Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3383 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF NOVEMBER
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY
WRIT PET TION NO: 37263 0F 2026
Between:
Karasala Prasad Rao, s/o. Karasara venkata Subbaiah, Aged about 67 years,
Occ ; Contractor, R/o. H.No 7-15gl2, Naspur Colony, Near Enarat petrof 6ump,
Naspur, Naspur Mandal, Mancherial Djstrict.
AND
.....PET|T|ONER
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its principal Secretary Municipal
Admintstratton Department, Secretariat Building, Hyderabad.
Mancherial Municipar corporation, Rep. by its commissioner, Mancheriar,
Mancherial District.
3. The Town Pranning officer, Mancheriar Municipar corporation, Mancheriar,
Mancherial District.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Articre 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased
to issue an appropriate writ, order or Direction, more particurarry one in the nature
of
writ of Mandamus, declaring the action of the 2nd Respondent in issuing the
shortfall Letter bearing Notice No.oB2oso/MANcloo721AAB]t2o26 dated
29.10 2026, in respect of the petitioner's apprication for buirding permission for the
land bearing PIot No.12 admeasuring to an extent of 201.66 square yards or 16g.60
square Meters in sy.No.24, situated at Naspur vilage, Naspur Mandar, within the
limits of Mancheriar Municipar corporation, Mancheriar District, on the ground that
the regrstered sale deed of the petitioner was executed after the LRS culoff date of
26.08.2020 and the plot does not saflsfy the eligibility criteria prescribed under Rule
4(a) of c.O.Ms.No 13't MAandUD dated 31.08.2020, as iilegat, arbitrary, violative of
Articles 14, 21 and l)00-A of the Constittrtion of lndia and contrary to the law laid
down by this Hon'ble Court, set aside the same and consequently direct the 2nd
Respondent to grant cuilding permission, luithout reference to the impugned Shortfall
Letter dated 29.10 2A26.
|.A.NO:1 OF 2026
Petition Under Section 151 CPC p-aying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition the High Court may be pleased to direct
the 2nd Responden'. to grant building permission, in respect of the Plot No.12
admeasuring to an,lxtent of 201.66 Sq,rare Yards or 168.60 Square Meters in
Sy.No.24, situated at Naspur Village, Naspur Mandal, within the limits of Mancherial
Municipal Corporatic,n, Mancherial Distr ct, without reference to the impugned
Shortfall Letter dated 29.10.2026, pending disposal of the main writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI THOOM SRINIVAS
Counsel for the Respondent No.l : GP t'OR MCPL ADMN AND URBAN DEV
Counsel forthe Respondent Nos.2 & 3 : SRI PUTTA KRISHNA REDDY
The Court made the following ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY
WRIT PETITION No.87263 of 2026
(CNR. No. I{ BHC0 I 07653220261
DATE: O4.11.2026
Between:
Karasaia Prasad Rao
Pctitioner
AND
The State of Telangana
Rep. by its Principal Secretary
Municipal Administration Department,
Secretariat, Hyderabad & 2 others
.
.l?espondents
ORDER:1
.
This Writ Petition is filed seeking to declare the action of 2na
Respondent in issuing the Shortfall Letter bearing Notice No.
082050/ MAN C / OO7 2 | I LABP / 2026 dated 29. 10.2026 in respect of
the Petitioners application for building permission for the land
bearing Plot No.12, admeasuring to an extent of 2OL.66 Square
Yards or 168.60 Square Meters in Sy.No 24, situated at Naspur
Village, Naspur Mandal, within the limits of Mancherial Municipal
Corporation, Mancherial District on the ground that the registered
sale deed of the Petitioner was executed after the LRS cutoff date of
26.Oa.2O2O and the plot does not satisfy the eligibility criteria
I
i
prescribed under Rule a(a) of G'O tvl s No 13 1 Ir4A
and UD dated
31.08.2020 as iliegal and arbitrary 'rnd for consequential
relief'
HeardSriThoomSrinivas,leztrner]counselforthepetitioner
and Sri Putta Krishna Reddy, learned Standing Cour:rsel
l,4ancherial Muni':ipal Corporation appearing
for
for respondent Nos'2
o[J
3.
