Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 15.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010429422026
+
FAO (COMM) 263/2026 CM APPL. 61558-61560/2026
KASIF AHMED
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Sandeep Kumar Mahapatra, Sr.
Adv. with Mr. Tribhuvan and Ms.
Amruta Padhi, Advs.
versus
M/S TENAX INDIA STONE
PRODUCTS PVT LTD.
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Anirudh Bakhru, Mr. Shravan
Kumar Bansal, Ms. Ayushi Arora and
Mr. Siddharth Sekhri, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
ORDER
%
15.09.2026
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J. (ORAL)
1.
This is an appeal under Section 104 read with Order XLIII Rule 1(d)
read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 [‘CPC’], read
with Section 13(1) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 [‘Act of 2015’],
assailing the judgment dated 17.07.2026 [‘impugned order’] passed by the
District Judge (Commercial)- 03, South, Saket Courts, New Delhi in Misc.
DJ 195/2025 [‘Trial Court’] in CS(COMM) No. 260/2020 titled as
‘M/s Tenax India Stone Products Pvt. Ltd v. Kasif Ahmed’. The learned
Trial Court, vide the impugned order, dismissed the Appellant’s application
seeking setting aside of the ex-parte judgment dated 07.07.2025, as well as
the order dated 20.04.2023 whereby the Appellant was proceeded ex-parte.
1.1.
The learned Trial Court, vide ex-parte judgment dated 07.07.2025 on
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
the basis of the ex-parte evidence led by the Respondent, passed a decree for
permanent injunction restraining the Appellant from using the impugned
trademark and granted damages and costs to the extent of Rs. 9,00,000/against the Appellant. The said ex-parte judgment dated 07.07.2025 is not a
subject matter of this appeal.
BRIEF FACTS SET UP BY THE APPELLANT
2.
The Appellant, based in Kolkata, has been engaged in the business of
adhesives for the past eight [8] years. The Appellant is using the impugned
trademark ‘T-MAX’ for his products.
2.1.
It is stated that the Respondent is engaged in the business of
manufacturing and trading of adhesives, industrial glue and adhesives,
natural resins, corrosion inhibitors, polish, polishing, etc., and that it had
been using the trademark ‘TENAX’, which was registered in 2003.
2.2.
The Respondent instituted a commercial suit, i.e., CS (COMM)
260/2020, on 28.09.2020 seeking permanent injunction reliefs against
infringement of its trademark/copyright, and other ancillary reliefs in respect
of the use of the impugned trademark ‘T-MAX’ by the Appellant.
2.3.
It is stated that upon service of summons, the Appellant engaged
Mr. Somraj Gangopadhyay, Advocate, who appeared before the learned
Trial Court on 04.11.2022, when four [4] weeks were granted for filing the
written statement. However, on 10.01.2023, a further extension of time was
sought. It is stated that the Appellant had the written statement prepared and
signed the said statement. It is stated that the Appellant was informed by his
counsel that the written statement had been served on the Respondent and
would be filed with the Court.
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
2.4.
It is stated that thereafter, when the matter was taken up on
22.02.2023, it was recorded that the Respondent had received the
Appellant’s written statement through WhatsApp, but the same had not been
filed in the Court.
2.5.
It is stated that the proceedings held on 04.11.2022, 10.01.2023 and
22.02.2023 show that the Appellant was diligently prosecuting his defence
to the suit. The act of engaging a counsel and filing a written statement is
proof of the said diligence. It is stated that the Appellant was not aware that
the written statement signed by him had not been filed in the Court by the
counsel.
2.6.
It is stated that in October, 2023, the Appellant was informed by his
counsel that the Respondent was willing to settle the matter and a settlement
would be in the interest of both the parties. It is stated that the settlement
talks between the counsel for the Appellant and the Respondent continued
for more than a year. It is admitted that the Appellant himself did not
participate in the said settlement talks. It is stated that the counsel for the
Appellant informed him that though the settlement talks had not fructified,
the same were underway. It is stated that the Appellant therefore believed
that the suit was pending and settlement talks were ongoing since October
2023.
2.7.
It is stated that on 12.08.2025, the Appellant received a legal notice
dated 08.08.2025 from the counsel for the Respondent, inter alia, informing
him that the subject suit had been decreed ex-parte by way of judgment
dated 07.07.2025 and damages as well as costs amounting to Rs. 9,00,000/had been imposed upon him.
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
2.8.
