The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
29. 02.2018 made in Mutation Case No. 244/SDC/IW(C) and another dated 25.07.2018 made in Misc. Case No.306/SDC/IW(C), both being orders made by said SDC. In instant order of this Court, for the sake of convenience and clarity, the former i.e., ‘29.02.2018 order of said SDC’ shall be referred to as ‘Mutation Case Order’ and the latter, viz., ‘order dated 25.07.2018 made by said SDC’ shall be referred to as ‘separation of patta case order’; that both these orders were made by said SDC at the instance of revision petitioner in captioned main CRP; that both these orders viz., mutation case order and separation of patta case order were assailed inter-alia by respondent No.2 by way of revisional jurisdiction before said Revenue Tribunal by resorting to Section 95 of MLR & LR Act, the said Revenue Tribunal disposed of the revision case in and by an order dated 18.08.2022 sustaining/upholding the mutation case order and setting aside the separation of patta case order and directing the ‘concerned authorities’ to decide the matter afresh; that this 18.08.2022 order of said Revenue Tribunal has attained finality i.e., it has been given legal quietus by all the parties concerned; that post this 18.08.2022 order of said Revenue Tribunal, the 5(five) respondents in captioned CRP, petitioned said DC vide a petition dated 19.12.2022 inter-alia with prayers to make an order indicating the area of …
19. 12.2022 (petition inter-alia seeking indication of area of amalgamated land, partition of amalgamate land, etc.,) ought to be heard by said DC along with the separation of patta case which has been remanded to concerned authorities by Central Revenue Tribunal in and vide order dated 19.08.2022 made in Revenue Revision Case No.1 of 2021. [7] The afore-referred contention of learned senior counsel and learned counsel on either side converges on one point and that one point is the impugned order made by said DC is legally incorrect, not in accordance with MLR & LR Act, more particularly, not in accordance with Sections 46, 51B (1) and 41 read with Section 2(f) of MLR & LR Act. [8] In this view of the matter, there is consensus between the learned counsel on both sides and the consent to have the impugned order set-aside. This means that the afore-referred petition of respondents being petition dated 19.12.2022 and the separation of patta case vide M.C No.306/SDC/IW(C) i.e., have to be now heard out by said DC and they are to be heard out together. [9] Before concluding, there are three aspects of the matter which this Court deems appropriate to set out and they are as follows: (i) There appears to be some erroneous descriptions of parties in the captioned CRP and it is open to the parties on both sides to seek appropriate array when said DC hears out the separation of patta and 19…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Abujam
Surjit
Singh
Digitally signed
by Abujam Surjit
Singh
Date: 2026.06.26
12:05:39 +05'30'
ca
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
REPORTABLE
Sl. Nos. 14 to 16
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 34 of 2024
Kangabam Mahendra Singh, aged about 74 years, S/o Late K.
Ibotombi Singh, a residence of Sagolband Moirang Leirak, P.O.
& P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
……Petitioner
Vs.
1.
Oinam Momon Devi, aged about 70 years, W/o Late K.
Manindra Singh, a residence of Sagolband Moirang
Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur.
2.
Kangabam Indramani Singh, aged about 73 years S/o
Late K. Babu Singh, a resident of Sagolband Moirang
Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur.
3.
Mantosh Kangabam, aged about 43 years S/o K. Babu
Singh, a resident of Sagolband Moirang Leirak, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
4.
Laishram Birlata Devi, aged about 38 years W/o K.
Maheshkumar Singh, a resident of Sagolband Moirang
Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur.
5.
Kangabam Minota Devi, aged about 38 years W/o Megha
Singh Ningthoujam, a resident of Uripok Sorobon
Thingel, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur.
……Respondents
With
MC(CRP(CRP.Art.227)) No. 58 of 2024
Kangabam Mahendra Singh, aged about 74 years, S/o Late K.
Ibotombi Singh, a residence of Sagolband Moirang Leirak, P.O.
& P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
……Applicant
Vs.
1.
Oinam Momon Devi, aged about 70 years, W/o Late K.
Manindra Singh, a residence of Sagolband Moirang Leirak,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
2.
