Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:549
Serial No. 07
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC(EP) No. 16 of 2024
In El. Pet. No. 1 of 2023
Date of Decision: 08.04.2025
Shri. Kartush R. Marak
S/o (L) Soilendro S. Momin
R/o Gasuapara, PS & PO Gauapara,
South Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
:::Petitioner
-VsShri. John Marak
S/o Sh. Raphel Sangma
R/o H No. 21, Dangsubil (Dimapara)
South Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
:::Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Applicant(s) :
Ms. Y. Pallavi, Adv. with
Mr. A.M. Pala, Adv.
For the Respondent/Opp. Party(s):
Mr. S. Jindal, Adv. with
Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
Mr. I. Kharmujai, Adv.
Ms. T. Pohlong, Adv.
2025:MLHC:549
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
This is an application under Section 379 of Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 read with Section 229 Bharatiya Nyaya
Sanhita (BNS) and Section 528 of BNSS, 2023.
2.
The instant application has been filed alleging that the respondent
has given a false statement by way of an affidavit, and committed perjury
by making false statements regarding presentation of the Election Petition
before the Stamp Reporter of this Court in accordance with Section 81 of
the Representation of People’s Act, 1951.
3.
The point in contention is whether contradictory statements made in
a show cause reply filed in an earlier application under Order 7 Rule 11 of
the CPC, and Section 86 of the RP Act 1951, and the Evidence on Affidavit
filed by the Election Petitioner, with regard to the identity and name of the
official/person before whom the Election Petition was allegedly presented,
would amount to tendering false evidence, and therefore, liable for
prosecution under the law.
2025:MLHC:549
4.
Ms. Y. Pallavi, learned counsel appearing for the applicant has
submitted that Section 227 and 229 of the BNS 2023 are the provisions that
deal with giving false evidence and punishment for the same. She submits
that prima facie the ingredients of Section 227 of the BNS are satisfied,
inasmuch as, the petitioner has deposed in the show cause reply dated
04.07.2023, that the presentation of the Election Petition was made before
Smti. S. Lanong. However, she submits contrary to the said statement, the
Election Petitioner in his Evidence on Affidavit dated 11.09.2024, claims
to have made a personal presentation before Smti. Sunita Lyngksor. She
thus submits that the same being blatant, demonstrates the fact that false
evidence has been led to mislead this Court and abuse the process of law.
In support of her submissions, the learned counsel has relied upon series of
judgments, which are noted hereinbelow:
(i)
State of Punjab vs. Jasbir Singh, 2022 SCC OnLine
SC 1240
(ii)
Umrao Lal vs. State, AIR 1954 Allahabad 424
(iii)
Amarsang Nathaji vs. Hardik Harshadbhai Patel &
Ors., (2017) 1 SCC 113
(iv)
Rasiklal Manikchand Dhariwal & Anr. vs. M.S.S.
Food Products (2012) 2 SCC 196
2025:MLHC:549
(v)
Bhagwan Singh vs. State of UP & Ors., 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 2599
5.
The learned counsel submits that in the light of the aforesaid
judgments, this Court may in accordance with Section 379 of the BNSS,
pass necessary orders for lodging an appropriate complaint before the
Jurisdictional Magistrate against the Election Petitioner.
6.
In reply, Mr. S. Jindal, learned counsel for the respondent/Opp. Party
(Election Petitioner in the main case) has firstly submitted that the instant
application is not in conformity with the High Court Rules, inasmuch as, no
leave was sought from this Court which is violative of Rule 10 of Chapter
8A of the Gauhati High Court Rules, as adapted by this Court, which
mandates that prior permission and/or leave from this Court be taken
before filing of any miscellaneous application in the Election Petition. The
application it is submitted, being an offshoot of the main Election Petition,
notwithstanding the fact that various provisions of the BNS and BNSS
have been invoked, the High Court Rules as applicable, will necessarily
have to be complied with.
7.
It is further submitted that the applicant is seeking prosecution of the
Election Petitioner under Section 229 of the BNS, which requires that the
evidence has to be shown or proved to be false, and false evidence should
have been intentionally submitted by the accused person. It is further
2025:MLHC:549
submitted that the defination of the word ‘evidence’ as count in Section
2(1)(e) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA) 2023, has defined
evidence as to mean and include or statements which the Court permits or
requires to be made before it by witnesses in relation to matters of fact
under inquiry. In this context he submits, this Court would have to
determine as to whether the statements made in the show cause affidavit
and an Affidavit on Evidence filed can be constituted as evidence. In
support of his contention, the learned counsel has placed reliance on the
case of Ayaaubkhan Noorkhan Pathan vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
reported in (2013) 4 SCC 465, which he submits held that, an affidavit is
not evidence within the meaning of Section 3 of the Evidence Act, 1872.
As such, he contends, this judgment makes it clear that as on date there is
no evidence on record.
8.
