Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:553
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC (EP) No. 18 of 2023 in
El. Pet. No. 1 of 2023
Date of Decision: 19.06.2024
Vs.
Shri Kartush R. Marak
Shri John Marak
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)/Applicant(s): Ms. Y. Pallavi, Adv. with
Ms. S. Nongrum, Adv.
Mr. A.M. Pala, Adv.
Mr. M. Prasad, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Jindal, Adv. with
Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
Mr. I. Kharmujai, Adv.
Ms. B. Jyrwa, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This application under Order 7 Rule 11 has been filed
by the respondent/applicant herein, for rejection of the election
petition and for dismissal of the same, as not being maintainable
2024:MLHC:553
under the provisions of the Representation of People Act, 1951
(herein referred to as RP Act, 1951) read with Chapter VIII-A of the
Gauhati High Court Rules (as adopted).
2.
The main contention is that the election petition has
been filed contrary to Section 81 of the RP Act, 1951 and Rule 1 of
Chapter VIII-A of the Gauhati High Court Rules as adopted, which
requires that the election petition must be presented by any
candidate or any elector before the Stamp Reporter of this Court.
The election petitioner, it is alleged had not presented the election
petition in accordance with the aforementioned provisions, which
therefore by the operation of Section 86 of the RP Act, 1951 should
be dismissed.
3.
Ms.
Y.
Pallavi,
learned
counsel
for
the
applicant/respondent has submitted that Section 81(1) strictly
provides that the election petitioner must present the election to the
authorized officer of the High Court i.e. the Stamp Reporter who is
the Assistant Registrar-III, and that the same must be presented duly
verified in the form prescribed with the requisite Court Fee affixed
thereon within 45 days from the date of the results of the election.
She submits that the election petitioner by himself in Para-11 of the
2024:MLHC:553
show cause reply to the instant Misc. Case has stated that the
election petition was presented before the Assistant Registrar (Smti
S. Lanong) on 21.03.2023, which she contends was not the
Assistant Registrar-III, and that further there is no endorsement of
the Stamp Reporter on the petition. It is further submitted that the
report of the Stamp Reporter does not show that the petition was
personally presented by the election petitioner.
4.
The learned counsel then submits that the election
petition served on the respondent and the certified copy of the
election petition shows that many pages of the election petition had
not been attested by the notary public and the election petition
served on the petitioner does not at all bear the seal and signature of
the notary public. She contends therefore, the election petitioner has
not filed the election petition accompanied by as many copies which
is the mandatory requirement of Section 81(3) of the RP Act, 1951.
The learned counsel also submits that Section 86 of the Act serves
as a threshold bar to entertain election petitions not filed in
compliance with Sections 81 or 82 of the Act, and that Section 86
and Article 329(b) of the Constitution of India are to be read
together, which expressly bar any election petition from being
2024:MLHC:553
entertained, if the same is not in compliance with the specific
provisions of the RP Act, 1951. The learned counsel has in support
of her submissions relied upon the followings judgments and
orders:-
5.
i)
MC (EP) No. 19 of 2023 in El. Pet. No. 2 of 2023 (Shri
Gavin Miguel Mylliem & Ors. vs. Shri Titosstar Well
Chyne)
ii)
Jamal Uddin Ahmad vs. Abu Saleh Najmuddin & Anr.
2003 4 SCC 257 (Para-14)
iii)
G.V. Sreerama Reddy vs. Returning Officer (2009) 8
SCC 736 (Para-7)
She finally submits that no evidence is required in the
matter since the petition had not been presented personally by the
election petitioner, and that there is no effective reply to the instant
Misc. application except for bald statements without any material in
particular. Evidence, she contends can be led only if there are
requisite pleadings in this regard, and that the same being absent in
the instant case and with the petitioner’s admission that there was
no endorsement by the Stamp Reporter, the election petition should
be dismissed.
6.
