Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 2nd February, 2026
%
+
RFA 84/2026, CM APPL. 5355/2026 (stay), CM APPL.5358/2026
(delay in refiling)
KAMLESH PRASAD
S/o sh. Telhoo Ram
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pankaj Kumar Sharma, Advocate.
versus
SAHADEO RAM
S/o sh. Biletan Ram
.....Respondent
Through: None
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M E N T (oral)
CM APPL. 5356/2026 (Exemption), CM APPL. 5357/2025 (Exemption)
1.
Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The Applications stand disposed of.
RFA 84/2026:
3.
Regular First Appeal under Section 96(2) of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’), has been filed on behalf
of the Appellant, to challenge the ex parte Judgment and Decree dated
28.08.2024 and also the Order dated 22.09.2025 of the learned District
Judge-01, New Delhi whereby the Application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC
seeking set-aside of the ex parte decree, has been dismissed.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
RFA 84/2026
4.
The learned counsel for the Appellant submits that the possession in
execution of the ex-parte Judgment, has already been taken on 21.02.2025.
Suit No. CS DJ 431-23 for Possession, Recovery of Mesne Profit,
Mandatory and Permanent Injunction:
5.
The brief facts of the case are that a Suit for Possession, Recovery of
Mesne Profit, Mandatory and Permanent Injunction in respect of the Suit
Property bearing No. C-158, Ekta Vihar, Jaitpur Extension, Jaitpur, New
Delhi-110044, had been filed by the Plaintiff/Respondent, Sahadeo Ram.
The Plaintiff claimed that he had purchased the Suit Property from the
erstwhile owner, on the basis of registered GPA and SPA, Agreement to
Sell, Affidavit, Receipt, Will and Possession Letter all dated 01.08.2000.
The Defendant/Appellant, Mr. Kamlesh Prasad was his nephew, who
approached the Plaintiff for residential help. The Plaintiff allowed him to
reside in the Suit Property purely on a license basis, without any
consideration in October, 2020 (sic-2000).
6.
On 17.10.2013, the Defendant had given an Undertaking to vacate the
Suit Property as and when demanded by the Plaintiff. In 2019, the Plaintiff
requested the Appellant/Defendant to vacate and hand over the possession of
the Suit Property. However, he requested for some more time to vacate the
Suit Property. The Plaintiff again approached the Defendant for vacating the
Suit Property in January, 2022 but he failed to do so.
7.
The Legal Notice dated 20.02.2023 for termination of the License was
served upon the Defendant/Appellant. Since neither any Reply was received
nor were the terms complied, the Plaintiff filed the Suit for Recovery of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
RFA 84/2026
Possession, Mesne Profits @ Rs.20,000/- p.a. w.e.f. 01.06.2020 to
31.05.2023 and a Decree of Mandatory Injunction for directing the
Defendant, to remove all his belongings from the licensed premises and not
to block ingress and egress of the Plaintiff and his family members. A
Decree
of
Permanent
Injunction
was
also
sought
against
the
Appellant/Defendant, to restrain him and his family from creating third party
rights in the Suit Property.
8.
The Defendant/Appellant was served with the Summons by way of
affixation, on 18.08.2023. The Statement of the process server was recorded
on 04.12.2023. Since none appeared on behalf of the Defendant despite
service, he was proceeded ex parte on 04.12.2023. Thereafter, the Plaintiff
examined himself as PW-1 and proved all the requisite documents.
9.
The learned District Judge on the basis of the evidence and
documents, decreed the Suit and directed the Appellant to hand over the
vacant and peaceful possession of the Suit Property within 30 days and also
restrained him from creating any third party rights in the Suit Property.
Misc DJ No. 263/25: Application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC:
10.
The Defendant/Appellant thereafter, filed an Application under Order
IX Rule 13 CPC, for setting-aside of the ex-parte decree. However, the
learned District Judge vide Order dated 22.09.2025, dismissed the
Application.
11.
The present Appeal has been preferred both against the ex-parte
decree dated 28.08.2024 as well as the Order dated 22.09.2025 vide which
the Application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC, was dismissed.
