handover the custody to the petitioner and therefore, the
necessary direction may be issued, as prayed for against the motherrespondent.
8.
Opposing the prayer, Mr. Ashish N. Chaudhary, learned counsel
appearing for and on behalf of the respondent – mother herein submitted
that, from 23.05.2026, the custody of the minor daughter is with the
mother and during the interaction with the daughter, it was revealed that,
the daughter was crying on 26.05.2026 and told her mother that she like
her company and in the company of her father, she was locked in the
house and she was scolded by father and others and lastly, her father
slapped and scolded her. Thus, during the custody with the father, the
minor corpus was kept under metal pressure and created fear in her mind
and subjected the minor to mental and physical cruelty. Thus, the mother
compelled to lodge an FIR with Karad Police Station on 29.05.2026
under Section 75 of The J.J. Act, 2015, Section 115(2), 127(2), 351(2)
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
and 3(5) of the BNS, 2023. The corpus daughter was brought before the
Child Welfare Committee, Karad. The mother had informed to the
Judicial Magistrate Court, Karad about the cruelty meted out to her at the
instance of father and others and therefore, considering these subsequent
events, the mother’s custody of the daughter for all purpose cannot be
said to be unauthorized and/or illegal. It was further submitted that, it was
the husband who had raised the legal contention before the Supreme
Court in a Special Leave Petition arising out of the order passed by the
High Court of Judicature at Bombay in Writ Petition No.21439 of 2024,
that the power of High Court in granting the writ of habeas corpus in
child custody matter, is qualified only in cases where the detention of a
minor by a person who is not entitled to his legal custody.
9.
In such circumstances, it was submitted that, instead of availing
appropriate remedy before the Sessions Court, Satara for non-compliance
of the order of before the Family Court where the custody matter is
pending, the petitioner husband with a view to harass the wife, has
preferred this Habeas Corpus application and therefore, the petition is
misconceived and amounts to an attempt to bypass the statutory remedies
available.
10.
Lastly, it was submitted that, the custody of the daughter with the
mother is lawful and in her best interest and cannot be termed as illegal
detention so as to justify the issuance of writ of habeas corpus and
therefore, it is prayed that, no case is made out for exercising
extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court.
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
11.
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
We have considered the submissions made by learned counsel
appearing for the respective parties and carefully perused the material on
record.
12.
It is not in dispute that, since the order passed by the Sessions
Court, Karad, the minor daughter aged about 6 years, is presently residing
with mother at Karad, Satara. We have interacted with the child in the
chamber. The minor daughter aged about 6 years, has expressed her
desire and wish that she is happy with her mother and does not wish to
reside with the father. Admittedly, the dispute a custody battle between
the parents. The record indicates that on 06.10.2026, the Coordinate
Bench of this Court had interacted with the corpus and noticed that, the
corpus was having strong reservation against the petitioner father. It is not
in dispute that the order granting one week’s custody and directing the
mother to handover the daughter to the father was passed by Additional
Sessions Judge, Karad. In that view of the matter, the petitioner father
should have approached the court concerned for enforcement or
appropriate proceedings instead of invoking jurisdiction of this Court
under Article 226/227 of The Constitution of India. It is settled position
of law that, the custody with natural guardian, particularly the mother
cannot ordinarily be termed “illegal” so as to justify the issuance of writ
of habeas corpus.
13.
We may profitably refer to and rely on case of Sarita Sharma Vs.
Sushil Sharma, (2000) 3 SCC 14, wherein, considering the all the aspect
relating to the welfare of the children, the Supreme Court while
dismissing the writ petition, observed as under:
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
when the minor child is in custody of the mother, such custody
cannot be considered unlawful merely because the father seeks
custody, and it was not proper for the High Court to have
allowed the Habeas Corpus writ application and directed the
appellant to handover custody of the children to the respondent
and permit him to take them away to USA. What would be in the
interest of children requires a full and thorough enquiry and
therefore, the High Court should have directed the respondents
to initiate appropriate proceedings in which such an enquiry
can be held.
14.