Learned ccunsel for the cetitioner as well as
Standing Counsr:l for respondent Nos 2 & 3
learned
submitted that the
issue raised in the present writ petition is sqr'rarcly
covered by the
order dated 02.O2.2O22 passed in W P'No 515O
of 2022 and prayed
to pass similar order in the instanl. writ petition
as well'
4,Inviewofthesubmissionsmadebyleerrnedcounseiforthe
petitioner arld lt:arned Standing Counsel for respondent
this Writ Petitr.on is disposed of in terms of the
Nos 2 & 3'
order dated
O2.O2.2O22 passed in W P No'51"O of 2022'
Miscellaneous applications pending' if any'
shall stand
closed. There shall be no order as to costs'
Sd/.P.PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTAI{T REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
A-
sEc qoN OFFICER
To
1. The Principal Secretary, Municipal Administration Department' Secretariat
Building, State of Telangana at Hylerabad
2. The 6omrrissioner, Mancherill Municipal Corporation, Mancherial'
Mancherial District.
3. The Town Planning Officer, Mancherial Municipal Corporation, Mancherial,
Mancherial District.
Two CCs to GP FOR MCPL AI)MN AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT, High
Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OUT]
5. One CC to SRI THOOM SRINIVAS, Advocate [OPUC]
one CC to SRI PUTTA KRISHNA REDDY, Advocate (OPUC)
7. Two CD Copies
(Along with a copy of the order dated 02-02'2O22 passed in WP'No.5150
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0411112026
ORDER
WP.No.37263t of 2026
ofl
*
.)
J
o
i
1 HE S-.ii
Nttv
,i
'325
*
DISPOSING OF THE W.P
PWITHOUT COSTS.
c
1b
z
o
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE P.MADHAVI DEVI
W.P. No.S1 50 of2022
ORDER:
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner seeking
a writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in
not considering the petitioner's application for grant of building
permission for construction of residential building in open plot
in an extent of 191.33 sq.yds., in Sy.Nos.247/1, Housing Board,
Jagityal Municipality, Kariminagar district on the ground that
the same is not coming under cut of date of layout
regularization scheme, 2O2O as per G.O.Ms.No.131, dated
37 .O8.2O2O as illegal and arbitrary.
2.
Brief facts leading to the flling of this case are that the
petitioner had purchased the subject plot vide registered sale
deed No.4803/ 2O2l dated O4.O9.2O27 and thereafter, when the
petitioner applied for building permission ttrrough TS b-pass
instant approval was given on 14.09.2027. Thereafter, vide
order dated 05.11.2027 the building permission dated
74.09.2021was revoked with the following remarks:
PMD. J
w.P.No.i 150 of202:
)
"'lhe title & techniccl scruting officers are
not recommend.ed due tt "The proposed plot is
foming patt of unauthorized lagout and not
applied under LRS. The plot is registered
afier cut-off date i.e., 26.O8.2020 and has no
regtstered link docum<:nt pior to the cut-off
date". This application is reuoked."
Challenging the same, this writ l)etition is filed.
3.
Counsel for both the parties are heard.
4.
During the course of hea:-ing, the learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that this nlatter is squarely covered by the
order passed by this Court Ln W.P. No.19i56 of 2O2l on
17 .O4.2O27 and this
writ petition may also be disposed of in
terms of the said order.
5-
For ready reference, th,: relevant portion of the order
passed in !r\r.P. No.19156 of 2C2l on 17.O8.2O21 is reproduced
hereunder:
"3. Admittedly, the l)etitioner herein acquired
the said plot in an unapproved layout. The
grievance of the petitioner in the present writ
petition is that the rr'spondent authorities ale
n(,t accepting the application of the petitioner for
PMD, J
w P.No.5i50 of?022
grant of building permission on the ground that
the subject plot falls under unapproved layout
and is not recognized within the scheme
introduced by the 1st respondent vide
G.O.Ms.No. 131, dated 31.08.2020.
