Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 26.05.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 14.09.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 14.09.2026
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
KANCOR INGREDIENTS LTD. & ORS.
Through:
.....Petitioners
Mr. Pramod Kumar Dubey,
Senior Advocate along with
Mr. Puneet Relan, Mr.
Ramchandurni B Siddhartha,
Ms. Khushi Arora and Ms.
Shivangi Mishra, Advocates.
versus
GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ANR.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Digam Singh Dagar, APP
for the State.
CORAM:
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA
JUDGMENT
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
1.
By way of the present petition filed under Section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 [Cr.P.C.], the petitioners seek
quashing of the Complaint Case No. 71/1996, pending before the
learned ACMM-II, Patiala House Courts, New Delhi [hereafter
‗Trial Court‘] qua them, as well as setting aside the order dated
25.05.2012 [hereafter ‗impugned order‘], passed by the learned
Trial Court in the said complaint case.
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
2.
Briefly stated, the facts of the case are that, on 31.10.1995, Sh.
Bal Mukund, Food Inspector (PFA), Delhi [the complainant], took a
sample of ‗Hot and Spicy Marinade‘, a food article, from Sh. Vikas
Vij, Assistant Restaurant Manager of M/s Pepsico Restaurant
International (India) Pvt. Ltd., situated at 20, Community Centre,
New Friends Colony, New Delhi-110065. The said food article was
found ready for use in the preparation of chicken, etc. The cooking
medium was also not found displayed in the said restaurant. The
sample consisted of three originally sealed packets, each containing
680 gms. of ‗Hot and Spicy Marinade‘. Although the packets bore
identical label declarations, they did not mention any Code No.,
Batch No. or Lot No. The complainant thereafter divided the sample
into three equal parts, each of which was separately packed, fastened,
marked and sealed. Upon completion of the requisite formalities, one
counterpart of the sample was sent to the Public Analyst in an intact
condition. The Public Analyst, vide report dated 04.11.1995, opined
that the sample was misbranded and violated Rules 32(e) and (f) of
the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955 [hereafter ‗PFA
Rules‘]. It was further found that the said ‗Hot and Spicy Marinade‘
had been sold and supplied by M/s Kancor Flavours and Extracts
Limited, Bazar Road, Cochin-682002, to M/s Pepsico Restaurant
International (India) Pvt. Ltd. The said food article was allegedly
imported into India by M/s Kancor Flavours and Extracts Limited
from M/s Mc Cormic Ingredients Southeast Asia Pvt. Ltd., 4
Enterprise Road, Jurong, Singapore-2262, the manufacturer of the
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
product, despite such import being prohibited under Section 5 of the
Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 [hereafter ‗PFA Act‘].
3.
Consequently, the complaint in question was filed against 11
accused persons. Accused nos. 1 and 2 were Sh. Vikas Vij and M/s
Pepsico Restaurant International (India) Pvt. Ltd., respectively, who
were alleged to have violated Section 2(ix)(k) of the PFA Act and
Rules 32(e) and 50(7) of the PFA Rules, and to have committed an
offence punishable under Section 16(1) read with Section 7 of the
PFA Act. Accused nos. 3 to 11 comprised M/s Kancor Flavours and
Extracts Limited, its seven directors and its general manager; they
were alleged to have violated Section 2(ix)(k) and Section 5 of the
PFA Act and Rule 32(e) of the PFA Rules, and to have committed an
offence punishable under Section 16(1) read with Section 7 of the
PFA Act.
4.
The learned Trial Court, after perusing the complaint and the
Public Analyst‘s report dated 04.11.1995, passed the order dated
09.09.1996, vide which summons were issued to all the accused,
including the petitioners herein, for 19.11.1996. On 19.11.1996, the
learned Trial Court exempted the petitioners from personal
appearance and adjourned the matter to 17.12.1996 for issuance of
fresh summons to accused nos. 8 to 10, who were residents of the
United States of America. Thereafter, the matter was adjourned on
various dates on account of the failure to serve summons upon
accused nos. 8 to 10. It is stated that during this period, the
petitioners, who were represented by the learned counsel, were
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
exempted from personal appearance on a day-to-day basis. However,
vide order dated 31.03.2010, the learned Trial Court separated the
trial qua accused nos. 8 to 10 and directed the remaining accused,
including the petitioners, to remain present in person so that notice
could be framed against them. In the meantime, accused no. 1, i.e.,
the Assistant Manager of the concerned restaurant, was declared a
proclaimed offender.