It is stated that on receipt of notice, the Appellant tried to contact his
counsel, Mr. Somraj Gangopadhyay. However, despite repeated attempts,
the Appellant was unable to contact his counsel, who stopped responding to
his calls. Consequently, the Appellant filed a complaint against the counsel
before the Bar Council of West Bengal on 28.08.2025 and engaged another
counsel, who, after inspecting the publicly available records, informed him
that no written statement had been filed till then.
The Appellant further learnt that he had been proceeded ex-parte vide
order dated 20.04.2023 in the suit as no one had appeared on his behalf.
2.9.
The Appellant thereafter filed an application under Order IX Rule 13
CPC before the learned Trial Court, seeking setting aside of the order dated
20.04.2023 proceeding the Appellant ex-parte and the ex-parte judgment
dated 07.07.2025, along with condonation of delay in filing the application,
inter alia, on the ground that despite having engaged Mr. Somraj
Gangopadhyay as his counsel to defend the case, his counsel’s negligent
conduct resulted in the passing of an ex-parte decree against him.
2.10. After hearing the parties, the learned Trial Court passed the impugned
order dismissing the Appellant’s Order IX Rule 13 CPC application, holding
that the Appellant had failed to demonstrate that he was prevented by any
sufficient cause from appearing when the suit was called out for hearing on
20.04.2023. The learned Trial Court held that the Appellant’s conduct shows
total negligence in defending the suit and that shifting the entire blame for
non-appearance on 20.04.2023 and thereafter in the suit is not bona fide and
does not satisfy the test of sufficient cause under Order IX Rule 13 CPC.
2.11. In these facts, the Appellant has preferred the present appeal.
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
SUBMISSIONS BY THE APPELLANT
3.
Mr. Sandeep Kumar Mahapatra, learned senior counsel for the
Appellant, stated that the Appellant was under the bona fide belief that the
counsel engaged by him was looking after his interest by undertaking all the
requisite exercises like filing of written statement and appearing before the
learned Trial Court.
3.1.
He stated that the Appellant was not well versed with Court
proceedings or aware of the manner of monitoring the same through digital
means, and genuinely believed that his interests were being duly protected
by him.
3.2.
He stated that the Appellant had been informed by counsel that
settlement talks were underway and that the Respondent was willing to
amicably resolve the matter. He further stated that the Appellant had been
advised that he would be kept informed of the progress thereof. Thereafter,
the said counsel kept assuring that the settlement talks were still underway
throughout 2023-2024.
3.3.
He stated that the learned Trial Court erred in not appreciating that it
was a fit case to construe the term ‘sufficient cause’ liberally to ensure that
substantial justice is done to the Appellant, who was otherwise diligent in
pursuing the case and would have been able to participate in the proceedings
but for the conduct of his counsel.
3.4.
He relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in A. Murugesan
v. Jamuna Rani (2019)1 to state that sufficient cause is required to be
construed liberally, having regard to the facts and circumstances of each
(2019) 20 SCC 803
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
case.
3.5.
He stated that the learned Trial Court, having condoned the delay on
the very grounds pleaded, could not have subsequently held the same
grounds to be insufficient for setting aside the ex-parte judgment dated
07.07.2025, rendering the impugned order inherently contradictory.
SUBMISSIONS BY THE RESPONDENT
4.
Mr. Anirudh Bakhru, learned counsel for the Respondent, stated that
the Appellant has not placed on record any documents, viz. printouts of email, letters, call detail records, etc., to substantiate his contention that he
was in constant touch with his counsel in the year 2023-2024.
4.1.
He stated that the Appellant has filed no documentary evidence to
substantiate the pleas taken by him in the application.
4.2.
He relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Rajneesh
Kumar v. Ved Prakash (2024)2 to state that a litigant owes a duty to be
vigilant about his own rights and is expected to be equally vigilant about the
judicial proceedings pending in the Court, and cannot throw the entire blame
on the Advocate.
COURT’S FINDINGS
5.
This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused
the record.
6.
The non-controvertible facts evident from the record of the suit
proceedings are as under:
i.
The Appellant was duly served with summons on 27.08.2022. The
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3380
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
counsel for the Appellant entered appearance before the learned Trial
Court on 04.11.2022 and, while admitting service of summons, sought
a copy of the plaint and the documents. It is admitted that the plaint
and documents were duly supplied.
ii.
The learned Trial Court, vide order dated 04.11.2022, granted four [4]
weeks to the Appellant to file his written statement along with an
affidavit of admission/denial of documents filed by the Respondent,
failing which the Appellant was liable to pay costs of Rs. 20,000/- to
the Respondent.
iii.
The Appellant failed to file the written statement and the affidavit of
admission/denial of documents within four [4] weeks. The Appellant
sought further time from the Court at the hearing dated 10.01.2023.