4. During the course of arguments, it is
brought to the notice of the Court that the
Commissioner, Grealer 2 Hyderabad Municipal
Corporation, in respect of unapproved layouts,
issued Memo No.14148/PLG.lll l2O2O, dated
3O.72.2o2O, and a copy of the same is placed on
record by the learned counsel for the petitioner
as material paper and the said memo reads as
under:
"Buitding permission in such
plots/sites may be considered by
the Competent Authodty bY
collecting basic penalization
charges as per LRS-2O15 and
33% compounding fee on the
same, plus open
space
contribution charges (14%) on
the present ma-rket value of the
site/plot applied for Building
Permission."
5. It is very much evident from the above
memo that the applications for building
permissions can be considered by the competent
authorities by collecting 337o compounding fee
on the same plus open space contribution
charges at 14o/o on thle market value of the plot
PMD. J
W.P No 5150 of2022
.l
applied for building perrrission. The Government
issued the said memo in respect of the
plots/sites, for which no applicatioa under Land
regldarisation Scheme uas submitted. It is also
ver}- much evident from the reading of the above
merno that the building application of the
petitioner herein desenes to be considered in
terrns of the said m,:mo dated 30.12.2020
subject to compliance of statutory requirements.
ri. Accordingly, the \Vrit Petition is disposed
of, directing the respo,ldent - Municipa-lity to
accept the application o,'the petitioner herein for
building permission itr terms of the Memo
No.14148/PLG. [/2020.
dated 30.12.2020
issred by the Commissjoner, Greater Hyderabad
Municipal Corporation and 3 pass appropriate
orclers, as per law. As a sequel, the
miscellaneous petitionr, if any, shall stand
closed. There shall be n I order as to costs."
6.
Thus, the petitioner is seeking relaxation ofthe conditions
of G.O.Ms.No.131, dated 31.08.2020 and G.O.Ms.No.135, dated
76.09.2020 in terms of the Memo No.14148/PLG .IIll2O2O,
dated 30.12.202O.
.
Havirrg regard to ttre facts of the case and material on
record, this Court finds that after formation of the State of
PMD. .,
W.P.No 5150 of2022
Telangana in 2014, the Government of Telangana issued
G.O.Ms.No. 151 dated O2. 1 1.2015 with the following objective:
"Govemment of Telangana with a view to
promoting planned development of urban areas
in the State are encouraging development
through approved layouts and development of
integrated townships t}rough both public alrd
private initiative. However, Govemment has
observed that there are many unapproved and
illegal layouts which are not only in violation of
the Statutory Development Plan/Master Plan
and Layout Rules but also deficient in layout
norms and development standards and lacking
in basic civic infrastructure facfities like proper
roads, street lights and drainage. On account of
the above, frequent complaints are being
received from the public. Such substaldard ald
unapproved sub-divisions of land into building
plots is not only defeating the very objective of
planned development but also affecting the
plalned extension of services and amenities by
the local bodies. Government have in the past
brought out a scheme of regularization of such
unapproved layouts but they met with limited
success since it was a voluntary scheme with
onus on plot owners to come forward for
regularisation and there were no deterrent
provisions against the owners who did not come
forward for regularization. Therefore in order to
bring a1l these unplanned areas into the fold of
PMD, J
W.P.No.il50 of 2022
planned development ;rnd to provide basic
facilities in these areas so as to promote an
overall and integrated area urnd city level
development and a bett,tr quality of life for the
citizens, Government hereby issue the Rules for
Regularization of Unapproved and Illegal
Laycuts."
The said G.C. was made effectivs from 28.1O.2015 and
Rule 2 thereof read as under;
"2. Applicability:
(a)
'Ihese Rules shall be applicable to Hyderabad
Metropolitan Development Authority, Kakatiya
Urbaa Development Authority ald Basara
Urban Developmen: Authority, Municipa.l
Corporations, Mur icipalities and Gram
Panchayats falling in the Master Pla-n limits in
the State of Telanga-r: a.
(b)
These Rules and cc,nditions herein sha_ll be
applicable to all existing unapproved
sub-division of plots, existing unapproved
layouts or ventures promoted by land
owners/private devr:lopers/firms/compalies/
property developers,'Societies where the plots
have been sold by registered sale deed on or
before 28.10.2015.