5.
Subsequently, in October 2010, the petitioners herein,
excluding petitioner no. 6, Sh. J.J. Negandhi, who filed a separate
petition, preferred CRL.M.C. 3497/2010 before this Court seeking
quashing of the complaint case, wherein the proceedings before the
Trial Court were stayed. Before this Court, it was contended that
various judgments interpreting the notification dated 20.09.1985
issued by the Government of Delhi were squarely applicable to the
facts of the present case and that the continuation of the criminal
proceedings amounted to an abuse of the process of the Court.
However, vide order dated 29.02.2012, this Court permitted the
petitioners to withdraw the petition, since notice had not yet been
framed, and the petitioners were granted liberty to raise all such pleas
before the learned Trial Court. The learned Trial Court was directed
to consider and decide the same, in the first instance, at the stage of
framing of notice itself, within three months from the date of the said
order.
6.
Pursuant thereto, the petitioners preferred applications on
16.04.2012 seeking their discharge or, in the alternative, dropping of
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
the proceedings. The learned Trial Court, however, dismissed the said
applications vide the impugned order dated 25.05.2012.
7.
Aggrieved by the impugned order dated 25.05.2012 passed by
the learned ACMM, the petitioners, who are accused nos. 3 to 7 and
11 before the learned Trial Court, have preferred the present petition.
8.
Vide order dated 27.07.2012 passed in the present petition, this
Court stayed the proceedings arising out of the complaint case in
question.
9.
The learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners argues
that the impugned order dated 25.05.2012, whereby the learned Trial
Court dismissed the applications filed on behalf of the petitioners
seeking their discharge from the present complaint case, primarily on
the ground that it had no power to discharge them at that stage, is
unsustainable in law. It is contended that, while passing the said
order, the learned Trial Court failed to take into consideration the
order dated 29.02.2012 passed by this Court in CRL.M.C. 3497/2010.
It is argued that, under Section 251 of the Cr.P.C., the Court is
required to examine the allegations in the complaint and the material
on record to determine whether any offence is disclosed. The learned
Trial Court, therefore, erred in holding that the merits of the case
could not be gone into at the stage of framing of notice. Reliance in
this regard is placed upon the decision of the Hon‘ble Supreme Court
in Bhushan Kumar & Anr. v. State (NCT of Delhi) & Anr.: (2012)
5 SCC 424.
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
10.
It is submitted that the allegations forming the subject matter
of the complaint pertain solely to the offence of ‗misbranding‘ of the
food article in question, on account of the absence of a batch-code/lot
number, and not to any adulteration thereof. It is contended that the
Public Analyst‘s report dated 04.11.1995 records the sample to be
misbranded solely on account of violation of Rules 32(e) and (f) of
the PFA Rules. Even the complaint has been filed for violation of
Rule 32(e), and contains no finding whatsoever regarding
adulteration. In this regard, reliance is placed by the learned senior
counsel upon the Notification bearing No. F6(228)/85/ENF/PFA,
dated 20.09.1985, issued by the Government of NCT of Delhi
[hereafter ‗Notification dated 20.09.1985‘]. It is contended that the
said Notification, issued in supersession of earlier instructions,
contemplates that, in respect of a first offence of misbranding under
Rule 32 of the PFA Rules, the erring party ought to be issued only a
written warning, and that prosecution ought to be resorted to only in
the case of a second or subsequent violation. It is argued that,
admittedly, the present case concerns the first alleged offence
attributable to the petitioners, or even to the other accused persons,
and that no warning, written or otherwise, was ever issued to them
prior to the institution of the complaint. The launching of prosecution
in the teeth of the said Notification, therefore, renders the
continuation of the proceedings against the petitioners wholly
unsustainable and amounts to an abuse of the process of law. It is
further contended that, even if the complaint is framed under Section
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
5 of the PFA Act, i.e. for import of misbranded food, the allegation
remains one of misbranding. The Notification dated 20.09.1985,
therefore, applies equally, since the alleged misbranding in this case
arising out of violation of Rule 32 of the PFA Rules is punishable
under Section 16 of the PFA Act, which is subject to the protection
contemplated in respect of a first offence. The reasoning of the
learned Trial Court that violation of Section 5 of the PFA Act creates
a separate offence is, according to the learned senior counsel, legally
untenable.
11.