Kangabam Indramani Singh, aged about 73 years S/o Late
K. Babu Singh, a resident of Sagolband Moirang Leirak,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
3.
Mantosh Kangabam, aged about 43 years S/o K. Babu
Singh, a resident of Sagolband Moirang Leirak, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
4.
Laishram Birlata Devi, aged about 38 years W/o K.
Maheshkumar Singh, a resident of Sagolband Moirang
Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
5.
Kangabam Minota Devi, aged about 38 years W/o Megha
Singh Ningthoujam, a resident of Uripok Sorobon Thingel,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
..…Respondents
With
MC(CRP(CRP.Art.227)) No. 59 of 2024
Kangabam Mahendra Singh, aged about 74 years, S/o Late K.
Ibotombi Singh, a residence of Sagolband Moirang Leirak, P.O.
& P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
……Applicant
Vs.
1.
Oinam Momon Devi, aged about 70 years, W/o Late K. Manindra
Singh, a residence of Sagolband Moirang Leirak, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
2.
Kangabam Indramani Singh, aged about 73 years S/o Late K.
Babu Singh, a resident of Sagolband Moirang Leirak, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
3.
Mantosh Kangabam, aged about 43 years S/o K. Babu Singh, a
resident of Sagolband Moirang Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur.
4.
Laishram
Birlata
Devi,
aged
about
years
W/o
K.
Maheshkumar Singh, a resident of Sagolband Moirang Leirak,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
5.
Kangabam Minota Devi, aged about 38 years W/o Megha Singh
Ningthoujam, a resident of Uripok Sorobon Thingel, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
……Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
For revision petitioner
Mr. N. Ibotombi, Senior Advocate instructed by
Ms. N. Savitri and Mr. Leo. N., Advocates
For respondents
Mr. R.K. Milan, Advocate along with Ms.
S.Jayaluxmi, Advocate
Date of Judgment & Order
24.06.2026
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(ORAL)
[1]
The following abbreviations/short forms have been used in this
order (for the sake of brevity, convenience and clarity):
Sl.
No.
Abbreviation/Short
Form/other short
references
Full Form/Expansion
1.
CRP
Civil Revision Petition
2.
MC
Miscellaneous Case
3.
MCs
Miscellaneous Cases
3.
said SDC
Sub-Deputy Collector, Imphal West
(Central) Manipur.
4.
said Revenue Tribunal
Revenue Tribunal at Lamphelpat,
Imphal West District, Manipur
5.
said land
Land comprised in C.S. Dag. No.7121
in Village No.85-Sagolband.
6.
MLR & LR Act
Manipur Land Revenue and Land
Reforms Act,1960 (No.33 of 1960)
7.
MLR & LR Rules
Manipur Land Revenue and Land
Reforms Rules,1961
8.
said DC
Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West
District, Manipur.
9.
impugned order
Order dated 31.07.2024 made by said
DC in Revenue Revision Case No.1 of
[2]
This order will now dispose of captioned main CRP and captioned
two MCs thereat. Captioned main CRP has been filed in this Court on
28.08.2024 under Article 227 of the Constitution of India assailing impugned
order made by said DC. To be noted, in and vide impugned order, said DC has
opined that there is no requirement for hearing in Revenue Revision Case
No.1 of 2023 and he has directed that said SDC should complete the revision
case exercise in a time bound manner i.e., within 2(two) months.
[3]
Short facts (shorn of elaboration and details which are not
imperative for appreciating instant order) are that the genesis of the matter is
2(two)
orders,
one
dated
29.02.2018 made
in
Mutation
Case
No.