It is then submitted that contradiction does not amount to perjury,
and if the two affidavits filed contradict each other, it cannot amount to
perjury, and at best is a contradiction that has arisen between a previously
made statement and a recent statement, which can be resolved by crossexamination to determine the truth. The contradiction he submits, is only in
the surname of the Stamp Reporter, which is inadvertent and not
intentional, and as such, an examination of the concerned Stamp Reporter
will clarify the issue. Further he submits, the material aspect of the
2025:MLHC:549
affidavits is the assertion that the Election Petition had been presented to
the Stamp Reporter, which has remained unchanged in both the affidavits,
except for the name mentioned therein. Learned counsel has also referred
to a recent judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of James Kunjwal
vs. State of Uttarakhand & Anr., 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1943, wherein it
has been held that the prosecution for perjury should be sanctioned by
Courts only in those cases, where the perjury appears to be deliberate and
conscious and conviction is reasonably probable or likely. In conclusion he
submits that, there is no question of any perjury having been made or
committed by the Election Petitioner, as there is nothing in the application
filed by the applicant to dispel the fact that the Election Petitioner had
personally presented the Election Petition, before the Stamp Reporter.
9.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, without alluding to
the details, the only question to be decided is whether the contradiction that
has appeared in the show cause and affidavit of the Election Petitioner, as
to the name of the Stamp Reporter, will amount to an offence under Section
229 of the BNS, 2023. At this juncture, it would be expedient to reproduce
hereinbelow Section 227 and Section 229 of the BNS 2023.
“227. Giving false evidence.- Whoever, being legally bound
by an oath or by an express provision of law to state the truth,
or being bound by law to make a declaration upon any
2025:MLHC:549
subject, makes any statement which is false, and which he
either knows or believes to be false or does not believe to be
true, is said to give false evidence.
Explanation 1.—A statement is within the meaning of this
section, whether it is made verbally or otherwise.
Explanation 2.—A false statement as to the belief of the
person attesting is within the meaning of this section, and a
person may be guilty of giving false evidence by stating that
he believes a thing which he does not believe, as well as by
stating that he knows a thing which he does not know.
229.
Punishment
for
false
evidence.-
(1)
Whoever
intentionally gives false evidence in any stage of a judicial
proceeding, or fabricates false evidence for the purpose of
being used in any stage of a judicial proceeding, shall be
punished with imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to seven years, and shall also be liable to
fine which may extend to ten thousand rupees.
(2) Whoever intentionally gives or fabricates false evidence in
any case other than that referred to in sub-section (1), shall
be punished with imprisonment of either description for a
term which may extend to three years, and shall also be liable
to fine which may extend to five thousand rupees.”
10.
A perusal of the above noted Sections, shows that the statement
made must be false, and also that the same must be intentional for the
purpose of being used in any stage of a judicial proceeding. As held in the
2025:MLHC:549
case of Chajoo Ram vs. Radhey Shyam & Anr. reported in (1971) 1 SCC
774, the prosecution for perjury should be sanctioned by Courts, only in
those cases where the perjury appears to be deliberate and conscious, and
further prosecution should be ordered, when it is considered expedient in
the interest of justice to punish the delinquent and not merely because there
is some inaccuracy in the statement, which may be innocent or immaterial.
Further, in the case of Bhima Razu Prasad vs. State represented by Deputy
Supdt. of Police, CBI/SPE/ACU-II reported in (2021) 19 SCC 25, three
essential factors which can be said to be sine qua non for the application of
Section 193 IPC have been illustrated, which are (i) false statement made
On Oath or in affidavits (ii) such statements be made in a judicial
proceeding or (iii) such statement be made before an authority that has
been expressly deemed to be a ‘Court’. These above noted judgments have
been referred to in a recent judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of
James Kunjwal(supra), wherein the three judge bench at Para 16 thereof,
had crystalized the law on this aspect.
“16. What we may conclude from a perusal of the abovenoticed judicial pronouncements is that:(i) The Court should be of the prima facie opinion that there
exists
sufficient
and
reasonable
ground
to
initiate
proceedings against the person who has allegedly made a
false statement(s);
2025:MLHC:549
(ii) Such proceedings should be initiated when doing the
same is “expedient in the interests of justice to punish the
delinquent” and not merely because of inaccuracy in
statements that may be innocent/immaterial;
(iii) There should be “deliberate falsehood on a matter of
substance”;
(iv) The Court should be satisfied that there is a reasonable
foundation for the charge, with distinct evidence and not
mere suspicion;
(v)
Proceedings
should
be
initiated
in
exceptional
circumstances, for instance, when a party has perjured
themselves to beneficial orders from the Court.”
11.
In the instant case, the counsel for the applicant has been at pains to
impress upon the fact that the statements made on affidavit will amount to
tendering of evidence, as held in the case of Rasiklal Manikchand
Dhariwal(supra), which has pronounced that an Examination-in-Chief in
the form of an affidavit, which is always sworn before the Oath
Commissioner or a Notary or Judicial Officer, the same is thus an oath
already. In the instant case, what has been maintained by the Election
Petitioner is that the evidence has to be shown that it is false, but however,
as to which of the two statements is correct, that is the name of the Stamp
Reporter, the same is yet to be established or determined. Further, is the
2025:MLHC:549
contention that the statements have never been made intentionally knowing
them to be false, and at the most, will amount to a contradiction, and an
inaccuracy, brought about by a bonafide mistake.
12.
In the face of these circumstances, and in the light of the conditions
as illustrated in the case of James Kunjwal(supra), this Court finds force in
the contentions of the Election Petitioner, and it is held that the ingredients
of Section 229 BNS, are not met, moreover, as the substantial facts are yet
to be determined. The instant application therefore is not entertained and is
dismissed.
Judge
Meghalaya
08.04.2025
“D.Thabah-PS”
THABAH
Date: 2025.06.27 00:11:38 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review