The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. The writ petition is allowed in the above terms.
20. In view of the order passed today, the Original Application bearing O.A. No. 28 of 2023 stands allowed in these terms.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S/L 26
24.02.2026
Court No.04
B.K.N
W.P.S.T. 166 of 2023
Kartic Alias Kartick Biswas
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Uttiya Ray,
Mr. Ashutosh Pal,
Mr. Atish Santra
… for the Petitioner.
Mr. Tapan Kumar Mukherjee, Ld. AGP,
Ms. Sangeeta Roy
… for the State.
1. Heard learned advocate for the petitioner and the
learned advocate for the State.
2. The present petitioner made a claim for appointment on
compassionate ground in view of demise of his father in
harness. His claim was rejected on 03.05.2018 by an
order issued by the Joint Secretary to the Government of
West Bengal in the Public Works Department. The
reason assigned for rejection of the claim was that the
petitioner’s father was not brought in the regular
establishment.
3. The order of the Joint Secretary dated 03.05.2018 was
assailed by the writ petitioner before the West Bengal
Administrative Tribunal (SAT) in O.A. No. 40 of 2019.
The Tribunal set aside the order of the Joint Secretary
dated 03.05.2018 and remitted the matter to authority
to reconsider by a reasoned and speaking order after
affording an opportunity of hearing to the writ
petitioner
and
on
going
through
the
records,
considering the law laid down in the judgment of one
Manoj Kumar Sharma.
4. After consideration in terms of the order passed in O.A.
No. 40 of 2019 an order with reason was passed by the
Secretary to the Government of West Bengal in the
Public
Works
Department.
The
same
contains
conclusion in the following terms:
“C.
Conclusion
As per direction of The Hon’ble West Bengal
Administrative Tribunal opportunity of
hearing to the applicant was given and the records
verified again. After verification of the records it is
concluded that
1.
None
can
claim
compassionate
appointment, on the occurrence of death/ medical
incapacitation of the concerned employee, as if it
were a vested right, and any appointment without
considering the financial condition of the family of
the deceased is legally impermissible.
2.
Compassionate appointment can only be
made on Group C and Group D posts subject to
satisfaction that the family members have been
facing financial distress and that an appointment
on compassionate ground may assist them to tide
over such distress is not enough, a dependent must
fulfill the eligibility criteria for appointment.
3.
The applicant did not fulfill the
criteria of educational qualification and
maximum age limit as per extant rules since
he is Class VI pass and his present age is
more than 45 years.
4.
In spite of considering the deceased
employee deemed to have been absorbed in the
regular establishment the present applicant is
ineligible on other criteria.
D.
Order with reason
1.
In view of the above it is finally concluded
that the application dated 29.06.2011 of the
applicant has been scrutinized in the light of
relevant Government orders which are in force.
After scrutinizing the application it is found that
the applicant, Sri Kartic Biswas did not fulfill the
criteria as laid down in Notification No. 251-Emp.
Dated 03/12/2013, West Bengal Services (Group
D) Recruitment Rules, 2009.
2.
Thus the application of Sri Kartic Biswas, son
of Late Sankar Biswas is considered, but rejected
due to the reasons stated above.”
5. This order of 01.12.2022 was put to challenge before the
SAT again in O.A. No. 28 of 2023. The Tribunal
disposed of the petitioner’s Original Application without
passing any orders and without interfering with the
order dated 01.12.2022 rejecting his claim.
6. The learned advocate for the writ petitioner submits that
from the conclusions recorded by the Secretary in the
impugned order it is obvious that the petitioner’s claim
was rejected for not having the requisite educational
qualification and since he was found to be overage.
7. He submits that insofar as the issue of petitioner’s age,
the conclusion is unsustainable as the age of the
petitioner on the date of demise of his father is the age
relevant for consideration under the scheme. The date of
unfortunate demise of the petitioner’s father is
11.02.2011. The age for eligibility for appointment on
compassionate ground, therefore, on the date of demise
of his father is the relevant date. Because the authorities
have delayed consideration for over a decade, the
petitioner cannot be made to suffer.
8. Insofar as the other criteria regarding not possessing the
educational qualification (7th), he submits that there is a
specific provision in the notification dated 03.12.2013
bearing no. 251-Emp enabling relaxation of the
educational
qualification.
