The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. In view of above statements of the victim, I find no material to sustain the conviction of the appellants. Accordingly, the judgment of conviction dated 31.08.2021 and order of sentence, dated 02.09.2021 passed in Sessions Trial No. 53 of 2021 arising out of Domchanch P.S. Case No. 55 of 2020, by the learned Additional Sessions Judge-III, Koderma are quashed and set aside.
14. The appellants are on bail. Hence, they are discharged from the liability of their bail bond.
15. The present criminal appeal is allowed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:20808
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Cr. Appeal (S.J.) No. 428 of 2021
----[Against the judgment of conviction dated 31.08.2021 and order of sentence,
dated 02.09.2021 passed in Sessions Trial No. 53 of 2021arising out of
Domchanch P.S. Case No. 55 of 2020, by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge-III, Koderma]
1.Karu Yadav, aged about 43 years, S/o Late Kali Yadav, R/o VillageDurodih, P.O. + P.S.- Domchanch, Dist.-Koderma
2.Upendra Rana @ Upendra Kumar Sharma, aged about 32 Years, S/o Ashok
Sharma, R/o Village Durodih, P.O. + P.S.- Domchanch, Dist. - Koderma
--- --- Appellants
Versus
The State of Jharkhand
--- --- Respondent
…....
For the Appellants
For the State
: Mrs. Rashmi Kumar, Advocate
: Mrs. Nehala Sharmin, Spl.P.P.
PRESENT
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH KUMAR
JUDGMENT
By Court
1.
Heard learned counsel for the appellants and learned Spl.P.P.
representing the State.
2.
The present appeal has been preferred against the judgment of
conviction dated 31.08.2021 and order of sentence, dated 02.09.2021
passed in Sessions Trial No. 53 of 2021arising out of Domchanch P.S.
Case No. 55 of 2020, by the learned Additional Sessions Judge-III,
Koderma, whereby the appellants have been convicted for the offence
punishable under Sections 365/34 of the IPC and have been sentenced
to undergo R.I. for 2 years with a fine of Rs. 2000/- each and in
default of payment of fine, they have been further directed to undergo
S.I. for 3 months each.
3.
The criminal law has been put into motion on the fardbeyan by
the informant- Gopal Kumar Kashera recorded by the S.I. Kamla
Kumar Rai of Domchanch Police Station on 24.05.2020 at 01.20
hours.
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 428 of 2021
2026:JHHC:20808
In the said fardbeyanm the informant has stated that when he
went to take some household goods i.e., biscuits etc. from a betel shop
of Bindu situated at village Mahtadih at about 07.15 P.M. on
23.05.2020, at that moment the accused persons Karu Yadav, Upendra
Rana and Sagar Kumar , all of village Durodih, P.S. Domchanch,
Koderma came there with two motorcycles and stopped near the
informant. Accused Karu Yadav with the help of other accomplices
forced the informant to sit on the motorcycle and took him to Niru
Pahari forest area where they assaulted him brutally by lathi. The
accused Karu Yadav scolded him by saying that why he had beaten his
son and threatened him of dire consequences. Karu Yadav instigaged
the co-accused Upendra Rana to throw stone upon the informant.
However, as soon as Upendra Rana was about to throw a big stone on
the head of the informant, Police arrived there and on seeing the
police party, Upendra Rana and Sagar Kumar managed to flee away
but during the moment police chased the accused Karu Yadav and
captured him.
4.
On the basis of the above fardbeyan, the case was registered
being Domchanch P.S. Case No. 55 of 2020 dated 24.05.2020 under
Sections 364/34 of the IPC against the accused persons.
5.
Cognizance of the offence under Sections 364/34 of the IPC
was taken against the accused on 20.07.2020.
6.
On appearance of the accused, the charge for the offence under
Sections 364/34 of the IPC was framed on 07.07.2021 and the content
of charge was explained to the accused to which they pleaded not
guilty and claimed to be tried.
7.
To
substantiate
the
prosecution
story
altogether
nine
prosecution witnesses have been examined. Their brief statements are
as follows:
I.
P.W.1(Manju Devi) – She is the mother of the informant.
She has been declared hostile by the prosecution.
II.
P.W.2(Khadakdhari Yadav) – This witness has also been
declared hostile as he has shown his ignorance about the
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 428 of 2021
2026:JHHC:20808
alleged occurrence.
III.
P.W.3(Anil Kasera) – He is the father of the informant. He
has deposed that on the alleged date of occurrence he was
present at his house when some persons came thereand
forcibly abducted his son. However, he could not say as to
where his son was taken by those persons. Then he went to
the police station for giving information and later on got the
news about recovery of his son. This witness has been
declared hostile by the prosecution on the point of denial of
the further contents of the alleged occurrence. In his cross
examination he has stated that the occurrence did not happen
in is presence. He has further stated that both the accused are
co-villagers.
IV.
P.W.4(Dr. Arun Kumar) – He is the medical officer, who
has examined the injured informant and found the following
injuries on his person:
i. A swelling 1” x1” on left fore arm
ii. A cut injury on lip 1/4" x 1/4" on lower lip.
The doctor has opined that the injuries were caused by
hard and blunt substance. Time of injuries are within 06
hours. In his cross examination he has stated that such type
of injury may be caused due to fall on a hard surface.
V.