PMD, J
W P.No 5i50 of 2022
(c)
These Rules are only intended for regulating
the unplanned development and shall be
applicable to a1l unapproved layout areas
which have clearance from the competent
authorities under the Urban land Ceiling and
Regulation Act 7976, AP Land Reforms
(Ceiling on Agricultural Holdings) Act' 7973
wherever required and which have not been
entered in the Prohibitory Register of lalds
maintained by the Revenue Department. The
Regularisation measure would not absolve the
plots or layout from the application of Land
ceililg Laws, land disputes or claims over
title, boundary deisputes, etc. In respect of
assigned lalds, prior clearance from the
Distdct Collector sha.ll be obtained.
(d)
In the event of only some plot holders coming
forward for regularization in an unapproved
layout, the layout pattem as approved by the
competent authority shall be applicable to the
entire layout area. The local authority shall
be responsible for enforcing such approved
layout pattern."
Rule 4 thereof specified the cut-off date for considering
regularisation of unapproved layouts as under:
PMD. J
W.P No.5l50 of2022
Cut-oIf
date
for
coasidering
regularization of unapproved layouts:
Only those unapproved layouts and subdivision of plots v.ith re8istered sale deed
/ title deed existing as on 2a.1O.2O15,
sha.ll be consid,:red for regularization
under these rules As proof and evidence,
the piot holder/kmd owner/ Association/
Society/Colony developer is required to
furnish copies of -:he sa-le deed/ title deed.
Agreement of sale or General Power of
Attorney shall not be considered as
evidence."
8.
Thereerfter, vide Government Letter No.2252/M1 /2017
dated 06.04..2017, certain orders were issued in respect of
Municipal Commissioner, HI\{DA/Commissioner, GHMC to
consider permission in the plots/sites which are not applied
under the LRS, 2015.
Thereafter vide
Memo
No.2252 /ML / 2017, dated, 28.04.2017, these directions were
made applicable to entire State i.e., all the Municipal
Corporations/Municipalities/Nagar Panchayats and Urban
Developmerrt Authority areas. For the sake of ready reference,
the Memo l{o.2252 /Ml /2017, dated 28.O4.2OI7 is reproduced
hereunder:
PMD, J
W.P.No 5150 of2022
"Building permission in such plots/sites may
be considered by the Competent Authority by
collecting basic penalisation charges as per
LRS-2015 and 33% compounding fee on the
same, plus open space contribution charges
(14%) on the present market value of the
site/plot applied for Building Permission."
9.
Subsequently, LRS 2020 was introduced vide G.O.Ms.
No.131 dated 31.O8.2O2O. Vide G.O.Ms. No.131, dated
31.O8.2O2O, the Govemment has issued the scheme known as
LRS 2020 for reularisation of unapproved/unauthorised/illegat
layouts by pal.rnent of the charges mentioned therein. The cut-
off date for applicability of the said G.O. was mentioned as
31.O8.2O2O. Subsequently vide G.O.Ms. No. 135, dated
16.O9.2O2O, the 1"t respondent/Government of Telangana has
amended the LRS 2020 Rules by reducing the regularisation
charges. It was also held that the LRS regularisation charges
includes NALA charges also and no separate NALA charges
shall be paid. Thereafter, on receipt of representations from
various quarters, the Govemment has issued a Memo
No.14148/PLG .lll/2o2o, dated 3O.12.2O2O grving such
relaxations only to such plot owners whose documents have
been registered on or before 26.08.2020.
PMD. J
w.P.No.5l50 of2022
l(r
f0. For th,: sake of clarity and completeness, the Memo
No. 14148/PLG.IIII 2O2O, dated
30.72.2O2O is reproduced
hereunder in toto.
"GOVERNM};NT OF TELANGANA
MUNICI]'AL ADMINISTRATION AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMEI{T
Date:
Memo No.14 4a
Sub
.1,2.2020
GHMC - LRS - 2020 - Telangana
Regulariau,ation of Unapproved and
illegal La)out Rules 2020 - Processing
of Build ng Permissions - Certain
Clarifiacti rns - Iisued - Reg.