244/SDC/IW(C) and another dated 25.07.2018 made in Misc. Case
No.306/SDC/IW(C), both being orders made by said SDC. In instant order of
this Court, for the sake of convenience and clarity,
the former i.e.,
‘29.02.2018 order of said SDC’ shall be referred to as ‘Mutation Case Order’
and the latter, viz., ‘order dated 25.07.2018 made by said SDC’ shall be
referred to as ‘separation of patta case order’; that both these orders were
made by said SDC at the instance of revision petitioner in captioned main
CRP; that both these orders viz., mutation case order and separation of patta
case order were assailed inter-alia by respondent No.2 by way of revisional
jurisdiction before said Revenue Tribunal by resorting to Section 95 of MLR &
LR Act, the said Revenue Tribunal disposed of the revision case in and by an
order dated 18.08.2022 sustaining/upholding the mutation case order and
setting aside the separation of patta case order and directing the ‘concerned
authorities’ to decide the matter afresh; that this 18.08.2022 order of said
Revenue Tribunal has attained finality i.e., it has been given legal quietus by
all the parties concerned; that post this 18.08.2022 order of said Revenue
Tribunal, the 5(five) respondents in captioned CRP, petitioned said DC vide a
petition dated 19.12.2022 inter-alia with prayers to make an order indicating
the area of amalgamated
land as per the documents, for partition of
amalgamated land after correction of the area and other incidental orders;
that, it is at this juncture that the impugned order has been made by said DC;
that assailing the impugned order, captioned CRP has been filed in this Court
on 28.08.2024 as already alluded to supra.
[4]
In the hearing today, Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel instructed
by Ms. N. Savitri, learned counsel on record for sole revision petitioner (along
with Mr. Leo. N., learned counsel) and Mr. R.K. Milan, learned counsel along
with Ms. S. Jayaluxmi, learned counsel on record for all the respondents are
before this Court. This Court, with the consent of learned counsel on both
sides, took up the main CRP and heard out the same.
[5]
The entire case turns on a very short legal point and that is
whether said DC can relegate the matter to said SDC. The answer is clear as
daylight in the light of provisions of MLR & LR Act. There is no disputation or
disagreement before this Court that the afore-referred mutation case was filed
by CRP petitioner under Section 46 of MLR & LR Act. The separation of patta
case was filed under Section 41 read with Section 51(B) sub-Section (1) of
MLR & LR Act. While there is no difficulty about the said mutation case, the
separation of patta case has been erroneously filed before the said SDC as the
authority which is vested with power to deal with the application is said DC.
The reason is section 41 as well as sub-Section (1) of Section 51-B of MLR &
LR Act makes it clear that an application under Section 51-B(1) of MLR & LR
Act ought to be made in writing before said DC. In this regard, what is of
significance is Section 2(f) of MLR & LR Act as it defines Deputy Commissioner
(which obviously includes said DC) and the same reads as follows:
‘2. Definitions. In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires(a)
……………………………………………………………….……
(b)
……………………………………………………………….…….
(c)
……………………………………………………………………..
(d)
………………………………………………………………….…..
(e)
………………………………………………………………..……..
(f)
‘Deputy Commissioner’ means the Deputy Commissioner
of the district and includes any officer appointed by the
State Government to exercise and perform all or any of
the powers and functions of a deputy commissioner under
this Act;’
The above definition of ‘Deputy Commissioner’ makes it clear
that it includes an officer appointed by the State Government to exercise and
perform all or any of the powers and functions of a Deputy Commissioner but
it is nobody’s case before this Court that said SDC is such an officer appointed
by the State Government. This means that the separation of patta case was
erroneously filed by revision petitioner before said SDC. Mr. N. Ibotombi,
learned senior counsel, on instructions, very fairly conceded that the
separation of patta case was erroneously filed before said SDC and that it
ought to have been filed before said DC.
[6]
Per contra, Mr. R.K. Milan, learned counsel for respondents after
making a faint attempt to support impugned order by relying on Rule 4 of MLR
& LR Rules, contended that the petition of respondents being petition dated
19.12.2022 (petition inter-alia seeking indication of area of amalgamated land,
partition of amalgamate land, etc.,) ought to be heard by said DC along with
the separation of patta case which has been remanded to concerned
authorities by Central Revenue Tribunal in and vide order dated 19.08.2022
made in Revenue Revision Case No.1 of 2021.
[7]
The afore-referred contention of learned senior counsel and
learned counsel on either side converges on one point and that one point is
the impugned order made by said DC is legally incorrect, not in accordance
with MLR & LR Act, more particularly, not in accordance with Sections 46, 51B (1) and 41 read with Section 2(f) of MLR & LR Act.