12.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
The Appellant in the present Appeal, has explained that the
RFA 84/2026
Respondent is his Uncle and the Property dispute extended over decades of
financial, familial and documentary transactions. The Appellant has claimed
that he negotiated for the Suit Property from Harbhans Lal and took a loan
of Rs.20,000/- from the Respondent, who was then a Deputy Secretary in the
Government of India. The formalities were completed on 01.08.2000 when a
Registered General Power of Attorney and other supporting documents,
were executed. At the insistence of the Respondent, the General Power of
Attorney was executed in the name of the Plaintiff, considering the alleged
insistence to be benign, given his official position.
13.
The Plaintiff has claimed that he has been continuously residing in the
Suit Property, which is evidenced by Municipal records, utility bills and
other documents. The Appellant has refuted the allegations of being a
licensee or tenant in the suit property.
14.
The Appellant claimed that he repaid the loan to the Respondent and
persistently pressed for title rectification, only to be met with repeated
delays, false assurances and ultimately evasive conduct from the
Respondent. At one instance, the Respondent coordinated with the BSES
Manager for electricity paperwork, but he withdrew his co-operation and
some discrepancies in his signatures were raised, which created a doubt
about his intention and bona fides.
15.
The Appellant claimed that the Respondent, in an attempt to defeat
the Appellant’s continuous, exclusive, and open possession in the suit
property, alleged that the possession was merely permissive and by licence,
with no proprietary rights accruing to the Appellant. This allegation was
made despite the Appellant’s long-standing occupation of the property,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
RFA 84/2026
which is supported by extensive documentary evidence, including his
School Certificates, identity documents (ID cards, Aadhar), utility bills and
other records. Each of these documents bears the Appellant’s credentials as
a resident and reflects his uninterrupted possession since the purchase.
16.
The Appellant claims that the Plaintiff/Respondent had placed
reliance on record, which is Vada/Sahmati Patra dated 17.10.2013 wherein it
was stated that the Respondent had permitted the Appellant to have
temporary residence in the Suit Premises, solely on the ground of financial
distress and medical necessity, with a stated undertaking that the Appellant
would vacate upon demand. The document, was claimed by the Respondent
to bear the signatures of the Appellant. The Plaintiff, on the basis of this
document, had asserted that the possession was merely permissive with no
other right. The Appellant denies his signatures on the said document and
claims it to be a forged document, produced to misrepresent the nature of
possession.
17.
The Respondent further asserted that purported service of Legal
Notice was made upon him on 20.02.2023, at both the addresses known to
be of the Appellant. However, he does not mention the Appellant’s true
residential address, apparently with an intention to manipulate the service
and to facilitate the ex parte decree. The Legal Notice contained assertions
that the Appellant was a tenant and was forcefully remaining in the Suit
Premises without rights, but its service not only remains disputed and
unacknowledged by the Appellant, but there is also no definitive proof of the
same.
18.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
The overarching context and timing of these actions, demonstrate that
RFA 84/2026
the Respondent’s allegations and the challenged Notice was intended solely
to rebut the Appellant’s claim of adverse possession. Under Section 27 and
Article 65 of the Schedule (First Division) to the Limitation Act, 1963, the
Appellant’s occupation being open, exclusive, and hostile for well beyond
the statutory period, it satisfies all conditions required for the perfection and
vesting of ownership through adverse possession, thereby extinguishing the
Respondent’s right to recover the property. The Respondent’s contentions
regarding Licence or tenancy are not only baseless, but are tactically
engineered to undermine the Appellant’s legally protected rights and to
mislead the Court.
19.
The Order dated 18.08.2023, vide which the Appellant was proceeded
ex parte, is challenged on the ground that the significant procedural lapses
have tainted the purported service of summons dated 18.08.2023. The
summons was delivered at the address where the Appellant does not reside;
only his wife, who has a documented history of chronic psychiatric illness
and is under continuous medical treatment, resided there with their son,
who, due to private employment, was generally absent. The Medical
Records and the OPD slips from Safdarjung Hospital (VMMC), Delhi
incontrovertibly evidence the wife’s chronic psychiatric illness.