Rel
G.().Ms.No.131 MA, Dated:
31.08.2020
G.O.Ms.No.135 MA, Dated:
16.t\9.2O2O
Govt. Letter No.2252/M\ /2017,
Daled 06.04.2016.
From GHMC Lr.No.B/ 15a5/ TPS/
CCr,/Ho/GHMC/20 l6-20, Dated:
2a 12.2020.
In the reference 1st !L 2nd cited, Government have
issue(l Telangana Regulalization of Unapproved and itlegal
Layor-t Rules 2O2O by givin.; oppo rtunity to the plot/site
owner-s on whose name txe plot is registered with a
registered sale deed executed on or before 26.08.2020 (orl
layout owners who have de.reloped the layout and sold at
least 10% of the plots on or before 26.Oa.2O2O for
regul.lrizing their plots/lay)ut under LRS Scheme 2O2O.
The l:rst date for filing ofapplications was on 31.1O.2O2O.
In the reference 4th c:ted, it has come to the notice of
(iovernment
the
that, som,: of the plot/site owners have
submitted applications to creater Hyderabad Municipal
PMD, J
W.P.No 5150 of2022
l1
Corporation seeking building permission by enclosing the
online receipts filed under LRS 2020 application and some
of the plot/site owners have submitted applications seeking
building permission without applying under LRS-2O20.
After careful examination of the matter following
procedure is prescribed for gtanting building permissions in
the following categories :
in unapproved/illetgal layouts having
documents registered on or before 26.08.2020 for which
1- The ptots/sites falling
application filed under New LRS 2020 Scheme and applied
for grant of building permissions, the building permissions
in such cases can be processed duly collecting the
fee/charges as per the LRS-202O on submission of LRS2O2O acknowledgement receipt by the applicant in the
respective building application.
2. The plots/sites falling in unapproved/illegal layouts having
documents registered on or before 26.0A.2020 for which
applications not frled under New LRS 2020 scheme, the
building permissions can be processed duly collecting basic
penalization charges as per LRS-2O20 and 33Vo
compounding fee on the same, plus open space
contribution charges (14%) on the present market value of
the site/plot applied for Building Permission."
The Commissioner, Greater Hyderabad Municipal
Corporation/Metropolitan Commissioner, Hyderabad
Metropolitarr Development Authority/Director of Municipal
Administration/Director of Town and Country Planning/
Vice Chairmen of UDAs, shall take further action
accordingly.
ARVIND KUMAR
PzuNCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT"
PMD, J
W.P.No.5l50 of2022
l2
11. From the above, it can be seen that the relaxations under
LRS 2020 are applicable only to the plots/sites falling in
unapproved/ illegal layouts having documents registered on or
before 26.08.202O. In the case before this Court, the plot was
registered on O4.O9.2O21 by wa1, of sa-le deed No.4803/2O27 i.e.
alter 26.08.2020. In the decisjons relied upon by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, this Fion'ble Court has considered the
Memo ated 28.04.2077 applicrLble to LRS 2015, whereas the
Memo dateC 3O.72.2O2O is applicable to this case and the
petitioner is not eligible for relaxation under the said Memo.
However, it is noticed that the (iovernment has not provided for
any formula for regularisalion of plots/sites falling in
unapproved /illega1 layouts having documents registered on or
after 26.08.'.2020.
72. As the petitioner is not provided with any a.lternative
remedy, and for the sake of uniformit5r and consistency, it is
deemed fit and proper to direct the respondents to consider
granting building permissiorr to the petitioner herein by
collecting ttee penal charges as provided in LRS-2020 and 33%
compounding fee on the sarr.e, plus open space contribution
PMD, J
w.P.No 5150 of2022
l3
charges l14o/ol on the market va.lue of the site/plot applied for
building permission as on the date of applications.
Accordingly, this writ petition is allowed. No order as to
costs.
Miscellaaeous applications, if any pending, shall stand
closed.
JUSTICE P.MADHAVI DEVI
Date: O2,O2.2O22
LSK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review