[8]
In this view of the matter, there is consensus between the
learned counsel on both sides and the consent to have the impugned order
set-aside. This means that the afore-referred petition of respondents being
petition dated 19.12.2022 and the separation of patta case vide M.C
No.306/SDC/IW(C) i.e., have to be now heard out by said DC and they are to
be heard out together.
[9]
Before concluding, there are three aspects of the matter which
this Court deems appropriate to set out and they are as follows:
(i)
There appears to be some erroneous descriptions of
parties in the captioned CRP and it is open to the parties on
both sides to seek appropriate array when said DC hears out
the separation of patta and 19.12.2022 petition (to be noted,
‘this 19.12.2022 petition’ shall be referred to as ‘partition plea’.
(ii)
It has been contended before said Revenue Tribunal that
the description of area qua said land is incorrect, correction
pleas have been made and the same remain unattended and it
is open to both sides to make necessary plea in this regard
also.
(iii)
As regards the faint attempt on the part of learned
counsel for respondents to support impugned order by relying
on Rule 4 of MLR & LR Rules, though this was given up and
learned counsel consented to have impugned order set aside
for the sake of clarity in days to come this Court deems it
appropriate to write that a provision in a subordinate legislation
cannot override provisions in parent statute. MLR & LR is a
piece of subordinate legislation made by State Government in
exercise of Rule making power vide Section 133 of MLR & LR
Act. Rule 4 of MLR & LR Rules reads as follows:
‘4. Application of rules.
(1)
Subject to the provisions of sub-rules (2) and (3)
allotment of land belonging to the Government shall be
made in accordance with these rules.
(2)
Rules 5 to 12 shall not apply to the allotment of any town
land.
(3)
Rules 5 to 17 shall not apply to the allotment of land
coming under any of the following categories:(a)
(b)
land set apart or likely to be set apart under
section 13;
land acquired or held for any particular public
purpose;
(c)
land required for rehabilitation of displaced
persons.’
The above pertains to ‘allocation’ and not ‘delegation’. In any
event, even on a demurer it cannot override rigour of Sections 41, 46, 51-B(1)
of MLR & LR Act read with Section 2(f) as Deputy Commissioner is defined
statutory mandate is petition under Sections 41, 46, 51-B(1) should be heard
by Deputy Commissioner.
[10].
In the light of the narration, discussion and dispositive reasoning
set out thus far, the following order is made:
(a)
Impugned order dated 31.07.2024 made in Revenue
Revision Case No.1 of 2023 by Deputy Commissioner, Imphal
West District is set aside as being contrary to the scheme and
architecture of MLR and LR Act;
(b)
Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West District is directed to
take up partition plea (petition dated 19.12.2022 made by
respondents
in
captioned
CRP)
and
MC
Case
No.
306/SDC/IW(C) pursuant to order of the said Revenue Tribunal
dated 18.08.2022 in Revenue Revision Case No.1 of 2022, hear
out both together and dispose of the same on their own merits
and in accordance with law;
(c)
If
any
plea
is
made
by
parties
regarding
array
of/description of parties, the same shall be considered on its
own merits and in accordance with law and in accordance with
revenue records;
(d)
If any plea qua extent or description of said land is made,
the same shall also be considered on its own merits and in
accordance with law as per the revenue records
and
(e)
The said DC viz., Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West District
is directed to dispose of the two cases viz., partition plea and
separation of patta plea as expeditiously as the official
business of said DC would permit.
[11]
Captioned main CRP i.e., CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 34 of 2024 is
allowed and disposed of in the aforesaid manner
with afore-referred
directions and observations. As regards captioned M.C(CRP(CRP.Art.227))
No.58 of 2024 which has been filed with a dispense with plea, the same is
disposed of as closed, the same having become otiose. As regards captioned
M.C(CRP(CRP.Art.227)) No.59 of 2024 though obvious, the interim order made
by this Court on 29.08.2024 is vacated and M.C(CRP(CRP.Art.227)) No.59 of
2024 now stands subsumed by the order in captioned main CRP. There shall
be no order as to costs.
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Ab. Surjit
P.S. I : Upload forthwith
P.S. II : All concerned will stand bound by instant order vide web copy unloaded
in High Court website inter-alia as the same is QR coded.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review