Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:40892-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.
11542 of 2024
Decided on: 23.09.2026
Kapil Thakur and others
…….Petitioners
Versus
Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited
and others
Coram
… Respondents
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Yogesh Jaswal, Judge
Whether approved for reporting?1Yes
_____________________________________________________
For the petitioners
:
M/s Devender K. Sharma and
Rehamtullah, Advocates.
For the respondents
:
Mr. Rajesh Kashyap, Advocate for
respondent No. 1.
:
Mr. O.P.Negi, Advocate for respondents
No. 2, 3, 11, 18, 31, 36, 57, 60 and
71.
:
Mr. Dheeraj Kanwar, Advocate for
respondents No. 4, 7, 12, 13, 17, 19,
26, 40, 41, 43, 46, 48 to 50, 56, 58,
59, 63, 66, 70, 72 to 77, 81, 86, 90,
92, 100, 102, 106, 108, 109, 110, 114,
117, 121 and 125 to 128.
:
Mr. Sudhir Bhatnagar, Advocate for
respondent No. 24.
:
Respondent No. 79 ex parte.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
(Oral)
By way of this writ petition, the petitioners have inter
alia prayed for the following reliefs:1
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:40892-DB
“1.
That a writ of certiorari may kindly be issued and
recruitment and promotion rules issued vide notification
dated 13.09.2022 to the post Senior Assistant qua providing
eligibility criteria to the post of Junior Assistant/junior office
assistant (Annexure P-13) and recruitment and promotion
rules dated 13.09.2022 to the post of Junior Office Assistant
(IT) wherein provision for placement on the designation of
Junior Assistant (Annexure P-14 ) may kindly be quashed
and set aside.
2. That a writ of prohibition may kindly be issued and the
respondent board be restrained from holding Departmental
Promotion Committee (DPC) to the post of Senior Assistant in
terms of office order dated 19.09.2024 (Annexure P-23) in
the interest of justice and fair play.
3. That a writ of mandamus may kindly be passed and the
respondent board may kindly be directed to treat both Clerk
and Junior Office Assistant (IT) equally in the matter of
promotion and pay scale in the interest of justice and fair
play.”
2.
The grievance of the petitioners is that the Recruitment
and Promotion Rules to the post of Senior Assistant (Ministerial
Services), which have been issued vide notification Annexure P-13
dated 13.09.2022, discriminate between the two feeder categories for
2026:HHC:40892-DB
promotion to the said post, i.e., the category belonging to the post of
Clerk
and
the
post
of
Junior
Office
Assistant
(Information
Technology) (the category to which the petitioners belong), in a
manner that whereas a Clerk is eligible for promotion after putting in
four years of regular service, a Junior Office Assistant (IT) (the
category to which the petitioners belong) becomes eligible only after
putting in seven years of service.
3.
Learned Counsel for the petitioners argued that the
petitioners were appointed against the post of Junior Office Assistant
(IT)
[hereinafter
to
be
referred
to
as
JOA(IT)]
in
terms
of
advertisement Annexure P-1 in the year 2017–18. Thereafter their
services were regularized against the said post in terms of Annexure
P-3, order of regularization dated 07.10.2020 and subsequent
notifications issued in the year 2021 and 2022. Learned Counsel
further argued that earlier there were no posts of JOA(IT). By
referring to orders Annexure P-4, dated 18.03.2015 and Annexure P5, dated 22.06.2015, learned Counsel submitted that in terms of
these two orders, 100 posts of JOA (IT) and 235 posts of JOA (IT)
respectively were created in the pay band of Rs.5910–20200+1950
grade pay in the Electrical Sub-Divisions under Operation Wings.
This was done by abolishing equal number of posts of Clerks in the
respective Units under the Operation Wings. Learned Counsel
2026:HHC:40892-DB
thereafter
referred
to
the
notification
Annexure
P-6,
dated
18.03.2015 i.e. the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of
JOA (IT) and submitted that said post of JOA (IT) was to be filled
100% by way of direct recruitment on a regular basis or on a
contract basis in the mode and manner prescribed therein. Said post
was a Class-III Non-Gazetted Ministerial post, created in the pay
scale of Rs.5910–20200+1950 grade pay. Learned Counsel referred
to Clause 7 of the Rules and submitted that the essential
qualifications required for being eligible to the said post were as
provided therein. He submitted that the petitioners participated in
the recruitment process undertaken by the Electricity Board and
were appointed initially on
contract basis. Subsequently, their
services were regularized from the year 2020 onwards.