20.
Despite the Respondent’s knowledge of the Appellant’s correct
address, no effort was made to serve him at the address where he actually
lived. The Process Server did not secure the attestation from the neighbours
or provide any photographic, video, or electronic evidence of affixation. No
attempt was made to serve via registered post, courier, email, or WhatsApp,
as has been established under the prevailing practice of this Court. This
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
RFA 84/2026
omission deprived the Appellant of Notice of the proceedings, in violation
of principles of natural justice, despite ongoing contact between the parties
through WhatsApp chats as late as 21.12.2023.
21.
Medical records from Safdarjung Hospital and VMMC, Delhi,
confirm that the Appellant’s wife was medically incapable of understanding
or relaying any court communication. The Appellant and his family were
totally unaware of the litigation till the bailiffs arrived for execution on
11.02.2025.
22.
It is claimed that the Appellant was completely unaware of the
pending litigation. He participated in the Panchayat Meeting on 19.11.2023
and convened with the community witnesses for amicable settlement. The
Respondent agreed to transfer 50 square yards out of 100 square yards to the
Appellant in exchange of Rs.1,71,000/- paid through Bank transaction and
documented by cheque, passbook entry and deposit slips. Despite receiving
full consideration, the Respondent failed to formalize the Panchayat
Agreement or effectuate title transfer, further demonstrating his mala fide
intent.
23.
The Respondent’s Civil Suit was reserved for Judgment on
06.08.2024 and was decreed ex parte on 28.08.2024.
24.
During the execution proceedings in Execution Case No. 3249/2024,
the
learned
District
Judge
on
15.02.2025,
directed
that
videography/photography of the eviction and affixation process be
conducted and placed on the judicial record, before the next date i.e.,
05.04.2025. During the subsequent proceedings in the Execution Petition,
the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
record
RFA 84/2026
reveals
that
contrary
to
the
express
direction,
no
videography/photography of the eviction or affixation, was ever filed or
conducted, establishing material breach of the Court’s direction.
25.
The Appellant challenged the ex parte decree dated 28.08.2024
under Order IX Rule 13 CPC read with Section 5 Limitation Act, on the
ground of lack of proper service and medical incapacity.
26.
The Application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC filed by the Appellant,
was dismissed on 22.09.2025, by observing that the claim of the Appellant
that the service was improper, delayed or there was medical incapacity of
the wife, who had received the summons, was untenable and the service was
held to be legally sufficient and proper. The possession has already been
delivered in the execution.
27.
The grounds of challenge of the Appeal, are that there was no proper
service of the summons in terms of the Order V Rule 15 CPC. There was no
videography/photography of the affixation of the summons or of the eviction
proceedings done, which was in violation of the directions of the learned
District Judge. Despite being a close relative and in continuous
communication through WhatsApp on 21.12.2023, the pendency of the Suit
was never disclosed by the Respondent to the Appellant, reflecting his mala
fide intent and suppression of material facts. Reliance is placed on Gauhati
University vs. Niharlal Bhattacharjee, (1995) 6 SCC 731.
28.
Reliance is placed on Parimal vs. Veena @ Bharti, (2011) 3 SCC 545
wherein it was held that a liberal interpretation of “sufficient cause” must be
done while considering the condonation of delay Application. The Appellant
claimed that he was genuinely unaware of the litigation and became aware
about it only when the Bailiff arrived on 11.02.2025, for execution.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
RFA 84/2026
29.
The delay in filing the Application for setting-aside the ex-parte
decree, was not wilful but occasioned by absence of actual notice, family
medical incapacity and procedural lapses. Reliance has placed on G.P.
Srivastava vs. Shri R.K Raizada & Ors., (2000) 3 SCC 54 wherein it is held
that genuine bona fide non-appearance or delay, must be liberally construed
in favour of the substantive justice. The Respondent’s allegations of forceful
possession and tenancy, are completely contradictory to the Appellant’s
documents, who has been in continuous peaceful possession.