In reply Mr. S. Jindal, learned counsel for the election
petitioner submits that firstly, no written statement has been filed by
2024:MLHC:553
the respondent till date. On the contentions raised by the applicant,
it is submitted that the election petitioner was present before the
Stamp Reporter on the date of presentation i.e. 21.03.2023, and that
each and every page of the petition along with annexures thereto
had been duly signed by the election petitioner personally, duly
verified in a proper manner and notarised in Shillong. The learned
counsel contends that the instant application under Order 7 Rule 11
is not maintainable, inasmuch as, no leave was sought from the
Court, which is violative of Rule 10 Chapter VIII-A of the Gauhati
High Court Rules. It is also submitted that the application does not
satisfy the requirement of Order 7 Rule 11 (d) CPC, inasmuch as,
the respondent has not pointed out any statement made in the plaint,
which would make the Suit barred by law. In this context, reliance
has been placed on the judgment of Prem Kishore & Ors. vs.
Brahm Prakash & Ors. reported in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 356.
7.
The learned counsel submits that for the suit to be
barred in law, the bar in question has to be a threshold bar that
prevents the Court even to take cognizance of the matter as
contemplated under Section 9 CPC. He submits that as this Court
has already taken cognizance of the instant matter, there cannot be a
2024:MLHC:553
threshold bar as the power under 86 (1) of the RP Act, can be
exercised even at the stage of judgment. The learned counsel then
reiterates that the election petitioner had personally presented the
election petition and that the office note/check slip dated
21.03.2023 issued by the Stamp Reporter having passed the same,
there is a presumption of compliance in favour of the election
petitioner. It is further submitted that the contention that the election
petitioner was personally not present is vague and ambiguous and is
not substantiated by any material on record, and hence the burden
lies on the respondent to prove the same as per Section 101 of the
Evidence Act. On the judgment presented by the applicant, i.e. GV
Sreerama Reddy (supra) the learned counsel submits that the same
will not be applicable as there is no objection or a registry note
present in the instant case to raise doubts about any improper
presentation. With regard to the judgment of this Court i.e. Gavin
Miguel Mylliem (supra) dated 14.03.2024, the learned counsel
submits this Court has held that the issue of presentation cannot be
determined without adducing evidence in such regard. He therefore,
submits that as there is no merit in the instant application, the same
should be dismissed.
2024:MLHC:553
8.
Having heard the learned counsels for the parties, in
conformity with the earlier judgments of this Court passed in the
same issue, this Court deems it fit that at this stage only the
objections as to the presentation of the election petition be
considered, and the other allegations with regard to attestation etc.
be taken up at a later stage consequent upon any future orders that
will be finally passed as to whether the election petition was
presented as per the requirement of Section 81(1) of the RP Act.
9.
An overview of the contentions, allegations and replies
thereto, as presented in application, show cause and arguments of
the respective counsels, it can be seen that the crux of the matter lies
on the issue as to whether the election petition was presented in the
manner prescribed by law on 21.03.2023, before the Stamp
Reporter. It is noted that there is some confusion as to who is the
Stamp Reporter before whom the election petition was presented
and whether the election petitioner was present personally. As has
been held by this Court in MC (EP) No. 19 of 2023 in El. Pet. No.
2 of 2023 (Shri Gavin Miguel Mylliem & Ors. vs. Shri Titosstar
Well Chyne) in its order dated 31.10.2023 and MC (EP) No. 25 of
2023 in El. Pet No. 7 of 2023 (Shri Rupa M. Marak vs. James
2024:MLHC:553
Pangsang Kongkal Sangma & Ors. dated 14.03.2024, in the instant
case also, it is seen that it would not be possible on the basis of
pleadings to come to any conclusive findings, as to the correct
presentation of the election petition. Accordingly, this Court deems
it fit to take up the issue of presentation of the election petition as a
preliminary issue for consideration. The objection that the instant
application has been filed without leave of this Court is overlooked
and not considered as the same has been made under the procedural
provision of Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.
10.
It is therefore ordered that the issue as to the
presentation of the election petition shall be taken up as a
preliminary issue for consideration.
11.
This Misc. application accordingly stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
19.06.2024
signed by
VALENTINO Digitally
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2024.06.19
LYNDEM
17:00:52 +05'30'
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review