Learned
Counsel thereafter referred to Annexure P-8, i.e. notification dated
12.11.2008 and submitted that these were the Recruitment and
Promotion Rules for the post of Clerk in the respondent-Board and in
terms of said Rules, the post of Clerk was to be filled in 75% by way
of direct recruitment and 25% by promotion from amongst Class-IV
Non-Technical staff. By referring to Clause 7 of the said Rules,
learned Counsel submitted that the minimum educational and other
qualifications prescribed for recruitment to the post of Clerk were
same and akin to those of a JOA (IT).
2026:HHC:40892-DB
4.
Learned Counsel thereafter referred to Annexure P-9,
which is a notification dated 18.06.2012 and submitted that the
Recruitment and Promotion Rules to the post of Clerk were amended
by the respondent-Board in terms of Annexure P-9 and essential
qualifications, as mentioned therein, stood amended in face of what
was earlier existing in Annexure P-8.
Learned Counsel thereafter
referred to Annexure P-10, which is a notification of the respondentBoard dated 29.10.1975 and submitted that earlier there was no
post of Senior Assistant and there existed a post of Upper Division
Clerk, which was filled in 80% by way of promotion from amongst
Lower Division Clerks/Stenos/Meter Readers and 20% by way of
direct recruitment. He submitted that a perusal of the said Rules
would demonstrate that for all the feeder categories for promotion to
the post of Upper Division Clerk, similar period of minimum service
in the feeder grade was prescribed.
5.
Learned counsel thereafter referred to Annexure P-13
and submitted that in terms of the impugned Recruitment and
Promotion Rules to the post of Senior Assistant, this post, which is
again a Class-III Non-Gazetted post to be filled in 100% by way of
promotion, the method of recruitment to the said post is by way of
promotion from the category of Clerks to the extent of 43% with four
years of regular service as a Clerk and from the category of Junior
2026:HHC:40892-DB
Assistant to the extent of 57% with seven years of regular service as
a JOA (IT) or Junior Assistant as mentioned therein.
6.
Learned Counsel argued that there is no difference or
distinction between the post of a Clerk and that of a JOA (IT). He
submitted that as both the posts of Clerk and JOA (IT) are the feeder
posts for promotion to the post of Senior Assistant, the distinction
created by the respondent-Board whereby a Clerk is eligible for
promotion to the post of Senior Assistant after four years of regular
service, while a JOA (IT) has to put in seven years of service, is
completely arbitrary and discriminatory. Learned Counsel has
argued that it was evident from the documents referred to that the
posts of JOA (IT) were created after the abolition of an equal number
of posts of Clerk, which demonstrated that there was no difference or
distinction between the post of a Clerk and JOA (IT). He submitted
that in this backdrop also, the difference in the number of years to
be put in by each of the categories to be rendered eligible for
promotion to the post Senior Assistant, was totally unsustainable in
law. Learned Counsel further argued that there is otherwise also no
qualitative or quantitative difference in the kind of service being
rendered by a Clerk as compared to a JOA (IT), therefore, this
classification in the Rules is arbitrary and discriminatory. Learned
Counsel also referred to Annexure P-16, which is a copy of
2026:HHC:40892-DB
notification
dated
11.11.2022,
issued
by
the
Department
of
Personnel, Government of Himachal Pradesh and submitted that in
terms of this notification, which contains the Recruitment and
Promotion Rules to the post of Senior Assistant, the feeder categories
are both Clerks and JOA (IT), etc. and the eligibility criteria for both
posts is the same, i.e. seven years of service.
Learned Counsel has relied upon the following judgments of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in support of his contentions:(I) S.G, Jaisinghani vs. Union of India and others, AIR 1967 Supreme
Court 1427;
(II) E.P.Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 1974 Supreme Court
555;
(III) P.U. Joshi and Others vs. Accountant General, Ahmedabad and
others, (2003) 2 SCC page 632;
7.
On the other hand, learned Counsel for the respondent-
Board argued that there is no merit in the petition and the same
deserves
dismissal.