The
authorities
were,
therefore, required to consider the petitioner’s claim for
relaxation of this requisite qualification in terms of Note
(b) of Clause 6 of the notification no. 251-Emp which
has not been done.
9. The learned AGP on the other hand submits that there is
no dispute that the petitioner did not possess the
requisite educational qualification, the order of the
Secretary dated 01.12.2022, therefore, requires no
interference. The Tribunal has rightly rejected the
Original Application.
10. We have considered the rival submissions. The
conclusions and order of the Secretary in the impugned
order dated 01.12.2022, extracted above leaves no room
for doubt that the financial condition of the family of the
deceased and the financial distress arising from sudden
loss of their bread earner are issues germane to the
claim for compassionate appointment. The conclusions
in this regard require no interference.
11. We, however, consider it worth mentioning that these
issues were not enquired into by the authority
competent to consider the petitioner’s claim. The
scheme for appointment contemplates consideration of
such issue by a Three Member Committee. There is
nothing on record to show that these issues were ever
considered by the Three Member Committee.
12. Insofar as the maximum age criteria is concerned, we
are in agreement with the submission advanced on
behalf of the petitioner that he cannot be non suited for
the delay attributable to the State authorities in
considering his claim.
13. Insofar the issue regarding the petitioner’s father being
a work charge employee, the same is laid to rest by the
conclusion no. 4, extracted above since authorities,
having regard to the long period, nearly 37 years served
by
the
petitioner’s
father
in
the
work
charge
establishment, have considered the petitioner’s claim
deeming his father to be absorbed in the regular
establishment.
14. Therefore, an only issue which arises and remains is
whether on account of not possessing their requisite
educational qualification for appointment under the
General Rule (6th Pass), the petitioner could be deprived
of a benefit of compassionate appointment. We are
unable to agree with such conclusion of the Secretary.
The scheme as contained in notification no. 251-Emp
and
the
other
notifications
governing
the
field
contemplates an enquiry by a Three Member Committee
as regards the financial condition and financial distress
for the purposes of eligibility for compassionate
appointment. The authorities, therefore, were primarily
required to consider this issue by referring the
petitioner’s claim to the Three Member Committee for a
thorough examination of this issue and decision in this
regard. We are of such opinion because the relevant
provision allows a relaxation of the educational
qualification in Note (b) which reads:
“Note: (b) Relaxation in educational qualification
may be granted in eligible cases for appointment to
Group „D‟ post in consultation with the Finance
Department.”
15. From plain reading of the provision it is more than
obvious that
the relaxation can be granted in
consultation with the Finance Department but in
“eligible cases”. Considering this provision we had
earlier allowed the learned AGP an opportunity to take
instructions as to whether there is any elaboration of
this “eligible cases” by any guideline or executive
instruction. Today he submits upon instruction that
there is no such executive instruction or guideline. Such
being the circumstance we are of the view that the only
possible way of defining the expression “eligible cases”
employed under Note (b) of Clause 6, is to rely upon the
other eligibility specified in Rule 6 being the criteria of
financial destitution, the monthly income of the family
and other such requirements as stated in Clause 6 of the
251-Emp.
16. We are, therefore, of the opinion that the authority
(Secretary) of the Public Works Department should
ensure consideration of the petitioner’s claim and his
entitlement with reference to the other eligibility criteria
specified in Clause 6 of 251-Emp. If after such
consideration the claim of the petitioner is found to be
otherwise eligible then appropriate steps are required to
be taken for considering a relaxation of the educational
qualification in terms of Note (b) (supra).
17. To facilitate such consideration we remit the matter to
the Secretary, Government of West Bengal in the Public
Works Department, respondent no. 1. We make it clear
that while according such consideration the conclusions
contained in the earlier order dated 01.12.2022 shall not
come in the way. Let such consideration be accorded
without raising an objection regarding the petitioner’s
age in view of our findings and observations recorded
above.
18. Insofar as the other criteria are concerned the procedure
applicable for a compassionate appointment is required
to be adopted and followed. Let the entire exercise be
completed within a period of three months from the
date of receipt/production of a copy of this order before
the respondent no. 1.
19. The writ petition is allowed in the above terms.
20. In view of the order passed today, the Original
Application bearing O.A. No. 28 of 2023 stands allowed
in these terms.
21. Urgent Photostat Certified copy of this order, if applied
for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance with all
necessary formalities.
(Madhuresh Prasad, J.)
(Prasenjit Biswas, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review