It is further argued on behalf of the petitioners that the
complaint contains no specific allegations against the petitioners,
who have been roped in merely on the bald assertion that they were
―in-charge and responsible‖. Such an assertion, it is contended, is
directly contrary to the settled law on vicarious liability. It is also
argued that the petitioners are, in any event, entitled to the protection
available under Section 19(2) of the PFA Act, inasmuch as the food
article in question had been purchased by them from the
manufacturer in a duly sealed and labelled condition and was
thereafter sold/supplied in the very same condition, without the seal
or label having been tampered with or altered in any manner. It is
also argued that Rule 50(7) of the PFA Rules is not attracted to the
present petitioners. It is accordingly submitted that the present case is
a fit one for exercise of the inherent jurisdiction of this Court under
Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. and that the complaint, insofar as it relates
to the petitioners, along with the impugned order dated 25.05.2012,
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
be quashed and set aside.
12.
On the other hand, the learned APP for the State refers to the
Status Report placed on record and admits that the Department of
PFA used to issue warnings in cases involving violation of Rule 32 of
the PFA Rules. However, it is contended that the present case
involves not only a violation of Rule 32(e), but also violations of
Section 5 of the PFA Act and Rule 50(7) of the PFA Rules. Since the
case pertains to multiple violations, and not merely to a violation of
Rule 32, it is argued that the same is not covered by the policy of
warning contained in the Notification dated 20.09.1985, which was
being followed at the relevant time. It is, therefore, argued that the
present petition ought to be dismissed and that there is no infirmity in
the impugned order passed by the learned Trial Court.
13.
This Court has heard arguments addressed on behalf of the
petitioners as well as the State, and has perused the material available
on record.
14.
One of the principal questions which arises for consideration is
whether, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, the
petitioners could have been prosecuted for the alleged violation of
Rule 32(e) of the PFA Rules and the consequential violation of
Section 5 of the PFA Act, without first being issued a written
warning in terms of the Notification dated 20.09.1985.
15.
Section 2(ix) of the PFA Act defines the expression
―misbranded‖. The relevant provision, i.e. Section 2(ix)(k), provides
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
that an article of food shall be deemed to be misbranded if it is not
labelled in accordance with the requirements of the PFA Act or the
Rules made thereunder. The provision reads as under:
―(ix) "misbranded" – an article of food shall be deemed to be
misbranded :xxx
(k) if it is not labelled in accordance with the requirements
of this Act or Rules made thereunder…‖
16.
Thus, the misbranding contemplated under Section 2(ix)(k) is
specifically related to failure to comply with any statutory
requirement relating to labelling.
17.
In the present case, the allegations against the accused persons
are not founded on any defect in the contents of the food article. The
Public Analyst report does not record that the sample was adulterated
or that its contents failed to conform to the prescribed standards. The
alleged violation arises only on account of the absence of a
distinctive batch number, lot number or code number on the packets,
as required under Rule 32(e) of the PFA Rules.
18.
Rule 32 forms part of Part VII of the PFA Rules, which deals
with ―Packing and Labelling of Food‖. Rule 32 requires every
package of food to carry a label containing the particulars specified
therein. Clause (e) specifically requires the label to contain a
distinctive batch number, lot number or code number, preceded by
the prescribed words or distinguishing prefix. The said Rule reads as
under:
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
―32. Package of food to carry a label.
Every package of food shall carry a label and unless otherwise
provided in these rules, there shall be specified on every label:xxx
(e) A distinctive batch number or lot number or code number,
either in numericals or alphabets or in combination,
representing the batch number or lot number or code number
being preceded by the words ‗Batch No‘. or ‗Batch‘ or Lot
No". or, Lot or any distinguishing prefix.
Provided, that in case of canned food, the batch number may be
given at the bottom, or on the lid of the container, but the
words "Batch No", given at the bottom or on the lid, shall
appear on the body of the container.‖
19.
It is, therefore, evident that the allegation against the
petitioners is confined to a deficiency in labelling. The provision of
the PFA Act invoked for this purpose is Section 2(ix)(k), which treats
non-compliance with the labelling requirements as misbranding. The
alleged misbranding, in turn, is based only on the violation of Rule
32(e). There is no allegation that the food article was adulterated,
unsafe, sub-standard or otherwise defective in its contents.
20.