Learned
Counsel
has
argued
that
the
petitioners, were recruited against the post of JOA (IT) in the year
2017–18. Thereafter, their services were regularized against the said
post from the year 2020 onwards. He submitted that the petitioners
are assailing Annexure P-13, which is a notification issued on
13.09.2022, which prescribes the feeder categories for the post of
2026:HHC:40892-DB
Senior Assistant (Ministerial Services). He submitted that the post of
JOA (IT) was created in terms of Annexure P-4 and Annexure P-5
and the creation of these posts by abolishing an equal number of
posts of Clerks is a matter of record. However, he submitted that this
does not mean that the posts of a Clerk and the posts of JOA (IT) are
qualitatively or quantitatively the same and similar. He referred to
the Recruitment and Promotion Rules of the post of Clerk, Annexure
P-8,
dated
12.11.2008
and
submitted
that
the
educational
qualifications mentioned therein were amended vide Annexure P-9,
notification dated 18.06.2012 and if one compares the essential
qualifications which are required for appointment against the post of
Clerk with the essential qualifications which are required for
recruitment against the post of JOA (IT), there is a qualitative and a
substantive difference between the two. Learned Counsel drew the
attention of the Court to the reply filed by the respondent-Board and
submitted that the respondent-Board has created and notified the
post of JOA (IT) on the pattern of the Government of Himachal
Pradesh. The Recruitment and Promotion Regulations, which have
been framed and notified in this regard are also on the same pattern
as of the Government of Himachal Pradesh. He submitted that even
as far as the promotional avenues are concerned, in Government
Departments, the next promotional post from the post of JOA (IT) is
2026:HHC:40892-DB
that of a Senior Assistant and a JOA (IT) becomes eligible for
promotion to the post of Senior Assistant after putting in 7 years of
service. He submitted that in light of this fact, there is no
arbitrariness or discrimination in the act of the respondents as per
the notification which is under challenge. He submitted that as the
post of JOA (IT) was subsequently created on the pattern of the State
Government in the Board, the 7-year period for eligibility to the
promotional post was fixed in consonance with the Rules of the
State. Learned Counsel for the respondent-Board has also relied
upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in P.U. Joshi and
Others vs. Accountant General, Ahmedabad and others reported in
(2003) 2 SCC 632, to substantiate his contentions.
8.
Learned Counsel appearing for the private respondents
have adopted the arguments addressed by the learned Counsel for
the respondent-Board.
9.
In rebuttal, learned Counsel for the petitioner referred to
Annexure P-14, i.e. Notification dated 13.09.2022 and argued that in
terms of said Annexure the essential qualifications for recruitment to
the post of JOA (IT) stood amended and it is now same as that of a
Clerk.
10.
We have heard learned Counsel for the parties and have
also carefully gone through the pleadings and documents produced
2026:HHC:40892-DB
on record, as well as the judgments relied upon by the learned
counsel for the parties.
11.
The factum of the petitioners having been recruited
against the post of JOA (IT) pursuant to the creation of the post of
JOA (IT) as per two office orders dated 18.03.2015 (Annexure P-4)
and 22.06.2015 (Annexure P-5), which posts were created after the
abolition of an equal number of posts of Clerk, is a matter of record.
12.
Otherwise also, it is settled law that what terms or
conditions are to be applied in of the Recruitment and Promotion
Rules for a post, is the prerogative of the employer. The Courts,
ordinarily are not to interfere or intervene with the said prerogative
unless it has been exercised by the employer either in a manifestly
illegal manner or is a result of some malafide.
13.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in S.G, Jaisinghani
vs. Union of India and others, AIR 1967 Supreme Court 1427, has
been pleased to hold that the absence of arbitrary power is the first
essential of the rule of law upon which the whole constitutional
system is based and in a system governed by the rule of law,
discretion, when conferred upon executive authority, must be
confined within clearly defined limits. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
has also held that the rule of law from this point of view means that
decisions should be made by the application of known principles
2026:HHC:40892-DB
and rules and in general, such decisions should be predictable and
the citizen should know where he stands.
14.
Similarly, in E.P.Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR
1974 Supreme Court
555, Hon’ble Supreme Court of India was
pleased to hold that Article 16 of the Constitution of India is merely
an instance of the application of the concept of equality enshrined in
Article 14 of the Constitution. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
in other words, Article 14 is the genus, while Article 16 is a species.
Article 16 gives effect to the doctrine of equality in all matters
relating to public employment and the basic principle informing both
Articles 14 and 16 is equality and prohibition against discrimination.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court also held that Articles 14 and 16 strike
at arbitrariness in State action and ensure fairness and equality of
treatment. They require that State action must be based on valid
relevant principles applicable alike to all similarly situated persons
and it must not be guided by any extraneous or irrelevant
considerations as that would amount to denial of equality. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court further held that where the operative reason
for State action as distinguished from the motive originating from
the antechamber of the mind is not legitimate and relevant, but
extraneous and outside the realm of permissible considerations, it
would amount to a malafide exercise of power and is hit by Articles
2026:HHC:40892-DB
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
15.