The learned Trial Court granted additional time to the Appellant to
file the written statement and directed him to pay costs of Rs. 20,000/to the Respondent and listed the matter for 22.02.2023.
iv.
When the matter was taken up on 22.02.2023, the learned Trial Court
recorded that the Appellant had failed to file the written statement, the
affidavit of admission/denial of documents with the Court, and had
failed to deposit the costs of Rs. 20,000/-. The learned Trial Court,
however, recorded the statement of the counsel for the Respondent
that he had received a copy of the written statement through
WhatsApp. In these facts, the Court fixed the matter for 20.04.2023 to
enable the Appellant to bring the written statement, the affidavit of
admission/denial of documents on record, along with costs. The
matter was further fixed for case management hearing and framing of
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
issues.
v.
However, on 20.04.2023, none appeared on behalf of the Appellant.
The learned Trial Court recorded that no written statement had been
filed with the Court, though a copy had been shared with the counsel
for the Respondent through WhatsApp. It noted that the costs of
Rs. 20,000/- imposed vide previous order had not been paid. It further
recorded that since the Appellant has been served on 27.08.2022 and
supplied with the plaint and documents on 04.11.2022, the period of
120 days, which is the outer limit for filing a written statement under
the Act of 2015, has since expired. In these facts, relying upon the
judgment of the Supreme Court in M/s SCG Contracts India Pvt.
Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. (2019)3, the
Appellant’s right to file written statement was closed. In addition, the
Court recorded that none had appeared despite several calls during the
day and therefore proceeded ex-parte against the Appellant.
vi.
As per the suit record, Appellant’s counsel appeared through Video
Conferencing [‘VC’] link on 01.04.2025 and 23.05.2025; however, no
application was filed for setting aside the order dated 20.04.2023
proceeding ex-parte.
vii.
The Respondent thereafter, on 23.05.2025, led ex-parte evidence of its
witness Mr. Sachin Sharma, PW1, who tendered in evidence
documents marked as Ex. PW1/1 to Ex. PW1/23 [Colly]. Two [2]
years after the Appellant was proceeded ex-parte, the final arguments
in the suit were heard on 09.06.2025, and the ex-parte judgment was
(2019) 12 SCC 210
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
pronounced on 07.07.2025.
7.
The aforesaid facts show that there is no dispute that the Appellant
was duly served with the summons and was aware of the pendency of the
suit.
8.
Thus, the only issue arising for consideration is whether the Appellant
was prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing in the suit when it was
called out for hearing on 20.04.2023 or any date thereafter to defend the suit
proceedings until the ex-parte judgment was passed on 07.07.2025.
9.
The Appellant has averred that his non-participation in the suit
proceedings from 20.04.2023 is solely due to the negligence of his counsel
Mr. Somraj Gangopadhyay, engaged by him to represent him in the suit
proceedings. He submitted that since he signed the written statement in
February, 2023, he presumed that the same had been duly filed. He
submitted that he believed that compromise talks were going on between his
counsel and the Respondent from October, 2023 until August, 2025, when
he received the legal notice dated 08.08.2025 from the Respondent’s counsel
demanding compliance with the ex-parte judgment dated 07.07.2025.
10.
The Appellant has admitted that he has no written evidence to
substantiate his follow-ups with the counsel from 2023 to 2025. The
Appellant contended that he is not digitally literate and therefore could not
access the Court’s website for verifying the order sheets to learn about the
progress of the suit proceedings.
11.
The learned Trial Court, whilst considering the aforesaid submissions
of the Appellant, has held that the pleadings of the Appellant demonstrate
that he was negligent in defending the case. The relevant findings are as
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
follows: “7. Ex-parte decree can be set aside under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC if defendant
satisfies the Court that summon was not duly served on him or that he was
prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing when the suit was called
on for hearing. In the present case defendant accepted that summons of case
were duly served on him. Therefore, present case will falls in second
category as provided under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC.
8. As per defendant’s own case, written statement was signed by him
somewhere around February 2023 while ex-parte decree was passed on
07.07.2025. It is surprising that defendant was not following up his case for
more than two years. This only demonstrates that defendant was not only
negligent but also callous in defending the present case. A litigant is not
expected to remain indifferent to legal proceedings initiated against
him/her for more two years. Furthermore, defendant has not placed on
record any documents viz. prints out of e-mail, letters, call details
record, etc., to substantiate his contention that he was in constant touch
with his Advocate who kept assuring him that interest of defendant is
being protected.