P.W.5(Gopal Kumar Kasera)- He is the informant of the
case. He has deposed in his examination-in-chief that the
alleged occurrence had happened on 23.05.2020 at about
07.15 P.M. when he went to the betel shop of Bindu situated
at Mahthadih to take some household items like biscuits etc.
At that moment, three persons namely Upendra Rana, Karu
Yadav and Sagar Kumar came there in motorcycles. They
forcibly caught hold of him and started dragging and
compelled him to sit on the motorcycle. The informant has
further deposed that there was some previous dispute with
the accused persons and due to that they took him to
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 428 of 2021
2026:JHHC:20808
Neerupahari forest area and started beating him by danda,
fist and slaps. While the accused were beating him, he
pleaded to leave him and at that moment, the Police came
there. Seeing the police, two miscreants Upendra Rana and
Sagar Kumar managed to flee away while Karu Yadav was
caught by the police. In his cross examination he has stated
that he has simply put his signature on his statement
recorded by the Police and he could not say about the
contents of the fardbeyan. He has further stated in his cross
examination that the accused persons are known to him but
he does not know about the profession of the accused
persons. He has further stated that he sustained injuries on
his hand and back side due to the scuffle with the accused
persons and for treatment he was sent to the Referral
Hospital, Domchanch. He has also admitted at para 4 of his
cross examination that he is a literate person; however, he
had not written the fardbeyan rather whatever statement was
taken by the Officer Incharge of the Police Station, he has
signed on it without reading the content. He has further
deposed that he does not know what is the content of the
fardbeyan. At para 10 of his cross examination he has
admitted the fact that there was no injury mark on his
person. However, due to scuffle some minor scratches have
occurred for which treatment was going on in the Referral
Hospital, Domchanch. After lodging the case police has not
recorded his statement. Further the case was lodged due to
mistake.
VI.
P.W.6(Kamla Kumar Rai)- He is the Investigating Officer
of the case. After getting charge of the investigation of the
case, he had gone through the fardbeyan of the informant
and then recorded restatement of the informant . He sent a
requisition for examination of the injury of the informant to
the Referral Hospital, Domchanch. He has also stated that
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 428 of 2021
2026:JHHC:20808
the alleged motorcycle used by the accused has been seized
from the place of occurrence situated at Neerupahari forest
area and seizure list was also prepared to that effect.
VII.
P.W.7 (Sunil Kasera)- He is the uncle of the informant. He
has deposed that he has only heard about the occurrence. In
his cross examination he has stated that he has simply signed
on the plain paper on the instruction of the police at the
police station. He has been declared hostile.
VIII.
P.W.8(Arvind Kumar -Chaukidar 3/4)- He is the
choukidar of Domchanch police station, who has appeared
before the court on behalf of the prosecution with the
material exhibits of the case.
IX.
P.W.9 (Anup Kumar @ Anup Kumar Thakur)-He is a
seizure witness who has proved his signature on the seizure
list. However, he has denied anything relating to the alleged
case and showed his ignorance about the informant and the
accused persons of this case. He has been declared hostile
and in his cross examination he has deposed that the police
has taken his signature on a plain paper.
8.
The prosecution has also adduced documentary evidence as
under:
I.
Exhibit -1 – Injury report of Gopal Kumar Kasera
II. Exhibit-1/1- Signature and requisition for injury report of
injured Gopal Kumar Kasera.
III. Exhibit-2-Signature of informant Gopal Kumar Kasera on
fardbeyan
IV. Exhibit-3- Seizure list.
V. Exhibit-3/2- Signature of witness Sunil Kasera on seizure list.
VI. Exhibit-4- Memo of arrest of accused Karu Yadav.
VII. Ext. 4/1- Signature of witness Sunil Kasera on memo of arrest
of accused Karu Yadav
VIII. Ext.5- Memo of arrest of accused Upendra Rana @ Upendra
Kumar Rana
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 428 of 2021
2026:JHHC:20808
IX. Material Exhibit Ext-I- A motorcycle bearing registration No.
JH-12J-6673.
9.
After conducting full-fledged trial, the learned Trial Court has
convicted and sentenced the appellants as aforesaid.
10.
Learned counsel for the appellants by referring to the above
depositions, has submitted that it is a case of no evidence. The only
available witness is the victim, who has denied the incident, even the
content of the F.I.R has been denied by him. On the above basis,
learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that the impugned
judgment needs interference by this Court.
11.
Learned counsel for the State has supported the judgment of
conviction passed by the learned Trial Court.
12.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of
the record, it appears that the informant/ victim was barely aware
about the content of the F.I.R. He has denied any kidnapping/
abduction and it has been stated that it is merely a scuffle between the
parties. Due to misunderstanding, father has gone to the police station.
13.
In view of above statements of the victim, I find no material to
sustain the conviction of the appellants. Accordingly, the judgment of
conviction dated 31.08.2021 and order of sentence, dated 02.09.2021
passed in Sessions Trial No. 53 of 2021 arising out of Domchanch P.S.
Case No. 55 of 2020, by the learned Additional Sessions Judge-III,
Koderma are quashed and set aside.
14.
The appellants are on bail. Hence, they are discharged from the
liability of their bail bond.
15.
The present criminal appeal is allowed.
16.
Let the scanned copy of the trial court record be sent to the
concerned court, forthwith.
(Rajesh Kumar, J.)
A. Mohanty
Jharkhand High Court
Dated 14th July 2026
Uploaded
___/____/2026
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 428 of 2021
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review