Similarly, in P.U. Joshi and Others vs. Accountant
General, Ahmedabad and others, (2003) 2 SCC 632, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court was pleased to hold that questions relating to the
constitution, pattern, nomenclature of posts, cadre, category, their
creation,
abolition,
prescription
of
qualifications
and
other
conditions of service, including avenues of promotion and criteria to
be fulfilled for such promotion, pertain to the domain of policy.
These fall within the exclusive discretion and jurisdiction of the
State, subject, of course, to the limitations or restrictions envisaged
in the Constitution of India. It is not for statutory Tribunals to direct
the State Government to adopt a particular method of recruitment,
eligibility criteria, or avenues of promotion, nor to impose themselves
by substituting their view for that of the State. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court also held that it is well open to and within the competence of
the State to change the rules relating to service and to alter, amend,
or vary by addition or subtraction the qualifications, eligibility
criteria and other conditions of service, including avenues of
promotion, from time to time as administrative exigencies may need
or necessitate.
16.
Coming to the facts of this case, as we have already
observed herein above, the grievance of the petitioners is solely that
2026:HHC:40892-DB
while there are two feeder categories for promotion to the post of
Senior Assistant, a Clerk becomes eligible for promotion after four
years of service, whereas the condition of seven years of service for a
JOA (IT) to become eligible for promotion
to the said post, is
arbitrary and discriminatory.
17.
In our considered view, as the post of Clerk and the post
of JOA (IT) are two distinct posts, it cannot be said that the condition
of seven years of service as a JOA (IT) for promotion to the post of
Senior Assistant is per se arbitrary or discriminatory vis-à-vis the
category of Clerks. We say this because the petitioners could not
demonstrate before us that in any other department, whether of the
Government or otherwise, a JOA (IT) is eligible for promotion to the
post of Senior Assistant after four years of service. On the contrary,
it is evident from the documents appended by the petitioners
themselves with the writ petition, that even in Government
departments, a JOA (IT) becomes eligible for promotion to the post of
Senior Assistant only after seven years of service.
18.
In terms of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
of India in E.P. Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu (supra), State action
must be based on valid and relevant principles applicable alike to all
similarly situated individuals and it must not be guided by
extraneous or irrelevant considerations. In the present case, the
2026:HHC:40892-DB
petitioners have failed to substantiate from the record that the
requirement of seven years of service as a JOA (IT) for promotion to
the post of Senior Assistant is guided by any extraneous or irrelevant
considerations.
19.
On the contrary, the Board has explicitly stated in its
reply generally and in paragraph 11 on merits thereof in particular,
that the post of JOA (IT) in the respondent-Board was created on the
same analogy as corresponding posts in Government departments.
Since the post of JOA (IT) serves as a feeder post for promotion to
Senior Assistant, and a JOA (IT) becomes eligible after seven years of
service, a similar provision was adopted by the respondent-Board for
promotion to the post of Senior Assistant for this particular category.
The petitioners could not prove the contrary that in Government
departments, a JOA (IT) becomes eligible for promotion after only
four years of service.
20.
The judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in P.U.
Joshi v. Accountant General (supra) clearly lays down the law that
the prescription of qualifications and service conditions including
promotional avenues and eligibility criteria, fall in the field of policy
and the exclusive discretion and jurisdiction of the State, subject
only to constitutional limitations or restrictions. These limitations or
restrictions, as envisaged in the Constitution, are those spelled out
2026:HHC:40892-DB
in E.P. Royappa vs. State of Tamil Nadu case (supra).
21.
We
have
already
observed
that
it
could
not
be
demonstrated before this Court that the seven year service
requirement for a JOA (IT) for promotion to the post of Senior
Assistant, is motivated or guided by extraneous or irrelevant
considerations. As the Hon’ble Supreme Court has clearly and
categorically held that matters regarding promotional avenues and
criteria, belong to the field of policy and is within the exclusive
discretion and jurisdiction of the State and since we find no
arbitrariness or discrimination in the act of respondent-Board to
prescribe seven years of service as a condition for a JOA (IT) for
promotion to the post of Senior Assistant, we are of the considered
view that this is not a case where said prerogative of the Board
requires any interference by this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
22.
However, in light of the fact that as amongst the feeder
category to the post of Senior Assistant, a Clerk is made eligible after
completion of four years of service, whereas, presently a JOA (IT) has
to put in seven years of service, though we are not holding that the
said provision in the Recruitment and Promotion Rules is arbitrary
or unconstitutional, however, this adjudication shall not come in the
way of the respondent-Department, if it intends to have a re-look on
2026:HHC:40892-DB
the issue, independently. With these observations, the writ petition
is disposed of, so also pending miscellaneous applications, if any.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
(Yogesh Jaswal)
Judge
September 23, 2026
(narender)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review