At this stage, this Court notes that the Notification dated
20.09.1985 records that, in several cases, the contents of sealed food
articles were found to conform to the prescribed standards, whereas
the labelling on the container or packet was deficient in some respect
and did not comply with Rule 32 of the PFA Rules. It was
accordingly appreciated that, where the contents of the sealed packet
or container conformed to the prescribed standards, the deficiency in
labelling constituted a technical offence. The policy decision
embodied in the Notification was that, in such cases, the affected
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
party should initially be issued a written warning drawing attention to
the requirements of Rule 32. Prosecution was contemplated only if
the same practice was repeated after the issuance of such warning.
The Notification expressly clarified that this policy would not apply
where the contents of the sealed packet or container did not conform
to the prescribed standards and were found to be ‗adulterated‘. In
such cases, prosecution could be launched both for adulteration and
for breach of Rule 32. The relevant portion of the Notification is set
out below:
―2. It would be noted from the perusal of the above Rule that
an elaborate procedure has been prescribed for labeling sealed
contents indicating therein the code number date of packing
etc. However, it has been noticed that in quite a few cases
contents of the sealed article of food was found conforming to
the standard prescribed under the Rules, whereas the labeling
done on the container or the packet was deficient in certain
respect and was not in conformity with the provision contained
in Rule 32 of the PFA Rules, 1955. After detailed discussion
on the subject, it was appreciated that in case the contents of
the sealed packets or container conform to the standard laid
down under the PFA Rules, deficiency with regard to Rules 32
which pertains to the particulars of the labeling on the
container or packet, was only a technical offence, though it
attracted Rule 32 and there was breach of this Rule in some
respect in the course of packing the article of food. In such
cases there was unanimous view during the course of
discussion that the party effected may be given a written
warning drawing his attention to Rule 32 which provides for
labeling particulars to be exhibited on the sampled Tin or the
packet and in case the practice is repeated after a written
warning to the party concerned, the party committing the
offence second time should be prosecuted. However, this could
not apply in case where the contents of the sealed packed or
container are not conforming to the prescribed standard and
hence are adulterated. In such cases, prosecution would be
launched both for adulteration and for breach of Rules 32.
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
After the Secretary (Medical), as the consenting Authority, has
approved the above proposal all the pending cases would be
disposed of accordingly.‖
21.
Therefore, the distinction made in the Notification is clear –
where the defect concerns only the particulars required to be
displayed on the label, and the contents of the food article conform to
the prescribed standards, the violation is treated as a technical firsttime violation for which a written warning is required. On the other
hand, where the contents themselves are adulterated, the benefit of
the warning policy is unavailable and prosecution may be launched
for both adulteration and breach of the labelling requirements.
22.
The aforesaid policy has also been considered by the
Coordinate Benches of this Court in several decisions which have
been placed on record by the petitioners. In M/s Hindustan Unilever
Ltd. v. State: 2011 [1] JCC 689, the Coordinate Bench of this Court
observed that where the prosecution was based on misbranding under
Rule 32, and there was no allegation that the petitioners had
previously been served with a warning notice or that the alleged
violation had been repeated after such warning, the requirement of
the notified policy had not been adhered to. The Court consequently
held that prosecution for misbranding of the food products was not
justified and was violative of the notified policy, and was accordingly
quashed. The relevant observations of the Coordinate Bench are
extracted hereunder:
―8. In the instant matters also, it is not the case of the
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
prosecution that the petitioners arrayed in the complaints were
given warning by way of a notice, drawing their attention to
Rule 32 of PFA Rules, 1955 framed under the Prevention of
Food Adulteration Act, 1954, which requires for particulars to
be exhibited on the packaged food products. It is also not the
case of the prosecution that the complaints in question related
to the violation of Rule 32 after the service of requisite warning
notice on the respective petitioners. Thus, the ratio of the
judgment of this court in the matter of S.S. Gokul
Krishnan (supra) squarely applies to the facts and
circumstances of this case and the respondent, before taking a
decision to prosecute the petitioners, was required to serve the
warning notice upon them as envisaged by Rule 32, which
requirement of the policy has not been adhered to. Therefore,
the prosecution of the petitioners on the allegation of
misbranding of the food products is not justified, being
violative of the notified policy.‖
23.
Therefore, in the considered opinion of this Court, the
prosecution cannot disregard the procedure contemplated by the
Notification dated 20.09.1985. Where the alleged violation is a firsttime violation of Rule 32 and there is no allegation of adulteration,
the concerned party had to first be issued a written warning. In the
absence of such warning, prosecution for the alleged misbranding
was not justified.