……
10. Plaintiff is right in contending that if such a ground for non-appearance
of a litigant is accepted, then any litigant can simply wait for an adverse
judgment/decree to be passed against him and thereafter put blame on his
Counsel so as to prolong the litigation. Such an approach would defeat the
legislation intent behind enacting the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The
obvious conclusion is that defendant failed to satisfy the Court that he was
prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing in the Court when the suit
was called on for hearing.
……
21. Principles of law laid down in the abovesaid case are squarely applicable
to the facts of present case. The version putforth by defendant that his
Advocate kept assuring him that he is protecting his interest appears to be an
afterthought and does not inspire the confidence of Court.
22. It may also be mentioned here that we are living in an age of information
and technology. A litigant like defendant who is based in a metropolitan city
like Calcutta can easily have access to information about his case available
on online platform like Court’s website. Defendant only has to remember
some particulars of case viz.title of case, case number, date of hearing, name
of Court etc. to know about the status of case online. Law does not come to
the aid of negligent litigant.
23. From the above discussion, it is clear that defendant has miserably failed
to demonstrate that he was prevented by any sufficient cause from hearing
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
when the suit was called on for hearing and hence, the application under
Order 9 Rule 13 CPC must fail. Accordingly, the application filed by
defendant under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC is dismissed.”
[Emphasis supplied]
12.
The learned Trial Court relied upon the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Nitin Mahadeo Jawale v. Bhaskar Mahadeo Mutke (2024)4,
International Business Machines Corporation v. Tivoli Gardens (2026)5
and New Bank of India v. Marvels (India) (2001)6 to conclude that the
tendency of a litigant to attribute to his/her negligence on the Advocate for
adverse orders suffered in Court proceedings has to be deprecated.
13.
In this regard, the reliance placed by the learned counsel for the
Respondent on another judgment of the Supreme Court in Rajneesh Kumar
v. Ved Prakash (supra) is also apposite. The relevant paragraphs read as
under: “10. It appears that the entire blame has been thrown on the head of the
advocate who was appearing for the petitioners in the trial court. We have
noticed over a period of time a tendency on the part of the litigants to blame
their lawyers of negligence and carelessness in attending the proceedings
before the court. Even if we assume for a moment that the concerned
lawyer was careless or negligent, this, by itself, cannot be a ground to
condone long and inordinate delay as the litigant owes a duty to be
vigilant of his own rights and is expected to be equally vigilant about
the judicial proceedings pending in the court initiated at his instance.
The litigant, therefore, should not be permitted to throw the entire
blame on the head of the advocate and thereby disown him at any time
and seek relief.
11. In the aforesaid context, we may refer to a decision of this Court in the
case of Salil Dutta v. T.M. & M.C. Private Ltd. reported in (1993) 2 SCC
185, wherein this Court observed as under:“8. The advocate is the agent of the party. His acts and statements, made
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3468
2026 SCC OnLine Del 828
2001 SCC OnLine Del 523
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
within the limits of authority given to him, are the acts and statements of
the principal i.e. the party who engage him. It is true that in certain
situations, the court may, in the interest of justice, set aside a dismissal
order or an ex parte decree notwithstanding the negligence and/or
misdemeanour of the advocate where it finds that the client was an
innocent litigant but there is no such absolute rule that a party can
disown its advocate at any time and seek relief. No such absolute
immunity can be recognized. Such an absolute rule would make the
working of the system extremely difficult. The observations made in Rafiq
[AIR 1981 SC 1400] must not be understood as an absolute proposition.
As we have mentioned hereinabove, this was an on-going suit posted for
final hearing after a lapse of seven years of its institution. It was not a
second appeal filed by a villager residing away from the city, where the
court is located. The defendant is also not a rustic ignorant villager but a
private limited company with its head office at Calcutta itself and
managed by educated businessmen who know where their interest lies. It
is evident that when their applications were not deposed of before taking
up the suit for final hearing they felt piqued and refused to appear before
the court. May be, it was part of their delaying tactics as alleged by the
plaintiff. May be not. But one thing is clear they chose to non-cooperate
with the court. Having adopted such a stand towards the court, the
defendant has no right to ask its indulgence. Putting the entire blame
upon the advocate and trying to make it out as if they were totally
unaware of the nature or significance of the proceedings is a theory
which cannot be accepted and ought not to have been accepted.”
[Emphasis supplied]
14.