In the judgment of Tejaswini Goud Vs. Shekhar Jagdishprasad
Tiwari, (2019) 7 SCC 42, the Supreme Court reiterated that writ of
habeas corpus in child custody matter is maintainable only where the
custody is unlawful or without authority of law. Even in such cases, the
Court must be guided by the paramount consideration of welfare of the
child rather than the legal rights of the parties. The Supreme Court further
held that, in child custody matters, the ordinary remedy lies only under
the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 or the Guardians and
Wards Act, 1890. If the court believes that the matter requires a thorough
examination of facts, it may choose not to use its extra ordinary
jurisdiction and instead instruct the parties to seek relief before a Civil
Court. Only in rare and exceptional circumstances, the court will decide
custody rights through its extra ordinary jurisdiction. The relevant paras,
19 and 20 reads as under:
"19. Habeas corpus proceedings is not to justify or examine the
legality of the custody. Habeas corpus proceedings is a medium
through which the custody of the child is addressed to the
discretion of the court. Habeas corpus is a prerogative writ
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
which is an extraordinary remedy and the writ is issued where
in the circumstances of the particular case, ordinary remedy
provided by the law is either not available or is ineffective;
otherwise, a writ will not be issued. In child custody matters, the
power of the High Court in granting the writ is qualified only in
cases where the detention of a minor by a person who is not
entitled to his legal custody. In view of the pronouncement on
the issue in question by the Supreme Court and the High Courts,
in our view, in child custody matters, the writ of habeas corpus
is maintainable where it is proved that the detention of a minor
child by a parent or others was illegal and without any
authority of law.
20. In child custody matters, the ordinary remedy lies only
under the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act or the
Guardians and Wards Act as the case may be. In cases arising
out of the proceedings under the Guardians and Wards Act, the
jurisdiction of the court is determined by whether the minor
ordinarily resides within the area on which the court exercises
such jurisdiction. There are significant differences between the
enquiry under the Guardian and Wards Act and the exercise of
powers by a writ court which is of summary in nature. What is
important is the welfare of the child. In the writ court, rights are
determined only on the basis of affidavits. Where the court is of
the view that a detailed enquiry is required, the court may
decline to exercise the extraordinary jurisdiction and direct the
parties to approach the civil court. It is only in exceptional
cases, the rights of the parties to the custody of the minor will
be determined in exercise of extraordinary jurisdiction on a
petition for habeas corpus."
15.
Again, in Kanika Goel Vs. State of Delhi, (2018) 9 SCC 578, the
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
Supreme Court held that in petition seeking the writ of Habeas Corpus,
the High Court must examine at the threshold whether the minor is in
lawful custody of another person (private respondent). Whether the
custody is with the mother, the Court may not make any further enquiry
or resort to a summary or elaborate enquiry to determine the welfare of
the child.
16.
Reverting back to the facts of the present case, the petitioner father
though residing in Ahmedabad, but he is serving at the remote area of
Gujarat i.e. at Godhara far away at the distance of 250 kilometers from
Ahmedabad and in his absence, the minor daughter was in care of her
grandparents, whereas, presently, the minor is with her mother and
considering her age and other attending circumstances, as referred above,
the mother has kept custody of the minor daughter beyond statutory time
limit as directed by the Sessions Court, Karad. However, the fact remains
that the petitioner father till date, not filed any application, raising
grievance about the custody of the child with the mother before any Court
of Karad, Satara, nor filed any application before the Family Court,
Ahmedabad or Karad. Admittedly, both the parties have filed a custody
application under Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 and same are pending
at different Family Courts i.e. Karad and Ahmedabad. In such
circumstances, in our opinion, the petitioner husband should pursue
ordinary statutory remedy before the Competent Court instead of directly
approaching this Court seeking an extraordinary remedy under Article
226/227 of The Constitution of India.
17.
For the aforementioned reasons, in the facts of the present case, we
deem it fit not to exercise our extra ordinary jurisdiction. It is open to the
R/SCR.A/12282/2026
(GJHC240625632026)
ORDER DATED: 27/10/2026
parties to avail alternative remedies in accordance with law. We further
make it clear that, we have not examined or expressed any opinion on the
rival claims of the parties regarding permanent or interim custody of the
minor child.
18.
Accordingly, this petition stands dismissed at the admission stage.
(ILESH J. VORA,J)
(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
TAUSIF SAIYED
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review