24.
In the present case, it is not in dispute that the alleged violation
of Rule 32(e) was a first-time violation insofar as the concerned
restaurant and the petitioners are concerned. There is no allegation
that any written warning had previously been issued to them in
respect of the same or a similar violation. It is also not the case of the
prosecution that the petitioners had repeated the alleged violation
after receiving a warning. Further, there is no allegation of
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
adulteration in the present case. The sample was allegedly found to
be misbranded only because the packets did not bear the requisite
distinctive batch number/lot number/code number. Thus, the case
falls squarely within the category of cases contemplated by the
Notification dated 20.09.1985.
25.
The respondents have sought to distinguish the Notification on
the ground that the complaint also invokes Section 5 of the PFA Act
and that the food article was imported. However, this Court is of the
opinion that this contention also cannot advance the case of the
respondents. It is apposite to take note of Section 5 of PFA Act,
which reads as under:
―5. Prohibition of Import of certain articles of food. No
person shall import into India—
(a) any adulterated food;
(b) an misbranded food;
(c) any article of food for the import of which a license is
prescribed, except in accordance with the conditions of the
license; and
(d) any article of food in contravention of any other provision of
this Act or any rule made thereunder.‖
26.
Section 5 prohibits the import into India of, inter alia,
misbranded food. The provision is thus attracted when the imported
food article is alleged to be ―misbranded‖ within the meaning of
Section 2(ix) of the PFA Act.
27.
In the present case, the allegation of misbranding is traceable
only to Section 2(ix)(k), which deals with non-compliance with the
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
labelling requirements prescribed under the PFA Act or the Rules
made thereunder. The particular labelling requirement allegedly
violated is Rule 32(e), concerning the absence of a distinctive batch
number/lot number/code number. Consequently, the invocation of
Section 5 of PFA Act is not based on any independent defect in the
imported food article, but is only a consequence of the allegation that
the imported article was misbranded on account of the alleged
violation of Rule 32(e). The fact that the food article was imported
cannot, by itself, take the case outside the scope of the Notification.
The Notification does not make a distinction between a labelling
deficiency in an article manufactured in India and the same labelling
deficiency in an imported article. Its applicability depends upon the
nature of the violation – i.e., whether the contents conform to the
prescribed standards and whether the alleged defect is confined to the
labelling particulars required under Rule 32. If an imported food
article had been found to be adulterated, or if there had been any
other substantive violation of the PFA Act or the PFA Rules, the
warning policy would not have protected the concerned party.
However, merely because the food article was imported, the
prosecution cannot ignore the fact that the only alleged defect in the
present case pertains to requirements under Rule 32(e). Thus, once it
is found that the primary violation is only a first-time violation of
Rule 32(e) of PFA Rules, and that there is no allegation of
adulteration, and that no prior written warning was issued, the mere
addition of Section 5 of PFA Act cannot defeat the benefit of the
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
policy contained in the Notification dated 20.09.1985.
28.
The Court is, therefore, of the view that the prosecution of the
petitioners for the alleged violation of Rule 32(e), and for the
consequential violation of Section 5 of the PFA Act, could not have
been initiated without first complying with the requirement of issuing
a written warning as contemplated by the Notification dated
20.09.1985. Since admittedly no such warning was issued, and since
the present case concerns only a first-time violation relating to
labelling, the continuation of the prosecution against the petitioners
for the said violations would be contrary to the notified policy.
29.
As regards Rule 50(7) of the PFA Rules, the said provision
relates to a separate requirement concerning the display of a notice
board containing separate lists of articles cooked in ghee, edible oil,
vanaspati and other fats, for the information of intending purchasers.
The allegation concerning Rule 50(7), as noticed in the complaint,
pertains to the concerned restaurant, and accused nos. 1 and 2. The
said provision has not been invoked against the present petitioners.
30.
Accordingly, the complaint and the consequential proceedings
are quashed insofar as they relate to the alleged violation of Rule
32(e) of the PFA Rules and Section 5 of the PFA Act.
31.
However, the proceedings relating to the alleged violation of
Rule 50(7) of the PFA Rules by accused nos. 1 and 2 shall continue
in accordance with law.
32.
Consequently, the present petition is allowed to the aforesaid
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
extent.
33.
The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026/
T.D./T.S.
CRL.M.C. 2503/2012
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:19:21
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review