We find no error in the findings of wilful negligence of the Appellant
returned by the learned Trial Court. The orders passed by the learned Trial
Court show that full opportunity of participating and presenting his defence
was granted to the Appellant in the suit proceedings. The orders dated
04.11.2022, 10.01.2023, 22.02.2023 and 20.04.2023 show that the learned
trial Court granted sufficient time to the Appellant to file his written
statement and defend the suit. The non-filing of the written statement and
the affidavit of admission/denial of documents despite the opportunities
evidences the Appellant’s own inaction. Even after the Court proceeded exparte on 20.04.2023, the suit remained pending for two [2] years. The
explanation of the Appellant that it was orally informed by the counsel that
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
there are settlement talks underway between the counsel and the Respondent
would not be a sufficient cause for the Appellant to not be aware of the
status of the suit proceedings, especially when the Appellant admittedly has
failed to place on record any evidence of correspondence with his counsel
during the intervening period to substantiate the said claim. The order dated
11.09.2024 records that the settlement talks between the parties are not
progressing and therefore, the matter was listed for ex-parte plaintiff’s
evidence. In these facts, we are of the considered opinion that due process
was followed by the learned Trial Court before proceeding ex-parte on
20.04.2023 and passing the ex-parte judgment dated 07.07.2025, and the
Appellant has failed to show any sufficient cause.
15.
It is incumbent upon a litigant to remain vigilant about the
proceedings in which he is a party. The litigant has a duty to keep himself
apprised of the orders passed, directions given by the Court and steps taken
by his counsel in the suit. A litigant is expected to maintain copies of the
relevant suit record, and orders passed by undertaking reasonable efforts, not
only through his counsel but also on his own accord by inspecting the Court
record, to remain abreast with the status of the proceedings. The entire Order
IX CPC embodies this obligation. Traditionally, litigants used to physically
inspect the Court files. With the advent of the internet, the Court’s digital
platforms and online case-status facilities have been set up with an intent to
facilitate public access to the orders online and for the convenience of
litigants to observe the suit proceedings in the Courts where VC facilities are
available. In the facts of this case, the orders of the Commercial Court were
available online, and there was also a facility for attending the Court
proceedings through VC for the litigant and his/her counsel.
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
In this backdrop, the contention of the Appellant that he could not
independently access the Court’s website to download the daily orders or
ascertain the status of the proceedings on account of his lack of digital
literacy does not merit acceptance. Firstly, there is no material on record to
substantiate this assertion, particularly when the Appellant, by his own
showing, is a businessman. In present times, businessmen are compelled to
be digitally savvy to make tax compliances, which all happen online.
Secondly, even assuming that the Appellant is unable to operate a computer
himself or use the internet or access the Court website, he had the option to
seek assistance from any other person capable of using a computer and
accessing the internet.
16.
The Appellant thus had options to physically inspect the Court
records, physically attend the Court hearing or inspect the orders through the
website and attend the Court hearing virtually. As per the Appellant, he
exercised neither of the aforesaid options to pursue his interest. The
prolonged inaction of the Appellant shows wilful lack of diligence and fails
to constitute a sufficient cause within the scope of Order IX Rule 13 CPC.
17.
If such feeble contentions are accepted as evidence of ‘sufficient
cause’ under Order IX Rule 13 CPC in a commercial suit, for setting aside
an ex-parte judgment passed after giving full opportunity to a defendant to
defend himself, it shall set at naught the procedural framework of the Act of
2015 which is intended for time-bound adjudication. In this case, the suit
was instituted in the year 2020, the Appellant was proceeded ex-parte in the
year 2023, and the ex-parte judgment was passed by the learned Trial Court
after recording evidence in the year 2025. The delay of five [5] years in
deciding the commercial suit was evidently due to the non-participation of
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
the Appellant after the year 2023.
18.
The reliance placed by the Appellant on A. Murugesan v. Jamuna
Rani (supra) is distinguishable on facts. In the said case, the defendant was
proceeded ex-parte due to his non-appearance on one date before the Court.
The defendant therein, however, had shown specific circumstances
preventing his appearance on that particular date, namely, a Court boycott
by the Bar Association coupled with his illness. The application for setting
aside the ex-parte order was moved immediately; however, the Trial Court
declined to accept the said application. The Supreme Court, in those
circumstances, found sufficient cause for the defendant’s non-appearance.
The present case stands on a different footing. The Appellant herein was
proceeded ex-parte on 20.04.2023. The suit proceedings remained pending
till July, 2025. As held above, the Appellant was not diligent and took no
steps to participate and defend the suit proceedings despite full notice.
19.
We therefore find no infirmity in the impugned order. The appeal is
dismissed. Pending applications are disposed of.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
SEPTEMBER 15, 2026/mt/aa
Signed By:RASHMI
DABAS
18:03
FAO (COMM) 263/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review