30.
Hence, a prayer is made that the impugned ex-parte Judgment and
decree dated 28.08.2024 and the Order dated 19.09.2025 of the Execution
Court recording the satisfaction of the decree, be declared null and void.
31.
It is further submitted that 151 days’ delay in filing the Application
under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC, be condoned.
Submissions heard and record perused.
32.
The Plaintiff/Respondent had filed a Suit for Possession, Mesne
Profits, Mandatory and Permanent Injunction in respect of the Suit
property against the Appellant. Undeniably, the Appellant is the nephew of
the Plaintiff. The case of the Appellant himself as narrated in the Appeal, is
that he was instrumental in negotiating the deal in respect of purchase of
property for which he had taken a loan of Rs.20,000/- from the Respondent,
who was then Deputy Secretary in Government of India. The full purchase
formalities were completed on 01.08.2000 including the registered GPA and
other supporting documents. He himself has admitted that the GPA was in
the name of the Respondent. The case of the Respondent was also that he
was the owner of the property having purchased it in August, 2000 on the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
RFA 84/2026
basis of registered GPA and supporting documents.
33.
The Appellant has tried to justify that it was he who had purchased
the property, but he himself admits that loan of Rs.20,000/- was taken by the
Respondent. Moreover, the documents had been executed in the name of the
Respondent. The admissions of the Appellant in the present Appeal, reflect
that the Respondent is the owner in respect of the Suit property.
34.
It is also significant to refer to the assertions of the Appellant that he
participated in the Panchayat Meeting on 19.11.2023, convened with the
community witnesses for amicable settlement. The Respondent agreed to
transfer 50 square yards out of 100 square yards to the Appellant in
exchange of Rs.1,71,000/- paid through Bank transaction and documented
by cheque, passbook entry and deposit slips. Despite receiving full
consideration, the Respondent failed to formalize the Panchayat Agreement
or effectuate title transfer, further demonstrating his mala fide intent.
35.
This again reflects that Appellant was a licencee or else, he would not
have again agreed to purchase the property.
36.
It was the case of the Respondent that Appellant being his nephew,
was permitted to reside in the Suit property since October, 2000. It was
further asserted that in 2013, he had given an assurance that he would be
vacating the premises despite which he failed to do so.
37.
The Respondent has asserted that he has various documents like
Municipal records, Utility Bills etc., to establish his uninterrupted
possession in the Suit property, but this is also the case of the Respondent
that the Appellant has been in possession of the property since October,
2000 as a permissive user.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
RFA 84/2026
38.
The next aspect which emerges is that the Appellant has claimed to
have perfected his title in the Suit property, on the basis of the adverse
possession. It is asserted by him that because of his continuous,
uninterrupted, open and hostile possession, he had become the owner by
adverse possession.
39.
However, it is established not only from the averments contained in
the Petition which have essentially not disputed and the evidence of the
Respondent in the Suit that Appellant was introduced in the property merely
as a permissive user. Admittedly, the Appellant has not been able to show
any documents of Title in his favour. He may have been in possession of
the Suit property but it cannot be termed as open, hostile and adverse to that
of the Respondent. The plea of Adverse Possession as taken by the
Appellant, is not tenable at the outset.
40.
It is pertinent to note that while the Respondent had filed the Suit for
Possession, the Appellant failed to appear in response to the summons and
was proceeded ex-parte. The Appellant has challenged this ex-parte Order
dated 28.08.2024 on the premise that the service was effected upon him
through pasting of the summons. It is claimed by the Appellant in his
Appeal that at that time he was in his native village in Ghazipur, U.P and
only his wife and son were available at the Suit premises.
41.
Pertinently, it is his own admission that his family continued to reside
in the premises. For him to claim that he had no notice of the summons is
not made out on the averments made by the Appellant himself.
42.
It has been contended that no Videography of pasting of the summons
outside his house were taken. However, there is a Report of the Process
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
RFA 84/2026
Server and also the statement of the Process Server recorded by the Court to
conclude that the service through Pasting of the Summons was duly
effected. There is a presumption of the correct name, genuineness of the acts
done by a Government official in discharge of his official duty. There is
nothing brought on record by the Appellant to repel that no service was
effected on him, by Pasting. His contention that he was not duly served with
the summons is, therefore, absolutely without any merit.
43.
Another significant aspect is that he himself has admitted that he had
appeared before the Panchayat on 19.11.2023 wherein the matter was
settled. It is claimed that had he been aware of the pendency of the Suit,
there was no reason for him to appear before the Panchayat and settle the
matter.
44.
Though, this contention may seem appealing, but in fact, it reflects
that because he was aware of the Suit for Possession, he sought to settle the
same with the Respondent by agreeing to purchase the 50 Sq. Yds of the
Suit land. It is also important to note that there is no document of the
Panchayat Settlement which has been placed on record nor any assertion that
Rs.1,71,000/- has ever been transferred to the Respondent. This contention
of the Respondent was required to be proved during the trial. Moreover, this
alleged Agreement of purchase of property, would not change the nature of
his possession in the Suit property as that of a Licensee till the execution of
sale documents in his favour. There is not a single document of Title in
favour of the Appellant on the basis of which he can claim that he had
acquired the ownership in the Suit property.
45.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
As already noted above, all these are the defences of the Appellant
RFA 84/2026
which should have been pleaded and proved in the Suit by way of Written
Statement and evidence. The record shows that he despite service failed to
appear and was proceeded ex-parte on 04.12.2023 and an Ex-parte
Judgment of Possession has been passed against him.
46.
It is further contended that the Application under Order IX Rule 13
CPC has been dismissed vide Order dated 22.09.2025 essentially on the
ground of limitation. It is not in dispute that the Application under Order IX
Rule 13 CPC was filed on 28.02.2025. The Appellant has contested the
dismissal of the Application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC by Order dated
22.09.2025 on the ground that no service was ever effected upon him and
the learned Trial Court has wrongly dismissed the Application.
47.
The learned District Judge in the Order dated 22.09.2025 had
considered the procedure under Order V and found that the summons had
been served on the wife of the Defendant who had refused to accept the
same. Thereafter, the summons was directed to be served through affixation
which was effected on 18.10.2023. Order V Rule 17 CPC deals with the
procedure in case the summons are refused to be accepted or the Defendant
is not found in the premises. Since, there was a refusal to accept the
Summons by the wife, the Summons were directed to be affixed on the
House of the Defendant.
48.
In terms of Order V Rule 19 CPC the Process Server was examined
on 04.12.2023, who deposed about the affixation of Summons at the address
of the Appellant as his House was found locked. There was due compliance
of Order V Rule 19 CPC. The learned District Judge considered the due
procedure as prescribed under Order V for the service of the Defendant
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
RFA 84/2026
which had been duly complied.
49.
The learned District Judge thus, rightly dismissed the Application
under Order IX Rule 13 CPC.
50.
The Appellant had placed reliance on The Koushaik Mutually Aided
Cooperative Housing Society vs. Ameena Begum and Ors. 2023 15 SCR
841, wherein it had been observed that when there is an ex-parte Decree, the
Defendant has three options i.e. to file an Appeal against the ex-parte
Judgment; to move an Application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC or to seek
the Review of the ex-parte Decree. The Appellant herein had availed his
twin remedy of filing an Appeal as well as to challenge the Order under
Order IX Rule 13 CPC. However, he has miserably failed to sustain either
the Appeal or the challenge to the Order under Order IX Rule 13 CPC.
51.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, it is held that there is no merit
in challenging the Ex-parte Decree dated 28.08.2024 and the dismissal of the
Application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC by Order dated 22.09.2025. The
Appeal is accordingly, dismissed.
52.
The Appeal is accordingly disposed of along with the pending
Application(s).
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 2, 2026/RS/va
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
RFA 84/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review